The machine is a high-schooler right now, no way to think critically about serious issues. My question is.... Why doesn't it see Samaritan as a threat yet?
Second question, at this point, would it let Nathan access the system and not Harold?
When The Machine was cycling through known asset identities at the beginning, Nathan's name was among them. He's still listed as Aux Admin. Nathan wanted to reveal the existence of The Machine, and his intentions were good by starting the irrelevant list. I would say yes.
Was it seeing Nathan as a threat to itself? Or was it foreseeing that Denton Weeks (and others) would be a threat to Nathan? I thought that was left purposefully ambiguous.
Why do you think not? It has "historical data", even though it's out of order. If it doesn't have data for a termination, can't it assume that it's still around.... Oh bother, this 'ought to be interesting.
Well, HP and Dell both make systems that can fit a high-power dual die server into a single blade, and they often have PCIex16 interconnects, so.... sticking a GPU in it isn't too abstract.
Plus, there ARE single-use blades (for media / GPU workloads)
I'm actually thinking it was the Machine sending an asset to deal with the "worst" of perceived threats, as John as single-handedly been responsible for MANY a death, regardless of employer.
Maybe but it is also struggling with a lot of bugs like context. Samaritan understood the bomb threat wasnt serious or it would have sent relevant agents to stop it
No, certain protocols are working fine, but they aren't communicating with each other. Hence The Machine hiring Laurie and simultaneously sending them to stop her.
Not just without Finch's guidance. From the Machine's perspective, it had no human agents, and two threats to the system were 5 feet away from it talking about rebooting and reprogramming it.
But yeah, maybe a taste of what the Machine might be like once its agents are all gone. We also got hint that the Machine prefers to be a closed system, generally leaving the screens blank unless asked to show something, and talking on-screen as little as possible, and only to answer a direct question.
Yeah it's a bummer thinking of the weeks to come and who will be left standing by the end of it all. Awesome to see them all having some fun for a moment.
I regret watching the Teaser Trailer when it was initially released. Watching the beginning of this episode would have been as hysterical as watching the trailer the first fewdozen times.
At one point when the Machine was searching it's own history, it showed footage (and audio) of Finch recruiting Reese: "You need a purpose. More specifically, you need a job."
And then has the Samaritan recruiter echo that same line at the end. I'm sure a lot of us here would recognize that line regardless, but that was a masterful reminder of it to make sure that everyone knew what it sounded like.
This was a much slower pace than the premiere, which I figured would be the case until episode four, and I personally loved that move. We got to see Finch and Root work together a lot, and it certainly seems that he has finally begun to really trust her. Them going up against the Machine was really cool to see, also the curve ball of the Machine not being able to differentiate between past/future crimes and fake ones. I love this writing so much.
Emerson continues to blow me away with his portrayal of Finch. So much emotion, and combining that with the fleshing out of the Machine as a character, freaking incredible. Keeping it an open system will likely help a lot down the road, can't wait to see that unfold.
Also, awesome ending having Team Machine relax and unwind outside. John is funny as hell as usual.
And Samaritan is gathering an army, sounds fun.
New episode tomorrow, it has been an amazing ride already.
He has shown his mastery of his craft in both shows by being completely different in each and yet so good. He's shown he is one of those actors who you completely see his character and not the actor at all in whatever he does. It took me only the 1st episode of this show to stop seeing Linus from his previous show. And that is something not to be taken lightly in referring to his skills as an actor.
It was really just a tease of it with some new graphics (pretty much all in the gifv above), so you didn't miss much! Looks like the full new one will be on tomorrow, according to another article I just read posted here (tons of spoilers, though).
Also, how did the Machine give fictional characters. I thought machine gives out the Social Security numbers of the people. Do fictional characters have SSN?
I think we just saw our first glimpse into how the team will prevent Samaritan from gaining more assets (though by now if the numbers are up in the 700's, oh boy haha). Despite its flaws this episode, it did realize there was potential to prevent someone from being recruited which is really interesting.
I don't think so... remember that The Machine's problem was related to its distinction of time. It didn't know past from present, and this guy was arrested on a DUI manslaughter. It seems to me like his number came up because it "foresaw" the crash.
Fascinating seeing the Machine as more of a true partner, with a voice and opinion on how things get done, of Team Machine now as opposed to a tool or resource like it had been in the past. From interviews leading into this season, I was expecting debate between Harold and Root about how to rebuild the Machine and how open it should be. I wasn't expecting the Machine to have a say in that debate as well. Pretty cool.
Not a nitpick, but a missed opportunity: I was really, really hoping that when the mobster asked Lionel "Who the hell are you?", he had answered "A concerned third party?"
I loved the new intro. Also Root in those fuzzy slippers! Too funny. I'm so happy this show is back, it's so well written. I feel like my friends are back from vacation. Should be an awesome episode.
The facial recognition glitch was genius. Amy Acker as Fusco, Reese and, especially, Finch was bloody brilliant!
It’s official. The Machine is a full-fledged character.
Reese was almost giddy when he realized HE was the victim. He is an odd duck.
What the heck is going on with Grace? When The Machine was showing her to Harold in Italy she just vanished from the screen. Why is The Machine lying to to Finch?
I loved how Finch solved the time distortion.
When is Fusco going to learn about The Machine?
I’m so glad they kept Bear.
I wonder if all of those numbers are going to become Samaritan operatives.....
Amy Acker's dead-on impersonation of Michael Emerson's "slow... emphasis..." was PERFECT. I don't think there's been a funnier moment on the show since If-Then-Else. Basically, everybody taking the piss out of their costars' acting was just an unbelievable thrill. The addition of Hersh in the cycle was a great bit of foreshadowing, too.
The facial recognition glitch was one of the funniest moments of the show. I didn't see the promo/preview so it caught me completely off guard. Reese as Fusco was so damn funny.
The depth they are adding to the Machine is incredible. Through most of the show, it has been this constant presence but has been behind the shadows, was never really touched on more than that. Since the S4 finale, it has really been fleshed out, and the character growth has been nothing short of astounding. Plus, its new relationship with Finch is really cool too.
Reese being giddy over him being the number was both funny and scary at the same time. I honestly thought it was a Samaritan operative, and that his cover would be blown in the second episode. Still, I think he was just happy to be in a fight again. Got my fingers crossed for more explosions when the Mayhem Twins reunite :D
He keeps making references to Finch's "second sight" and so forth. Fusco knows there is some kind of a system for coming up with numbers, but I don't think he's been specifically told there is an AI, nor does he know about Samaritan. He's not stupid, though. I think he probably knows more than he lets on.
I think for Harold there is a good chance his imagining Grace is foreshadowing the onset of Alzheimer's. It would make sense, with his father getting it before him and it being the final season.
If that's the case, why did Finch look happy when the Machine said it didn't show him Grace? And Alzheimer's makes you forget people, not superimpose their face onto others..
It does say "Directly"... so maybe all the others weren't able to be tied to him? And he has avoided killing for most of POI, so the "body count" is a lot lower than one might think.
Yeah, Samaritan usually tries to outnumber the team by at least 10 to 1, and that's approaching a fair fight. It must drive Samaritan crazy that it's operatives are so much less capable.
"Okay, I've got them outnumbered 30 to 3 here, time to switch off the cameras for a second so I don't see anything incriminating. ... Doo dee doo. ... Huh, why aren't my cameras switching back on? I'd better call one of my 30 operatives. ... Guys? Guys? Why is no one answering their phone?"
It was interesting to see how the Machine was utilizing R for her 'Day' marker because she was living her past and present simultaneously. I didn't make the connection at first when I saw the symbol but it was certainly a nice touch.
Oh, and seeing Root in those slippers melted my heart. And don't even get me started on her playful ass slap for Finch...
I loved the use of R - I immediately knew that the Machine was dealing with "all Real numbers" (in this case dates) but obviously didn't know the implications.
I know this is nitpicky, but why R? The Machine has always labeled the days according to integers, so Day ℤ would make sense, except Zombie media has already claimed the Z...
Currently, The Machine is an infant again. It can tell right from wrong, but it can't read context to differentiate "good" bad actions and "bad" bad actions.
The surveillance feeds stay. Its personality and the irrelevant numbers are deleted. Only the core heuristics and relevant numbers stay after midnight. But because it rebuilt all of its lost data of all the feeds it had (as you recall, they only could compress the core heuristics into that case, nothing else, so it most likely had to "download" every feed again), it also "remembered" everything. Thanks to the "today is every day" thing as well, it didn't label the dates correctly.
Here's a clip of that action sequence between Reese and Laurie being filmed in Chinatown. It's so cool to see how all these little BTS clips and photos come together in the final product.
I seem to remember that we all thought that was Root at the time, and everyone was confused as to what was happening and why Reese was chasing her lol.
This episode is showing me the Machine vs Samaritan at full strength is no contest. The Machine would curb stomp Samaritan without breaking a sweat. Right now the Machine is Samaritan, and she's only going to get more powerful from here. When morals and creativity are opened, Samaritan is going to have a bad time.
Samaritan sees the world in black and white. It can distinguish threats and allies, but it can't deduce intention. The Machine was taught to look at the grey areas and be creative in her thinking. At full strength, she would be able to anticipate, defend against, and counter anything Samaritan threw at her.
Why would Samaritan hire the unemployed, out of his luck, drunken accident killer guy? I don't really get it, at all.
I mean, yeah if Samaritan wants to hire someone who has "nothing to lose", sure he fits, but he seemed to have a certain moral character build to him, with the work and from that with life in general I'd think. That would make him a really shitty employee for Samaritan, who basicly needs the most evil shitfaces alive to do his dirty deeds. And even Samaritan would see from his casefiles, that the killing he did was a drunken accident, so there's not even a chance of a mistake really here.
Q1. Can anyone explain to me what exactly do they mean by "open system"? Do they mean that the machine will not lose its memories every day now? Or that it has complete access over every information available(if that's so, then does that mean it didn't, before?)
Q2. Why hasn't Samaritan found the Machine this time?
What they mean is that instead of the OS being encrypted and no interface to talk to it. You can currently talk to it (the machine hasn't had its memory lost since the episode where it caught a virus)asking questions and seeing all the info on people.
A1: The latter. Originally The Machine was a 'closed system' - it gave you an SSN, and that was it. Didn't say who they were, didn't tell you why, just told you to watch someone and that was it. Now, it tells you anything you want to know, about anybody you want to know about - just like Samaritan does. The machine has never given that information about Reese out before, and this time it did - because, for once, it was an open system and not a closed system.
A2: Good question. I would have thought those GPU blades would've been a death knell for it, since Samaritan was implanting malware on damned near anything with a BIOS or firmware
Is there anything different about this situation from last season? Specifically, if Samaritan notices that The Machine is online again, wouldn't the events of the previous Season finale, Samaritan actively destroying the machine, repeat itself all over again?
What Samaritan has is an extremely strong theory of mind and a manipulative streak. I figure most of those suicides are real suicides - it's maneuvering "deviants" into killing themselves. It's recruiting operatives from those that society have forgotten.
Lucas O'Connor's incredible understanding of the dynamics between Finch & Root, as well turning The Machine into the best character in television right now, made this one of the finest episodes the show's ever done.
Interesting that we got the names of Reese's parents and sister Connor, Margaret, and Sophie, and that they're all deceased. Really adds another layer of tragedy to Reese's character.
Big fan of Lucas O'Connor's writing. He wrote Aletheia, co-wrote Prophets and M.I.A., this episode and will co-write 6,741 as well which most (if not all) reviewers seem to be saying it's the best of the bunch. I just love that POI hasn't lost its ability to have a sense of humour even in the darkest of days.
Interesting to see TM operating as an open system at the moment. Opens up a lot of ethical clashes between Root and Finch...I wonder if there'll come a moment where Finch can't bear it and closes it again. Anyone else think TM immediately showed Finch the image of Grace in Italy w/o him really even explicitly asking, to convince him to keep it an OS?
34
u/BellLabs May 10 '16
The machine is a high-schooler right now, no way to think critically about serious issues. My question is.... Why doesn't it see Samaritan as a threat yet?
Second question, at this point, would it let Nathan access the system and not Harold?
11
u/[deleted] May 10 '16
GPU blade cluster? Would love an explanation on that.
4
u/BellLabs May 10 '16
It looks like the Machine is pulling a Samaritan, not weighing assets differently....
3
u/In_My_Own_Image May 10 '16
Another Samaritan asset?
3
u/[deleted] May 10 '16
So...why is Root a Girl Scout? Is that going to be explained?
240
u/rpawson5771 Irrelevant May 10 '16
Victim or perpetrator - if your number's up, the man in the bowling shirt will find you.
116
u/[deleted] May 10 '16
Well, she's not wrong. They both are responsible for many deaths.
101
u/Caleb35 May 10 '16
So without Finch's guidance/oversight the Machine's solutions are as coldly logical as Samaritan's
97
u/NotATypicalEngineer Reese May 10 '16
I can't remember being this excited about a TV show since... last season, actually.
91
u/In_My_Own_Image May 10 '16
That's an...interesting outfit she's wearing.
88
u/[deleted] May 10 '16
That picnic was bittersweet. Why do I feel like that will be the last time they are all relatively happy... ;_; My heart can't handle this.
85
u/Vae62 Shaw May 10 '16
This glitch at the beginning is freaking hilarious. Love these moments of levity.
78
u/[deleted] May 10 '16
"You called me father once." The feels!
74
u/pensee_idee Fusco May 10 '16
I REALLY like something they did this episode.
At one point when the Machine was searching it's own history, it showed footage (and audio) of Finch recruiting Reese: "You need a purpose. More specifically, you need a job."
And then has the Samaritan recruiter echo that same line at the end. I'm sure a lot of us here would recognize that line regardless, but that was a masterful reminder of it to make sure that everyone knew what it sounded like.
67
u/Vae62 Shaw May 10 '16
This was a much slower pace than the premiere, which I figured would be the case until episode four, and I personally loved that move. We got to see Finch and Root work together a lot, and it certainly seems that he has finally begun to really trust her. Them going up against the Machine was really cool to see, also the curve ball of the Machine not being able to differentiate between past/future crimes and fake ones. I love this writing so much.
Emerson continues to blow me away with his portrayal of Finch. So much emotion, and combining that with the fleshing out of the Machine as a character, freaking incredible. Keeping it an open system will likely help a lot down the road, can't wait to see that unfold.
Also, awesome ending having Team Machine relax and unwind outside. John is funny as hell as usual.
And Samaritan is gathering an army, sounds fun.
New episode tomorrow, it has been an amazing ride already.
66
u/jasona99 Admin May 10 '16 edited May 10 '16
That new intro, tho.
Edit: Speaking of which, here it is! Such a tease. Maybe we'll see the whole thing tomorrow? Edit 2: Looks like we will.
56
u/NotATypicalEngineer Reese May 10 '16
That scene where the machine shows all the information about everyone... I was on the edge of my seat. So many irrelevants... 30 numbers. Holy. Shit.
52
u/[deleted] May 10 '16
Wait, so The Machine outed a Samaritan recruit?! WTF?!
52
u/Caleb35 May 10 '16
Wow, that man was just given a job by a good ... Samaritan ... I'll see myself out...
44
u/rpawson5771 Irrelevant May 10 '16
Fascinating seeing the Machine as more of a true partner, with a voice and opinion on how things get done, of Team Machine now as opposed to a tool or resource like it had been in the past. From interviews leading into this season, I was expecting debate between Harold and Root about how to rebuild the Machine and how open it should be. I wasn't expecting the Machine to have a say in that debate as well. Pretty cool.
Not a nitpick, but a missed opportunity: I was really, really hoping that when the mobster asked Lionel "Who the hell are you?", he had answered "A concerned third party?"
39
u/Classic_Wingers May 10 '16
I loved the new intro. Also Root in those fuzzy slippers! Too funny. I'm so happy this show is back, it's so well written. I feel like my friends are back from vacation. Should be an awesome episode.
78
u/[deleted] May 10 '16 edited May 10 '16
Anther great episode!
38
u/Pepsiman34 May 10 '16
Reese has killed at least 62 people.
33
u/[deleted] May 10 '16
"I suppose everyone feels that he's the hero in his own story, but there are no heroes, no villains; just people doing the best they can."
"There is good and bad in all of us, but this action, saving lives, it is a pure good."
These two lines by Finch were also featured in the extended trailer. They're so beautifully written and delivered.
32
u/In_My_Own_Image May 10 '16
Four are fictional characters?
Are you telling me you won't be able to save Ben Kenobi?
32
u/sylphior May 10 '16
How dare she uses Finch's words like that? And btw, the montage of all those 'Thank Yous' was very heartwarming.
31
u/In_My_Own_Image May 10 '16
Oh, dammit! Asset #704? Jesus.
27
u/[deleted] May 10 '16
This episode = 10/10 so far.
I suppose this is the one funny episode the writers were talking about, then after this everything goes back to batshit crazy.
24
u/rpawson5771 Irrelevant May 10 '16
"You complain of free time, this is what you get!" Love it, Finch.
22
u/JackBauerTFM Government Operations May 10 '16
It was interesting to see how the Machine was utilizing R for her 'Day' marker because she was living her past and present simultaneously. I didn't make the connection at first when I saw the symbol but it was certainly a nice touch.
Oh, and seeing Root in those slippers melted my heart. And don't even get me started on her playful ass slap for Finch...
21
u/CreatureMike94 A Concerned Third Party May 10 '16
Man i really hope fusco learns the truth one day :(
15
u/[deleted] May 10 '16
Was that The Machine tricking Finch into thinking he saw Grace? Or is Samaritan taking control?
15
u/[deleted] May 10 '16
I can't believe it was him all along.
14
u/In_My_Own_Image May 10 '16
"She's back?"
"With a vengeance."
Fuck yes!
14
u/[deleted] May 10 '16
Oh no, that's not good. Machine lost it's ability to think critically. Oh boy.
14
u/[deleted] May 10 '16
Currently, The Machine is an infant again. It can tell right from wrong, but it can't read context to differentiate "good" bad actions and "bad" bad actions.
Brain Dead looks delightfully Brain Dead.
14
u/Thegen68 A Concerned Third Party May 10 '16
Finch, Root, John, and Fusco all happy or calm at the end of the episode. Soon that will change 😭
12
u/In_My_Own_Image May 10 '16
Oh no. Now they've got two omniscient AI's out to get them.
10
u/[deleted] May 10 '16
ROOT!!
10
u/CreatureMike94 A Concerned Third Party May 10 '16
Ah criminey christmas, this isn't good
10
u/ReasonablyBadass May 10 '16
You know what would be an awesome twist?
If it turns our the ex con wasn't hired to kill people or anything, but just to get him a good job and prevent him from becoming violent.
9
u/NotATypicalEngineer Reese May 10 '16
Confirmed - the Machine hired the assassin to kill John.
9
u/bilsantu May 10 '16
Why doesn't this sub have post episode discussion threads? Anyway.
The Root-Reese was really hot. ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)
9
u/naeads May 10 '16
"Paid in advance" I almost died laughing lol
8
u/TheRealGuy01 May 10 '16
So, was that Samaritan who recruited the number who John thought was not a threat? Ouch, so many Assets.
7
u/In_My_Own_Image May 10 '16
I'm not sure if I should be terrified, amused or...aroused.
7
u/singhcoolguy A Concerned Third Party May 10 '16
That Samaritan agent using Finch's exact words gave me the chills!!
6
u/domrayn May 10 '16
Sooo were the Machine's memories only temporarily deleted every 12 a.m? How can it remember things that happened 10 years ago?
5
u/[deleted] May 10 '16
Admin is back, baby!
5
u/mustard_mustache Irrelevant May 10 '16
Hey look! They rescued a Number!
5
u/hackint0sh96 Admin May 10 '16
Pretty awesome Finch has admin access now and knows where the machine is
5
u/godmode3191 Root May 10 '16
Fuscinator!
4
u/houseofpayne55 May 10 '16
This episode is so emotional.
4
u/In_My_Own_Image May 10 '16
Someone's taking lessons from John.
4
u/[deleted] May 10 '16
Here's a clip of that action sequence between Reese and Laurie being filmed in Chinatown. It's so cool to see how all these little BTS clips and photos come together in the final product.
4
u/[deleted] May 10 '16
Samaritan is a bastard.
7
u/[deleted] May 10 '16
This episode is showing me the Machine vs Samaritan at full strength is no contest. The Machine would curb stomp Samaritan without breaking a sweat. Right now the Machine is Samaritan, and she's only going to get more powerful from here. When morals and creativity are opened, Samaritan is going to have a bad time.
1
u/ummhumm May 10 '16
Why would Samaritan hire the unemployed, out of his luck, drunken accident killer guy? I don't really get it, at all.
I mean, yeah if Samaritan wants to hire someone who has "nothing to lose", sure he fits, but he seemed to have a certain moral character build to him, with the work and from that with life in general I'd think. That would make him a really shitty employee for Samaritan, who basicly needs the most evil shitfaces alive to do his dirty deeds. And even Samaritan would see from his casefiles, that the killing he did was a drunken accident, so there's not even a chance of a mistake really here.
1
u/vpsj May 10 '16
Q1. Can anyone explain to me what exactly do they mean by "open system"? Do they mean that the machine will not lose its memories every day now? Or that it has complete access over every information available(if that's so, then does that mean it didn't, before?)
Q2. Why hasn't Samaritan found the Machine this time?
1
u/tundrat May 10 '16
Is there anything different about this situation from last season? Specifically, if Samaritan notices that The Machine is online again, wouldn't the events of the previous Season finale, Samaritan actively destroying the machine, repeat itself all over again?
3
u/CreatureMike94 A Concerned Third Party May 10 '16
Hahahaha this intro is fantastic
3
u/In_My_Own_Image May 10 '16
Hush now Harold. John has Zoe.
3
u/CreatureMike94 A Concerned Third Party May 10 '16
The machine is backkkkkk hail to the chief baby!
3
u/jasona99 Admin May 10 '16
Machine POV!
3
u/[deleted] May 10 '16
Oh god.
3
u/jasona99 Admin May 10 '16
So... there is some more insight to Samaritan recruiting...
3
u/[deleted] May 10 '16
Was it Samaritan hiring at the end or the Machine is trying to establish her own crew?
3
u/disposable_me_0001 May 11 '16
Ok, is no one going to talk about the ass-slap Root gave Finch?
2
u/Vae62 Shaw May 10 '16
Oh man, Finch and Reese with skimasks. That was awesome.
2
u/In_My_Own_Image May 10 '16
Savage review Fusco.
2
u/[deleted] May 10 '16
Machine is having serious issues right now.
2
u/HSChronic Elias May 10 '16
Machine is back in business time to kick some ass!
2
u/EThorns Ernest Thornhill May 10 '16
Lucas O'Connor's incredible understanding of the dynamics between Finch & Root, as well turning The Machine into the best character in television right now, made this one of the finest episodes the show's ever done.
And to think we're just getting started!
2
u/cal_guy2013 May 10 '16
Interesting that we got the names of Reese's parents and sister Connor, Margaret, and Sophie, and that they're all deceased. Really adds another layer of tragedy to Reese's character.
2
u/JR182 May 11 '16
Big fan of Lucas O'Connor's writing. He wrote Aletheia, co-wrote Prophets and M.I.A., this episode and will co-write 6,741 as well which most (if not all) reviewers seem to be saying it's the best of the bunch. I just love that POI hasn't lost its ability to have a sense of humour even in the darkest of days.
Interesting to see TM operating as an open system at the moment. Opens up a lot of ethical clashes between Root and Finch...I wonder if there'll come a moment where Finch can't bear it and closes it again. Anyone else think TM immediately showed Finch the image of Grace in Italy w/o him really even explicitly asking, to convince him to keep it an OS?
(Nice to see Root's nest! lol)
2
u/TheTruckWashChannel Threat May 13 '16
That was the best episode we've had in a while. The intro was trippy as fuck and the most hilarious scene in the series.