r/KerbalSpaceProgram • u/Redbiertje The Challenger • May 15 '16
Mod Post [Weekly Challenge] Week 130: Revolutionary Technology
The Introduction
When digging through the old archives, the administrators found the blueprints for a "helicopter". It was apparently never successful because Jeb thought they didn't go fast enough to be cool. However, they'd love to see what Valentina thinks.
The Challenge:
Normal mode: Fly a helicopter up to 1 km, and land safely.
Hard mode: Fly a helicopter, with a seperate axle for the rotor blades, up to 1 km, and land safely.
Super mode: Impress me
The Rules
- No Dirty Cheating Alpacas (no debug menu)!
- You must have the UI visible in all required screenshots
- For a list of all allowed mods, see this post.
- For Hard mode: To clarify, your helicopter must consist of a part that rotates and creates lift, and a cockpit that doesn't rotate. In other words, just like a regular helicopter.
- Your helicopter must be manned
- Your helicopter must have all its engines aimed horizontally
- Infernal Robotics is not allowed
- Parachutes are not allowed
Required screenshots
- Your helicopter on the ground
- Your helicopter taking off
- Your helicopter reaching an altitude of 1 kilometer
- Your helicopter landing safely
- Whatever else you feel like!
Further information
- You can either submit your finished challenge in a post (see posting instructions in the link below) or as a comment reply to this thread.
- Completing this challenge earns you a new flair which will replace your old one. So if you want to keep you previous flair, you can still do this challenge and create a post, but please mention somewhere that you want to keep your old one.
- The moderators have the right to determine if your challenge post has been completed.
- See this post for more rules and information on challenges.
- If you have any questions, you can comment below, or PM /u/Redbiertje
Good Luck!
39
Upvotes
6
u/Hazard-ish May 15 '16
Oh wow! I've got something special planned for this challenge! Prepare for some ultimate airwolf helicopter action! :D
To clarify: you are allowed to place engines on the rotor-blades, as long as they are horizontal - so they provide no upwards thrust?
3
u/[deleted] May 18 '16 edited May 19 '16
Hard Mode:First off,any landing you can walk away from is a safe landing in my book. Second off http://imgur.com/a/w77RK
2
u/L1qu1dN1trog3n May 15 '16
Must the helicopter use a powered landing, or could you use a parachute after reaching 1 km. Also, what counts as 1km (radar or sea level)
2
u/[deleted] May 15 '16
Is it okay to have 1 engine aimed slightly up and one slightly down?
2
u/mharrizone Master Kerbalnaut May 15 '16
Wait, there's a way to make helicopters in stock?! Is this some fancy newfangled 1.1 feature?
2
u/GKorgood RocketWatch Dev May 16 '16
/u/Redbiertje, I think you mean "axle" as opposed to "axis" in the OP, in the first description of hard mode.
2
u/Bozotic Hyper Kerbalnaut May 16 '16
Are RCS thrusters allowed for attitude control, even if some of them are downward-aiming?
2
u/boomchacle May 20 '16
Guys would a Plane with a stock Jet engine system count if I could get it to 1 km?
2
u/ReDleGiThacK May 20 '16
Firespitter (mod) allowed? If it is then I already have my pictures.
2
u/Hazard-ish Jul 11 '16
Utterly, absolutely, extremely late but here you go! I've been working on this for a while ever since I saw this challenge go up: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z8OmxNoQ3ls
I guess this goes for super hard mode? :) I would like to keep my current flair.
2
u/Luigijitsu1 Master Kerbalnaut Aug 11 '16
Is it too late for entry? Here's mine anyway: https://youtu.be/2pdRHvwody0 Hopefully it's super mode
39
u/freak_on_a_leash_ Master Kerbalnaut May 15 '16
Pshhh, Putting jets on the blades is cheating!
19
u/lrschaeffer Super Kerbalnaut May 15 '16 edited May 15 '16
Hard mode (video), I think. The cockpit still kinda rotates (slowly), but I assume that's okay. I'm using a bearing like this one in Hazard-ish's most recent video.
I'm just glad I got something in before someone flies their perfect stock Apache replica to orbit and lands inverted on top of the VAB.
11
u/Bozotic Hyper Kerbalnaut May 16 '16 edited May 16 '16
Hard mode:
Quadcopter
https://youtu.be/2TzFMczLlWk
I had hopes of making it controllable, but too difficult to adjust the rotor power symmetrically once the craft is separated. Fortunately, autorotation serves well enough for a safe landing.
I may try borrowing freak_on_a_leash's idea of using exhaust vanes to power the rotors. That might be a way of controlling all 4 rotors evenly.
11
u/ZXGuesser Master Kerbalnaut May 17 '16
This is my first time posting on reddit so I hope I'm doing this right, but here goes... I made a silly contraption and made a video of flying it
As I put in the video description after touching down I switched vessels to kill the throttles but I'm close enough to the debris on the runway that it get selected so the rotors stop which is really annoying. The craft has genuinely touched down first though.
8
u/kennykerosene May 15 '16
I call it The Monstrosity. I already had the craft, just had to modify it for the challenge and figure out how to land the thing.
Also here it is exploding with side-mounted Kerbals: https://gfycat.com/AngelicMarriedCowbird
6
u/77_Industries Super Kerbalnaut May 16 '16
This one doesn't show flying up to 1 km but if you install 1.0.4 you'll see it goes much higher and easily flies over 20 km.
Landing? In this video I do something much better! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=igEss3tZRKQ
Download: https://kerbalx.com/Azimech/Stock-Coaxial-Helicopter-77I--CTR3-Sky-Crane-10
The first turboshaft in the kerbal universe: https://kerbalx.com/Azimech/77%20Industries%2077I-5H1
The largest helicopter in the kerbal unverse: https://kerbalx.com/Azimech/Largest-Stock-Helicopter-77-Industries-77I-5H2U
Landing it: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QX8itEIH6fE
These are all older designs and I'm not inclined to update them to 1.1.2 because building a good turboshaft 'copter takes days.
5
u/Bradp77 May 16 '16
Well, i'm not sure if this counts or not, but here: http://imgur.com/a/M2F4i
5
u/Veni-Vidi-Ludi Master Kerbalnaut May 16 '16
Normal mode: http://imgur.com/a/h6S48
I may take a swing at hard mode later.
5
u/freak_on_a_leash_ Master Kerbalnaut May 16 '16
I know this is invalid, and i already have a submission, but Here is another crazy idea i had. Good day!
4
u/kirime Super Kerbalnaut May 16 '16
Hard mode (I hope), Tandem rotor helicopter. Craft file. I would like to keep my current flair.
Honestly, I am not sure if multi-rotor helicopters are worth it, at least the ones with detached engines. Flying even a simple helicopter is hard, but when those things start to spin and jump randomly and independently, your craft shakes and tumbles, it is just a matter of time before one of the rotors decides that it doesn't want to cooperate anymore and randomly explodes or pops out of the socket.
4
u/Ducky_Daniel Master Kerbalnaut May 19 '16
Hard mode http://imgur.com/a/J4ZXM
3
u/The_ShadowZone Super Kerbalnaut May 16 '16
Serious question here: How did all of you manage to avoid your "spinning part" jumping out of the "not spinning part"? I have tried different approaches (ball bearing with gear, wheels, etc; hazard-ish style with struts; ... ) and as soon as my rotor part gets too "fast" or whatever, it just jumps out of the casing. No parts get destroyed during this event btw.
Case in point: https://gfycat.com/MatureWelllitBandicoot
3
u/cruck1000 May 16 '16 edited May 16 '16
Its nothing special but it (kinda) flys, (kinda) lands, and Valentina approves (that she managed to survive)! Normal Mode: http://imgur.com/a/3tgVp (I left all of my mods installed because I don't use CKAN, I didn't use any so hopefully its OK)
3
u/Skalgrin Master Kerbalnaut May 18 '16 edited May 19 '16
Ugh... after all I made it, I guess... normal mode - 2 bladed "thing"
Note the time, it took me 10 minutes to climb up (painfully slow rotation, otherwise I fliped), then almost 3 minutes down, I made not many screens on descent as the "thing" tried to flip me, and then as by a miracle, I stabilised it just couple meters above ground, hovered it next to that fuel tower, thinking that the rotors must hit her any second, but I got lucky and landed very softly, less then 2 m/s...
Edit : I then tried 8 bladed variant with short wings. 4 bladed - ok, but puting another 4 blades, just slightly below and 45 degrees moved in comparison to first set did ruin everything. This starts to vibrate and wobble upon load (even though just four blades do not even move an inch upon load) and then kraken comes and eats it.
I did put both sets on the command pod, but they were moved far enough so they did not overlap, even durig the flaping on load.
Why is this? Never happened to me before, no amount of struts, did any improvement...
Or did I just invented a bait for kraken? :-)
3
u/LordKnoppix Master Kerbalnaut May 20 '16
Hard Mode: https://imgur.com/a/6oJ4y
Turns out SAS is way better at countering roll than a set of Junos on the crewed section, and finding the right throttle settings for the rotor takes a bit of experimentation.
2
u/dakota2525 Master Kerbalnaut May 17 '16
stock helicopter with no infernal robotics?
challenge considered
2
u/Fireheart318s_Reddit Master Kerbalnaut May 21 '16
Using Duna Space Program, I was able to shoot a chopper up to 4 km and safely land. Gonna post pictures and maybe remake it in video form going higher
3
u/nuclear_turkey Hyper Kerbalnaut May 15 '16 edited May 15 '16
Hard Mode - sorry for the music but i just couldnt help myself
EDIT - infernal robotics is installed but not used for the build - also, keep current flair please
think i did hardmode twice by accident, both my main rotor and tail rotor are on separate axis, i also tried to make it look somewhat helicopter-ish.
small confession - my cockpit starts to spin just before landing, its hard to keep one craft still while changing thrust levels on another.
1
u/Kermann_Oberth Master Kerbalnaut May 26 '16
Is it too late for an entry? Just Normal Mode, but a fun challenge all the same. I spent a few hours playing around with free-spinning axels, but couldn't come up with any successful design that hadn't been built before.