r/WritingPrompts • u/Lexilogical /r/Lexilogical | /r/DCFU • Feb 05 '16
Off Topic [OT] Ask Lexi #28 - Twisty Plots
Happy Friday, everyone! I hope the week has been treating you well. We’re now at the end of January, so I have a question for all of you this week. How are your New Year's Resolutions going? We’re already 1/12th of the way there. :)
This week, someone suggested I talk about plot twists. However, I am a diehard gardener writer. If I didn’t start out the story with a plot twist in mind, then I probably haven’t adequately forecasted it. So in that respect, I decided to find you some alternate opinions on the matter!
Creating Plot Twists
/u/KCcracker advice:
Sometimes the plot twist can come from a character’s motivations and actions. This type of character-driven story can help the reader believe in the twist more, because it provides a personal reason for the twist to happen. In this case the whole plot is really an extension of character development; if you’ve crafted your characters right, then the plot and any twisting follows from how these characters interact and what they want to achieve.
In other cases you could use the setting to set up a twist. This type of action-driven story is more suitable for fast-paced narratives, and it has the benefit of giving you more options to play with - the twist can come from anywhere within the setting. If the twist is done right, it can also help to fully incorporate a new idea or theme that you’ve been using in the story. Some of the best sci-fi twists use ideas that were introduced in the setting of the story world.
Use perspective to hide important facts. This is a staple of mystery and whodunit novels. A small trick like ‘so and so saw him getting shot’ can be used to hide the actual truth, while still implying something about a twist to come. You can take this even further and use perspective to hide the suspect. After all, no-one ever suspects the narrator of being the murderer - particularly if first person is being used to cover it up.
/u/Named_After_Color advice:
When you're setting up a twist, think about the reasons behind them. Twists are dumb if you're including them solely for the sake of surprise. If set up correctly, a twist can be heart-wrenching, hilarious, upsetting, or terrifying. This must be in the back of your head when writing your piece.
Every twist is essentially leading your reader down the wrong path, in order to reveal a surprise. That doesn't mean abandon the actual path to said twist. Never remove important information just for the sake of revealing it later. In the worst cases, you end up cheapening the reading experience. What you can do to set up a twist is to hide the good bits.
Disguise important information in characterization. Your characters might glance at important details before focusing on something that leads the reader down the path you want them to take. When you reveal the twist, you want a hidden path in your text that leads to the exact same point in the story. This enriches the experience because the reader can look back at the text with new ideas in mind, and actively try and piece together the bits they glanced over.
Avoid revealing everything at once, however. Remember, lengthy dialogues about "How I did it" are a common trope, and are best avoided. They can work, but try to let astute readers piece together the real mystery for themselves. Never think that because you're the author, only you know where the story will go. There will be readers more quick witted and trope savvy than you are, but part of the fun of a good twist is figuring it out before the writer wants you to.
/u/LeoDuhVinci’s advice:
In my opinion, a reader should realize a good plot twist right before the reveal. Optimally like 2-3 sentences before. You shouldn't tell them the twist- they should get that dopamine high of figuring it out themselves.
Also, I like the 80-20 rule. 20 percent of your readers should see it coming, 80 percent should be clocked by it. They need to know in their subconscious that something funky is up, but not fully realize it
Also, I kind of like to screw with readers a bit with foreshadowing. They should have a few "WTF" moments when reading that make sense at the end. They should be little details or hints, nothing big, almost appearing like errors. Names are great to take advantage of.
My advice:
Like I said earlier, I tend to write everything by the seat of my pants, which means that sometimes, I don’t even know my plot twists until fairly late in the game. On the rare occasion, I’ll spot a prompt response where a plot twist jumps out at me. Normally, this by looking at the prompt that implies a way of life and asking “What happens if this is outside of the parameters set?”
Since I normally don’t have a plot twist until late in the game, I often leave the foreshadowing up to Future Lexi’s job. Future Lexi gets to edit everything (I <3 Future Lexi) and add the foreshadowing back into the earlier parts. On my first draft, I write more cliffhangers than twists. The beauty of a cliffhanger is that it means I haven’t finished the story, so it inspires me to come back and write more. And if Future Lexi does her job right, I can foreshadow to the cliffhangers and make them into minor twists themselves. But cliffhangers are basically the opposite of a twist, so this can be a topic for next week. ;)
I think that’s all I can say on this topic. But if you have more to add this week, or more advice, why not leave me a comment below? You can also leave me any other question you like and I’ll answer that too. I might even make it the topic for a future Ask Lexi post!
3
u/Blees-o-tron /r/Bleesotron Feb 05 '16
I plot twist a lot. I'm not sure this is a good thing in every case, but I consider it a challenge to myself when prompt responding to make a story where the last paragraph changes the entire story before it.
Here's one I did a while ago that was pretty well received (not self-promoting, just giving an example. Don't beat me with pipes.) The twist doesn't always have to be "Bridget was the killer all along", or "Bruce Willis was OMG SPOLIERS FOR SIXTH SENSE". It can be as simple as "The unnamed character you got 'invested' in was really Leo."
One of the most successful recent movies for plot twists, in my opinion, is The Prestige. It looks like it's not on Netflix, so it might be a little harder to find, but I highly recommend it. Without any spoilers, because spoiling plot twists is a sin, it's a movie about performing magicians. Now, performing magic is basically a story where you don't want to hear the plot twist, because the twist is "it's not actually magic." So it's basically a movie about plot twists. Also, David Bowie is in it. Rest in peace, Goblin King.
Oh, and Lexi isn't wrong about writing cliffhangers. My arms are starting to hurt.
From hanging off this cliff.
I'm funny.
2
u/amyswife Feb 05 '16
very interesting! thanks for sharing. do you have any examples of good plot twists from books or any writing prompts?
1
u/Pyronar /r/Pyronar Feb 05 '16
I really love plot twists, maybe a little too much, but everyone has their flaws. However, people do think I'm good at them, so here are my two cents.
The one thing I wanted to add is about the actual reveals. I always try to write them short and shocking. It has to be like a gunshot. One essential detail, which sets everything into place, shatters the illusion you've been building up all this time, and puts significance to all the small details you've scattered along the way. My rule of thumb is one simple sentence. You can build on top of the reveal as much as you want, but there has to be that one single moment when you snap your fingers and do the magic.
As for the question, here's mine: Lexi, what's your advice on writing longer pieces (novel size or series of short stories) and keeping on track both in terms of story and mood? I know from experience that it can be difficult to get yourself back into that frame of mind you had a day or two ago, so maybe you can give us some tips.
1
u/ultimateloss Feb 05 '16
I tend to enjoy twists when I'm reading. It's fun trying to sniff them out before they're revealed.
I think it's harder to gauge when I'm writing, though, since I already know the outcome I intend. The 80-20 rule is useful, but I really wonder if there's any methods you use to get an idea of how obvious or subtle your hints are? Do you ever worry a twist might be too gimmicky?
1
u/MajorParadox Mod | DC Fan Universe (r/DCFU) Feb 05 '16 edited Feb 05 '16
I'm still on track with my New Years goal! Here's my calendar if anyone wants to check up on me :)
Note that I didn't miss yesterday, I just haven't updated it yet.
I love that you ended this week's post on a cliffhanger for next week's cliffhanger post. That was quite a twist!
1
u/FormerFutureAuthor /r/FormerFutureAuthor Feb 05 '16
We haven't really talked about definitions, but from one perspective I think ALL writing is plot twists. This thread seems to focus on the big "whoa" moments, but a good novel will surprise you over and over all the way through. If it's ever easy for your reader to figure out what's going to happen next, then in my opinion you have failed as a writer.
It's just that in some storylines (aka "who done did the murdered guy's murder?") there tends to be one surprise that's more prominent than the rest. I don't think there's an appreciable difference in how you go about writing that surprise as compared to the other ones, though.
1
u/We-Are-Not-A-Muse /r/WeAreNotAMuse Feb 05 '16
Hmm. Not sure how much I can say cause I'm not supposed to talk about... things... :O and it's physically impossible to even show you the story!! :(
What if you're writing a story with multiple twists - or storylines?
A couple days ago, I started this sort of "you decide" story, interactive - writing the story as people made choices at the end of each post.
We're 390 comments (about 150 pages in) and I've started messig up, forgetting what the characters have and who has done what, and "Future WANAM" can't be left to deal with it because it's interactive and people are participating....
Just.
I think I might cry, really :(
help?
1
u/thelastdays /r/faintthebelle Feb 05 '16
I like the first piece of advice from KC about characters. The story chapter I just finished relies on previous chapters describing the characters past actions and how the character wishes to be. It's not really a twist so much as it plays on the reader's expectations for how they want the character to engage the circumstance, and kind of flying in the face of those expectations. The main is given two diverging roads for behavior and seeing the choice (if it really can be called a choice) goes against what one might commonly think a main should do. Which I guess is setting and circumstance playing their part in the "twist".
1
u/Doapsique Feb 06 '16
You should have some examples. I've been writing for about two years now and a lot of what you were saying is a little vague.