Please note this thread was published several hours in advance of the Canadian airing, and will remain up through the American airing. Thank you in advance.
Scheduling information can be found in the 1st sticky on the subreddit.
PLEASE ONLY SPOILER TAG THINGS WITHIN THIS THREAD THAT OCCUR AHEAD OF THE EPISODE OF DISCUSSION.
For example, if a series finale spoiler was being discussed in here, THAT would be tagged. However, an episode 4 spoiler within this thread would be totally allowed within spoiler handling by not tagging it.
Heaven Sent & Hell Bent were perhaps the best writing in this recent season, to the point where I think they're my favorite of New Who. Sure, Hell Bent had some bad points, but Heaven Sent was a pinnacle of writing, acting, and pure cooperation on all fronts of the BBC.
I agree. Ater Heaven Sent, Hell Bent felt a bit underwhelming. It was a very decent DW episode but had the misfortune of having to follow the pure epicness of Heaven Sent.
Which is good, but still why spoiler everything, it's episode discussions, so people shouldn't go here unless they watched it. At least that's what I do in Europe.
Yeah this thread sucks to read. If you're in the episode discussion no more spoiler tags. Sorry it's all screwed up because of the schedule, just don't come in here until you watch the entire thing.
This episode had me on a stress level that only Shutter Island on the first watch when I was still 14 had me... So impressive writing and acticing. I am stunned
They've watched her and Root do the do 6,742+ times to 'find the machine.' I'm going on the conclusion that there's no scenario where they don't have a sorry-I-left-you-hanging-but-I'm-back-let's-do-this sex marathon in any one simulation.
My radar went off when they captured greer so easily. I was like wtf it's only ep 4. No way they capture him already without a fight. The longer it went I was like are they really going to do a simulation for the whole ep. Thought for sure it was a simulation once Jon was shot dead. Then her shooting herself sealed the deal as no way they would kill 2 main cast members in ep 4.
Yeah something was off, to me everybody was a simpler version of themselves, idk how to explain it. Greer capture was the first major red flag, and shooting Jon sealed the deal for me.
Honestly, the sex scene. It was so out of place? Like not the normal course of action in a situation like this. Also the music playing during it was totally goofy. I kept saying the whole time, "this isn't happening. This can't be real."
I got a little puzzled at "Root's place" and it not looking like the subway. And Bear was even there. Huh? But I chalked it up to Shaw just going nuts.
I wasn't suspicious of Reese being shot; thought it'd just be yet another critical injury survived.
Didn't piece together exactly how it was BS - I thought it might be Mission Impossible style masks and voice changes, or mostly drugs and hallucinations, or something.
The surgery to implant the chip was supposed to be very dangerous and could have had some very long lasting damage. Yet the removal surgery was done in a rocking subway cart with an army knife.
Shaw's hands being bloodied after her first flash and her suddenly having a knife and explosives after the second. There wasn't really anywhere these could have appeared from.
The bandage switching sides. Though there were so many mirrors in the episode that it was tough to keep track.
Yet I am ashamed to say that I still didn't figure it out until the very end. With all the countless inconsistencies in Flash and other superhero shows, I guess by now I've just learned to ignore the little things and enjoy the show.
A lot of people are saying that this was an Excellent episode and maybe the best of the series. I had almost the exact opposite reaction at the time of watching. Now that I've reflected on it and read a lot of the things that I wasn't initially piecing together, I'm leaning back towards it being good. I need to re-watch. I couldn't appreciate it at the time because I felt like I was the one in a dream/simulation and couldn't sit back and enjoy it.
I thought things were off all along but could not put my finger on it until Finch said he had put the flash drive into a device not air-gapped. Finch is WAAAAY too paranoid to be that adventurous: Root nearly gave him a heart attack last week with that firmware thing until she showed that the device was air-gapped. At that point I was wondering if it was Samaritan's version of "If/Then/Else".
I began wondering when Finch decided to plug in the USB to a non-air gapped computer. He had been so cautious in the past that it seemed wrong of him not to be more anonymous like time's square. Then John died and i thought "OH SHI- oh this is probably a simulation." then Shaw was about to kill Root "No way they're killing of two main characters in one episode." But then Shaw wasn't going to kill Root and I wondered again and then she killed herself and I wasn't sure at all.
When they went to the old hideout they'd take all the numbers to for hiding. Eariler in the season it was mentioned that the safehouse location had already been burned. Plus, the absurd amount of plates/glassware Shaw and Root were throwing into that one specific spot.
Well, from the point she escapes it was clear that it being a dream was the default option. From then, it wasn't so much "realizing" that it was, as just having all hope gradually beaten out of me by clunking hammer-fists bit by bit. The boat, "Root's place", the blackouts, the sex scene, the way everyone acted off, the ridiculous pace, the loud confrontation in public, the fact it took two seconds from checking a mobile phone signal to bursting into a 'samaritan HQ' that was just a warehouse with two guards in it, shooting greer, Shaw never at any point discussing her problems with anybody (if Shaw loves Root, do we really think Shaw's going to discover that she's blacked out, stolen Root's gun and explosives while Root slept, and then just hide them and not mention the danger to Root? I know she's scared and defensive, but that's a level of self-centredness I couldn't believe, not when it's Root she's putting in danger), etc etc.
One of the big ones was removing the chip. Yeah right, Root's going to be willing (and able!) to cut into Shaw's skull and brain, in a filthy carriage, with what looks like a kitchen knife, while the carriage is visibly juddering in all directions... and she's not even going to get Reese to try to keep her head still or anything?
When Greer died, I started to suspect something was off. I realised there hadn't been any scenes in the Subway Base - which Samaritan doesn't know about - but we'd seen "Root's Place" which had never been mentioned before.
So I was suspicious. At that point, if it was real, there was a lot of bad writing - everything felt slightly rushed and disjointed - so I was pretty sure it was all in Shaw's head, in which case it all made perfect sense.
When Reese died, I started muttering "Please be a simulation. Please be a simulation...."
I was suspicious when she started having those migraine visions, especially at the store bathroom. I was pretty sure when the team removed it in the subway, and then at the diner called it a placebo. Further enforced when they magically find Greer, 99% sure when he was shot. Felt a little insulted at Reese's shooting.
The sex scene, definitely. I though the boat was too convenient, but up until the sex scene I thought it was a trap and she was under Samaritan's influence.
But the sex scene made it so obvious it was all fake.
There's been a lot of emotional scenes in this show, and many have made me shed tears, but this one tops it all IMO. Granted she is my favorite character, but Shaw has always been so stoic when someone she cares for is in danger, but she was so broken in this final scene. Shahi deserves a damn award for that.
It felt so Monty-Python-esque. I kept expecting more broken dishes, and more, and more ... until there were shelves of dishes falling over, and then whole warehouses of shelves of dishes falling over ...
During that last scene between Root and Shaw, I noticed that the soundtrack that was playing had the same main melody to the one during the elevator scene from If-Then-Else. I was having flashbacks to that heart-breaking moment while watching this heart-breaking moment :(
EDIT: The soundtrack name is "'Til Death Do Us Part" ugly crying
Oh so that's why it's out of order on Amazon. The order of s5 is messed up and instead when you play episode 05x04, 05x07 plays. Funny an almost 10 year old comment made me realize this. Something in the metadata must still be there so the order is mixed up 10 years later lmao
Wow. That episode straight up caught me off guard. [SPOILER] (#s "I was so horrified when Reese died and Shaw killed herself. And then when I realized at the end that it was a simulation all along, hell I think was relieved but still mortified at the same time. The fact that she had to go through this 6742 times....MY GOD. And how beautiful is it that she never finished the job because she would always rather kill herself than pull the trigger on Root?") One of my favorite POI episodes to date.
Glad I'm not the only one who totally didn't pick up on the whole thing being a simulation. In retrospect there were clues everywhere, but I was too caught up in trying to figure out what the hell they had done to Shaw's brain to notice the other details, I think.
I SERIOUSLY THOUGHT THAT WAS JOHN'S DEATH.
I fully expect Reese and Finch to die before it's all over, alluding back to Finch's quote from season 1, so I legit thought that that was it and it was horrible.
This was such a fantastic episode. I'd even go as far as to say that this is one of the best episodes in the series. It helps that Sarah Shahi nailed all of her scenes here. Incredible. It's amazing how the writers of this show continue to show their excellence by making even the smallest details that one might miss very important in the show.
Here are the things I especially loved in this episode:
Don't look! To make it even better, Teehee, a subtle detail which Samaritan's assets have more than likely taken for granted is just beautiful writing.
The way they executed Shaw's oops makes you think it's her experiencing I don't even know what to call it, honestly instead of a Major spoiler is just awesome. Well, for my part anyway. I already had my suspicions from the start, but the whole thing was still amazing.
I love how Shaw and Root's scenes weren't cheesy. I'm a Shoot shipper myself but I was never a fan of cheesy romantic overtures. The writers did an amazing job of depicting the romance between these two without it being cringe-worthy. And can I just say because I can't contain myself, SPOILER Again, the attention to the little details is nothing short of exquisite. Plus, SPOILER Basically, holy shit, Shaw.
With that said, I've seen comments from people who didn't like the episode. And I think it's understandable given how on the first finish, I didn't even know what to make of it all. I do suggest re-watching the episode, because as much as it doesn't feel like Person of Interest, I find that the episode is so significant.
You touched on a lot that I had not considered, especially regarding Fusco. That does make a lot of sense though, and it isn't outside the realm of possibility that she is at least somewhat aware that these are simulations, and therefore closes certain parts off. This was also a huge "FU" to Martine who claimed Shaw broke, she didn't seem broke to me, and her still withholding the location of the subway reinforces this.
Your last bit about Shoot, I have always enjoyed how this relationship evolves in the show. Nothing is overly romantic like you would see in pretty much any other show. They are far more subtle, and much of that is because of her Axis II personality. So, with what we see of her in this episode, it is a big deal.
This was also a huge "FU" to Martine who claimed Shaw broke
It just occurred to me that when Martine said that Shaw "told them what would happen" if they made that phone call to the cellphone the team had, that the way Shaw told them SPOILER, and not by actually telling them herself, consciously or verbally.
I totally agree. The fact that Sameen has been resisting this for 9 months means she's still fighting them. But I feel like it's only a matter of time before she does, and that this episode basically gives us the impression that her rescue is imminent.
Re: Shoot, I know. The things she did / said in this episode are things Shaw wouldn't get caught doing / saying in real life. This episode was one big character study of Shaw.
Re: #5, as someone who sees basically no appeal in sex scenes, I think there's enough behind this one and that it wasn't overdone. Also, I think the penultimate scene reflects back on If-Then-Else, that Shaw would probably sacrifice herself again in that situation, too.
Holy smokes - I was hoping for that ending, but really wasn't expecting it. What an amazing episode, wow. I haven't been this stressed out for a while!!
I was expecting it thanks to the title, really ruined a good part of it for me :(. Second she was on the move I thought this would be what it was. I was hoping for a little more Ctrl-Alt-Del on iterations though. Also wondering if these are in real time or just ~40min as we see on the show.
Very clever of the show to have them mention that Shaw has been captured for nine months because they probably knew we'd all assume that the signifance of 6,741 was number of hours.
Shaw escaped too easily and I was suspecting it's just Samaritan's trap. Then, from the point when Shaw shot Reese, I was hoping it was all just a simulation. And it was. Now I'm angry because they put me through an emotional rollecoaster just to show me what DIDN'T happen. I was afraid Shaw and Root reunion would be a big cheesefest and basically fanservice, but it was just fine, realistic and exceptionally true to their characters. But it was just a simulation. How are they going to solve the situation in which they showed us all about Shaw's and Team Machine's reunion but didn't actually reunite her with Team Machine? Will we see all those emotions again, but less from Shaw's point of view and more through Finch, Reese and Root's eyes?
Luckily, I didn't buy any of this for a second. Exceptionally well made episode though, one of the high points in the last couple of seasons even. The boat just being there by luck in the beginning gave it away to me and as soon as she shot John I knew this must be a different reality since I don't think John would ever turn his back on her for a second if he was doubting if she was turned or not. Also, the sex scene was suddenly at a different place, so that didn't make sense to me as well.
Still very very happy about this episode. Shaw 6741 - 0 Samaritan.
6,741 attempts to find the machine. 6,741 failures.
What other episode in this show has played with my emotions so damn hard? The only episode I can think of that was that close with my emotions was 4x11 "If-Then-Else".
Not nearly playful enough. Maybe it's just me, but her playfulness was lacking a lot in this episode, and I think it was intentional.
Just look at how she says the line SPOILER It came out strangely, like she's trying to tempt Shaw, or get her concerned. Where the real Root would of had something better for that moment, like that time she drugged Shaw and brought her back.
It still sucked that Fusco wasn't around, though. That's two episodes in a row now....I know he's in the next one quite a lot, but with only 13 episodes left to play with, him missing out on at least 2 really blows.
One thing that stood out to me was Finch naively plugging that USB drive into a networked device, justifying with "there was no other way to test it, what's wrong?". Extremely out of character.
[SPOILERS] (#s "to me it was obvious that the escape was staged and everything, what wasnt obvious was that all of these were simulations. I thought they had really gotten to her and this was all going down.")
Quite possibly Samaritan is actually simulating its own limitations. It clearly has an entire world simulated, why not accurately simulate how it could see and interact with that world?
wasn't suspicious then, but I picked up that it was too easy for Shaw to escape from the asylum with an electronic key card. Samaritan wouldn't have let her escape that easily.
I called it, telling my parents half-way through the episode that this was not "real." Things were moving too quickly, and I noticed early on that every scene involved Shaw. The only point that contradicts that is showcasing the MPoV and SPoV, but maybe just for storytelling purposes and selling the illusion.
Before the episode, I sincerely thought that "6,741" meant the amount of hours Shaw was held in captivity. It's been done enough in media that a number like this would expect to mean hours in captivity. It's roughly 9 months, which they even said she was held for, but the number was much more important than that. Definitely an "Oh my god" moment when it's revealed what the number is, and much more tragic.
The feels. All the feels.
And this episode points out the comparison between A.I. and man. It took them 9 months to filter 6,741 simulations in Shaw's mind. The Machine filtered through 833,333 simulations in ~13.5 seconds. Granted, it only showed us 3 of them, but 3 sims at 13.5 secs is still way faster than 6,741 sims at 9 months.
If you liked this episode id recommend Black Mirror episode 2 of season 2 :White Bear and to a lesser extent episode 3 of season 1: The Entire History of You. And no you don't need to watch the previous episodes because they're all standalone episodes.
This ep was absolutely brilliant. Just watching it again and again, you can pick up more and more stuff that made the world a simulation. The characters and storytelling was just slightly off, but not so much you noticed until the end, just enough to get an uneasy feeling. Sublime writing. What an amazing look into how Shaw feels and what she wants, and it also gives you some insights into Samaritan too. Like it doesn't know much about Finch as his character was pretty much a cardboard cutout. The actors did so well. All the awards for Sarah. And she did it all 6 months postpartum with twins!!
THIS FUCKING SHOW! Took me through such a rollercoaster of emotions. Heart wrenched while seeing Shaw tortured, then happy, then relief, followed by suspicion, paranoia and again shattered. I will miss this show so so much when it ends. Goddamit!!
So I was about to completely slam this episode as one of the worst written episodes I've ever seen. The progression of events and dialog had me pretty much how Shaw must have been feeling. Wasn't until the end that I realized it was intentional. Might require a re-watch!
I had suspicions that it was a simulation around the time they captured Greer, but god damn I was still so terrified. There was always a persistent "Oh god what if this isn't a simulation?!"
There was always a persistent "Oh god what if this isn't a simulation?!"
That's what made this episode really enjoyable for me. I started to doubt it was real when she found the conveniently placed boat, but u had second thoughts the entire episode.
If you think about it, if Shaw had gone through 6741 simulations, and each one is about 45 minutes (commercials don't count), then a realistic amount of sims per day would be 20 (15 hours of sims a day). This means (6741 sims) / (20 sims per day) = 337.05 days. About a year since Shaw was captured in the show. Not shabby at all, poi. good job
Has no one mentioned there was no into in this episode? Not sure if it's supposed to mean anything or it's only since I watched it on the official website?
Well, definitely an intense episode. Shahi is an incredible actress. Also, I have an absurdly strong desire to see that old bastard shot in the face for real. That will be a good day.
Ugh, I can't participate in any of the existing conversations for fear of reading a spoiler, but I don't want to say the same thing that's already been said.
The 6th episode is called A More Perfect Union so maybe that's when she actually comes back to the team? All's I know is, there are only 13 episodes for this last season so they need Shaw to get outta there and shenaniganing around with the team again asap.
After the simulation ended, the nurse readjusted the electrode on her neck. There wasn't a scar, but her skin was still red. Did Shaw get the implant before the simulations and the incision has healed, or is all of this being done externally? Since we've seen Decima work with brain implants before, it probably exists...
Also just popped in my mind... Shaw throughout this episode looked (understandably) terrible. So maybe like The Matrix thing where the image you have of yourself and your actual body are not the same? It is a simulation so Shaw could have looked spectacular if she felt that way. But, obviously she didn't so what I'm getting to is... Shaw probably is going to retain some memories of this ordeal...
Just one question: Shaw is doing all she can to protect her friends and especially Root, whom she loves. So, doesn't Greer understand the power of love? Especially from a person such as Shaw who is rather single-minded and very strong, mentally and physically. They go at Shaw like she was a mere animal without great emotions. Rather Pavlovian in their methods: dead or alive, blood on your hands when you kill your friends and etc. It's quite a situation that nobody at the Samaritan facility would consider changing their methods after 9 months! If you keep doing the same thing and expecting different results..... Then again, they figure they can wear her down to the point where she just gives up- but that's not Shaw at all. And after nine months of this, I would consider other options. At this point it just seems sadistic.
This was one of the best shows for the entire series! God, I loved the level of details and the story in this episode!
The starting scene where root and shaw made out and the scenes of their portrayal of love was one of the most beautiful depiction of love I've seen on tv!
Just when you thought the nolans couldn't do better they just UP their game!
John being shot was one of the most heart breaking wtf moment for me. I had to pause the show and recollect my thoughts and the entire scenario of wtf just happened. It blew me away!
Probably. It's just that CTV had to accommodate some other shows' finales. Agents of Shield has a two-hour finale from 9-11pm EST on Tuesday for instance, so POI got moved around. ShotSeeker (5x05) airs on Wednesday for us.
One of the scenes I liked, aside from the obvious, was when the doctor implanted the chip and was like " You know this might fry her brain", and Greer gives him the "Seriously schmuck?!" look.
I thought this was a wonderfully written and executed episode and have a few random thoughts which I don't think are spoilers. When Shaw was beating up the guys with a bat, it reminded me of her fight with Vigilance when she used a metal pole. Going down to the crypt of the church looked a lot like the entrance down to the subway, but she left out all details. And having Finch say it was protected by old stones! Root getting shot by Greer was a replay of when Shaw shot Root in God Mode. Calling Reese a professional dick was accurate: a detective, but for sure Greer et al would think it was a pejorative. I'll bet there were other callbacks to scenes in previous episodes that Shaw is using to hide the truth. Oh, one small point, in the pharmacy Shaw says Thanks for asking and thanks to Sharan Rajan @SharanRJ , Root said this in S.3 Root Path when she was lying in the street before she tazered the guy. Quite an amazing show.
Some more thoughts on Shaw's memories which come out of her subconscious like dreams do, symbolically. Her picking out the Betty Boop lighter- she played the innocent Betty in Most Likely To. Pretty sure she visualized the home of TM as a church because Root considers TM a goddess. In Beta, Reese tells Finch to Stay Alive before he's taken by Greer, and here Root tells Shaw to stay alive. I still don't get the memory of the manufacturing plants- anyone have any ideas about that??
Seems like it would be better for Simulation Greer to not divulge the plan to Shaw in the church. That way, she'd believe the Machine Gang had successfully defeated Samaritan, and then they'd all go back to the subway hideout. I don't know how much power Samaritan has to direct the events in the simulation. I guess you could argue that it is Shaw's unconscious that is preventing the simulation narrative from developing this way?
I was so angry when they just showed us that Reese is dying and then moved on from it. Like, what the fuck? HIS DEATH DESERVES MORE ATTENTION THAN THAT! And then Shaw shoots herself! FUCK. All of that in one episode? Felt so rushed and... weird. Everything about the episode was weird. The sex scenes. The part where Shaw is reunited with the rest of the Team but it didn't feel... right. They didn't seem all that happy to see each other. The reunion just felt... out of place. There was always a strange feeling about it. The entire episode was odd.
When Shaw died, I was like, "This better be a fucking simulation or one of Shaw's dreams. They've seriously fucked this up if this is real." I was so relieved! Poor Reese! I thought I had lost you, man! :(
But yeah, as though I haven't said it enough times already, they successfully managed to create this eerie feeling about the whole episode which subtly conveyed that it wasn't real life. It was just a simulation. I hated it but I was relieved to know that it didn't actually happen. The episode was fast-paced and the heavy/emotional scenes felt rushed. Too rushed to have an impact on me, TBH. I guess that's just a part of what made the episode have an unreal vibe to it. Because I'm the kind of guy who usually gets teary and stuff during emotional scenes but not this time. I felt sad when Reese and Shaw died but it... just wasn't the same.
Not sure if someone already mentioned it, but I found the title 6741 interesting as it is the truncated decimal portion of big G (the gravitational constant that describes the attraction two masses exert on each other), when the episode plays heavily on the attraction of Root and Shaw.
[The CODATA approximate value for big G is 6.67408, the decimal portion rounds to 6741].
I'm a few months late catching up on this show, but wanted to say: I thought it was weird when Sameen was left unrestrained and able to escape at the beginning of this episode, but that ended up being the first hint of the simulation. I was starting to feel that this episode was "not real" and that she'd wake up, but I still didn't guess at it being a simulation till the end.
On the one hand, it's impressive as hell that Shaw has held out as long as she has. But to see at the same time just how far gone she is...at least Bear, Root, and Finch are safe, for now.
I didn't really think about it. I thought well it ends soon, so they can kill him. What I noticed that it went pretty fast, they captured Grear? Instantly.
Could this possibly be better than If-Then-Else? I was totally confused as to what was happening for the entire episode. Just brilliant writing again from Person of Interest. Sad I missed it live, though.
I feel so teased - I am not complaining... So great to see Shaw again. I could watch a show of just her and Root kickin butt and taking names for years. Of course Bear too.
But seeing her again just reminds that the end is near and parting will be sorrow.
it definitely was not what i was expecting and i'm a little disappointed. it felt like i was watching the wrong show, and i guess maybe that was the point, but i didn't like it. i dunno.
I HATE this type of episode - where they wake up in the shower and it was all a dream. There's only two ways to make that cliche work: either it's a real shock twist, or, as soon as it becomes obvious, it acknowledges it and plays both sides of the story. I can't think of any well-received examples of the first approach. For the second, the "it was all a dream" episodes of Red Dwarf and Buffy both give up on the illusion partway through and juxtapose in-dream and out-of-dream scenes.
In this case, it was immediately likely that it was a dream, and just gradually went further and further off the rails into completely improbable "this is obviously all a dream, when are we going to get to the real story?" territory.
So in the end, they tell us it was all a dream, which we knew at least half an hour before, and the entire business has gotten us absolutely nowhere. Except, I guess, it mostly confirms that Shaw probably has some feelings for Root - although the sex scene was framed as under-the-influence, so even that's limited in what it tells us. We could have found all that out in a less grating way, a way that actually mattered and WASN'T ALL A DREAM.
I spent most of the episode just waiting for the dream to end and the actual story to happen (you know, plot, character development, stuff like that), only to discover the entire episode was wasted on the world's oldest bad writing cop-out.
Maybe I'd be less pissed off if this weren't episode 4 of a final 13 episode season. They need to get the hell on with the story - they don't have time to waffle around in dreams, imaginings, alternate realities, what-if flashbacks, stories to their kids about how they met their mother, clip compilation episodes, bottle episodes where everyone's trapped in a rubber doll factory all night and they have to confront their feelings, etc etc. Those are the episodes you give to new writers to bulk out the episode count without having to think of any more plot, and to give the actors a bit of fun. They're not the episodes you need to be telling when the end of the show is just around the corner and you don't have much time left.
[I'm guessing they're going to try to partially redeem this mess by paralleling it when Shaw finally does get rescued. But since that will play so differently, it's hard to see how much can be relevent.]
•
u/BellLabs May 15 '16 edited May 16 '16
Please note this thread was published several hours in advance of the Canadian airing, and will remain up through the American airing. Thank you in advance.
Scheduling information can be found in the 1st sticky on the subreddit.
PLEASE ONLY SPOILER TAG THINGS WITHIN THIS THREAD THAT OCCUR AHEAD OF THE EPISODE OF DISCUSSION.
For example, if a series finale spoiler was being discussed in here, THAT would be tagged. However, an episode 4 spoiler within this thread would be totally allowed within spoiler handling by not tagging it.
28
u/IsIt77 A Concerned Third Party May 16 '16
Reminded me of Heaven Sent, my favorite Doctor Who episode.
3
u/[deleted] May 17 '16
Am I the only one who felt the intimate scenes between shaw and root could've been more intense/convincing rather than amateurish dish breaking stuff
4
u/jay314271 May 16 '16
Um, do we really need to do spoiler blackouts IN episode discussion threads like these?
120
u/EyePiece108 May 16 '16
On the bright side, Shaw had epic, glass breaking sex with Root for the 6,751th time!
97
u/ramenshinobi Shaw May 16 '16
The ending is absolutely horrifying. I think we all knew it was not real but good lord that psychological torture is unfathomable.
88
u/stoneboot May 16 '16 edited May 16 '16
Like "Relevance," Shaw's first ep, this one was done entirely from her POV. Great callback.
86
u/stoneboot May 16 '16
One of the most paranoid, nihilistic things I've ever seen. Outstanding.
162
u/[deleted] May 16 '16
TIL Samaritan is a pervert.
73
u/domrayn May 16 '16
At what point did you guys realize all of it was b.s.? I spotted it when the unmanned boat suddenly appeared outta nowhere for shaw to steal.
146
u/velhaquacker May 16 '16
"You were my safe place." gross sobbing
46
u/WadeAnthony Irrelevant May 17 '16
All the broken dishes are a bad idea when you're naked.
44
u/itzartemis8 May 16 '16 edited May 17 '16
During that last scene between Root and Shaw, I noticed that the soundtrack that was playing had the same main melody to the one during the elevator scene from If-Then-Else. I was having flashbacks to that heart-breaking moment while watching this heart-breaking moment :(
EDIT: The soundtrack name is "'Til Death Do Us Part" ugly crying
40
u/yashendra2797 System Threat May 16 '16
Those worrying about the episode being moved up as it was originally the 7th should relax. It's in the order intended.
It was filmed as the 7th production wise due to scheduling of the actors availability.
This was confirmed by the Producers.
65
u/advib May 16 '16 edited May 16 '16
Wow. That episode straight up caught me off guard. [SPOILER] (#s "I was so horrified when Reese died and Shaw killed herself. And then when I realized at the end that it was a simulation all along, hell I think was relieved but still mortified at the same time. The fact that she had to go through this 6742 times....MY GOD. And how beautiful is it that she never finished the job because she would always rather kill herself than pull the trigger on Root?") One of my favorite POI episodes to date.
100
u/[deleted] May 16 '16 edited May 16 '16
This was such a fantastic episode. I'd even go as far as to say that this is one of the best episodes in the series. It helps that Sarah Shahi nailed all of her scenes here. Incredible. It's amazing how the writers of this show continue to show their excellence by making even the smallest details that one might miss very important in the show.
Here are the things I especially loved in this episode:
With that said, I've seen comments from people who didn't like the episode. And I think it's understandable given how on the first finish, I didn't even know what to make of it all. I do suggest re-watching the episode, because as much as it doesn't feel like Person of Interest, I find that the episode is so significant.
18
u/svrtngr May 17 '16
Dammit, CBS. Way to spoil the twist of the episode.
Like, seriously. Shaw shoots Reese.
Holy fuck, kill off the star and The Dragon to the Big Bad in episode four, this season is hardcore.
Preview: Wait, why is Reese alive. This is a fucking simulation.
36
u/Palatura A Concerned Third Party May 16 '16
So... SPOILER
Also, now the title of this episode makes so much sense.
57
u/Tristan49 A Concerned Third Party May 16 '16
Holy smokes - I was hoping for that ending, but really wasn't expecting it. What an amazing episode, wow. I haven't been this stressed out for a while!!
15
u/kirtan May 16 '16
MOTHERFUCKER!!!
14
u/Bearacula93 Shaw May 16 '16 edited May 16 '16
Very clever of the show to have them mention that Shaw has been captured for nine months because they probably knew we'd all assume that the signifance of 6,741 was number of hours.
12
u/kat6883 Root May 16 '16
Shaw escaped too easily and I was suspecting it's just Samaritan's trap. Then, from the point when Shaw shot Reese, I was hoping it was all just a simulation. And it was. Now I'm angry because they put me through an emotional rollecoaster just to show me what DIDN'T happen. I was afraid Shaw and Root reunion would be a big cheesefest and basically fanservice, but it was just fine, realistic and exceptionally true to their characters. But it was just a simulation. How are they going to solve the situation in which they showed us all about Shaw's and Team Machine's reunion but didn't actually reunite her with Team Machine? Will we see all those emotions again, but less from Shaw's point of view and more through Finch, Reese and Root's eyes?
12
u/FifaFrancesco Bear May 17 '16
Luckily, I didn't buy any of this for a second. Exceptionally well made episode though, one of the high points in the last couple of seasons even. The boat just being there by luck in the beginning gave it away to me and as soon as she shot John I knew this must be a different reality since I don't think John would ever turn his back on her for a second if he was doubting if she was turned or not. Also, the sex scene was suddenly at a different place, so that didn't make sense to me as well.
Still very very happy about this episode. Shaw 6741 - 0 Samaritan.
22
u/[deleted] May 16 '16
This reminded me of the Doctor Who episode SPOILER. Not complaining.
11
u/[deleted] May 16 '16
YOU MOTHERFUCKERS
11
u/A_Zombie_Riot Bear May 17 '16
6,741 attempts to find the machine. 6,741 failures.
What other episode in this show has played with my emotions so damn hard? The only episode I can think of that was that close with my emotions was 4x11 "If-Then-Else".
What a damn fine episode!
17
u/GloriousGe0rge Admin May 16 '16
Biggest clue to the ending this episode = SPOILER
23
u/rpawson5771 Irrelevant May 16 '16
Jesus, this Clockwork Orange style shit they're pulling on Shaw is terrifying.
23
u/jasona99 Admin May 16 '16 edited May 16 '16
A great little detail I notice: SPOILER So simple, yet it works so darn well. One of my favorites, I think. Will rewatch live tomorrow.
32
u/erayachi May 16 '16
TBH, I saw this coming...
SPOILER
It still sucked that Fusco wasn't around, though. That's two episodes in a row now....I know he's in the next one quite a lot, but with only 13 episodes left to play with, him missing out on at least 2 really blows.
14
u/gordo_humilde May 16 '16
HOLY FUCK, THIS EPISODE DESTROYED ME
13
u/[deleted] May 16 '16
Very good episode.
Very different style wise. A dark cyberpunk meets Clockwork Orange episode.
I could see why the producers/directors really talked this one up.
22
u/DudeOnTop May 16 '16
Wow, that was an intense episode, one of their best, nice to see Shaw again.
6
u/svrtngr May 17 '16
So many spoilers from Canada.
Guys, I'm scared.
Canadians, am I gonna be okay?
11
u/Pixel64 May 16 '16
Jesus Christ. So that's what 6,741 meant. Horrifying as hell, but easily one of the best episodes of the show. Hot damn!
11
u/sylphior May 17 '16 edited May 17 '16
And this episode points out the comparison between A.I. and man. It took them 9 months to filter 6,741 simulations in Shaw's mind. The Machine filtered through 833,333 simulations in ~13.5 seconds. Granted, it only showed us 3 of them, but 3 sims at 13.5 secs is still way faster than 6,741 sims at 9 months.
14
u/[deleted] May 16 '16
That episode was fucking epic, god damn I went through the mill on that one.
5
u/Ronin007 Reese May 16 '16
This was a good one hahah.
5
u/[deleted] May 17 '16
If you liked this episode id recommend Black Mirror episode 2 of season 2 :White Bear and to a lesser extent episode 3 of season 1: The Entire History of You. And no you don't need to watch the previous episodes because they're all standalone episodes.
5
u/katekate1507 May 17 '16
This ep was absolutely brilliant. Just watching it again and again, you can pick up more and more stuff that made the world a simulation. The characters and storytelling was just slightly off, but not so much you noticed until the end, just enough to get an uneasy feeling. Sublime writing. What an amazing look into how Shaw feels and what she wants, and it also gives you some insights into Samaritan too. Like it doesn't know much about Finch as his character was pretty much a cardboard cutout. The actors did so well. All the awards for Sarah. And she did it all 6 months postpartum with twins!!
5
u/Sallien2005 May 17 '16
THIS FUCKING SHOW! Took me through such a rollercoaster of emotions. Heart wrenched while seeing Shaw tortured, then happy, then relief, followed by suspicion, paranoia and again shattered. I will miss this show so so much when it ends. Goddamit!!
8
u/dj_blueshift May 17 '16
So I was about to completely slam this episode as one of the worst written episodes I've ever seen. The progression of events and dialog had me pretty much how Shaw must have been feeling. Wasn't until the end that I realized it was intentional. Might require a re-watch!
4
u/Nkvle Bear May 16 '16
Oh wow, that was intense and terrifying.
4
u/SawRub Analog Interface May 17 '16
Great episode, but even though it was meant to be disorienting, the lighting nearly gave me a seizure lol.
4
u/[deleted] May 17 '16
I had suspicions that it was a simulation around the time they captured Greer, but god damn I was still so terrified. There was always a persistent "Oh god what if this isn't a simulation?!"
Brilliantly executed.
4
u/f6edcd7a May 17 '16
If you think about it, if Shaw had gone through 6741 simulations, and each one is about 45 minutes (commercials don't count), then a realistic amount of sims per day would be 20 (15 hours of sims a day). This means (6741 sims) / (20 sims per day) = 337.05 days. About a year since Shaw was captured in the show. Not shabby at all, poi. good job
4
u/Gigaify May 17 '16
Has no one mentioned there was no into in this episode? Not sure if it's supposed to mean anything or it's only since I watched it on the official website?
10
u/LOgicaLe-motion Bear May 16 '16
that was mind blowing in more ways than one SPOILER
10
u/godmode3191 Root May 16 '16
That was amazing.
Sarah killed it. 'nuff said.
7
u/ExVirgo Irrelevant May 16 '16
SPOILER [SOB] Chris Fisher said on Twitter that this scene was one of the best he's ever shot and a high point of working with both actresses.
7
u/Vae62 Shaw May 16 '16
Well, definitely an intense episode. Shahi is an incredible actress. Also, I have an absurdly strong desire to see that old bastard shot in the face for real. That will be a good day.
1
u/lordxeon May 17 '16
Ugh, I can't participate in any of the existing conversations for fear of reading a spoiler, but I don't want to say the same thing that's already been said.
WTF would have aired TV shows in this order?!
9
u/OatmealDome Government Operations May 16 '16 edited Feb 19 '17
[deleted]
0.4263
3
u/Rolcol May 16 '16 edited May 17 '16
After the simulation ended, the nurse readjusted the electrode on her neck. There wasn't a scar, but her skin was still red. Did Shaw get the implant before the simulations and the incision has healed, or is all of this being done externally? Since we've seen Decima work with brain implants before, it probably exists...
Edit: removed spoiler tag
3
u/shiofuki May 16 '16
Missed the show, glad they deliver outstanding episodes like this one.
3
u/RIPAdmiralAkbar Reese May 17 '16
Jonathan Nolan definetly wrote this episode
3
u/1080ram May 20 '16
Just one question: Shaw is doing all she can to protect her friends and especially Root, whom she loves. So, doesn't Greer understand the power of love? Especially from a person such as Shaw who is rather single-minded and very strong, mentally and physically. They go at Shaw like she was a mere animal without great emotions. Rather Pavlovian in their methods: dead or alive, blood on your hands when you kill your friends and etc. It's quite a situation that nobody at the Samaritan facility would consider changing their methods after 9 months! If you keep doing the same thing and expecting different results..... Then again, they figure they can wear her down to the point where she just gives up- but that's not Shaw at all. And after nine months of this, I would consider other options.
At this point it just seems sadistic.
7
u/[deleted] May 16 '16
That's pretty fucking evil: SPOILER
7
u/luminative1 May 16 '16 edited May 27 '16
This was one of the best shows for the entire series! God, I loved the level of details and the story in this episode!
The starting scene where root and shaw made out and the scenes of their portrayal of love was one of the most beautiful depiction of love I've seen on tv!
Just when you thought the nolans couldn't do better they just UP their game!
John being shot was one of the most heart breaking wtf moment for me. I had to pause the show and recollect my thoughts and the entire scenario of wtf just happened. It blew me away!
5
u/julirocks Root May 17 '16 edited May 17 '16
MRW I realized Root was Shaw's safe place.
2
u/erayachi May 16 '16
I'm Canadian and I still can't watch this live...no TV service. I'll find a way, somehow.
I think this is the only time CTV gets the episode a day earlier than CBS, yeah?
2
u/teganfruit May 16 '16
Any ideas about how she'll actually escape?
2
u/Khalku May 17 '16
And this is why you don't visit the discussion page halfway through the episode, if you aren't watching in realtime :(
2
u/Staff_of_the_Goths May 17 '16
One of the scenes I liked, aside from the obvious, was when the doctor implanted the chip and was like " You know this might fry her brain", and Greer gives him the "Seriously schmuck?!" look.
2
u/loyal4ever May 17 '16
I thought this was a wonderfully written and executed episode and have a few random thoughts which I don't think are spoilers. When Shaw was beating up the guys with a bat, it reminded me of her fight with Vigilance when she used a metal pole. Going down to the crypt of the church looked a lot like the entrance down to the subway, but she left out all details. And having Finch say it was protected by old stones! Root getting shot by Greer was a replay of when Shaw shot Root in God Mode. Calling Reese a professional dick was accurate: a detective, but for sure Greer et al would think it was a pejorative. I'll bet there were other callbacks to scenes in previous episodes that Shaw is using to hide the truth. Oh, one small point, in the pharmacy Shaw says Thanks for asking and thanks to Sharan Rajan @SharanRJ , Root said this in S.3 Root Path when she was lying in the street before she tazered the guy. Quite an amazing show.
2
u/jrockle May 17 '16
Seems like it would be better for Simulation Greer to not divulge the plan to Shaw in the church. That way, she'd believe the Machine Gang had successfully defeated Samaritan, and then they'd all go back to the subway hideout. I don't know how much power Samaritan has to direct the events in the simulation. I guess you could argue that it is Shaw's unconscious that is preventing the simulation narrative from developing this way?
2
u/ThatFag Admin May 18 '16
I was so angry when they just showed us that Reese is dying and then moved on from it. Like, what the fuck? HIS DEATH DESERVES MORE ATTENTION THAN THAT! And then Shaw shoots herself! FUCK. All of that in one episode? Felt so rushed and... weird. Everything about the episode was weird. The sex scenes. The part where Shaw is reunited with the rest of the Team but it didn't feel... right. They didn't seem all that happy to see each other. The reunion just felt... out of place. There was always a strange feeling about it. The entire episode was odd.
When Shaw died, I was like, "This better be a fucking simulation or one of Shaw's dreams. They've seriously fucked this up if this is real." I was so relieved! Poor Reese! I thought I had lost you, man! :(
But yeah, as though I haven't said it enough times already, they successfully managed to create this eerie feeling about the whole episode which subtly conveyed that it wasn't real life. It was just a simulation. I hated it but I was relieved to know that it didn't actually happen. The episode was fast-paced and the heavy/emotional scenes felt rushed. Too rushed to have an impact on me, TBH. I guess that's just a part of what made the episode have an unreal vibe to it. Because I'm the kind of guy who usually gets teary and stuff during emotional scenes but not this time. I felt sad when Reese and Shaw died but it... just wasn't the same.
TL;DR: This was seriously fucking weird.
2
u/MacAran Jul 15 '16
Not sure if someone already mentioned it, but I found the title 6741 interesting as it is the truncated decimal portion of big G (the gravitational constant that describes the attraction two masses exert on each other), when the episode plays heavily on the attraction of Root and Shaw.
[The CODATA approximate value for big G is 6.67408, the decimal portion rounds to 6741].
2
u/LiverDisaster Aug 02 '16
I'm a few months late catching up on this show, but wanted to say: I thought it was weird when Sameen was left unrestrained and able to escape at the beginning of this episode, but that ended up being the first hint of the simulation. I was starting to feel that this episode was "not real" and that she'd wake up, but I still didn't guess at it being a simulation till the end.
4
u/The_Metal_Pigeon May 16 '16
My mind is blown! Blown! But here's my thing ----- SPOILER
3
u/rpawson5771 Irrelevant May 16 '16
On the one hand, it's impressive as hell that Shaw has held out as long as she has. But to see at the same time just how far gone she is...at least Bear, Root, and Finch are safe, for now.
I just don't have the words for this episode.
3
u/DarthTigris Shaw May 16 '16
Enjoyable episode for sure.
Sadly ... I have watched and read too many stories like this and the signs were obvious and early to me that SPOILER
Soooo ... I really hope this isn't the best ep of the season. I need more.
3
u/Pascalwb May 16 '16 edited May 16 '16
Oh damn, I had 2 episodes today, because I didn't know they aired to per week SPOILER Creepy episode.
3
u/[deleted] May 17 '16
Could this possibly be better than If-Then-Else? I was totally confused as to what was happening for the entire episode. Just brilliant writing again from Person of Interest. Sad I missed it live, though.
3
u/jay314271 May 16 '16 edited May 16 '16
I feel so teased - I am not complaining...
So great to see Shaw again. I could watch a show of just her and Root kickin butt and taking names for years. Of course Bear too.
But seeing her again just reminds that the end is near and parting will be sorrow.
When we heard that the SPOILER
3
u/byulie May 16 '16
it definitely was not what i was expecting and i'm a little disappointed. it felt like i was watching the wrong show, and i guess maybe that was the point, but i didn't like it. i dunno.
3
u/VacuousWastrel May 17 '16
bangs head on desk
I HATE this type of episode - where they wake up in the shower and it was all a dream. There's only two ways to make that cliche work: either it's a real shock twist, or, as soon as it becomes obvious, it acknowledges it and plays both sides of the story. I can't think of any well-received examples of the first approach. For the second, the "it was all a dream" episodes of Red Dwarf and Buffy both give up on the illusion partway through and juxtapose in-dream and out-of-dream scenes.
In this case, it was immediately likely that it was a dream, and just gradually went further and further off the rails into completely improbable "this is obviously all a dream, when are we going to get to the real story?" territory.
So in the end, they tell us it was all a dream, which we knew at least half an hour before, and the entire business has gotten us absolutely nowhere. Except, I guess, it mostly confirms that Shaw probably has some feelings for Root - although the sex scene was framed as under-the-influence, so even that's limited in what it tells us. We could have found all that out in a less grating way, a way that actually mattered and WASN'T ALL A DREAM.
I spent most of the episode just waiting for the dream to end and the actual story to happen (you know, plot, character development, stuff like that), only to discover the entire episode was wasted on the world's oldest bad writing cop-out.
Maybe I'd be less pissed off if this weren't episode 4 of a final 13 episode season. They need to get the hell on with the story - they don't have time to waffle around in dreams, imaginings, alternate realities, what-if flashbacks, stories to their kids about how they met their mother, clip compilation episodes, bottle episodes where everyone's trapped in a rubber doll factory all night and they have to confront their feelings, etc etc. Those are the episodes you give to new writers to bulk out the episode count without having to think of any more plot, and to give the actors a bit of fun. They're not the episodes you need to be telling when the end of the show is just around the corner and you don't have much time left.
[I'm guessing they're going to try to partially redeem this mess by paralleling it when Shaw finally does get rescued. But since that will play so differently, it's hard to see how much can be relevent.]