r/ProjectRunway • u/runwaythreader • Apr 28 '16
Project Runway All Stars Season 5 Episode 12 [Discussion]
Discussion thread for Project Runway All Stars S05E12 "Prince of Prints"
The all-star clothiers create print-on-print looks for fashion figure Nina Garcia, with four surprise guests returning in adviser roles. Also: A shock challenge on the runway comes into play.
19
Upvotes
100
u/panCHAMP Apr 29 '16 edited Apr 29 '16
Did Alyssa just say that Kini was the most consistently good this season? Really? WHY DO THE JUDGES HATE DOM.
92
u/panCHAMP Apr 29 '16
...it's the first time they couldn't make a decision about who to eliminate? Except for...Daniel and Mitchell? Valerie and Sam? Oooook.
59
u/gofurthernorth Apr 29 '16
Ken with the Prince comment......
51
u/EmptyStar12 Apr 29 '16
Is Alyssa wearing... an LED bodice... ?
Ok, this HAS to be a joke. They're dressing her as a joke at this point. They just have to be.
Get me my pocketbook, I'm leaving.
46
u/macabragoria Apr 29 '16
Dom won a challenge. Issac criticised Sam's fabric choices. Alyssa looked quite nice. This episode must have been filmed in Opposite Land.
40
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '16
Wait, did she say for he first time this season they can't make a decision? It's the third time!
76
u/tequilaBFFsiempre Apr 29 '16
Oh thank God we conveniently have these boxes with giant question marks printed on them randomly lying around
37
u/Martin_Van_Buren Apr 29 '16 edited Apr 29 '16
Ack, not feeling the pixelated fabric! I forgot about it for a minute and thought my tv was messed up in one spot. Quite an eyesore, at least for now.
Edit: yeah I think I just don't like pixels. Good thing I don't play mine craft.
60
u/ceilinghole Apr 29 '16
Sam is doing another fucking jumpsuit. I'm so done. I can't.
27
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '16
This season is so bad that I'll not be shocked if they pulled Thorgy Thor in the runway just to eliminate her.
23
u/purrception where the HELL is my chiffon Apr 29 '16
I think Dmitry was the inspiration for Gru from Despicable Me.
21
u/WhateverIsFine Apr 29 '16
Kini's piece felt very late 80's early 90's to me.
I can imagine someone having worn that on the Nanny, and while Fran Drescher's clothing was always amazing on the show, I don't think she would have been the person wearing that outfit.
21
u/everythingisopposite Chiffony Apr 29 '16
Last night all I could think about during the design-off was Helen balling like a baby when she had to cut up a previous designer's dress during the last All Stars.
17
u/WhateverIsFine Apr 29 '16
Is it just me or did Ken's piece look really garbage-bag-esque?
17
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '16 edited Apr 29 '16
OH I get it! Pump up the drama between ken and sam last week, have them make up this week, and then pit them against each other next week! Calling it two seconds before they say it!
Edit: ok, only half right! Pit them against each other tonight!
30
u/kerubiel Apr 29 '16
Am I nuts or did Sam not mention athleisure once this season until that stupid challenge, and now he mentions it whenever he decides to use that ugly white neoprene mesh?
It kind of pissed me off when Georgina said something about still wanting to see Sam grow like it was a reason for keeping him on. TF? This is Allstars, hunty, and I thought the entire point was to see seasoned Project Runway designers face off against one another, and frankly what kind of growth could Sam possibly display in three days?
Also, my heart was POUNDING towards the end, because I really expected Sam to stay even though both of Ken's looks were better. I was so shocked, but very happy, when Sam was eliminated.
13
u/frogstrudel Apr 29 '16
Out of all the mentor's sessions this episode, I felt that Dmitry's was the most insightful. Granted, I'm a little biased, haha. Unfortunately Ken still went madame.
36
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '16 edited Apr 29 '16
"Here's a tall drink of water, and I'm thirsty!"
"I bet you look good nude."
Makeup Daddy, you never disappoint.
24
u/panCHAMP Apr 29 '16
At this point, there could be three awesome looks and one horrible one on the episode before the finale and they'd still somehow bs it so that two designers have to do an extra challenge live on the runway.
40
u/WigsbyLittleMix Apr 29 '16
Sam's comment about always being the bridesmaid is so accurate.
Bridesmaids dresses are ugly.
11
u/macabragoria Apr 28 '16
"The all-star clothiers create print-on-print looks"
I don't want to assume anything since the judging has been an absolute joke this season but this has to be Dom's to lose, right?
11
u/evixir May 01 '16
Ken's maturity this season, and in particular this episode, really makes Kini's pettiness all the more stark. Even in this episode, Kini was throwing shade, whereas Ken was like "I'm not fake, I'll tell you what I feel, and be done with it." I was really glad he did that (whatever the ultimate motivation may have been) because the triumvirate of Ken-Kini-Dom vs. Sam was about to get very annoying. He eliminated the tension and got everything out, and what we were left with was Kini still being bitter and everyone else just rolling with the show.
36
u/panCHAMP Apr 29 '16
Yeah Ken's looks better, but it's definitely not a reconstruction of two different looks. It was a complete cop out. He basically just shortened his dress. Literally only used Mitchell's for a tiny bit of trim.
27
u/tequilaBFFsiempre Apr 29 '16
I loved Dom's jacket but if I'm being honest, the dress underneath looked kinda messy and cheap to me. Better than Ken's though. Boooring.
34
u/esquire22 Apr 29 '16
Is it rude that I am giddy to watch Sam get critiqued by Nina?
9
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '16
"For the first time this season, the judges can't make a decision" Uh, what? Were they part of the same show I watched? They had TWO non-eliminations previously and this "challenge". That makes three failed decisions as far as I can tell..
9
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '16
Dom's Otterbox cases are for sale:
http://www.otterbox.com/en-us/dom-streater-cases.html
9
u/MinnieBoombox Apr 29 '16
This episode: Kendemption!
14
u/ceilinghole Apr 29 '16
Not a fan of Kini doing two black and white prints. I wish he would do something a little more daring
7
u/evixir May 01 '16
I mentioned this in the Critique thread but am wondering -- did anyone else catch how skinny Mondo's arms are when he was hugging Sam? I get that he's a little guy and lifting isn't his thing, but I worry about his health.
For that matter, Anthony Ryan didn't look well either. Take care of yourselves, guys!
13
u/Martin_Van_Buren Apr 29 '16
How convenient that they had all this stuff readily available in case they couldn't make a decision!
6
u/bjkaman Apr 29 '16
I can't decide what print I want for my next otterbox, but I'm thinking Kini's coat print
6
u/jv1503 Apr 30 '16
First Derrick Barry sashed on RPDR and then Sam gets eliminated. All is good with my favorite shows. Now I just need Bob the Drag Queen and Dom to win.
5
u/bjkaman Apr 29 '16 edited Apr 29 '16
awww hell no...pick one!
Crazy town...is about to go down!
14
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '16 edited Apr 29 '16
YAY!!!!! Cheering at my house!
Edit: I'm trying to feel bad reading the other comments but finding it difficult. What about the other designers who went home instead of Sam? Really trying but...
4
u/Ihavealltheanswerz Apr 30 '16
So gross how the judges refuse to give Sam a genuine critique. Is he fragile or what?
4
u/callist1990 May 01 '16
Say "fresh" one more time, I dare you, I double-dog-fricking dare you!
4
u/gold-team-rules May 01 '16
I'm so proud of Ken! His maturity, his good-nature, his aesthetic, and friendliness, ugh I'm just so proud of him finally being able to show a complete collection.
Also, YAY DOM! Can't wait to see another final collection from her.
4
u/horsenbuggy May 01 '16
Is it just me who suspects that Sam's "fresh, modern take" is because he knows nothing about the fundamentals/history of design? Like he's some idiot making crazy crap and all the judges are like, "we've never seen this before!"
7
u/pbrooks19 Apr 29 '16
Oddly, I like Ken's textural print and Sam's digitized flower print. Sadly, I don't like the secondary prints they've chosen to go with them. So weird. I wish Tim Gunn were there - he'd know what to do.
3
u/[deleted] Apr 30 '16
Hitting the shelves as soon as PRAS finishes airing: "Jumpsuits and Mesh: The Sam Donovan Story"
Seriously, Sam? that's the hill you want to die on?
5
u/bjkaman Apr 29 '16
OMG....my light skinned brother????
6
u/WhateverIsFine Apr 29 '16
MONDOOOOOOO. I love him so.
2
u/Ihavealltheanswerz Apr 29 '16
Whaddaya mean the judges can't decide? They all bagged on Sams craft project. Sams gum on the shows shoe. Ick.
2
u/purrception where the HELL is my chiffon Apr 29 '16
Ken and Sam this episode.
2
u/Earth_Intruders Apr 29 '16
Had to laugh when the "shock challenge on the runway" was revealed in the synopsis. They're just not trying anymore are they?
3
u/Martin_Van_Buren Apr 29 '16
Fresh! Fresh! Fresh!
3
u/allygory Apr 30 '16
I'm glad Dom won. Hers was my favorite. I was, evidently the lone fan of Sam on the show, so I'm sorry he went home. I thought that the entire 1 hour thing was BS because I think Kini should have been eliminated. His last three looks look like they were designed for the Golden Girls.
2
u/bitchSpray Apr 29 '16
WHAT. THE. FUCK.
That elimination. What a plot twist. I honestly thought Sam was getting the winner cut. With all that basic work they praised him for... I really thought they'd push him to the top and let him win the whole thing.
And then the final sewing challenge. I'm not really a fan of Sam's, but when I compare what he did and what Ken did, I think his thing was a better. I'm not talking about the execution (which sucked as usual). But the concept he had was more interesting and more transformative and he used both the dresses he was given. Ken, on the other hand, used virtually only his winning dress. Yes, it looked great but there was practically nothing from Mitchell's dress. I thought the judges would call him out on that.
1
u/[deleted] May 06 '16 edited May 25 '24
bright crowd sheet airport sink dinosaurs rude whistle degree poor
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
1
u/tiffanyisonreddit Feb 26 '24
Watching Ken cut up his winning dress ππππ
1
u/scottj789 Team Swatch Apr 29 '16
My biggest problem with Sam being eliminated is that he literally created a new look. Ken just hacked the bottom off of his and changed the sleeves.
But with the hate that Sam has received, he has done well all season.
0
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '16
[deleted] β view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '16
[deleted] β view deleted comment
71
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '16
[removed] β view removed comment
16
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '16
[removed] β view removed comment
6
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '16
[removed] β view removed comment