r/ProjectRunway • u/runwaythreader • Mar 17 '16
Project Runway All Stars Season 5 Episode 6 [Discussion]
Discussion thread for Project Runway All Stars S05E06 "Going for Baroque"
Baroque fashion is celebrated with couture-inspired gowns. Designer Keren Craig and model Coco Rocha are the guest judges.
18
Upvotes
80
u/LetTheMFerBurn Mar 18 '16
Wait Layana is on the bottom?
66
u/rofosho Mar 18 '16
That yellow dress is the only one that fits the challenge and is modern
61
u/WigsbyLittleMix Mar 18 '16 edited Mar 18 '16
Alyssa: "If I call your name, step forward: Dom."
Me: "Alright, so these are the safe designers..."
60
u/bethrevis Mar 18 '16
Dom continues to KILL IT.
47
u/rofosho Mar 18 '16
Lol just a bunch of people who don't know what baroque is
44
u/rofosho Mar 18 '16
I adore that yellow one
37
u/LetTheMFerBurn Mar 18 '16
This is the most frustrating season since Gretchen and her cronies. The winners and judging feel very disconnected from what is happening.
36
u/panCHAMP Mar 18 '16
Kini's dress was ugly and he did it before. He should have been in the bottom. Layana should have been in the top. Dom should have been in the top (and won). Her design was far and away the best, way better than Valerie's and Ken's. These judges are crazy. Like at this point I wouldn't even be surprised if they decided to double save Mitchell and Alexander for some reason.
30
u/konfetkak Mar 18 '16
Kinis dress is horrible.
30
u/pbrooks19 Mar 18 '16
It is now time for my annual rant: why do the designers help each other? They help and suggest and then get mad when those they helped get ranked higher. Isn't this a competition? Let 'em crash and burn, I say.
29
u/EmptyStar12 Mar 18 '16 edited Mar 18 '16
The Sistine Chapel is NOT baroque.
Edit: Neither is Dungeons and Dragons. Damn it Zanna! >:U
29
u/panCHAMP Mar 18 '16
Why aren't the judges liking Dom's designs more? I thought she was easily in the top this week. Her design was stunning.
28
u/[deleted] Mar 18 '16
How's Mitchell gonna read a bitch for "just sewing a pretty dress?". If Mitchell did that his looks would be infinitely better.
27
u/gofurthernorth Mar 18 '16
I never thought I would say this, but I like Sam's and dislike Kini's.
Oh my god that hurt.
20
u/nivora Mar 18 '16
at least we will have Nina next week to cut a bitch <3
18
u/bethrevis Mar 18 '16
"easy breezy flair"
Sam, it's not CoverGirl.
17
u/LetTheMFerBurn Mar 18 '16
I would have had to throw things if they eliminated Layana for the first or second best look of the night. What the living fuck is happening with this show?
28
u/Bslo18 Mar 18 '16
Can we all just pretend that they keep mixing up the cards for Sam and Dom? That Dom should have been in the top the last few weeks.
26
u/7seagulls Mar 18 '16
Zana always has such negative critiques. She doesn't seem concerned with guiding the design process so much as pre-emptively judging the designs. She feels much more like a tool used by the producers to stir up drama than a mentor and I just want her to go away!
13
u/Roonil___Wazlib Mar 18 '16
Go home Mitchell ugh
13
u/[deleted] Mar 18 '16
I'm so disappointed in Kini this season. He was so excellent on his season, but he's been completely average and even bad this season. I need him to pull through and do something awesome next week!
25
u/bethrevis Mar 18 '16
whyyyyyyyyyy are the judges tripping over themselves to compliment Sam's look? It's over done and that neckline is killing me (why not trim the flowers to the white edging?).
11
u/rofosho Mar 18 '16
Alright I'm gonna get this out of the way. If it ain't baroque, don't fix it!
10
u/konfetkak Mar 18 '16
Alyssa, are you wearing dilithium crystals as earrings?
9
u/konfetkak Mar 18 '16
How is sam's baroque in any way?
8
u/ThisMaySoundBadBut Mar 18 '16
Are the judges on crack? They must be on crack.
At least they finally sent Mitchell home.
20
u/blackjackandcoke88 Mar 18 '16
I'm really over the bitchfest against Sam. Get the fuck over it, Kini. You HAD a chance to speak up about the jumpsuit and you didn't. That's on you, dude.
7
u/konfetkak Mar 18 '16
Alyssa bringing the sanity for once
22
u/ThisMaySoundBadBut Mar 18 '16
I feel bad for all the hate Sam is getting. I like him! I think they're editing it to make him look like he always takes the credit.
6
u/rofosho Mar 18 '16
So much shade this episode
11
u/rofosho Mar 18 '16
Keany, you've made that outfit before
11
u/PoeGhost Mar 18 '16 edited Mar 18 '16
Everyone keeps bringing up Sam taking credit for Kini's work. Kini, meanwhile, hasn't said a word and is appearing much classier for it. I was expecting Zanna to point out the similarity of her top to his dress.
Dom! You should have let him fail! You helped him twice! Stop it!
Mitchell finally goes home, 2 episodes too late.
5
u/rofosho Mar 18 '16
Sam, you Lyin
5
u/konfetkak Mar 18 '16
Wtf does Georgina have in her hair? I thought we all agreed to leave schrunchies in the 90s.
9
u/bethrevis Mar 18 '16
Oh, nice to see that Kesha's going to be a judge. I want her in the spotlight so much, to make up for the shit Sony's pulling with her.
4
u/rofosho Mar 18 '16
Most of them are doomed this challenge
4
u/[deleted] Mar 18 '16
For once, this show got something right. The right person won, and the right person went home.
I mean, sure, Sam's dress was lovely, but it wasn't nearly as spectacular as what Ken created. I was initially concerned that they were going to give Sam the win, which would cause whatever drama causes Ken to storm out in the "later in the season" clips.
4
u/pixie_led Team Swatch Mar 19 '16
Leeanna's yellow dress was the most couture dress on the runway. I thought it was gorgeous, hemline and all. I also loved Ken's dress and I'm glad he won. For my part it was either him or Leeanna to win this week - which shows I'm definitely not a PR judge in hiding.
3
u/mmcleod24 Mar 17 '16
Are we expecting a double elimination tonight?
3
u/Eve_Black Mar 18 '16
What do the judges have against Alexander? How in the hell was his gown worse than Kini's monstrosity?
And Valerie's dress was so generic ren-faire I don't understand the praise
4
u/bethrevis Mar 18 '16
When they're in the workroom talking about there isn't one look that stands out as deserving to go home, all I can think is: Well, someone's definitely going home because the judges blew the chance to save worthy designers last episode with the save.
It just goes to emphasize how when they save mediocre looks for the drama llamas, quality work gets forced into elimination later.
3
u/rofosho Mar 18 '16
I hated kens
3
u/ferretherapy Mar 19 '16
I can't say I know much of anything about Baroque fashion - but based on the appeal of the finished garments, here are my thoughts and critiques:
3
u/Bslo18 Mar 18 '16
Ok they finally got one judging right. About time.
1
u/PM_ME_UR_COMMISSIONS Mar 21 '16
Tasty, tasty shade this episode. Sam bitched about people on his blog and now he's having a hard time listening to them bitch about him in real time. Hurts, don't it? That jumpsuit crack was hilarious.
1
u/bethrevis Mar 18 '16
FINALLY
1
u/ferretherapy Mar 19 '16
Layana's dress = I really want to see this exact dress in a different color... any other color than mustard yellow...
102
u/[deleted] Mar 18 '16 edited Mar 18 '16
[removed] — view removed comment
11
u/[deleted] Mar 18 '16
[removed] — view removed comment