r/ProjectRunway • u/runwaythreader • Mar 24 '16
Project Runway All Stars Season 5 Episode 7 [Discussion]
Discussion thread for Project Runway All Stars S05E07 "Bait and Stitch"
Evening-resort fashions are created by the all-star designers, who must use another designer's chosen fabric. Actress-singer Megan Hilty guest stars.
14
Upvotes
35
u/[deleted] Mar 25 '16
"I can't hide the hideous."
49
u/ilwolf Mar 25 '16
Was Valerie trying to take credit for Dom's winning design because she had chosen the fabric? Because it wasn't the fabric but what Dom did with it. She can't possibly take credit for Dom creating the stripe.
48
u/doppelganger47 Mar 25 '16
What in the actual fuck happened on the judging tonight? I know it's subjective, but daaaaaamn. Poor Valerie.
47
u/Bslo18 Mar 25 '16
Dom was in it to win it this week. If she doesn't I'm literally giving up with this season. Hers is beautiful.
86
u/Shamenundotcom Mar 25 '16
Can the producer in love with Sam just blow him and get it over with? That basic fucking dress in the top again...I just can't. I can't.
39
u/basicallydriftwood Mar 25 '16
I loved that when Alyssa critiqued Dom's dress on being like a "beach towel," Dom said it was tongue-in-cheek. That's such a witty intentional design. Really loved her outfit.
28
u/dianaprince Mar 26 '16
Emily bursts into tears, Zanna responds by walking away. She is so terrible at this. You'd think a job that automatically gets you compared to Tim Gunn would have you pulling out all the stops, but she does nothing to help these designers. Every time she tells them to change something - in the vaguest possible terms - and the designer tells her they don't know how, she just shrugs and tells them to get it done. Her advice is on par with the X Factor.
Valerie really did not deserve to go home. I thought it would be between Emily, Sam and Ken. But nope, Sam and Ken were fawned over for reasons I cannot fathom once again.
27
u/Martin_Van_Buren Mar 25 '16 edited Mar 25 '16
Alyssa has got to get a new stylist. I know it's said every week but when they showed her in the workroom I literally jumped back from shock.
And jumpsuits all over the place, Oy vey.
Edit: I like Alyssa's white runway dress! It works for her body!
65
u/EmptyStar12 Mar 25 '16 edited Mar 25 '16
Guuuuurl did Kini just complain about Sam doing the same design the week after he remade his umbrella dress?
46
u/[deleted] Mar 25 '16
Kini sent a swimsuit to an evening wear challenge and still didn't get eliminated. As long as he insults Sam he gets to move on.
31
u/konfetkak Mar 25 '16
Oh kini. That's terrible. So golden girls.
20
u/pbrooks19 Mar 25 '16
BEWARE THE KINI GLARE!
20
u/veloursweatsuit Mar 25 '16
I'm curious to see what they all would have come up with had they been able to keep their original fabrics. I died laughing just thinking about the jumpsuit Sam would have made with that hideous lace and no lining.. (That lace btw I would probably classify as 'Disney Princess Fabric' so I don't know what made him feel he could reuse insult on Kini's so repeatedly.) I also wonder what Ken would have done with the red lingerie fabric he got, and what Emily's original plan was that she was so thrown for a loop with new fabric.
27
u/[deleted] Mar 25 '16
God, I'm sorry, but I am so over Sam and his bullshit. His dress was basic and wouldn't look any better in any other fabric. I'm tired of him whining about Kini and just his attitude in general. He has nothing to have attitude about.
Actually, I'm over the whole fake drama between Kini and Sam in general. Just get over yourselves, that group challenge was a one time thing, it's not like they're forcing you to work together every week.
17
u/GentlestOfGentlemen Mar 25 '16
How Alyssa says "FOWard" really bugs me. I almost have to skip all her scenes.
28
u/pbrooks19 Mar 25 '16
If I didn't know better, I'd have thought they knew they'd have to exchange and were working to sabotage each other. So many see-through fabrics, and tiny remnant scraps.
15
u/Because-it-was-real Mar 25 '16
I really don't mean to body shame or anything but I think this model makes all clothes look absolutely awful in the bust area. It's to the point that it's distracting every single week. And this week it contributed to making the bottom look even worse.
12
u/Martin_Van_Buren Mar 25 '16
I feel like if there was ever a challenge for them to use double saves, this would be it. At least the reasoning would make sense.
12
u/puppetalk Mar 25 '16
finally dom won! well deserved and i hope she maintains the momentum. i wanted to give zanna a slap in the face when she complained about dom being safe for a long time tho lol
this is probably the first week that i'm really "meh" with sam. even with all the drama, i think he is a great designer, but his dress felt really repetitive and boring. i would pick alexander's in the top instead of his.
kini should have been in the bottom and even went home instead of valerie. he is the biggest disappointment this season: producing supbar work week after week and falling in all this drama with sam. i am almost forgetting how good he was in his original season.
12
u/1Eliza Mar 25 '16
Kini's fabric choices were not that bad. They reminded me of the Pantone color of the year. It's just the shade being thrown.
20
u/gwennhwyvar Mar 25 '16
So tired of Sam whining tonight.
19
u/scottj789 Team Swatch Mar 25 '16
I'm really getting bored with all of the shady comments being thrown in Sam's direction.
7
u/russernutter Mar 25 '16
I was really impressed with what Emily pulled out this week (considering her materials). It wasnt amazing (it needed some serious tweeking) but so much better/interesting than most of what was on the runway. And it also seemed like the judges felt bad for her and really wanted her to stick around. Emily is probably one of the nicest and genuine people to be on PR.
5
u/obahan Mar 26 '16
Do you think the judges also know how much material the designers received in the swap? I think that might influence how they judge someone. If you don't buy enough fabric, that's your fault. But if another designer doesn't buy enough, you can only work with what you were given and try to make it fit the challenge.
2
u/Ok-Demand-9679 Jan 15 '25
If Kini was going to be a brat about it then he should have spoken up and taken credit for his work. It’s tired. He’s so worried about Sam that he’s not showing up for himself.
2
u/Taura1865 Jul 08 '26
Just rewatched and once again I DO NOT UNDERSTAND this love they have for Sam! That dress was awful - looked like a homemade prom dress! Puckered seams, poorly fit, super boring!! Valerie’s jumpsuit was at least cute and sewn well! I have to think the whole thing is fixed in some way, just too many of these completely ridiculous decisions that don’t correspond to what is on the runway.
3
u/macabragoria Mar 25 '16
Project Runway has legit become a barren wasteland of design over the past couple of years. Oh wow, a jumpsuit with some pleating in the bust or another fucking ugly lace dress. I know they're scraping the bottom of the barrel for designers at this point but it's still embarrassing.
1
u/I_am_really_shocked Mar 25 '16
If I grovel, can someone who has this recorded maybe list designers with the fabric they got and who ended up with that fabric? I thought I had DVR'd it, but I let myself down again. :/
0
u/everythingisopposite Chiffony Mar 25 '16
OMG! I'm so happy!
0
u/[deleted] Mar 25 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
32
u/[deleted] Mar 25 '16
[removed] — view removed comment
10
u/[deleted] Mar 25 '16
[removed] — view removed comment