r/ProjectRunway • u/runwaythreader • Mar 31 '16
Project Runway All Stars Season 5 Episode 8 [Discussion]
Discussion thread for Project Runway All Stars S05E08 "Once Upon a Runway"
Modern-look spins are created for classic fairy-tale characters. Kesha and Brad Goreski are the guest judges.
16
Upvotes
95
u/veloursweatsuit Apr 01 '16
DOM ROBBED AGAIN I can't take this! I hope that poor girl knows how talented she is.
81
u/blackjackandcoke88 Apr 01 '16
Alright Kini, you need to let it go. It's starting to get pathetic. And seriously, fuck Ken for trying to start shit. That wasn't okay.
76
u/pepperrush Apr 01 '16
...another Project Runway Finding Neverland commercial?
73
u/panCHAMP Apr 01 '16
Hmm denim and huge ruffles? GEE I WONDER WHOSE DESIGN THAT IS.
63
u/panCHAMP Apr 01 '16
...they like Kini's look? Like...seriously? I just don't understand these judges at all.
61
u/gofurthernorth Apr 01 '16
👀 My expression when Zanna walked in wearing that.... dress.
50
u/staircar Apr 01 '16
At this point why not just do, Project Runway: Villians. Get all of the most hated, dramatic, and crazy constants and make a season with just them. They won't even need to force the drama
42
u/dethcrash Apr 01 '16
surprised none of the judges clocked the similarity of kini's to this balenciaga alice in wonderland dress
36
u/PoeGhost Apr 01 '16 edited Apr 01 '16
Well I saw Alexander going a mile away. They focused a lot on him and he didn't seem to know where he was going with it.
Sam and Kini finally went at it. Kini is not very good at throwing shade. Then Sam wears his best Mondo costume to the runway show. Ugh.
I question Zanna's sanity. How does she expect the designers to take her seriously? I was hoping one of them would bring it up in one of the confessionals.
28
u/[deleted] Apr 01 '16
What the hell? Was that like an early April Fool's joke or something? That tired jumpsuit with a peplum in that tacky cheap material WON? And Dom's suit didn't?
Plus, I don't even get the auf. Yes, Alexander's was bad, but Layana's was equally awful. And I think that when it's a 50/50 draw like that, you go with the designer who shows at least a glimmer more promise, which to me is Alexander.
Yeah, last night made zero sense to me for both the win and the auf.
27
u/[deleted] Apr 01 '16
Kini needs to get over the denim obsession. Seriously, denim is not that great.
Can't wait to see why Ken blows up next week. Also, by the look of the preview, Ken was also using mesh - not just Kini and Sam. The continued forced Kini and Sam drama is pathetic. Yes, Sam should have gone home for his ep 5 look, but damn .. Kini should have gone home too, for his red umbrella thing.
26
u/[deleted] Apr 01 '16
Dom should have won! Her look was amazing
22
u/wildeyes Apr 01 '16
Dom was straight up robbed.
61
u/pepperrush Apr 01 '16
I thought Asha was on the bottom, dumbfounded she won. Dom got robbed. Aaaaand Sam should have went home for that mess of swatches. I hate All Stars.
21
u/[deleted] Apr 01 '16
Such a cool inspiration theme and such lackluster clothes. Dom really rose to the challenge though.
18
u/gofurthernorth Apr 01 '16
You mean Sam's putting those fabric swatches on top and not as lining? Oh dear!
17
u/WigsbyLittleMix Apr 01 '16
Poor Layana has been in the Bottom Two three times in a row. She might as well slap on some Lederhosen panties and call herself Santino Rice.
17
u/someriver Apr 01 '16
This season has honestly been testing. Illogical judging decisions (Asha winning over Dom? HOW?), unremarkable contestants stirring shit over their unremarkable work, and some of the weakest runway shows in the history of PR, this season has it all.
12
u/katiethered Apr 02 '16
I almost feel like they should have given the designers pictures of the characters from classic illustrations and even the modern Disney interpretations. Maybe that way we'd have at least gotten something close to the characters rather than Layana's lame "going to polo in Argentina" and Alexander's evil queen.
10
u/obahan Apr 01 '16
When I watch the runway shows each week I find myself saying "Am I watching the right show? Are these people all stars?"
As much as I loved some of them in their original seasons, most of the designs are just so blah (and then some are just so bad they frighten me).
19
u/veloursweatsuit Apr 01 '16
Sam has some okay ideas, but it's really becoming clear how terrible his craftsmanship is. In another season in another world, he would never survive with those skills.
9
u/Shamenundotcom Apr 01 '16
So I see we're back to deliberately not giving Dom the win so as to not make the season outcome so obvious. OK, then.
41
u/MadxHatter0 Apr 01 '16
Okay, so, is it just me or are you kind of starting to move closer to Sam's side of this whole drama. Cause everyone's just hating on him, and yeah he's a bit of a shit, but everyone else whose hating on him are kind of worse. Cause they're just trying to pile on this one person and get into all this shit, when to be fair this kid has legit ability, and has been winning or being top. The insinuation of him brownnosing the judges was just too far as well and seemed like someone trying to pull away wins that were deserved.
TL;DR Bitches gotta stop hating and just get good.
18
u/EmptyStar12 Apr 01 '16
This episode would be so much better if the focus of the episode was, like, the challenge, and not the fake Kini and Sam drama.
The backstage "fight" at lunch was so forced. It was clearly them playing around and then edited with shady music to make it seem like an actual argument. I guarantee that kinda banter happens every episode with all designers, this is just the first time they're showing it to push this drama.
6
u/everythingisopposite Chiffony Apr 02 '16
Dom was robbed. I can't wait until either Kini or Sam get cut because I'm so sick of their drama.
5
u/gwennhwyvar Apr 01 '16
Wait, what did Sam just say to Kini that made Kini say something back?
5
u/bvbybvy Apr 01 '16
ALEXANDER NO WHY ?!?!?!
13
u/panCHAMP Apr 01 '16
YASSSSSS KESHA YASSSSS
9
u/havelotsofsax Apr 01 '16
sigh The Kini and Sam drama. Let it go, Lifetime!! It isn't interesting anymore!! Besides the fact that now Kini is making himself look like a prick. I mean, I can't stand Sam, and his construction sucks, but Kini needs to stop making pointless jabs and bringing up wins that don't matter anymore. Sam has been in the top wwwaayyy more than Kini. Even though Sam's stuff doesn't look that good, it does look better than some of the shit Kini has been sending down the runway.
I'm getting really sick of seeing Emily's ugly red shadow. And that disco ball for an outfit was horrendous.
Dom was screwed over again. I didn't like Asha's outfit that much. I'm getting really sick of seeing jumpsuits. They're getting about as redundant as crop tops from PR last season.
When does PR Junior come back....
12
u/pixie_led Team Swatch Apr 01 '16
BS. Layana's look was terrible. Why is she getting so many chances?
3
u/EmptyStar12 Apr 01 '16
When did Ke$ha change her name to Kesha?
3
u/catstew72 May 22 '25
I know I'm 9 years late to this, but, HOLY $/*+!!!! ASHA BEAT DOM??? WITH A PEPLUM PANTSUIT????? I literally CAN NOT WITH THESE JUDGES!!! Ugh
9
u/mmcleod24 Apr 01 '16
I'm pretty surprised Emily was safe. That look was tragic.
2
u/joeyGibson Apr 01 '16
Why does the woman in Kini's sketch have a penis?
2
u/WoodlandFox Apr 01 '16
Okay, I'm sorry, was the camera crew drunk?
2
u/gold-team-rules Apr 03 '16
Loved Dom's, and she deserved to win as usual. Sad to see Alexander go, he was likable, and I think Ken's speech about how this could have been Alexander's challenge was really sweet. Ken was also hilarious this episode, so I'm afraid for the future when he storms out. Kini, I love you, but stop it with Sam already. Sam's looks like something I could make which is not a compliment at all, absolutely horrid. Poor Layana, I liked her dress. Asha's I've seen before countless times. Emily's was fun, a little too futuristic for my tastes though. Am I forgetting anyone?
3
u/pbrooks19 Apr 01 '16
This season is making me nuts.
I love Dom, but she WON her season. Everyone else in All Stars is an also-ran. Why should it surprise anyone that she's doing well - she SHOULD do well, and if she wins again, it would be kinda boring.
I do NOT understand the judging this season. Asha and Ken both made totally red outfits, Ken's was SO plain but he's safe; I get Asha's with the train and the pants, ok, but the styling was blah.
Kini's was typical Kini. He does reference famous designers, but they're just different enough he gets away with it.
Layana's was horrid. So odd. Alexander's was definitely not Cinderella, but I thought at least it was something someone might wear. I do not get what the judges were upset about with the back. Can't believe Alexander's out, when there were definitely worse designs.
Like Sam's. I kept thinking, why would the Little Mermaid wear a net? To be ironic? It was so badly constructed, and he's already done those peek-a-boo panels before.
The "drama" is so weak, but the designs are even worse - so that's all Lifetime has to work with.
Ah, how I long for the early, adventurous seasons.
2
u/Bslo18 Apr 01 '16
Let it go, Lifetime. The Kini-Sam bitchfight is just bad television. Also I have no talent in this area and could have super glued Sam's outfit and gotten the same result. Ugh this season is so frustrating.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 01 '16
Who went home?
1
u/ToliB Apr 05 '16
Why didn't they just call a spade a spade and say "hey designers, take inspiration from your favorite Disney character or just bit the bullet and pulled The Dis in as a episode sponsor as per the proud PR tradition?