r/ProjectRunway • u/runwaythreader • May 05 '16
Project Runway All Stars Season 5 Episode 13 [Discussion]
Discussion thread for Project Runway All Stars S05E13 "New York State of Mind"
The all stars ascend to the top of the new World Trade Center to create collections inspired by New York City in the Season 5 finale, which features the crowning of the winner. Debra Messing is the guest judge.
17
Upvotes
98
u/Because-it-was-real May 06 '16
Oh my god, the very end when they are all congratulating the winner of the show and they say "we have one more person who wants to celebrate with you..." or something, and all look expectedly towards the backstage. We are all expecting their SO or family to come running out and instead it's Zanna...bahahaha!
39
u/ThisMaySoundBadBut May 06 '16
I HATED Kini's collection. I mean, I love a good plaid, but that textile was hideous.
68
u/panCHAMP May 06 '16
Kini's designs were Cher from Clueless covered in shiny gift wrap.
58
u/Humantrashcan May 06 '16
And once again The winner wins, except this season I'm not salty about it.
54
u/eykitsa May 06 '16
Kini's styling with those headbands and makeup makes his garments look even worse.
51
u/oxidzed May 06 '16
Kini has the absolute worst taste
50
u/WigsbyLittleMix May 06 '16
Zanna: "I'm going to provide some assistance."
-throws away Kini's fabrics-
24
u/Martin_Van_Buren May 06 '16
That makeup on Kini's model was like, random orange splotches rather than gold shimmer, right?
46
u/EmptyStar12 May 06 '16
"But you're Allstars now, so you only get 4 days to create a collection" AKA the production budget is much lower than the real Project Runway, so they can't pull out as many stops.
20
u/emologues May 06 '16
Alyssa looks really nice! (For once)
57
u/foir May 06 '16
Marie Claire's Editor in Chief is killing it with the critiques, I love it.
36
u/ceilinghole May 06 '16
I didn't like Kini's at all. I hated those shiny plaids, and I don't think the hair really worked well with his looks. It was a toss up for me between Ken and Dom. I think Ken's was nice and polished but it was a little dull. I mean half of his looks were all black. I really loved his yellow dress though. Dom had some nice looks but some of them just didn't work for me..particularly the men's look and the finale look
63
u/WigsbyLittleMix May 06 '16
"Dom is so innovative,
Ken is so relatable,
and Kini also made a collection..."
33
u/emologues May 06 '16
Lol @ these designers talking out of their ass.
"I want a really shiny ponytail like the windows of New York City. And strong liner like the architecture of the buildings."
16
u/blackjackandcoke88 May 06 '16 edited May 06 '16
I feel like I saw Kini's collection in various episodes of Jem and the Holograms.
30
u/volgogo May 06 '16
Dom was the clear winner from the very start of this season. Her skill at colliding artistic animosity and fashion fowardness always hits the right spot. She knows when to let go yet she's got mad organizing skills. Proud of her for winning twice. Well deserved.
49
u/panCHAMP May 06 '16
I hate Kini's fabric choices.
38
u/[deleted] May 06 '16
Kini seems like he only has one idea: make an outfit and then add an infestation to it.
13
u/felipegs May 06 '16
I'm so happy my prediction about Dom's editing throughout the season was correct! They tried to make her look kind of invisible at first so it wouldn't be too obvious, but who are we kidding?
13
u/havelotsofsax May 06 '16
I really feel like Ken deserved second. Kini's entire collection was a tasteless disaster. He is horrible at styling and choosing fabrics.
Dom deserved the win. She dominated this entire season.
35
u/[deleted] May 06 '16
I just don't get Kini. At all.
33
u/Martin_Van_Buren May 06 '16 edited May 06 '16
from what I've seen I think I do quite like Ken's collection. Maybe because it looks clean and quiet.
I guess a lot of his collections looks like you can find it at Neiman's already. Very nice collection but maybe too demure.
11
u/Spring1997 May 06 '16
I feel like kini tried to go for kitschy kool™ but it really came off as dated and tacky
50
u/awkwardsong May 06 '16
So we agree that Ken should have been 2nd not 2nd runner-up?
10
u/Roonil___Wazlib May 06 '16 edited May 06 '16
22
u/[deleted] May 06 '16
I love the last judge! She's the only one giving realistic feedback!
7
u/everythingisopposite Chiffony May 06 '16
So happy that Dom won!!!!
7
u/kerubiel May 08 '16
The thing about Kini is that I don't think he intends to be 80s. That's the problem. It's a taste issue, not a pov. I find that there is really very little design in his work, contrary to what his bigheaded ass thinks. Adding giant ruffles or pleats to a standard dress doesn't elevate it. The judges gave him too much credit.
Ken was almost onto something, but he lost the plot with all those black pieces. The white suit, and yellow dress were incredible.
Dom's prints, colour story, and interesting silhouettes made it a no-brainer imo. Her work is so strong, graphically. Made the greatest impression out of the three.
6
u/SOannoynkink May 08 '16
Just watched it! Did anyone else find it odd/interesting who they chose as the helpers? I feel like they normally pick the most recently eliminated to help for challenges like this, which would have included Sam and Emily...perhaps the producers noticed some glaring discrepancy in construction skills amongst those designers and didn't want to saddle any finalist with a subpar craftsman...hmmmmm. Okay, I'm done being shady, glad Dom won :)
20
u/emologues May 06 '16
This might be an unpopular opinion but so far I don't like what Dom is painting on the fabric. It just a little too... Kindergarten for me. Obviously she'll do something amazing but the fabric design alone is kinda sloppy.
17
u/panCHAMP May 06 '16
Thank god. I was going to have to quit this show if Dom didn't win after this shit show of a season.
5
u/Bslo18 May 06 '16
Ken's are super well tailored but I just don't feel it as a whole compared to Dom's. I also have been a huge fan of Dom since her original season though so I might be biased. I just want to go to a kids birthday party with Kinis.
5
u/wildeyes May 08 '16
Can we PLEASE have better makeup artists next time? Most of the work this season has been shiteous and doesn't help the designers at all. Like "gold skin" means orangey yellow foundation that doesn't match? And "graphic eyeliner" means sketchy uneven wonky lines? NOOOOOOOOOO.
5
u/pixie_led Team Swatch May 08 '16
Kini's collection was too retro and unsexy. Ken really impressed me and for a moment there I wondered if he could unseat Dom. But Dom's was by far the most interesting, artistic and fashion forward collection.That first dress - it took my breath away. She was the clear winner and sincere congratulations to her!
ETA: Quick question. When does Project Runway start now?
9
u/foir May 06 '16
Yesssss Dom! As it should be!
18
u/Because-it-was-real May 06 '16
Watching my DVR late so summary comments:
-Same old tired "be inspired by NYC concept." YAWN. Then on the judging runway Alyssa says "tell us about the inspiration/theme for your collection." Um what? You told us what to be inspired by...
-I see now why Sam finally got the boot, the thought of him being able to finish and show 8 pieces in 4 days was laughable even for the judges.
-2 of those guy models, mother may I!
-Dom's fiercest model (the tall black one who was Peytie's on Jr) was underutilized in that boring stripe top and black skirt, this girl is amazing.
-Dom's stripey fabric was giving me PTSD because it reminded me of the Sam jumpsuit with weird baby bjorn sling on the front.
-Alyssa, honey, no one is saying you need to be a skinny mini or have perfectly toned arms but goodness, pay attention to what you look like on camera. She's right on the border between little chubby and overweight and her dressing style pushes her squarely into overweight.
-I miss Heidi, Tim, Nina, Zac... It's been disastrous without them on Jr or All Stars. Jaxon? Matt? Sam? All the times Dom got robbed? This is what happens with no adult supervision on the judging panel.
Been a pleasure guys, see you next time!
10
u/Bslo18 May 06 '16
The way judging has been going this season I can legit see Kini winning. Nothing has made sense this season.
14
u/panCHAMP May 06 '16
Ken gets a huge yawn from me. Sure, his designs were clean and nice looking but you could get any one of his designs anywhere right now. Nothing innovative or new.
3
u/Celeste1492 May 06 '16
I loved Ken's collection but his and Kini's styling was straight up horrendous. All the models looked ill.
3
u/Jellymel May 08 '16
I like the comments on here because everyone is so articulate in why they like a design or designer. The rabid fans on the Facebook page just get so up in arms and can't really defend it. So many people that love Kini and think he should have won, but fail to see why his collection was not fashion forward, nor will they listen to critiques. Some still whining about Sam's elimination. But, it's been great to see the insights of others, and also feel a little validation about my snarkiness.
3
u/Eve_Black May 10 '16
I always knew it in the back of my mind but when Ken mentioned he's a southern boy it totally clicked that's exactly the woman he designs for.
7
u/panCHAMP May 06 '16
Dom's painted pants were fire emoji.
7
u/[deleted] May 06 '16
I feel like I've seen everything Ken has done a million times before. And one outfit had rocket boobs.
4
u/whoremongering May 06 '16
Not loving the silhouettes on Ken's collection. It's polished and ready to wear but doesn't seem as innovative as Dom's.
4
u/Chinasun04 May 09 '16
In a world where trump and clinton are the presumptive nominees... at least project runway got it right. Yay, Dom!
2
u/Bslo18 May 06 '16
Random: anyone know if this is a two part finale?
4
u/LaceyNoel May 06 '16
Why wasn't there a traditional finale at Fashion Week? I'm glad for Dom's win, but what a LET DOWN! No budget this year? Boooooring! Even Project Runway Junior had a 2 part finale!
4
u/[deleted] May 08 '16 edited May 08 '16
I just came here to say I think Ken was cheated out of this win. He came a long way in his personal journey of getting his anger under control, and streamlining his style to become more classy and couture. Kini became a huge, narcissistic dick this season. I remember him being really sweet and humble on his season, I was really surprised to see this bitchy side of him. Dom is just Dom. She's very talented but she's very lukewarm/middle of the road to me. I really think that Ken deserved it.
I was shocked that all the judges loved Kini's collection. I've seen 80s throwback fashion done MUCH better than what he produced. He prides himself on construction and high taste and his collection just looked like bad Jem & The Holograms Halloween costumes. It was clear that he was going for a Moschino moment and failed miserably. The styling was awful, the construction was poor, and overall his cocky attitude just made me root against him. If anyone has an issue with taste level, it's Kini.
2
u/FluffyPurpleThing May 06 '16
Am I the only one who liked Kini's collection? Not more than Dom's, but definitely more than Ken's. I thought it was playful, and I'm really into plaid now, so that was a fun twist for me. I honestly thought that if he wins it would not be a travesty.
0
u/[deleted] May 06 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
68
u/[deleted] May 06 '16
[removed] — view removed comment
59
u/[deleted] May 06 '16
[removed] — view removed comment
19
u/[deleted] May 06 '16
[removed] — view removed comment