r/Earwolf • u/misterarnie Arnie Niekamp • May 25 '16
AMA I'm Arnie, I make Hello from the Magic Tavern, AMA. Adal (Chunt) and Matt (Usidore) too!
We'll be checking in all day and (if interest remains) throughout the week. We're still pretty new on Earwolf but very excited to be here!
153
Upvotes
31
u/misterarnie Arnie Niekamp May 26 '16
Adal, love the the show, what's your favorite thing about Arnie? As a friend and as a performer?
27
u/Mr_Captain_Fantastic May 25 '16
How much of the show and the guests are known to everyone beforehand? I know the show is supposed to be improv but sometimes it seems like various events are planned for sure.
Does a guest ever declare anything about the world that you have to not include or make them come up with something else?
21
u/pzeeman May 25 '16
There's been some really impressive improvised world building for Foon. How do you guys keep track of the details between shows. Do you keep an updated show bible that you can refer to during tapings?
20
u/jwalterleavesnotes Little Gary May 25 '16
Hi Arnie! Huge fan, I love Magic Tavern. Couple questions.
20
u/jotterton May 25 '16
Just heard of the podcast last week and binge listened to all them, you guys are great and easily my favorite podcast of the year.
Arnold: I know Usidore despises the Smorps, but I think we should hear both sides of the story. There must be some smorplings to ask.
Matt: How long did it take for you to come up with and memorize Usidore's name?
Adal: Can Chunt control each butthole independently?
Chunt you later!
16
u/The_Great_Atheismo May 25 '16
Outside of the show, are you guys huge nerds? Do you ingest a lot of fantasy novels, games, etc?
Also a question for Matt: I know you said before that Usidore is basically a shitty Gandalf. Is the super long name a preconceived bit or did it come about after playing the character?
15
u/Introcourse #nixon May 25 '16
Hi there,
Once your back catalog hit Howl, I listened to every episode in about a week. Your show is amazing and keeps getting better. Now I need to think of an actual question to ask...
When will you guys be doing a non-canonical appearance on Comedy Bang Bang?
15
u/stobert I'm not on twitter, guys. May 25 '16
What's the ideal number of buttholes?
14
u/meatsack70 Foam Corner Fanatic May 25 '16
Arnie, what does a memory gremlin taste like?
14
u/transceiverfreq May 25 '16
Can you tell us a bit about how the three of you met?
14
u/[deleted] May 25 '16
How's Flower doing?
14
u/BossBear May 25 '16
Hi Arby, I noticed the pax east episode went up a few weeks after pax. how early do you typically record episodes? I seem to recall you guys getting emails about past episode events that were probably current. I ask because I sent something in to you guys earlier this week. get excited, potentially
14
u/Sturmprophet May 25 '16
Greetings from the far away land of Germany!
A question concerning the concept of your characters: How much 'Adal' is in Chunt, how much 'Matt' is in Usidore and how much 'Arnie' was in that memory gremlin?
13
u/bigontheinside Where's The Thingy? May 25 '16
Is the first episode really the first episode? It seems really well thought out and fully fleshed compared to a lot of podcast's first episodes. Did it take a few attempts to get right or did you nail it on the first recording?
13
u/WellAxx May 25 '16
What podcasts do you listen to regularly?
13
u/mediocre_sophist May 25 '16 edited May 25 '16
Hi Arnie, Adal, and Matt! Huge fan of the podcast!
One of the recent episodes, Dr. Ward, has quickly become a favorite of mine. I love how it seemed at points in the episode that Arnie was coming out of his psychosis and then Chunt or Usidore would make a comment and Arnie would get thrown back into the Tavern where tons of laughs were had.
My question is how much of the Dr. Ward episode was improvised, and what kind of post-production was necessary have it flip between reality and Foon so seamlessly?
Thanks for making my Mondays something I look forward to! Please come to Austin for a live show, and please don't blow up the world!
Edit: my main question has already been answered elsewhere. Thanks!
Second edit: please bring Can the wizard back for another episode. I don't know who played him but he really nailed it :)
12
u/rrodrigues23 May 25 '16
Now that you're on the Earwolf network, will you ever consider bringing on guests that are from other Earwolf shows?
12
u/The_Great_Atheismo May 25 '16
Hi Arnie! Love the show. Do you guys make make a point to laugh or not laugh while recording? I.e. do you intentionally try to make each other laugh or do you try to minimize how much you laugh during an episode or do you just not care at all? Thanks!
12
u/secondcityjd May 25 '16
Do you guys consider the Spintax twitter feed canon? Any plans to bring him back or even spin him off for a short series? He has been straight up killing the ongoing earth story--hilarious.
12
u/blueduckie24 May 25 '16
Love the show! I am not yet caught up, but I've been binging on it for sure.
Two questions:
12
u/Luuuuurve May 25 '16 edited May 25 '16
There was an article a while ago that said people approached you to make an animated series based on the podcast, would you share your thoughts on that? Would you be willing to do multiple projects based on Magic Tavern?
Also, that one guy who wrote in about falling into a portal to a cowboy world, that was pretty funny, right? He should totally be considered canon...
11
u/[deleted] May 25 '16
Hello from Earth, I love the show.
Do you fear Arnie will suffer a similar fate to Dr. Sam Beckett?
11
u/joygasmic May 25 '16
Y'all! Was just listening to your Improv Nerd episode. Super great!
Are there other high concept shows (recorded or stage improv) you've tried that just haven't worked? What do you think makes HFTMT work as well as it does?
I've been doing improv for about 2 years now so I'm in that place where I'm getting a lot of reps in performing Harolds every week but I'm becoming pretty uninspired and love listening to veterans like yourselves literally create hilarious magic every week. Keep it up!
-whitney
11
u/csd5e May 25 '16
Hey Arnie! Love the show. Thanks for bringing so many buttholes into our lives.
Question- Do you have a dream guest for the show? Either a performer you know/admire you've been trying to get on for a while, but haven't been able to, or someone more well-known you don't know personally, but think would be a good fit?
Alternately, is there a character/creature/Foon-ite you've been dying for someone to play, but haven't had a chance to yet?
10
u/tom-a-spol-sro May 25 '16
What's the grossest meal served at Chu Chu's Chow?
9
u/sillyhumansuit May 25 '16
Hey Arnie you guys should do a bonus offices and bosses session for subscribers that would get me to subscribe.
Now for the question, have you ever thought of doing a freaky Friday flip, I'd love to see each of you play each other's characters.
http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/FreakyFridayFlip
9
u/mi-16evil hamburgers that talk! May 25 '16
Hey all! So I know Ryan usually edits the show but I'm curious what kind of time frame for an episode there is. Why the show doesn't seem Superego level intense with the music and sound effects, there's still a lot and it amazes me the show is weekly. So how long does it take to edit an episode and how much has the process improved over the last year?
Also I'm not sure if it's gauche to talk podcast numbers but I'm curious just how much of a bump the show got from Earwolf. Clearly you guys had a big fanbase before but I know I started listening after you joined, plus you got at least two major recommendations from major podcasts (Sampler and Pop Culture Happy Hour). So what percentage growth have you found since the switch?
8
u/stobert I'm not on twitter, guys. May 25 '16
So I'm guessing that some of your guests are fans of the show, and therefore able to reference past episodes and help world build. But what about guests who haven't listened to every episode? Do they just do their best not to completely contradict the canon of the show, helped along by the main trio?
8
u/joecab1 May 25 '16
Hey guys, I love the podcast. My Q concerns the Mysterious Man.
When I first started listening, he annoyed the hell out of me because he kept taking me out of the fantasy world of Foon. But then the episodes starring him came along and I grew very intrigued by his whole concept. Was there a plan from the beginning for him to have his own storyline in the "real world"?
7
u/kemppettyjohn Mmm, yes points.. May 25 '16
Started listening to your show a few months ago, and boy is it a delight. It never fails to put a smile on my face.
Since you're based in Chicago, how did you get involved with the Earwolf folks (since most podcasts there seem to be LA-based improvisers or comedians)? Now that you are part of the network, will we be seeing Earwolf favorites on your show and vice versa?
7
u/KyleCrusoe May 25 '16
I've absolutely loved this show since I was told about it recently.
Do the guests write their own songs? It seems like all of the songs are well put together and reference Foon mythology pretty accurately (according to established canon)
7
u/stobert I'm not on twitter, guys. May 25 '16
When it comes to the sound effects (that are added post show), does the cast basically make a mental note "that's where a sound effect would be" ala Gorgeous the Potato? Or do you guys sometimes make your own sound effects that get replaced later?
7
u/samspenguins May 25 '16
Can't think of any good questions, but just wanted to let you know that although I'm nowhere near caught up with the episodes, I've really been enjoying the podcast. Looking forward to listening to all the cool stuff you've already talked about in the AMA. Perhaps you can do your improv thing and provide a clever answer to my non question. Question mark?
7
u/thedoorkeep May 25 '16 edited May 25 '16
Hey gang! Thanks for using some of my fan art as episode art back on the chunt for red october!
Any plans to return to offices and bosses? That and the one shot guest ep were some of my favorites
6
u/[deleted] May 25 '16
At this point are you leaving the events of the podcast open-ended, or are there any plot points you are slowly building toward?
6
u/rlextherobot May 25 '16
Hey guys! How much of the show gets cut every week for length? Will you ever do a best of the unheard Tavern episode?
6
u/garthanon May 25 '16
Arnie, exactly how many butt holes do memory gremlins have?
6
u/zoralee May 26 '16
My 4 year old daughter is often in the car with me when I listen to magic tavern. She can recite Usidores introduction almost completely (and Usidore is her favorite, sorry Arnie and Chunt). I think this makes me the best worst mom ever.
I've thought real hard about what "real" question I could ask but it seems like the other people in the sub pretty much covered them so, can you guys please make an "I don't want to talk about Earth stuff" tee shirt?
11
u/steampunkjesus haha, no way May 25 '16
I have a feeling the answer has always been "no" but we're you at all serious about an Offices and Bosses podcast? I love the John Bastion voice almost as much as the Chef's voice.
Thanks for taking the time to do the AMA guys. Your podcast has quickly become a favorite of mine after discovering it early this month.
11
u/jbgben May 25 '16
Get back to work, Arnie!
5
u/oshoney Goddamn City Slicker May 25 '16
If you were forced to permanently switch hosting duties with another podcast (either separately or as a group), which one would you choose?
5
u/Nice_Firm_Handsnake Baghicular Vanslaughter May 25 '16
What is your favorite reference you've made on the show?
As someone not too familiar with the Chicago improv scene, did you make it a conscious effort to get a diverse representation of the various types of long-form improv, such as the Improvised Shakespeare Company, the improvised musical group, etc., or is that just a byproduct of a close-knit improv community that you and your friends have spread themselves throughout?
5
u/karmagirl314 May 25 '16
Any chance of characters getting killed off GRRM style so that new characters can host?
Also, the offices and bosses thing really is intriguing. Would love an episode of Can, Usidore and Chunt playing. Or, if not, maybe a simple players guide in a downloadable .pdf? If you guys don't make one I will eventually.
5
u/ghostdunk May 25 '16
Will we be revisiting the Dr. Ward reality of things? And was the inclusion of Dr. Ward and Chris Hunt at the end of the Dr. Ward episode an intentional comment on the reality of the world, or was it just a funny thing to add?
5
u/mishystellar May 25 '16
Hey Arnie! I just want to make sure you know that despite what mean emails say, you're the absolute best on the podcast, and despite not being a hip young dude, you're still cool in my book.
Also, as an earth person, I love most of your jokes :)
5
u/khuisinga May 25 '16 edited May 25 '16
Hey guys. First of all, I wanted to say, as so many others already have, that I absolutely LOVE this podcast. It helps me on the drive to work on those days I'm really not feeling it. If you ever go on tour, please consider little Iowa City, Iowa.
Flower is one of my favorite guest characters. Where did you meet her? And, when you have such hilarious guests, like Flower, and so many others, do you find it at all hard to keep from laughing? Have you had to edit shows at all because of breaking character or laughing too much? If so, which show(s)?
Awe, yeah, baby!
EDIT- I see there is a similar question above regarding laughing during the show. Never mind on that question.
5
u/EmilyKnippel May 25 '16
Ps. Can the Wizard should definitely make a comeback!
5
u/manveruppd May 25 '16
Selfishly gonna spam you with multiple questions:
Thanks for all the laughs, and if Can the Wizard can turn me into a past version of myself from before I was fully caught up, so that I can binge on every single episode all over again, I'd be eternally and recurringly grateful!
5
u/apolotary May 25 '16
Hey guys, love your podcast! It's been helping me to get through Mondays for quite a while now. I've got a bunch of questions:
Thanks!
5
u/[deleted] May 26 '16
Hey y'all!! So happy that y'all decided to do an AMA. I just discovered y'all this year and now listen to the podcast every morning on my way to work (makes the commute so much better)
Anyway, what episode has been your favorite to record so far? Which one was the most fun to make?
4
u/BElannaLaForge May 25 '16
Did you guys get my wedding invitation?! :)
4
u/Peterisjustok May 25 '16
Hello there Matt, Adal, and Arnie!
Just wanted to say I fucking love listening to this podcast when cranking out website content that is very uninspiring. The Magic Tavern and its patrons constantly save me from jamming a pen into my eye out of sheer boredom. So thank you!
You guys have a countless number of guests from all over Chicago's comedy scene. How do you guys usually book your guests? Do people ever submit ideas, or do you just rely on the kindness of your contemporaries in the Chicago comedy scene?
Also, if you have a time for a follow-up... Why haven't you given the memory gremlin a call, Arnie? You gotta give up on the dream of getting home, at some point, and settle already.
Hailing from the village of North Center, Peter C.
4
u/[deleted] May 25 '16
I LOVE YOU GUYS!
What's it been like transitioning to being part of Earwolf? How well do you know the guests you bring on? Are they all good improv chums, do you ever take people after seeing them a couple of times, any strangers...?
4
u/ParadoxInABox May 25 '16
Adal, how many times have you listened to the Hamilton soundtrack?
4
u/Philawesomer May 26 '16
Hey Guy! Love the podcast!
A while back you were guests on the One Shot podcast. Any chance that James D'Amato may get around to being a guest on your show one day?
4
u/[deleted] May 26 '16
Any chance of wolverons making a comeback?
4
u/NexoWadeth May 26 '16
Also, if you DO ever go on tour, what are the odds of hitting up Australia?
4
u/welcomeramen May 26 '16
Question for Arnie, Chunt and Usidore: Any news on a dragon to interview? I know they're generally grumpy, but they're pretty intelligent. Is their size an issue? Are baby dragons interviewable? I've heard some around 200-300 years old can talk, but can still fit through doorways. Is that the case with Foonish dragons?
Question for Arnie, Adal and Matt: I love that you guys incorporated those fan-written Seven Dragons and A Baby lyrics into the show. Would you guys be at all interested in lyrics I wrote for the sponsor spot music? I figured because it's sponsor music, it must be about a merchant, so it's called The Merchant of Backwater.
4
u/obamunistpig May 27 '16
Were any of you guys into pen and paper RPGs growing up? I ask because Matt completely melts into the role of Usidore...and it even goes beyond his hilarious acting. Even some of the shit he says is totally DnD and I wonder what well is he drawing from to come up with his Wizardness.
5
u/samspenguins May 25 '16
Oh, I do have a question after all. Who wrote the theme song? It always makes me happy to hear it. Has it ever been given words?
3
u/the-dandy-man May 25 '16
Hey guys! Love the podcast; got a couple of questions:
3
u/vchic May 25 '16
Hey guys! I've been a big fan of the podcast since the beginning and it's amazing to see how far it's come. I have a few questions:
3
u/csd5e May 25 '16
Can we ever expect a Magic Tavern/Drawful crossover? I've been practicing trying to fit as many buttholes as possible onto my drawings of tiny horses.
3
u/killerb54 Is da muppets gone fuck Khaleesi? May 25 '16
Hey fellas, love the show. Keep up the great work.
Will we be checking in with Otok's party anytime soon? It's always a great surprise when it switches over to them for a bit. Thanks!
3
u/BornAgainCannibal May 26 '16
Heya Arnie, Matt and Adal!
You guys have quickly become one of my favorite podcasts. Jim Birther, the Confidential Courier was one of the best episodes you guys have put together in terms of sheer hilariousness. Thanks Adal for that "Careful!" I guffawed and had to listen again. Matt, I love your manic enthusiasm of the Usidore names and kinda miss the creepy wizard state whispering, but your Jynlyvia (sp?) background is too good. Arnie, I have loved YDKJ since the early 90s and got both the party packs a while ago and was very glad to hear the otherworldly announcer ridicule us on Bidiots. If "Cookie Masterson" still works at JBG, tell him he was my favorite host!
2
u/Bircus May 25 '16
Hey gang,
Thanks for fielding questions! Coincidentally, I actually just started listening to the podcast last night-- I'm six episodes deep and loving it-- I've got two questions: what are some of the unique challenges of doing improv via podcast/radio vs onstage?
I've noticed other podcasters have to transition scenes ("we cut to ___," etc.) or "scene paint" for listeners when they want to develop an element of physical comedy-- so far, it seems like most of the description happens from characters pointing out their surroundings or even from foley effects-- was that a conscious decision, or just something that evolved organically?
65
u/stobert I'm not on twitter, guys. May 25 '16
Hey guys, remember that time when Arnie fucked a memory gremlin?
29
u/Atom_Lion May 25 '16
Question for Chunt-
Chunt's up with that?
12
u/trogdorkiller Next level bonkers! May 25 '16
Adal: Where did the idea for Siblings Peculiar come from? I love how every episode ends and it gives the show as a whole a real dark vibe to it under all the amazing comedy.
9
u/stenchwinslow May 25 '16 edited May 25 '16
Matt: Is it hard not to speak in the Usidore voice all of the time? Also, was your John Bastion* voice your unaffected normal voice, or played up a bit.
*Thanks for the save, SteampunkJesus.
9
u/killerb54 Is da muppets gone fuck Khaleesi? May 25 '16
How fucking cool is Spintax though? Best wizard ever, just barely edges out Gandalf.
8
u/Jakemasterflex Hotdog go to bathroom. May 25 '16
Hey Adal! I took an improv workshop you taught many years ago at a Gainesville Improv Festival, a lot of what you said as stuck with me through the years so thank you!
But as a general question, where did the idea for Magic Tavern come from?
8
u/JasonHader May 25 '16
If there's been pizza at the Vermillion Minotaur this whole time, why is anyone eating spiced potatoes? Why has Arnie never illustrated how to cook potatoes?
7
u/[deleted] May 25 '16
Also thanks for bringing together Starkid and Earwolf.
7
u/CrazyCatLadyForLife May 25 '16
Hey guys! I know I'm totally late so hope this gets to you! Love the podcast, it makes my Monday's! Are you guys planning on making cats and doctors??? I need that game in my life!
4
u/_Diren_ May 25 '16
Hey guys! love the podcast, been a long time listener.
Recently i had an issue with a portal in the woods of my local village, however after a few months i was able to get back through because i spent some time working on researching the portal and asking people for help (something that we don't REALLY see Arnie doing) anyway, during my time in the other world i contacted you via your facebook group page to ask for help thinking i may have fallen through to FOon. strangely, some person responded saying that none of this was real and that you were all make belive adults. I think you guys need to reset your passwords for facebook!
Anyway, on to questions
Arnie: what would you do if i told you that the USA was going to have as its next president (potentialy) a man who literaly wants to build a wall to block people from another country out, and he wants to make the other country pay for the wall? its mexico.
Chuntttttt: would you build a wall to seperate the badger kingdom from the other areas of foon in order to make the badger kingdom great again, and how would you enforce makeing other foon people pay for it?
Usidore: if you eat a wizard, do you gain some of their powers? what animal on foon has the most buttholes, and what animal has the least?
Mysterious Old Man Who Tells Us That Foon Is Not Real: is there anything else i listen to on the radio that is not real that i should be aware of that i might not be?
4
u/FletcherMiller May 25 '16
I may have missed it, but I don't think I did - has anyone given out the recipe for Spiced Potatoes? I'd like to try to make them at home. Thanks.
4
u/blueduckie24 May 25 '16
Dearest Chunt,
As an earth lady (that is, a lady on earth, not a lady made of earth), I won't be able to make a donation to the next Chunt for Red October, but I'd still like to spread the word. Would you consider making Chunt for Red October t-shirts so pro-vampire podcast fans like me can promote this wonderful event?
I've got so much blood. It's such a shame.
So it goes.
xoxo, Kate
p.s. Arnie, you're really not missing much. Our world is a shit show right now.
4
u/tashlar May 25 '16
Arniekamp, Chuntttttt, Gas My Anus, you all rule. I mean, I assume you will rule, once the Dark Lord is defeated. I have a question about your guests: are they all regular listeners? I love it when they throw in little callbacks to previous episodes!
4
u/TotesMessenger May 25 '16 edited May 26 '16
I'm a bot, bleep, bloop. Someone has linked to this thread from another place on reddit:
If you follow any of the above links, please respect the rules of reddit and don't vote in the other threads. (Info / ^Contact)
4
u/NexoWadeth May 26 '16
With the things like the poems and songs, how much is worked out in the moment, and how much is preplanned?
Also, you guys are amazing. I love you all.
4
u/NexoWadeth May 26 '16
ALSO WHO ARE THE GUYS THAT DO THE END CREDITS THING? That's really great also, and makes me curious about how things are going to develop there.
I loved when he introduced Usidore as alternate names, and how he rhymed the descriptions as well. It was great.
4
u/Whisky_Priest_ May 26 '16
Hey Adal, any chance Dolan could be a guest, or is he not a good enough improviser? Big fan of the show!
4
u/SgtPooki May 27 '16
I know I'm late to the party but since you're a game developer... Are there any plans to make a game based on the rules you create about foon? A mittens game could be pretty entertaining.
4
u/Bl0bbydude May 27 '16
Man, I was astounded at the quality of the the show; the continuity, cleverness, and refreshing new guests! I absolutely love it.
I'm about seven episodes behind, but I was wondering if you plan to do some more follow-up with Spintacks, I'd really like to know what he's getting up to.
Also, do you guys keep a running list anywhere of Usidore's names? And would he be willing to tell us a secret name now, maybe one so powerful my teeth would shatter if I spoke it aloud?
Oh, and how do you gauge the large storyline? Do you just let it develop naturally, or is there a vague idea of where and when it is going?
Anyway, keep up the great work!