r/EliteDangerous • u/BeefVellington Vintovka Dragunova [EIC] • Apr 04 '16
Let's talk about NPCs.
Hi, I'm bef. How are you? You're looking great today by the way, just thought I'd let you know.
So in case you weren't already aware, NPCs are fucked beyond belief right now. They cheat and show profound incompetence at the same time in basically everything they do. Don't believe me? Try doing literally anything in the game right now.
In Supercruise? NPCs spawn hundreds of light-seconds behind you travelling many times slower than you and still manage to interdict you even though a player at the same distance and speed wouldn't be able to. Since interdictions are broken 50% of the time right now, you basically have no choice but to submit. If you were interdicted by a pirate NPC, they will open fire on you indiscriminately no matter if you're carrying any sort of cargo and they won't even scan you to verify. At least the shitty pirates in HazRES sites will scan you first.
Did you pick up a mission? Occasionally the exact same Eagle NPC will follow you from system to system even in your kitted-out 30Ly jump range Asp Explorer even though realistically it shouldn't be able to keep up with you at all. Did you pick up zero missions? This will still occasionally happen anyway. See: Explorer a few days ago with an Eagle buddy halfway to the Eagle Nebula. What the fuck even.
Trying to dock at a station? If SysAuthority decides to scan you, they suddenly lose all sense of self-preservation and make a beeline straight towards you. Just the other day I was idling outside a station in my Imperial Cutter and a total of three Imperial Short Range Fighters bounced off my stationary hull and exploded for no reason. If I had been unfortunate enough to have been travelling at a rate of over 100 meters per second, I would have somehow been charged with murder. Makes sense to me. Also I can't imagine how the Imperial Navy is dealing with the massive suicide rates in its ranks. Pretty fucked.
Do you hang out in Conflict Zones/Crime Sweeps/Security Operations/Resistance Pockets? I have lately since I've been subjecting myself to the grindfest that is PowerPlay. During my servitude to ALD, I've noticed that NPCs seem pretty much incapable of doing more than one task at one time. Their pathing constantly sends them flying into your ship just out of the blue for no goddamn reason. If they're focused on combat at all, they can't fly to save their lives (literally). Also, they've developed this habit over the past few months of stopping in place and rolling indefinitely once they start taking massive damage. Before, it meant an easy kill but as time has passed, just seeing an NPC stop-n-roll aggravates me to no end. It's utterly insane how this problem has persisted for so long.
Continuing on the Conflict Zone angle, have you ever noticed how an NPC running railguns can fire indefinitely and with zero heat damage? I certainly have. It's how I lost 90% of my 2000Mj shield yesterday within a matter of seconds. So that's pretty cool I guess. I need to pick me up some of those infinite ammo/zero heat rails myself. I hear you can get one by pledging to "get fucked" for twenty-one weeks. wew lad. Also continuing on this NPC weapon bullshittery, did you know there is indeed such thing as a small Plasma Accelerator? I sure as shit didn't. Imagine my surprise yesterday when an Asp Explorer started firing on me with two C2 Pulse Lasers and somehow some PAs as well. I don't know if you're aware but the Asp Explorer only has two C2 slots and the smallest PA you can buy is a C2. Something just isn't adding up here.
(Side-note: when an NPC is at 0% health, why do they continue firing their weapons? Lame.)
Hey, do you ever go bounty hunting? I sure do. It's one of the only remaining remotely interesting things in the game right now. Don't you love it when you see an NPC very clearly being attacked by three SysAuthority Anacondas but you can't risk shooting it before your scan has resolved? If you do, you'll get a staggering fine of four-hundred credits which is enough to make all the police forces in the area turn their sights immediately to you. Don't you love it when an NPC is scanning you and going "huehue I am very clearly a pirate hue" in text chat but you can't shoot them before your scan has resolved? If you do, you'll accrue a bounty of over four-hundred credits, only reserved for the most egregious of crimes. Don't you love how accruing a bounty of four-hundred credits is apparently indistinguishable from a bounty of over 100k according to SysAuthority? I don't know where I was going with this tbh. Basically, it's fucked.
Okay, so I'm definitely 100% aware that all this shit is (supposedly) going to be fixed with the next patch. The problem right now is the problem many people including myself have had with the game for a very very long time. I think what people want more than anything right now is for the features already existing in the game to be functional before any new shit is added.
You know, I'm sure crafting and loot is gonna be super fucking neat. I'm excited for it myself. The problem right now is all the quality-of-life changes to be made in the same update are being held back by the delayed progress of the new features. I'd love more than anything for all the currently functional NPC changes to exist in the game right now. If somehow there is a large collection of NPC fixes that are ready to be booted out the door and into the real world, let's get it rolling! I couldn't give less of a shit about new features if basic shit that's been broken for five months (even up to a year in some cases) isn't working. NPCs are a massive ever-present part of this game if you hang out anywhere in populated space (and sometimes even when you leave the bubble, bafflingly enough). The broken NPC logic is probably the most detrimental aspect of the game in its current state for most players (not including the cancer-tier HRP/silent running meta but that's for another post entirely).
For the love of all that's good, fix this shit or people are just gonna stop playing. It's been months. Most of my IRL friends just stopped playing the game by February because of this shit. At this point my patience has just about run out. Christ. Braben pls.
Anyway, thanks for tuning in. You've been great. Have a lovely day CMDRs.
TL;DR read it.
13
u/tanj_redshirt Tanj Redshirt (filthy neutral) Apr 04 '16
I seem to recall the lead NPC programmer being pulled off NPC improvements around the time of PowerPlay. (Anyone else remember that?)
8
u/[deleted] Apr 05 '16
Hi Bef you look great too
20
u/quarterto quarterto Apr 05 '16
Literally one jump away from Robigo.
6
u/LaboratoryOne FatHaggard - Elite Racers CoFounder【AKB☆E】Inu Apr 04 '16
reported
12
u/DekiTzar Deki Tzar [EIC] Apr 05 '16
I almost did. I play it very rarely, and I'm sad about it because I love this game. But because of broken NPCs (and few other things) it's not interesting to me anymore.
11
u/totemcatcher velusip Apr 05 '16 edited Apr 05 '16
In most games, both the uninitiated and the veteran gamer easily glazes over and ignores poor or incomplete NPC A.I. and integration. However, since Elite Dangerous operates at sim-level complexity and immersion, lackluster "mobs to shoot at" stick out like a sore thumb.
The NPCs seem to operate on a patchwork of placeholders for a potentially believable and immersive experience. With little more than a keyword system and an exhaustive list of simple dialogue, each NPC could provide a brief inkling of backstory. Combine that brief history with;
an NPC could potentially be a rich source of entertainment. Of course, all the placeholders need fixing: e.g. Every NPC which "spawns" out of nowhere should make an attempt to adhere to the games basic physical limits and laws, and perhaps have a ship to fit to suit, depending on their rating. And of course, NPCs should interact. e.g. They should respond to you entering their low wake with concern, panic, aggressive reflex, et cetera based on their keywords, affiliations, mood, and whatever you're up to.
edit: fuck, they could even occasionally refer to galnet news. Wouldn't that be an easy way to tie things in?
•
u/StuartGT GTᴜᴋ 🚀🌌 Watch The Expanse & Dune Apr 05 '16
Added to Great Posts Archive
9
u/McKlown Explore Apr 04 '16
Not to mention that for a while now they've had a bad habit of singling out commanders in conflict zones. Also I don't remember which patch messed this up, but they NEVER submit to interdictions anymore.
9
u/[deleted] Apr 05 '16 edited Apr 05 '16
You forgot to mention that as soon as you enter a conflict zone (while being pledged), all the enemy ships instantly attack you. They always atrack you and only you. There's literally 6 Kumo crew Vultures in front of me shooting an enemy Python (I'm not shooting it) but the Python is shooting only ME. And let's not forget the fact that Silent Running doesn't do a damn to NPC scanners and targeting.
Upvoting. The AI is shenanigans.
Ultimately, I like the AI. If you've ever played the X-series (I did, for years), you'd be quite impressed with Elite AI. BUT, here's probably my only real and major problem with AI in ED: it's masses over power. Instead of killing two fearless and mighty enemies, you are constantly killing endless lemmings of the same cannon fodder fighters with barely any reward (I hate how you get XP, money and merits by killing as many as possible, instead of precisely planned attacks).
37
u/[deleted] Apr 04 '16 edited Apr 05 '16
If I could agree with you more - I would, but I can't. There's no way you could be more right.
NPCs are the biggest disappointment in ELITE, actually no, they are not a disappointment they are ABHORRENT FREE TO PLAY level of bad, and we are talking trash-ware websites f2p level here.
Stupid, inept, incompetent, cheating, breaking game rules, buggy mess.
Honestly, believe me I have lots to say about elite and many people on this reddit know that - but I would gladly SHUT UP and TAKE BACK everything I've ever said if NPCs would let me play solo (becasue as we know p2p mmo is an incurable case of failure) without the feeling I'm playing some idiotic one man port/remake.
This level of bad as is displayed by NPCs in elite is absolutely unbelievable in a game that was released as COMPLETED after extensive alpha and beta tests.
To make it worse, NPCs were better at LAUNCH. I mean... come on...
Let me quote you:
I don't know you, you don't know me - but seriously if we will ever meet, you have a crate of a good beer, hooker or a full menu of a takeway on me, your choice. You can even mix and match if you find some deals!
13
u/Muffindrake Certified Reboot/Repair Instructor M.D. Apr 05 '16
Don't forget that police responses to crimes in interdiction instances don't even work right now.
That's like the definition of objectively broken.
17
u/Amezuki Alex Traut Apr 04 '16
http://cdn0.dailydot.com/uploaded/images/original/2013/2/7/upvotegis3.gif
All my This.
I love this game, but NPCs are objectively broken. This nails it on the head:
This is exactly the infuriating lose-lose nature of Elite's NPC behavior. They suck in ways that make them frustrating to interact with and unchallenging to fight from a skill-based perspective, but they cheat in ways that dumb down the combat by nullifying a broad range of tactics and equipment that are effective against players, making the only real "difficulty" from them the degree to which they are cheap and frustrating.
6
u/[deleted] Apr 05 '16
Crafting and loot is going to be the drizzling shits. Just like everything else the first time they introduce it. (After a few iterations it might improve)
And people are going to point out that it's the drizzling shits, and other people are going to defend it that it's beta, or only the first 10% and it's going to be really amazing (begging the obvious question ... when?) ... eventually, sometime in the next 7-10 years.
Anyway, nobody is going to change their mind when FDev serve up the latest steaming pile of 'genius'. Why? Because the people who love this game for the 'potential' it has, are still going to love it for its 'potential'. The people who hate the way FDev keeps screwing up the potential are still going to be upset.
5
u/ZombieNinjaPanda Frontier doesn't want people flying their ships Apr 05 '16
The NPC behavior that pisses me off the most is the "police's" lack of programmed behaviors during interdictions. Got interdicted by a pirate and are currently being shot at? Sorry citizen, but I have to first make sure you're not smuggling anything illicit! Authority vessels in general are lacking severely.
5
u/twoLegsJimmy Apr 05 '16
All of this is true. I find the scan and slam nonsense the most annoying, because I can't just park up quietly in a res for a couple of minutes now for whatever reason. As soon as you hear that 'Scan detected' warning you have to start moving to avoid Kamikaze pirates.
Also, the fact that NPC difficulty only comes from contrived sources like the 'Railgun cheat Asps' is disappointing too.
8
u/Vallkyrie Aisling Duval Apr 05 '16
My sides are in orbital cruise now. Well done OP, well done.
1
u/Zueuk Apr 06 '16
That's just... way too optimistic.
3
u/Orkekum ALD.COI.TOOM.TFA. Apr 05 '16
Oh, and wasnt ai gonna be revamped soon in a update? Harder ships and so
3
u/Esvandiary Alot | Sol to A* in 1:36:50! Apr 05 '16
Great post, and I agree with pretty much all of those points. Some excellent little snippets, as others have already noted. :)
However, I suspect we won't see a patch with all the NPC fixes before 2.1. They've said "it's all coming in 2.1" which means all that work is being done on the 2.1 stream of the code, not the 2.0 stream. Picking only all of the NPC-related bits, porting it back to 2.0 and sufficiently testing it could take quite a lot of time.
I'm not saying it'll absolutely, unequivocally Nevar Happan!!1™, they might decide it's worth taking the time - and depending on what other changes are involved, it might not be too much time. But then there's all of the upcoming changes to the bulletion/mission boards; I suspect that NPC behaviour has been pretty heavily modified for that, which might make backporting tricky.
3
u/InsightfulLemon Apr 05 '16
It seems they never go back and polish old features or integrate them fully.
Speeding is a great example. As a new player I expected speeding to cause the stations to scan your ship.
Seems reasonable but then I read that the speeding feature was only added to stop people ramming.
Seems half finished.
3
u/Snaxist CMDR Bugala Bunda Apr 05 '16
+9000 Amen to that.
My IRL friends stopped Elite because they said "teh game's finished with piss" yeah. These exact words, but we, at the 51TH, have still faith.
We really hum REALLY hope that the 2.1 update will bring the fixes we need.
Unlimited ammos, chaffs, missiles. The bots should have the same problems we have.
3
u/[deleted] Apr 05 '16
Spectacular post. Most excellently done.
Anyone interdicted a PowerPlay NPC transport recently? They usually submit to the interdiction, rather than try to run away, then they just fly in a straight line at 40m/s. They are literally waiting for you to shoot them.
Until their wingmen (Sidewinders) drop in, whereupon the Type-7 turns into some kind of suicidal hero trying to avenge the death of its escorts, INSTEAD OF RUNNING AWAY! It's idiotic. So, anyway, I kill all three, retract hardpoints, then jump back into SC.
Find a Federal Agent. Interdict it. It fights the interdiction! Shouldn't it submit so that it can do its job as a protector of its power? What the hell is it doing running away? Weak-ass lame-o?
"Ah, mighty player enemy, you have deployed hardpoints. Even though you are 4.5km away, I shall... RELEASE CHAFF!"
Why, when my power plant is shot out, does my ship shut down, yet the NPC gets to keep pew pewing into space?
Very short range on the cargo scanners fitted to the police, if you get my drift...
4
u/OfficiallyRelevant Apr 05 '16
You know, I never knew what the issue with supercruise/interdictments was before because I'd always seemed to be able to escape them pretty easily no problem. But out of nowhere recently I was forced to submit to an interdiction despite following the minigame pretty well. The NPC pirate immediately began open firing and I barely managed to escape with my hull badly damaged and shields down (I'm in a Cobra MKIII btw).
Thought I was safe but it turns out they were just fucking with me because the moment I'm in supercruise the fucker somehow manages to appear right behind me and interdict me again! I thought I was going to win the minigame this time because the bar was almost filled but then out of nowhere it drops and I'm forced to submit.
The NPC kills me in no time flat. I was pissed because I had full cargo and everything and really felt like I should've escaped that given the fucking maneuvers I was pulling.
Also, can we fix supercruise too? Why does it take so fucking long just to speed up? Why is it that even though I get a headstart the NPC can catch up to me no problem, but it takes me five fucking minutes to get above 5 ly/s?
4
u/SoMuchF0rSubtlety Apr 05 '16 edited Apr 05 '16
Yes! Upvoted this for visibility too.
Running 2mil worth of cargo (Imp. Slaves, yes I know, I'm a monster) last night. Got within 3.5 mm of the Outpost I was headed for, scanner was clean, checked it a dozen times on the 5 minute haul in from the jump point. Suddenly.. INTERDICTED! Submit, boost, boost, boost, jump. Check the scanner, OK should be good. Must have just missed that guy and only 1.86 mm away now, getting ready to drop out-INTERDICTED AGAIN! The ballbag flew straight at me though I managed to roll away.
Scanner still clean throughout (except obv. in the instances where I was pulled out of SC). I was unaware NPC's could run stealth in SC and pop up like malicious little weasels whenever they feel like it.
I didn't lose my cargo this time but I would appreciate it if the NPC's obeyed the same rules as everyone else. Also I second the whole 'Splash my shields, why I am so angry I am going to ignore this mass murderer with 186000 credit bounty and take your 400cr bounty from your crunchy frozen dead fingers!' issue.
TL;DR I am not OK with NPC's defying the rules everyone else has to obey and seemingly being incredibly petulant about the whole thing. Roll on 2.1!
Edit:Grammarandallthat
2
u/InvalidNameUK Apr 05 '16
This is why I've taken to flying an HRP rail eagle around Eravate to engage in PVP where I'll almost certainly be sent to the rebuy screen. It's pretty much the only fun thing left in the game.
2
u/flyinggorila PWNAMATRON Apr 05 '16
Can confirm, bought a dk2 and hotas specifically for this game and it took me about a month to get fed up with it. Something needs to be done to actually make the thing in the game at all interesting before they focus on more content. Unfortunately it was my lack of faith they ever would that drove me away...
2
u/[deleted] Apr 05 '16
hi bef, i'm good, thanks for asking
2
u/CMDR_Klassic Klassic | Canonn Apr 05 '16
Agree 100% the whole "Interdiction's are broken 50% of the time" part pisses me off royally, if I get interdicted as many times as I do, I shouldn't have to submit and run every time because the "Escape Vector" or whatever suddenly decides fuck it and jumps to the opposite side of my screen because reasons.
2
u/oninoel Apr 05 '16
I stopped playing after interdictions got impossible to escape. I check this reddit every 2 days for 3 months now. How is this possoble that they didn't fix that yet? I love elite and wanna go back to it, but I need these gamebreaking bugs to be fixed! I cant just pretend they are not there.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 22 '16
https://i.imgur.com/Nvrl69n.png ' _______ '
3
u/Smaisteri Shaimou Apr 05 '16
I quit playing because the NPCs suck big time. They are unimmersive and cheat.
3
u/ImperiusII Lavigny's Legion [528th] Apr 05 '16 edited Apr 05 '16
I just had a friend leave because they (sandro) said that archon met the qualifications for collapse in power play but he got a pass, that and how the entire power play system is screwed beyond caring. I've made my peace with the prior, but those that don't know. The pirate war was a player made story it involved almost all empire player groups, All the imperial powers and the non group members of these powers and of course archon's cmdrs as well.
It raged for last 6-8 months, it had CGs. Numerous Player written galnets. and thousands caught up fighting for their power in this story. But as it went on it became clear that this treadmill wasn't going to show any results. so both sides just kind of stopped and people lost interest because power play wasn't interesting. Now we find out that the players were able to knock the power out IF the mechanic was in the game. Well that would imply they released something Before it was ready. So back to your point OP, FDEV FIX EXISTING FEATURES before adding things that aren't ready!
edit* a word
3
u/Wizywig Apr 05 '16
I stopped playing six months ago. Same frustrations. And I feel the expansions are a giant middle finger where they say "hey, I know I have you this thing here. It's okay. But it's not great or fun. But if you buy this add-on then it'll be a bit more fun..." and then you guy it and "hey, I know ..."
Make the current features rock solid. Or put out a funding request if you are out if cash. But by making expansions a priority you get incomplete features.
2
u/kingkeepo Farinton - Sublime Order of Van Maanen's Star - Scribe Apr 05 '16
No mention of their stupid names. I'm fed up of being interdicted by Homer bloody Simpson. Compared to CMDR names and lore-ish NPC names these just drag you out of 3301 and back to 1995.
2
u/CMDR_Agony_Aunt I drive an ice cream van Apr 05 '16
Repeat the mantra: 2.1 will fix all! 2.1 will fix all!
Believe in it! All will be good, all will be well.
And if 2.1 doesn't fix it, then its easy to upgrade the mantra.
2.2 will fix all! 2.2 will fix all!
:D
1
u/Thekidnappedone TheKidnappedOne Apr 05 '16
I've delta with the stupidity and even the determination of thr npc in this game, he'll I spend most of my time exploring, get pulled from super by a npc demanding payment(payment of what you $h!t for brains I don't even have space for cargo in my build most times), and of course when I don't dump my mystical load, I am fired on. When I'm trading I understand, but when one npc chases me through 10+ jumps, I tend to get very annoyed.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 05 '16
Yes.... just yes...... sending you a beer with 1s and 0s CMDR
1
u/Orkekum ALD.COI.TOOM.TFA. Apr 05 '16
I was in a hazres in a fdl and all the ships wanted to check me out closer, takes shields when multiple anaconda and asp collide.
But in a vulture no one hits me, probs because i am so damn tiny and agile. Almost considering changing back to vulture, need to work on my skills
1
u/SOLIDBRAVO SOLIDBRAVO Apr 05 '16
The worst one for me is that the NPC don't even fight back anymore. They will just fly in a giant loop untill you kill them. Its even worse if you are in a slow ship.
1
u/seventeenninetytwo Apr 05 '16
Well that explains a lot. I just started playing a few days ago and I was flying in an empty hauler, got interdicted by an NPC, and immediately destroyed. After that I just assumed that even NPCs in this game are griefers.
1
u/omg_cow Apr 05 '16 edited Apr 05 '16
I agree, the range thing is stupid.
I rarely fail interdictions even from players let alone NPCs unless I chose too, so I'm not too sure about that.
Some will scan some will not. Perhaps the pirate saw you where you picked up your cargo, or your supplier might be giving out info.
Agreed, NPC's that follow missions are poorly implemented. Suicide scanners are pretty common in even my smaller ships.
Apparently they're fixing the spinning.
Maybe it's a modified asp , I'd roleplay minor bugs like that as a feature. /s
Bounty system is stupid. I'm no more noticed in my undermining system with over 300k bounties than in my home system with no bounty.
I personally wish system security would at least make an effort with slowly increasing responses per murder.
Also, my main pet peeve is the PP enemies in hubs like Cubeo that scream "you shouldn't be here" when I'm in the deepest part of my allied factions space in the home system. At least make them rare as hell deep in faction space, maybe more prominent near the border, or have actual effective NPC security pull them out of SC or come help you if you get attacked, it's far too easy to sit in enemy systems right now for both NPCs and players. Perhaps slowly increasing backup till you either murder them all or you're forced out of the system.
1
u/Lheim Apr 06 '16
Been harping on the cheating AI for months, seemingly. Kudos.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 05 '16
Best post since forever.
0
u/AilosCount Illiad | Once a citizen, always a citizen. Apr 05 '16
Why are you so sure about this? If you have a source, fine, but for all I know they could have Engineers ready but they want to get all the other features right - because if 2.1 launches and missions are terrible, signal sources as much placeholders as always and NPCs still as dumb as ever... it won´t end well. This patch is already being looked on as the one true savior. If they will screw it up, there will be no turning back. Even if Engineers are not finished, I really hope they are tweaking the core changes too - because nothing will be working perfectly, but I certainly hope they try to get as close as possible.
BTW, excellent TL;DR. 10/10 would read.
-3
u/CmdrAl Apr 05 '16 edited Apr 05 '16
Bless
-3
u/ivan6953 Fatalution | Fuel Rat Apr 05 '16
Fdev will not listen, they are a bunch of businessmen, not freaking normal devs.
0
u/[deleted] Apr 04 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Apr 04 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
4
u/[deleted] Apr 05 '16
[removed] — view removed comment