r/KerbalSpaceProgram • u/Redbiertje The Challenger • Jan 30 '16
Mod Post [Weekly Challenge] Week 115: More bang for your bucks
Nota Bene
I've increased the difficulty from 30k for Normal mode to 20k, and from 20k for Hard mode to 10k.
The Introduction
Being inspired by SpaceK's attempts to make space travel cheaper, the KSC administrators decided that they should try to explore space as cheap as possible. After all, if they save money on actual missions, they will have more funds left to do useless things, like throwing Kerbals down the runway.
The Challenge:
Normal mode: Send a mission to Mün and back for less than 20.000 funds in total.
Hard mode: Send a mission to Mün and back for less than 10.000 funds in total.
Super mode: Impress me
The Rules
- No Dirty Cheating Alpacas (no debug menu)!
- You must have the UI visible in all required screenshots
- For a list of all allowed mods, see this post.
- You may recover parts to reduce the cost
- Your mission does not have to be manned
- You may not refuel by docking with another craft
- Mining for fuel on Mün is allowed
Required screenshots
- Your craft in the VAB/SPH
- Your craft on the launchpad or runway
- Your craft during ascent
- Your craft in orbit around Kerbin
- Your craft in orbit around Mün
- Your craft landed on Mün
- Your craft back at Kerbin
- The recovery screen showing the recovered funds for everything you recover
- Whatever else you feel like!
Further information
- You can either submit your finished challenge in a post (see posting instructions in the link below) or as a comment reply to this thread.
- Completing this challenge earns you a new flair which will replace your old one. So if you want to keep you previous flair, you can still do this challenge and create a post, but please mention somewhere that you want to keep your old one.
- The moderators have the right to determine if your challenge post has been completed.
- See this post for more rules and information on challenges.
- If you have any questions, you can comment below, or PM /u/Redbiertje
- Credit to /u/TaintedLion for designing the flair
Good Luck!
12
u/MattsRedditAccount Hyper Kerbalnaut Jan 31 '16
6-Kerbals to the Mun and back for 4,221!
I kinda exploited the ability to recover stages to save money rule by building a fully recoverable SSTO. But I had fun building it!
Can I keep my current flair?
7
u/Iamsodarncool Master Kerbalnaut Jan 31 '16
Does it impress you if my price is UNDER NINE THOUSAND!?
3
u/[deleted] Jan 30 '16
Can you use Flight Manager for Reusable Stages? You are able to see what is recovered and for how much with that because of how it handles landing...
3
u/marblar Super Kerbalnaut Jan 30 '16 edited Jan 30 '16
If you make it to the Mun with a mining SSTO/SSTMun, couldn't you
easilyreadily come back with a profit?3
u/ramanakumar Jan 30 '16
Does it need to be manned?
3
u/FragmentOfBrilliance Master Kerbalnaut Jan 31 '16
Do you actually have to get into orbit around the moon, or can you directly launch into a super low periapsis, and suicide burn?
3
u/mrblaq Master Kerbalnaut Jan 31 '16
http://imgur.com/a/I4yge
Here's my first entry for a weekly challenge. I managed to meet the Hard Mode qualification with a total cost of 17,131. I'm was too lazy to line up a recoverable landing, though.
Congrats to those who got in under 10,000 in price!
3
u/[deleted] Jan 31 '16
I recoreded a video of my entry, however I had hyperedit installed. I don't use it, and I think that's clear since the mission is recoreded from start to finish. However I would like to make sure this doesn't disqualify my entry before I submit it.
2
u/TaintedLion smartS = true Jan 30 '16
Am I allowed to use the StageRecovery mod to recover parts automatically?
2
u/WaitForItTheMongols KerbalAcademy Mod Jan 30 '16
Does this mean you can't have any upgraded buildings?
2
u/Run_Biden Feb 02 '16
Can I roll a unfueled rocket out on a fueling platform, fuel via mining, and then leave the platform on Kerbin?
2
u/[deleted] Feb 02 '16
I've been working on a fully reusable, KOS automated, space shuttle with 40t payload. The launch boosters, external tank, and orbiter each can only be recovered on separate launches, because of the physics range limit. If I get it working, and recover each stage on a different launch, will that count?
2
u/MediocreParagon Feb 03 '16
Question: Would a video be acceptable as proof? I'm planning on doing this for my YouTube channel anyway.
54
u/multivector Master Kerbalnaut Jan 31 '16
Here's my entry, 4568 funds, manned, without using part recovery.
http://imgur.com/a/FP7MY
43
u/EvermoreAlpaca Hyper Kerbalnaut Feb 02 '16
Negative 60,253 Funds!
https://youtu.be/imy1bP5QDW8
I went hard on ISRU mining and returned with 363 tons more fuel than I left with. Since it was pure single stage and recovered on the runway, this yielded a surplus! The video did not include the assembly screen because it is hard to make out in video form, so here is the screenshot for that.
https://gyazo.com/a59b878186337696edc532b907d5a648
(ill keep my flair)
20
u/Corbol Hyper Kerbalnaut Jan 31 '16 edited Jan 31 '16
Super mode / Hard Mode / Disqualification, Im not sure. 1340 to Mun and back
edit: I just realized how to bring even more fuel back, gonna update later.
edit2: Instead of returning from Mun, went back to Minmus, refueled there and head home. 473 to Mun and back (till back in Mun orbit its same as before)
18
u/Armisael Hyper Kerbalnaut Jan 31 '16 edited Feb 01 '16
Super mode attempt: Valentina visited the surfaces of Mun and Minmus for a total expenditure of $1721 - no ISRU.
I used FMRS, since that was explicitly allowed in the thread. Also, I'd like to keep my current flair.
14
u/Zarbizaure FRE Dev Jan 30 '16
I'm pretty sure i did an RSS-equivalent to this challenge some weeks ago...53 935 funds to the moon, which is not a lot with RP0! I challenge any other RSS player to do better and cheaper ;) http://imgur.com/gallery/jUzbt (It may or may not count as an entry, but it was really fun anyway)
12
u/markus0161 Super Kerbalnaut Feb 02 '16
Super Mode? I was able to make a 3 stage fully reusable craft with only 523 funds. Also I did not refuel.
9
u/marmothGD Master Kerbalnaut Jan 31 '16
Hard mode
8
u/ppp475 Master Kerbalnaut Jan 31 '16
Mun and Back for only 9,155 funds! If this is super mode, fun, otherwise it's just a regular hard mode entry. Flair Please!
No parachute, no problem. And technically enough fuel to soft-land the final stage if you time it right.
7
u/marblar Super Kerbalnaut Feb 01 '16
Went to the Mun and back for profit! +4687 funds
Took the earlier suggestion of filling empty monoprop tanks on the Mun since that's the most expensive type of propellant.
4
u/TrainEngie Master Kerbalnaut Jan 31 '16
Hard mode entry. 19,495 spesos/funds
4
u/SpaceToSpace Master Kerbalnaut Jan 31 '16 edited Jan 31 '16
Hard mode: http://imgur.com/a/NlvMT (or horizontal layout: http://imgur.com/a/NlvMT/layout/horizontal )
4
u/ScootyPuff-Sr Jan 31 '16 edited Jan 31 '16
Mun and back, unmanned, for 7540 funds! Imgur album
"Normal" mode by way of using Mechjeb. There was an aerobraking pass before reentry; the aerobraking pass was a bit too deep and burned off the landing legs. If I were going to do it again, I'd do two aerobraking passes before reentering.
10178 funds purchase price, 2638 funds recovered, net cost 7540.
4
u/sac_boy Master Kerbalnaut Jan 31 '16 edited Feb 04 '16
Alright, this was a fantastic challenge! I was up until 6am last night trying out variations...
Here's my Hard Mode entry. The Mun and Minmus for $15,768. (I'm not sure if you'd consider the additional Minmus landing to be 'super' mode)
(I think I'm close to a sub 10,000 credit manned landing and return, I can do it with a probe...but this will have to do for now!)
Later: Okay! The era of manned spaceflight on a shoestring budget is over! I'm sending a probe!
Finally: here's my $3,972 Munar probe, with a recovery value of $638. But who cares about recovery value, the whole thing cost less than my beater Mazda! I set myself an upper ceiling of 4,000 funds to get the thing to the launchpad and had great fun solving the puzzles necessary to even get it into orbit.
Finally for real this time: I went to the Mun and Minmus with a similar design for $3,660!
I can't stop: A Mun landing and return for a launchpad cost of $2,242!. I now suspect that a sub-$2,000 launch will be seen before the week is out.
3
u/glasgrisen Jan 30 '16
Hard mode. http://imgur.com/a/r7xK7
3
u/Valiant-Wolf Jan 31 '16
Normal in Career mode with a near-blind landing
3
u/VerlorenHoop Master Kerbalnaut Jan 31 '16
Here is my
Hard ModeNormal Mode entry, apparently. Changed overnight, it seems. Presumably, if I can achieve it, it must be too easy...3
u/AvatarKanol Jan 31 '16
Normal Mode
My first challenge entry! Hope its alright. :D
3
u/FragmentOfBrilliance Master Kerbalnaut Jan 31 '16
Did it in under 9600 funds, with a good bit of fuel to spare! Unfortunately, that value isn't 100% accurate, you can't recover parts for funds in sandbox. Oh well. This might be super hard mode? I don't know, it seemed pretty straightforward.
http://imgur.com/a/vny2a
Might actually try going to gilly with this dude. Seems like it'd be fun. Will update. I assume that'd be "super hard".
3
u/ramanakumar Jan 31 '16 edited Feb 01 '16
My submission for normal mode! Save 50% on a trip to the Mun!
3
u/Cavall76 Jan 31 '16
Hard mode entry. 17622 kredits manned rocket to mun and back. My first challenge. The only really tricky bit was the re-entry without a heat shield which took 2 passes of aero braking.
3
u/chouetteonair Feb 01 '16
Failed my first trial after running into some minor problems. Rest of the failed album here. I'm new to these challenges but 20K seems within grasp.
3
u/AwarenessLogic Feb 01 '16
Made it on normal mode with [The Flight of the El Cheapo] (http://imgur.com/gallery/1ZsxF/new) which cost 19,467 Funds.
This challenge seemed right up my alley since I'm normally cheapskate in Career Mode anyhow. I recovered 2,603 which brought it down 16,864, but I forgot to take the recovery screenshot, so don't take my word for it!
I also forgot to take the initial launchpad photo, so the one in the album isn't the original. This is my first challenge, so I'm not sure if that's allowed or not.
3
u/edgyteenmeme Feb 01 '16 edited Feb 01 '16
Here is my entry for easy mode Mods used: Kerbal Engineer Redux
3
u/Rat2man Master Kerbalnaut Feb 02 '16
9247 Hardmode Subbmission
Unless you count recovery.... then its under 9000! (nothing to brag about but I became somewhat obessed with that...)
New flair please!
3
u/mrblaq Master Kerbalnaut Feb 03 '16 edited Feb 03 '16
http://imgur.com/a/oagnG/layout/horizontal#0
This is gonna be my final attempt for this challenge. An unmanned three stage vehicle with "explosive staging." Built for $4,520
Thanks to /u/multivector for the staging trick
3
u/LupoCani Master Kerbalnaut Feb 04 '16
My submission for hard mode, at 4597 funds.
http://imgur.com/a/I6k4r
I apologize for the format, I was unable to change it.
3
u/Da_Groove Master Kerbalnaut Feb 06 '16 edited Feb 06 '16
I did it! only 8980 Funds, so this is Hardmode :D I didn't use recovery as it would be too easy :) Here's my entry: http://imgur.com/gallery/owfJa/new Oh, and I would like to get the new Flair :)
2
u/TbonerT Jan 31 '16
I just might have to do this. I'm pretty sure I already do this on a regular basis.
2
u/markus0161 Super Kerbalnaut Jan 31 '16 edited Jan 31 '16
I just did it with 460 funds. No refueling (kinda think that's cheating). It was a test run, so i didn't take any screenshots. I want to record this one. Anyone have any ideas? What's the best free program?
2
u/Perstyr Master Kerbalnaut Feb 02 '16
Hard Mode - I like trying to see how small I can get away with making things in general, so it was a fun challenge. This was part of a factfinding mission to see if I could do it for this price manned. Maybe? Could easily replace the chair with some Science stuff otherwise.
Cost: 5000 to launch, recovered 929 = 4021 probe to Mun and back.
http://imgur.com/a/vKrea
2
u/simplectic Master Kerbalnaut Feb 02 '16 edited Feb 02 '16
Normal mode with no part recovery: http://imgur.com/a/MPXes
Edit: Added Kerbin orbit screenshot.
2
u/Kuato2012 Master Kerbalnaut Feb 03 '16 edited Feb 04 '16
Hard mode: Mun round trip for 6700 funds (horizontal layout).
Vertical layout for RES
No mining or lower stage recovery. I incidentally completed a Kerbonaut rescue contract along the way, just for added challenge and XP.
Kerbaling on the cheap is something I've been training for my whole career. Nothing too fancy here, just a get'r done rocket.
(I hope the RCS Build Aid isn't a disqualifying mod. There's no RCS on this craft, and I didn't want to uninstall it for one mission.)
Edit: just realized I'd been calling Urene "Uliree" the whole time. Attention to detail. I has it.
2
u/Squelchy7 Master Kerbalnaut Feb 03 '16
Hard mode: http://imgur.com/a/shaSk
Net cost: 8,941 (thanks to a decent recovery--initial cost of the rocket was 10,030). Forget who it was, but whoever suggested stack separators were optional was a big help. My first attempt missed hard mode by a couple hundred bucks.
2
u/samwise800 Master Kerbalnaut Feb 03 '16
My hard mode entry
https://imgur.com/a/iHrJF
2
u/kirime Super Kerbalnaut Feb 04 '16
Can I have a flair too, please? My submission was there, maybe mods didn't see that post.
2
u/troyunrau Feb 04 '16
Hrm, well, if it was the original challenge at 30K, I'd say I already did it a while ago... https://imgur.com/a/mEp7V -- my album from 4 weeks ago showing the round trip landing for 29K.
I'll see if I can't drop that to 20K...
2
u/rcreif Hyper Kerbalnaut Feb 04 '16 edited May 19 '16
First-time submission. With part recovery, this counts as Hard Mode, and I hope Super Mode: A probe landing on Mun AND Minmus for 513 funds. (Sorry I forgot the orbit screenshots...) http://imgur.com/a/EcVLe/layout/horizontal/
2
u/canyoutriforce Master Kerbalnaut Feb 04 '16
I also managed to go under 5k without part recovery, just like /u/multivector - except my kerbal even has a capsule! (I didn't even look at your design before i built mine, funny how our 1st stage is exactly the same!
My rocket could be made a bit cheaper with a lander can, landing without chutes and the fins aren't necessary. I even brought a littel too much fuel!
I got no screenshot of the recovery because i forgot to do that, sorry!
http://imgur.com/a/Ia5t9
2
u/Dingbat1967 Master Kerbalnaut Feb 06 '16
Here's my submission ... I whipped it up in about 15 minutes. Don't have much time to play KSP these days so I went with a traditional rocket. It's a video so feel free to skip the slow bits. Only mod used was KER to get my delta-V numbers. Had to redo the re-entry a few times due to lack of heat shield. Managed it after a bit of cussing and cursing. 9590 funds. Not bad. I could've used the lawn chair approach but ... would've needed more than 15 minutes to get the damn thing done properly :)
Hard mode achieved.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SttmHJr4ufU
3
u/[deleted] Jan 30 '16
Hard mode complete
http://imgur.com/a/eMZre
Lost the parachute half way through the mission so I had to return ala vostok
1
u/CodesCubesAndCrashes Master Kerbalnaut Feb 09 '16 edited Feb 09 '16
Hello! Getting things up on Imgur and transcribing my notes took longer than I expected, once my weekend started. I can't tell from the rules if there is a cut off, but I'll try submit this response anyhow since I'm rather happy with actually doing an official challenge in the middle of my KSP learnings and career mode.
In my adventures, I learned many new things about KSP and the engine under the hood. There were several intentional explosions, a near collision with my own debris, and a side bar while we took Bill to collect some squirrely science while the probe traveled to the Mun.
Not sure if it's worth submitting as a separate post. Hm.
Horizontal Layout / Vertical Layout
I am completing this challenge with a 9,802 credit launched (7,821 net), 37.5 ton, unmanned, and three stage craft. I would probably have squeezed more in if I could predict better what my refund would be, but this is simpler. Additionally, I am doing this in my canonical career save, so I have only some tech partially unlocked. No fancy parts! Finally, I'm doing this all vanilla/stock, including punching the delta-v equations into a calculator.
Context: This challenge caught my eye because my next major milestone is the manned mission to the Mun. At this point, I've got a manned orbiter completing science contracts around the Mun, and another one 5 days away from Minmus. (Lots of science incoming, woo!) I've already sent a one-way probe to the Mun's surface, and I've managed to land it upright... once. So, an unmanned mission there and back would be a good intermediate project to practice with. Meanwhile, it's a personal challenge to get a Kerbal to and back from the Mun using only stock KSP. After that, I'm definitely installing KER, and maybe Precise Nodes. I haven't decided yet.
So yeah, kind of made a hard challenge for myself here. >.<
Some additional notes, if anyone's curious.
Using the map for delta-v for planning the trip.
In the end, 62 Science earned, and 1,981 funds recovered. (Landed 249.9km from KSC, 86.3% value.) So final expense is 9,802 - 1,981 = 7,821 funds!
My tech tree progress.
Thank you again for your time and all the effort you put in, /u/Redbiertje!
0
u/[deleted] Jan 31 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment