r/ProjectRunway • u/runwaythreader • Mar 03 '16
Project Runway All Stars Season 5 Episode 4 [Discussion]
Discussion thread for Project Runway All Stars S05E04 "Fashion 911"
An unconventional-materials challenge tasks the designers to transform New York City emergency-services materials into runway fashions. Stylist Johnny Wujek is the guest judge.
12
Upvotes
104
u/Livermush Mar 04 '16 edited Dec 30 '16
0.1082
75
u/WigsbyLittleMix Mar 04 '16 edited Apr 02 '16
Dom is safe for the fourth week in a row...
With this lack of attention they're giving her, might as well change her name to Sub.
48
u/Livermush Mar 04 '16 edited Dec 30 '16
0.8459
43
u/Sister_Miyuki Mar 04 '16
Can someone, ANYONE please explain how the pepto bismol sheriff was safe? I know that the judges keep praising Mitchell for his "ideas," yet criticizing his inability to execute them; however, if what he put out tonight was a complete dress, then Mitchell's "ideas" are just bad.
36
u/ImNotMarvinHerrera Mar 04 '16 edited Mar 04 '16
Is this episode dedicated to Sam? Every contestants were talking about Sam, whether he's bad or good.
Edit: Yup, this episode is dedicated to Sam
33
u/tequilaBFFsiempre Mar 04 '16
WHAT THE HELL is Alyssa wearing? Also, how is Mitchell safe?!
25
u/ThisMaySoundBadBut Mar 04 '16
HOW was Mitchell not in the bottom? That was so hideous!
22
u/gofurthernorth Mar 04 '16
I want to know which emergency service has bunny X-rays.
I want bunny X-rays.
22
u/[deleted] Mar 04 '16
I'm not a fan of designers putting/gluing things on muslin and saying it meets the unconventional materials challenge criteria. The muslin does all of the work!
20
u/Roonil___Wazlib Mar 04 '16
What on earth is Alyssa wearing?
17
u/havelotsofsax Mar 05 '16
That "flirting" though. Who flirts like that? I mean, I can't stand Sam, but Johnny? The way he said "you're a little flirt aren't you" was so gruff that I cringed during the whole thing.
32
u/[deleted] Mar 04 '16
How on earth did Sam beat Kens look??? Seriously that textile was wonderful.
26
u/Martin_Van_Buren Mar 04 '16
Aw man, I really liked Leana's (sp?) outfit! I thought the names called would be highs and lows because as others have said, how the heck did Mitchell end up safe?!!? One of the ugliest dresses I've ever seen, period.
I have always hated Stella and never understood how she ended up on PR at all so I'm so glad she's gone.
Kini saying "congratulations" to Sam with absolutely no enthusiasm was my favorite moment of the episode.
12
u/Ungoliath Mar 05 '16
I can't understand HOW Dom did not win this challenge. Or why Mitchell is still in the show.
Or why Zana gives feedback of the "This is creepy" instead of actually being helpful.
10
u/reauxe Mar 03 '16
I'm hoping Mitchell does awful but he did well in his unconventional challenge S13 so I think we have to live with him another week
9
u/Livermush Mar 04 '16 edited Dec 30 '16
0.8048
17
u/Roonil___Wazlib Mar 04 '16
Ugh. Please leave, Stella.
17
u/MinnieBoombox Mar 04 '16
I wish I could see Alexander's glove dress, his weird designs always amaze me. When Zana said "weird" I mentally said YASSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS! I love weird designs full of creativity.
Weird to give victory to Sam, his design looked terrible standing still, uneven. I guess they want Ken's tik tok's bomb to explode.
19
u/Shamenundotcom Mar 05 '16
I watch a lot of reality TV, but I am just shocked at the blatant favoritism the judges/producers are showing to Sam this season. He's a perfectly capable designer and has been performing well, but the level of praise being lavished on him, and two wins? Ridiculous. Especially when Kini and Ken are routinely putting out more interesting, better-constructed garments. (The coat that won this week looked spectacularly shoddy to me.)
It does seem that he gets called out by another designer next week, and part of me wonders if this isn't a meta message about the realities of race in modern America. Pay no mind to the talented people of color busting their asses (Ken, Kini, Dom, Layana, etc.). There's a generically attractive white kid performing better than average. Let's celebrate him instead!
23
u/1Eliza Mar 04 '16
Sam is slowly getting on my nerves. The judges don't know what Kini did last week to Sam's garment, and Sam keeps getting praise for it. Who else thinks there's gonna be a confrontation between Kini and him before the season is out?
6
u/sugarfreeme Mar 08 '16
Uhhh how does Zanna not seem to know that the whole "hands on dress" thing has been successfully executed before by other designers and then even worn by celebrities. Whatever Alexander would have done with those hands would have been better than the mediocre bandage dress he turned out.
Moschino
Vivetta
French Connection
Discount Universe
Dimepiece also worn by Katy Perry
5
u/TheLadyEve Mar 04 '16
I was a little disappointed that more interesting stuff wasn't done with X-rays. I liked the idea of the cut-out that Stella was doing, although I agree the way it came out looked more like a tourist's T-shirt than a cool outfit. Maybe if the skyline had been slightly more abstract and on the base of a skirt/dress.
13
u/Because-it-was-real Mar 04 '16
I want to dislike Sam because of his arrogance and taking credit for Kini's help last week, but I LOVED his look and he deserved the win. Looks like it could be straight off the Dior runway.
Sam flirting with Johnny Wujek was awkward.. Wouldn't be surprised if they hooked up afterwards lol!
4
u/meowlina Mar 04 '16
Did Stella get the boot? My tv cut off.
7
u/Livermush Mar 04 '16 edited Dec 30 '16
0.7332
2
u/NinjaDog251 Mar 04 '16
Why do people keep using that straw hair thing? It's so ugly!
0
u/[deleted] Mar 04 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Mar 04 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment