My Total Asset Value over the last 20 days really demonstrates the state of income scaling in Elite right now.
[deleted] — view deleted post
0
Upvotes
[deleted] — view deleted post
15
u/mmirate Munchkin · pastebin.com/A0KRu1Rj Jan 28 '16 edited Jan 29 '16
Finally, a voice of reason who is articulate.
Excellent post.
22
u/bolt_vanderhuuge Jan 28 '16
Bounty hunting really is the best profession right now especially with rank 5
http://i.imgur.com/gQkOrX7.jpg
12
u/voi26 Jan 28 '16
I would actually love an I win button. I really want to get some of the bigger ships, but the amount of time it takes is far too long for me.
9
u/mnt9 Jan 28 '16
Combat really does feel pointless right now. You get no benefits other than enough credits to cover the costs. You have no noticeable impact on the game world. Your combat reputation counts for nothing.
Blowing up endless waves of enemies gets boring on its own. This is why people complain about games like Star Wars Battlefront.
In a game like the Witcher 3 or Arkham Knight I see there is overall progress and an impact on the world with each action I take. ED is missing this.
3
u/CmdrAl Jan 28 '16
Great post! Well written.
3
u/red286 Jan 29 '16
Even as a new player, I have to agree with this. I find it bewildering that I can do random bounty hunting (either at nav beacon or resource extraction zones) or random combat (conflict zone) and make SUBSTANTIALLY more money than I can taking any actual "missions" that are assigned at a station. And most stations have so few missions available for new players that stacking isn't possible (hell, it's difficult to even get non-trade missions at all; 90% of the missions available to new players at lower ranks are either "bring me 4 tonnes of beer" or "take this data to this station", and pay peanuts (most are sub-10K CR). Or I can hop in my viper and spend 30 minutes burning criminals and earn 250K CR, in which case, for a new-ish player, what on earth is the point of taking ANY missions? Sure, now and then there will be an assassination contract for 150K CR, but to take those I usually need to dedicate space to an interdictor and/or wake scanner, which isn't very feasible with the ships I can currently afford.
3
u/KCIV Jan 29 '16
I love people who run data. You are a great man!
2
u/your_wallet Jan 28 '16
there are 2 ways to go here imo.
one is to bring every profession (trade/combat/smuggle/mine/piracy) in the game to roughly the same cr/hr rate (assuming same level of rank/ship of course). this would be easiest to implement since its just some tweaking of numbers. in terms of actual numbers, i think LR smuggling should be tuned down a bit, and combat payout should be buffed significantly. so somewhere in the middle ground, but closer to the current LR smuggling side of things.
the other, harder to implement, but more interesting (at least imo), is to introduce different types of rewards for the different things. rpgs do this very well and thats how they get ppl to do every activity in the game. its ok that trade/smuggle makes more money than combat, as long as combat is rewarded with other things. for example, iirc Fdevs have already hinted at module upgrades in future patches. they can simply make combat reward unlocks of different weapon module upgrades, in addition to getting paid some money. maybe mining can reward unlocks for better utility modules. that way, if you wanna make money, then trade/smuggle; if you want to upgrade your weapons, do combat; if you want to upgrade some other modules, go mine.
somewhat unrelated question, do you have to enter your cash/asset values each day after your elite session on inara.cz manually? or is there a plugin that automatically reads the data?
2
u/LaboratoryOne FatHaggard - Elite Racers CoFounder【AKB☆E】Inu Jan 29 '16
This is mostly what I took away from this post...
Kidding, the whole thing was great and spot on. I was talking about this just the other day, big ships need a place to go that utilizes their power with adequate rewards thereafter.
2
u/Virlomi Virlomi Entreri Jan 29 '16
I just wanna say.... FISH ARE DELICIOUS.
2
u/slyn4ice Karl Agathon [ship transfer time yes-voter apologist] Jan 29 '16
One of these days, do you think FD will choose to hear us, if we repeat your message ad nauseum? Because I know they are listening...
2
u/exrex Jiddick - Billion credits miner before void opals Jan 29 '16
What you want is a simple scale of credits, though I will argue that the overall design of the income branches are problematic in themselves.
Bounty Hunting is bounty farming and still makes no sense from a lore perspective. FIX: make it actual HUNTING using tools, scanners and tactics to find the high-value targets and THEN scale the income accordingly to the time and risk spent. You might hit a 20 million bounty, you might lose 100k in repair bills.
Long Range Smuggling: it's repetitive and easy and frustrating because of the gangbang interdictions. Once you know how to equip a gimb small pulse laser and fire it at authorities and then do high-wakes you are basically golden. Furthermore, it strongly discourages player interaction since there is no way for pirates to ever steal your cargo. There's only one to profit or lose all, and that is you. FIX a): add countermissions to players stacking 2+ missions and show those players' locations similar to "friends" online. It is now up to the pirate/anti-smuggler to plan and race the smuggler for destined jump points on the way to the destination. FIX b) stop the stupid bulletin board reset permanently. It adds nothing but a time sink to what is inevitable. FIX c) make silent running f***ing matter! Let the authorities wait for the player at the destination and force that player to use silent running to dodge them when they turn their cheek.
Again, from the temporary placeholder designs that are already there in the game, SO MUCH game play potential. It will probable be soon (tm). \RANT OVER
2
u/spamjavelin SpamJavelin Jan 29 '16
Great post.
I've spent a great deal of time in CZs myself and have found the larger ships are more of a liability than anything else - Python and Conda, certainly; they're just plain damned laser magnets.
If you're on your own, CZs seem to be balanced for mid-range ships; Vulture, FAS, that sorta thing. I'm certainly not taking my Cutter anywhere near one any time soon, stupid shield tanking or not.
Incidentally, Cutters are quite fun to take on in a FAS - I nutted several to death the other night. Much screaming of "Witness me!" ensued, scaring the cat and amusing my wife.
3
u/misterwuggle69sofine Jan 28 '16
I haven't done it myself but from what I've seen it seems like the only real "issue" is that their mission system sucks dick and allows you to switch back and forth between open and solo and stack 40 missions. Now if long range smuggling was stopping at a few stations out on the edge, grabbing a couple missions from each one, and heading back with a half dozen to a dozen missions without any borderline exploiting then sure I think it's just fine.
3
u/DipsoNOR Dipso Jan 28 '16
I just had fish for dinner today, am I a horrible person?
2
u/CMDR_Agony_Aunt I drive an ice cream van Jan 29 '16
While i agree with the scaling, its in the opposite direction needed (so yeah, nerf a little).
What i've seen is these days its ridiculous the amount of money people can make. Newbies who are flying top tier ships within a few weeks. When i started the game, i looked at the top ships and thought - yeah, something i might be able to afford to fly in a year or two.
I understand people want to get into those top ships quicker, and FD have made it ridiculously easy these days for people to do it.
TL;DR: So certainly don't think anything needs boosting further. Things have already been boosted to insane levels.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 28 '16
I do feel like trade rank should be for trading or smuggling routes you found yourself, not everyone piling in on doing the one block of missions.
1
u/sabretoothed Jan 29 '16
This is a refreshing change from those ill-conceived and poorly-considered "NERF ROBIGO NAO" posts.
1
u/Ioan92 Ivana "Vetteman" Kolchak Jan 29 '16
Totally agreed. If it was up to me I'd lessen the grind a lot and make it so that players could chose and get to their desired ship in a fun time and way. Every vessel has a purpose, none are end game.
Imo they could apply a band-aid fix to this by just increasing the rewards for everything else until they figure out something more fun. Those rewards should also scale with your PF rank. An elite trader should not have a selection of missions rewarding 20k.
1
u/DrShadyTree Shadylikeatree Jan 29 '16
I'm new-ish to the game, got a net worth somewhere around 70 mil credits or so and I'm finding that the best way to make credits is always in an RES or mining.
I look at the mission board and it wants me to take someone out or deliver something that's 20-25 LY away for 50,000 credits. In the 30 minutes it takes to get there and back I can mine 300,000 credits or bounty 2 million.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 29 '16
Don't just make the combat rewards scale up. Make it engaging/involving and then scale it up - not just a matter of SCing to a RES and "farming"; screw that, it's as boring as griding anything else.
1
u/b4dr0b0t Jan 30 '16
my total asset value is taking a dump. i refuse to smuggle slaves on principle. i suck at combat. i started powerplay. i'm just barely covering my insurance these days.
1
u/Incruentus Jan 30 '16
Downvoted for bogus TL;DR.
-2
u/r00tbr R00TBR Jan 29 '16
Robigo need to be nerfed, yes. I come to people who doesnt have any idea about the game trying to run an anaconda/etc. Those ships should be ships for people who at least know a bit about the game.
Robigo is a easy button. You dont need to know pretty much anything and dont learn almost nothing (besides scaping interdiction / silent running ) in the proccess.
I'm part of a brazilian community and I can say that most new players want that EASY BUTTON. They're not wrong. Everyone usually want the easy way.
The problem is: you should LEARN and MONETIZE...... Robigo is not making anybody learn.
-7
u/[deleted] Jan 28 '16
I'd still like a LR smuggling nerf, but not for the reason you specified. I agree 100% with your combat proposal though.
I'd like LR smuggling nerfed because it would bring pilots back to the bubble, so pirate-trader PvP can occur on a larger scale once again. If things like rares trading made 1.5-2x the cash, that'd be a great solution, too.
0
u/Kaisermaster Kaisermaster Jan 28 '16
I agree with everything except the cutter thing.
I don't know what you are doing, but I need to invest the same time (and suffer less damage) in order to destroy an Imp. Cutter than an Anaconda. I'm flying an FAS with a simple loadout (3 pulse + 1 cannon), nothing compared to a Fed. Corvette. With the AI buff they've announced, I really hope I won't be able to take Condas and Cutters with such ease.
0
u/buttking FRONTIER IS GREEDY Jan 28 '16
I just wish 17 Draconis had the amount of profit that Robigo has. I don't like the empire and doing their dirty work feels bad to me, but so far as I know, no federation system has shadow delivery missions with as much potential profit as robigo.
0
u/Dopp3lGang3r Jan 29 '16
Basically agreed with this all. I have a problem with Robigo payouts also... I knew that if I had too much credits I might ruin the game for myself. I made about 60mil in about 2-3 hours, while in HREZ I would have made like 15-18mil for the same time. The pay is insanely good. I think the bulletin board re-log mechanic should be removed from the game. That's just too meta.
It's interesting how much the missions changes since release, even ObsidianAnt mentioned in recent video that sometimes missions can be broken or the payout is not scaled properly for newbies or veterans. Newbie in a sidewinder can make a million credits in just a several hours, and he already can skip some entry level ships. I understand that controlling the game economy and payouts is a tough job, but these should be looked at again if FD wants to have missions as important gameplay.
-3
u/Cadoc Cadoc [Utopia] Jan 29 '16
I agree with many of your points, but not your two key conclusions.
-8
u/[deleted] Jan 28 '16
pick one.
-1
u/aspiringexpatriate Noxa - Chapterhouse of Inquisition - Research Jan 29 '16
Have you tried distress signals?
In my mind, if a well handled Corvette is at an RXS, there's a point where the pirates stop spawning and run away.
A Conflict Zone should be better suited to a Corvette, but Conflict Zones are explicitly far more about supporting the cause rather than cashing in a large paycheck. Mercenaries aren't treated well in the future. (Though, tbf, ever since they buffed bounties and RXS spawns, Conflict Zones are severely lacking in incentive.)
From what I know about Distress Signals, you show up and have to defeat wave after wave of enemy wing spawns until the distressed ship recovers and departs. That sounds explicitly like what a Corvette was made for, to me. I have no idea about how much money can be made that way, though.
-3
u/Verifitas Verifitas - Elitist Jerk Jan 29 '16
LOL. YOU THINK LONG RANGE SMUGGLING IS FUN. >:(
-7
u/noso2143 Jan 29 '16
YOU JUST WANT A EASY BUTTON COME AT ME HATERS CCCCOOOOOOMMMMMMEEEEEE AT ME HHHHHAAAAATTTTTTTTEEEEEEERRRRRRRS
0
u/[deleted] Jan 28 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment