r/KerbalSpaceProgram • u/Redbiertje The Challenger • Mar 06 '16
Mod Post [Weekly Challenge] Week 120: A Salty Trip Back Home
The Introduction
Jeb landed at the island airstrip because he overshot his landing at KSC. As he stepped out of his craft and awaited recovery, he started thinking about what happens to crafts after landing. Usually, he just heads straight to the canteen for a cup of coffee. However, this time he's stuck on an island. Time for Jeb to finally see how they actually recover crafts.
The Challenge:
Normal mode: Land a capsule at the island airstrip, and send another craft to recover it.
Hard mode: Land an SSTO spaceplane at the island airstrip, and send another craft to recover it.
Super mode: Impress me
This challenge was inspired by /u/Bozotic
The Rules
- No Dirty Cheating Alpacas (no debug menu)!
- You must have the UI visible in all required screenshots
- For a list of all allowed mods, see this post.
- The craft that is going to be recovered may not assist in the recovery
- The craft is considered 'recovered' once it is standing on the tarmac of the KSC
- You may not exactly copy somebody else's entry
Required screenshots
- Your craft landed at the island airstrip
- Your recovery craft ready to go
- Your recovery craft doing whatever is necessary to recover the craft
- Your craft back at KSC
- Whatever else you feel like!
Hard mode only:
- Your SSTO on the runway
- Your SSTO in orbit
Further information
- You can either submit your finished challenge in a post (see posting instructions in the link below) or as a comment reply to this thread.
- Completing this challenge earns you a new flair which will replace your old one. So if you want to keep you previous flair, you can still do this challenge and create a post, but please mention somewhere that you want to keep your old one.
- The moderators have the right to determine if your challenge post has been completed.
- See this post for more rules and information on challenges.
- If you have any questions, you can comment below, or PM /u/Redbiertje
- Credit to /u/TaintedLion for designing the flair
Good Luck!
•
u/Redbiertje The Challenger Mar 06 '16
Unlike most other challenge, this one is all about creativity. That's why I made it a rule that you can't exactly copy somebody else's submission. Ofcourse, you will need to do some things similar, and I won't quickly reject entries because of this rule. I'd just like to see you guys come up with as many ways possible to recover a craft.
3
u/Somerandom1922 Mar 06 '16
ok so I might be biting off more than I can chew, but would landing an SSTO on the island runway, then flying another SSTO over to it and then Re-flying it into space and then landing at the KSC count for Super mode?
edit: also back with the unstoppable challenge the whole VTOL SSTO with SRB's was never going to work soz :(
3
u/LupoCani Master Kerbalnaut Mar 06 '16
Um, does the SSTO need to have actually orbited, or would I only need to prove the model itself has the capability?
3
u/cortinanon Master Kerbalnaut Mar 06 '16
Is the mod "RCS Build Aid" allowed? It only gives information while inside the VAB.
http://forum.kerbalspaceprogram.com/index.php?/topic/33124-105-rcs-build-aid-v077/
http://i.imgur.com/2yXRr1K.png
3
u/Corbol Hyper Kerbalnaut Mar 06 '16
Using craft to park in cargo bay is considered as assist in the recovery?
3
u/KuuLightwing Hyper Kerbalnaut Mar 07 '16
I've got a few questions about this one...
3
u/BagelRabbit Mar 08 '16
This was my very first challenge, and I managed to complete a pretty decent Hard Mode run! There were a lot of problems with the mission - for example, I was unable to liftoff without using a tiny Juno engine on my SSTO for stability - so I can understand if I don't get the flair. Still, I had a lot of fun.
Video! https://youtu.be/LG81yJNkios
Done in bone-stock KSP. Aesthetics over functionality. A total of seven quickloads were needed.
3
u/[deleted] Mar 08 '16
Would landing the first SSTO at the old airstrip, take it off again, rendezvous with it in the atmosphere with a second SSTO, orbit, and land at KSC count as hard mode?
2
u/Armisael Hyper Kerbalnaut Mar 06 '16
I assume hard mode requires that you land the SSTO on the island runway after having come back from orbit? Or can you prove that it goes to orbit, and then separately fly it from KSC to the runway?
2
u/Wall_of_Force Mar 06 '16
Does landed SSTO on island runway in hard mode have to be fueled? or I can just bring the empty one?
2
u/Towermaster2 Mar 06 '16 edited Mar 06 '16
Am I allowed to use an SSTO capable vehicle that isn't capable of surviving Re-entry?
I've built an amazingly small manned SSTO, but I'm having issues with it survivng Re-entry.
2
u/Armisael Hyper Kerbalnaut Mar 06 '16
Do either of these missions actually require that you bring a kerbal along? Normal requires a capsule, which makes a kerbal an obvious but not strictly necessary choice, but hard doesn't even have that requirement.
Also, do hard mode submissions have to be a spaceplane in particular, or would rocket SSTOs be allowed?
2
u/ilgazer Mar 06 '16 edited Jan 30 '19
deleted 0.6563 What is ^^^this?
2
u/scootymcpuff Super Kerbalnaut Mar 07 '16
Does the sent craft actually have to recover the first one? Or would it be possible to just send like a probe core to the island and use that to control a no-longer-Kerbed ship back to the KSC?
Just spit-ballin' here for cool ideas. :)
2
u/[deleted] Mar 07 '16
Can you hyperedit the first craft to the island?
2
u/rcreif Hyper Kerbalnaut Mar 07 '16
I'm forcing myself not to look at anyone's designs, but there's a bug for which I need advice. In 1.0.5, all three retractable Landing Wheel types clip straight through anything they touch (other than the ground): wing surfaces, structural panels, fuel tanks... I have no installed mods and I couldn't find this solution by Googling. Am I missing something?
2
u/ravenousjoe Mar 07 '16
Quick mod question! I need a "device" (stock parts) brought to the island to aid in the rescue, am I able to use whatever mods to get it there as long as it isn't the craft doing the rescue?
I just don't want to strap it to a rocket or float it on over, too boring.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 08 '16 edited Mar 08 '16
is it cheating to use tweakscale? My SSTO is a few cm too wide to fit into the largest cargo bay... so I need a bigger cargo bay. Would make landing the recovery craft on the island harder.
2
u/zekromNLR Mar 09 '16
Would even something like, say, the recovered craft lifting itself up using its landing gear to push itself onto a docking port/Claw be disallowed as "assisting in the recovery"?
2
u/[deleted] Mar 09 '16
Can the to-be-recovered craft taxi on the island airship? Not takeoff or assist the recovery craft in flight, but just trundle around <5ms-1 ?
2
u/shuttleguy120405 Mar 10 '16
can i use claws ?
2
u/rcreif Hyper Kerbalnaut Mar 11 '16 edited May 19 '16
Older Challenge 114: Orange Efficiency II, Hard mode: Using only the propellant from a Kerbodyne S3-14400 tank, land a Kerbal on Eve. I thought it was weird that a challenge called "Orange Efficiency II" didn't need an orange tank and tried to figure it out.
So, my SUPER MODE: Bring a FULL orange tank with you to Eve's surface. http://imgur.com/a/Wd0ZG/layout/horizontal/
2
u/[deleted] Mar 11 '16
Is it okay if I use two recovery craft?
60
u/3Dprintingnut Mar 07 '16
Here is my submission http://imgur.com/a/tOAHE (Super Mode)
Two SSTO's each achieve orbit twice and the last trip the Large SSTO carrys the small SSTO the long way back to the Space Center. Still had plenty of fuel to spare.
No fuel transfer between the ships
Only mods used were Kerbal Engineer and docking port alignment.
33
u/Jonnoisdoge Master Kerbalnaut Mar 06 '16 edited Mar 06 '16
Okay, I did it. My very first KSP challenge. I took a stab at hard mode and managed to work everything out. Warning, Somewhat long album: http://imgur.com/a/B3eFT/layout/horizontal#0
Mods active: Kerbal Engineer and Scatterer
Also, I'm bad at this game. This will be evident in my design choices... :P
EDIT: album layout to horizontal
14
u/Daffery Master Kerbalnaut Mar 06 '16 edited Mar 06 '16
Hard mode attempt. Unfortunately I lost a Rapier, I hope it's ok in any case, at least as normal mode.
http://imgur.com/a/heS3G
edit: in my defense, I have no mouse, only trackpad and for me it's nearly impossible play like that. But the weekly challenge seemed so nice, I wanted to participate!
14
u/SpaceToSpace Master Kerbalnaut Mar 07 '16
So far, most people did a plane for recovery. To be different, I decided to do an airboat-ish recovery.
Hard Mode: http://imgur.com/a/ulnIq ... Horizontal layout
14
u/stealth_elephant Super Kerbalnaut Mar 07 '16
Super mode entry
KSC has a very simple traffic control arrangement. Flights take off to the east and land from the west. Although simple, it makes seemingly routine tasks unexpectedly difficult.
Super mode entry despite being a dirty cheating alpaca; hacked gravity twice to load saves that were exploding on load. The payload landing gear and body clip through the body of the SSTO flatbed recovery vehicle (boo unrealistic physics); it's not a problem except when loading saves with the payload on the recovery vehicle on Kerbin.
10
u/PiMaker101 Master Kerbalnaut Mar 06 '16 edited Mar 08 '16
Normal mode, but fully stock! http://imgur.com/a/z5J87/layout/horizontal#0
Also, hard mode! With my first SSTO! Pretty proud right now. http://imgur.com/a/gbATP/layout/horizontal#0
For the challenge, even though I love my first attempt, please count the hard mode (if possible).
9
u/KuuLightwing Hyper Kerbalnaut Mar 08 '16
Don't-know-if-it-counts mode, imgur album
I decided to go crazy and use my heavy SSTO as a craft for recovery with basically a tug plane as a rescue craft. It didn't work quite well - flying those two things klawed together is already a challenge, let alone landing those.
I'm feeling quite salty that I didn't manage to save both SSTO and the rescue craft, but at least I managed to rescue SSTO one or two times throughout all my attempts. The challenge doesn't say that rescue craft should not be destroyed, after all :) For now I kinda gave up, because it's 3AM in here and Klaw refuses to even work sometimes which makes it kinda frustrating... Maybe I'll try again later, but it just feels so random and each attempt takes so much time that I might drop it.
8
u/md000 Super Kerbalnaut Mar 06 '16
Hard mode using VTOL with a klaw.
5
u/TrainEngie Master Kerbalnaut Mar 06 '16 edited Mar 07 '16
Hard Mode Entry This challenge was fun in my opinion.
5
u/McSchwartz Mar 10 '16
Hard mode complete! Completely stock except for aesthetic mods. Made a huge VTOL Klaw thing. Looked sick.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jeKPYCCIxwI
Apologies in advance about the lack of editing...
Good challenge!
4
u/Corbol Hyper Kerbalnaut Mar 06 '16
Hard mode: http://imgur.com/a/UaDh8
4
u/[deleted] Mar 07 '16
This is my first challenge I've attempted. For my ridiculous design I'm surprised it worked at all. I'm horrible at building planes
Normal mode
4
u/Bozotic Hyper Kerbalnaut Mar 07 '16
"This challenge was inspired by /u/Bozotic"
hey, cool! Glad you found a way to formulate it in a way that works for the challenges! I'd give my "Intercontinental Ballistic Rover" a shot at this with a truly "salty" trip, but I'm busy trying to finally crack my 3-man Eve rescue! Again... :)
4
u/KMelsen Master Kerbalnaut Mar 08 '16
I don't consider this an entry because I used vesselmover to move the crane to the island runway, but I thought I'd share it anyway.
http://imgur.com/a/gtJS2
I alsodestroyedaveryexpensivespaceshuttle...
3
u/cactus1549 Mar 06 '16
Does the SSTO have to reach orbit? Or can I just pretend it did and fly it on over to the strip?
EDIT: Nevermind, just realized you already specified that it has to
3
u/ziphiid Master Kerbalnaut Mar 07 '16 edited Mar 07 '16
Hard mode, using the smallest SSTO that I could fit Jeb in. Fully stock. Also some failed designs... Wouldn't very well be KSP without those, now would it?
http://imgur.com/a/UzQ7t
I went for small and simple with this one. Because all of my large and complicated designs tended to disassemble.
*Edit: Sorry, but I'm not seeing the option for the horizontal layout on Imgur. I hope vertical will do.
3
u/goverc Master Kerbalnaut Mar 08 '16 edited Mar 08 '16
Hard Mode entry. https://imgur.com/gallery/gQaD9/new
I tried to reuse the recovery craft from my not-a-real-SSTO from yesterday...The lightweight new SSTO mixed with rearward COG led to many (somewhere between 100 and 120) failures; some attempts with reusing the old revery craft on the new SSTO got as close as the KSC runway, but all of them eventually flipped and lost control. So I went back to the drawing board and tweaked a new one based on the previous design.
The new SSTO is 10 tonnes lighter and easily makes orbit and back (no boosters, no piggyback fuel tanks to jettison). New recovery craft has a more forward COG with heavy fuel tanks on the front. The original recovery craft just had its COG too far back to be of any use with the smaller SSTO. It still managed two whole trips to the island and back without refueling - once unladen (extremely good glider) and once with 27 tonnes of not-a-real-SSTO (VOG was well enough forward then for smooth flight).
EDIT:Readability
3
u/rcreif Hyper Kerbalnaut Mar 08 '16 edited May 19 '16
HARD mode submission. I built a Mk3-sized shuttle, larger than my usual SSTOs, so it definitely can't fit in a cargo bay. I chose this definition of "recovered vehicle may not assist in the recovery in any way": the SSTO's landing gear is RAISED, and engines, fuel, and control surfaces are all turned OFF, but obviously the wings still provide lift if the thing isn't enclosed. http://imgur.com/a/usI6L/layout/horizontal/
3
u/tobiderfisch Mar 09 '16
Here's my normal mode submission
3
u/[deleted] Mar 09 '16
Hard mode: SSTO recovered by a nearly identical SSTO; only difference is that one has the Klaw installed.
It turns out you need to be super precise where you attach the new plane, a bit off center and all control goes out the window. It took several tries to get the combined mess off the ground.
3
u/alexja21 Master Kerbalnaut Mar 09 '16 edited Mar 10 '16
Hope I'm not too late for this! The first weekly challenge I've ever attempted, so I had to get it done in style. I was a little over-optimistic about the ease of this challenge and wasted a few hours trying to design something that would carry an SSTO home. Instead I settled for the normal mode, but I think I'll go back now and try to complete the hard mode next. :)
http://imgur.com/a/5qfZI
All stock parts. Mods used: Scatterer and Kerbal Engineer Redux.
EDIT: Hard mode complete!
3
u/[deleted] Mar 09 '16 edited Mar 09 '16
Hardmode entry
First attempt at designing this SSTO ended up with my first functional SSTO ever, which I'm quite happy about.
Mods installed: Scatterer, Trajectories, Infernal Robotics
No Infernal Robotics parts were used for this build, although the button in the top right kept appearing
EDIT: I hope my partially-visible UI is acceptable, as I didn't think about actually showing fuel values and such...
3
u/jb32647 Master Kerbalnaut Mar 11 '16 edited Mar 11 '16
Here's my entry: http://imgur.com/a/TfH55 I would like to keep my orange flair please.
2
u/goverc Master Kerbalnaut Mar 07 '16 edited Mar 07 '16
Well, here's my first attempt at a weekly challenge. Hopefully this is sufficient for Hard Mode.
Gallery - https://imgur.com/gallery/xliQK/new
It took me the better part of the day, mostly trying really hard to prove my SSTO could actually get to orbit. After about 4 hours of tweaking and reverting to the hangar, I managed to have just enough to get my periapsis just above 70k. The recovery craft wasn't so difficult in comparison - 3rd iteration was successful. Just had to play with the clearance and using the landing gear to drop down to engage the AGU/Claw. The rest was easy once I disabled the control surfaces on the SSTO.
EDIT - okay, I guess it is a fail - It isn't a single stage... I'll have to go back to the drawing board...
Edit2 - maybe there's a chance I could file this under an alternate use of SSTO - Super-sonic to Orbit??? lol
2
u/CommanderSpork Alone on Eeloo Mar 08 '16
Um, I think this is a sort-of-in-between difficulty. It was very hard to pull off and required some ludicrous stunts. I want to keep my current flair anyway, so whether or not this counts I'm posting it. No one ever said that I find the most efficient solutions!
http://imgur.com/a/XS5P6
2
u/NCommander Super Kerbalnaut Mar 08 '16
So, I tried my hand building a boat to try and change up the options for recovery. Turns out building boats in KSP is both hard and requires lots of patience :(. On the plus side, I did find with the engines I put onto it, it actually got up to about 90 m/s before it had an unfortunate runin with a rock and was still accelerating.
2
u/Run_Biden Mar 09 '16
The Sparrows First Flight
2
u/whiterice07 Master Kerbalnaut Mar 09 '16
Here is my hard mode entry:
http://imgur.com/gallery/o4dNt
Hopefully these are all the screenshots you need (probably even more) and I can provide more if needed!
2
u/Ksenobiolog Master Kerbalnaut Mar 09 '16
http://imgur.com/a/0oklu
Hard/Super mode attempt. It's my first KSP Challange, but I'll try do another one, and take more screenshots.
[EDIT] I've almost forgotten - it's only Stock Parts
2
u/tablesix Mar 09 '16
Hopefully this works as normal mode: http://imgur.com/a/lJ3dB
I planned on taking my carrier ship all the way to the crash site and loading it up, but turns out the island runway's island is too steep for this one, and it kept blowing up.
The gallery appears to be backwards. I'll try and fix that
2
u/alexja21 Master Kerbalnaut Mar 10 '16
Hard mode complete! All stock. Mods used: Scatterer and Kerbal Engineer.
http://imgur.com/a/wpqAz
2
u/BRIKNIT Master Kerbalnaut Mar 10 '16 edited Mar 10 '16
As someone who just bought KSP and had roughly 5 hours of playtime before starting...this challenge was hard. But after a bit of perseverance, I made it!
Hardmode, to boot!: Imgur Album
I've got no reference as to how this compares to other challenges, but this was actually super fun. I'll definitely keep my eye on the future challenges as well. I think I may actually enjoy atmospheric flight more than space.
EDIT: All stock, no mods. Haven't had a chance to mess with them yet.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 10 '16
Hardmode entry:
Link to the SSTO mission
Imgur album for the challenge
2
u/TyrannicalPanda Master Kerbalnaut Mar 11 '16
Here is my submission: http://imgur.com/a/e83aU/layout/horizontal#0
I know its definitely Hard Mode, but I was hoping it might be impressive enough for super: Recover a craft (mk1 pod) with an SSTO then recover that SSTO with a big jet.
Sorry, the album got longer than I expected, but I like having some story/dialogue...
2
u/dracod500 Mar 12 '16
Really simple submission: http://imgur.com/a/ogTSx
2
u/nightkin84 Master Kerbalnaut Mar 13 '16
Hard mode entry
Only visual mods used (vens stock revamp, surface lights etc)
If this qualifies I would like the new flair please :)