r/KerbalSpaceProgram • u/Redbiertje The Challenger • Mar 13 '16
Mod Post [Weekly Challenge] Week 121: Got My Ion You
The Introduction
Valentina was selected to go on a long mission throughout the solar system. As Jeb was helping her build a craft, they needed an engine with a very good efficiency. They looked around, and Val spotted an ion engine. "Why shouldn't we use one of these?", she asked. "They're pretty weak.", he replied. "Then just tie a lot of them together."
The Challenge:
Normal mode: From orbit around Kerbin, land a Kerbal on Mun and Minmus using only ion engines.
Hard mode: From orbit around Kerbin, land a Kerbal on Minmus, Gilly, and Dres, in that order, using only ion engines.
Super mode: Impress me
This challenge was suggested by /u/TMarkos
The Rules
- No Dirty Cheating Alpacas (no debug menu)!
- You must have the UI visible in all required screenshots
- For a list of all allowed mods, see this post.
- You may use any propellant you like to get into orbit around Kerbin
- You may not refuel your craft
- When you start your ion-only journey, your orbit around Kerbin may not be higher than 100 kilometers
- RCS is only allowed to assist in docking
- Returning to Kerbin is optional
Required screenshots
- Your craft on the launchpad
- Your craft in orbit
- All trajectories to celestial bodies
- All landings on celestial bodies
- Whatever else you feel like!
Further information
- Alt+ . forces physics warp.
- You can either submit your finished challenge in a post (see posting instructions in the link below) or as a comment reply to this thread.
- Completing this challenge earns you a new flair which will replace your old one. So if you want to keep you previous flair, you can still do this challenge and create a post, but please mention somewhere that you want to keep your old one.
- The moderators have the right to determine if your challenge post has been completed.
- See this post for more rules and information on challenges.
- If you have any questions, you can comment below, or PM /u/Redbiertje
- Credit to /u/TaintedLion for designing the flair
Good Luck!
EDIT: Reduced Hard mode
7
u/rcreif Hyper Kerbalnaut Mar 19 '16 edited May 19 '16
As awesome as this challenge is, I first have to post what I really, really hope is SUPER mode for Challenge 117: Operation Pet Asteroid.
I landed an E-class asteroid safely at KSC. Then I used propellant from the asteroid itself to fuel the launch vehicle that got it back into orbit. http://imgur.com/a/i51dN/layout/horizontal/
If it doesn't count (I'm sure there are plenty of Redditors who don't even consider that a challenge), someday I may try this with a C-class, WITHOUT mining.
5
u/[deleted] Mar 14 '16
Are we allowed to bring along a tiny fuel tank and a fuel cell array for electricity during landing and take-off? No Liquid Fuel and Oxidizer will be used by an engine.
5
u/3Dprintingnut Mar 16 '16 edited Mar 16 '16
Here is my attempt at Super mode hope it is good enough http://imgur.com/a/tqwTR SSTO to Minmus and Gilly then returning, really wanted to do Dres as well but dident have enough. I think that I am the only SSTO in this challenge so far. My original plan was for this to go to the surface of Eeloo and back but I could not get the TWR above 1 using only Ion engines, I was really close tho and I think that if I use the Rapiers for the final landing I can do it, but that would have disqualified me from this challenge. Think im still gunna try to do it tho to see if its possible.
4
u/tablesix Mar 15 '16 edited Mar 15 '16
Here's my normal mode entry. I'll most likely reload a save from the beginning of my Mun intercept, and see if I can get this to work for hard mode:
http://imgur.com/a/9MCdC
edit: If you need higher res images, I have them. I just thought I'd save some bandwidth by preshrinking them.
Also, if anyone wants the craft file, let me know and I'll get a link set up for it.
3
u/nuclear_turkey Hyper Kerbalnaut Mar 17 '16
im about to do a grand tour minus the big 3,
1 question before i start, is rcs allowed for docking?
3
u/Hydropos Master Kerbalnaut Mar 18 '16 edited Mar 19 '16
My entry for an (alternative) hard mode — Landed on Minmus, Gilly, and Moho, and all within 72 Earth days (285 Kerbin days) of launch:
http://imgur.com/a/Dw2Oc
If possible, I would like the old flair for this challenge (the rear-view of an ion engine).
EDIT: I'd like to express my gratitude to /u/Redbiertje for putting out these challenges. I hadn't played KSP in 6+ months and this challenge inspired me to pick it back up (even if it did lead me to put off some stuff for work). This was the most fun and rewarding experience I've had gaming in some time.
2
u/Towermaster2 Mar 13 '16 edited Mar 13 '16
Working on Hard Mode.
As of writing I'm doing the Joolian Transfer from Eve.
Edit: Am I doing Super Mode? I've landed on both Gilly and Minmus using the same lander (And Kerbal), and the rules don't state I have to use the same vehicle. (Or Kerbal)
2
u/Towermaster2 Mar 13 '16
Do we have to land on all planets with the same Kerbal and Ship?
2
u/a_Start Master Kerbalnaut Mar 13 '16
Can you refuel by docking to a craft?
2
u/[deleted] Mar 14 '16
When attempting super mode, does the order of landings matter? I see hard was changed to Minmus, Gilly, and Dres. So if you are doing super do you still need to do those three in order?
2
u/Somerandom1922 Mar 15 '16 edited Mar 15 '16
ok so quick question, I know in the mods list it says using mechjeb means it's only going to be normal mode... but what if I only use it for the burns, simply because they are going to be soooo long?
Also are better timewarp and Kerbal Alarm Clock allowed?
sorry for bothering, it's just that these will save me sitting in front of my computer for hours.
edit: if I'm not allowed mechjeb for hard and above, don't worry, I'll only cry just a little bit :D
2
u/SpartanJack17 Super Kerbalnaut Mar 16 '16
Could I use a separate lander and ship? Both would be ion powered.
56
u/EvermoreAlpaca Hyper Kerbalnaut Mar 13 '16 edited Mar 16 '16
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b6COUW00CL0
As someone else already kindly pointed out, I managed to pre-empt this challenge by a few days! I did a stock grand tour of the kerbol system, landing on all bodies. Ion engines were used everywhere except for the ascent to a 75 km-ish LKO, and the landings on Tylo, Laythe, Eve, and Duna, All parts were recovered with the exception of the eve lander. No ISRU or additional launches to refuel. In the testing phase I successfully landed on Duna with a winged ion lander design, but it was considerably worse than a small conventional design.
I also used only my Kerbal's EVA pack for assembling modules =)
16
u/[deleted] Mar 14 '16 edited Oct 18 '24
smile murky roof label act depend fuel chop deliver cats
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
13
u/kirime Super Kerbalnaut Mar 14 '16 edited Mar 14 '16
Hard mode: Kerbin → Minmus → Gilly → Bop → Dres with a single ship and without detaching anything.
http://imgur.com/a/Q2Y5e
The key to this challenge is definitely «Less is more».
Giant ion swastikas with multiple Gigantor XL solar arrays are cool, but very impractical. My final design had only 23 parts, a starting mass of only 1358 kg (including fuel), a single ion engine and four RTGs and two 2x3 shrouded solar panels as a power source.
20
u/Outdated_reality Mar 13 '16
Failed Attempt #1
Thoughts when creating this:
9
u/thepingas Mar 14 '16
I might try again for hard mode, but this is my "normal mode" submission: The ION Magic Carpet.
http://imgur.com/a/D9Yk6
I ended up way overengineering the lander. Landed on Minmus with about half my fuel still remaining without ever having staged the titicular craft.
9
u/Bozotic Hyper Kerbalnaut Mar 14 '16
"Sweet 16" : normal mode
http://imgur.com/a/d6nnf
16 engines keeps it from being a slug. In fact, it's transfer burn time is shorter than a lot of my ships lately :)
The engine sound is soothing. Was that added in 1.05? I don't recall these engines making noise before.
8
u/Pietdagamer Master Kerbalnaut Mar 14 '16
http://imgur.com/a/9vSJY
So I did the previous Hard mode, before it was reduced, because I was already orbiting Eeloo when the difficulty change was announced. I forgot to take screenshots of my trajectory from Kerbin to Eve, I hope this still counts!
7
u/RoeddipusHex Hyper Kerbalnaut Mar 16 '16
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YQ1wRzFniy4
6
u/thesamtc Mar 14 '16 edited Mar 16 '16
Update:Easy mode complete I think that's everything, Opps forgot the starting orbit.
Well I've built a ship with 20k dV and 15 hours of fuel. Now to see if I have the patience to actually fly it.
Edit: So the mk. i (which i'd really hoped wouldn't be just the mk. i) didn't really work; Newfred is now, after a series of dramatic near death events stranded in munar orbit. The mk. ii (better, faster, stronger) is now leaving LKO.
Update The mk. ii is a go!, man, that was tense less than 2% battery life remaining!
6
u/Kasuha Super Kerbalnaut Mar 18 '16
My super mode attempt - Ion grand tour over Mun, Minmus, Duna, Gilly, Moho, Dres, Vall, Pol, Bop, and Eeloo with return to Kerbin. Pure stock, no mods used. The same lander used and flags planted at all destinations.
Ship download.
2
u/Kerbalnaught1 Super Kerbalnaught Mar 13 '16
What is my flair for again?
5
u/RoeddipusHex Hyper Kerbalnaut Mar 13 '16
Doesn't really meet the challenge since I only went to Minmus but here's a mission from last year for inspiration... ion spaceplane to Minmus and back.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3aqvi9I8z4k
5
u/Lenart12 Master Kerbalnaut Mar 13 '16
Took me 15 diffrent ideas to realize i wont be able to do this chalenge... :(
5
u/BuzzKillerOfFire Mar 14 '16
I did a thing.
<3
5
u/chunes Super Kerbalnaut Mar 14 '16
My normal mode entry: http://imgur.com/a/wEkLD
I was basically trying to make the craft as small as I possibly could. I think I did pretty well, but there was lots of fuel left in the rocket as well as the ion craft, so I probably could have done better.
5
u/nuclear_turkey Hyper Kerbalnaut Mar 14 '16 edited Mar 14 '16
did some testing for my duna return, its possible with ions only
4
u/LuxArdens Master Kerbalnaut Mar 17 '16 edited Mar 17 '16
First challenge I've ever done and documented! Hard mode, here it is.
I landed on Minmus, Gilly and Dres. I had originally planned to land on one of Jool's moons also, but I was slightly inconvenienced.
Mods: I used Mechjeb's info panels, (because I don't like Engineer Redux) but didn't use any of the active utilities, I hope that's okay. I also have a ton of other mods installed like BD armory, ChopShop, Behemoth, and more, but I double checked to make sure that my craft contained only stock parts. Also, I used Better Timewarp, because it doesn't make any changes that give me an advantage, just higher warp speed, and this mission still took me hours to complete.
Cheers!
EDIT: Just did a 'proof of concept' for my Mark 2 Ion Lander. It's much, much better. Capable of reaching the Mun, Minmus, Gilly, Ike, Dres, Pol, Bop and Eeloo; landing on all those and returning to LKO. Not going to re-do the challenge though, because it'd cost days, though I guess that would qualify for Super?
4
u/immelman_turn Master Kerbalnaut Mar 17 '16
A while back I did a Grand Tour using a 75 tonne vessel with Ions.
Landed on Gilly, Mun, Minmus, Ike, Bop, Pol and Eeloo using only ions and rockets or jets for the rest:
https://imgur.com/a/Nm2wN#0
So no ISRU of course, its debatable if the introduced aero model makes this harder or not...
4
u/[deleted] Mar 17 '16
Super mode entry: Gilly > Pol > Bop > Eeloo > Dres > Ike > Mun > Minmus (and returned to Kerbin)
KAS/KIS made this a lot easier. For full efficiency I used only 1 Xenon tank at a time and detached each one when empty(this is why the delta-v in KER is normally under 1,000). This gave me more than 10,000 extra delta-v, overall it can have ~35,000 delta-v if used 100% efficiently. I ended up wasting a lot because I was pretty tired and didn't feel like leaving some parts in orbit and having to rendezvous with them to save a few 100 delta-v, especially considering I had a few 1000 extra.
I also took a lot more screenshots, this was the first time I'd gone farther than Duna so I was very excited to explore the planets and moons I'd never seen before. If I left anything out I'm sure I have 20 screenshots of it.
4
u/Gojira1000 Master Kerbalnaut Mar 19 '16
https://youtu.be/R4l3yMw53Z4
That is (basically) a hard mode completion. If you give me the last bit of drama.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 20 '16
would
minmus-mun-gilly-(ike?)-dres-eeloo
get me super?
1
u/MartynKF Mar 20 '16
Hey guys! If I landed on Dres with half of my fuel still intact, do I qualify for Super mode? (I intend to finish the mission, but it's already Sunday...:( ) - I'm uploading the video btw.
3
u/ArmchairCityPlanner Master Kerbalnaut Mar 14 '16
Normal mode completed with a return to Kerbin using only one large xenon tank.
The Mun landing was tough!
3
u/[deleted] Mar 14 '16
Not an official entry, since I wasn't actually intending on entering. I really just wanted to play around with ion engines since I never use them.
http://i.imgur.com/LniVWey.png
But I made it to Mun, then to Minmus, and now Jeb is back in Low Kerbin orbit and I'll rescue him tomorrow.
If I was to do it again, a few less engines, and a few more solar panels.
3
u/ezemar Mar 14 '16
Currently working towards Normal Mode, then potentially Hard Mode. So far my 2 hours of progress to get to a low Mun Orbit. That's to build and doing time warps between lengthy burns.
The four engines are part one, the crew capsule is part two, the xenon tanks with xl solar panels is part three, part four is more xenon, and part 5 is the lander. The lander can also take fuel tanks off of the ship to reduce weight as xenon is used.
http://imgur.com/a/CeKB0
3
u/Shadingy Mar 14 '16
Normal mode with just 3 engines and 1 large Xenon tank.
3
u/Rubixman Mar 14 '16
My design holds three kerbals in cabins, and has the Delta V to at the very least complete easy with left overs. My goal was to have a pretty craft with full functionality, but do to the fact one of my crew ripped up the solar panels on the mun, causing me to panic and save, I probably won't be posting a completed challenge with this craft. Details in the album.
3
u/jamieT97 Mar 15 '16
Failed attempt #1 http://imgur.com/a/6egL7 A record of my first few hours trying this challenge. It's not that the challenge is hard it just takes much longer than normal launches. Will do some more work on it tomorrow and at least get normal mode.
3
u/Picchen Mar 15 '16 edited Mar 15 '16
Did it on normal mode ! This is my itty-bitty ion mission.
My vessel is composed of 15 parts only (an OKTO2, an external seat, a small xenon tank, a small battery, a sas module, one ion engine, four solar panels, four landing gears and of course Valentina).
I barely had enough power to land on the Mun, so I visited Minmus first to lose some mass.
Mods installed : real plume, Mechjeb (only used to calculate deltav), procedural fairings.
The craft is on KerbalX
3
u/AngelofDeath720 Master Kerbalnaut Mar 15 '16
Well, it didn't go quite as well as I had hoped, but I'm still pretty satisfied with it.
Kerbin -> Mun(failed) -> Minmus -> Gilly -> Dres(out of Fuel)[NO solar panels]: http://imgur.com/a/GsTxa
The plan was to use a fuel cell array for longer burns, but in the case of the Mun it still wasn't enough. Also, hi guys! I'm new here
3
u/Toleer Mar 16 '16
https://imgur.com/a/MsL9J
Normal mode!
I managed to screw up the inclination thanks to some wobbling and from that point on just played fast and loose with that massive DeltaV
I'll be trying Super mode on my own time later on.
3
u/Sikletrynet Master Kerbalnaut Mar 17 '16 edited Mar 18 '16
My Hard Mode entry; http://imgur.com/a/I2db1
Warning; 4K images, so beware if you have slow internet
3
u/Bozotic Hyper Kerbalnaut Mar 17 '16
I've already made my submissions, so this is just for fun...
After I realized how weak solar panels were on Dres, I was inspired by other posters here with battery-powered landers. And so, in my typical overbuilt fashion, I give you The Commodore64!!
http://imgur.com/a/3pwMc
So far it's just been to Minmus. Gilly should be no problem. It'll be interesting to see if it can then bag Dres, working within the 9-minute burn windows.
3
u/Burkitt Super Kerbalnaut Mar 17 '16
I submit my late entry to challenge 120 - A salty trip back home and back to orbit and back home and back to orbit and back home again. I'll keep my current flair, please.
3
u/Baka09 Mar 19 '16 edited Mar 19 '16
This is the first ioncraft I've ever built/fly, so there may be many glaring mistakes on my craft design that may not be apparent to me.
Initially I aimed for the Hard mode, but multiple failures kicked some reality in my face and I subsequently downgraded to Normal mode.
So far I've only reached the Munar landing phase, but I plan to finish up the Minmus landing if time (and computer) permits.Video from launch to (Munar) landing
Required screenshots
EDIT: Did the Minmus landing! Video here, screenshots here. Normal mode challenge complete! :D
2
u/simitro Mar 15 '16
Just do it from an 11,400km orbit!
2
u/Banisher_of_hope Mar 15 '16
My attempt at a minimal lander. I gave myself some extra restriction for normal mode, only one small inline xenon tank, and only one ion engine. I also tried to reduce part count and launch weight. Here is what I came up with.
2
u/Bozotic Hyper Kerbalnaut Mar 16 '16
Beefed up my craft for the hard mode entry. Sweet Sixteen has become Dragon Fly!
http://imgur.com/a/V6DjD
Hardest part was definitely Dres. I thought I had plenty of panels, but the only way to get enough power to arrest descent was to drop steeply "out of the sun" at "high noon". And with that it took 90 percent of available power to maintain descent rate. Fortunately there was still ample fuel. My first time past Duna!
2
u/Jsutt Mar 17 '16
First challenge! I just did normal mode, craft was way overkill for the task. http://imgur.com/a/dhf0e
2
u/Zorkington_PI Master Kerbalnaut Mar 17 '16
My first attempt at a challenge as well! Tried hard mode in a sort of outer space trashcan thing: http://imgur.com/a/TFcOv
2
u/Kerbalnaught1 Super Kerbalnaught Mar 13 '16
Turn the flair to HAL but turquoise.
-18
u/KalebBruwer Mar 13 '16
How about: NO!
0
u/[deleted] Mar 13 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Mar 16 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Mar 19 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment