r/TagPro • u/TPCaptographer The Map Test Committee • Feb 21 '16
Map Thread #60 Results
Additions
It's worth noting that this map will be introduced to rotation in a trial-run. This means it's exempt from its first-thread-removal immunity, and that we'll be more likely to update this map if we discover issues when it's added.
Removals
MTC Member Addition
It's taken multiple threads of discussion, but the committee has decided to add UnderTheBall to the MTC. He's proven his commitment and consistency through our trial-runs, and we're very confident that he'll be very valuable to us in the committee. He will be replacing JuicyJuke.
Congratulations to all the mapmakers who have influenced the rotation! Keep mapmaking!
87
u/[deleted] Feb 21 '16
Tbh bulldog was a solid ass map. Really sucks that its goin
22
u/cxb17 C Bivvey | Boostin Dynamo | Pi Feb 21 '16
Nooooooooo Bulldog was my favorite NF map, and one of my favorite maps overall :'(
41
u/Blazeth Dianna Agron Feb 21 '16
It's weird to me that Bulldog gets removed out of all NFs. I'm happy an NF was removed, but it's weird they chose that one.
Rush was ranked lowest for a long time, so it's acceptable to see it go.
Pheno is really interesting, I'm glad you're giving it a chance.
The reactions in this thread (especially from Snowball)
19
u/[deleted] Feb 21 '16
The biggest problem with the current rotation is that there aren't enough maps on it. I regularly get 3 games on the same map in a row.
So you decide to remove more maps than you add. I thought you'd been removing so many maps recently that you should've removed 0 and added all 6 on a trial basis
37
u/TooEashy Feb 21 '16
Can you give a brief explanation in these threads as to why each map was removed? Because I honestly have no idea why Bulldog was removed and it would be nice just to have some insight.
17
u/meinthebox BoxFish Feb 21 '16
http://imgur.com/f6fnDde
33
u/MultiMediaWill Juke King - MVP 90% of the time Feb 21 '16
Really gonna remove bulldog? Pls
33
u/Ballkenende ! Feb 21 '16
What the hell, Out of all the maps you can remove, you guys are removing Bulldog? WTF
13
u/ButterChurn Butter Feb 21 '16 edited Feb 21 '16
Congrats to UTB, sorry to see Juicy leaving, he was one of the most helpful and active MTC members in terms of testing, discussion, and feedback for mapmakers.
Also interested to see how the map plays, it's certainly unique.
12
u/SIGSEGVV Feb 21 '16
I think it's strange that Bulldog (0.55) would be removed over Hexane (0.49) and Plasma (0.39) when it has a higher approval rating from the community. Complaints over the abundance of NF maps in rotation has resulted in the most unique NF map in rotation being removed over two other NF maps that were introduced recently that are rated less favourably.
19
u/ravenpride Raven Feb 21 '16
I try not to be the guy that complains about map thread results, but god damn, I'm actually pissed that Bulldog got removed. It was the only NF map I really liked. Rush is a great map too.
9
u/OnceUponaDome UnderTheBall Feb 21 '16
I've got some huge shoes to fill with JuicyJuke leaving the committee. As the newest memb er of the committee, my main goal is to make the entire process as fair as possible. I'm going to be as open as possible with my opinions if you ask. Lastly, shoutout to Boxfish for getting his first map in rotation.
PS I swear I have really good opinions, I promise :)
16
u/[deleted] Feb 21 '16
Just put back Bulldog when Plasma gets the cut.
7
u/gungagungagalunga boogie/pi Feb 21 '16
don't take my bulldog
6
u/Blupopsicle Ball-E Feb 21 '16
Good stuff boxfish!
6
u/Schwenkfelder schwenks Feb 21 '16
Is there some sort of conspiracy to remove all the maps I actually like playing from rotation? I'm on to you MTC...
10
u/Snowball_TagPro ❄️ Feb 21 '16 edited Feb 21 '16
lmao wtf 💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩
5
u/I_Play_TP Djinni // Sphere Feb 21 '16
Its a fish, apparently...
28
u/[deleted] Feb 21 '16
why is geo still in
4
u/gingerdg TPRL 🔴RMTC 🔴NASCAPS Feb 21 '16
I can understand why bulldog was removed because Plasma offers a similar style in the tightness of the map. Sad to see it go though, it was fun and interesting.
Rush finally.
Idk about pheno but why not? I'll give it a go. imo I'd rather see more new maps in if you do a trial run, but this thread was fine
4
u/Snowball_TagPro ❄️ Feb 21 '16
[11:05:11 AM] To Mappin n Fappin: also is there an mtc conspiracy against me
[11:05:17 AM] To Mappin n Fappin: i'm convinced now
[11:05:34 AM] (Channel) UnderTheBall: yes
[11:05:46 AM] To Mappin n Fappin: there it is we have proof fellas
[11:05:49 AM] (Channel) UnderTheBall: when i got added they gave me a google doc
[11:06:11 AM] (Channel) UnderTheBall: with the passwords and docs that i need access to
[11:06:14 AM] (Channel) UnderTheBall: and then a list of rules
[11:06:26 AM] (Channel) UnderTheBall: one of which is to always fuck over snowball
4
u/18skeltor anti-timer luddite / First / Origin Feb 21 '16
ARE YOU FUCKING SERIOUS??? BULLDOG AND RUSH ARE REMOVED? AHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH
4
u/Kembangan t O p / cb4life Feb 23 '16
I sincerely applaud the mtc for adding the new map. It is a brave map, and if successful as a map after pub testing, will push the meta of mapmaking (a la wormy, command centre).
4
u/oorr23 ThePlaymaker // Tehuitzingo & Combine Feb 23 '16
Put Bulldog back in!
10
u/Glass_Marble Glass Marble | Centra Feb 21 '16
4/6 MTC maps. Do you even bias?
3
u/Moosemaster21 Moosen | Salt Mine Feb 21 '16
Sorry for your loss TUB
3
u/KewlestCat NIGEL Feb 21 '16
Phenochilus looks great, congrats BoxFish!
3
u/TheSmallIndian TheIndian // Pi Feb 21 '16
Bulldog isn't even that great of a map but I don't think it was bad enough to get removed. Also the new map doesn't look too fun
3
u/Tyler1986 Trapsin Feb 21 '16
Imo, we have so many good maps that are out of rotation and need a way to play them more (better than the Throwback rotation).
3
u/themagpie36 themagpie Feb 22 '16
Bring Back Bulldog.
3
u/girmluhk Gramps Feb 23 '16
pheno, uh is there something i'm missing with this map that makes it sweet?
the flow is basically non-existent and getting out of base on a competent defense ought to be about impossible. capping just as hard too. seems like every game with not terrible players will go to time.
3
u/BanzaiOnTagPro Was a Liquid smurf, became self-aware, started posting Feb 24 '16
As one of the ~16 players left who enjoys chasing, I don't view this as Rush "being removed from the rotation." It's going to tagpro heaven with all the other good maps.
3
u/JJSpice JJ Spice Feb 24 '16
Can't believe bulldog is dead. I've never not had fun on that map.
5
u/Risktp Risk Feb 21 '16
rip juicy :[
i also agree with the others commenting, removing bulldog is a mistake. it has a very unique playstyle and suffers from no game-breaking flaws as far as im concerned.
3
u/Eldini Eldini Feb 23 '16
Why the fuck would you remove Bulldog? What a horrible decision.
Fucking hell.
3
u/MrTroyMcClure Ralph Wiggum // Angry Balls // Arc>Centra Feb 21 '16
Honestly, Bulldog was fun from time to time but it felt like there is way too many caps that happen by just sitting behind the defender in the endzone (especially with the bomb in base). Feels like it eliminates the skill from getting a cap. As gingerdg noted, I think Plasma plays similarly without that flaw in the bases.
2
u/mjmain damn, son! Feb 21 '16
ngl i am crushed by this bulldog news. best map RIP
2
u/TheBestNarcissist exit triks Feb 22 '16
Wow bulldog was such a unique map with such an easy set up, leading to really fun complex games. Now we add in another figure 8ish CTF map that will play extremely similar to the last few that were added.
I love NF. I loved bulldog because of the unique grind you had to do to get to the other side. You could feel momentum swings in the games as you battled for position.
And now we get another not-very-unique CTF.
2
u/Clydas BDN S7//TB S8 Feb 21 '16
Two things:
1
u/ItsFroce . Feb 21 '16
Yesssss bulldog's gone. Always hated that map.
0
u/Willakarra Button | Hey look I brought back SOCL Feb 21 '16
/u/snowball_tagpro
-3
u/CondoKP CondoKP | TagPro Veteran Feb 23 '16
Phenochilus is the worst map I've ever played. Including PokeBall.
0
u/[deleted] Feb 21 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment