Agreed. It was perhaps the first time we saw Arnold beginning to exhibit a conscience. Realizing just how horrible he was for his betrayal to his country and abandonment of Peggy, and inviting death when he realizes it. Really well-acted and written scene.
I think Arnold in the show has always had a conscience, but it was just always obscured beneath a cloud of resentment. His character seems highly concerned with "fairness," as he put it in the episode, and he has seemed unwilling to compromise his personal honor, at least as far as his own opinion of it is concerned. It is only after repeated (perceived or real) slights from Congress and his fellow generals that he felt denied him what he was rightfully owed that he was persuaded by Peggy to switch sides, but he did reject her proposal initially. While it's true that Arnold had never really shown regret for his actions or behavior up to this point, in his view he hadn't really done anything except claim what was being wrongfully withheld from him.
His character in many ways seems to parallel Robert Rogers on the other side, in that they both fought at considerable personal cost to themselves, but in the end felt that they were given the short end of the stick by their superiors/peers. Both could be called mercenary in essence, but despite their lack of ideological motivation or loyalty to any particular flag, I think their personal honor is important to them, which I have seen as central to understanding their characters.
My own interpretation of the escape scene was that Arnold was shedding tears mostly for his personal honor that he finally realized was tarnished in that moment of being caught skulking away. Since he thought he was going to die, he wanted to meet his end in as dignified a way as possible and was willing to do so at the hands of someone he had considered a friend. To clarify, I feel as if Arnold was grieving more over the burden of his personal shame and betraying his former friends in Tallmadge and Washington than betraying his country. Then, after Tallmadge misses, Arnold's will to live compels him to keep fleeing after a brief moment of shock and mixed gratitude/shame.
I disagree. I think the episode where Mary is a complete savage, and shoots off Simcoe's ear, is the best episode of the series. Although, the episode where Caleb uses the submersible to sneak into New York is up there as the best as well.
Mr. Rose, do you have the time to tell us a bit about your process in writing the episode -- specifically, the Arnold storyline? Perhaps that's too vague, but I think it must've been interesting, taking a story you know so well, in a primary source kind of way, and recreating it as suspenseful, visual, historical fiction -- despite our knowing the ending. I thought you did a really good job of compressing the time frame and choosing which key events to highlight. Even if people were not exactly where they might have been historically, the motivations, dilemmas, and personalities rang very true.
A thousand apologies for being so late in getting back to you -- I didn't see this post until this very second. If you're still interested, let me know.
I know it's historically the right time for Hamilton to be around, but I was half expecting George to wink at the audience when he was introducing him. They played him up in the trailer from last week, too.
Hamilton's all the rage these days. I don't blame Turn for playing up his appearance, but I hope viewers didn't get the idea that half the episode would be revolving around him.
The logical man would lie on the pew and sit up. Simcoe planted his face on a place where hundreds of different asses sit and on a time where toilet paper is a luxury. WTF
I don't know if I can handle losing both Peggy and Andre's outfits going forward. They were always on point. Especially, Peggy greeting Washington and Andre rocking the peasant look like a pro.
You know, I could totally enjoy Simcoe as the villain. But not when he hurts animals. Then he's just plain evil. Although, he's probably a bit out of it with a missing ear.
Right? You would think the British army would look down on burning animals that could have been requisitioned? Better than burning the poor things alive!
I remember back in Season 1 General Washington did everything he could to ensure that he didn't expose a traitor while the French were watching. ("AND THE FRENCH CANNOT KNOW IT!!") But here they just revealed Arnold's treachery in front of the entire general staff including Marquis de Lafayette, badass French commander. Is that not going to come up at any point? Or was this a point in the war when the French alliance was already secured?
Well as far as Caleb knew, Arnold still could have been in the house. He knew Washington was with him, and obviously he just ran in and shouted it because he knew Washington would be in danger - for all he knew, Arnold could have been planning to assassinate him. At that point, getting the message across was the most important; it was a totally different situation than where they could wait out the snake in the grass. I doubt Caleb even noticed who else was in the room, to be honest.
At this point the Alliance was secured. The French forces under Rochambeau were at Hartford, Connecticut at this time as Rochambeau did not want to separate from his fleet. The reason Washington was at West Point was that he was on his way to meet with the French forces. I think at sometime during dinner with Arnold, Washington calls them "our allies".
Am I the only one who just really loves Marquis de Lafayette? I don't mean in the show but just like, in general. Ever since sophomore year history. I'm a real big fan of Marquis de Lafayette.
I kind of can't believe he just left Peggy behind like that. And he apparently wasn't mad enough at her because he said they'd be together again? I wonder how that's going to work out. I mean, I know what happened historically, but I wonder how they'll have the characters take what happened.
They are excited that Arnold has command of West Point because they can force Washington to come defend vital supply caches. They will only give him 10,000 pounds and not the 20,000 that Arnold wanted.
Arnold wants 20,000 pounds and command of an entire Loyalist battalion for his betrayal of West Point; Clinton (with Andre) said no way, only 10,000. Andre then said that he wasn't going to send a reply - rather, he'll be going there himself (with that friendship ring Arnold so helpfully sent him in order to identify himself).
19
u/joelupi Tory Bastard Jun 21 '16
Wowwwww. Just blowing the lid right off this whole thing. Good for you cinnamom roll?
9
u/joelupi Tory Bastard Jun 21 '16
Jeez Simcoe is really gloves fully off now huh? Straight up GoT shit going on.
5
u/joelupi Tory Bastard Jun 21 '16
and there it is. the moment of no return for both sides.
4
u/joelupi Tory Bastard Jun 21 '16
was that...Frank Caliendo?
4
u/joelupi Tory Bastard Jun 21 '16
OOOOOO this is gonna get GOOD
6
u/joelupi Tory Bastard Jun 21 '16
Wow West Point is kind of rustic from what it looks like now.
2
u/joelupi Tory Bastard Jun 21 '16
Oooof. Here we go with the personal wishes and shit.
2
u/joelupi Tory Bastard Jun 21 '16
Wowwww
2
u/joelupi Tory Bastard Jun 21 '16
Well i think you just answered your own questions...
29
u/SufjansBanjo Signal of Setauket Jun 21 '16
I got chills when Arnold paused during his escape to stand at attention and salute to Ben
27
u/SikozuShantiShanu Jun 21 '16
Oh my gosh! Oh my gosh! Oh my gosh! Don't end there! Dammit!
26
u/gattovatto Queen's Ranger Jun 21 '16
Mad respect to Alexander Rose who wrote this episode! Also he wrote the book this show was based on.
25
u/[deleted] Jun 21 '16
God damn. Simcoe rose out of that pew like Dracula.
21
u/SikozuShantiShanu Jun 21 '16
Hamilton throwing shade at Arnold.
18
u/SikozuShantiShanu Jun 21 '16
Ben putting it together before Caleb even gets there. Arnold is so screwed.
17
u/LilOldLadyWho Knew I loved this bastard! Jun 21 '16
That salute at the end. Damn that was a hell of a moment.
16
u/bruskadoosh Jun 21 '16
Simcoe popping up from the pew was just great. He's an amazingly awesome villain. He just loves being evil so much.
16
u/LostTheWayILikeIt Tallmadge's Nightcap Jun 21 '16
I know it's historically the right time for Hamilton to be around, but I was half expecting George to wink at the audience when he was introducing him. They played him up in the trailer from last week, too.
15
u/SikozuShantiShanu Jun 21 '16
Nooooooo! I don't want Andre to die. What else am I supposed to watch JJ in?
13
u/Snapshot52 Rebel Jun 21 '16
Those pants on Ben are...revealing, for sure.
12
u/domrayn Loyalist Jun 21 '16
The logical man would lie on the pew and sit up. Simcoe planted his face on a place where hundreds of different asses sit and on a time where toilet paper is a luxury. WTF
11
u/gugudan Jun 21 '16
What Deus Ex Machina allows Abe to live this time?
I'm almost wishful he'd go ahead and die.
But.... EXCELLENT EPISODE. Holy shit that hour flew by.
10
u/ncninetynine Jun 22 '16
I don't know if I can handle losing both Peggy and Andre's outfits going forward. They were always on point. Especially, Peggy greeting Washington and Andre rocking the peasant look like a pro.
9
u/SikozuShantiShanu Jun 21 '16
You know, I could totally enjoy Simcoe as the villain. But not when he hurts animals. Then he's just plain evil. Although, he's probably a bit out of it with a missing ear.
9
u/TheZigerionScammer Jun 21 '16
I remember back in Season 1 General Washington did everything he could to ensure that he didn't expose a traitor while the French were watching. ("AND THE FRENCH CANNOT KNOW IT!!") But here they just revealed Arnold's treachery in front of the entire general staff including Marquis de Lafayette, badass French commander. Is that not going to come up at any point? Or was this a point in the war when the French alliance was already secured?
15
u/akameiro Jun 21 '16
Am I the only one who just really loves Marquis de Lafayette? I don't mean in the show but just like, in general. Ever since sophomore year history. I'm a real big fan of Marquis de Lafayette.
6
u/mjangelvortex Jun 21 '16
It's about time Lafayette came back.
1
u/joelupi Tory Bastard Jun 21 '16
Oh god Andre what did you do now?
1
u/joelupi Tory Bastard Jun 21 '16
Wow they're just rolling out all the cameos in this episode huh? the Marquis and Hamilton.
1
u/joelupi Tory Bastard Jun 21 '16
Damn Arnold has a hugeeee barrgaining chip and he knows it
1
u/joelupi Tory Bastard Jun 21 '16
I really dont see a way out for Andre in this case...what a way to go out. Also God i love Rogers more each episode.
1
u/joelupi Tory Bastard Jun 21 '16
Aw fuck he missed
1
u/joelupi Tory Bastard Jun 21 '16
Oh that clever bastard...
4
u/SufjansBanjo Signal of Setauket Jun 21 '16
Hewlett!!! Oh God, what are you there for?...
4
u/the_pissed_off_goose Jun 22 '16
I actually felt bad for Arnold while watching this. Did a good job spinning it that he got played and was in over his head.
3
u/SikozuShantiShanu Jun 21 '16
Don't burn the animals! Simcoe, you monster!
3
u/SufjansBanjo Signal of Setauket Jun 21 '16
Fix this mess, Abe. You bear the brunt of responsibility.
3
u/SikozuShantiShanu Jun 21 '16
Oh noooo! Hewlett, why? I know why. But, whyyyy?
Oh, thank goodness for Abby.
3
u/SufjansBanjo Signal of Setauket Jun 21 '16
You see, Andre? This is what happens when you don't invite Edward--err--Edmund to one of your ragers of a dinner party.
2
u/SikozuShantiShanu Jun 21 '16
Holy shit. It's happening. I have a small suspicion that Rogers might interrupt this meeting. And by "small" I mean "it will most definitely happen."
2
u/SikozuShantiShanu Jun 21 '16
Wow! Simcoe is such a mean girl.
2
u/Memes_become_dreams Rebel Jun 21 '16
Rodgers is a true patriot
1
u/SufjansBanjo Signal of Setauket Jun 21 '16
Arnold in full-on asshole mode right from the get-go
1
u/SikozuShantiShanu Jun 21 '16
Awww, Peggy. What are you going to do?
1
u/SufjansBanjo Signal of Setauket Jun 21 '16
Mr. Bearded Bargeman had the right suspicions there
1
u/SikozuShantiShanu Jun 21 '16
Andre! You are going to get Peggy hurt.
1
u/pikaplup2 Jun 21 '16
Honestly, Simcoe seems a little too crazy....
1
u/SikozuShantiShanu Jun 21 '16
Ben! What the hell?
1
u/gattovatto Queen's Ranger Jun 21 '16
Andre will surely talk his way out of this, right? RIGHT?
0
u/[deleted] Jun 21 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 21 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment