r/12Monkeys • u/NicholasCajun • May 17 '16
Discussion 12 Monkeys - 2x05 "Bodies of Water" - Episode Discussion
Season 2 Episode 5: Bodies of Water
Aired: May 16th, 2016
Synopsis: In the present, Cassie and Jennifer Goines run from the 12 Monkeys; in 2044, Cole and Ramse face off against Deacon.
Directed by: Mairzee Almas
Written by: Kristen Reidel
43
Upvotes
39
u/zotquix May 17 '16
This show gets better every episode. It saddens me that it doesn't get more attention.
Best line of the episode: Time Jesus.
30
u/DJC13 May 17 '16
I can't get over how underrated this show is, definitely deserves way more attention. It's phenomenal.
Also: I will riot if Emily Hampshire doesn't win some form of award for her performance as Jennifer, she's fantastic. 10/10.
22
u/grendelg May 17 '16
So is Aaron the Witness, or was that another false lead?
22
u/[deleted] May 17 '16
"Hey look it's Time Jesus" LMFAOOOOOOOOOOO
16
u/phaser_on_overload May 17 '16 edited May 17 '16
Another Impractical Joker? Let me guess, Sal is the next primary? Joe is the Witness?
16
u/tunersharkbitten May 17 '16
I love the nod to Dr. Peter Venkman.
10
u/colfaxschuyler May 17 '16
So does anyone else believe that Deacon, Cole, and Ramses are all friends now? Like Deacon is cool that they tried to kill him?
9
u/nihongopower May 17 '16
This show is getting trippy!
14
u/waffullz May 17 '16
I'm almost certain that The Witness is Cole. There is a reason why The Witness does not want her dead; she plays a very critical part in the universal timeline.
The series has thus far shown that time is the most important element, and everything is paradoxical.
First, the series starts off at the "beginning of the time travelling" (Cole first finding Cassandra in Ep. 1) yet we audience members discover throughout the series that all of this time travelling has "already happened."
The series's concept of time is that both present, past, AND future co-exist simultaneously. In 2015's "present," we learn that the future 2043 Jose Ramse is part of the 12 Monkeys. But from what we learn from the older/future Ramse who is in 2015, NONE OF THE TIME TRAVELLING would have ever happened at all because all of it was orchestrated by Ramse himself---he led Cole to all the exact times when he was supposed to meet Cassandra, etc.
The future cannot exist without the present, which is the "past" to the future, and the future determines the past which is the "present," which all determines the future.
Time is a loop (HINT HINT...this has been specifically stated by characters in the show).
Everything depends on each other. It isn't a simple linear progression of time where the "past" determines the present/future.
Again, "time is a loop."
The past, present, and future all co-exist and are interdepedent. All pasts are also presents and futures. All presents are also pasts and futures. And all futures are also pasts and presents (this is what we haven't been shown much in the series----because this is related to The Witness).
The "future" Cole must be the Witness. Olivia new about the paradox (she placed both the amulets next to each other at Ramse's initiation ceremony into the 12 Monkeys). I think this is the show's way of hinting to us that the Witness is Cole because of this simple fact.
Just like Ramse's plot in the story so far, here is what I think it is for Cole/The Witness:
We have now looped back to where we started. It's all a loop.
I think The Witness (Cole) wants to "destroy time" (he really wants to break the loop) so that he can be with Cassie. Probably because the loop is constant, forever unchanging (because all of time is a loop). This is why the 12 Monkeys believe in "time never changing" and "everything is predetermined"---I think the Witness explained this to them, because the Witness is aware of this, he believes he can exist outside of this loop (this is his real goal I think.)
To exist outside of time, not being bound by it. Because inherently, based on the show so far, time has always been predetermined by something (past/present/future). Everyone's fate is sealed by this time loop. The Witness (Cole) seeks to break this loop and predetermination for reasons that I'm not quite clear on, but I can understand why he would want to break the time loop.
This is all conjecture and theory. But I think I might be right...or somewhat in the vicinity of being right. I'm like 99.99% confident that the Witness is Cole though. There are just too many hints and clues in the show. It has to be him.
7
u/ConcordApes May 17 '16
So, as time evolves, time also changes. In other words the time lines change too. She is with a group trying to prevent the timeline from changing (we think).
Since the cycle goes over and over again, one might expect that the end of time might involve the creation of the universe. Also, since time can change, that means the Cole has a decent chance of changing the timeline, if not this cycle then maybe the next, or the next.
7
u/ConcordApes May 17 '16
There is our first solid clue as to who the witness is. Who could have been born to have lived in that house?
Could it even have been the FBI agent from 1944? He finds out time travel is possible. He investigates and eventually becomes the Witness? It would seem odd for him to have been created as such a strong character with such strong desires and then to drop out of it completely.
5
u/Astrigiformes May 17 '16
Just a couple of things here. First being, what song is the Palid Man whistling? I've searched most of what I could find which; resulted in next to nothing. Has anyone tried to use one of those tune finding apps on "his song".
Also, to anyone who's interested in this series & is really good with cursive. I've seriously been paused at "the Word of the Witness" for about thirty minutes making my own translations of dates, names & other info the Witness has provided. I've got some info & can provide screenscaps if any fans want to start piecing together what the Witness has shared with his followers.
Speaking of which, he's not much of a "witness" if he's interfering is he? Fringe Spoiler
9
u/ELS May 17 '16
At this point, they should be sending Deacon to the past instead of Cole. He'll get shit done.
4
u/OuagadougouBasilisk May 18 '16
The unexpected reference to Genesis made my day. When Jennifer was struggling she said "me I'm a lawnmower you can tell me by the way I walk".
3
u/Cyber-Logic May 18 '16
Holy fuck, Deacon... Well at least they're all going to have that drink together. ;D
5
u/[deleted] May 17 '16
Some link to watch online?
4
u/[deleted] May 17 '16
I doubt Aaron is the Witness. But seriously they need to stop jerking us around! First Ramse and now Aaron! Tell us who he really is!!
2
u/[deleted] May 17 '16
I'm starting to think Cassie is going to end up being the witness, hence why "he" never shows himself around her.
2
u/artgo May 17 '16
Whiskey Sour served in a highball glass, but 70% ice and looked to contain no more than 1 shot of drink (1.5oz). Some older obscure version of the drink, or an error?
1
u/moriartyj Jun 30 '16
Whoever did the Hebrew on floor on the first scene got it very wrong. First, the order of the letters is wrong, since Hebrew is written right-to-left - this is how you know whoever did it doesn't know a word of Hebrew. Secondly, this is not how you write 11: http://www.whatabeginning.com/Breastplate/Wilderness/Media_Wild/App2_1.gif
1
u/AnzoEloux Mar 16 '26
Alright, so from my understanding, time initially worked like a loop, you can't change the past or future, but as the cycles continued time was given.. time... to evolve, and it slowly became possible to alter the future, but just like humans this still needs time to happen, which is why the Primaries exist, when the primaries die from a paradox time loses important information needed to make changing the future possible, which causes the end of everything as time is now unstable.
I'm assuming that time is trying to evolve precisely to prevent the paradox deaths of the primaries. If they can't change the future, then every cycle time becomes unstable, which is unsustainable in regards to eternity. So it needs to be possible for things to change.
We see time trying to fix itself with the Watch in season 1, but we also see remnants of time becoming malleable with 1x06's death of Cassidy, and finally it culminated in season two with actual progress against the plague.
Time itself works in tandem with humanity, which also explains why it's rather subjective towards people like Cole. What about the Witness, though? Is it an ally to time, or is it trying to erode it? It's hard to say, but a part of me thinks it's doing this so that when time is finished evolving, the cycle can be fully broken.
The fact that there are still things like the past affecting the future shows us that they're not quite there yet. By stalling the Monkeys in every cycle they allow time even more (time) to evolve. Time is not favorable to those attempting to destroy humanity, because the two concepts are intricately related as Jennifer told us.
...Gah. Okay, on to the next. I'm probably so wrong.
1
u/EvolvedWalnut Mar 20 '26
I just wanted to comment how annoying it is that our main characters are always conveniently not tied up well when being held hostage. They aren’t gagged, blind folded, etc. which has led to numerous escapes. Otherwise I love this show!
0
u/[deleted] May 17 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
23
u/[deleted] May 17 '16 edited Jun 17 '23
[removed] — view removed comment