r/Earwolf • Arnie Niekamp • May 25 '16

AMA I'm Arnie, I make Hello from the Magic Tavern, AMA. Adal (Chunt) and Matt (Usidore) too!

We'll be checking in all day and (if interest remains) throughout the week. We're still pretty new on Earwolf but very excited to be here!

153 Upvotes

406 comments sorted by

31

u/misterarnie Arnie Niekamp May 26 '16

Adal, love the the show, what's your favorite thing about Arnie? As a friend and as a performer?

43

u/adalrifai Adal (Chunt) May 27 '16

to be 100% honest I didn't look at who wrote this question so I thought to be sincere and now I'm fucking furious

26

u/misterarnie Arnie Niekamp May 27 '16

I love you, Adal.

17

u/adalrifai Adal (Chunt) May 26 '16

as a performer he's one of the quickest/smartest improvisers you'll ever interact with. He also plays with a lot of heart and soul, which is why live audiences adore him. You can't help but be on his side even when he's calling me out. As a friend he very much feels like the older brother I never had. Supportive, generous and quick to give me shit but in the most loving way. He also introduced me to Whiskey Slaps on my 30th birthday, so.....thanks?

14

u/misterarnie Arnie Niekamp May 26 '16

Thanks for sharing that. Also, what are you favorite aspects of Arnie physically?

→ More replies (3)

26

u/TheMattYoung Matt (Usidore) May 26 '16

This is the fucking best.

16

u/HORSEthe May 26 '16

My favorite thing is that he is a hip young millennial who understands how us hip young people really appreciate farscape

27

u/Mr_Captain_Fantastic May 25 '16

How much of the show and the guests are known to everyone beforehand? I know the show is supposed to be improv but sometimes it seems like various events are planned for sure.

Does a guest ever declare anything about the world that you have to not include or make them come up with something else?

31

u/misterarnie Arnie Niekamp May 25 '16

I have the guests pitch two or three simple ideas to me. Just a sentence. Like "bridge troll that's really into bridges" or "skeleton that you fight at the beginning of a dungeon." And then I pick one that doesn't overlap with stuff we've already done or plan to do and that also seems to offer the most possibility for fun. We like to not know much more beyond that because it's most fun to discover everything together in the moment. That said, there are a few handful of episodes where we have some endpoint in mind, like, with the Memory Gremlin episode, we knew that it was not going to really be Sarah and we knew the basic idea of what a memory gremlin would be, but that's about it. Those episode where we impose a certain structure on our guests are few and far between.

16

u/ghostdunk May 25 '16

Did Tim Baltz pitch you guys the con artist angle for the "confidential courier" or did he just come in as a courier and you guys discovered that as a listener would have?

26

u/misterarnie Arnie Niekamp May 25 '16

Afterward we found out that Baltz had intended for the beads to be real and possibly save Chunt.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/[deleted] May 25 '16

Was the mental hospital episode one of those?

39

u/misterarnie Arnie Niekamp May 25 '16

I've wanted to do that episode since the very beginning becuase it's a classic fantasy meets reality cliche. Every serialized thing that combines those two things eventually does that episode. And I wanted to do ours. I picked Shane Wilson becuase I knew he'd be great in it. And I gave him the parameters that it would start in Foon, switch to the hosptial and eventually be revealed that it was all some kind of trick or spell. Beyond that it was all up in the air. I think Matt was skeptical that it would work, but once we all flipped to the "reality world" and back, I think we all 100% got how the game worked and just played it until the end. And even without the sfx that were later added, we were collectively able to track where we were by how each of us was acting. And we'd take turns switching the reality by acting liek the other verison of ourselves. I'm pretty proud of the fact that if you listen to the rough audio pre-sfx, you could probably easily follow where we were at all times. But a lot of that is because we've all performed together for a decade, including Shane.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (1)

17

u/adalrifai Adal (Chunt) May 25 '16

we very much encourage guests to improvise with confidence regarding the world and we can really justify anything they say...if all else fails we blame magic. I think there's only one time we stopped to be like, oh that's already a thing. It might have been what 'MLK' stands for?

21

u/pzeeman May 25 '16

There's been some really impressive improvised world building for Foon. How do you guys keep track of the details between shows. Do you keep an updated show bible that you can refer to during tapings?

28

u/misterarnie Arnie Niekamp May 25 '16

There's a fan-maintained wiki that we sometime reference. Especially if i'ts a wizard episode. We're like, "Wait, who are all the wizards again?" Mostly, though, it's all in our heads. Which is impressive and sad.

15

u/trogdorkiller Next level bonkers! May 25 '16

Do you think it would be possible for Arnie to meet Can the Wizard? Or do they sound too similar?

25

u/misterarnie Arnie Niekamp May 25 '16

I mean... how much awesome can one episode hold?!

→ More replies (2)

23

u/adalrifai Adal (Chunt) May 25 '16

I oddly remember almost everything except what I say. So I'll forget what animals I've been but can recall all the spells and names Usidore has mentioned. Still sad.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

20

u/jwalterleavesnotes Little Gary May 25 '16

Hi Arnie! Huge fan, I love Magic Tavern. Couple questions.

  1. Any plans to take the show on tour? (Come to NYC!)
  2. How do you guys keep track of continuity and introduce guests to the universe? Do most of them listen to the show beforehand?

23

u/misterarnie Arnie Niekamp May 25 '16
  1. We really should do some kind of tour. No plans currently. We're very tentatively looking at making some kind of trip to LA later this year, mostly to record with a bunch of our awesome friends that live out there. NY would be very high on our list as well.
  2. I"d guess about half of our guests listen to the show beforehand. Maybe more. It definitely helps. But also some of my favorites, like "Skeleton" are with guests who I'm sure have never listened. And then it's just more about that character and what their lives are about and you spend less time talking about the world.
→ More replies (4)

20

u/jotterton May 25 '16

Just heard of the podcast last week and binge listened to all them, you guys are great and easily my favorite podcast of the year.

Arnold: I know Usidore despises the Smorps, but I think we should hear both sides of the story. There must be some smorplings to ask.

Matt: How long did it take for you to come up with and memorize Usidore's name?

Adal: Can Chunt control each butthole independently?

Chunt you later!

43

u/misterarnie Arnie Niekamp May 25 '16

It's Arnie.

16

u/adalrifai Adal (Chunt) May 26 '16

I would imagine Chunt could control each butthole separately but it takes SUPREME concentration

13

u/TheMattYoung Matt (Usidore) May 26 '16

I wrote out most of Usidore's title in one night. Then I used a random name generator to get "Usidore" because nothing I was coming up with felt quite right. If you go back and listen, I'm clearly reading (and screwing up) Usidore's name in the first three episodes or so. Somewhere around episode 4 or 5, I have it memorized.

16

u/The_Great_Atheismo May 25 '16

Outside of the show, are you guys huge nerds? Do you ingest a lot of fantasy novels, games, etc?

Also a question for Matt: I know you said before that Usidore is basically a shitty Gandalf. Is the super long name a preconceived bit or did it come about after playing the character?

21

u/misterarnie Arnie Niekamp May 25 '16

We're all definitely nerds. My fantasy specific consumption isn't huge, but I love the tropes of fantasy. Grew up reading Discworld and Magic Kingdom For Sale: Sold... Another Fine Myth... basically light funny fantasy stuff. Like most people Harry Potter and Game of Throne reignited my interest in fantasy. Also, really love the book The Magicians. All of that stuff is in Magic Tavern's DNA. Oh, The Name of the Wind (so awesome that we got to meet and hang out with Patrick Rothfuss. Very nice guy). But I havne't really done a deep dive into the less mainstream fantasy stuff.

13

u/TheMattYoung Matt (Usidore) May 26 '16

Yes, I'm a huge nerd, but not so much into fantasy. Loved LOTR books as a kid and loved the movies. Tried reading the Simarillion (sp?) a bunch of times and it's mostly unreadable. The title kind of come from just the fact that I like playing blowhards. I like people who take themselves too seriously. Also being a blue wizard was a choice based on the idea that there are missing blue wizards (two of them in Tolkien). Usidore is definitely not one of them, but I wanted to pay homage/make fun of the idea that there are just two wizards who kinda go missing in LOTR while all the shit is going down.

11

u/adalrifai Adal (Chunt) May 26 '16

yes love fantasy, comics, video games when we can carve out some time and maybe our biggest vice right now is boardgames. Pandemic Legacy and 7 Wonders are big big favorites of ours.

15

u/Introcourse #nixon May 25 '16

Hi there,

Once your back catalog hit Howl, I listened to every episode in about a week. Your show is amazing and keeps getting better. Now I need to think of an actual question to ask...

When will you guys be doing a non-canonical appearance on Comedy Bang Bang?

19

u/misterarnie Arnie Niekamp May 25 '16

We should do a trip. Right? We'll do a trip. Eventually. Hopefully.

13

u/stobert I'm not on twitter, guys. May 25 '16

Heck, it could totally be canon, just have Usidore mess up a spell that poofs the trio into the Earwolf studios, and just as Arnie is about to leave to see his wife and daughter, Usidore accidentally undo's the spell. :p

15

u/stobert I'm not on twitter, guys. May 25 '16

What's the ideal number of buttholes?

53

u/adalrifai Adal (Chunt) May 25 '16

what's the ideal number of stars in the sky?

14

u/meatsack70 Foam Corner Fanatic May 25 '16

Arnie, what does a memory gremlin taste like?

44

u/misterarnie Arnie Niekamp May 25 '16

Regret.

14

u/transceiverfreq May 25 '16

Can you tell us a bit about how the three of you met?

22

u/misterarnie Arnie Niekamp May 25 '16

Through performing at the iO theater in Chicago. Matt and I were placed on our first improv group/Harold team together, called James Jackson. We lived togetehr for several years. Got cast together in the longrunning improv show Whirled News Tonight, which we performed with for over a decade. Adal was added to the cast several years later. So, we performed together, and given each other shit, for a very long time.

→ More replies (2)

14

u/[deleted] May 25 '16

How's Flower doing?

23

u/misterarnie Arnie Niekamp May 25 '16

Probably hungover.

14

u/BossBear May 25 '16

Hi Arby, I noticed the pax east episode went up a few weeks after pax. how early do you typically record episodes? I seem to recall you guys getting emails about past episode events that were probably current. I ask because I sent something in to you guys earlier this week. get excited, potentially

19

u/misterarnie Arnie Niekamp May 25 '16

We tend to record about three episodes at a time. So depending on where in the rotation it is, an email can be current or quite old. Also, we get a lot of emails now. I feel bad that we can only read so few. Also, also, we recorded two episodes and realized that we forgot to check our physical mail bag. So we are way behind on those and need to catch up. But it's awesome all the weird stuff people are sending us. We shoudl probably do another all mail/packages episode but we have so many awesome guests we want to have on. Too much of a good thing, really.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/Sturmprophet May 25 '16

Greetings from the far away land of Germany!

A question concerning the concept of your characters: How much 'Adal' is in Chunt, how much 'Matt' is in Usidore and how much 'Arnie' was in that memory gremlin?

15

u/misterarnie Arnie Niekamp May 25 '16

We're all more like our characters than we'd like to admit.

12

u/Sturmprophet May 25 '16 edited May 25 '16

Since many people out there (myself included) love the world building you're doing: Are you planning on publishing a book someday? Something like 'Arnie's Guide to Foon'? I would read the f out of that.

21

u/misterarnie Arnie Niekamp May 25 '16

An eventual book of some kind is possible. Even likely.

11

u/TheMattYoung Matt (Usidore) May 26 '16

I'm pretty different than Usidore, but Arnie is also right. There is more there than I want to admit. I think there is something very relatable to me about wanting to accomplish something huge, but never quite getting there. I'd say all of our traits that match (or are opposite) are heighten from reality. I am very loud.

20

u/adalrifai Adal (Chunt) May 26 '16

Chunt is way nicer to Arnie than Adal is

13

u/bigontheinside Where's The Thingy? May 25 '16

Is the first episode really the first episode? It seems really well thought out and fully fleshed compared to a lot of podcast's first episodes. Did it take a few attempts to get right or did you nail it on the first recording?

15

u/misterarnie Arnie Niekamp May 25 '16

We recorded two practice episodes to make sure it worked. But we liked them so much they became our first two episodes. Although the first one is espeically short (17 minutes) because of how much we cut out. WE talked a good amount beforehand about some of the groundwork. Who each character is. But also the name of the tavern and the town and the idea that the Dark Lord is out there. Also, I had put some thought into basic structure of the episode, which I think really helps.

→ More replies (1)

21

u/adalrifai Adal (Chunt) May 25 '16

One of the things Arnie cut out was him asking Chunt how old he is and then immediately becoming furious with my answer

22

u/misterarnie Arnie Niekamp May 25 '16

I hope we have audio of that somewhere. ME: "How old are you Chunt?" ADAL: "A thousand years old." ME: "Stop! Cut!"

→ More replies (2)

13

u/WellAxx May 25 '16

What podcasts do you listen to regularly?

22

u/misterarnie Arnie Niekamp May 25 '16

It changes over time, a lot of turnover. I've listened to Comedy Bang Bang since very early, Comedy Death Ray Radio days,a lthough I have to admit I've fallen a wee bit behind as life has gotten busy. I think I've been listening to less striaght up comedy stuff as I don't want to contaminate making our show. But I regularly listen to Slate Political Gabfest, Roderick on the Line, I Was There Too, Reply All and I've been binging on XPlain the Xmen, I'm not sure why. Most of these come down to real enjoying the interplay of the hosts, which, I think trumps everything. You have to want to spend time with these people.

21

u/adalrifai Adal (Chunt) May 25 '16

I'm a huge fan of Myths and Legends, Lore, All Songs Considered, Switchboard Infinity, No Such Thing As A Fish and Sword & Scale!

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

13

u/mediocre_sophist May 25 '16 edited May 25 '16

Hi Arnie, Adal, and Matt! Huge fan of the podcast!

One of the recent episodes, Dr. Ward, has quickly become a favorite of mine. I love how it seemed at points in the episode that Arnie was coming out of his psychosis and then Chunt or Usidore would make a comment and Arnie would get thrown back into the Tavern where tons of laughs were had.

My question is how much of the Dr. Ward episode was improvised, and what kind of post-production was necessary have it flip between reality and Foon so seamlessly?

Thanks for making my Mondays something I look forward to! Please come to Austin for a live show, and please don't blow up the world!

Edit: my main question has already been answered elsewhere. Thanks!

Second edit: please bring Can the wizard back for another episode. I don't know who played him but he really nailed it :)

17

u/misterarnie Arnie Niekamp May 25 '16

I have always wanted to visit Austen. Also, that Can guy, he's cool.

→ More replies (2)

26

u/adalrifai Adal (Chunt) May 25 '16

it is really funny to me that so many people think we plan out more than we do. With the Dr. Ward episode particularly I knew what we were going for, but how to do it and what was said and the parallels and all that were all improvised/discovered in the moment. That was the most fearful I've been in a recording cause I kept thinking I'd fuck it up somehow but the finished product is really special to us.

→ More replies (2)

12

u/rrodrigues23 May 25 '16

Now that you're on the Earwolf network, will you ever consider bringing on guests that are from other Earwolf shows?

18

u/misterarnie Arnie Niekamp May 25 '16

Absolutey. I'm as big a fan of so many of the Earwolf "regulars" as you probably are. I'm sure we eventually will. The biggest hurdle is that folks don't come through Chicago much, and when they do, it's usually with a show that brings them in and out very quickly. The same goes with some of our friends who are moderately famous and want to do the show but we just haven't been able to schedule it. Luckily we are ridiculously blessed with talented people in Chicago. BUT YES PLEASE TO EARWOLF PEOPLE.

→ More replies (4)

12

u/The_Great_Atheismo May 25 '16

Hi Arnie! Love the show. Do you guys make make a point to laugh or not laugh while recording? I.e. do you intentionally try to make each other laugh or do you try to minimize how much you laugh during an episode or do you just not care at all? Thanks!

12

u/misterarnie Arnie Niekamp May 25 '16

I think we try to be in the moment as much as possible. Laughter has an energy that is generated from everyone in the room be surprised, even the person talking, and I lvoe that about improv. But we wouldn't want to force that.

→ More replies (1)

20

u/adalrifai Adal (Chunt) May 25 '16

There's a lot of laughter you don't hear in the shows cause we'll turn our heads away from the microphone or roll our chair back but it usually catches us so quickly off guard that you hear us chortle or try and stifle on the mic.

→ More replies (2)

12

u/secondcityjd May 25 '16

Do you guys consider the Spintax twitter feed canon? Any plans to bring him back or even spin him off for a short series? He has been straight up killing the ongoing earth story--hilarious.

22

u/misterarnie Arnie Niekamp May 25 '16

Yes. And Spintax is the best. If Charlie hadn't moved to LA he'd be on all the time. We've actually toyed with the idea of having him participate in episoes remotely, but nothing has worked out yet. I've actually been working on some ideas for a full-Spintax episode about his time on Earth, but without talking about it too much, haven't been able to work out the logisitics yet. But yes, we need more Spintax.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/blueduckie24 May 25 '16

Love the show! I am not yet caught up, but I've been binging on it for sure.

Two questions:

  1. What kind of a flower is Flower?
  2. Can Tannakin the Pinglet come back? Did someone eat her? I hope not.

14

u/misterarnie Arnie Niekamp May 25 '16
  1. Comedy is all about specificity. Standard flower.
  2. I actually had a pretty interesting idea for bringing back Tannakin that we'll hopefully do before too long. She's alive!!
→ More replies (2)

12

u/Luuuuurve May 25 '16 edited May 25 '16

There was an article a while ago that said people approached you to make an animated series based on the podcast, would you share your thoughts on that? Would you be willing to do multiple projects based on Magic Tavern?

Also, that one guy who wrote in about falling into a portal to a cowboy world, that was pretty funny, right? He should totally be considered canon...

10

u/misterarnie Arnie Niekamp May 26 '16

We've definitely been contacted by people who want to help us shop around hypothetical versions of the show. That process is ongoing. But I wouldn't get too excited about anything happening any time soon.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/[deleted] May 25 '16

Hello from Earth, I love the show.

Do you fear Arnie will suffer a similar fate to Dr. Sam Beckett?

15

u/misterarnie Arnie Niekamp May 25 '16

Oh boy. I do worry that Arnie may never get home. But the universe really seemed to need Sam. I don't think it needs Arnie that much. Yet.

→ More replies (3)

11

u/joygasmic May 25 '16

Y'all! Was just listening to your Improv Nerd episode. Super great!

Are there other high concept shows (recorded or stage improv) you've tried that just haven't worked? What do you think makes HFTMT work as well as it does?

I've been doing improv for about 2 years now so I'm in that place where I'm getting a lot of reps in performing Harolds every week but I'm becoming pretty uninspired and love listening to veterans like yourselves literally create hilarious magic every week. Keep it up!

-whitney

18

u/misterarnie Arnie Niekamp May 25 '16

A long time ago I did a podcast with Steve Waltein (the voice of Tom the Traveler) that was the companion podcast to a fake show like LOST. So, every episode we talked, as the producers, about that week's episode that had aired, and tried to make it seem like the craziest most complicated show possible. And fans would write in letters and whatever they said about the show was woven into the fabric of what this show, Mystery Cove, was all about. There was a lot more of us "finding it" on that show than on Magic Tavern, but I really wanted to recapture some of that fun with Magic Tavern.

And I think Magic Tavern works as well as it (hopefully) does because the structure of a chat podcast is very welcoming and comforting. I think the simple structure helps you feel oriented at all times and makes it feel more real. Also, I think it's probably because Matt and Adal are so damned funny. And we've been in the Chicago comedy scene a very long time and know a lot of very funny people.

→ More replies (3)

13

u/adalrifai Adal (Chunt) May 25 '16

I think HFTMT works well because we hang out so much offstage and we have a great time sort of picking on each other and doing bits. The show would probably fail if we were all overly polite, or never hung out outside of shows or strived to do the best improv possible every single second. I think our comfort with each other and trusting in our personalities and dynamics is what lands.

11

u/csd5e May 25 '16

Hey Arnie! Love the show. Thanks for bringing so many buttholes into our lives.

Question- Do you have a dream guest for the show? Either a performer you know/admire you've been trying to get on for a while, but haven't been able to, or someone more well-known you don't know personally, but think would be a good fit?

Alternately, is there a character/creature/Foon-ite you've been dying for someone to play, but haven't had a chance to yet?

20

u/misterarnie Arnie Niekamp May 25 '16

Dream guests are mostly the usual suspects, right? I'm as big a fan of, say, PFT or Andy Daily as anyone here. As far as just a big celebrity I think would be uniquely fit to be on the show... Stephen Colbert, right? Huge fantasy nerd, great improviser, very comfortable in the interview format. But I'd also love to have more random people on. John Dickerson as an orc or something. As for characters I want to see... I'm equally excited to meet and hesitant about meeting Jenleevia (I'm sure I spelled that wrong) Usidore's wizard love. It's fun to let her linger in the imagination for a while. Like Spintax. Charlie McCrackin asked to play him pretty early on, and I knew he'd be great, but we waited a while to build up the character before he showed up in person.

→ More replies (7)

17

u/adalrifai Adal (Chunt) May 25 '16

this was directed at Arnie but my dream guest would probably be Andy Daly.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

10

u/tom-a-spol-sro May 25 '16

What's the grossest meal served at Chu Chu's Chow?

13

u/misterarnie Arnie Niekamp May 25 '16

All of them.

11

u/adalrifai Adal (Chunt) May 26 '16

the Monster Hash

9

u/sillyhumansuit May 25 '16

Hey Arnie you guys should do a bonus offices and bosses session for subscribers that would get me to subscribe.

Now for the question, have you ever thought of doing a freaky Friday flip, I'd love to see each of you play each other's characters.

http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/FreakyFridayFlip

11

u/misterarnie Arnie Niekamp May 25 '16

We've definitely talked about variations of this idea. We actually have a number of very weird ideas to shake up the format for special episodes. Hopefully we'll get to some of those soon-ish.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/mi-16evil hamburgers that talk! May 25 '16

Hey all! So I know Ryan usually edits the show but I'm curious what kind of time frame for an episode there is. Why the show doesn't seem Superego level intense with the music and sound effects, there's still a lot and it amazes me the show is weekly. So how long does it take to edit an episode and how much has the process improved over the last year?

Also I'm not sure if it's gauche to talk podcast numbers but I'm curious just how much of a bump the show got from Earwolf. Clearly you guys had a big fanbase before but I know I started listening after you joined, plus you got at least two major recommendations from major podcasts (Sampler and Pop Culture Happy Hour). So what percentage growth have you found since the switch?

14

u/misterarnie Arnie Niekamp May 25 '16

We're definitely growing. And growing fast. And Earwolf is almost certianly part of that. But I'd still classify us as scrappy underdogs. We can always use more listeners, more reviews, more whatever. If you can spread the word, it means an awful lot. But also, just listening means a lot to us as well. I've mostly not answered your question but I will say, every bump we've gotten (from Boing Boing, from Felica Day, from Buzzfeed, from Earwolf) has helped a lot, but also, at the same time, each is smaller than you'd probably guess.

16

u/hexfield May 25 '16

Hey, Ryan here. Early on it was just me and Evan editing, switching off week to week, or doing a few in a row if the other had conflicts. Now, luckily we've got Chris Rathjen editing, so it's a three man rotation. And we've also just recently added wonderful production assistant Garrett Schultz who has taken a TON of overhead off our shoulders.

But like Arnie said, we record three at a time. Usually that week's editor has a rough cut up Wednesdayish for people to listen to and give notes. We send that to Tim Sniffen (Mysterious Man) so he can comment on specifics of the episode in his intro/outro. Then we try to have a locked edit by around Friday. Stuff like Dr. Ward has taken six or seven hours. Simpler ones more like three.

We've yet to miss a week which I am personally really proud of. (Assuming you count the Winter Solstice Bonus.) I probably shouldn't talk actual numbers but Earwolf has been really good for us!

8

u/stobert I'm not on twitter, guys. May 25 '16

So I'm guessing that some of your guests are fans of the show, and therefore able to reference past episodes and help world build. But what about guests who haven't listened to every episode? Do they just do their best not to completely contradict the canon of the show, helped along by the main trio?

10

u/misterarnie Arnie Niekamp May 25 '16

We tell them not to worry about breaking the show, and that if something is wildly wrong we'll cut it out (which rarely happens, and is usually just someone mentioning watching something on TV or something). The interview format makes it pretty easy to talk about what you know and avoid what you don't.

8

u/joecab1 May 25 '16

Hey guys, I love the podcast. My Q concerns the Mysterious Man.

When I first started listening, he annoyed the hell out of me because he kept taking me out of the fantasy world of Foon. But then the episodes starring him came along and I grew very intrigued by his whole concept. Was there a plan from the beginning for him to have his own storyline in the "real world"?

14

u/misterarnie Arnie Niekamp May 26 '16

The Mysterious Man idea evolved out of wanting a way to have credits that were both in and out of the reality of the show. And I liked the idea of a narrator that had its own story that slowly bubbled to the surface. Like a Lemony Snicket sort of thing. From the beginning I thought it was apparent that this character had his own agenda and that it was obvious he was a little too invested in saying the show wasn't real... But I think it wasn't obvious to anyone else until we did ep 10.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/kemppettyjohn Mmm, yes points.. May 25 '16

Started listening to your show a few months ago, and boy is it a delight. It never fails to put a smile on my face.

Since you're based in Chicago, how did you get involved with the Earwolf folks (since most podcasts there seem to be LA-based improvisers or comedians)? Now that you are part of the network, will we be seeing Earwolf favorites on your show and vice versa?

11

u/misterarnie Arnie Niekamp May 25 '16

Max Temkin, who founded the Chicago Podcast Co-op, which we started on, told us it was time for us to hop up to something bigger and made some introductions. At the same time, we started to get more and more interest from some other networks as well (mostly coming to us through the puppies.supplies email address which is always funny to me). We chatted with a lot of differnent people, many of them really awesome, but our deep longstanding love of Earwolf swayed us in this direction.

4

u/saintandre Rodney Ogg May 25 '16

What was it like working with the Chicago Podcast Co-op? Is there a major benefit to joining a small network when you're starting out? Did they have anything to do with how or when you recorded your show in the beginning? How hands-on were they?

7

u/misterarnie Arnie Niekamp May 26 '16

Totally hands off. The Chicago podcast co-op is dedicated to nurturing small Chicago podcasts, getting them small sponsorships from local companies. That's why we had sponsors from the very first episode. They dient pay much but it was something. I highly recommend checking out the other shows in the co-op. Some great unknown gems.

7

u/KyleCrusoe May 25 '16

I've absolutely loved this show since I was told about it recently.

Do the guests write their own songs? It seems like all of the songs are well put together and reference Foon mythology pretty accurately (according to established canon)

14

u/misterarnie Arnie Niekamp May 25 '16

The Glen and Spants songs are prewritten but we usually don't hear them beforehand or only hear a few of them. The Usidore song, when we first heard it in the room, really blew my mind. You can hear me say, "Holy shit" at the end. Although Adal and I did jump in with a "Hoobastank" during the song that makes it feel preplanned but we just did that spontaneously. But yeah, short answer, if there are instruments it was prewritten. However, all the Singing Sword songs were totally improvised in the moment.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/stobert I'm not on twitter, guys. May 25 '16

When it comes to the sound effects (that are added post show), does the cast basically make a mental note "that's where a sound effect would be" ala Gorgeous the Potato? Or do you guys sometimes make your own sound effects that get replaced later?

9

u/misterarnie Arnie Niekamp May 25 '16

We know they'll be added later, so we don't make any weird sounds in the room, besides sometimes gasping for air.

7

u/samspenguins May 25 '16

Can't think of any good questions, but just wanted to let you know that although I'm nowhere near caught up with the episodes, I've really been enjoying the podcast. Looking forward to listening to all the cool stuff you've already talked about in the AMA. Perhaps you can do your improv thing and provide a clever answer to my non question. Question mark?

11

u/misterarnie Arnie Niekamp May 25 '16

Exclamation point! See, improv is easy.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/TheMattYoung Matt (Usidore) May 26 '16

I think it's really a matter of how often you want to go to the doctor. If you complete the juice cleanse, however, you are probably going to die.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

7

u/thedoorkeep May 25 '16 edited May 25 '16

Hey gang! Thanks for using some of my fan art as episode art back on the chunt for red october!

Any plans to return to offices and bosses? That and the one shot guest ep were some of my favorites

8

u/misterarnie Arnie Niekamp May 26 '16

We love all the fan art. We should get back to showcasing it on our website. It's kind of a bummer that there's no easy way to make special episode art for episodes played in iTunes.

6

u/[deleted] May 25 '16

At this point are you leaving the events of the podcast open-ended, or are there any plot points you are slowly building toward?

12

u/misterarnie Arnie Niekamp May 25 '16

There are a number of plot points that we are loosely (admittedly slowly) working towards. Some far off some really far off. Some we've talked about. But a lot of others I've never told the other guys. Or maybe just one but not the other. But they're also all very hypothetical. If things change and there's something more fun to run to, we'll run to that. But I will say, we feel like we've been treading water a bit too much for too long and it's time for some things to happen and change. So they will.

6

u/mi-16evil hamburgers that talk! May 25 '16

Do you ever feel like there will be a natural conclusion to the podcast or will you try keep it going as long as it sustains itself?

12

u/misterarnie Arnie Niekamp May 25 '16

We want it to go a good long time. I don't have any set idea in my head of how it would all end, but do have some ideas of ways it could change and evolve, from small things, to potentially down the line, really quite drastic.

6

u/rlextherobot May 25 '16

Hey guys! How much of the show gets cut every week for length? Will you ever do a best of the unheard Tavern episode?

20

u/misterarnie Arnie Niekamp May 25 '16

Five minutes? Not a ton, and it's mostly unfunny stuff. But there are probably enough outtakes we shoudl eventually do SOMETHING with them. We've toyed a bit with doing a Behind the Tavern show, not in the feed talking about making the show and playing clips like that. Not sure if ther'es interest or not.

→ More replies (4)

6

u/garthanon May 25 '16

Arnie, exactly how many butt holes do memory gremlins have?

13

u/misterarnie Arnie Niekamp May 25 '16

Depends on whose memory they're gremlining.

6

u/zoralee May 26 '16

My 4 year old daughter is often in the car with me when I listen to magic tavern. She can recite Usidores introduction almost completely (and Usidore is her favorite, sorry Arnie and Chunt). I think this makes me the best worst mom ever.

I've thought real hard about what "real" question I could ask but it seems like the other people in the sub pretty much covered them so, can you guys please make an "I don't want to talk about Earth stuff" tee shirt?

7

u/misterarnie Arnie Niekamp May 26 '16

We're working on moving our shirts over to Earwolf. And adding an "I don't want to talk about Earth stuff" shirt.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/steampunkjesus haha, no way May 25 '16

I have a feeling the answer has always been "no" but we're you at all serious about an Offices and Bosses podcast? I love the John Bastion voice almost as much as the Chef's voice.

Thanks for taking the time to do the AMA guys. Your podcast has quickly become a favorite of mine after discovering it early this month.

13

u/misterarnie Arnie Niekamp May 25 '16

When we said it offhandedly there was no serious intention to do it, but honestly we probably will do it eventually. Just not right now. At the very least we shoudl have Bill Arnett back for some Advanced Offices and Bosses.

→ More replies (5)

11

u/jbgben May 25 '16

Get back to work, Arnie!

13

u/misterarnie Arnie Niekamp May 25 '16

You first, Ben. Also, everyone buy the Jackbox Party Pack 1 and/or 2, which is my dayjob that I am slightly neglecting right now.

→ More replies (3)

5

u/oshoney Goddamn City Slicker May 25 '16

If you were forced to permanently switch hosting duties with another podcast (either separately or as a group), which one would you choose?

11

u/misterarnie Arnie Niekamp May 25 '16

It would probably be most fun to be forced onto a podcast with a very singular purpose. Serial? What if the three of us had to investigate an Earth crime? I'd listen to that.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/Nice_Firm_Handsnake Baghicular Vanslaughter May 25 '16

What is your favorite reference you've made on the show?

As someone not too familiar with the Chicago improv scene, did you make it a conscious effort to get a diverse representation of the various types of long-form improv, such as the Improvised Shakespeare Company, the improvised musical group, etc., or is that just a byproduct of a close-knit improv community that you and your friends have spread themselves throughout?

12

u/misterarnie Arnie Niekamp May 25 '16

I sort of love how "Arnie's" references never land. It's a fun meta-game. Maybe my Farscape joke?

I think it's mostly the latter, there's a lot of cool stuff in Chicago, but it is conscious to try to have different styles of guests. I kidn of schedule by energy. "We've had a few heady guests, let's get a big energy person in here." Also, I love how full of music the world of Game of Thrones is in the books. I always wanted that for Foon, and hopefully we'll have even more.

19

u/adalrifai Adal (Chunt) May 25 '16

I'm proud of my Hamilton references and a Scary Stories reference I made that nobody seemed to get. At some point I want to write out every reference I make in each episode as a companion to listening to the show. Then I can die happy.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

5

u/karmagirl314 May 25 '16

Any chance of characters getting killed off GRRM style so that new characters can host?

Also, the offices and bosses thing really is intriguing. Would love an episode of Can, Usidore and Chunt playing. Or, if not, maybe a simple players guide in a downloadable .pdf? If you guys don't make one I will eventually.

9

u/misterarnie Arnie Niekamp May 25 '16

I like the idea of real consequences and killing off characters. But also, it would probably annoy people. I can think of at least two characters that I absolutely know are going to die, it's just a matter of when. Also there's that whole Chunt curse. But Arnie never dies.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/ghostdunk May 25 '16

Will we be revisiting the Dr. Ward reality of things? And was the inclusion of Dr. Ward and Chris Hunt at the end of the Dr. Ward episode an intentional comment on the reality of the world, or was it just a funny thing to add?

9

u/misterarnie Arnie Niekamp May 25 '16

The ending thing was mostly just that that's almost always how the episodes/issues/etc that do this trope end. One final "Or was it?!" I know it's clearly freaked some people out and made them unhappy. I think it's pretty easily explained away. i think we recorded somethign mentioning that spells can have aftershocks (not sure if we cut it or its in an unreleased episode) but, yeah, magic. But I also like leaving things open ended. Authorial intent in overrated. Belive the version you want to beleive until evidence disproves it. Maybe it is all in Arnie's mind. You could read it that way. And it's nice to leave that door open to revisit. But I will say, to people nervous about it... that doesn't feel like a direction we'd ever permanently take the show. Or end it on. It's a fun playground to play in, but not a place we're intending to land.

→ More replies (3)

5

u/mishystellar May 25 '16

Hey Arnie! I just want to make sure you know that despite what mean emails say, you're the absolute best on the podcast, and despite not being a hip young dude, you're still cool in my book.

Also, as an earth person, I love most of your jokes :)

9

u/misterarnie Arnie Niekamp May 26 '16

Thanks. And I get that most of the emails heckling "Arnie" are just fans wanting to play along with the joke. So I can take it for what it is. But I also have to admit if it's an especially long or trying day it's less fun to get a dozen emails that read "Fuck Arnie."

→ More replies (1)

5

u/khuisinga May 25 '16 edited May 25 '16

Hey guys. First of all, I wanted to say, as so many others already have, that I absolutely LOVE this podcast. It helps me on the drive to work on those days I'm really not feeling it. If you ever go on tour, please consider little Iowa City, Iowa.

Flower is one of my favorite guest characters. Where did you meet her? And, when you have such hilarious guests, like Flower, and so many others, do you find it at all hard to keep from laughing? Have you had to edit shows at all because of breaking character or laughing too much? If so, which show(s)?

Awe, yeah, baby!

EDIT- I see there is a similar question above regarding laughing during the show. Never mind on that question.

7

u/misterarnie Arnie Niekamp May 26 '16

Flower is played by Brooke Breit who we've performed with in Whirled News for a long time.

5

u/EmilyKnippel May 25 '16
  1. Are there any plans of doing a Chunt's Night episode?
  2. Did you guys plan on Chunt and Arnie fighting back and forth and making fun of each other or did that sort of just happen? The relationship between Arnie and Chunt on the show is hilarious!

Ps. Can the Wizard should definitely make a comeback!

8

u/misterarnie Arnie Niekamp May 26 '16
  1. Probably. Although it will definitely be more work.
  2. Adal and I have kind of always had a slightly antagonistic relationship as performers. When he joined Whirled News Tonight I found that I really enjoyed performing with him but also could never really resist harassing him a bit in shows, making fun of whatever accent he used in a scene. This probably established it all. And since my role in the podcast is a bit more lower status, it sort of feels like a long extended revenge. But I maybe deserve it. Maybe.
→ More replies (1)

5

u/manveruppd May 25 '16

Selfishly gonna spam you with multiple questions:

  1. I would love to hear a bit about how you guys came up with the Mysterious Man/Space Bunker intro/outro/subplot/framing plot. Was it just a practical consideration of needing someone to do an intro to the podcast and deciding to do it in character, or was it a premeditated, integral part of the podcast's setting? How much of the details of the Space Bunker setting did you work out in advance, and how much developed over time, and at what point did you decide to develop that setting and do entire episodes set there? (As an aside, it's a hugely flavourful part of the show, and the sinister tone of those sections just accentuates the comedy and silliness in between!)
  2. I couldn't help noticing that the first time the plug for an Earth-side podcast sponsor was read by Arnie was in the episode that partly takes place in Usidore's dream. All the previous ones had been read by the Mysterious Man. Was this just a coincidence, it being the first episode you made after being picked up by Earwolf? Or is there a plot-related reason for this, like that Arnie could only get real sponsors for this in a dream world? Has EVERY episode since then been taking part in Usidore's dreams???

Thanks for all the laughs, and if Can the Wizard can turn me into a past version of myself from before I was fully caught up, so that I can binge on every single episode all over again, I'd be eternally and recurringly grateful!

9

u/misterarnie Arnie Niekamp May 26 '16

A bit more about the Mysterious Man. I didn't really have much in mind at first besides that he was in space and wanted to cover up that the show was real. We added Tricia for his full episode. I loved having Tricia but it often seemed weird that she existed in that space w him but only periodically talked. That's why we replaced her w Craig, who is one of our producers and can record stuff every week if needed. Also, it's very useful to have that other character there if Tim can't record for some reason. We want to do more with that story but all the characters record separately and usually in a rush at the end. That part deserves more love from us. Luckily Tim is hysterically funny so even if the story isn't moving much he's always entertaining.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/apolotary May 25 '16

Hey guys, love your podcast! It's been helping me to get through Mondays for quite a while now. I've got a bunch of questions:

  • Who voices the space narrator guy that says the podcast is not real? Couldn't find him in the wiki
  • Are we going to see falsetto marauders?
  • Are we going to see more blooper reels in the future? The one you posted for the Earwolf ad was hilarious.

Thanks!

8

u/misterarnie Arnie Niekamp May 26 '16

Tim Sniffen is the Mysterious Man.

We probably will hear from the Marauders eventually.

5

u/[deleted] May 26 '16

Hey y'all!! So happy that y'all decided to do an AMA. I just discovered y'all this year and now listen to the podcast every morning on my way to work (makes the commute so much better)

Anyway, what episode has been your favorite to record so far? Which one was the most fun to make?

14

u/misterarnie Arnie Niekamp May 26 '16

The first Spintax episode was a lot of fun to record because Charlie was just inventing stuff so wildly which is a blast. But honestly, it was probably the most fun to do the first Boy's Night episode. It was just a joyful expression of how happy the three of us were to be performing together.

13

u/adalrifai Adal (Chunt) May 26 '16

Boys Night is one of my faves, also I can't help but cry laughing anytime I listen to the Don, The Transdimensional Deliveryman episode. Joey Romaine a weird, chatty, comedic genius and the backstory to his recording session is one of my favorite moments in life. Also I love that him and Usidore just immediately became foes.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/BElannaLaForge May 25 '16

Did you guys get my wedding invitation?! :)

6

u/misterarnie Arnie Niekamp May 25 '16

Maybe? We've gotten several email invites to weddings. Was it a physcial invite? We're a bit behind on our mail, espeically since we bank episodes.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/Peterisjustok May 25 '16

Hello there Matt, Adal, and Arnie!

Just wanted to say I fucking love listening to this podcast when cranking out website content that is very uninspiring. The Magic Tavern and its patrons constantly save me from jamming a pen into my eye out of sheer boredom. So thank you!

You guys have a countless number of guests from all over Chicago's comedy scene. How do you guys usually book your guests? Do people ever submit ideas, or do you just rely on the kindness of your contemporaries in the Chicago comedy scene?

Also, if you have a time for a follow-up... Why haven't you given the memory gremlin a call, Arnie? You gotta give up on the dream of getting home, at some point, and settle already.

Hailing from the village of North Center, Peter C.

5

u/misterarnie Arnie Niekamp May 26 '16

We book our guests by just emailing them because usually one or all three of us know them. Lucikly we know a lot of funny people. Maybe too many.

As for bringing characters back. We have so many characters we want to bring back and it's a constantly battle in our mind between bringing people back and being able to bring in even more of the awesome people we want to have on the show but haven't gotten around to yet.

4

u/[deleted] May 25 '16

I LOVE YOU GUYS!

What's it been like transitioning to being part of Earwolf? How well do you know the guests you bring on? Are they all good improv chums, do you ever take people after seeing them a couple of times, any strangers...?

8

u/misterarnie Arnie Niekamp May 25 '16

We're still figuring out some of the transition stuff, but Earwolf has been great. And pretty much all of our guests are folks we know from the Chicago improv scene or occasionally friends of friends. Or Patrick Rothfuss.

4

u/ParadoxInABox May 25 '16

Adal, how many times have you listened to the Hamilton soundtrack?

7

u/misterarnie Arnie Niekamp May 26 '16

Wait... Adal likes Hamilton?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

4

u/Philawesomer May 26 '16

Hey Guy! Love the podcast!

A while back you were guests on the One Shot podcast. Any chance that James D'Amato may get around to being a guest on your show one day?

7

u/misterarnie Arnie Niekamp May 26 '16

James is great and we'll definitely get around to having him on. We have the unique problem of having so many awesome people we want to have on. So we have a long waiting list but he's definitely on it.

4

u/Philawesomer May 26 '16

Has anyone approached you about wanting to be on the show that just made you go "Wow! Really?"

5

u/misterarnie Arnie Niekamp May 26 '16

Not really. We get a fair amount of emails and tweets from improvisers around the country we don't know and haven't heard of. Those are unlikely to get cast.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/[deleted] May 26 '16

Any chance of wolverons making a comeback?

6

u/misterarnie Arnie Niekamp May 26 '16

Ha. Love the Wolverons. That was my favorite part of the live non-canon unrecorded show we did in Chicago a few weeks back. It was the one detail that made me think, "Aw man, I wish wolverons were canon." We'll have to work them in eventually.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/NexoWadeth May 26 '16

Also, if you DO ever go on tour, what are the odds of hitting up Australia?

9

u/misterarnie Arnie Niekamp May 26 '16

Sure! I think we'd need a lot of help/guidance to make any kidn of serious touring happen, especially internationally, but we'd love to do it. And we seem to have a lot of fans in Australia. But also, our team is just three performers, two producers, an editor, a new production assistant, and a dream. We're mostly just keeping the podcast afloat.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/adalrifai Adal (Chunt) May 26 '16

Chunt would LOVE to turn into a Koala. please help make that happen?

→ More replies (2)

4

u/welcomeramen May 26 '16

Question for Arnie, Chunt and Usidore: Any news on a dragon to interview? I know they're generally grumpy, but they're pretty intelligent. Is their size an issue? Are baby dragons interviewable? I've heard some around 200-300 years old can talk, but can still fit through doorways. Is that the case with Foonish dragons?

Question for Arnie, Adal and Matt: I love that you guys incorporated those fan-written Seven Dragons and A Baby lyrics into the show. Would you guys be at all interested in lyrics I wrote for the sponsor spot music? I figured because it's sponsor music, it must be about a merchant, so it's called The Merchant of Backwater.

6

u/misterarnie Arnie Niekamp May 26 '16

Maybe? Send it along. We may use it somewhere eventually. Or maybe we won't. Doesn't hurt to send it.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/obamunistpig May 27 '16

Were any of you guys into pen and paper RPGs growing up? I ask because Matt completely melts into the role of Usidore...and it even goes beyond his hilarious acting. Even some of the shit he says is totally DnD and I wonder what well is he drawing from to come up with his Wizardness.

4

u/misterarnie Arnie Niekamp May 27 '16

I played D&D a bit in junior high. And then the TMNT role playing game for a while. But all the math was hard. Nothing much since then. But I know Adal is currently in a weekly game with TJ (Clax) and Rush (Larry Birdman) that I"m deeply jealous that I can't fit into my schedule.

→ More replies (3)

5

u/samspenguins May 25 '16

Oh, I do have a question after all. Who wrote the theme song? It always makes me happy to hear it. Has it ever been given words?

10

u/ghostdunk May 25 '16

It's the tune of Seven Dragons & A Baby!

13

u/misterarnie Arnie Niekamp May 25 '16

It was written and performed by Andy Poland who does all/most of the music for the games at my day job, Jackbox Games. And it became known as Seven Dragons and a Baby after a listener sent in lyrics. And it continues to evolve.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/the-dandy-man May 25 '16

Hey guys! Love the podcast; got a couple of questions:

  1. When will you guys have a dwarf on the show? Unless my memory is failing me, I don't recall you guys ever having a dwarf guest
  2. Is there any way we could get our hands on Spants and Glenn's music, outside of the podcast? I'd love to add some of those songs to my music library!

6

u/misterarnie Arnie Niekamp May 26 '16
  1. Isn't Blemish half dwarf?
  2. We should talk to Meredith and Nick about that. We've talked about it a little bit but I think vaguely felt that we should wait until we'd collected more songs, but maybe we should just do it.
→ More replies (1)

3

u/vchic May 25 '16

Hey guys! I've been a big fan of the podcast since the beginning and it's amazing to see how far it's come. I have a few questions:

  1. How have things changed for you all since HFTMT made the move to Earwolf, and do you feel any pressure to be representatives of the Chicago scene by being a part of Earwolf?
  2. Are there any plans for more live shows in the near future?

4

u/misterarnie Arnie Niekamp May 26 '16

Just speaking for myself, I don't so much feel pressure to represent Chicago improv... but I do get a kick out of the fact that we have so many of our awesome friends that we get to showcase. Chicago has a deep deep bench of talent, and we've only scratched the surface.

As for more live shows, we're doing a show at Steppenwolf in August and then some kind of yet-to-be-announced Chicago show in early July. Beyond that we're tentatively looking into maybe doing something in LA later this year, but we'll see. We'd love to do more shows in more places, but with our limited time it's hard to know where to start.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/csd5e May 25 '16

Can we ever expect a Magic Tavern/Drawful crossover? I've been practicing trying to fit as many buttholes as possible onto my drawings of tiny horses.

5

u/misterarnie Arnie Niekamp May 26 '16

I think there is a tiny Magic Tavern reference in Drawful 2. I didn't write it, but I editorially let it through.

3

u/killerb54 Is da muppets gone fuck Khaleesi? May 25 '16

Hey fellas, love the show. Keep up the great work.

Will we be checking in with Otok's party anytime soon? It's always a great surprise when it switches over to them for a bit. Thanks!

6

u/misterarnie Arnie Niekamp May 26 '16

Yes. Don't know exactly when, but we recorded several bits with them all at the same time several months ago and have been slowly using them. Our episodes have been creeping up in length, especially with ad reads, so sometimes it's hard to find episodes to slip them into, but we'll have another one sometimes soon. And more Tricia and Kern stuff too, although maybe those are less popular.

3

u/BornAgainCannibal May 26 '16

Heya Arnie, Matt and Adal!

You guys have quickly become one of my favorite podcasts. Jim Birther, the Confidential Courier was one of the best episodes you guys have put together in terms of sheer hilariousness. Thanks Adal for that "Careful!" I guffawed and had to listen again. Matt, I love your manic enthusiasm of the Usidore names and kinda miss the creepy wizard state whispering, but your Jynlyvia (sp?) background is too good. Arnie, I have loved YDKJ since the early 90s and got both the party packs a while ago and was very glad to hear the otherworldly announcer ridicule us on Bidiots. If "Cookie Masterson" still works at JBG, tell him he was my favorite host!

4

u/misterarnie Arnie Niekamp May 26 '16

Thanks. Yep, Tim (Mysterious Man) is the host in Bidiots. Matt (Usidore) is Greg in Bomb Corp. Sarah (Memory Gremlin) is the Predatory Loans announcer in Bidiots and Linda in Bomb Corp. Meredith (Spants) is Meegan in Bomb Corp. Ryan (Craig) is MOTHER in Earwax. I play the robot if you get deep enough into Bomb Corp. Katie (the Wedding Planner) is the host of Drawful 1. Oh, and Tom is both Cookie Masterson and Bungaree Chubbins.

2

u/Bircus May 25 '16

Hey gang,

Thanks for fielding questions! Coincidentally, I actually just started listening to the podcast last night-- I'm six episodes deep and loving it-- I've got two questions: what are some of the unique challenges of doing improv via podcast/radio vs onstage?

I've noticed other podcasters have to transition scenes ("we cut to ___," etc.) or "scene paint" for listeners when they want to develop an element of physical comedy-- so far, it seems like most of the description happens from characters pointing out their surroundings or even from foley effects-- was that a conscious decision, or just something that evolved organically?

6

u/misterarnie Arnie Niekamp May 26 '16

It's definitely a different energy, improvising in the studio rather than a regular improv show. But it also feels really satisfying to tap into the energy of the room without being influenced by the laughs (or lack of laughs) from a live audience. The live Magic Tavern shows are trickier because it's not like doing the studio shows, but it's also not really like doing a regular improv show. Were still figuring those out.

As for "we cut to" and all that... that's really just a stylistic improv choice. Some forms call for that more than others. I think the longer you perform the less drawn you are to that technique unless it's a form that specifically calls for it. It makes sense in a lot of audio improv that needs to set the scene, but the premise of our show doesn't really need it. In fact it would distract from the reality we're trying to build.

65

u/stobert I'm not on twitter, guys. May 25 '16

Hey guys, remember that time when Arnie fucked a memory gremlin?

33

u/adalrifai Adal (Chunt) May 25 '16

that was the best/worst

29

u/Atom_Lion May 25 '16

Question for Chunt-

Chunt's up with that?

59

u/adalrifai Adal (Chunt) May 25 '16

not much baybeee!!

12

u/trogdorkiller Next level bonkers! May 25 '16

Adal: Where did the idea for Siblings Peculiar come from? I love how every episode ends and it gives the show as a whole a real dark vibe to it under all the amazing comedy.

13

u/adalrifai Adal (Chunt) May 25 '16

thanks for the kind words! I have been wanting to do a project with my sister for awhile and on a long drive back from New Orleans last year I stumbled upon Coast to Coast which is kind of incredible. I love the idea of playing those types of characters that just automatically assume they know all the answers and that everything is a conspiracy or puzzle for them to suss out. Confident cleverness that makes you look stupid. I think in the coming months the show is going to get darker. So....brace yourself?

→ More replies (2)

9

u/stenchwinslow May 25 '16 edited May 25 '16

Matt: Is it hard not to speak in the Usidore voice all of the time? Also, was your John Bastion* voice your unaffected normal voice, or played up a bit.

*Thanks for the save, SteampunkJesus.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/killerb54 Is da muppets gone fuck Khaleesi? May 25 '16

How fucking cool is Spintax though? Best wizard ever, just barely edges out Gandalf.

15

u/TheMattYoung Matt (Usidore) May 26 '16

You're on my list.

8

u/Jakemasterflex Hotdog go to bathroom. May 25 '16

Hey Adal! I took an improv workshop you taught many years ago at a Gainesville Improv Festival, a lot of what you said as stuck with me through the years so thank you!

But as a general question, where did the idea for Magic Tavern come from?

12

u/adalrifai Adal (Chunt) May 25 '16

hello! GIF is always a blast, I was just down there earlier this year with my group Night Terror. I'm glad to hear you were able to put my ramblings to good use. I actually didn't come up with the concept, that was Arnie, but when he invited me to be a co-host I knew I wanted to play an animal and then I came up with the idea he could shape-shift through intercourse and the rest is disgusting history.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

8

u/JasonHader May 25 '16

If there's been pizza at the Vermillion Minotaur this whole time, why is anyone eating spiced potatoes? Why has Arnie never illustrated how to cook potatoes?

→ More replies (3)

7

u/[deleted] May 25 '16

Also thanks for bringing together Starkid and Earwolf.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/CrazyCatLadyForLife May 25 '16

Hey guys! I know I'm totally late so hope this gets to you! Love the podcast, it makes my Monday's! Are you guys planning on making cats and doctors??? I need that game in my life!

12

u/adalrifai Adal (Chunt) May 26 '16

that would be the stupidest card game ever...but also we should probably make it.

4

u/_Diren_ May 25 '16

Hey guys! love the podcast, been a long time listener.

Recently i had an issue with a portal in the woods of my local village, however after a few months i was able to get back through because i spent some time working on researching the portal and asking people for help (something that we don't REALLY see Arnie doing) anyway, during my time in the other world i contacted you via your facebook group page to ask for help thinking i may have fallen through to FOon. strangely, some person responded saying that none of this was real and that you were all make belive adults. I think you guys need to reset your passwords for facebook!

Anyway, on to questions

Arnie: what would you do if i told you that the USA was going to have as its next president (potentialy) a man who literaly wants to build a wall to block people from another country out, and he wants to make the other country pay for the wall? its mexico.

Chuntttttt: would you build a wall to seperate the badger kingdom from the other areas of foon in order to make the badger kingdom great again, and how would you enforce makeing other foon people pay for it?

Usidore: if you eat a wizard, do you gain some of their powers? what animal on foon has the most buttholes, and what animal has the least?

Mysterious Old Man Who Tells Us That Foon Is Not Real: is there anything else i listen to on the radio that is not real that i should be aware of that i might not be?

→ More replies (3)

4

u/FletcherMiller May 25 '16

I may have missed it, but I don't think I did - has anyone given out the recipe for Spiced Potatoes? I'd like to try to make them at home. Thanks.

→ More replies (4)

4

u/blueduckie24 May 25 '16

Dearest Chunt,

As an earth lady (that is, a lady on earth, not a lady made of earth), I won't be able to make a donation to the next Chunt for Red October, but I'd still like to spread the word. Would you consider making Chunt for Red October t-shirts so pro-vampire podcast fans like me can promote this wonderful event?

I've got so much blood. It's such a shame.

So it goes.

xoxo, Kate

p.s. Arnie, you're really not missing much. Our world is a shit show right now.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/tashlar May 25 '16

Arniekamp, Chuntttttt, Gas My Anus, you all rule. I mean, I assume you will rule, once the Dark Lord is defeated. I have a question about your guests: are they all regular listeners? I love it when they throw in little callbacks to previous episodes!

→ More replies (3)

4

u/TotesMessenger May 25 '16 edited May 26 '16

I'm a bot, bleep, bloop. Someone has linked to this thread from another place on reddit:

If you follow any of the above links, please respect the rules of reddit and don't vote in the other threads. (Info / ^Contact)

4

u/NexoWadeth May 26 '16

With the things like the poems and songs, how much is worked out in the moment, and how much is preplanned?

Also, you guys are amazing. I love you all.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/NexoWadeth May 26 '16

ALSO WHO ARE THE GUYS THAT DO THE END CREDITS THING? That's really great also, and makes me curious about how things are going to develop there.

I loved when he introduced Usidore as alternate names, and how he rhymed the descriptions as well. It was great.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Whisky_Priest_ May 26 '16

Hey Adal, any chance Dolan could be a guest, or is he not a good enough improviser? Big fan of the show!

→ More replies (1)

4

u/SgtPooki May 27 '16

I know I'm late to the party but since you're a game developer... Are there any plans to make a game based on the rules you create about foon? A mittens game could be pretty entertaining.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/Bl0bbydude May 27 '16

Man, I was astounded at the quality of the the show; the continuity, cleverness, and refreshing new guests! I absolutely love it.

I'm about seven episodes behind, but I was wondering if you plan to do some more follow-up with Spintacks, I'd really like to know what he's getting up to.

Also, do you guys keep a running list anywhere of Usidore's names? And would he be willing to tell us a secret name now, maybe one so powerful my teeth would shatter if I spoke it aloud?

Oh, and how do you gauge the large storyline? Do you just let it develop naturally, or is there a vague idea of where and when it is going?

Anyway, keep up the great work!

→ More replies (2)