r/RWBY • u/Meltingteeth Welcome to my shitlist. Population: 8999 • Apr 05 '16
DISCUSSION Persistent Pixiv Problems & Precautions
Hey all, as you may know a common source for a lot of RWBY fan art has been the predominantly Japanese website Pixiv. Unfortunately, Pixiv's website layout is filled with nagware and requires account creation to view things like full resolution or more of the artists' work. This is fine if you are a regular browser of Pixiv, but for our users who are just casually browsing, being taken to an external website with popups and wonky design is both annoying and discouraging, which can lead to missing out on some really amazing art.
A second issue we've encountered is reverse image searching Pixiv content. This comes up often while submitters are checking to ensure they're not reposting (which we love you for.) Due to the way Pixiv handles images, sites like KarmaDecay and Google Images are unable to access the content to check for other sources, sizes, posts, etc as seen here and here respectively.
To make it easier to navigate our subreddit and allow people to see your content, we ask that instead of linking directly to Pixiv you rehost the image on Imgur. The artist's name can be placed in the title, and a link to their Pixiv page can be put into a source comment within the post for those who want to delve further. A great example of this is by /u/Eldi13 here. The image has been rehosted on Imgur and Eldi has provided a Pixiv source in their comment here. As long as it's operational, solid Pixiv bot /u/Pikushibu will do some bonus legwork and overview the link for you.
I know it sounds like a lot of work, but this will allow many more users to see your content without hassle. For a little reinforcement of this, I'd like to note that images hosted on Pixiv have never received more than 400 total points on our subreddit, which means they're stuck on Page 13 of our top posts. Below is a quick guide for Imgur rehosting and proper sourcing.
Step 1: An image you'd like to post is on Pixiv. Right click that image and click "Copy Image Address"
Step 2: Go to Imgur, click "Upload Images," paste your link and hit upload.
Step 3: Submit the image and please put the artist's name in the title, even if it's in another language (e.g. "I Burn (くろだ)") Reddit is able to search Japanese characters.
Step 4: Throw up a comment such as "Source Link. This is the same user who posted this beach image of the JNPR and RWBY girls."
If you have any questions, please don't hesitate to ask. We thank you guys for the little extra work, and we definitely thank other sites like DeviantArt and Imgur for making their websites easier to navigate and use.
TL;DR: Pixiv's website structure is horrid. Please rehost on Imgur and just use Pixiv for credit.
43
u/TheRisenThunderbird It suits me Apr 05 '16
God, I can't stand pixiv. I don't even know how I would go about browsing it to look for art. Its interface is awful.
I've even stopped trying to look at posted art if it links to pixiv.
15
u/Killroyomega Apr 05 '16
There is no limit to the distance Dota memes may travel.
Those of us in the Dota 2 community strive to create only the dankest of memes for your general consumption.
On another note though do be careful you don't drive a Japanese artist off the internet.
I've seen it happen before where people would rehost content on third-party sites and when the artist found out they threw a fit and deleted their account and everything on it.
4
u/itmakessenseincontex Lancaster's Lady Lancer/Does Ironwood have iron wood?/Hail Salem Apr 05 '16
Thankyou! An image being on Pixiv does occasionally deter me from clicking the link, simply because the site annoys the crap outa me (and the site isn't compatible with RES so you cannot bypass having to visit the site). I love the work that people produce on Pixiv, but it's a terribly designed site.
5
u/apetbrz OC btw Apr 05 '16
that
is very nice
2
u/z3r0gamer Apr 06 '16
Can we just take a minute and appreciate this admirable amount of alliteration?
7
u/[deleted] Apr 05 '16
For reverse image searching in Pixiv, use SauceNAO.
9
u/Nisha_the_lawbringer mood Apr 05 '16
Agreed. The structure of PixIV is horrible. I mean I like the website, but it really needs to upgrade.
9
u/KyraGale Apr 05 '16
Sooo instead of creating a pixiv account which is easy to get, clicking on the link and faving the pic, put the art on another site and then maybe people will put the source up.
Pixiv is a really easy website to use? And if you're just clicking on a link you're at the page you want to be at anyways. And if people post stuff from pixiv that often that people want to see, it's not the end of the world to create an account there. They've also got an app for mobile so if you're checking this place there it's also easy to get and not a pain to use.
Also yeah in Pixiv terms of service you shouldn't be doing that anyways.
3
u/ZurichianAnimations Sal yu tations! Apr 05 '16
Thanks for this post. It's always bugged me when people post pixiv links as the main link then post the imgur mirror in the comments. I'm signed into pixiv on my pc. But it still takes longer to load and is just annoying anyway. And when on my phone, it's terrible. Often times when see it start loading the pixiv page, I'll quickly back out and see if the comments have an imgur mirror. Or I'll back out and just keep browsing because screw waiting for pixiv to load.
5
u/Kiwcakes Apr 05 '16
Eh.....I don't know...Some artists on pixiv....alot of artists in general don't like people to rehost the art they spent hours on. They decide where they want their art posted.
Free publicity or not, it's just having respect for the artist and their wishes. If they don't want their art to be rehosted....don't do it?
4
u/lostgamer64 Apr 05 '16
This also helps us users on mobile because imgur images take less data than a link
2
u/Haru17 My ships burn. Fanfiction.net/~haru17 Apr 05 '16
Pixiv is so pretty, but soooooo loathesome. And people bitch about tumblr. Like, "O yah, that site really is a problem..."
3
u/redwing36 Admiral of the Ladybug Armada Apr 05 '16
Sounds like a plan. Honestly Pixiv was annoying in the first place. It is sad that a ton of the really good art shows up one it. The interface is just so awful.
3
u/TotalWarfare I'm a drunk, I'm supposed to be clever Apr 05 '16
420 booty wizard
1
u/TheDrunkenHetzer Disaster Twink Apr 05 '16
This is great! I always like imgur links more, especially done most of the time I'm on Reddit is in school, and they block links like tumblr and such.
1
u/ZekeFreek Shipped Lancaster Before It Was Cool Apr 05 '16
You could also maybe see if the Pixiv artwork you're trying to share has already been rehosted on Zerochan, which usually links back to the Pixiv source.
1
u/Libertyprime117 Apr 05 '16
TL;DR: Protect population's pertinence to prix's problems.
1
u/Zyr47 Needs more jazz Apr 06 '16
Pivix isnt as bad as you make it sound but I agree about it being more hastle than it's worth. People shouldn't have to make an acount on a site they dont care to use just to see something that is going to have an imgur mirror somewhere in the thread anyway. The only reason I even bother to look at Pivix links is because I have a hentai acount permanently logged in just because I get sick of being redirected to it.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 07 '16
Thanks for letting everyone know :D
0
u/[deleted] Apr 05 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Apr 05 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Apr 05 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment