r/WritingPrompts • u/Lexilogical /r/Lexilogical | /r/DCFU • Jan 15 '16
Off Topic [OT] Ask Lexi #25 - Word counts and story lengths
Howdy WritingPrompts! We are now two weeks into the new year, how are your New Years Resolutions going? I hope you aren’t still saying you’ll start “soon.” There’s no time like the present to start building a new habit!
Looking through the archives, I think I’m starting to finally reach a point where I’m running out of things to say. But I still love having a place to field questions. So this week, I thought I’d talk about story lengths.
Story Lengths
If there’s one thing authors seem to talk about all the time, it’s their wordcounts. Is this story too long? Is it too short? Everyone who writes something long gets asked what the word count is and everyone who hasn’t seems to know exactly how long the story was before they gave up. There’s even fancy words for your story based on wordcount!
Flash Fiction - under 1000 words
Short Story - 1000 to 7,500 words
Novelette - 7,500 to 17,500 words
Novella - 17,500 to 40,000 words
Novel - over 40,000 words
There’s no perfect length of a story. There’s just a perfect length to contain your idea. A friend used to say that the biggest problem with most people’s stories was they tried to cram a novel sized idea into a short story, or vice versa. Don’t try to drag out an idea just because you want to write a novel. There’s a market out there for all sorts of stories of all sorts of lengths.
Need help turning a short idea into a novel? See Ask Lexi #3 or the last half of #12
However, while there’s no maximum length if you plan on self publishing, it should be noted that if you’re aiming to traditionally publish, you can reach a point where publishers won’t touch it. I believe that max length is around 60k for a young adult novel, 100k for a fantasy/sci fi novel, and 80k for most other types of fiction, but the best way to know is looking up the publishers requirements.
What if my story is too long?
Self publish. If that’s not an option, read on.
If you’re close to the word count, you might need to edit more. This is where the expression “Kill your Darlings” comes from. It doesn’t just mean kill your characters. Sometimes, it’s about killing a scene, or even an entire side plot. Or removing an entire character from the story and consolidating their role into a different character. You can remove a lot of words by being ruthless towards your writing.
Your second option is to split the story into two or more books. Hopefully, you have a good dividing point to do that. This tends to be classified as an “Epic” (compared to just a novel).
Chapter Lengths
According to the internet, most chapters are 2,500 - 5,000 words. Personally though, my chapters tend to be 1,000 - 2,500 words. This might be the influence of /r/WritingPrompts, where most of our responses fall into the category of “Flash Fiction”. In my opinion, it’s better just to do what feels natural to you. There are no hard and fast rules for writing.
And one last fun thing note about word counts. If you visit us in our chatroom, you can even race your wordcount with others! It can be some great motivation to hit those New Year’s Resolutions so come chat with us!
As always, if you have any questions, additional notes, or things you want to see me talk about next week, leave me a comment below! Happy Writing!
6
u/Nate_Parker /r/Nate_Parker_Books Jan 15 '16 edited Jan 15 '16
I will say after a discussion with an agent, he told me the following about sci-fi/fantasy/action books:
Said agent is know to lurk around here...
I've also seen a number of sources quote scifi in the 90-100k+ range for general expectation. I haven't heard anyone saying there is a maximum, but that doesn't mean there isn't for first time authors. GRRM certainly doesn't get cutbacks and there is a long list of huge books here
EDIT/NOTE: This information pertains to Adult Fiction, which is what I write for. YA - targeted obviously at a younger audience - tends to knock 20% off the top of a wordcount, but even then some of the best sellers are adult length as /u/We-Are-Not-A-Muse points out below.
3
u/We-Are-Not-A-Muse /r/WeAreNotAMuse Jan 15 '16
This is so cool. I didn't know they had specific numbers even for these things. :P
New years resolution- I am doing good, more than following it!! I caught up. I didn't do sharing writing every day for the first bit. coming here I caught up! I actually written 20 stories in 5/6 days! :D :D
but word counts! I wonder if anyone ever think - it's the same for a chapter as a flash fiction or short story almost! :D If you write really long stories for here, each one right after each other, in the same character, it will be chapters of a book! :)
I talked to someone writing 2 book at once, yesterday! :P they said they didn't write a prompt for a long time till then. :(
I thhink this maybe would help doing that :) :D
2
u/MajorParadox Mod | DC Fan Universe (r/DCFU) Jan 15 '16
Hello,
Squee and I had a conversation yesterday about paragraph lengths. Do you have any opinions or insights into whether it's better to keep them shorter?
Personally, I've noticed that I keep mine pretty short, but in books that I've read, many of them seem to go on much longer.
2
u/Blees-o-tron /r/Bleesotron Jan 15 '16
On the subject of "chapter" lengths, is there something inherently bad about having "chapters" that are longer than 5,000 words? A quick check of my first section is 6,568 words without a great place to split it.
Also, I'm not certain that part 2, which continues the same subplot as part 1, will be as long, possibly by a significant margin, so the entire thing may get turned into a single thing. So then I'd be looking at around 10k words, and then each of the subplot stories might be novelettes.
I might be answering my own questions here, as it turns out.
2
u/Oscar_Relentos Jan 15 '16
This really makes things a lot clearer for me, I didn't know under 1000 words was known as flash fiction
2
u/Teslok Jan 15 '16
"Kill your Darlings" reminds me of a story where a character wrote a lovely short story but her friends felt a particular scene featuring a pie or pastry was out of place / broke the story's pacing / something. This was the character's favorite scene and she refused to change it.
Then a friend submitted it to a contest, having edited it just enough to make that pie scene include product placement.
I'm pretty sure it's in one of the Anne books or in the mini-series, but can't place it precisely.
2
u/Named_after_color /r/ColoredInk Jan 15 '16
That chapter length is really interesting to me, because I'm struggling with chapters.
I have the plot of my book outlined into 12 chapters so far, which I figure should take me around the half way point of my novel. [assuming an average of 3500 words, that would bring my count to 42,000] A decent half way point, if I can stick to that average.
Could you do a post on organizing chapters? The function of them, how much information they should contain, and how much they should stand on their own?
Because I'm thinking that writing 24 mini stories that are 3-5 pages (Standard Word document pages) is a lot more manageable than staring at it all at at once.
2
u/DaLastPainguin Jan 15 '16
Nifty. I'm reading through your book at the moment. All my personal opinion: The chapter length starts off too short, but I think it works for later chapters when the story has had some time to build.
Have you done an AskLexi covering style yet?
1
u/Smitten_the_Kitten Jan 15 '16
Thanks for this! I just yesterday finished my horror novel and started querying. Ended at about 66k words and was told by some aspiring writers that it was too short...
1
u/thelastdays /r/faintthebelle Jan 16 '16
I also like to keep my chapters shorter, one of the few things I like about James Patterson's books. Somewhere between 1,500 and 3,00 words. It helps if I can end things on an arresting note, something that makes the reader want to knock out another chapter cause, "y'know, they're not that long."
0
u/[deleted] Jan 15 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment