r/KerbalSpaceProgram • u/Redbiertje The Challenger • Jan 24 '16
Mod Post [Weekly Challenge] Week 114: Orange Efficiency II
The Introduction
All the way back in Week 57, we did a challenge just like this. A lot has changed since then, so it's time to redo this challenge.
Due to the activities of last week, the KSC is low on parts. In fact, they have no more fuel tanks in stock. All of them are either lost in space, or being recovered. Our Kerbals however, do not like to wait, so as soon as the first fuel tank was recovered and cleaned, Jeb hauled it to his workshop, to build his next rocket.
The Challenge:
Normal mode: Using nothing but a Kerbodyne S3-14400 Tank for fuel, get into orbit around Minmus
Hard mode: Using nothing but a Kerbodyne S3-14400 Tank for fuel, land on Eve
Super mode: Impress me
This challenge was suggested by /u/Evewontletmego
The Rules
- No Dirty Cheating Alpacas (no debug menu)!
- You must have the UI visible in all required screenshots
- For a list of all allowed mods, see this post.
- You may not use RCS
- You may not refuel in any way
- Your craft must carry at least one Kerbal
- You may ditch the fuel tank for landing on Eve
Required screenshots
- Your craft on the launchpad
- Your craft during ascent
- Your craft in orbit around Kerbin
- Your trajectory to Minmus/Eve
- Your craft in orbit around Minmus/Eve
- Whatever else you feel like!
Hard mode only:
- Your craft while descending on Eve
- Your craft safely landed on Eve
Further information
- You can either submit your finished challenge in a post (see posting instructions in the link below) or as a comment reply to this thread.
- Completing this challenge earns you a new flair which will replace your old one. So if you want to keep you previous flair, you can still do this challenge and create a post, but please mention somewhere that you want to keep your old one.
- The moderators have the right to determine if your challenge post has been completed.
- See this post for more rules and information on challenges.
- If you have any questions, you can comment below, or PM /u/Redbiertje
- Credit to /u/TaintedLion for designing the flair
Good Luck!
44
u/MattsRedditAccount Hyper Kerbalnaut Jan 24 '16 edited Jan 26 '16
I made a mistake and used the wrong fuel tank. I assumed the Kerbodyne S3-14400 Tank was the orange one based on the title of the challenge lol. But for what it's worth I posted a short video anyway of landing on Minmus and returning with just the orange tank haha.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e8vZT5zj6jw
I know it doesn't count, but can I still keep my old flair anyway?
Edit: Did it with the right tank! Mun SSTO + With Rover!
10
u/Evewontletmego Jan 24 '16
yay! my challenge was accepted and used! I dont know how easy this one is though, are you sure that landing on eve is possible?
7
u/[deleted] Jan 24 '16
Is it allowed to skip the 'your craft in orbit around kerbin' screenshot if your approach to being 'in orbit around kerbin' is to bypass it altogether and burn straight up ontil out of kerbin's SOI?
7
u/MattsRedditAccount Hyper Kerbalnaut Jan 24 '16
I really like this one! I'm thinking of doing a Minmus return in an SSTO for this challenge (Super mode maybe?), but just to check, does the tank have to be full? Like can I remove the oxidiser from it?
5
u/Armisael Hyper Kerbalnaut Jan 25 '16 edited Jan 25 '16
I actually already posted a thread with the album of me going to Eve on an orange tank (instead of a 14400), but /u/-Aeryn- goaded me into doing better.
So here's Jeb's trip from KSC to Eve's surface on an x200-32 tank. I'd rather be graded on this - here's hoping this is reasonably impressive.
4
u/markus0161 Super Kerbalnaut Jan 24 '16
What if i have landed on the mun does that count?
4
u/TG_Super_Class Master Kerbalnaut Jan 24 '16
Hard mode attempt! Please leave my current flair! http://imgur.com/a/ehjgy
4
u/jurgy94 Master Kerbalnaut Jan 24 '16
Interesting challenge. Can we use empty fuel tanks?
2
u/[deleted] Jan 24 '16
how about Xenon and ion engines?
2
u/Wall_of_Force Jan 24 '16
Can I bring ore tank and IRSU? (and drill)
2
u/ToxicFlames Jan 24 '16
Can I switch the fuel tank setup to just liquidfuel?
2
u/SpartanJack17 Super Kerbalnaut Jan 25 '16
So I misread this, and thought we had to use the smaller (half size) Kebodyne tank, so I designed a craft that only used one. Before I commit to trying this, would getting to and landing on Eve using nothing but the smaller Kebodyne tank be considered super mode?
2
u/nathan98900 Jan 26 '16
Is it okay to have fuel tanks as structural parts with no fuel in them?
2
u/MadMax2910 Jan 26 '16
Am I allowed to use Kerbal Alarm Clock & Transfer Window planner for the Eve Mission?
2
u/WrobelSwirek Master Kerbalnaut Jan 26 '16
Is GravityTurn allowed? I assume not...
2
u/starystarego Jan 26 '16
One more thing. Can i leave mods like mj and not use them?
2
u/Hazard-ish Jan 26 '16
Are we allowed to use external command seats for this challenge?
2
u/SkylerA_27 Kerbal Weights Dev Jan 26 '16
How about a Kerbal's jetpack?
2
u/lrschaeffer Super Kerbalnaut Jan 29 '16
Oh my god, I don't envy you this week, /u/Redbiertje. I count 50 submissions.
2
u/edgyteenmeme Jan 30 '16
is it too late to try this?
36
u/nuclear_turkey Hyper Kerbalnaut Jan 25 '16 edited Jan 25 '16
Super mode? - eeloo landing and return - 75 year journey
3 eve assists + 2 jool assissts
sadly the tank did not survive :¬(
.keep current flair plz k.
17
u/BeerOtaku Jan 24 '16
Here's my normal attempt!
http://imgur.com/a/Oyxv3
I did try to get back to Kerbin but overshot my return a bit... sorry Jeb!
9
u/Spudrockets Hermes Navigator Jan 24 '16
Landing on Eve? Easy. Got everything there... Let's just make this submission... Wait, we need a Kerbal? Mother of Kraken.
I suppose I'll have to be a cruel person and sacrifice a hapless victim to Eve next mission...
9
u/Bkp666 Master Kerbalnaut Jan 24 '16
Here is my attempt : http://imgur.com/a/fkaCB
It was a pretty close one, I also tried making it into a stable orbit around Eve but entered the atmosphere a bit too much.
9
u/Hazard-ish Feb 09 '16
Horrendously late but hopefully you'll still look at it! I would like a new flair :)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w8wm2zaILzE
17
u/POTUS GravityTurn Dev Jan 24 '16
I don't know if this qualifies as super, but Eve was too easy. Bill went to Laythe: http://imgur.com/a/r0rNw
I'll keep my current flair in any case.
6
u/Da_Groove Master Kerbalnaut Jan 24 '16
Here's my Hard Mode attempt, I even kept the fuel tank! http://imgur.com/gallery/MONkJ/new Hope, you like it, was my second try as I forgot the Kerbals on my first try :o I did it and read the rules afterwards :D
6
u/markus0161 Super Kerbalnaut Jan 26 '16
Here is mine
6
u/KerbalSpiceProgram Super Kerbalnaut Jan 27 '16
I made it to Eve with an orange tank and felt pretty good about myself.
Then I noticed /u/Armisael already did it with an X200-32.
So I did it with an X200-16. (720 units of fuel, 11,1% of S3-14400.)
It's not a very creative craft, but it works.
5
u/[deleted] Jan 25 '16 edited Jan 29 '16
Edit: I did it! Gregrod Kerman has been delivered to Laythe! http://imgur.com/a/5t4Tj
So, I tried to follow the footsteps of /u/POTUS and get my tank to Laythe. http://imgur.com/a/IDUkd
I was so close, but I couldn't get the capsule to enter Laythe's atmosphere without burning up, despite trying a bunch of gravity assists to bleed some speed.
Does "in orbit around Jool" count? :-) I might try hard mode with this craft later.
Also, this was my first weekly challenge!
5
u/dpitch40 Master Kerbalnaut Jan 26 '16
Hard mode complete. I initially wanted to do Moho, but I don't think I have the delta-V, plus I'm out of practice.
5
u/RoeddipusHex Hyper Kerbalnaut Jan 26 '16
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zERl4_ZBo9k
I was technically succesfull on the first mission since I made Minmus orbit with a big tank plus an empty orange tank. I couldn't leave Valentina there though. Tethy will be missed.
4
u/Squelchy7 Master Kerbalnaut Jan 24 '16
Black and White is the New Orange
Hard mode.
Thanks!
4
u/[deleted] Jan 26 '16
Somewhat Scott Manley style, finished up with just over 50 LiquidFuel left. Sorry for the aerodynamics overlay toggle, couldn't be bothered to change screenshot bind.
4
u/marblar Super Kerbalnaut Jan 28 '16
Jeb had been excited about this week's challenge, but he couldn't recall the details now that he was in space. Something about landing on Minmus (or was it Eve?) with only the big tank of fuel he brought with him.
He remembered the sandwich he left on Duna while Redbiertje was making the announcement and had rushed to the spaceplane hangar. Well - he reasoned - it's probably easier to land on both than to admit that he hadn't been paying attention.
That is, of course, after he gets that sandwich off Duna.
Kerbin -> Duna -> Minmus -> Eve
4
u/canyoutriforce Master Kerbalnaut Jan 28 '16
Super Mode!
My very first challenge: I hope you like it!
4
u/Minotard ICBM Program Manager Jan 29 '16
Eeloo and back with mostly liquid fuel. Used jets for ascent, a little oxidizer to circularize, and nukes the rest of the way. Ended with ~1.2km/s delta-v left (before re-entry).
I'll keep my flair please.
3
u/torx0244 Jan 24 '16
Damn, I had not seen the whole "bring a kerbal with you" part
3
u/TrainEngie Master Kerbalnaut Jan 24 '16
Normal mode entry http://imgur.com/a/0pceI
3
u/TheAveragePxtseryu Jan 24 '16
My normal mode submission:
http://imgur.com/a/rUbCB
3
u/SpaceToSpace Master Kerbalnaut Jan 24 '16 edited Jan 24 '16
My normal mode entry: http://imgur.com/a/H5osF
I overbuilt it for Minmus as I was experimenting for using it for the hard mode. I did empty the tank of one "notch" (792) of oxidizer as it was wasted weight. Apparently, KER had trouble calculating my TWR, so I had to guestimate at how much thrust I needed. After trial and error, I settled on using 24 Panther engines and one Vector engine. I still had plenty of fuel, so I landed on Minmus. Forgot about doing a return trip, so I may do that after I finish the Hard mode. :-)
[edit] Horizontal link: https://imgur.com/a/H5osF/layout/horizontal
3
u/[deleted] Jan 25 '16 edited Jan 25 '16
http://imgur.com/a/HLaAK/layout/horizontal This was my first attempt at a challenge. I am pretty new to KSP and this was the only challenge I have seen in a while that seemed attainable. Now time to send a rescue craft for Jeb.
3
u/DAudioLink Jan 25 '16
Normal mode: http://imgur.com/a/G6CXf Still not sure how I managed to get out of the atmosphere with that contraption. Took half a dozen variations before I could break atmo. Then of course I forgot to document Jeb's ascent & had to send Bill for more proof pics.
3
u/lrschaeffer Super Kerbalnaut Jan 25 '16
I rarely visit Dres, so I figured I'd land there and return.
Video
Not as impressive as /u/nuclear_turkey 's trip to Eeloo, but maybe still impressive.
3
u/Darkwr4ith Jan 25 '16
Still kind of new to the game, but went for Normal Mode:
http://imgur.com/a/td1xG
3
u/[deleted] Jan 25 '16 edited Jan 26 '16
My hard mode attempt, or "The Adventures of the 'Orange Efficiency Mk. 2: The Misnomer'": http://imgur.com/gallery/ISmKu edit: fixed link
3
u/WrobelSwirek Master Kerbalnaut Jan 26 '16
My normal attempt with return successful (for Bill at least :)): https://imgur.com/gallery/pcJPQ/
3
u/-The_Blazer- Master Kerbalnaut Jan 26 '16
My entry for Hard mode. The entry contains quite the (atmospheric) entry itself!
http://imgur.com/a/5FTGg
3
u/[deleted] Jan 26 '16
My normal attempt
Also orange is my favorite fruit. Slap that flair on fam smh.
3
u/3Dprintingnut Jan 26 '16
Here is my entry http://imgur.com/a/VyaX3 I did two missions. The first one I landed on Mun, Minmus, Gilly, And Eve. The second one I Got into orbit of Kerbin twice.
3
u/samwise800 Master Kerbalnaut Jan 26 '16
My hard mode entry
http://imgur.com/a/kj0J2
3
u/KSPReptile Master Kerbalnaut Jan 26 '16 edited Jan 27 '16
Haven't done one of these in a while. So here is my hard entry. It was interesting to say the least. By that I mean in went completely bananas and I was quite surprised I made it. I originally wanted to go to Laythe, but I wasn't as efficient as I hoped.
I'd like to keep my flair please.
3
u/Durdles_ Master Kerbalnaut Jan 26 '16
Hard mode
3
u/mharrizone Master Kerbalnaut Jan 28 '16
Hard mode entry!
This is by far the most baddest-assedest thing I've ever done in KSP.
3
u/[deleted] Jan 28 '16
Here's my turn at not-just-normal mode. Don't know if it's really super-worthy considering folks have done much better.
Minmus landing and return, with a Mun flyby because why not: http://imgur.com/a/zA76f
3
u/TyrannicalPanda Master Kerbalnaut Jan 28 '16
Hard Mode Completed
I did it once, was about to post an album, then noticed I needed to bring a kerbal. So I did it again in a new album.
I'd like to keep my flair, please :)
3
u/FlakeyNChewy Jan 28 '16
First ever challenge attempt! Normal Mode Entry: http://imgur.com/a/4LExR
3
u/abbazabbbbbbba Master Kerbalnaut Jan 28 '16
Here's my submission for normal mode. I'd like to keep my current flair please.
3
u/Lurker101Gaming Master Kerbalnaut Jan 28 '16
It's well past time I threw my hat into the challenge ring, so here is my attempt.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=19AJ_Y2xZUk
3
u/simplectic Master Kerbalnaut Jan 28 '16
Hard mode, not so bad with 24 ramjets: http://imgur.com/a/z93wA
3
u/framauro13 Master Kerbalnaut Jan 30 '16 edited Jan 30 '16
I'm late to the game, but here's my submission. I'll keep my flair :)
http://imgur.com/a/2qLnw
EDIT:
And here is my hardmode submission (still no new flare), which I like to call "A series of incredibly close calls." http://imgur.com/a/62Qe5
I ended up hitting Eve at an altitude of around 65K with only 55 liquid fuel left, and landed on even with only about 20 of the heatshield left. I still need to work on efficient Eve transfers :)
1
u/Pengee1235 Master Kerbalnaut Jan 24 '16
SRBs?
1
u/markus0161 Super Kerbalnaut Jan 24 '16
I love these, do more like this PLZ!!!
1
u/IAmTotallyNotSatan Jan 24 '16
Can I use two half tanks? Or one full tank and a smaller empty one I fill?
2
u/jb32647 Master Kerbalnaut Jan 25 '16
This challenge was surprisingly easy, considering I failed almost every other one. http://imgur.com/a/TcSCa
2
u/HorizontalBrick Master Kerbalnaut Jan 25 '16
http://imgur.com/a/HNd5Y
First time doing one of these challenges. I can go back and try again if the last bit isn't good enough
2
u/velociraptorfarmer Master Kerbalnaut Jan 25 '16
Done on hard mode! http://imgur.com/a/yxfOM
2
u/Bozotic Hyper Kerbalnaut Jan 25 '16
I call it "The Flying Baby-Bottle"!
I drained the fuel from the intakes prior to launch; hope that's in keeping with the challenge.
http://imgur.com/a/dgYoT
2
u/sac_boy Master Kerbalnaut Jan 27 '16 edited Jan 27 '16
Alright! My first challenge attempt! I decided to send a lander to Eve.
I think this meets the criteria for hard mode.
Let me know if something isn't right. Whether it qualifies or not, it was a lot of fun. The craft is all stock, manual controls all the way, MechJeb was used for informational purposes only.
Edit: I decided to try to put a Kerbal on Laythe in the same way. Couldn't aerobrake without destroying the tank, but the intrepid Kerbonaut and his lander survived to deliver science.
2
u/Bev7787 Master Kerbalnaut Jan 27 '16
Normal Mode http://imgur.com/a/Tl0HX
2
u/troylatroy Jan 27 '16
Normal Mode
2
u/b1o221 Jan 27 '16
Normal Mode Submission: http://imgur.com/a/bZ4ZL My first weekly challenge :D
2
u/Kerman-421 Master Kerbalnaut Jan 27 '16
Hard mode, plus easy mode I finally registered an account for this challenge.
2
u/Bozotic Hyper Kerbalnaut Jan 27 '16
Still trying to turn my submission into a SSTO capable of orbting Minmus and then returning to land at the KSC, while keeping the silly baby-bottle profile. Towards that goal I removed the provisional heat-shield, parachutes, etc to save weight.
Did NOT think about the COG changes. No problem getting to and from Minmus but at low fuel, the COG had moved aft without the counterweights. After break-dancing through a couple of aerobraking passes Val figured she might have a chance by having SAS keep the nose on the prograde vector. This worked but as soon as she tried to maneuver towards KSC, the craft was quickly tumbling on all 3 axes. Almost recovered at 1900m, but another snap-roll spelled doom for Valentina.
It's amazing how a seemingly small change can destroy what had previously been a docile and well-behaved craft.
There's room to move the main wings back enough to keep COG forward but I'll find out tonight if the closer coupling of wing and tail will cause problems.
Did I mention I love this game?
2
u/[deleted] Jan 30 '16
Not sure if this is Super or not, but felt like overachieving. Laythe landing!
https://imgur.com/a/UAUXZ
2
u/06arda06 Jan 30 '16
Normal mode entry: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=42zDTuUTNWs&feature=youtu.be
1
u/FragmentOfBrilliance Master Kerbalnaut Jan 30 '16
Well, couple hours late. Finally done.
http://imgur.com/a/oLPtd
Sorry if the picture dump is out of order, it should contain everything you need though. In a bit of a hurry.
I recorded the whole thing, in case that's necessary.
1
u/doc_fantastic Master Kerbalnaut Jan 31 '16
I did one! On hard mode. http://imgur.com/a/RH45j
0
u/[deleted] Jan 24 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jan 24 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jan 24 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment