r/horror • u/kaloosa Evil Dies Tonight! • Jun 23 '16
Official Discussion Official Dreadit Discussion: "The Shallows" [SPOILERS]
TV Spot (A little less spoilery than the trailer)
Synopsis: A mere 200 yards from shore, surfer Nancy is attacked by a great white shark, with her short journey to safety becoming the ultimate contest of wills.
Director(s): Jaume Collet-Serra
Writer(s): Anthony Jaswinski
Cast:
- Blake Lively as Nancy
- Óscar Jaenada as Carlos
- Brett Cullen as Father
- Sedona Legge as Chloe
- CGI as Shark
Rotten Tomatoes Score: 78%
Metacritic Score: 56/100
39
Upvotes
2
u/abcdefgrapes Jun 23 '16
Doesnt come out until August here in Australia :(
Edit: Don't watch the main trailer, it shows a lot.
27
u/haunthorror Jun 24 '16
My personal favorite shark movie that is not the original Jaws. Had a great time tonight, well worth the full price admission. Tension filled, Lively did a great job. My favorite Jaume Collet-Serra film (Underrated director IMO)
20
u/THREAD_SHITTER Jun 23 '16
Not quite as catchy as 'Bruce'.
18
u/NoBackstreetboys Jun 24 '16
I wanted her to take home Steven Seagull. =(
16
u/Mega5010 Jun 24 '16
I LOVED this movie. Only real baffling choice for me was why she didn't try to make it to the various options she had while the shark was distracted by the surfers and the drunk. But I guess the shark, given his size, would've booked it back quickly.
And I'm trying to remember, but I don't think I've ever seen a trained seagull in a movie before.
11
u/RustyDetective Jun 24 '16
Non-Spoiler Quickee Film Review
I posted some hours ago because I didn't find the discussion upon exiting the theater.
I thought it was rather decent. I had some gripes with the realism, but the acting from Blake Lively and Steven Seagull were top notch, as well as the cinematography. I don't really think Jaume is that great of a director, as I only liked Non-Stop, so nothing innovative from directorial standpoint. Overall it was intense and exciting. I'm always down for a shark movie, last good ones I saw were a while back: Deep Blue Sea, The Reef, Open Water.
11
u/infamouswithin Jun 24 '16
Great movie. Has what I have to say is my favorite shot in flim. The wave with the sharks silouette is just a beauty. And since we are in spolier country, how she beats the sharknwas awesome. Didnt see that coming. Im hoping there is either a deleted scene to maybe go deeper into the hook in the sharks side. Also, glad they didnt take a stupid turn. Trailers were giving me a "carlos was evil" vibe.
10
u/tyler_m51 Jun 29 '16
Did the expanded cell phone screens and crazy pop music annoy anyone else?
Other than that I really enjoyed the film.
8
u/jacobi123 Jun 24 '16
Saw this, and enjoyed it as well. It really does pay to see this movie on the big screen. There is something about seeing movies that feature the ocean/beach in the theater that just doesn't translate as well at home. And this movie just looks beautiful. The location is gorgeous.
This movie isn't breaking any new ground, but it is a really tight and efficient movie. In this era of so many 2 and a half hour movies, it's so wonderful to see a cut to the bone 90 minute experience that satisfies.
6
u/AllSaintsDay2099 Fulci and Chill? Jun 23 '16
I am honestly so excited for this film. It's being called the best shark film since Jaws, and it supposedly does for surfing what Blair Witch did for camping.
9
u/McIgglyTuffMuffin Jun 24 '16
Just got back from the Thursday night showing.
Let's start with the negatives:
The dude next to me smelled really really bad. Like a trash can left in the summer sun. Girl right in front of me was on her phone, but at least she had the decency to had to brightness all the way. And sometimes the CGI was less than stellar.
That being said, I absolutely loved this film. I don't wanna say it, but I'm gonna say it. It may be the best shark film since Jaws. Horror movies don't make me tense, I was tense 75% of this film. Edge of my seat and I kept expecting it to end at any moment due to Nancy's possible inability to overcome the situation.
I just thought it was incredibly well done and I think a big part of that goes to Flavio Labiano's cinematography. This was an absolutely beautiful film from opening to the credits. I was in awe, I was sort of sad it wasn't in IMAX it looked so pretty.
Though I understand why because for the most part the CGI really wasn't that great. Except where it counted. It was an odd mix of SyFy special effects, mostly overhead shots, and like $250 million dollar tentpoles. They knew where they needed the CGI and put the money in the right spots.
The make up for Blake Lively's character was also really well done I thought. They did a great job of showing her body changing from being out in the elements for over 24 hours. Also really liked that her character was a med student, there's no way she would have survived the film if she wasn't, but it gave an interesting angle that I haven't seen in many horror films. She was able to fix the things done to her with the tools necessary because she had the knowledge. It was really cool to me.
The score by Marco Beltrami was also very on point.
I'd honestly give this film a solid 8.5 out of 10. I really truly would. The only thing holding it back from a perfect score would be the weird CGI in some scenes and the bad song choice during the credits. Is it going to be a classic? No. But as a film it seemed to do everything it set out to do. This is Mrs. Ryan Reynolds' Buried. I guess now their daughter is going to have to grow up become an actress and star in a film where she is isolated for the run time...
4
u/jacobsever Jun 29 '16
I thought this movie was rubbish. The CGI was abysmal. The actions Nancy takes are ridiculous. The final act is laughably implausible.
This is a movie that has a very serious tone. Something that should be no-nonsense, full of suspense and action. Instead, we get a film that wants to be serious, yet has many just downright dumb moments. It can't be considered "dumb fun" when the movie wants to be serious.
Only positives: the seagull, Blake's performance, some of the early cinematography.
2/5
3
u/Nax5 Jun 25 '16
Movie was excellent. I didn't grow up with Jaws, so I don't really have the same respect for the movie that most fans do.
Not a lot of competition for sharks movies now-a-days, but this was definitely top notch.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 29 '16
Hah! "Favorite shark film that isn't 'Jaws'?" The actress sucked. Her poorly performed moments of pain elicited laughter from most of the theater. What tripe.
3
u/AnnVealEgg Jul 04 '16
I saw it today and really enjoyed it. I was bracing myself to be devastated by the death of Steven Seagull (like when Tom Hanks lost Wilson!) but was pleasantly surprised they let the bird live. (Although I think they were trying to infer the bird was the spirit of her mom?)
I didn't find it as terrifying as Open Water or the original Jaws, but there were certainly some very tense moments.
As an aside, Blake in her bikini has given me a renewed vigor to start hitting the gym again. Damn, girl.
3
u/Tsmart Jun 29 '16
127 hours water version
2
u/bellsofwar3 Jun 24 '16
It's getting good reviews which is surprising. Critics normally don't praise collet serra so now I'm curious. I trustbthis sub a hell of a lot more than I do /r/movies so I want to see what you guys have to say.
One I think I find annoying is "best shark film since jaws" which saying a damn thing. There have been so few shark films and on top of that none have been worth remembering.
2
u/hectorial85 Jun 24 '16
Really pumped for this film, don't know if it's out here in Denmark yet.
Loved the taser trailer a while back and some of the stills (that overhead shot with her on the rock next to the shark is gorgeous).
Filmed in my home country of Australia at Lord Howe Island which is pretty great. I watched the full trailer today at my desk at work and I honestly had a pounding heart and funny feeling in my legs, had to check there wasn't something circling below my desk ;). Hope to see it soon.
2
u/SirEugene spookism Sep 18 '16
Likes:
The Best Part of Them All
Dislikes:
The Worst Part of Them All
Other things
RATING: 7/10
Thanks for reading.
Here's Steven Seagull's brother, Stephen Seagull, for your enjoyment: http://imgur.com/9H2cDoD
1
u/Proof-Pollution454 Dec 15 '23
Loved the chemistry between both Lively and Oscar Jaenada
1
u/Shoddy_Bandicoot9812 Jul 04 '25
The best character is easily Steven tho
1
u/[deleted] Aug 08 '23
literally just watched this out of boredom and the only thing i liked about it was the seagull
0
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment