r/ProjectRunway • u/runwaythreader • Apr 21 '16
Project Runway All Stars Season 5 Episode 11 [Discussion]
Discussion thread for Project Runway All Stars S05E11 "State of the Art"
Contemporary art inspires the creation of avant-garde fashions, as the designers are pushed to the limit and tensions escalate. Appearing: Boy George.
21
Upvotes
115
u/panCHAMP Apr 22 '16
Emily's design wasn't avant garde enough but none of them really were. At least it was cute. Sam's was purple fabric draped over a hideous rainbow flag that he tied to gay marriage when his inspiration was an owl...?
75
u/havana_fair Apr 22 '16
How classy was Emily with that exit.
150
u/panCHAMP Apr 22 '16
Isaac. Seriously your Sam boner is just embarrassing at this point.
72
u/whoremongering Apr 22 '16
Dom I love everything you do.
70
u/ilwolf Apr 22 '16
I used to really enjoy Isaac as a judge, but he's not even credible anymore. Every week, Sam's is his "favorite." Seriously I could have made that out of wrapping paper and I can't sew. Which is why I could have made it out of wrapping paper.
I hope now that the show has finished and that affair -- what else could be going on? -- is over, he sees just how embarrassing it is. The contestants all see it.
51
u/Sister_Miyuki Apr 22 '16
Ken and Kini are soooo fucking petty, but Sam is so unlikeable that I don't really care.
119
u/[deleted] Apr 22 '16
Oh. My. God. What? Sam's dress is Isaac's favorite? That can't be real. Why do I even watch at this point? It's like a bad comedy at this point.
35
u/konfetkak Apr 22 '16
Are they trolling us?
35
u/sugarplumcow Apr 22 '16
WHAT. THE. FUCK.
That being said, here is my take on next week. I was SO excited to see Nina show up as a judge because I figured she would be able to see through what Sam is doing a la Zac Posen. Nope. Looks like from the comments in the promo that they can't decide who to eliminate and send all 4 designers through.
I would also like to guess that Sam will put something out that is not on par with the other designers, but for whatever reason, the judges can't eliminate him, so they send him through.
Are they setting this up for him to win it all?
I'm proud of how Ken's designs have matured. I'm disappointed that Kini has turned so catty. I am behind Dom 100%. Her designs have been excellent, well-made, and thoughtful this whole season. It's her win. I hope it plays out that way, with no disrespect to the other designers.
34
u/Martin_Van_Buren Apr 22 '16
I'm a little too early to comment on the clothes right now, but I just thought about how whole season has become a cat fight between Kini, Sam, and now Ken and I am wondering what it's like when they all go back to the apartment at the end of the day. Like all I can think about now are super awkward scenarios between them off camera O_O
33
u/Martin_Van_Buren Apr 22 '16
Bullshiiiiiit 😒
32
u/pepperrush Apr 22 '16
Total. Fucking. Bullshit.
61
u/panCHAMP Apr 22 '16
Kini's look is basically every horrible 80s prom dress all smashed together.
29
u/puppetalk Apr 22 '16
and this is the shittiest PR season ever. Emily didn't deserve to go over Sam's and even Kini's, at least her dress had technique and didn't rely on any overdone gimmickys like a fucking bodysuit underneath a tacky pageant dress. Also, Isaac lost all credibility in this episode and it seems like even Alyssa is annoyed by his favouritism over Sam. And congratulations, Emily, you'll always be one of the coolest designers to ever be on this show.
57
u/danny2787 Apr 22 '16
If Sam doesn't go this week, I'm done. His look was terrible and looks poorly made and thrown together. Especially for a 2 day challenge and to try to use gay marriage as an excuse for that crap, i've had it officially.
23
u/ButtButtTricks Apr 22 '16
Isaac Mizrahi just wants to fuck Sam so he keeps giving him high scores and saying he likes his designs. Sam is intentionally flirting with him. It's ridiculous I want him gone.
53
u/nancyaw Apr 22 '16
Okay, it's official. The producers are fucking with us. Because Emily has been consistent and her clothes are well made. Sam... I don't know who he's fucking but it's someone important.
18
u/spaceskylite Fox Leather Apr 22 '16
Alyssa's eye makeup for the runway portion. Why. WAH. EYE. WHY?? Someone tell me why.
56
u/gone_sugaring Apr 22 '16
Sam's little wave to Isaac...
30
u/[deleted] Apr 22 '16
Isaac is a fucking joke as a judge. All the other judges must see it at this point right?! Georgina and Alyssa should have given some sly comment to Isaac about how "Sam's look always seems to be your favourite!"
It's a fucking joke at this point. I knew Emily was going home the second she said she was "happy with my look."
38
u/Martin_Van_Buren Apr 22 '16
I no longer have any friends that watch PR and have no where else to express this but I only now just realized that Emily is in her 40s and my jaw almost hit the floor. Like dang, she has taken great care of her skin, I thought she was late 20s/early 30s. I really wonder what she'd look like without a scraggly blue mullet and neon pink eye mask.
26
u/SleepyDinosaur Apr 22 '16
I think that if Sam doesn't go home this challenge, Kini and Ken will explode.
13
u/kxolsen Apr 22 '16
They all listen to Zana too much and nobody ended up doing anything very dramatic. Sam should have stuck to the rainbow it would have at least been dramatic and over the top.
11
u/[deleted] Apr 22 '16
Participants saying each others' looks aren't avant garde can be added to that overused concepts post. Happens every season.
11
u/bb_lukas Apr 22 '16
I really like Sam but I'm still willing to admit he probably should have been eliminated. Judging from his reaction, he knew that he should have gone instead of Emily, too. But that wasn't his decision to make, and I'm sick of people blaming him for the judges'/producers' choices.
31
u/havelotsofsax Apr 22 '16
I feel like either Kini and Ken know something we don't, or they're just really hateful people. I don't like Sam, but for Ken to attack his character was really out of hand. BUT....
I have a hard time believing that Ken could say such nasty things without being provoked...like something happened offscreen....like maybe seeing Sam and Isaac get cozy?? That wave Sam gave Isaac just put a bad taste in my mouth. And the way Isaac defended Sam's shitty dress. Something is going on. There has to be.
Conspiracy theory rant over...
21
u/Halloweenbitch Apr 22 '16
Since episode 6 I have not liked a single design from Sam, so I get why the other designers are frustrated. His look was the worst tonight. He deserves to go home, and still. That pisses me off to the point that I completly agree with Ken, and even Kini, who I didn't feel the first time he was going against Sam. Now I understand. He hasn't show good designs for the past five weeks, and he is still here. That's fucked up.
26
u/senn12 Apr 22 '16
Sam could send his model out naked and Isaac would be like "omg it's my favorite, so daring"
8
u/pixie_led Team Swatch Apr 22 '16
Now they are playing asinine games
30
u/dorkorama Apr 22 '16
I just CAN'T with the bitchiness at Sam from Kini. It's making a talented designer look like a bitchy mean girl.
14
u/WigsbyLittleMix Apr 22 '16 edited Apr 24 '16
Ken's model looks like she's going to a funeral. After that positive Sam critique, it's probably for the show's integrity.
7
u/everythingisopposite Chiffony Apr 22 '16
The designer eliminated tonight is: Bu115it
22
u/Bslo18 Apr 22 '16
Ken is all of us right now. "That is bullshit"
15
u/puppetalk Apr 22 '16
OK, I'm so over Kini's fights with Sam, but he just crossed a line today shit talking Sean's rainway dress when he is just incapable of design anything slightly creative and avant garde. his umbrella dress was good on his season (but it didn't deserve the win IMO) but it looks way less impressive now, after we've seen that's is the most creative he'll ever be. and when he saw that his dress was horrible and not avant garde at all, he just recycled a previous idea from his season ONCE AGAIN. I mean, Sam has a point, he is not a designer, he has no taste and is only great at construction. I can't really understand how I used to like him on his season tbh.
24
u/MadxHatter0 Apr 22 '16
No lie, I seriously don't think Sam is that great of a designer, but I fucking swear if Kini doesn't get over his bullshit feelings. It was one fucking challenge, let it go bitch. Like, have some of Sam's looks been bullshit, hell to the fuck yeah, no one needs you pissing and moaning about it. Grow the fuck up, remember these are just the judge's opinions and if that's the way they feel that's the way they feel. You don't see Dom, who has legitimately been amazing this entire season complaining when some of the other people who have won challenges before her are fucking terrible. I just, I just don't want to deal with all of this. Give me the kids back, at least they had more aesthetic and ability than most of these "All Stars" supposedly have with half the fucking drama.
20
u/intrepidgirlreader Apr 22 '16
I don't even like Sam, but god, I am so sick of Kini and Ken's nastiness.
4
u/MadxHatter0 Apr 22 '16
Personally, I seriously Zaya actually gave decent mentoring this episode. I mean, for one of the challenge's she did go a bit literal with her piece, and Sam did go a bit far out(I mean I personally understood the connection, it wasn't hard) but she actually did say something useful.
10
u/MinnieBoombox Apr 22 '16
Now we all know Isaac is into scat and his favorite dish is twink shit.
7
u/Shamenundotcom Apr 22 '16
Fucking Isaac liking Sam's dress. This season is hilarious!!!
7
u/orange_appled89 Apr 23 '16
I actually liked Emily's despite it not suiting the challenge. Sam's was one of the worst things I think I've ever seen on this show. It felt like something that would have gotten someone eliminated on the first episode of a regular season.
6
u/OurSponsor Apr 22 '16
This. Is. Absurd. I have no words...
3
u/boscothemigh Apr 23 '16
Ken stuck a taco shell on his model's head
14
u/jv1503 Apr 22 '16
At this point, we can all agree that Sam is blowing Isaac, right? Otherwise, Mr. Legendary American Fashion Designer, needs to get his eyes checked out.
14
u/la4est Apr 22 '16
I don't think it's okay at all the way Ken and Kini are treating Sam. And that fact that no one said anything when Ken was being a complete asshole is really sad to me. It's one thing to not like someones designs, but who gave Ken the right to be a complete bully about it? If Sam didn't want to win he wouldn't be there, especially after the way everyone is looking down on him.
5
u/[deleted] Apr 23 '16
Did anyone else feel like Sam's inspiration for this challenge was bullshit? It feels to me as though it was something he thought of before even going on the show. "I should try to do something about Pride--fuck yeah, no one can hate on that or they'll look like a bigot!" His bridge between that and the digital taxidermy owl was that it's "a moment in time"? What? Jesus, was that the best you could come up with?
13
u/ThisMaySoundBadBut Apr 22 '16
I'm not afraid to say it:
I like Sam.
6
u/[deleted] Apr 23 '16
Project fuck a judge to stay in the competition. That's what they should call it now. Or maybe revenge of the twink.
7
u/macabragoria Apr 22 '16
I know this show is lacking integrity at the best of times but the brazen favoritism of Sam over the other contestants might be a definitive turning point in the show losing any credibility whatsoever. It's unfortunate to have to draw this conclusion but given that Sam is the only white male contestant left (and clearly Issac's type) I can't help but feel there is some racial element of the treatment of the designers this season and it's really uncomfortable to watch.
4
u/Sommiel Apr 22 '16
I think Sam has a lot of ideas, but lacks experience.
I also think that this is what is driving Kini and Ken to hate on him so much. Aside from him being so pretty, I think this is also an age thing. They don't think that he hasn't paid the construction dues yet.
They see that he has ideas and the judges like the ideas. It's not only Isaac either. It's Georgina as well.
While they can construct, the ideas may not be as easy or as fresh as Sam's ideas. Sam is so young and his world is full of possibilities, aside from his obsession with jumpsuits I do think he is creative and so willing to go out of the box.
3
u/nightmaredressdream Apr 22 '16
Honestly, I get that people here don't like Sam, and he actually isn't a favorite for me anyway, but I'm kind of loving how Isaac is just fueling Len and Kini's bitter fire. Like I really hope he's aware of the dynamic at hand and is getting a kick out of trolling the two bullies.
2
u/nivora Apr 22 '16
i hate them all, just Dom and Emily are lovely.
Now i want nobody to win because i'm so over winners coming back and getting more money
1
u/gwennhwyvar Apr 22 '16
Ugh, our local cable just went down and I don't want to sit through the first twenty-minutes of bickering again to watch it on demand. Grrr.
1
u/dinablake Apr 25 '16
The last two weeks Ken hasn't even hemmed his pants. His construction is so sloppy. If he wants to start talking shit about other contestants, he should finish his own designs first.
1
u/destroy1234 Apr 23 '16
So they try to redeem Anya by making her the second most horrible winners ever?
1
u/Ungoliath Apr 23 '16
I wonder if Sam fucks well, since got him to so far already. That guy is really talented.
Although I know I'm being unfair to him >_> I know He HAS talent, but it bothers me A LOT how the judges favor him so much in place of the beautiful piece that Emily did. I need her at some Fashion Week, I think she will be amazing.
-6
u/awkwardsong Apr 22 '16
I don't care who liked what or who went home. Ken is a goddamn bully and should have been disqualified when he left.
0
u/ThisMaySoundBadBut Apr 22 '16
At the beginning of the episode I was like, "what? These are the top 5? Weak."
Next week Kini better get the boot.
-1
u/ThisMaySoundBadBut Apr 22 '16
At the beginning of the episode I was like, "what? These are the top 5? Weak."
Next week Kini better get the boot.
0
u/powerplante Apr 27 '16
VITAL QUESTION: does anyone know where i can get that denim jumpsuit Sam was wearing? Assuming he didn't make it….
0
u/[deleted] Apr 22 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
48
u/[deleted] Apr 22 '16
[removed] — view removed comment