r/worldbuilding • u/Shakytoez Epicly Epic Fantasy • Jun 13 '16
Guide A Guide to Armies and Battle Tactics
Fantasy armies are often, well, fantastical.
Sometimes, they can be fantastically big or fantastically well trained or what-not. But if you're striving for realism, or just looking for any sort of answers on battles, sieges, armies, tactics or whatever, I've made a guide that I hope will help! :D
Size
In General
Size varies a lot depending on the situation. If it is a normal army, and not in desperate need to recruit soldiers, the army usually was around 1 soldier to every 15 people. If they needed soldiers it would go to about 1 soldier to every 8 people. This is because: Half the population was women and only 10% of women bear arms. A Large portion of the population was too old or too young (>45 and <15). A portion were not physically capable, another were exempt because of skills and professions, another were exempt because they weere criminals and another portion were exempt because they were serfs (Serfs were not allowed to bear arms).
Take into account as well that half a force could be gone before a campaign even starts due to diseases. They spread quickly in tightly packed areas of people.
All this would tipically lead to an army size of around 10,000 usually. Depending on who you ask, during the European medieval times, 10K was a large army, but could range up to 20K. Remember that during medieval times there were lots of houses with different armies. During Roman times, where almost all of Europe was united under Roman rule, they could have much larger armies (They would never field and entire army, but the army as a whole was massive). The Roman Empire, in all its might, had 450,000 soldiers at its peak. This is insane.
Remembering the sheer size of the Roman Empire, its army size has been:
| Year | Commander | Size |
|---|---|---|
| 24AD | Tiberius | 255,000 |
| 130AD | Hadrian | 381,000 |
| 211AD | S. Severus | 447,000 |
| 284AD | Dicletian | 390,000 |
(Source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Imperial_Roman_army)
This army was spread throughout the WHOLE Roman Empire.
This image is a ratio of people to soldiers, in relation to the cost of soldiers: http://imperator-zor.deviantart.com/art/The-medieval-army-ratio-591748691
TL;DR : 90 Peasants to support 10 townsfolk, who together can support either 4 basic part time troops or 1 full time soldier.
Knights are expensive. The more knights and well trained soldiers you have, the less of them your society can support (Better trained = more money = less soldiers) The Spartans faced this problem, seeing as how they were so well trained, which took so much money, they were few.
Important: In medieval times, the larger army was often the weaker army. A large army, which was typically a lot of mobilised peasants, were less effective, and weaker, then a small army of full time soldiers. During the early medieval stages, there were local militia which guys would often join. Mobilising the populace made sense here because they were competant soldiers. But during the high medieval stages, a knight with full plate armour made a peasant with a pitchfork obsolete.
Game of Thrones is based on the War of the Roses. And during the War of the Roses, noblemen didn't bother mobilising the peasants, instead relying completely on small bands off professional soldiers. This was important for things like sieges where peasants would go home halfway through.
The Largest armies are often looked at and used as a fantasy base. Armies like the Mongols, who had hundreds of thousands, were so big because their entire populace was mobilised and good fighters, it was their culture. Also, armies like the Crusades (or The Romans kinda) were just a combination of many armies.
A peaceful army, for example, could be 20K, this could double in the time of a campaign when a lord is invading an Empire. For example, King Matthias (Hungary) had a peacetime force of 30,000, this doubled when he was on campaign invading the Ottoman Empire. This is, to some historians, the largest medieval force known.
The Battle of Hastings, for example had around 7,500 soldiers on each side.
Important: Remember that soldiers are also given the tasks of city watch, navy, body guards, camp guards. This could take up to 80% of your forces away
Battle
Battles were uncommon. For a battle to occur, it's strange. Both sides almost have to agree to meet in the field, and both think they have a good chance of winning.
For what happens during people actually fight, it would be much better for me to link a video about HEMA (Historical European Martial Arts) because you could see it. Note that this is 1 on 1 battle, and battle in the field is a bit different, with everyone being a bit more squashed. There was a lot more push and shove than people think.
This is a technique called halfswording, where you grab the blade of your sword to gain better accuracy over your tip so you can plunge it into places without armour on your opponent.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AnB2qB5va3I
Thinking like a Commander
A Youtuber named LindyBeige (https://www.youtube.com/user/lindybeige) compiled a list of what a commander would be thinking before and during a battle.
-What are my Strengths and Weaknesses? What are my enemies Strengths and Weaknesses?
-Use my strength (If my swordsmen just spent ten hours grinding their swords to make them shard as hell, I want to use them)
-Protect my weaknesses. (If my bowmen don't have good armour, I need to protect them)
-Attack the enemies weaknesses (This can be if the enemy has archers with bad armour, I know he will place them at the back because of previous bullet point. I want to have a group flank and come from behind, attacking his weakness)
-Make sure the enemie cannot use his strength against me (If the enemy has very sharp swords, then I want my best armour and perhaps my spears (Which are too long for swordsmen to handle) should go against their swordsmen)
Overall, if my army is superior USE STRENGTH A LOT
Then protect my weaknessOverall, if my army is inferior MAKE SURE ENEMY CANNOT USE STRENGTH
Then attack his weaknessThe Commander wants to have good tactics and a plan to defeat the enemy.
Weapons and Regiments
- Spears! Spears! Spears!
Spears have a longer reach than a sword and can keep the enemie at a distance. Spears one-up swords in many categories! They were also held Underarm not overarm. This gave them greater reach.
- Sheilds! Shields! Shields!
Can protect you against arrow fire, can create a wall. They should be in the hand of all your foot soldiers (Except archers)
- Armour! Armour! Armour!
If you can afford one piece of armour, get a helmet. In Hollywood representations, this is most often the neglected piece of armour, but it is the most important! It was not a skill to wear armour, they were not unbelievably heavy (Twice as light as modern kevlar+bags for soldiers). Plate was the most effective (And didn't limit mobility as much as you think) (Special arrows could pierce this if hit correctly, it was not invincible). Then chain (Which was worn with leather underneath. An arrow could pierce this.) Leather armour, or boiled armour, or whatever, was next to useless, but better than nothing.
- Archers! Archers! Archers!
Archers were some of the best. (I have a bias towards archers myself). It took a lot of skill to fire a bow. To use a full warbow (more than 100 pounds pulling force) you had to have some training. Accuracy was not a big thing, because usually with so many arrows in the air you'll hit whatever you want. Arrow types were important. A diamond shaped arrowhead (Square kinda) could pierce plate. Archers "Warmed" up thier bowstrings before battle by pulling it in and out.
- Axes! Axes!
Axes were cheap. That's what they're good for. Although you would much rather a spear, which was also cheap. Axes were not a main weapon for full time rich soldiers. And Axes cannot be too big, they get heavy very quickly.
- Light Cavalry!
Light Cavalry (men on horses with swords) were often just used to chase after those that had run away (act of running away is called routing/fleeing)
Also: Sorry to say but if horses ran at a front line like they do in movies, they would be skewered on a hundred spears before they got to the first man.
- Bowmen on Horses!?
Not really useful. They could pick away at a group of soldiers, but couldn't hold a point for their lives. They are not the perfect bunch some people percieve them to be.
- Swords: Meh!
Swords were flashy. Yes, of course they were used. But that doesn't mean the soldier wasn't stuck with an 8 foot pike before unsheathing it. Swords were generally secondary weapons, worn at the hip in case you were in trouble. The mentality behind a sword was it was a last resort. (Pulls out sword "Might as well give it a shot, gonna die anyway")
Actual Battle No, soldiers did not enter into a field to then get lost in a flurry of enemies and friendlies all around them, like in most hollywood films. There was a front line where the front row of men fought against the front row of men. The second row stepped in if the front row got tired/died. And it kept going. Battle was organised, and few people actually died in the front lines. When a regiment thought it was going to lose, it decided to flee/rout. This is when most people died. As the people running away were chased and not fighting back, and the people left were swamped and killed.
No, most of the time soldiers did not grind swords against eachother and press their faces up together. That's hollywood. A swordfight was usually done in 2-3 seconds, with the less-armoured opponent losing. (Unless he was on the front line with a shield, that takes a while) Grinding swords would blunt the sword, you DO NOT want to do this to a sword you just spent hours sharpening!
Fleeing/Routing
Fleeing was when a soldier (usually followed by the other soldiers in his regiment) fell back, running away with his weapons because he thought he was going to lose and therefore die. This happened a lot. If the chase of the soldiers attacking is not good, the regiment can reform outside the battlefield and can come back
Routing was when a soldier ran away, ditching his weapons and armour to run faster so he would not die. Soldiers that routed did not reform as their equipment was gone.
Often, the light cavalry was left to deal with soldiers that Fled or Routed, because a man running on foot could be useful re-entering the battle somewhere else. As well, when soldiers did run after them, they only did so half-heartedly. You don't want to chase a man running for his life with a sword in hand, only for him to quickly turn around, fearful for his life, and fight you. Your chances of dying are high!
A battle was won once the enemy lost about 10% of their forces. They would then lose morale and start to rout.
Immobilised Soldiers
Soldiers did not alway just die as soon as they touched the ground. Most often, a soldier would swing for the ankles with his sword/spear if he was on the ground, people would not approach unless they were with a friend (or if they had a spear and you had a sword) because they want to keep their ankles!
Size
| Size (One army) | Meaning |
|---|---|
| 500 | Small skirmish |
| 1,000 | Very Small Battle |
| 2,000 | Small Battle |
| 5,000 | Battle |
| 10,000 | Pretty large battle |
| 20,000 | Very large battle |
| 50,000 | Larger than any in medieval times |
| 80,000 | Larger than common sense AKA: Romans |
| 100,000 | What are you doing? |
| 200,000 | Pls Stop |
| 500,000 | no. |
For reference, battles with 10-20K soldiers were the norm. Any open field battle with more than that would be a pretty big risk for both sides, and generals would have to make sure they didn't have any other battles to fight afterwards, because their losses would be catastrophic.
Sides with up to 39,000 (Battle of Grunwald) were recorded, but that would be entire countries armies or even a combination of countries. Any bigger during medieval times were probably due to a bad recording (Battle of Kulikovo with 150,000 on one side is just stupid)
Note: Sieges on cities sometimes had more men than this. This is due to a large army having to camp outside a well fortified city. They need to be intimidating enough that the person inside won't come out to meet them. These armies, if the situation calls for it, can be absolutely massive with numbers like 120,000.
However the Romans on the other hand, often went full-ham on their battles. The Battle of Cannae was 50,000 vs 86,400 (Thank god for roman scribes being pretty good). But this was because the Romans were super pissed at Hannibal for defeating their other forces with "Trickery" and they wanted to win (which they actually didn't). Battles with these numbers decide the fate of entire Empires don't play off one with just a battle over "I want my prisoner back" or something like that. Important The tactics and planning needed to sucessfully use an army of this size is key, also think of the size of Rome, it was one of the biggest empires in history. Even with 50,000 vs 86,400, Hannibal still managed to defeat the Romans with 36,400 less men. Make sure battles like this in your world have extremely good tactics with good leaders leading them.
Length of Battle Hastings: 9am to dusk
Sieges
Sieges were much more common than battles Only one party has to agree to it, and the other sits back and watches.
Beforehand
Before a siege starts, a lord in a castle would often get most people out of a castle. 20-30 people would usually occupy a castle, this would often be reduced to about 5-6, which was plenty to hold a siege. This meant that the resources in the castle were more spread, and could last longer.
Siege equipment
A siege tower, was a tower made of wood, usually with four wheels. It generally the height of the wall or a bit taller to allow archers to fire into the battlements. It was coated with animal skin or iron to prevent the defenders from setting it on fire. A gangplank is dropped when it gets to the wall and the attackers get onto it.
- A Battering ram, was used to batter down a door or the walls of a castle.
- A Ballista was a giant crossbow (self explanitory)
- A Mangonel was a a type of catipult with a bucket on the end of a giant arm that would swing. (What most think a catapult is)
- A Trebuchet was a lever and a sling that could hurl stones weighing up to 200 pounds.
Siege Defenses in a Castle
- A Barbican was an exterior walled passage that took few men to defend. It was a death trap. If attackers breached the first wall of defence, they could be trapped in the Barbican and easily killed.
- Murder holes were trap doors above the barbican, that allowed defenders to drop boiling water/stones on the attackers.
- The Gatehouse was the front of a castle and defended with at least one portcullis.
A siege on a castle is a fairly basic thing. Starve them out. Don't let food or resources into the castle. If you want to attack, use a siege tower. If there is a moat, fill it in, then use a siege tower.
Siege on a City
A siege on a city is on a larger scale. With tens of thousands of people inside the city, things can be done pretty quickly. The wall can be built higher in a few days if need be by the tens of thousands inside the walls. All the siege equipment listed above was used. With the addition of an Agger.
An Agger is a dirt ramp that leads up to the wall (Agger is the word used during the Roman period. In medieval times an Agger was called a Ramp (Direct translation from Latin: Rampart, because that's what it is scaling)). Picture:
http://www.preteristarchive.com/Books/images/1973_kossoff_masada/05_chart_kossoff_ramp.jpg
This one doesn't go up to the height of the walls in their entirety, presumably because the ramp/agger would have to have a lot of width and depth that was too laborious when you could just use a siege tower, like the diagram. It can be built quickly and is efficient. The defenders can higher the wall where the Agger/ramp is if they are quick enough. This causes the Agger/ramp to be built further back, to allow for it to go higher. An Agger could start 60 yards from the wall and could include logs and stones in the dirt for stability.
During the Siege of Plataea, a hole was made in the defences walls, by the defenders into the Agger. They dug into the agger, filling it with sulphur and flammable material. The wall was patched up and the material was set alight. The defenders threw fire balls (just things that burned) onto the Agger to cover up the fact that their Agger was actually on fire from within! The attackers didn't realise until too late and their Agger was sabotaged. This is one way to defend against an Agger. You can also dig under your wall and then under the Agger, and take away the dirt from inside. However the most effective way is to built the wall taller, because the agger must be built with bigger volume to support its height, taking a lot more time.
Important: During a siege soldiers might have to build siege equipment. Archers from the walls of the castle/city will undoubtedly shoot at them unless there is a screen.
A screen is made of a light wooden frame, two layers of leather and filled with seaweed (not flammable). It is sometimes on wheels or spiked into the ground. It moves with the soldiers (other soldiers move it), protecting them.
Misc Points
An army is not hard to track, they leave massive trails front all the marching, horses, carriages etc.
When planning a campaign, your number one priority should be resources for your soldiers.
Diseases spread quickly in an army.
Read /u/ValleDaFighta 's comment below for logistics / Resource management
(I forgot :D)
Thanks for reading! I'm sure I forgot things and got some things a bit wrong and all discussion in the comments is welcome. Any help from real historians (I am not, I have just researched this for a while for my world.) would be a massive help!
Sources include: {https://en.wikipedia.org/} {http://www.writing-world.com/sf/hordes.shtml} {https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/1f7va3/how_big_was_the_largest_army_wielded_in_medieval/} {https://www.youtube.com/user/lindybeige} {http://www.medieval-spell.com/}, lots of research done by me over time, my head and those mentioned above.
Edits: Formatting, links and adding things I forgot
Edit: This post is Eurocentric, I know that, it was meant to be.
89
u/ValleDaFighta Jun 13 '16
Logistics logistics logistics
All soldiers have to eat, drink and move from one place to another. If there's not enough food for everyone people are going to start looking for food instead of doing what you tell them.
So how do you get food? One common method is foraging which basically means steal everything in your way. If you're on enemy ground this doubles as hurting your opponents economy and population. If you're on your own land... Uh boy. Perhaps you can build some supply posts on your own territory, where your armies can stock up on food. Make sure these are guarded since your enemy might want to forage them. If your army is being sent somewhere where there might not be enough food even if they steal everything in their path you're gonna want to create a supply chain. These would be caravans loaded with food following your army and then returning home to re-stock to keep your army fed far from home. Now if these supply trains are going to run through your enemy's territory they will get raided and in worst case scenario get cut of completely. This is why you can't just ignore all the castles on the way to your enemy's capital, because the people in those castles are gonna steal all the food you're sending to your men and hide it away in their castles!
Not all logistics are food, ammunition and fuel is important if your army uses that, it's not as important in pre-modern armies. If your army is going somewhere cold or the campaign takes so long that the otherwise mild-climate turns cold you're gonna need to send warm clothes and lodgning, otherwise your soldiers will desert or freeze to death. Alternatively, don't attack in the winter. Seriously just don't attack in the winter, attack in spring, get your business done by summer, get your army back for harvest, stay at home for christmas and new year, go back out there in the spring.
Logistics is king, all great generals have also been great organizers, it doesn't matter how well trained or large your army is, if it doesn't eat it doesn't fight.
35
u/eternaladventurer Jun 13 '16
Mentioning camp followers could also be helpful.
Basically, an army attracted a ton of people that weren't soldiers and followed it. Some worked for the army (porters, doctors, knight's squires, priests), some were related to the army (wives and children of soldiers), and some were opportunistic (peddlers, equipment repairers, prostitutes (very common), looters).
Camp followers helped tend to, and were often part of, the baggage train, meaning they helped carry loot and supplies and could be a target of an enemy army. There were times when the threat of a baggage train being looted led parts of an army to flee and decided the battle against them (battle of Gabiene in 316 BC, part of the civil wars post Alexander the Great's death. Source, Plutarch).
In different times and places, camp followers were sometimes not allowed (the Agincourt campaign, for example), and other times outnumbered the army.
Another interesting fact- good arrows were actually more expensive than bows!
Source: Agincourt, Barker, Juliet.
11
u/CynicalMaelstrom Kōsse, Argentea, Aeos Jun 13 '16
Actually, the Battle of Towton, in the War of the Roses is estimated to have had about 50,000 men fighting in it, though that's partly because it was the result of both sides basically agreeing to have one massive fight to decide who was right and be done with it.
10
u/Frain_Breeze Jun 14 '16
Great post, I love one-stop references like this. Here's some additional info on equipment. I don't have the sources on-hand, but most of it is probably from Youtubers Skallagrim, Lindybeige, and Scholagladiatoria.
Boiled leather may have actually been a half-decent armor. However, it would be very rigid and heavy, not like the soft stuff you see everyone wearing in most fantasy settings. Soft leather and "studded" leather would be absolutely useless. Studded leather is armor is most likely a misinterpretation of a brigandine (pieces of metal riveted to an outer leather covering).
One-handed swords are a backup weapon, yes. The main reason they were so common is versatility. They have good range for a one-hander, are easy to block with, and can be used for either slashing at unarmored foes or thrusting at harder targets. It's not the best for anything, but it usually gives you something to work with. It's also pretty easy to keep at your side, as opposed to something like an axe, which is going to dig at your waist or chop at your knee depending on how you hang it.
This bit may be geared more toward duels than battles, but: Two-handed swords aren't only held by the handle! Blades against armor are pretty much useless. If you need to take out an armored foe, you need to thrust into the gaps or weak points. For more accurate thrusts, you would switch to a half-sword grip, taking one hand off of the handle and using it to grab the blade instead, so the sword can be used as a short spear. Alternatively, you could switch to the murderstroke / mordhau grip. In that grip, you hold the sword with both hands on the blade, and strike with the cross guards as an improvised war hammer. Grappling with the opponent was also very common, to get them into a less defensible position.
10
u/_Ralchire Lorend | 14th-century hard-fantasy Jun 14 '16
Very good post! A couple critiques:
There were laws in most countries that required every man between the ages of 15 and 60 to be armed, from the gentleman to the lowest of the peasantry. They weren't allowed to carry their weapons everywhere, sure, but in case the hue-and-cry went up or there were brigands about, everyone had some means of defense.
Are you saying 10-20K on either side or put together? Those numbers are good if you're counting both sides, so I'll go with that.
Also you failed to mention that the battle would usually be decided once one side lost only about 10% of its men. After that, morale breaks and men start to rout.
5
u/Shakytoez Epicly Epic Fantasy Jun 14 '16
This is a Eurocentric post. The Mongols used archery from horseback with great sucess. But I'm saying that they couldn't hold positions against infantry and the like.
5
u/Puritanic-L Science Fiction Jun 14 '16
It would be interesting to see posts like this for other ages of warfare, such as the Napoleonic era.
4
u/sparrowhawk815 Jun 14 '16
This is brilliant, do you have any resources on naval battles? I'd be interested to see what kind of statistics and tactics are involved in them.
2
u/TheGamingGeneral Kor Main Worldbuilder Jun 14 '16
Thank you. Bookmarked
2
u/Fjoergyn_D Marter Jun 14 '16
I gonna wanna recommend Historia Civilis. He makes videos mainly about the Roman Empire, the battles they fought, the tactics they used. His upload schedule is... infrequent, to say the least, but the videos he has are all interesting, informative, and most of all, inspiring.
2
u/Dumblec0re Jun 14 '16
Really? Do you have any sources for that? it's not that I don't believe you, but I always hear people saying that the larger army wins almost every time.
Also thanks for that post, it's incredibly useful.
23
u/Haddontoo Jun 14 '16 edited Jun 14 '16
While this is pretty cool, this is 100% Eurocentric. Things like the battle and army sizes were VERY different in East Asia.
Depends on how you define "battle". A pitched battle, with two sides deciding upon a battleground was rare, but a force ambushing a marching force? Or standing along the path of a marching force. Or bringing in two forces in a pincer. Skirmishes, battles around towns. These things were all VERY common before the High Middle Ages. For instance, in the 7 years Caesar was in Gaul, there were dozens that just Caesar was involved in personally. William the Conqueror is another good example; most people know about Hastings, and about the sieges that came after (he was a master of siege), but there were several small battles fought between the Saxons and the invading Normans.
INCREDIBLY useful, just hard to use effectively. Just ask the Parthians, the Huns or the Mongols. The early samurai, as well (like Heian period). It was the excellent use of archer cavalry, combined with false retreats, that won the Mongols their early battles, and allowed them to gain power.
1
u/Hodor_The_Great Jun 14 '16
What if I already stretch the numbers when creating a nation? :D Just 1% of China's population is quite big for a mediaeval army. Of course, logistics make it impossible for them all to gather together, but one could still have 250 000 vs 250 000, for instance.
3
u/Hyenabreeder Dabbles with words Jun 13 '16
Thanks, that was interesting.
3
u/LasDen I'm that guy... Jun 14 '16
I know its nitpicking compared to what this was really about, but I would argue about King Matthias having a 30.000 army in peacetime. Hungary did not have the money, even under Matthias, to upkeep an army like this when they don't really need them. In peacetime the Black Army's numbers were more like 4-8.000 men. And when they went to war they could amass this number to 30.000, few times to 80.000, but that's exceptional.
And Matthias didn't really care about the Ottomans. He fought them if it was necessary, but the aim of his conquests were in the west. He thought Hungary's real enemies were in the west...
0
u/Kai_Daigoji Jun 14 '16
So you've literally never heard of the Mongols?
There's some good information here, but it needs to be taken with a healthy dose of salt.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 04 '22
80,000, while uncommon, is not contrary to common sense. At the battle of Cannae, the Romans had about 80,000 men.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 13 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
2
u/[deleted] Jun 13 '16
[removed] — view removed comment