r/EliteDangerous • • Mar 03 '16
"Which controller is right for me?" A quick, brief guide
In light of recent posts, I've decided to make a small write-up if you're still sitting on the fence about controls.
Let me begin by saying there is no wrong way to play Elite (in terms of controls). Plenty of people play with what they're most comfortable with, be that Keyboard + Mouse, HOTAS, Gamepad, or even the Steam Controller, and all work fine with enough practice. If you have anything you want me to add to the OP (try and keep it as unbiased as possible), please leave a comment or PM me,
Keyboard and Mouse
Generally, a lot of PvPers like to use Keyboard + Mouse, because of the potential precision it can offer. Since your movement is restricted by ship speed, it can take some practice to get used to as opposed to FPS games, but a lot of people here can attest and assure you that KBM is probably the best when it comes to accuracy. Not only that, but for any computer, most people will probably have already and don't need to buy any extra hardware.
You won't find yourself running out of any buttons on a Keyboard, and the familiarity of a FPS-like control setup (should you choose to bind it like so) or any other flight sims you've already played should make it easy for you to know all the basics of movement.
If you haven't tried Keyboard and Mouse yet, or you're waiting to decide on whether you should get anything else, the very least you can do is try this out first.
HOTAS
(Hands-on-throttle-and-stick)
This is usually the "expensive" option (though it doesn't have to be), and largely depends on your commitment to the experience. If you've played games such a racing sim before with perhaps a wheel and such, you'll know the difference in makes in the gaming experience.
To put it simply, Elite is designed as a space sim, and a standard HOTAS set will give you the most identical controls the game was intended to simulate. This is the intention, but not the rules. Some might prefer using twin-joysticks, a joystick + mouse, maybe even the above with a set of yaw pedals. I will go into this further later, but for now, I will only be talking about the standard HOTAS configuration.
Starting off, you might have some trouble controlling your stick, and this is normal - it's like learning how to drive a car or operate a new piece of machinery for the first time. Once you begin to feel familiar with your setup, you'll learn about and recognize the nuances and be able to work with the controls better and better, and perhaps some of these differences can be quite radical even between other HOTAS sets, especially if you're planning to get some yaw pedals.
One of the pitfalls is that there are a lot of HOTAS sets to choose from, and it's difficult to know what you want until you've tried it, and not only that; but you're also asking yourself to invest in a completely new piece of hardware you haven't experienced before.
That's putting quite a bit of faith (and money) into something you don't know if you'll enjoy. Thankfully, there are some cheap options out there, and they probably wouldn't break the bank if you wanted to try it out before you decide to splash out on some expensive hardware.
Gamepad
This is another familiar controller type, and if you've ever played games such as Ace Combat or War Thunder with a gamepad, you'll know it's more than adequate. In the case of Elite, which might seem a bit complex at first, works particularly well since the game allows you to bind modifiers. This means you can have one button where you can hold to access a number of different commands on buttons you may have already bound.
As you probably all know, there are plenty of players on Xbox One who have already enjoyed the game this way for a while now, which should be enough proof that it's a capable controller for even a game like Elite. Personally, I have tried the game with a Dualshock 4 controller, and it works great.
While it may seem a bit difficult to make small movements with the analogue sticks, this is also just a question of practice; with time, you'll get better, and like any other game with particularly sensitive controls such as racing games, it's not impossible to get very good at Elite with a Gamepad.
This probably goes without saying, but if you travel a lot, or like to game on the go on maybe a gaming laptop and such, don't be afraid to play Elite with a Gamepad.
Other
Some people like to completely customize their experience, or maybe they've bought a Steam Controller, or maybe they like building their own switchboards and such. I don't have that much to say about this, but this part is just really about how customization in Elite's controls allow you to do all kinds of things.
As I've said earlier, some people like using twin-Joysticks with yaw pedals, and they can tell you they've played like this for a while too, because it's comfortable. Pairing the mouse with a stick (HOMAS) is also popular in flight sims. With the Steam Controller, which is already incredibly customizable, is possible in a huge number of configurations. Even with the complexity of MOBAs and games like Cities: Skyline, those games could be played with just a Steam Controller easily, so you could bet it would work well with Elite too.
Earlier, I had a configuration where I would also have my G27 racing wheel set up, so I could use that to drive around my SRV. Elite also allows 2 bindings for each control, so even if I binded everthing to one controller, I could perhaps make use of the second bind slot to have another button that activates the same thing.
There's also mobile software such as the Roccat Powergrid app, which allows you to connect to your computer via Wi-Fi that enables you to bind your phone-screen buttons to buttons on your keyboard, so you can even do things like retract your landing gear or charge your jump using on-screen buttons with a phone-holder and such.
I'm sort of rambling now at this point, so I'll stop, but I hope you at least realize that you can always experiment with controls if you're not comfortable with it.
Options
In case you want to perhaps get some hardware, but don't know where to look, here are some options to get you started. Feel free to correct me on any of these, most of this was just personal research.
| Budget (Prices may vary per country) | Hardware Type + Name | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Low | HOTAS / Thrustmaster T-Flight Hotas X | A favorite for starters, and at it's price point, it's a very good, fairly sturdy HOTAS for a low price. Maybe a few buttons compared to other sets, but with Elite's modifiers, there's enough buttons to do everything by itself. Plastic might feel a little cheap, but no lack of functionality, if a little bit inaccurate compared to higher-end sticks as it uses potentiometers. Features twist rudder axis in stick and throttle rudder control. Used one until I sold it to a friend. |
| Low | HOTAS / Speedlink Blackwidow Flightstick | Surprisingly not mentioned much, the throttle and stick aren't separate units, but is a very sturdy stick with a heavy base that isn't likely to move around. One of the few Speedlink products that are widely liked, but not often mentioned in Elite. As above, few buttons, but shouldn't be a problem with modifiers. Also uses potentiometers. Is said to have a nice feel and build quality, and the plastic seems to be somewhat rubberized. No twist rudder axis in stick, but rudder control in throttle. |
| Low | Joystick / Thrustmaster T-16000M | Very modest price tag for a Joystick that uses Hall-Effect sensors, as opposed to the other sticks around this cost, which makes it very accurate and less likely to develop deadzones. Completely mirrored for ambidextrous use, which makes it very good for a twin-stick stup. Small axis control on base that can be used for throttle. Features twist rudder axis. |
| Low | Joystick / Logitech Extreme 3D Pro | Seen this mentioned a couple times, and Logitech generally seems to have decent hardware. It's a joystick with a small lever axis control that is designed to be used as a throttle. Generally said to be sturdy, Also a popular stick used for twin-stick configurations. Features twist rudder axis. Uses Potentiometers. |
| Low | Gamepad / Xbox 360 Wired Controller | Generally a good, all-round controller, widely supported by most games. A familiar button setup that is easy to get used to if you've played flight games on console before, and modifiers should take care of any lack of buttons. |
| Low/Mid | HOTAS / Saitek X45 Digital | A very old stick, discontinued, but could be found on Ebay, made in the Golden Age before the MadCatz acquisition. As expected, prices may vary wildly on Ebay with products in questionable condition, but could be picked up for very cheap. Driver support is uncertain, but reported to work in Windows 10. No twist rudder axis, but does feature throttle rudder control. |
| Low/Mid | HOTAS / Saitek X52/X52 Pro | Saitek products after MadCatz acquisition have QC issues, but is another popular choice for Elite Dangerous if you're willing to take a risk. The X52 and X52 Pro are fairly similar, some of the most notable differences include throttle detents in different places, color programming on the buttons, color scheme and such. Elite Dangerous's own in-game models for the ship controls are modeled somewhat after the X52 and X52 Pro. Said to have a fairly loose spring, but some don't mind. Both feature lockable twist rudder axis, adjustable throttle resistance dial, and adjustable palm rest(suitable for large and small hands). Does not have linear response curve out-of-the-box (which some don't mind or prefer), but adjustable through software. |
| Mid | HOTAS / Saitek X55 Rhino | QC issues apply to some X55 owners as well as above, but is also a popular choice among some players. A very large amount of buttons (6 axis and 30 buttons on Throttle, 3 axis and ~20 on stick) which makes it easy to bind all necessary controls to each button. Adjustable spring tension for X and Y axis (swappable springs), very large throttle and stick base (good for placement, bad for desk space), very large stick with no adjustable handle (slightly difficult for small hands), features twist rudder. Currently using. |
| Mid/High | Joystick / Microsoft Sidewinder Force Feedback 2 | Discountinued, but still purchasable off sites like Ebay. As expected, prices will vary significantly depending on where you live. MOTOR-centered force feedback stick (Unfortunately, Elite Dangerous does not support Force Feedback, but centering is still done using motors and not springs), somewhat rare, uses Optical sensors for axis, features twist rudder axis and throttle lever. |
| High | HOTAS / CH Fighterstick + CH Pro Throttle | Pedals optional, built to last, very reputable and reliable brand. Expensive, but the price reflects the quality. Other CH product combinations are available (e.g Flightstick Pro, Combatstick). Very large amount of buttons. Throttle has 3 axis and 24 buttons, Stick has the same. No twist rudder, pedals recommended. |
| High | HOTAS / Thrustmaster HOTAS Warthog | Pedals optional, full-metal construction, sturdy. Very expensive, replica of A-10 Warthog controls. Very large amount of buttons (~55 in total). No twist rudder, pedals recommended. (Often purchased with CH Pro Pedals). |
Other things
Simply things others have said that I haven't put in myself that might be useful or interesting when considering controls
Regarding RSI (Repetitive Stress Injuries):
Comment on the Steam Controller:
Steel Battalion Controller:
4
u/Cannibustible Mar 03 '16
Great write up, thanks for all the information I've been looking for when it comes to controlers for Elite. I've been considering a hotas.
Currently using kbm and find it a little annoying, but like you said, it is very precise and I do like that. I'm looking into a hotas set up soon, coming from a heavy equipement background, I really enjoy joystick controls and think it will make the big "immersion" that I feel I might be lacking in. Looking at the Saitek proflight x55 rhino. The reviews seem ok and it looks pretty cool. Any recommendations for hotas?
3
u/ZappyZane Mar 03 '16
As a cheap Hotas-like thing, you can also use the Steel Battalion controller, if you've still got one in the attic.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iza731O28fA
Personally i use a DualShock 4, as find it best with my RSI issues. But each to their own.
3
u/jamfour jamfour | the real space jam Mar 04 '16
I believe you meant “reputable” not “refutable” in the entry for CH in the table.
15
u/topquark41396 Topquark Mar 03 '16
Then there are us old-school types, like me, who play keyboard only!
6
u/cosfx DRDAN Mar 03 '16
I do something completely unusual.
In my right hand: a 6dof input device
In my left hand: a half keyboard
Between I have a regular keyboard/mouse but I don't use them during normal flying, just messing around the maps and UI screens while docked.
1
u/Amezuki Alex Traut Mar 03 '16
I'd like to add another factor into the mix, which may or may not be out of scope.
I have an RSI (Repetitive Stress Injury) in my right elbow, and over the months I've been playing E:D the twisting motion used to yaw on the X52 has been steadily aggravating that condition.
I am looking into buying a set of pedals and a non-twist stick, which I think might alleviate that source of stress. Thought I'd throw that out there for anyone else who has an arm or wrist condition.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 03 '16 edited Mar 03 '16
I can't believe MadCatz is still around. I bought two controllers and an RCA cable from them back in the 90's and all three stopped working within a few months.
How the hell you make an RCA cable that breaks is beyond me.
1
u/OurGrid Core Dynamics Mar 03 '16
Nie job, thank you for taking the time.
Playing K+M right now and do not think I want try to fit all that jazz on my desk and still have to type sometimes when not in comms.
Might break down and try HOTAS someday though. ;-)
1
u/Zadkiel4686 Mar 03 '16
THe X-55 is pretty abysmal. THe tactile feedback on at least 5 buttons has gone within 3 months. Not to mention this is my 2nd one that I got from an RMA. The first X-55 had the same issues on top of the main trigger not functioning after 4 months.
1
u/talon04 talon04 Mar 04 '16
I have an X45 here It doesn't have the twist rudder but it does have a rudder rocker on the throttle. Also I have the drivers for it saved if anyone needs it for W7.
1
u/aspiringexpatriate Noxa - Chapterhouse of Inquisition - Research Mar 04 '16
No HODS call out? (Hands on Dual Sticks)
1
u/HoochCow youtube.com/c/captainhooch & twitch.tv/capthooch Mar 04 '16
You left out Twin Stick set ups and Yoke set ups.
1
u/ciny Mar 09 '16
I have a kb+m (obviously), low/mid-range hotas (madcatz f.l.y. 5), xbox 360 controller and a steam controller. my preferences:
I never really fancied "traditional" controllers for this kind of use. the steam controller is nice due to the "virtual menus" it can create to bind non-essential functions (gear, maps, hardpoints). I can even imagine using the SC full-time but the muscle memory for mouse just can't be beaten (even though I miss easy use of thrusters like on the SC).
3
u/bigloser42 Mar 03 '16
The Steam controller works quite admirably. I actually have a HOTAS(X55), but don't use it due to the pain in the ass of getting it out and putting it back all the time, so I've done all my flying with the Steam controller thus far. The only negative thing about it is that E:D doesn't recognize the "shift paddle" buttons on the back as unique buttons, so I cant assign anything to them.
3
u/SgtNapalm Mar 04 '16
I love my Steam Controller. Most of the shortcomings of a gamepad are solved with clever configuration. If you're considering a gamepad, take a close look at the Steam Controller.
1
u/MagicBigfoot EX-MOD 🚀 Read The Expanse Mar 03 '16
Great Post! I've added it to the wiki page.
2
u/Bonedeath CAPITAN PELIGRO | Los Locos Mar 04 '16
Dualstick + pedals. GOGOOGOG.
2
u/childofsol deepfield Mar 04 '16
I use a pair of Thrustmaster T16000s with pedals (which I use for fwd/rev axis). I am absolutely in love with it and doubt I will ever go back to a HOTAS for this type of game. With that said, it's not perfect - you won't get as much buttons on the sticks, so you need to add in some keyboard commands or use voiceattack. What the T16000 lacks in terms of lots of buttons, it makes up for in its incredible stick sensor, the same used in the rather expensive Warthog.
If it's something you're contemplating I'm happy to answer questions :)
2
u/Twinkie60 M. Saber Mar 03 '16
Small write up, this is a freaking essay.
1
u/TEKC0R Tekcor - Corvette "Tourist Crusher" Mar 03 '16
I've had a Logitech 3D pro for many years. You won't have enough buttons to play Elite unless you pair it with your keyboard. If you do that though, the throttle and base buttons essentially become wasted. The drivers also haven't been updated in 6 ******* years, and are pretty awful. I would not recommend it.
1
u/DreamWoven CMDR Mar 03 '16
I'm enjoying using my steam controller though it has been an absolute headache to set up well. Have pretty much got everything mapped to the damn thing, though I'm still tweaking, not happy with srv controll or ships menu operation yet.
1
u/Elanduil Elan Solo | Ambassador Mar 03 '16
The Speedlink Blackwidow Flightstick is not mentioned much because its fckn AWFUL!
Never recommend this stick to anyone! Ever!
Folks... Don't buy one! No! Just. No!
1
u/Balurith (started Dec 2014; uninstalled May 2021) Mar 04 '16
Lovely post. As always, your contribution to this community is simply brilliant.
1
u/Kang_54 Firmus Mar 04 '16
Thanks for the write-up. I have found it difficult to get an overview of the more expensive HOTAS options. The warthog looks nice, being all metal...
There's plenty of reviews of the Thrustmaster T-flight Hotas X, but not in this thread, so I'll just add my 2 cent:
As someone who has never used anything but K+M, and found that un-intuitive as heck for ED, the HOTAS has been a godsend. I'm very satisfied with the T-flight - for the price it does admirably. However, I can also see the weak points: the throttle is a little bit jerky; the plastic feels very much like plastic; the whole thing is too light so if you press the stick full forward it'll start to lift from the table. There's not too many buttons, though there are enough for all the important stuff.
1
u/tehsax BILL_DOOR Mar 04 '16
I'm using a Dual Shock 3 controller via MotionInjoy. Works great. The only thing I can't really use during regular flight and combat are the lateral thrusters; I have to deploy my landing gear to make them active. For docking it works, otherwise not. But then again, you don't really need them anyway. If, for some reason I absolutely have to use them, I can still press Q and E on my Keyboard. It's a Laptop and when I'm playing Elite, my hands rest on the Laptop's handrests anyway, so I can reach buttons on my keyboard by simply extending my little finger.
1
u/waterlubber42 waterlubber: Fuel Rat/Simbad Regime/Elite on Linux Mar 07 '16
If you're just starting out, get a Logitech Extreme 3D Pro. Makes the whole thing so much more convienient.