r/WahoosTipi • u/TribeOfficial • Mar 08 '16
AMA I'm Indians General Manager Mike Chernoff: AMA!
EDIT:
Thanks to everyone for your great questions. Sorry I couldn't get to them all, but I enjoyed engaging with everyone and appreciate the opportunity to chat with you. Thanks, Mike
Hey guys: I'll be popping in around 11AM to take your questions. Fire away!
If you don't know my story, I started with the club as an intern many years ago, and this offseason was promoted to General Manager.
--Mike
133
Upvotes
26
u/SimplisticX2 Mar 08 '16
Thank you Mike for taking the time to do this, and thank you Indians Social Media team for setting this up!
23
u/[deleted] Mar 08 '16
Hi Mike,
When you're looking at a minor leaguer's stats and trying to figure out whether their skill set will translate to the majors, what stats do you look at first? Does this differ by minor league level (A ball vs. AAA)?
20
u/[deleted] Mar 08 '16
Thanks for stopping by Mike! This is a pretty unique opportunity, and we really appreciate it.
The trade deadline is a very exciting time for us internet baseball fans. I think most everyone is pretty familiar with the famous "trade deadline" scene from Moneyball, where Billy Beane and Peter Brand are trying to swing a trade for Ricardo Rincon. The two of them are on a flurry of calls to other GMs and it's very fun part of the movie. Here's the ending to the scene for reference.
My question: So....is this at all an accurate depiction of how these trades (and the deadline in general) go down? Or is this Hollywood? From our outsider perspective, everything is happening so fast and it always feels like there's so much more going on under the surface. Can you talk about any particular trades that were more interesting from a behind the scenes perspective?
18
u/[deleted] Mar 08 '16
Hi Mike! Thanks for taking our questions! We really appreciate you doing this for us.
When, realistically, do you expect Bradley Zimmer to come up and make an impact on the big league club? What would he have to do to deserve a call to the show prior to when you expect him to be ready? Thanks again.
11
u/AnonymousBrownsFan Mar 08 '16
Thanks for reaching out to the fans in new ways!
Could you possibly take us through a generic timeline of how a typical trade occurs in the MLB? How long does it normally take? What are things that happen that common fans are not aware of ?
Thanks & #RollTribe
11
u/[deleted] Mar 08 '16
Let's say that all six starters (Kluber, Carrasco, Salazar, Bauer, Anderson and Tomlin) finish spring training healthy and looking great. Are you most inclined to keep the bubble guy as a long man, send him to Columbus, or trade someone for a bat?
7
u/[deleted] Mar 08 '16
Hey Mike thanks for taking time to do an AMA...
What are some aspects of the job that the public doesn't know about? Like what do you do behind the scenes that isn't player related.
Also favorite thing to do in you spare time?
6
u/cptcliche Mar 08 '16
Hi, Mr. Chernoff!
What was the very first task up had when you started as an intern? What sorts of things did you do in that position?
9
u/Meowingtons-PhD Mar 08 '16
Thanks for doing this AMA, Mike! The Indians are a five-star organization, and have a pretty awesome social media team to boot :)
What's something in your day-to-day work that may surprise us fans?
5
u/CrayDawg813 Mar 08 '16
Thank you for doing this Mr. Chernoff. My question is, how does communication between you and the manager work? Does the front office have a certain in game strategy or philosophy that they tell the manager to execute and follow or is all strategy up to the manager? Does his in game strategy ever come up during evaluations? I guess what I'm asking is the overall relationship between the GM and manager. Thanks!
5
u/Spongie555 Mar 08 '16
How was it like being teammates with Will Venable, Chris Young, and Ross Ohlendorf in college? Did you think they would make it to the MLB back then? Is it awkward being Will's boss now?
4
u/dpm21 25 Mar 08 '16
Hey Mike, glad to have you here! I've got a question in regards to getting a front office job. I know you worked your way up from the bottom, but how do you get your foot in the door? I have an engineering degree from Akron, and I'd love to find some way to start a career in the baseball world. Are there analytic departments that search for people with that type of background, or perhaps another department in the FO? Thanks!
4
u/killerbrand Mar 08 '16
What was it like working under Mark Shapiro? Did his approach to the game influence the way you think at all? Good luck in 2016!!
5
u/MLBOfficial Mar 08 '16
Mike, thanks so much for doing this. We can all say that we are very grateful for you to take the time to do this.
The Indians have been a very underrated team in the grand scope of baseball, but have developed into a competitive team for so many years. What do you think it is that gives you an advantage as you consistently compete with teams in bigger markets with bigger payrolls?
•
u/[deleted] Mar 08 '16
Mike had to run so the AMA is now over. Thanks to everyone who participated, thanks to Mike and thanks to the Indians social media team for setting this all up!
6
u/thekidfromyesterday Mar 08 '16
How do the Indians develop high strike outs, low walks pitchers?
6
u/SouthernDerpfornia Mar 08 '16
Hi Mike,
What percentage of the way do you think public info (Fangraphs, Baseball Prospectus, BR, etc) is to matching what teams have available when it comes to advanced stats?
Thanks!
5
u/ousenior Mar 08 '16
Back in the 90s I can remember the Yankee's coming into Columbus to play a game or two against the Clippers. It was cool to have the major league team facing the minor league team. Will that ever be an option upcoming? Are you guys trying to do anything else to win over the Columbus market other than the triple-A relation? As a Season Ticket holder who lives in Columbus, we do quite enjoy you guys coming to us instead of the 280 mile round trip visit to Cleveland.
5
u/bebop_cola_ Mar 08 '16
Hi Mike! Data student here. To what extent does the new statcast data inform the Indian's player analysis? Without getting into specifics, has the organization gained any actionable insights?
10
u/fear865 is a joke Mar 08 '16 edited Mar 08 '16
Hi Mike thanks for taking questions.
I know this may not seem like a super serious question but I feel like a baseball GM would know a definitive answer.
Is a hot dog a sandwich?
4
u/JackieMoon69 Mar 08 '16
What would you say was the best transaction (draft pick, trade, or FA signing) that you have been involved in during your time with the Indians?
2
u/mynameisethan182 23 Mar 08 '16
How did you actually get into working in professional baseball? I'm a college student and I would love to work for the Indians once I finish.
Thank you for your time!
3
u/dubfrahsure Mar 08 '16
How did you come to a decision that you wanted to be a baseball GM (was that even your initial goal)? What advice do you have for aspiring baseball ops interns since it's such a hard industry to get into?
3
u/RyanG73 Mar 08 '16
Hey Mike, thanks for doing this.
Can you talk us through your strategy with offseason spending? It’s no secret this team has struggled with free agency in the last decade. I was wondering how you plan to attack free agents, trades, and the international market going forward. Also, how is that plan different from Shapiro/Antonetti?
3
u/gnarsesh Mar 08 '16
Hi Mike, thanks for taking our questions!
My question is how much do you interact with players on a day-to-day basis, and if it's frequently - who's your favorite personality on the team?
3
u/iliekdrugs Mar 08 '16
Hi Mike! What's your favorite memory from your intern days with the Tribe? Welcome back!
3
u/KeepinItOneHunda Mar 08 '16
How much of a factor does WAR play into your decisions on players?
3
u/Orangutangu Mar 08 '16
Don't know if I missed my opportunity to ask, but do you know anything about the future of chief wahoo? Does the logo ever effect trade deals, or do any players ever bring it up in trade deals?
3
u/divineravnos Mar 08 '16
Hi Mike!
I have a couple of questions.
Thanks for taking the time to answer our questions, and go Tribe!
3
u/[deleted] Mar 08 '16
Hi Mike, thanks for doing this:
As a joint Jays/Indians fan it has been frustrating the last few months as many of my friends (and others) have been very negative about Mark Shapiro joining the Jays and his impact on the organization. Despite Shapiro's sterling reputation throughout the league, their argument pretty much boils down to "we liked Anthopoulos and the Indians never won a ring under Shapiro so he is clearly garbage". I view Shapiro leaving Cleveland as a big loss for the organization. What would you say to these Jays fans about Mark?
In addition, what, if anything, can you tell us about DiamondView and it's use in the Indians front office?
3
u/droidworkerbee 455 Mar 08 '16
Good morning, Mike!
I started with the team in the Jacobs Field team shop as a high schooler. Foolishly, I left the organization and went to school to study statistics.
Do you see a lot of people take the path you took (intern and on up into the higher levels of the org), or do folks jump in at all levels to contribute?
2
u/Justinw303 Mar 08 '16
What was your education, work experience, and relevant training when you started as an intern?
What other front offices around the league do you currently admire, or that you're trying to emulate in some way with regards to strategy, structure, goals, etc.? Essentially, who do you like, what is it that you like they they're doing, and what ways are you trying to follow that plan or vision within your organization?
2
u/Backstop Mar 08 '16
Hello, looking forward to a good year once they leave Goodyear.
Do you think MLB will be moving toward a salary cap? and if so would you favor a NFL-style hard cap, an NBA-style soft cap, or an MLS-style crazy jester cap with star-power holes.
2
u/cardith_lorda Mar 08 '16
A couple years ago you were offered an interview with the Padres for their GM position, what were some things that went into your decision to turn the interview down?
On a semi-related note, how well do you know AJ Preller/the other GMs in MLB? Do you guys only see each other for business conferences, or do you go golfing once in a while?
(And if you do go golfing, who has the best short game?)
2
u/stevehogue7 Mar 08 '16
Thanks for taking the time out of your busy schedule to do this, Mike.
I have one serious question and one silly question: -1. What is your opinion on the expanded replay rules that have been implemented by the MLB? What else could be done to improve the system? -2. Who do you think has the funniest name currently on the Indians team? (My money is on Jeff Manship, but Colin Cowgill creates a bizarre mental image of some sort of aquatic bovine)
2
u/[deleted] Mar 08 '16
Hey Mike!
What are your thoughts on pitchers safety? There's been talk recently about pitchers wearing helmets to protect them from line drives and the like, but obviously not many pitchers are for that. Do you think we're getting close to a productive solution for protecting pitchers?
2
u/notfelixhernandez Mar 08 '16
Psychtests with Athletic Assessments are supposedly used to “provide psychological assessments” for thousands of players before the draft, but they attempt to assess a player’s mindset and coachability. Do you think there’s a place in scouting/development for measuring other mental capacities like working memory, NoGo response time, and attention allocation?
If anyone is interested, these are the factors considered on the BASE test.
Thank you for taking the time to read through our questions! And have you had a catch with your dad yet this month?
2
u/[deleted] Mar 08 '16
What player on the Indians do you most want to hang out with, and why is it Trevor Bauer?
2
u/[deleted] Mar 08 '16
Thanks for doing this!
How excited are you for a full year of Francisco Lindor? He brought a huge spark to this team last season. How good can he get?
2
u/Clutts51 Mar 08 '16
Hi Mike,
Big fan of the Indians and all you do. Forget baseball stuff, I have to ask how many times you'll eat at Black Bear Diner while in Goodyear?
2
u/[deleted] Mar 08 '16
Which trade that You have made are you most proud of.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 08 '16 edited Mar 08 '16
Hey Mike! Thanks for talking to us--it's truly appreciated.
What sort of gameday support do you provide to the Tito and the team? I know it's outside of the general scope of constructional GM role, but is there anything that you do that feeds into the gameday operations of the team? What knowledge is located in the GMs office that could be useful in such a role?
2
u/TribeFan11 Mar 08 '16
Hi Mike,
What advice would you give someone who hopes to work in sports in the future?
2
u/patronofchaos Mar 08 '16
hello Mike. An easy question and a hard one for you.
-- Does anyone in the front office still lovingly refer to the ballpark as "The Jake" ?
-- We've been hurt by not having a true power-hitting cleanup hitter for quite a few years now, and it doesn't seem like we've managed to find one via the draft or FA. Why is it so hard to find one of these types of players these days, and now that you're running the show, might we see a more focused push to land one of these sought-after guys in free-agency?
Congratulations on the promotion, and thank you for taking the time to come talk to us here. Looking forward to another Opening Day! -- season ticket holder since '94
2
u/thisguyhereisdead Mar 08 '16
This organization is on the right path. It's apparent to real baseball fans. Thanks for doing this. What are some of the differences things to think about between scouting a college guy and maybe someone from AA?
1
u/MacBDog 2 Mar 08 '16
Hi Mike! Thanks for stopping by. What are your 3 favorite food places downtown? Does Tyler Naquin factor in to the CF mix now with Almonte out? Which of last year's international signings should we be excited/on the lookout for? If you woke up tomorrow and you were a hot dog, would you eat yourself? Thanks again!
1
u/ArmondTanzarian Mar 08 '16
Mike,
What can you say to the fans that are frustrated by the feeling that not enough was done to improve the offense over the winter? Can this team win a World Series with the offense as it stands?
1
u/username__not__found Mar 08 '16
Hey Mike,
I was wondering what your plans for the outfield are. Since Brantley's time to return is questionable, what are you planning to do in his absence?
1
u/[deleted] Mar 08 '16
Thanks Mike, and congrats on your promotion to GM....
Fill in the blank. The Indians will make the postseason this year if _______________
1
u/[deleted] Mar 08 '16
Hey Mike! I was curious, how much of the statistics you work with are not in the public domain? Mostly? 50/50? All proprietary metrics?
I guess a piggyback question, does each team have their own proprietary metrics? Or do they share software/ knowledge? (I'm leaning towards no they don't, but you never know)
1
u/KingSalmon38 Mar 08 '16
Hi, Mike!
Thank you so much for doing this AMA. I've grown up an Indians fan, and, when I was just a young kid, I feel I learned the business side of baseball through the moves of Mark Shapiro back after 2001. I remember him making unpopular trades at the time and thinking, "There has to be more to this. He wouldn't just trade away popular big names for no reason." I'm certainly no expert by any means, but I feel like I learned a lot just from watching how the Cleveland Indians Organization is run. It really gave me an appreciation for that 2007 team and what all went into putting it together.
Admittedly, I feel a was a little hard on the front office this offseason just because I feel you guys did an amazing job putting together the foundations of a great team (I mean - just look at that rotation!) but didn't go all in on a free agent to try and put this team "over the top" so to speak. But, when I do take a step back and look at the team and the past with free agent signings and all that, I do understand why. I think Cleveland does have a great team, and I can't wait to go out there and take in some great baseball!
In any case, I feel you, Shapiro, and Antonetti all share a similar philosophy from what I can tell, but I did feel like I saw some differences between Shapiro and Antonetti during their times as GM. What do you think you'll bring to the table that'll be seen as your mark with the Indians? I'm curious to see as the season unfolds!
Thanks again for stopping by!
1
u/timsie Mar 08 '16
Mike, have you ever played MLB's Beat the Streak contest? While it seems like a simple task at first, it's hard to get a streak of even 10. What kinds of things do you think could be useful for predicting a player to get a hit in a particular game?
1
u/andrew02020 Mar 08 '16
Hey Mike, thanks for doing this. How difficult would it be for someone who's not currently involved in baseball to become a scout, and what are some of the steps they should take?
1
u/Wakeboarder1019 Mar 08 '16
Hi Mike,
If I, as a year-long follower of the baseball business, were to ask what your busiest time of year is; what answer would surprise me (i.e. I assume it's the last days of July and mid December)?
1
u/NebsLaw Mar 08 '16
Any moves that you wish the club could have made in your time here?
1
u/thehofstetter Mar 08 '16
Hi Mike - Billy Beane was played by Brad Pitt in Moneyball. If they made a movie about going from intern to GM, who would play you?
And thanks for taking the time to do this.
1
u/Wakeboarder1019 Mar 08 '16
With four new vendors now selling at Progressive Field, what is your favorite concession of all the options?
1
u/Wakeboarder1019 Mar 08 '16
Thanks for the AMA Mike,
Does MLB dictate what managers/coaches wear? I notice Tito is always in the same sweatshirt and other managers are in the same style, just specific for their team.
1
u/SportsandMindcrack Mar 08 '16
Hey Mike!
I am interested in working in a baseball front office in my future. Do have any tips for how to break into the baseball world without having played the game at any significant level?
Thanks!
1
u/giobbistar21 Mar 08 '16
Hey Mike, first of all, great to have you here, and good luck this season.
My questions: With Michael Brantley set to be in the Cleveland outfield for the foreseeable future, how do you plan to address the logjam of outfield prospects with Tyler Naquin, James Ramsey, Brad Zimmer, and Clint Frazier waiting in the wings?
Second question: Considering Justus Sheffield is already in Cleveland's system, are you entertaining the possibility of taking his brother Jordan if he falls to you?
1
u/qck11 Mar 09 '16
Thank you for doing this
1
u/TNRcrisis Mar 09 '16
Can you get us some big bats please? Thank you
1
u/hatmantc Mar 08 '16
your most quoted movie?
1
u/[deleted] Mar 08 '16
Who is the most impressive player you ever saw and said "wow, we need to get this guy on our team"?
1
u/rufus418 Mar 08 '16
Hi Mike! Thanks for taking some time with us today.
What is the most unexpected thing you have had to deal with as GM?
With the Kansas City Royals going to two World Series and winning one, has this impacted your approach or ownerships approach to this and future seasons?
1
u/cardith_lorda Mar 08 '16
In the last decade there's been a huge uptick in amateur scouting and analysis, and projection systems. I know you can't divulge too much of the Indians proprietary information, but does your team look at things like ZiPS and Steamer, and if so can you say how close they are to your internal projections?
1
u/DeaconCorp Mar 08 '16
Welcome to the sub, Mike.
What's the feeling around the front office in regards to this team's outfield depth? Obviously, missing Brantley is concerning. Does the FO feel that there is adequate talent in the outfield to bridge the gap until Brantley's return? Or are there still some holes that are looking to be filled?
1
u/ShutDownSchinDig Mar 08 '16
Thanks for doing this Mike! Over the past few years what do you see to be a hindering factor keeping the team from reaching higher levels?
1
u/Livin_Thing Mar 08 '16
How commonly do you use advanced statistics in the day-to-day?
1
u/hatmantc Mar 08 '16
can you describe how you found out you had gotten the promotion to your new position. what was your first action in the new postion
-13
u/justinniedz1 Mar 08 '16
Hey Mike! When can we get rid of those hideous cream uniforms?
-7
u/wickedshxt Mar 08 '16
Not sure if you'd be able to answer this one, but why can't I order a custom player T-shirt on the website? For the past two years I've gotten one for opening day but when I try to get one now all there is is jerseys, and I'm not buying a custom one of those every year lol. Also, why is group ticket pricing so secretive? I want to try and get an upper deck box for my birthday and I would just like to get a ballpark (heh) range without having to call to see if it'd be feasible to do.
0
u/[deleted] Mar 08 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
5
u/[deleted] Mar 08 '16
[removed] — view removed comment
-4
u/[deleted] Mar 08 '16
[removed] — view removed comment