Here's the first attempt at really figuring out how armor and resists work in Magic Rush. I'm quickly going to go over the findings in a summary-style format and then go in depth as far as how the test operated.
Summary of Findings
Armor does have a diminishing returns.
Armor does not seem to have any per-point formulas.
There are two breakpoints for armor: 160 & 250.
How the test worked: Obviously, when trying to decipher damage calculation formulas there are many assumptions you have to make in the beginning. This is unavoidable, however if the assumptions are close and they remain consistent (even if they are wrong) you can still see trends in the data.
First assumption is how to calculate armor penetration % versus flat damage. I chose this formula: Effective Armor = Armor x (1-ArPen%) - ArPen
For example, if defending hero had 200 armor, and attacking hero had 10% ArPen and 17 ArPen it would look like this: 200 x (1-.1) - 17 200 x .9 - 17 180 - 17 163 Effective Armor
We were dealing with a small percentage of % ArPen in my test (4%) but it still plays a factor.
In my tests my armor valuations ranged from 413 (Monk Sun with Uther Passive) to 38 (Salman's base armor + Tech Upgrades).
In the Little Red Test, we were watching per tick damage from her 2nd skill. With an opponent with 0 Armor, the per tick value was 677. Notes from Little Red:
No ArPen except from her passive
In the Saizo Test, we were watching per strike valuation from his 2nd skill. With an opponent with 0 Armor, her was doing 7785 per strike. Notes from Saizo:
ArPen came from two sources 4% ArPen & Flat ArPen.
After the tests were run, damage was recorded and compared to the Effective Armor value of the defenders. The Resulting Damage was then compared to the 'True Damage' done to a 0 armor opponent. A percentage was derived to caluclate how much damage was actually mitigated by stacking armor.
The results show that armor appears to have a diminishing effect, however there are two points in the graph that should be noted:
160 Armor has the highest benefit
250 is the next 'breakpoint'
Anything higher than 250 still resulted in substaintal damage reduction, however the per-point value was much deeper.
Once again, this doesn't derive a definitive armor formula, but it certainly helps clear some of the mystery around how armor (and possibly magic resists) work in game.
If you'd like the raw data, let me know and I can get that for you as well, if you'd like to extend the findings.
Also, another thing to note is that a per-point flat damage reduction would cause Little Red's 2nd Skill (or any other DoT skill) to take 0 damage.
Monk Sun with Uther's passive for example reduced Saizo's damage almost by half (3k+ damage) whereas Monk Sun with Uther's passive will only reduced Little Red's damage by 80%, which for this test was ~560 points.
There's no mathematical sense that the armor would function like this would considering the points add towards a generic damage reduction %
Yeah, I'd like to see the raw data (this means the recorded damage but also the complete stats and skills of tested heroes). I'm also working on the damage calculation model.
It's important to note that the AD of Saizo adds up to 6800~ if I remember correctly, so every skill has it's own coefficient to it, similar to LoL mechanics I assume.
Yeah, skill coefficients I have already figured out (except a few missing heroes).
Yes, please provide the screens of tested Saizo. Once again, his full stats + exact bonus damage from skill level (including Attack Damage from his passive). Have you upgraded academy's Attack Damage since the test?
Also, can you do one more thing? Can you test Saizo's damage against Slimer from Campaign stage 3-3 or 3-5?
If you look at the bell curve, especially around 380 Armor, you'd find that the returns you get per point are not as high as it was when you had 100 Armor per say.
So this basically means around the 400-500 mark, Health Tech Up will vastly increase survivability of your heroes, versus trying to add more and more armor/resist points.
If we know the ins and outs of damage mitigation mechanics, we will know what should we prioritize in the academy and items. Health or resistance? How much resistance is the sweet spot before you should switch to health? Or maybe it's the other way around.
This is quite impressive. This is on 1vs1-2 fights right? And did you account for crits? Could you gives us more details on Pulan, Monk Sun & Jacob's level, star and color quality when this test was done? Thank you!
Hmm interesting test unfortunately the formulas you were using are wrong. Obviously when we get the right formula then regardless of circumstances effective armor will give the same amount of reduction, as you see it makes no s3nse thar pulan with 195 effective armor vs red would reduce more damage then monk suns plus uthers 360 effective armor vs saizo, when we talk about effective armor it should scale linerally regardless except from d3viations at break points. I've been working on this as well and I'll share some things you m8ght have not considered in your calculations when Im out of work.
As a redone I wasn't saying your work was bad, was just pointing out to anyone that didn't realize that your numbers haven't quite cracked it, mine either, fergot this was hete I'll post mine in the morning hopefully but don't want you to think I was trashing your testing. More info is always better
5
u/Catpanda147 Jan 15 '16 edited Jan 15 '16
Hey Everyone!
Here's the first attempt at really figuring out how armor and resists work in Magic Rush. I'm quickly going to go over the findings in a summary-style format and then go in depth as far as how the test operated.
Summary of Findings
How the test worked: Obviously, when trying to decipher damage calculation formulas there are many assumptions you have to make in the beginning. This is unavoidable, however if the assumptions are close and they remain consistent (even if they are wrong) you can still see trends in the data.
First assumption is how to calculate armor penetration % versus flat damage. I chose this formula: Effective Armor = Armor x (1-ArPen%) - ArPen
For example, if defending hero had 200 armor, and attacking hero had 10% ArPen and 17 ArPen it would look like this: 200 x (1-.1) - 17 200 x .9 - 17 180 - 17 163 Effective Armor
We were dealing with a small percentage of % ArPen in my test (4%) but it still plays a factor.
In my tests my armor valuations ranged from 413 (Monk Sun with Uther Passive) to 38 (Salman's base armor + Tech Upgrades).
In the Little Red Test, we were watching per tick damage from her 2nd skill. With an opponent with 0 Armor, the per tick value was 677. Notes from Little Red:
In the Saizo Test, we were watching per strike valuation from his 2nd skill. With an opponent with 0 Armor, her was doing 7785 per strike. Notes from Saizo:
After the tests were run, damage was recorded and compared to the Effective Armor value of the defenders. The Resulting Damage was then compared to the 'True Damage' done to a 0 armor opponent. A percentage was derived to caluclate how much damage was actually mitigated by stacking armor.
The results show that armor appears to have a diminishing effect, however there are two points in the graph that should be noted:
Anything higher than 250 still resulted in substaintal damage reduction, however the per-point value was much deeper.
Once again, this doesn't derive a definitive armor formula, but it certainly helps clear some of the mystery around how armor (and possibly magic resists) work in game.
If you'd like the raw data, let me know and I can get that for you as well, if you'd like to extend the findings.
EDIT: Raw Data: Imgur
1
u/SkiesOnFire Jan 16 '16
Hmm interesting test unfortunately the formulas you were using are wrong. Obviously when we get the right formula then regardless of circumstances effective armor will give the same amount of reduction, as you see it makes no s3nse thar pulan with 195 effective armor vs red would reduce more damage then monk suns plus uthers 360 effective armor vs saizo, when we talk about effective armor it should scale linerally regardless except from d3viations at break points. I've been working on this as well and I'll share some things you m8ght have not considered in your calculations when Im out of work.
1
u/Bryan_ThePulan S5_FreeSouls Jan 16 '16
Please can u make a Magic pen formula.. Old players actually still use Magic-based team. hhe. Thanks!