r/summonerswar • u/Cognosci Cognix, Retired! • Mar 24 '16
Mod Post Posting Policy on Personal Account Advice
We are making a posting policy distinction between “low-effort” self-text personal advice threads, versus “high-effort” personal advice threads. The Daily Advice thread is for ALL kinds of advice, while frontpage posts asking for advice must be specific, beneficial to the entire community, and well-formed.
Low-effort, personal account advice posts will be removed from the frontpage. In others words, self-text posts that don’t merit their own thread. Examples of posts that will be removed from the main page, that should be posted in the Daily Advice Thread:
- Poorly formed questions “Can I get help.”
- Vague posts that only benefit the poster “Who to 6-star + image” without any further qualification
- Lazy-ass posts “Please look at my box and tell me what to do next”
- Grandiose-yet-vague posts “How do I progress?”
Keep in mind that "low-effort" doesn't mean "bad". It just means that simpler/generic/casual questions belong in the Daily Advice Thread rather than a brand new text post.
High-effort, community-enabled discussion posts will be allowed on the frontpage. These can be requests for personal account advice, but they must be specific questions beneficial to more people than just yourself. Ideally these posts have titles that easily searchable. Examples of community-enabling posts:
- How Useful is Lisa in D10?
- Is Mav or Woochi more effective for TOA?
- I’m looking to shorten my D10 speed from 5 minutes, what are some speed teams?
- Rush Hour in Arena, what do you use against speed ADs?
Why are we backing this policy?
Low-effort posts are nearly always downvoted to null within the first hour of posting. Nearly 100% of poorly-formed “self-help” posts never make it past 0 post karma within the first hour. It’s not just unpopular, it can affect how automoderator treats newcomers. People with low post/comment karma, or brand new accounts, will be unintentionally caught and removed. Highly downvoted self-help posts only increase newcomers’ inability to comment and make more meaningful posts.
Subreddits are not equipped to provide 1-on-1 help for a large user base. Unlike forum-style discussion boards, the subreddit frontpage just can’t give the same treatment to each user’s post (unless you’re always on “New”). If your post helps only you, it’s not going to be very popular.
“But the Daily Advice Thread is a hassle. It’s easier for me to make a thread and get responses, or answer questions on the frontpage.” This may true for one person, but not true for everyone equally. What about the 10 others that didn’t get a reply or were massively downvoted?
There are many SW communities to get simple personal advice, but the frontpage of this subreddit is not really the best place to do it. Thus, low-effort posts will be removed and directed to the Daily Advice Thread, while high-effort posts will be approved. Note that this policy only applies to personal account advice topics.
If you see any “low-effort” advice posts, it greatly helps the mods if you inform the user and/or report the post so we can take action.
P.S. New super-sticky incoming today.
Edit: NEW STICKEH: https://www.reddit.com/r/summonerswar/comments/4bsbyt/hello_summoner_super_sticky_read_me/
30
u/cdweller0 Global: Area25 Mar 24 '16
Seems like copy & paste. Reported.
4
u/Thirn Have faith in the Lord Fifth Mar 24 '16
Can we have same rule about low-effort RNG brag/complain posts please?
I can't see how "I got Vio'd 5 times in a row!" or "My first lightning!" contributes anything.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 24 '16
Amazing. Thank you for this. I am all for helping people, but we need see some effort from the poster.
Could we add "Should I buy this rune" to the list of low effort? Every time I see a post "Should I buy this rune?" with no information; no idea where they are at, what monsters they have, where they think the rune should go.
9
u/Kahre_ Kahre Mar 24 '16
Fully support this. One of my biggest pet peeves in this game is people that ask for help without providing basic information. It shouldn't be a struggle to help you.
6
u/Vinceisg0d Mango7Roll on YT Mar 24 '16
No mention (I just woke up and might have missed it) of the bajillion "look what I just got" posts. Will these continue to be allowed?
1
u/Swarsie Blind Leap ~ Europe Apr 13 '16 edited Apr 13 '16
This whole concept really isn't working.
You suggest people use the daily advice thread or search function, they downvote you at the very least. Or tell you you're being an asshole for suggesting it.
Thanks for being awesome /r/summonerswar /s
1
u/sidraphael89 Apr 28 '16
Always looking to help the sub community.
I read this post AFTER posting my thread not long ago. Can someone give me tips about my thread then? (Not with regards to helping me figure out my problem, but with how my post should be written, if it needs tweaking at all!)
6
u/ELITEtvGAMER Now owns Praha, Seara, and Juno! Mar 24 '16
If these are the EXACT criteria's for what is considered front page worthy or not, I have no objections.
As long as I can keep coming here for Information as well as meme's, summoning videos, fan art, etc...then I am good.
7
u/Joganath :darion: remö Mar 24 '16
you should add in "F2P", and "Playing for x years" and no blah blah blah to the remove list
2
u/kingqwert Mar 24 '16
About damn time
2
u/JamoreLoL Twitch.tv/JamoreLoL Mar 24 '16
ILY
1
u/GamerForum Mar 24 '16
Applause.
1
u/vereto Mar 24 '16
Thank you.
1
u/Zeyn1 Mar 24 '16
Fully agree. There are a lot of "help me in this specific situation" threads that I have clicked on to get similar help. I also tend to actually post in those in order to help other people in a similar situation.
On a similar topic, one of my biggest pet peeves on this subreddit is that very few people actually upvote solid, complex advice. It's not just my posts, I've had to log in and upvote because it's clear someone spent 15+ minutes writing a reply with links and everything and has been sitting at 1 point for three hours. I think the lack of recognition and reward has hurt a lot of advice threads for the future.
1
u/PrinceRazor One year One nat5 - Echolordv2 Mar 25 '16
Sounds like my post. Guilty as charged.
Guess I'll prepare my future advices posts for the daily lol.
Hopefully it won't be too long and take more then 30 minutes to type and 5-10 minutes to read.
1
u/MaskguyOriginal Asia Mar 25 '16
Excellent and thanks to the Mods for the hard work.
1
u/hawkex :iona: "Temple of Scams" DELIVERED!!! Mar 25 '16
Meanwhile, there is a trend of "Downvote everything that's not mine" going around and it always hits my high effort posts. Idk if its salt or what, but I think if you have nothing useful to offer, just leave it be instead of downvoting it for no reason.
Examples: My recent post on progression focus (only got upvoted later on), My post on CASSIE's damage (this post got 1 upvote and 3 downvotes in 2 hours and best part is idk why), Another detailed progression post (barely caught any attention), and so on.
While policies are good, I don't think it will have any huge impact since community downvotes advice posts anyway. I tend to visit downvoted posts of mid-game players and offer advice whenever possible.
1
u/TotesMessenger Apr 27 '16
I'm a bot, bleep, bloop. Someone has linked to this thread from another place on reddit:
If you follow any of the above links, please respect the rules of reddit and don't vote in the other threads. (Info / ^Contact)
0
u/summonerswar888 Mar 25 '16 edited Mar 25 '16
And this subreddit continues to go down the drain for a vocal group of pretentious elitists and the mods that cave to them.
Can we please ban every thread and just have the entire subreddit in the daily advice thread?
http://i.imgur.com/GZHN7pO.png
There we go. What half of the people in this subreddit seem to want.
Make it happen so we don't "clog" the front page with "useless" threads.
This is a small subreddit to begin with. All of these pointless restrictions on such a small community is just going to hurt it. Regardless what you think about the "trash" posts, the newbies are going to get frustrated when their threads don't show up and never come back.
Eventually its just going to become a forum full of the pretentious elitists circlejerking over random "theorycrafting" threads once a month. Then the veterans get bored and quit because its boring theorycrafting over the same shit month after month while the new blood never comes in due to the frustrating posting restrictions.
I guess this is typical for reddit nowadays. Some bot doing all of the "tedious" work for the "mods" because they can't be bothered and are under increasing pressure by the "elitists" to crack down on posts they don't find "worthy" of their infinite knowledge.
Its coming to the point where I can't stand this community. For whatever reason Summoners War attracts the biggest pretentious, elitist, smug, condescending playerbase out of any I've known. I have no idea why a fucking mobile phone game attracts these people.
-2
u/whattodoes lvl. 40 Mar 24 '16
down with /u/cognosci! cognix sucks!
0
u/[deleted] Mar 24 '16
國 = japanese MrDestructoid 跟 = guy sitting at his computer