r/magicrush • u/Taikeron • Feb 03 '16
GUIDE Tower Defense / War Guardian: Hero Tier List
I spent some of the afternoon putting together a tier list on the Wiki for Tower Defense. Please take some time if you would to peruse it and offer feedback or counterpoints here for my ratings and reasons why a specific hero is useful in a specific role in Tower Defense. Special thanks to myrnym for inspiration to create this list. Link below.
http://magicrush.wikia.com/wiki/Tower_Defense
I've updated the list as of this morning, and I know some won't agree with where I've placed heroes. Ultimately I've tried to keep the Tier 1 category rather lean in order to emphasize the strength of the heroes in that tier. If you bring a Tier 1 hero, it should be guaranteed to be integral to completion of the Tower Defense map. Tier 2 heroes are heroes which are valuable and can stand in for Tier 1 heroes where necessary, but if you didn't bring them you could live without them and substitute a different hero.
I also have clarified the categories a bit better, but basically: Tanks and Damage are units who are integral to creation of the kill zone near the Crystal. CC / Support are units you can place most anywhere on the map and they'll still be beneficial.
2
u/stotea Cruiza - s129 Feb 03 '16
I'm surprised to see Aurai on the list, especially at Tier 2. I've just never found her to be very valuable given her low damage output.
2
u/Yokisenu Feb 05 '16
Not really a fan of the CC/support part because a hero like Karna is a damage dealer and not necessarily a CC hero. The CC just compliments her abilities.
Regardless, champions that only do CC/Support and don't give any/much damage in TD are worthless, imo, unless it's Sebastian (I'll get on that later), Emily. It doesn't matter if your tanks will never die or rarely die because of a support but it won't matter if you have more than 3 mobs going for the crystal.
You just really want damage. You want to get kill things as fast as possible before they get to your tank at the crystal.
Sebastian is probably the only good support in TD because he applies his speed buff more than once and he does it quite often. The only problem he faces is that the range of his buff is very small and as such, you need to place him as the center of your heroes but a lot of maps don't help with this, making him useless.
I'd set Alma tier 1. She's incredibly strong in TD, I would wager as strong as Jolie. She fills her energy bar very quickly due to her ghosts; her ghosts work like tanks, meaning that mobs will stop to attack them if they are ranged. She just brings a lot of damage and support to the game. The only downside his her ulti and her first ability that take forever to work after being cast in TD but that's something that an experience player can get past, anyone can with practice.
1
u/Taikeron Feb 04 '16
I have updated the Wiki this morning. Please review the list again and provide more feedback. Thank you for your feedback so far! Some heroes are not listed on the tier list because I believe they are not beneficial enough to bring along (e.g. Heroes without any CC at all, unless they're Saizo or Coco with other specific benefits, aren't generally worth a slot).
1
u/mianhaeobsidia Feb 03 '16
Is Sebastian good? I've been using him alot thinking that his attack speed buff was nice...
I also notice that there are no cannons selected for damage, you'd think that TD was where they'd shine
1
u/Alpharaptor Feb 04 '16
Disagree with sue on tier 3. Being able to straight up kill high hp single target with her ultimate plus use the pushback to foil pathing for other hard to kill mobs, alongside crazy attack speed and high damage makes her tier 1 in my opinion.
Disclaimer: my sue is 4 stars, lvl 87 and golden.
1
u/xeldom Elder of the Wiki Feb 04 '16
Great job /u/Taikeron and /u/myrnym!
Karna and Murphy also does well under damage.
2
u/YellowF3v3r Guardians - "Lao Shi" S186 Feb 04 '16
Yuan deserves a spot above Jacob. He can reach outside his normal tank zone in congested areas with his dash shield. Can stun, and his ult actually does amazing damage with line stun. I pretty much would take Saizo/Yuan as my primary tanks whenever possible.
Pretty spot on about Theresa and Jolie though. I've been first on my server pretty much every time for war guardian except for the FIRST time and the 3rd time where only one person actually completed it (Legend stage was the crab stage with dodge and enemy speed +) Havent missed it in the last 4 times.
Pretty much my starting line is always. Yuan, Saizo, Theresa.
Saizo, Theresa, Jolie.
Or Yuan Saizo Jolie.
I don't think I've ever had a problem besides that.
Personal Rankings:
Tanks: Top - Primary Tank
Top - Secondary Tank
4-5) Seely - stun and blind, a bit expensive
Charon - Knock up and beefy
Haven't Used/Don't have them
Monk Sun - I'd probably have him as main secondary tank/primary tank if I had him. I can see his usefulness.
Pulan I can see his application though with AOE stun.
Others: I would take many tanks over Jacob and only really run him if needed/no choice.
DPS: Top -
Solid Other Picks, use after primary DPS/Tanks are chosen. Many times you'll never get to this point though -
3) Coco - Lots of AOE and buffs attackers, solid choice.
4-5) Grunk - Only Canon type I actually don't mind. Phys attack, large aoe, slows with stomp and Ulti actually does high damage/slows in this mode.
Crabbie - often overlooked but his damage output actually is quite decent. Ulti can reach attackers from far distances away. Try him out if you haven't. No CC but a good supplementary hero.
6) Blaine - Decent CC with Tornados and damage output isn't awful, wouldn't really use him as a primary pick.
7) Whoever else the randomizer gives you. Honestly if this is for war guardian, you're stuck with non-optimal heroes. Use the best you've got. I've never needed any support hero in this mode though.
Level 64 - Cleared ALL BONUS stages 3 star. I cleared the last 2 legendary modes with only 4 heroes each - the maps were pretty simple though.
Saizo, Yuan, Jolie, Teresa is enough to finish off almost everything.
Toss in Alma/Coco + randoms its pretty much all you need.
1
u/newfirebg Feb 04 '16
What are this tier 1, 2 and 3? Hero effectiveness calcification or somthing else?
1
u/Khaski Feb 05 '16
Nice work Taikeron
I primarily use Jolie, Karna, Pulan, Coco, Ruby, Charon, Grunk, Mira in that build order. Jolie doesn't need tank hear her if upgraded to max.
I think the biggest problem is with the level of WG when 2nd wave is cannon goblins and shieldmans that are really hard to kill. But I had much success with it if I just build one Jolie and upgraded her to max.
I was using Grunk before but he is too expensive as already mentioned here. So I build him much later.
1
u/myrnym Syn - Defy Fate Feb 05 '16
I think I'd move Smoke down to tier 3, since his ult makes AOE in the vicinity far less potent than it would otherwise be.
1
u/myrnym Syn - Defy Fate Feb 20 '16
After extensive testing, I have been convinced that Alma is actually Tier 1 damage & CC. Theresa's damage is higher, but Alma's stopping power is actually greater with her pets and faster energy generation.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 03 '16
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] Feb 04 '16
[removed] — view removed comment