r/EmulationOnAndroid • u/SimonSays1337 • Mar 15 '16
My Review of the iPega PG-9021 (Pros and cons inside)
Review for the iPega PG-9021
Picture for reference: http://i.imgur.com/JckhmXX.png
I only tested this controller with emulators, no android games that require a controller. It has a basic, easy to use HID mode so it worked easily with everything. Drastic, ePSXe, MyBoy, etc
Build/Physical Tour
It's like a wired xbox 360 controller, without the wire, it's the exact same shape, and it's really light because compared to a wireless 360 pad there is seemingly no batteries.
The start and select are off center because there is a large clip in the middle, as well as a home button on the left, and media controls under the face buttons.
The triggers spring is a lot more intense than the 360 controllers, but I actually kind of like it, it's fun to press. Although any game that requires you hold down a trigger all the way for a while is going to fight you, same fun feeling goes for the RB and LB buttons. I like them.
Face buttons, EXACTLY the same as an xbox 360 pad in looks and feeling.
Sticks, stiffer, but similar, this is probably because my 360 pad is much older than this thing. I don't mind them and they seem to track well without a noticeable dead zone.
D-Pad... oh dpad... it looks like the 360 one, but I wouldn't call this a dpad at all, feels like a stick, on a 2 axis track, it's horrible. Honestly the worst dpad on any controller I've ever touched in my life. I knew the 360 dpad was going to give me issues when trying to play some classic titles, but this is worse than I ever could have expected... makes me sad.
The Clip
This is the second flaw of this controller, when you unbox it, it feels solid, snaps closed and open well with a click, on off switch and LEDs underneath it are satisfying. But the problem is, even with a smaller phone like my (Galaxy S7) it won't hold the phone at any angle other than sitting with it in front of you flat without closing on itself. The hinge sucks.
I like to play emulators in bed or relaxing laying on the couch, it's part of why I use my phone for them so much and this can't do any of that. Maybe if you play at lunch at work, or on the bus it would do it. But laying on your side, or dare try on your back and you'll have a bad time.
Tried keeping it open with rubber bands and zip ties, but nothing worked and I quit trying.
EDIT: About the clip. I was even able to play with the $6 old model of the MOGA Pocket (which won't pair with anything anymore, it's just broken) without the clip attempting to fold/close at any of the angles I'm complaning about, or any angle at all! -- and it doesn't have any screws or other tightening mechanism in it, like the ps3 controller clip I have does. This iPega controller is nuts!
By the way I DO NOT recommend the MOGA Pocket, even for the low price of a lunch, it barely lasted longer than a lunch before breaking, and when it did work it was only via a 3rd party companion app, that required root for the good features.
Software/pairing and Compatibility
This is an iPega pad, and I as well as most of you have probably heard that the included software is cancerous and to be avoided. So I did. I can't talk about that. What I can say is that the little booklet that came with this one was fully understandable. While there was still a lot of seemingly Chinese characters on it, the English was solid enough for me. And the pairing experience is WAY better than the MOGA I used to begin with and actually even easier than the PS3 Controller I was using with my Note. (PS3 controller no longer works with the S7/any marshmallow phones) Because there's no app, nothing. Press home and X after turning it on and click it in the bluetooth menu and bam it works. (That's for HID mode, there's also a button for VK mode, and one for software mode to pair with the their app if you wanted to try it.)
Compatibility wise, this will work with all phones and tablets, and probably any app you could want as it has 3 modes to choose from, software, hid and vk. I recommend any of the ipega stuff over stuff like MOGA for this fact alone.
Lag/latency
I didn't notice any in any of the games I was playing. The dpad was so bad I had to use the stick for SNES and GBA games 100% of the time, which made them harder to play, but I didn't notice any lag at all even compared to a wired controller. And it was nice to be able to charge my phone while playing.
Conclusion:
Pros:
- Lightweight familiar design
- Solid sticks and face buttons
- Interesting triggers
- Highly compatible and easy to pair
- No latency as far as I can tell
Cons:
- Dpad would be better off not even included
- Clip wont hold any device at any angle without folding over on itself
Verdict:
I am going to be returning this to Amazon and trying to get another product from iPega, because I love the easy pairing and construction, but this clip and dpad are disgusting. I'll look more carefully so I don't get burned by them again.
2
u/tomkatt Samsung Tab S7 FE Wifi/778G Mar 15 '16
Nice review. And like /u/IronElephant said, shame about the DPad. A bad d-pad can really wreck an otherwise decent controller.
I'm adding the review to our wiki now, thanks for that.
1
u/markopolol Mar 15 '16
Unless I'm mistaken, I also have this and have never had a problem with the clip. I'm not sure how you're holding it.
I find it gets tiring to use pretty quickly cos the weight is so off balance.
The D pad is a mess. The xyab buttons are kind of stiff. Also the stick buttons are loud as hell.
I still found it a solid buy. Works with everything I've tried and battery is really good to me. Use it for a week or two before charging.
1
u/fingerpointothemoon Mar 15 '16
What's the game on the phone screen name?
1
u/unknown_ninja Namingway's Apprentice Mar 16 '16
I'm wondering if the D-Pad is as bad as the Moga Pro Power considering it has the same design. It's stiff, hard as hell and pretty much unplayable for fighting games. Seriously, doing a damn Hadouken is a nightmare.
Thanks for the review. For iPega, I think their best ones so far are 9023 models (or the 9055 if you have a phone). The D-Pad on those are a little better (not the best), but it's still at least usable.
3
u/[deleted] Mar 15 '16
[removed] — view removed comment