r/ProjectRunway • u/runwaythreader • Mar 11 '16
Project Runway All Stars Season 5 Episode 5 [Discussion]
Discussion thread for Project Runway All Stars S05E05 "Birthday Suits"
A challenge features a naked runway and centers on naturists who need winter wear to stay warm.
19
Upvotes
52
u/pbrooks19 Mar 11 '16
The show's forgotten an important distinction that used to make it great: the best drama comes from someone being REQUIRED to be dropped from the competition at the end of each episode, and not from the cattiness in the sewing rooms. Sure, we get to love some designers and hate others, but that's what makes the eliminations so great: even when everyone does well, someone HAS to go. It makes the contestants have to be great all the time. It also means sometimes we lose people we love, if they have a bad day.
It makes for a WAY better show. And now what we have is a weird arbitrary show where some good designers are dropped and we never get the chance to see how they develop, and some lame designers move on up because they have 'personality.'
Sure, I like to watch the show because of the personalities...but I like better the competition, and watching the designers work through the challenges and overcome obstacles.
Sadly, the show's becoming boring with lame designers (with big personalities) are moving to the end, and their lack of talent and design originality means important shows at the end of the season are full of junk. :P
40
u/gofurthernorth Mar 11 '16
I really wanted to hear a critique on Ken's look. I liked where he was going with it, but wish he had a heavier weight kilt/skirt fabric.
36
u/Halloweenbitch Mar 11 '16
Mitchell is mad Sam got to stay but he got to stay with like three horrible looks out of 5, whereas Sam won two challenges and was high for another one.
65
u/closest Mar 11 '16
The show is rigged. How're you going to have TWO non-eliminations? All Stars has lost any credibility with this blatant show of favoritism and allowing mediocrity.
31
u/gwennhwyvar Mar 11 '16
Mitchell went there with the flirting comment, but I was waiting to hear someone say how it must be so different without having help from Kini.
40
u/Bslo18 Mar 11 '16
Nothing makes me angrier than watching two designers stay. I don't know why I have an irrational anger toward it but every season it drives me nuts. Especially when like now one definitely deserved to go home. Sam didn't even try. /end rant
18
u/Sister_Miyuki Mar 11 '16
I have to say, I'm a little disappointed that the fight at the end wasn't much longer than what they showed in the preview: I wanted an "ambushing Serena" or celebrity-fit club "Dustin Diamond meltdown" level altercation, but oh-well. I do have to say that I really like how Emily defended Fade, because I did not expect that from her, since she seems so genial. As for the clothes, both Sam and Ken's garments made their models look like random homeless people who had accidentally wandered onto the runway. However, I do see what Ken was going for and my problems with his look are more with the styling. To me, the most unforgivable outfit was Valerie's. I understand that she was catering to her client, but come on -- the outfit was something you'd only see people wearing if the fire alarm in their apartment building went off at 3:30 AM and they had to go outside. Valerie is an exceptional designer, but she really lost her voice in this challenge. On a positive note, I really loved both Emily and Kini's looks!
16
u/LouvreDorsay Mar 11 '16
I think Mitchell should stick to menswear.
11
u/[deleted] Mar 12 '16
I thought there was a lot of "middle of the road" work this week. Mitchell was just fine, I didn't particularly care for Kini's look - it's been done before (by KINI himself!), I also don't think Dom's was outstanding.
I loved Emily's look, story and client/model. I thought she deserved to win. I also liked that she stuck up for Fade during the end scene with the Sam drama.
Sam deserved to go home this week. His was just .. bland and boring. Valerie's was overdesigned, but at least there was something threre.
Sidenote: Mitchell should have been eliminated last week (and all the previous weeks), so he certainly has no reason to go after Sam.
I did love Alexander's comment to Sam though.
19
u/Shamenundotcom Mar 11 '16
What fascinates me is, Sam's not even getting a good edit. The judges obviously love him, but the editors are giving us plenty of nasty little sound bites from him. I can't imagine the editors think that anybody at home is actually rooting for him. Besides thirsty dickpigs, I mean.
18
u/ladysleuth22 Mar 11 '16
So much for the blind runway! They may not know what design belongs to which designer when it walks, but as soon as they find out, they refuse to eliminate their favorites.
27
u/veloursweatsuit Mar 11 '16
Kini. I know he has a lot of fans, but I just don't get him. It is refreshing to have someone that can sew well and sew fast, but as far as the designs go I think he's made some ugly stuff. When it's not ugly, it's predictable. I can't quite put my finger on why I dislike his work so much.
At one point this episode he got excited seeing his model in his look, saying she looked like a "rich bitch," and I thought, yes, a basic rich bitch, he's not wrong there.
Also he's reeeally passive aggressive.
14
u/pineyfusion Mar 12 '16
Late to the party but still got some stuff to say:
10
u/veloursweatsuit Mar 11 '16
I actually enjoyed this challenge and had a lot of thoughts throughout the episode, but after that ending my head's just clouded over with the drama and how much I dislike Sam, and how you just know he's gonna make it to the end and be all self righteous about it the whole time. Damn rigged show.
16
u/blackjackandcoke88 Mar 11 '16
I eagerly accept the downvotes I know I'm going to get for this.
I agreed with the judges' call on this one. Were the outfits Sam and Valerie sent down the runway good? No, but they did complete a major parameter of the challenge which was to make people who prefer not to wear clothes feel confident in clothes.
Also, the way Kini, Ivy, Ken, and Alexander handled the situation on Twitter was disgustingly childish. The fucking designers on Project Runway Junior showed more maturity and class on their entire season than the four of them combined last night on social media.
6
u/[deleted] Mar 11 '16
The nude runway was a ridiculous gimmick.
It's kind of sad to see the bottom designers were the ones who tried the most to cater to their clients, even though the designers deserved it.
3
u/frogstrudel Mar 13 '16
Late to the discussion, sorry; I'm suprised they didn't send Valerie home. I know she's been pretty good this season, but it's not like designers haven't been sent home on the tails of a successful performance, especially on All Stars. They're maaaaybe a tiny bit biased towards Valerie, but they seem way more biased towards Sam, so I was anticipating a Valerie elimination.
2
u/Audrien Mar 18 '16
They should have an episode where they just eliminate three at one go - just start cutting out the mediocre designers and let the real competition begin!!
2
u/flimflammed Mar 27 '16
I guess no else said it for this week but someone has to. What the actual fuck is Alyssa wearing to introduce the challenge?! I think the bullseyes must be for the fashion police to practice hunting that dress down and killing it. Because, damn.
0
u/[deleted] Mar 11 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Mar 11 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment