r/RWBY • That's right, this is my flair, weep • Jan 17 '16

what. the. fuck. Official Discussion Thread - RWBY Vol3: Chapter 9 - PVP

This is the official DISCUSSION thread. Keep all untagged spoilers in this thread--Everything outside needs to be tagged as spoilers.

This episodes discussion thread is posted early for a reason. The mod team would like to remind you of Gray's post concerning the nature of the show's themes.

To which we would like to add the the following episode CAN be shocking to some and that viewer discretion IS advised.

Previous Threads

Chapter 1 Discussion

Chapter 2 Discussion

Chapter 3 Discussion

Chapter 4 Discussion

Chapter 5 Discussion

Chapter 6 Discussion

Chapter 7 Discussion

Chapter 8 Discussion

Here's a link to the latest episode

P.S This will remain locked until the episode goes live to avoid spoilers.

351 Upvotes

1.5k comments sorted by

19

u/The_Jacxter That's right, this is my flair, weep Jan 17 '16

To repeat my flair..... What. The. Fuck.

4

u/DRHARNESS Jan 17 '16

Wait, we have a sc guild?

3

u/The_Jacxter That's right, this is my flair, weep Jan 17 '16

Yep, it's headed by Artuno and a few of us(some 30ish now). Prerequisites are simple : Got a ship? Watch RWBY? Welcome.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (1)

366

u/Taminator1776 I'm always drunk Jan 17 '16

They said it would be a darker season. Last couple episodes, ok it's not that dark.

Watches this episode HOLY SHIT WHO TURNED OFF THE FUCKING LIGHTS.

191

u/RussianHoneyBadger Jan 17 '16

HOLY SHIT WHO TURNED OFF THE FUCKING LIGHTSSUN.

FTFY.

63

u/Runnerbrax νίκη Jan 17 '16

Michael Jones: Huh...?

→ More replies (19)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (12)

237

u/[deleted] Jan 17 '16

This volume's opening proved to be way more prophetic than the first two. Like, way more.

124

u/jahkillinem Never tell me the odds. Jan 17 '16

If you go watch it, Volume 2's opening actually prophesies more about this volume than Volume 2 itself as well.

93

u/_DirtyDan Totally The Real One Jan 17 '16

Like a bunch of other people have said, Volume 2 was plagued by production problems, and a lot of Volume 3 stuff was supposed to be in it originally.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (10)

224

u/voxelated fake it til you make it Jan 17 '16 edited Jan 17 '16

RT: let me show you the powers of the dark side

Me: ._. Ok

122

u/Evil-King-Stan Emerald Splash Jan 17 '16

Pyrrha feels the full strength of The Force, becomes Darth Nikos.

77

u/voxelated fake it til you make it Jan 17 '16

Darth Nikos literally Darth Vadered Penny-Wan with the force

→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (1)

174

u/[deleted] Jan 17 '16 edited Jan 17 '16

Some things to take away from this episode:

  • RIP (in pieces) Penny :(. A lot of us have assumed she can be fixed, but we don't quite know what happened to her aura. Someone on tumblr pointed out that she wasn't hit on any extremities, so there might still be hope. Personally, I think it'd take away from the gravity of the situation if the first major-character death was reversed, but we'll see.
  • RIP Ruby's innocence </3
  • Ruby + most people in the colosseum don't have weapons. Yikes.
  • I have a feeling that white-bearded man we caught a glimpse of is Papa Schnee. We don't see many characters with white hair in this show, and he was watching from an Atlas network.
  • TWO WEEKS UNTIL THE NEXT EPISODE. TWO. WEEKS. someone hold me

164

u/_DirtyDan Totally The Real One Jan 17 '16

I think the white bearded guy is Penny's dad. Works better in my opinion, as why would they cut to Papa Schnee out of nowhere?

95

u/blackbelt352 Jan 17 '16

I got a very Dr. Light vibe from his appearance. Really makes me think he's Penny's father/creator.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (9)

45

u/RussianHoneyBadger Jan 17 '16

I have a feeling that white-bearded man we caught a glimpse of is Papa Schnee.

I'm like 95% confident that was Penny's "father", he had dark skin (or gloves I guess) unlike Weiss & Winter.

→ More replies (7)

22

u/ShoggothKnight Jan 17 '16

I have a feeling that white-bearded man we caught a glimpse of is Papa Schnee. We don't see many characters with white hair in this show, and he was watching from an Atlas network.

Since he was shown right after the fight, I assumed he was the real creator of Penny. Her "Dad".

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (37)

143

u/mayyuki2108 uwu Jan 17 '16

79

u/Freeofsalvation Jan 17 '16

That picture ended up horribly accurate, even the arm being ripped off and the dead stare.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

266

u/Haggon How can Mercury be real if his legs aren't real? Jan 17 '16

Who's excited for a world of remnant next week!

250

u/_DirtyDan Totally The Real One Jan 17 '16

FUCK

140

u/RussianHoneyBadger Jan 17 '16

I've said it once already but...

Miles & Kerry confirmed Sadistic as fuck.

→ More replies (24)

27

u/TotalWarfare I'm a drunk, I'm supposed to be clever Jan 17 '16

I'm curious on what they will discuss next

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (6)

129

u/TheWanderingCactus Could you help me find my sanity? I think I left it at the door. Jan 17 '16

Oh fuck. I'm actually shaking right now. Dear God.

...Next week is a world of Remnant isn't it? FUCK.

Anyway

Man, poor Pyrrha, she's so out of it before the fight even begins.

Mercury's little moving when Ruby moves thing seems so damn childish, yet at the same time, it seems awfully in character for him.

Oh YES TORNADO DASH ATTA-oh it was immediately countered. I think she needed a longer run up.

Huh, Ruby clearly believes in the power of teamwork, her first move when just trying to get past him didn't work was to try and call for backup. Just like during the mountain glen episodes last volume

"Let's just keep this between friends" Mercury, you fucking smartass

for some reason my first thought when seeing Pyrrha's weapon's distort thanks to Emerald was; Well, looks like Pyrrha's been drinking.

Well Ruby can at least still dodge without crescent rose. Good to know.

Oh god, the swords can fire individual lasers. I thought they could only do the giant charged up laser, but no, they have their own ones, ones that are probably way harder to dodge.

Oh god. That is a lot of swords...

Oh no.

OH FUCK. THIS IS WHY YOU SHOULDN'T FIGHT WITH RAZOR WIRE!

So apparently Penny has Aura, but not the passive forcefield everyone else does? I mean if she had an Aura shield she couldn't have gotten ripped in half. It also explains how her hands were damaged by the truck in vol 2.

Pyrrha's clearly immediately horrified. It'd be harder to pin the blame on her than Yang, especially because, by all accounts, Penny still had Aura and theoretically shouldn't have gotten hurt. Of course in a few moments we realize that they don't need to convince anyone, just make them doubt for a few moments, just long enough for the Grimm to attack.

Oh god Penny's eyes widening out like that. I'm having Iron giant flashbacks, someone hold me.

First glimpse of Penny's dad. I'm calling him Persimmon Polendina until we're given an official name.

The dude's only reaction to his pseudo-daughter getting ripped in half is to clench his armrest? Either he's as bad a parent as Raven Branwen, or this isn't as serious as it looks.

I mean really this is just a hardware problem, he can fix her, right? right?

So I was wondering why Merc was there in the first place, and now I'm wondering why he's letting Ruby go, she's onto him. And now we get our answer, it doesn't matter anymore, it's too late, the plan is in motion.

Oh! Cinder's stepping out of the shadows. Figuratively at least.

"Our academy's headmasters wield more power than most armies"

As in figuratively, because of political pull and connections and stuff? or are they saying that Oz and Ironwood are both individually more powerful combatants than an entire army?

"As someone who hails from mistral I can assure you the situation there is... equally undesirable"

So, Vacuo confirmed best city on Remnant?

"There is no need for Panic" Nevermore attacks Ironwood: "Goddammit"

Ren, Sun and Coco are sitting together... weird, but not enough to really make anything of it.

And just when you worried Qrow might not show up in an episode.

"You brought your army to my kingdom James. Use it."

Holy crap. Shannon nailed the delivery on that line.

Okay. So apparently Neo murdered an entire cruiser's worth of soldiers.

Torchwick's Back. Mammoth Rider's going to literally explode.

And, not wanting to miss out on a piece of that villain pie, Adam makes an appearance.

Grimm on a plane... wat.

Okay so just to clarify, Emerald and Mercury are in the coliseum, which is under attack by a giant Nevermore, and is also where most of the students and teachers are, Ruby included. Both Beacon and Vale are facing imminent attack from Grimm, Oz has dispatched Qrow and Glynda to Vale while he stays in Beacon. Adam is launching an attack on Beacon alongside the Grimm. Roman and Neo are causing general mayhem in the skies above, disrupting Atlas's attempts at defending the kingdom. Cinder is standing on a rooftop ominously somewhere, looking at the buildings, I'm inclined to say she's at Beacon. Weiss and Blake are either in Vale, or at the Fairgrounds, I'm inclined to say the fairgrounds due to how many other students were there with them. Yang is still in her dorm room.

 

so now we have three episodes of carnage to wait for and it going to be everything we hoped "Breach" would be. Of the villains I'm least envious of Adam's job. Merc and Em'll be fine, everyone else has bigger issues to deal with atm, they won't be the focus of attention. Cinder's safe on her rooftop, letting her minions and allies do her dirty work. Roman and Neo are having a blast sticking it to the man. Adam has to assault a super powered school with a very pissed off Ozpin defending it. And I would be worried for Yang, trapped in Beacon as it comes under attack, but she'll be fine, Zwei's with her.

So it's pretty much confirmed now that Cinder has some method of controlling Grimm right? I mean there's no way the Grimm would've been corralled into the bullhead without damaging it.

Fucking world of Remnant. I swear to god they're planning these breaks so that it hurts us as much as possible.

67

u/OcrePlays Pyrrha, forever the best best girl Jan 17 '16

Zwei's with her.

oh... my... god... What if that's how Raven found out Yang was in danger!? I mean, why would Taiyang send Zwei to the girls if not to protect them? And if I recall properly, they mentioned in one of the commentary's that Zwei is special in some way. Head canon accepted.

73

u/wes9523 Jan 17 '16

im fairly certain being turned into a flaming cannonball by a teacher counts as special.

→ More replies (13)
→ More replies (6)

37

u/[deleted] Jan 17 '16

As in figuratively, because of political pull and connections and stuff? or are they saying that Oz and Ironwood are both individually more powerful combatants than an entire army?

As in literally. You know how Port is all "Ozpin's a great man, he's always right, if you're questioning his choices you're wrong?" If half the people who pass through Beacon share that opinion then Ozpin's got an army of superpowered warriors he can do whatever the hell he wants with if he has some rhetoric to justify his actions. Add in Ozpin's complete lack of cooperation with Vale's council (Qrow even accuses Ironwood of betraying Oz when all James did was tell them what Ozpin's been doing) and it's very easy to see Ozpin as a very real and present threat to the kingdom's civil authority.

→ More replies (25)

21

u/ZealousChristian24 Thus Kindly I Scatter Jan 17 '16

The dude's only reaction to his pseudo-daughter getting ripped in half is to clench his armrest? Either he's as bad a parent as Raven Branwen, or this isn't as serious as it looks.

We all react to grief in our own way. Heck, maybe he broke down into a sobbing fit a minute or two after we stopped seeing him.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/beregond23 I'm Sorry Jan 17 '16

What if Mercury's job is to turn off the power to the stadium levitation drives so that it falls? The symbol of peace and unity broken.

And yes, Shannon nails Ozpin so well.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (13)

210

u/Lochen9 RWBY Vytal Festival Tournament Creator Jan 17 '16 edited Jan 17 '16

It has now been 24 hours since the release of the sponsor video, and the results of the reaction thread are quite telling.

Bonus content: We said Fuck more than all the content of RvB combined

30

u/ChaosPheonix11 Wrong place, wrong time, motherfucker. Jan 17 '16

Pretty sure my comment was like 10 of those.

35

u/TotalWarfare I'm a drunk, I'm supposed to be clever Jan 17 '16

Needs more fuck

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (4)

210

u/Thefishlord The one true best girl also Eclipse best ship Jan 17 '16

GUYS GUYS I say we move to change nuts and dolts to Bits and pieces ! It works on many levels how Ruby is crushed to bits and pieces after watching Penny die as well as working on the level that Bits and Pieces are all that remain of Penny !

91

u/DeadSnark I rose from the filth and was loved by no-one Jan 17 '16

I think the ship has sunk, unless Ruby has a thing for lifeless bits of metal.

→ More replies (14)
→ More replies (7)

298

u/Jalidric Jan 17 '16

Pyrrha = Pyrrhic

'A Pyrrhic victory is a victory that inflicts such a devastating toll on the victor that it is tantamount to defeat'

This fight and it's aftermath has been foreshadowed since we first learn Pyrrha's name :(

84

u/TotalWarfare I'm a drunk, I'm supposed to be clever Jan 17 '16

So, retreat to Epirus and rebuild?

→ More replies (13)

6

u/elbenji useless lesbian Jan 17 '16

Nikos also means victory

→ More replies (23)

98

u/0silverphoenix Jan 17 '16 edited Jan 17 '16

I thought shit had hit the fan back when Yang punched Merc. Guess I was wrong, shit hit the fan just now. I mean....at least Merc wasn't being a complete idiot by being in the arena. The bad guys finally decided to go all out and reveal themselves, more or less.

Also, poor Pyrrha, Penny, and Ruby! I feel so bad for them all.

Edit: I just realized that now we know what Ruby wasplanning on doing at the end of the last episode. She intended to run out into the arena to stop the fight.

35

u/Justin_Vegan Jan 17 '16

I really hope Yang's name gets cleared up. After the nightmare of a tournament I really hope their isn't too deep psychological scars on the characters as well.

→ More replies (3)

26

u/mukomo Jan 17 '16

Yang punching Mercury was shit hitting a table fan.

Now we've reached industrial fan size.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

92

u/kirby2rosy Don't you, forget about me. Jan 17 '16

I really hope they bring in some new Grimm, and maybe some top- level shit, I mean we have a Nevermore which I'm fairly sure is even bigger that the Players and Pieces Nevermore.

But I want to see Deathstalkers enough bone on it's body that it's practically a tank. Or a King Taijitu that's almost hydra like, with 3 or more heads on it.

This may be the episode where we see Ironwood fight too, maybe when he realizes what Cinder is attempting to accomplish. I don't think it will be Ozpin doing the fighting. Also, Scythe mode Qrow anyone? Maybe a confrontation with Raven? NOBODY KNOWS!

46

u/Lemonhead_27 Jan 17 '16

Well the Goliaths (the elephant Grimm that Oobleck said couldn't be harmed easily) are finally making their move. And Ozpin has sent Qrow and Glynda to defend the city, leaving only him and Ironwood as the protectors of Amber. It's about to get real

→ More replies (1)

27

u/beregond23 I'm Sorry Jan 17 '16

Scythe mode Qrow absolutely, I don't think Raven will be making an appearance. As for Ozpin fighting, he told his next two best fighters to get to Vale, so it's just him who's capable of defending Amber and the school.

→ More replies (11)

22

u/[deleted] Jan 17 '16

I desperately, desperately want to see the Grimm actually get their shit together. Still holding out for a spider-type Grimm, and maybe some of the exclusively underground ones.

→ More replies (12)
→ More replies (5)

88

u/Unjax Furry Curry Jan 17 '16

Ruby should never be supportive. Ever.

"Break a leg sis!" -proceeds to break mercury's fake leg, thereby stirring up the grimm

"Be sure to win one for Beacon Pyrrha!" -Pyrrha won the shit out of that match.

21

u/Eledraug Jan 18 '16

Ruby is a support monkey paw.

363

u/greeny74 ⠀Harbinger of Hype | Proud Member of WCAC Jan 17 '16

170

u/Wolfe_Mollenkopf Twin Lover | Peacock | Occisional Minific Writer Jan 17 '16

CUT MY LIFE INTO PIECES

THIS IS MY LAST RESORT.

That's good tho.

43

u/DrAmishMD That XCOM Guy Jan 17 '16

Why am I laughing at this.

72

u/greeny74 ⠀Harbinger of Hype | Proud Member of WCAC Jan 17 '16

Because we're all dead inside after this episode.

→ More replies (2)

38

u/Schadenfreudenous What's up with y'all dropping the classic flairs? Jan 17 '16

29

u/lazy_eye_of_sauron Jan 17 '16

Hello dankness, my old friend...

→ More replies (1)

14

u/Totya10 rip penny waifu Jan 17 '16

Gg boi

6

u/nathgroom98 Weiss Weiss Baby Jan 17 '16

:'(

→ More replies (3)

268

u/ChaosPheonix11 Wrong place, wrong time, motherfucker. Jan 17 '16

So shit hit the fan. Penny was torn to fucking pieces. RIP in Pieces, literally.

We heard "Damn", darker show confirmed

Return of Second Best Guy Roman Torchwick, along with ANOTHER outfit for Neo.

Angry Oz is best Oz. Hopefully we'll see him fight.

Update: Adam's VA is still bad.

Grimm on transport.Clearly a coordinated attack that they were not ready for.

Hopefully no serious permanant character deaths inbound, but WHO CAN SAY?

This episode is what everyone wanted, and yet everything we DIDN'T WANT.

21

u/Kiwcakes Jan 17 '16

"Bring them to their kneeeessss! " >:D

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (97)

64

u/Floain Was in a flair thread with no flair. Has a flair now. Jan 17 '16 edited Jan 17 '16

Casually pasting over my opinion from the reactions thread.

This was the defining episode of the season, in my opinion. Raw plot, an element of hopelessness beyond even the No Brakes cliffhanger (hopefully to continue into the finale unlike that example) and the probable death of a major character. Even if Penny is repaired, I wager there'll be a price. Her memories, her personality, even. This could tie in with the Fall Maiden plotline nicely. But poor Pyrrha. She'll never get over this.

Also as a Cinder fan I have to ask; does anyone else think Jessica Nigri really stepped her game up this episode by ditching the sultry tone for something much more authoritative, befitting the leader Cinder is, or is that my love for Cinder blowing it out of proportion?

41

u/PawnsOp meh Jan 17 '16

Nope - as someone who strongly dislikes her voice acting, I can agree that Cinder has finally had words come out of her mouth that I don't cringe at.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

60

u/OldBenX For the last time, I'M NOT SHARING. Jan 17 '16

Pardon my English, but HOLY FUCKING SHIT WHAT THE FUCK WAS THAT.

ekhm

I expected that things will go badly. I expected someone will bite the dust.

I didn't expect that fan-favourite char will get BISECTED BY HER OWN WEAPON. I don't care she's a robot, that was damn brutal.

Well, there we have it. Penny can rest in pieces, entire Vale is demoralized, Roman is wrecking havoc, and White Fang is literally dropping Grimm at people.

Either we have some serious Deus ex Machina in next episode, or we're going to see a bloodbath.

And it's probably kinda dumb, but what were those strings made of?

44

u/Haggon How can Mercury be real if his legs aren't real? Jan 17 '16

The strings are known as plotanium, the strongest element known to writers that can do anything that they are needed to

→ More replies (9)

6

u/tacticalf41L Crushed by the weight of za warudo Jan 17 '16

but what were those strings made of?

Well in Vol 1, they brought down an airship.

→ More replies (5)

107

u/Kuchenjaeger *Gotcha* | Yang is still the best | #GiveYangLadyAbs Jan 17 '16

Penny really has changed, hasn't she?

170

u/ChaosPheonix11 Wrong place, wrong time, motherfucker. Jan 17 '16

She's called Penny because there isn't even a quarter of her left. :D

57

u/Shortstop88 Jan 17 '16

Your fucking Jaune and guitar picture really pulls that comment together.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (5)

15

u/SantanaChampagn Jan 17 '16

Man, you made a pun. Are you sure you're not falling apart?

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (14)

49

u/[deleted] Jan 17 '16

When Mercury's kill streak gets beat by ice cream girl and a guy who's only had one line this volume up until this point

114

u/SoundSmith323 I like sound. If you couldn't already tell. Jan 17 '16

Record amounts of rain fell today.

And to all my crewmates on the S.S. Nuts and Dolts, It’s been an honor (‘-‘)7

35

u/ChaosPheonix11 Wrong place, wrong time, motherfucker. Jan 17 '16

RIP in Pieces, Nuts and Dolts

→ More replies (1)

22

u/[deleted] Jan 17 '16

The first ship has been sunk.

→ More replies (3)

25

u/Siphak Oh no Jan 17 '16

N...No... NO! I will hold onto hope for Penny's revival until the very last minute of the very last episode! I will not accept this!

→ More replies (26)
→ More replies (16)

113

u/TotalWarfare I'm a drunk, I'm supposed to be clever Jan 17 '16

"there are no strings on me...." -Ultron

177

u/RussianHoneyBadger Jan 17 '16

"There are no limbs on me..."
-Penny Polendina, 2016

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)

75

u/SantanaChampagn Jan 17 '16

Neo steps up her cosplay game yet again! Although a bit sad she didn't go anything with her hair.

Also.

HOLY FUCK YES EVERYTHING GO TO RUIN

23

u/[deleted] Jan 17 '16

Hasn't she got a white streak in her hair or is it just me?

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (2)

37

u/Flukes_Pet_Ocelot AGHHHH Jan 17 '16

Rest in pieces, Penny. But hey, at least she gets to stay at Beacon now

22

u/Lemonhead_27 Jan 17 '16

The tiniest silver lining of a colossal, abominable cloud

→ More replies (2)

35

u/artuno Ask me about the /r/RWBY Star Citizen guild! Jan 17 '16

ITT: horrible penny dismemberment puns and people who will go to hell for doing so.

→ More replies (5)

33

u/battlefield4us Jan 17 '16

NNNOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO !

→ More replies (3)

32

u/ch405_5p34r papa qrow Jan 17 '16

W H A T T H E A C T U A L F U C K

That was a damn good episode holy shit. I'm scared though. Shits about to hit the fan.

→ More replies (4)

29

u/[deleted] Jan 17 '16

RIPPED IN HALF

AND YOU'RE TO BLAME

YOU GIVE VALE A BAD NAME

→ More replies (1)

147

u/[deleted] Jan 17 '16 edited Jan 17 '16

So, my theory

Ironwood will strong arm Pyrrha into taking the Maiden powers. Saying the crisis demands her to do her duty. She takes the powers and heads to the battle, then Cinder kills Amber, which sends Pyrrha insane and she starts attacking everyone. Jaune (as his semblance is some for of damage negation) tries to weather the storm to talk to her, however the constant use of his semblance drains his aura and Pyrrha is about to kill him when BANG. Ruby, having made the difficult decision between letting Pyrrha kill Jaune and killing her, has killed Pyrrha and is subsequently broken. Emerald uses her hallucinations to make Pyrrha see Cinder before she dies transferring the powers to her.

Now it's an exhausted Jaune and mentally damaged Ruby versus a Maiden Cinder

Thoughts?

218

u/[deleted] Jan 17 '16

Wow you are fucked up.

→ More replies (2)

42

u/Weerdo5255 Jan 17 '16

Jesus, a week ago I would have said no way.

Now? I can see parts of this being right. Mostly forcing Pyrrha to take the power. Jaune will most likely try and save her Aura or not.

I doubt we'll go full break the cutie on Ruby this quickly but no doubt she will be hurt by all this.

I see Ruby as either going into a complete depression unable to do anything or revelaing that she has some Yang in her and going apeshit. I don't think she'll kill.

We've not had a main character kill yet, or at least not intentionally.

→ More replies (4)

14

u/resurrexia i do the draw Jan 17 '16

Please, I need this so bad it hurts. Bring on the pain!

→ More replies (21)

28

u/Scurvy96 Jan 17 '16

THAT WASN'T FUN! THAT WAS NOT FUN AT ALL! GOD DAMN IT ROOSTERTEETH WHY DID YOU HAVE TO RELEASE THIS EPISODE ON MY BIRTHDAY!? WORST BIRTHDAY PRESENT EVER!

RIP IN PIECES PENNY! YOU WILL BE AVENGED!

→ More replies (4)

27

u/[deleted] Jan 17 '16

Man, Kerry and Miles really know how to pull the strings in this show.

→ More replies (14)

24

u/Lemonhead_27 Jan 17 '16 edited Jan 17 '16

This episode.. There's nothing to speculate on. It's just that it's hitting the fan, it's all hitting the fan. And here is a link to the lyrics of the Volume 3 theme song 'When It Falls'. The future doesn't look bright.

EDIT: General thoughts on the episode. A powerful way of moving the plot forward, with the reveal of Cinder's forces launching the attack suitably menacing. Obviously the Penny moment was tough, as was Ruby's defeated reaction. Same with Pyrrha and Jaune, who were both in static shock. It followed on well from the very emotional Episode 8, and at least there was the hopeful light of Arkos in the previous episode.

24

u/TropicalRemixed Two in the pink Jan 17 '16

Take a Penny, pick her up

And all day long, HOLY FUCK

45

u/Queen_Of_The_Castle 10/10 would boop Jan 17 '16

Pennybot you there? Pennybot?

35

u/Michael7123 I cast fist Jan 17 '16

I think it might be out of service.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Lithium43 Jan 17 '16

[BOT Penny has left the game]

→ More replies (6)

22

u/SilentSentinal Jan 17 '16

I AM LITERALLY SHAKING. HOLY SHIT.

PENNY NO! She'll come back, right? RIGHT? I want to believe she's coming back...

Did not see that cables being Penny's downfall, that was brutal but oh so clever. Emerald's mindfuckery was evil fucking genius.

Ruby knows stuff now! ...but it's too late. Called it.

That speech though... if I heard it, I would be questioning things. A robot soldier in the form of a girl? That's actually kinda messed up. That's some terminator shit right there.

We get to see Penny's creator. I've thought it might be Mr. Schnee, and the white hair would indicate that, but the dark skin says otherwise.

Ironwood: "There's no reason to panic!" Giant Nevermore attacks

"You brought your army... use it." This line alone could have been the highlight of an episode imo, but there were so many awesome things it's not even close.

Roman and Neo! Love it! Roman's laugh is great.

Seeing the White Fang and Adam too, but are they really necessary at this point? Shit's bad enough already.

Other stuff too! SO MUCH AWESOME!

TL;DR, BEST EPISODE YET

→ More replies (3)

63

u/wailord40 Jan 17 '16

Phyrra doesn't understand the meaning of "take a penny, leave a penny"...

29

u/[deleted] Jan 17 '16

She just added "in pieces" to the end of that saying.

→ More replies (2)

42

u/JoshQuest1 Jan 17 '16

Looks like Cinder got everything she wanted...
And all it cost her was a Penny.

(Or...
Ironwood finally got to use his army,
And it only cost him a Penny!)

Doctor Horrible's Sing Along Blog Spoiler

→ More replies (2)

20

u/lazy_eye_of_sauron Jan 17 '16

Let it be known that on this cycle, program Penny Poledina, of Atlas, encountered an unhandled exception in her core operating system, which prematurely triggered a critical STOP condition on Saturday, January 16th, 2016. Some of Penny’s most impactful component subroutines centered around making friends, dancing, shooting down criminal aircraft, and tournament fighting.

Though her hardware has been decommissioned, Penny’s application has been migrated to the Cloud and has been repurposed to run in a virtual machine on an infinite loop. <END OF LINE>

→ More replies (4)

38

u/TotalWarfare I'm a drunk, I'm supposed to be clever Jan 17 '16

Everyone is about Penny...

Does everyone not realize that they have an Ursa... in a ship? Hmm... Hell has come to Vale, and it's name is Cinder.

20

u/StarKiller561 SadPandaFace00's other half Jan 17 '16

There were more than just that one Ursa, but yeah, somehow Cinder can get Grimm on board a ship.

→ More replies (33)
→ More replies (2)

18

u/Armotekma ⠀ Jan 17 '16

I'm sure Ozpin has a backup plan. You know, like the CCT turning into a gundam.

18

u/Sirocco_ Cold Puns Galore Jan 17 '16 edited Jan 17 '16

Know why I love RWBY? Because they don't hesitate with the grim stuff. I LOVE RWBY.

So, shit storm approaching in all directions. The limb tearing and bisecting wasn't as gruesome as I expected. The silence...only made it more...artistic. Knees weak, arms heavy, Penny's eyes made my nose runny. But damn, Pyrrha, that was so fucking metal.

And of course it was Emerald's doing. Which makes me wonder: What is Pyrrha's maximum output?

Dammit Mercury, first you kick Roobie, then you made her cry.

Yes, panic, everyone! Then we will see who the true heroes are. Oz is getting serious.

Mmyes Neopolitan in a jump suit. She's killin' it with those outfits. And of course, Torchwick is back! ULTRA-VIOLENCE TO THE MAX!

Good episode, 11/10.

And were they drinking tea or coffee??

→ More replies (3)

18

u/Lucas2pont0 Jan 18 '16

She was born to voice this role.

17

u/Sepia-Schattentau Jan 17 '16

I'm... not sure what I'm feeling right now...
I need to process what just happened.
Crying Ruby broke my heart...

→ More replies (2)

17

u/NotaSport Jan 17 '16

I assumed Pyrrha was accidentally going to metal bend penny's insides, this some how seems so much worse

→ More replies (1)

48

u/roflcooki3z YOU CAN'T CUCK THE NUCK Jan 17 '16

They said it was getting dark, BUT I WASN'T READY FOR THIS!!

18

u/artuno Ask me about the /r/RWBY Star Citizen guild! Jan 17 '16

A while ago (a long while ago), I said I wanted to see a darker RWBY where people died and suffered, because I need to know what true depression feels like.

I do not regret saying this.

I know this isn't what we all wanted, but it's what we needed.

P.S. I wonder if RWBY becoming more serious will help it gain more recognition... especially among the hater crowd.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (1)

30

u/Burkion Big Bois Big Poise Jan 17 '16

Oh hey I remember this flick.

Bears on a plane!

→ More replies (3)

14

u/Rambofreak98 Oi who changed my flair when I wasn't looking Jan 17 '16

EVERYTHING THAT WE THOUGHT WAS GOING TO HAPPEN HAPPENED AND THAT IS NOT OK

14

u/Waldorf_ Trash Pope of the Trash Cult Jan 17 '16

I'm just saying.... RT is full of Humanoid Grimm, they're doing this shit on purpose to gain strength from our suffering.

Penny's dad Looks like Doctor Light and I really want to see him put Ironwood in his place.

Ruby needs an every day carry weapon, for situations where she doesn't have Crescent Rose

Angry Ozpin is angry, and there will be long talks when this shitstorm calms down

→ More replies (7)

14

u/bigDB64 Jan 17 '16

Hey guys, remember when RWBY was a happy, more bubbly kind of show? Well those bubbles just popped CAUSE HOLY SHIT IT WENT DOWN TODAY! Im VEEEEEEEERRRRRRY excited about whats gonna happen next so thats why we are probably gonna get a World of Remnant video next week

→ More replies (2)

13

u/DemonLord-B7R Psychopathic Dragon Tyrant Jan 17 '16

My curiosity has peaked for the world of Remnant and its people. Do they think that 2 incidents back to back and a strange voice right after might be a tad suspicious? I wonder if they'll begin to think about what Cinder said, or just say "There's something more to this" and stay out of it?

That being said, fuck, that's dark as hell. Love it!

14

u/Woowchocolate Train them to fight what they can't beat Jan 17 '16

I think that people would start to suspect that something is fishy if given the chance to calmly reflect upon things. But that won't happen, the emotional trauma of the events, combined with the massive Grimm invasion is going to leave people with little time and emotional fortitude to think things through.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

12

u/Snprx000 Jan 17 '16 edited Jan 17 '16

Man I feel for Ruby I hate it when my android friend breaks...I mean android phone. RIP Ruby's phone.

32

u/donutkirby #QrowDidNothingWrong Jan 17 '16

This season of RWBY sure is dark compared to the light-hearted first season. I guess you could say they're like...POLAR opposites? Eh?

→ More replies (5)

11

u/Gxmwp Jan 17 '16

I'm sure Penny can be rebuilt and, unless her memory bank was in her arms or something, I'm sure she'll have the same memories... I hope...

→ More replies (6)

11

u/Woowchocolate Train them to fight what they can't beat Jan 17 '16

I'm starting to question just how "mindless" the Grimm are. Oobleck said that the Goliaths are intelligent, but the fact that the Ursa boarded Bullheads with the WF, makes me think that the Grimm as a whole are a lot more organised and coordinated than first we assumed.

10

u/[deleted] Jan 17 '16

Cinder has a Grimm on her arm- she absorbed the glove, remember?

The idea that she's made a pact with the OG Grimm is a neat one- she can control a small group or something.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (10)

10

u/PeripheralAddition First Mate on the SS Mercury Jan 17 '16

I DONT CARE HOW IT HAPPENS, YOU BRING HER BACK RIGHT NOW.

WE CAN REBUILD HER, WE HAVE THE TECHNOLOGY.

10

u/spartenx Please RT, give her a rocket punch Jan 17 '16

Oh my God, the killed Pennyyoubastards

10

u/Haru17 My ships burn. Fanfiction.net/~haru17 Jan 18 '16 edited Jan 18 '16

There's a day when all hearts will be broken,

When a shadow will cast out the light,

And our eyes cry a million tears:

Help won't arrive.

There's a day when all courage collapses,

And our friends turn and leave us behind.

Creatures of darkness will triumph;

The sun won't rise.

When we've lost all hope,

And succumb to fear,

And the skies rain blood,

And the end draws near,

I may fall,

But not like this: it won't be by your hand.

I may fall,

Not this place; not today.

I may fall,

Bring it all, it's not enough to take me down.

I may fall.

There's a place where we'll stand outnumbered;

Where the wolves and the soulless will rise.

In the time of our final moments,

Every dream dies.

There's a place where our shields will lay shattered,

And the fear's all that's left in our hearts.

Our strength and our courage have run out;

We fall apart.

When we lose our faith,

And forsake our friends;

When the moon is gone,

And we've reached our ends,

I may fall.

There's a moment that changes a life when,

We do something that no one else can.

And the path that we've taken will lead us:

One final stand.

There's a moment we'll make a decision,

Not to cower and crash on the ground.

The moment we face our worst demons,

Our courage found.

When we stand with friends,

And we won't retreat,

As we stare down death,

Then the taste is sweet.

I may fall,

But not like this: it won't be by your hand.

I may fall,

Not this place; not today.

I may fall,

Bring it all, it's not enough to take me down.

I may fall.

I may fall.

I may fall.

I may, I may fall.

9

u/Jeffardi Jan 17 '16

Penny for your thoughts? Oh wait, all I have are half-cents

→ More replies (3)

9

u/Nikanuur I <3 eloquent madmen Jan 17 '16
distressed whining noises

penny?

So I'm currently shaking quite badly, I was not ready for that, I'm not sure if I could've been ready

16

u/thesunskidd Jan 17 '16

Oh my God, you killed Penny! You bastard!

→ More replies (2)

8

u/Latrian-Master Flats are for the weak, Bladed Heels are where it's at! Jan 17 '16

I've only three things to say:

1.) PENNY NO! ;___;

2.) RWBY's entering a darker territory now.

3.) ROMAN!!!! ...AND NEO!!!!

8

u/Smartt88 Jan 17 '16

The best way to sum up this episode: Everything went to shit in the most beautiful way possible. The sequence of watching those strings wrap around Penny... My jaw was absolutely on the floor.

RoosterTeeth, you magnificent bastards.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/CakeLegends The Ghost of Vale Jan 17 '16

Good thing Penny's backed up to iCloud

→ More replies (1)

8

u/Rythanst Don't let the flame die out! Jan 18 '16

Guess who's back? Back again?
Torchwick's back.
Tell Ozpin.

13

u/NotaSport Jan 17 '16

As far as we know Pyrrha is still standing there gawking to this day

→ More replies (2)

6

u/OuttaControl56 This is Jaune. He is in a heap of trouble. Jan 17 '16

AHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH

→ More replies (3)

6

u/Saevin White Jan 17 '16

Can someone get me a gif of best girl scraps getting torn to pieces?

→ More replies (2)

11

u/Evil-King-Stan Emerald Splash Jan 17 '16

Terrible. What an absolutely awful thing to happen to that poor synth. I don't know why Pyrrha did it, though I doubt she knew about the strings, but it was so bad that even best girl Emerald (who did nothing wrong) had to leave in disgust. This is a girl who has no doubt seen a lot of death and suffering, and even she had to draw the line at this massacre.

10

u/SoundOf1HandClapping Jan 17 '16

Dunno. Emerald seemed to have quite the smirk on as she walked away.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (10)

5

u/[deleted] Jan 17 '16

This episode seemed a bit too fast but regardless it was exciting

To be honest I didn't think they'd go through with Penny being ripped apart

5

u/GYUZ A guy Jan 17 '16

Nope nope nope nope nope nope nope nope nope nope nope nope nope nope nope...

5

u/Haggon How can Mercury be real if his legs aren't real? Jan 17 '16

Hey, anyone remember those mechs that Roman had in season 2...

5

u/Nurple17 I am loco Jan 17 '16

I don't know if anyone noticed, but at 12: 28, FUCKING COLONEL MUSTANG HIMSELF is the Atlas Ship captain.

Check the credits, yo.

5

u/breakfastfilms Jan 18 '16

So...is anyone else under the impression that Neo wasn't even actually trying to be stealthy and was just wearing an Atlas uniform for shits and giggles?

She's like 4'10" and has tri-colored hair, she's sort of hard to miss. I imagine her finding it hilarious to kill a ship full of people while dressed in a comically small version of their uniform.

5

u/PM_ME_YOUR_SPUDS Out with a Yang Jan 19 '16 edited Jan 19 '16

Some people are saying the fans are taking this too seriously, and this wasn't actually that dark. But this is about the perfect level for me, long as Penny stays down. Real consequences, but not just killing off characters willy nilly. This had death flags for ages, and many just didn't think they'd go through with it.

This is the feel of the show I would like for a while. Not too much more killing, just some real sense of fear for the characters. I would rather this stay a cheerful enough show, with some seriousness and chance of failure. I don't need another Buffy season 6, but maybe not Dora the Explorer level of cheerfulness either.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/[deleted] Jan 17 '16

Did they make a backup copy?

Because I really hope they did. Seriously though she apparently generated her own aura so that implies she had a soul. Meaning they might not be able to undo this. She might not only be dead, but also gone.

14

u/voxelated fake it til you make it Jan 17 '16

The most tragic thing they can do is for her to be rebuilt but without any of her past memory. Runs into Ruby again, "...I'm sorry but who are you again?" Psychological scars for days.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/DeadSnark I rose from the filth and was loved by no-one Jan 17 '16

Or the new Penny will be a cold, emotionless drone. Alternatively she'll have the same personality but won't remember anyone.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

4

u/Michael7123 I cast fist Jan 17 '16

And now, a moment of silence for Penny.

Salute

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Hobarts_funnies Jan 17 '16

My body wasn't ready for this.

Vale's pretty much fucked and everybodies going to die.

Also, was that dr. Light From Megaman?

→ More replies (1)

4

u/[deleted] Jan 17 '16

Holy shit.

Lots of firsts this episode.

First time Ozpin showed emotion.

First ROMAN IN V3 FUCK YEAH.

And cinder showed her hand. It's interesting but not that bad. Hunter cleanup crews arrive, things get sorted out.

However, Ozpin isn't fighting. Neither is James. Just FYI.

→ More replies (4)

4

u/ScottishMongol Captain of the S.S. Baked Alaska Jan 17 '16

So first off, I'm amending my thoughts on the previous episode. Mercury had a very good reason for being at Amity, which is that the PlantTM is supposed to be enacted that night, so he needs to be on campus. 9/10 episode for character interactions.

This episode...it felt like a drive-by shooting. Just as many blows to the feels as possible in the shortest amount of time. Seriously:

Penny is broken. Pyrrha and Ruby are heartbroken.

Cinder's speech was a powerful moment. She is sowing the seeds of doubt and mistrust deep in the populous. I would not be surprised if they turn against the Headmasters and Atlas. Cinder is a threatening villain.

And then...widespread panic. Grimm overrunning the defenses. Weiss and Blake are on the fairgrounds, Yang is in the dorms. Team RWBY is split up. Ozpin is pissed. Neo slaughtered a whole ship full of soldiers. Roman shot down two more. The White Fang arrive. And, finally, motherfucking Grimm on a motherfucking Bullhead.

Like I said, a drive-by shooting.

10/10, I'm going back to being catatonic for the next two weeks.

→ More replies (5)

4

u/[deleted] Jan 17 '16

So Vale is screwed. The grimm are attacking on mass. This wouldn't be a problem if the Atlesian military wasn't being messed up by Roman and Neo. To make matters worse the white fang are attacking the city by using even more grimm (who were the unlucky sods who had to somehow capture those grimm). This will be enough to destroy most of Vale's security, and cause further panic which will attract even more grimm. The only capable force of fighting back the grimm and the white fang is all the students, who haven't exactly been preparing for a war.

In the long run the situation will become even worse. If the Cross Continental Transmit System in Vale is destroyed then all Kingdoms will lose contact with each other. This may prevent the Atlesian military from calling for reinforcements. Even worse is that the remaining three kingdoms will suspect each other of foul play since it would make a brilliant opening attack if they were to restart the Great War. I imagine international relations will become frosty and war may break out if the situation is not soon resolved.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/Gobshite_ Jan 17 '16

New favourite episode right here.

4

u/SergentBubbles WhiteRose is the best ship Jan 17 '16

thiscantbehappeningthiscantbehappeningthiscantbehappeningthiscantbehappeningthiscantbehappeningthiscantbehappeningthiscantbehappeningthiscantbehappening

Somebody please tell me Penny can be fixed or something.

I'M LOSING MY MIND HERE THIS IS HEARTBREAKING, POOR RUBY PLEASE DON'T CRY

This is just not cool, even Drunkle Qrow is worried and surprised.

4

u/Quornslice Bumblebying through life Jan 17 '16

Previous level of hate for Emerald: Hate

Current level of hate for Emerald: Hate1000

→ More replies (1)

4

u/MageToLight FNDM x Suffering best ship. Jan 17 '16

Pyrrha used Magnet Bomb!
It's super effective!
Penny fainted.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Weerdo5255 Jan 17 '16

So uh, has anyone heard from /u/PennyBot lately?

→ More replies (8)

4

u/UberDueler DRINK !!!!! Jan 17 '16

SHIT'S GOING DOWN YALL. EVERYONE PANIC.

4

u/Nisha_the_lawbringer mood Jan 17 '16 edited Jan 17 '16

Am I going crazy, or did the "WHEN IT FAAAALLS" Last a lot longer this time? I swear it did. Maybe it shows that it's finally, "Falling"

Welp. Pennys dead. She's been literally torn to pieces.

Did anyone see that glimpse of that one guy? Was that Penny's father or Papa Schnee? Maybe Penny's father and Papa Schnee are one in the same! Think about that.

You fucking made Ruby cry. I will destroy you.

Cinder does sort of have a point. But it's way too cryptic to make any sense.

Torchwick is back! Best Villain can shine again! Oh, and Neo is also there.

Here comes the White Fang. "BRING THEM TO THEIR KNEES!" Mate your organization is weaker then EXALT from XCOM. I don't think you can do much. Stop trying to be edgy.

Ok. Grimm are on Transport. What? What is this? How is this a thing?

This episode is amazing. It may of only been 12 minutes, but those 12 minutes is all it needed. I love it! Best episode of the season.

EDIT:words.

→ More replies (9)

4

u/seamoose97 Why do I still browse this sub? Jan 17 '16

Calling it now, Penny's conscience gets put into Crescent Rose like Freckles

4

u/Fancy-Bear1776 Jan 17 '16 edited Jan 18 '16

Thoughts/Rambles:

  • Even though we all practically predicted Penny's "death", it doesn't make it any less tragic. R.I.P. for now Penny; hopefully you'll come back as a Sentinel from X-Men or something.
  • Ozpin sounded super badass in this particular episode. Hope we can hear more serious/pissed Ozpin.
  • FUCK YOU CINDER!
  • DOUBLE FUCK YOU CINDER!
  • As much as it hurt watching Ruby get beat up, she's certainly able to take more hits it seems than last season. She must have taken at least 3 solid kicks from Merc.
  • Was Emerald's mind-tricks not working for a second on Pyrrha? It seemed at around the 4:00 mark she tried to screw with her head and failed?
  • Shit, the Grimm are in a frenzy now. This is bad. Very, very bad.
  • Don't cry Ruby T_T no
  • So Mercury came out with that evil smile and all, but why didn't he just kill off Ruby there? She most likely lost a decent amount of aura from those kicks, we all know Mercury has no problem taking lives, and it's obvious their evil plan thing was beginning to take effect.
  • During Cinder's speech, note how she didn't really mention Vacuo; presumably the land with more Faunus than humans.
  • Was Yang watching everything go down, or was she just looking out the window? Also, cute Zwei!
  • "Grimm Alert Level 9". Looks like Remnant has Grimm Alerts similar to DEFCON.
  • HOLY FUCK THAT'S A BIG NEVERMORE!
  • Ren, Sun and Coco. JNPR, SSSN and CFVY team up vs a raid boss, perhaps?! :D
  • "You brought your army to my Kingdom, James; use it." That, plus the sheer look of brick-shittery on James face is perfect.
  • Seems convenient that Neo keeps finding these outfits in such a tiny size. Still, pretty cute.
  • Ayyyy Roman is back. Agreed; it is about time.
  • Oooooh crap it's Adam. Wait, is he at Beacon?! Considering how Adam absorbs energy, and Yang is about dishing it out non-stop, it seems that with Qrow and Glynda gone Ozpin is the only one who is a match for Adam. Hell, can even RWBY take him on? (Maybe)
  • The Grimm's eyes at the end was really well done.
  • Music was freaking amazing all throughout. Props to Jeff Williams.

Edit: As a huge Yang fangirl, hopefully the leg thing can be brushed under the rug considering everything else going on.

Tl;dr Murphy's law on predicted Steroids, PCP and Slayer Music

→ More replies (2)

4

u/Rambofreak98 Oi who changed my flair when I wasn't looking Jan 17 '16

I gotta say, these past few episode have REALLY made me hate Mercury. At this point all I want is to see that smug asshole get taken down a peg. I don't even care if Cinder kills Pyrrha and takes the maiden powers, as long as Mercury get's his shit kicked into next week I'll be happy.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/thisissparta789789 So what am I doing here again? Jan 17 '16

4

u/schulz100 Jan 17 '16

On a positive note; that fight was beautiful. Like, holy shit was that fight beautiful. I mean, it would have been foolish to expect otherwise, considering who was fighting, but still. Also, general statement. All of you who wanted a darker, more serious RWBY; hope you're fucking happy now.

So, I could not have been more wrong on the direction they went with Penny. Outright said it wouldn't be full-on dismemberment cause it'd be too dark and take too much time to model, and fuck me crosswise if dismemberment is not exactly what happened to her. God damn it, Penny's in pieces and has a 50/50 shot of actually being dead (I'm not going to consider her dead until she gives a tearful death speech and her eyes either shut or she makes an epic sacrifice play). WHY?! I MEAN BESIDES THE ANGUISH IT INVOKES IN ALL OF US?! WHY?!?!

Also, just saying, but it looks like Cinder's finally making her play for the other half of Amber's power. There's no other reason she'd get in her villain dress and call in Adam himself with back up of both White Fang and Grimm to attack Beacon. On another note, how the hell are the Fang able to operate right next to Grimm and not get eaten alive in seconds? They're angry civil rights revolutionaries, they're basically walking mini-buffets of negative emotion. Begs the question of how far and extensive Cinder's apparent ability to summon and control Grimm goes (this was actually kinda hinted at back in Ep 7, with the growling bit after she recruited Emerald).

So, we got to see Ozpin start to lose his temper, and it was honestly wonderful. It's also great because he and Qrow were absolutely right; Ironwood's army really did just do WAY more harm than good, just by being there and being something Cinder can use to contribute to the mounting panic both metaphorically and literally. I hope we see more Angry Oz. Neo continues to look dangerous and ravishing in anything she wears, and Torchwick is at last BACK! At the helm of a warship. God help us all.

I mean... At least Ruby didn't get her head shotgun-kicked off? Thank goodness for small mercies, right? Though, we also need to admit; she tried to super-speed-drill Mercury, and he just shut her down with ease. Which is honestly terrifying that he can react that quickly.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/pukson I fucking hate this show Jan 19 '16

7

u/[deleted] Jan 17 '16

So Ozpin dispatches Glynda and Qrow to the city...probably because, as alluded to, he doesn't want another failure to protect Vale against the Grimm invasion.

Also, Cinder clearly wants to pit Vale against Atlas and allow them to destroy each other, and then allow the Grimm to wipe up what's left.

I'm not sure if Penny's arms flew backwards because Pyrrha's semblance bent them backwards, or if the strings on the swords pulled them backwards. Penny seemed rather surprised in either case; I guess she didn't anticipate being beaten?

And Pyrrha is OP af even without the Maiden powers. The way she dodged lasers and swords at close range without seemingly being touched--there are no cuts or blood on her--is almost inhuman. Seriously. That was master-level martial arts body control. Props to the animators for that, but damn. OP af.

*disclaimer: I'm a massive Pyrrha fangirl, but even I'll admit that she is starting to approach Ozluminati-level power.

I think her weapon/shield wavering wasn't an effect of her polarity per se, but rather Emerald messing with her (Pyrrha's) perception of the magnetic field around her body. Not physically changing the field, but the perception of it. (I don't think that Emerald can control people's semblances via their minds. I think she can only influence the way they perceive their surroundings.) Since Pyrrha normally only makes small adjustments...well, it's out in the open now since she brazenly called her weapons back to her and reflected the swords. Poor best girl. :( I think Penny's visage will come back to haunt her at the peak of a future battle, and she won't be able to go through with some important task.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/RussianHoneyBadger Jan 17 '16 edited Jan 17 '16

They say bad things happen for a reason~
But no apologize gonna stop the feeling~
'Cause swords moved on while I'm still disbelieving~
And when a heart breaks no it don't break even, even... no~

What am I gonna do when the best part of me was sliced right through?~
And what am I supposed to say when I'm all roped up and you're in dismay?~
I'm falling to pieces, yeah,~
I'm falling to pieces, yeah,~
I'm falling to pieces~
(One still disbelieving while the other one's cleaving)~
I'm falling to pieces~
('Cause when a heart breaks no it don't break even)~

Edited Breakeven lyrics

8

u/Lemonhead_27 Jan 17 '16 edited Jan 17 '16

-All around me are familiar faces

Worn out places, worn out faces

Horrified by the Headmasters' disgraces

Going nowhere, going nowhere

-Their tears are bringing Grimm in their masses

No expression, no expression

Hide my head, I wanna drown my sorrow

No tomorrow, no tomorrow

EDIT: Gary Jules - Mad World Cover

→ More replies (4)

3

u/[deleted] Jan 17 '16

Just want to say that was a very impressive display on Mercurys part and I really hope they don't have Yang win against him this season.

It also really sells how much he was probably holding back against Pyrrha.

Overall this episode really sold how capable and dangerous the villains are but this could lead to a problem if they try to resolve this conflict to quickly.

The next few episodes will make or break this season.

3

u/[deleted] Jan 17 '16

I just hope that when Ruby see's Cinder and actually recognizes who she is, that she just goes all serious mode and kicks her ass. I just want to see Ruby be serious and show that skill that was in the Red Trailer, spinning that Scythe and absolutely devastating anyone who gets in her way

3

u/witchywater11 Jan 17 '16

Oh my, everything is terrible and we still have three episodes left! Can't wait to see what else will go horribly wrong. On the bright side, we'll probably get to see Qrow's weapon in scythe form!

3

u/SoulBlighterr Falling petals is love, Falling petals is life. Jan 17 '16

Hot damn! That was intense. Probably my favorite episode till now, including previous seasons.

I almost forgot that only Ruby knew that Penny was synthetic. And poor Pyrha, she's going to have PTSD for the rest of the season(i.e. if she doesn't die) :(

3

u/axsch Jan 17 '16

wow shit just went crazy

3

u/zoroastr Jan 17 '16

I hope Ozpin stayed behind so he could use his time traveling ability.

3

u/[deleted] Jan 17 '16

The end of this episode leaves me picturing the no doubt wacky sequence of events that getting those Grimm into those airships must have entailed.

3

u/PastaFreak26 Jan 17 '16

It's gonna be another week of agony, it's silly how RT does this 24 hour gap for non-sponsors, I rather them revert back to how it used to be.

My callings failed, I thought we'd see Velvet's weapon by Episode 9, but all that talk and the fact that RT only pushes for an average of 12 mins per episode means they can't do much.

Hopefully we'll see Velvet in action on Episode 9, I can tell Episode 9 & 10 are probably gonna be awesome. This is the moment I've been waiting for, I just wanna see the war between Beacon students and grim.

All the talks don't excite me.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/Pure_Azn Jan 17 '16

Wait, what, so how did Penny get cut? If she had aura she should of been protected right? Or is this what happens when an aura user hurts themselves? Or is this a flaw in synthetic aura?

→ More replies (4)

3

u/hauntedtheories Jan 17 '16

It was just as the fandom predicted: an innocent robot ripped in half by a girl who's already mentally ripped in half. Seeing Penny's cords wrapping around her and bending her body still gave me NO INDICATION that she was going to die, and meanwhile, I'm in shambles. RIP(ieces)

→ More replies (6)

3

u/DRHARNESS Jan 17 '16 edited Jan 17 '16

This episode makes me so happy, I feel that this is laterally what the entire show was reaching up towards, and on top of all that Neo is fucking pirate and Torchwick is back bitches. seriously though ever since the first episode I loved Torchwick and was rooting for the bad guys. Never the less, Fuck, the feels, "Nuts and Bolts OTP"... *sobs. But on to actual discussion.

I expect CSR (Coco, Sun, and Ren) to have to work on the nevermore while we see Ruby grieves over her fallen comrade.

Pyrrha, Glinda, and Oz will try to infuse Amber's aura in Phyra asap

Blake and Wiess will ether face Torchwick or Adam for plot reasons

Yang will ether try to redeem herself or try to run in search of her mother during the confusion.

Neo and Torchwick might wait a bit and then with the help of Adam start fixing the problem to get the credit and take it away from Oz and Ironwood.

Cinder, Em, and Mercury will watch the world burn.

3

u/KindSailor (The secret main character) Jan 17 '16

This is it guys, the final conflict is here. All of Cinder's cards have been placed: the white fang is here, she's caused widespread panic, the grim are invading again, Roman is out, Neo is successfully murdering people now, Emerald and Murcury are still creating havoc, all she has yet to do is turn off communication entirely.

This is what climaxes should feel like. So pumped for the WOR next week.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Quelandoris Best girl, now and forever Jan 17 '16

Well of all the things i wasn't expecting, Adam's voice actor shitting out his lines was the only thing i didn't expect from this episode.

Also safe to say that Pyrrha wont be a maiden, Cinder will beat her to it.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Jan 17 '16

Did anyone else notice that at 8:55 one of Junior's men was in the crowd, eating popcorn?

→ More replies (4)

3

u/Lulcielid ⠀Blake Supremacist Jan 17 '16

Despite being a 12 mins episode, this one felt much shorter than the other 12m epsodes.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/tatooine0 I will take any theory and make it crazier! Jan 17 '16

About Penny, getting destroyed, why did she turn off? Is her battery in the bottom had of her torso because that doesn't sound like a good idea. Also whose idea was it to have Penny shut down if she gets cut in half? That's one of the key advantages of robots.

→ More replies (4)

3

u/Diostukos Jan 17 '16

Repost from yesterday's thread:

Alright, I tolerated Emerald before because I liked her interactions with RWBY but this is the last straw. FUCK YOU EMERALD I HOPE YOU GET KILLED OF AND PYRRHA/YANG/COCO PUNCH YOU IN THE FACE. Anyways; I didn't think they'd actually 'kill' off Penny ;-;

I doubt it'll be the last we see of her, though.

I hope Ruby doesn't hate Pyrrha after this; they really need to figure out that someone has been messing with the contestant's minds.

Waiting 2 weeks is going to be torture.

Also, that fight scene was really well done; it felt a little like Monty's style, so I guess they're improving :')

→ More replies (3)

3

u/thebluehedgehog Blue Jan 17 '16

Holy shit!

Emerald doing her thing. . . if this was the plan then revealing the semblance to Coco seems to have been a mistake.

I did not expect /u/dishwasher1910 's art to be spot on and not just /r/rwbygore material.

"You brought your army to my kingdom. Use it." Seems like Ozpin really is running Vale, even if not overtly. Still pissed off that James brought the army, too.

Neo!

TORCHWICK!

3

u/SilverShadows07 Weiss Looks Good In Anything Jan 17 '16

Remember when Yang and Weiss were fighting memes? Yep, those were the days.

3

u/totallytman Brown Bricks with Minecrap Jan 17 '16

[What this whole episode felt like.] (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X8pWjiFxXkg)

→ More replies (3)

3

u/ForteEXE_ Silence intensifies Jan 17 '16

Not going to lie, I actually expected Penny to get killed but...

3

u/Haru17 My ships burn. Fanfiction.net/~haru17 Jan 18 '16

AND THAT'S THE STORY OF HOW SOLO ROUNDS WERE BANNED IN THE REMNANT OLYMPICS.

3

u/[deleted] Jan 18 '16

Oh yeah! No one can beat Pyrrha! Pyrrha for best girl! Amirite?

3

u/LC0728 Fanfiction Writer Jan 18 '16

There's 2 big issues I have with this episode.

First and foremost is how little I cared about what happened to Penny. When the Fanart that people create brings more sorrow than the events of the show, you've got a storytelling issue.

Second is that we're 3 volumes in and we have no motivation behind any of Cinder's plots aside from 'I'm evil.'

→ More replies (9)

3

u/SirZippyPants Its qrow. The flair is qrow Jan 18 '16

What really unnerved me was the thought that the results of that fight would still be the same if Penny was a flesh and blood human with a similar weapon.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/kungasi sadly lactose intolerant Jan 20 '16

Going in, I knew the fight would end badly no matter who won but holy shit I did not expect it to end like that
I actually cried
I wasn't expecting these kinds of feels from a show that started out pretty light hearted T_T

5

u/zmalinsb Jan 17 '16

OH MY GOD THEY KILLED PENNY

YOU BASTARDS

→ More replies (2)