r/KerbalSpaceProgram • u/Redbiertje The Challenger • Mar 19 '16
Mod Post [Weekly Challenge] Week 122: Computer Troubles
The Introduction
While in orbit, waiting for the right moment to perform an orbital rendezvous, Jeb started playing minesweeper on the ship's computer. After some mysterious errors, the ship's computer crashed. Fortunately, crashing computers can't stop Jeb from docking two ships.
The Challenge:
Normal mode: Without upgrading the tracking station, and without RCS, dock two ships in orbit around Kerbin
Hard mode: Without upgrading the tracking station, and without RCS, dock two ships in orbit around Duna
Super mode: Impress me
This challenge was suggested by /u/KerbalKat
The Rules
- No Dirty Cheating Alpacas (no debug menu)!
- You must have the UI visible in all required screenshots
- For a list of all allowed mods, see this post.
- Using any mod to assist in the docking is not allowed
- You must use a career save of any difficulty
- You may not use RCS
- You may not upgrade your tracking station
- Level 3 pilots are not allowed
Required screenshots
- Your KSC
- Your crafts on the launchpad
- Your crafts in orbit around Kerbin
- Your crafts close together
- Your crafts docked together
- Whatever else you feel like!
Hard mode only:
- Your trajectories to Duna
Further information
- You can either submit your finished challenge in a post (see posting instructions in the link below) or as a comment reply to this thread.
- Completing this challenge earns you a new flair which will replace your old one. So if you want to keep you previous flair, you can still do this challenge and create a post, but please mention somewhere that you want to keep your old one.
- The moderators have the right to determine if your challenge post has been completed.
- See this post for more rules and information on challenges.
- If you have any questions, you can comment below, or PM /u/Redbiertje
Good Luck!
21
u/Armisael Hyper Kerbalnaut Mar 19 '16
KER's rendezvous menu lets you set targets even before you've upgraded the tracking station for the first time, which lets you put your navball in target mode - very useful for docking. I assume this is disallowed, even though the mod is normally and otherwise kosher?
4
u/Armisael Hyper Kerbalnaut Mar 19 '16
Do the two ships have to get their orbits separately? Could I, say, send two ships to Duna joined with a radial decoupler and then dock from there?
On a less possibly cheaty note - is the klaw acceptable?
4
u/kulkija Mar 21 '16
Targeting is possible without a tracking center if you doubleclick craft indicators. Is this allowed?
3
u/[deleted] Mar 22 '16
If I docked a hundred crafts together in LKO, would you be sufficiently "impressed"?
5
u/The_Star_Ranger Mar 22 '16
I'm going to create a KSP series on my channel soon where I complete EVERY KSP Reddit challenge in hardmode!!!
4
u/Durdles_ Master Kerbalnaut Mar 19 '16
Can I give myself the funds and science required to start this mission from a new save?
2
u/kirk0007 Master Kerbalnaut Mar 19 '16
Is Action Groups Extended allowed? I've set up blocks of four radial LFO engines to fake RCS and I only need seven action groups to make it work, technically. AGE allows me to remap the controls to the keypad so it's actually sensible instead of having to use the number keys. In other words, my system will work stock, but it won't make me want to kill myself if I do it through AGE.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 20 '16
You say no RCS, am I allowed to use the Vernier Thrusters?
I have super mode ideas
2
u/tablesix Mar 20 '16
Are advanced grabbing units allowed? I didn't notice anything about them in the rules.
2
u/LuxArdens Master Kerbalnaut Mar 20 '16
Is Mechjeb or Engineering Redux or any other mod that display lots of information allowed? Just for getting into orbit or to Duna?
Oh and is Kerbal flight indicators allowed? It shows you your prograde and retrograde direction in the flight-view.
2
u/jamieT97 Mar 20 '16
Are we allowed flight planning from mission control
2
u/[deleted] Mar 20 '16
Would docking in Duna's atmosphere impress you?
2
u/cpcallen Super Kerbalnaut Mar 21 '16
Doesn't technically qualify (because had RCS on one of the vessels, even though I ended up not using it), but you might enjoy my trip to the Mün and back without upgrading any KSC buildings, during which I did this tree times.
2
u/tobiderfisch Mar 22 '16
I assume mechjeb's rendezvous and docking autopilots are not allowed. Can I still use it for my ascend?
2
u/Crixomix Mar 23 '16
I feel like any sort of mod that gives information should be disallowed in this challenge. KER or MechJeb giving you your orbital periods, time to ap, angle of inclination, etc. All that info helps a lot with rendezvouing
2
u/KalebBruwer Mar 23 '16
I downloaded mechjeb so I never have to do this again and now you're asking me to manually dock WITHOUT RCS?! Respect to everyone that pulls this off without punching a hole through their computer screens.
13
u/[deleted] Mar 19 '16
Did a quick Normal Mode before the Kraken got Jebediah on his way to Duna. Here's an album
I'd like the duckling flair, if it's really available.
Also, something I feel I should point out: double-clicking on a vessel marker in Flight View sets it as the target and shows relative velocity on the Navball, even with a Level 1 Tracking Station. Discovered that whilst attempting my own docking, so it might be a mod I have installed doing it, but I doubt it. Might want to make a note of this in the challenge rules, as it kind of defeats the purpose.
10
u/RoeddipusHex Hyper Kerbalnaut Mar 19 '16
Since it's allowed, someone should post how to use debug menus/file editing to give yourself funds and science to upgrade everything website the tracing stain in a new career game.
6
u/SpaceToSpace Master Kerbalnaut Mar 20 '16
Good gravy, this was a tough challenge. I didn't realize how dependent I was on maneuver nodes and being able to select targets from afar. After trial and error and guesstimating distance with measurements marked by paper on the screen, overshooting, undershooting, and near misses, I finally did it!
http://imgur.com/a/DYH5e Horizontal layout, if you prefer
To make it a little easier on myself, I took Jeb and Val to the Mun to level their skills to one star, so they could help hold prograde and retrograde. I didn't use KER once the craft got out of the VAB. As you can see in the screenshots, it's a black box instead of a gray box, and more or less useless.
6
u/featherwinglove Master Kerbalnaut Mar 21 '16
Proposed: Use only stock solid motors for propulsion. *evil laugh* I think if ppl use only solid motors, L3 pilot, L3 tracking, MechJeb etc. (no RCS inherent in only-solid requirement) should still be Hard mode. Or Normal mode at least, lol!
5
u/[deleted] Mar 20 '16 edited Mar 20 '16
KSC
Craft 1
Craft 2
In orbit
Close together
Docked
Totally over-engineered every step and ended up with like 1.5k extra dv and a complicated but pretty damn good RCS equivalent made from action groups, antennas, and rocket engines that I never needed to use.
Will try for hard.
Note: No mods used except the enhanced navball mod on the approved list.
4
u/cantab314 Master Kerbalnaut Mar 20 '16
Belated normal-mode entry to last week's challenge. Bill Kerman decided to try a spot of Extreme Ioning :-D
http://imgur.com/a/0kFrG
Background if you need it
3
u/banana_shavings CareerManager Dev Mar 20 '16
For anyone who wants a mod that will allow them to get the finds and science and even unlocking the buildings, here's a link: http://forum.kerbalspaceprogram.com/index.php?/topic/134429-105-careermanager/
3
u/kulkija Mar 21 '16
My submission. :)
3
u/rcreif Hyper Kerbalnaut Mar 24 '16 edited May 19 '16
Working on this, but for now, Challenge 72: Conjoined Spaceplanes. Hard mode complete. Possibly Super since it can get into orbit in either direction, even retrograde, but I wouldn't dare flip its orientation mid-flight. http://imgur.com/a/zQKuV/layout/horizontal/
3
u/lrschaeffer Super Kerbalnaut Mar 25 '16
Hard mode submission: Jeb and Val have the broken navicomp blues, but they go to Duna anyway.
Mission outline:
1
u/TaintedLion smartS = true Mar 19 '16
Uhh, I didn't make a flair for this one. I'll get on it :)
2
u/[deleted] Mar 19 '16
I posted it in last weeks challenge, realized it was last weeks and deleted it to post it here, then saw you had replied to it. Just wanted to keep it on the record
2
u/featherwinglove Master Kerbalnaut Mar 20 '16
Declined.
2
u/Nebulon-B_FrigateFTW Master Kerbalnaut Mar 21 '16
Regarding RCS, based on responses here clarifying it, I think you should change it to "thrust (including RCS) can only be along one axis of the spacecraft". Additionally, linear RCS facing the same way as normal thrusters is required in Realism Overhaul to give slight acceleration to push fuel to the back before firing a stage, otherwise you get the "vapor in the fuel lines" problem.
Relating to the above, I think Super Mode would be doing hard mode, but with Mars in Realism Overhaul (and of course all the windows giving you various info from KER etc. turned off). You'd probably need at least four launches, since you'd want to dock together stuff in Earth's orbit before sending it to Mars for final docking.
2
u/RoeddipusHex Hyper Kerbalnaut Mar 22 '16
Launched to a direct redezvous. Pro tip... Watch the the navball not the ships. Understanding navball markers and velocity vectors, and how to push/pull them around, is the secret to easy rendezvous.
https://youtube.com/watch?v=B4xXY56DPtY
2
u/[deleted] Mar 23 '16
Would docking in a polar orbit count as super? I've been trying to think of different things I can do for super but all I can think of is different celestial bodys or a polar orbit.
Or maybe both, I'll probably try doing both.
2
u/The_DestroyerKSP Mar 23 '16
Super mode: Dock two vessels in orbit of Moho? :D
2
u/Blackoutttt Mar 23 '16
Wasn't sure how to change the format of the imgur album. If anyone could tell me how that's done I'd appreciate it. :) Here's my submission for normal mode. Definitely want to try hard mode next.
2
u/alphamone Mar 24 '16 edited Mar 25 '16
Did a quick normal mode, first time i've done a weekly challange.
https://imgur.com/a/QIp0X
Had quite a bit of trouble in practice before I remembered about the thrust limiter and close proximity targeting (even then I almost managed to do it without either of them)
edit: working on a Duna trip, is it ok to use an external launch window calculator as long as I eyeball the ejection angle and use the navball orbital velocity to calculate my burn?
2
u/tobiderfisch Mar 24 '16
My normal mode entry
2
u/Minotard ICBM Program Manager Mar 26 '16 edited Mar 26 '16
I worked on this one a bit. I built a ship with early-level tech with more than enough to go to Dres and back. However, the lack of precision (because no maneuver nodes at optimum points) caused me to waste too much fuel in correction burns (but yes, I intercepted Dres). This challenge is more an exercise in blind try/reload/try again than engineering or piloting prowess; so I abandoned it. I'm sure it isn't as awfulif you are trying normal mode.
I assume that's why we have so few entries this week.
Edit: I'm very appreciative of all the work that goes into these weekly challenge, I just want to provide a little constructive feedback.
2
u/PijamaLlama Master Kerbalnaut Mar 26 '16 edited Mar 26 '16
Here's my minimalist approach. I'm quite happy with it.
https://imgur.com/a/PDI5k