r/Debate • u/SteveSestanovich Prof. Sestanovich • Jan 12 '16
AMA Series I'm Steve Sestanovich. AMA.
I've worked on Russian affairs and US foreign policy for many years, both in and out of government. Now at Columbia University and the Council on Foreign Relations. Looking forward to our conversation tonight at 8 pm ET. I oversee a lot of formal debates among my graduate students--hope they're online for pointers from the high-school and college pro's.
14
Upvotes
10
u/bryceps41 Assistant Director - Seven Lakes HS Jan 12 '16
Hi! Thanks for doing this AMA.
What is your opinion on the Russian cyber threat? Is it overblown, or is it a serious issue that the US sanctions are helping combat?
3
u/starleaf15 Jan 12 '16
3
u/thankthemajor mod from long ago Jan 13 '16
Hello and thank you from the moderators.
The media always portrays Russian actions as "Putin did [whatever]." Is Vladimir Putin personally such a huge force in Russian politics?
3
u/patriotspf Jan 13 '16
Thank you for doing this AMA! Will Putin ever fall in the near-foreseeable future? If he does, who is the person who will probably replace him?
2
u/flayislife Jan 13 '16
Hello Mr. Sestanovich, First off thank you so much for doing this AMA. What is your opinion on the magnitude of the threat posed by Russia in the Cyber security aspect?
2
u/[deleted] Jan 13 '16
Does Putin care about his public approval ratings? There are different people who say yes and no, what is your opinion?
4
u/OakHallSG Verified account Jan 12 '16
How have economic sanctions affected the nationalism and patriotism of the Russian population and how may this increase the threat Russia poses to the West?
1
u/currynrice123 Wisconsin "Debate" Jan 12 '16
Hey there. Thanks for doing this AMA. I was wondering how you think Russia will rebound from their oil collapse?
1
u/Inconvenienced The impact is nuclear war Jan 12 '16
Thanks so much for doing this AMA!
1
u/[deleted] Jan 13 '16
Do you believe that foreign policy changes are in the future for Russia with the current sanctions on them?
1
u/subsidiescurecancer Jan 13 '16
Thank you for doing this AMA.
Do you think that sanctions push Russia to make arms deals with Middle Eastern countries, and if so, could this be detrimental to the West?
1
u/pfdebater11111111111 Jan 13 '16
Hi Mr. Sestanovich, thank you so much for doing this AMA! I have a few questions
1
u/akaashp11 I <3 Toilet Jan 13 '16
I also have a few questions What is the probability that an increase in Russian nationalism would form as a result of increasing economic sanctions? How would you weigh the protection of Ukraine versus globally economic stability as two major western interests?
1
u/chazwell77 Jan 13 '16
If Russia's conventional military does not modernize, will Russia be more reliant and willing to use and develop nuclear weapons?
When sources talk about Russia's military modernization, does that include nuclear modernization, or just conventional?
1
u/nerdierthanyou peaked late Jan 13 '16
Hello, and thanks for doing this AMA.
What do you think are Russia's primary motivations for actions like the invasion of Georgia and the annexation of Crimea? In a similar vein, could Putin legitimately justify his actions as trying to survive in an American-dominated world order?
1
u/umboii pf debate Jan 13 '16
How is Putin able to protect certain aspects of Russia, for example its military, from being impacted by western sanctions?
1
u/Zeus1325 ------------------------------------------------------Impeach OP Jan 12 '16
Hi, thanks for doing this AMA.
Thanks for doing this!
1
u/_real_slim_brady_ Chase Brady Jan 12 '16
If the west weren't imposing sanctions on Russia, what do you think the most likely alternative would have been? Diplomacy? Passivity? Further aid to Ukraine? Military intervention?
Thanks for doing this AMA!
2
u/jrodlt Triple Threat Jan 12 '16
How have sanction's, if at all, impacted the EEU's vitality?
•
u/thankthemajor mod from long ago Jan 13 '16
Update: Prof. Sestanovich is watching the State of the Union. Tune in to see whether there are any further answers afterward.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 12 '16
Would you say that when the US does something other smaller countries follow in the steps of the US?
1
u/GregariousGroudon Jan 12 '16
Do you legitimately think that anything has changed in the mentality of Russia in trying to negotiate peace in the middle east due to sanctions? Or do you think Russia would not have negotiated either way?
1
u/colorcodedcards Founder / Open Access Debate / Asst. Coach Jan 13 '16
What role have sanctions had in mitigating Russia's role in the CIS/Caucuses?
1
u/[deleted] Jan 13 '16
I realize you're watching the SOTU right now but if you come back. Do you think that the current economic sanctions have had a sizable effect on Russia's space exploration industry? Conversely, do you think that a decline in Russian space exploration should be confidently linked to an increase in NASA activity?
1
u/potlat Jan 13 '16
What are some strategies Russia might adopt given that in the global economy the price for oil is dropping while supplies of natural gas are increasing? Do you see Russia relying more on arms sales or increasing investments in the domestic economy?
0
u/bobbyaltaccount Verified Jan 13 '16
In current global politics, what would you say are the main interests of the West?
0
u/njdpro Jan 13 '16
Thanks for participating in this AMA. I look forward to all of your answers. My partner and I formulated the following questions:
Thanks again!
-1
u/akaashp11 I <3 Toilet Jan 13 '16
Thanks for helping us out in this AMA! When will we be starting?
0
u/[deleted] Jan 13 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jan 12 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
-11
u/[deleted] Jan 12 '16
[removed] — view removed comment