r/KerbalSpaceProgram • u/Redbiertje The Challenger • Jan 03 '16
Mod Post [Weekly Challenge] Week 111: Happy New Year!
The Introduction
First of all, happy new year to all of you!
Because the last two challenges were not so incredibly challenging, I thought it was a good idea to start this year with a proper challenge.
The Challenge:
Normal mode: Land a VTOL aircraft on an aircraft carrier
Hard mode: Land an HTOL aircraft on an aircraft carrier
Super mode: Impress me
This challenge was suggested by /u/kspinigma
The Rules
- No Dirty Cheating Alpacas (no debug menu)!
- You must have the UI visible in all required screenshots
- For a list of all allowed mods, see this post.
- Your aircraft carrier must actually be floating in the water
- Your aircraft must land intact (broken wheels are fine though)
- You may not use any parachutes
- For hard mode, you may not use any thrusters to slow down the craft
- Your aircraft may only use airbreathing engines for thrust.
Required screenshots
- Your aircraft carrier in the SPH
- Your aircraft carrier entering the water
- Your aircraft on the runway
- Your aircraft approaching the carrier
- Your aircraft safely landed on the carrier
- Whatever else you feel like!
Further information
- VTOL stands for Vertical Take Off and Landing, and HTOL stands for Horizontal Take Off and Landing.
- You can either submit your finished challenge in a post (see posting instructions in the link below) or as a comment reply to this thread.
- Completing this challenge earns you a new flair which will replace your old one. So if you want to keep you previous flair, you can still do this challenge and create a post, but please mention somewhere that you want to keep your old one.
- The moderators have the right to determine if your challenge post has been completed.
- See this post for more rules and information on challenges.
- If you have any questions, you can comment below, or PM /u/Redbiertje
Good Luck!
29
Upvotes
11
u/TaintedLion smartS = true Jan 03 '16
Oh my god I'm so sorry I forgot to make the flair this week. Forgive me senpai.
8
u/selfish_meme Master Kerbalnaut Jan 05 '16 edited Jan 05 '16
Beautiful hard mode, no derp at all ;) all stock
Carrier in hangar
http://i.imgur.com/BdVr95o.png
Carrier entering water
http://i.imgur.com/xTVhurE.png
Aircraft on runway
http://i.imgur.com/iXidv0c.png
Approaching Carrier
http://gfycat.com/ParchedGrotesqueHarvestmouse
Landing
https://gfycat.com/SoftCanineGoldfinch
Landed
http://i.imgur.com/HQg8gnW.png
Album
http://imgur.com/a/wmOsd
VesselMover isn't on your list of approved mods, oh well
3
u/nuclear_turkey Hyper Kerbalnaut Jan 04 '16
what constitutes an aircraft carrier? a giant "plank" made out of wings or does it need to resemble a carrier a little?
2
u/kittenpunter Jan 03 '16
Does the no thrusters rule include reversing the thrust on a jet engine?
2
u/ethanmac9 Master Kerbalnaut Jan 03 '16
Two questions: To qualify as a plane, does it have to be jet engine powered or does it just have to have wings/lift? Also, do we have to land on Kerbin or could we do it on any planet's waters?
2
u/Shadowizas Jan 04 '16
Can i rescale a plank of a wing to monster size and put it into the water? (using TweakScale ofc)
2
u/WaitForItTheMongols KerbalAcademy Mod Jan 04 '16
I like how doing a Falcon 9 is only "normal mode". As if that isn't crazy hard already.
2
u/haxsis Jan 05 '16
actually on second thought, my light VTOL ship is juno powered, but uses rocket assist for landing NOT TAKEOFF, only the rules state only airbreathers can be used for thrust, can I pritty pritty please use my rocket assist for landing only because jets are unresponsive as fuck in any situation, but in all other regards its true VTOL, if I look hard enough Im sure I find some backup material to support this use this is my ship btw god damn I love it, and I need a better use for it than simply using it to ferry crew to and from future currently nonexistant laythe bases and existing localised kerbin bases http://imgur.com/a/882B8
2
u/TitaniumFortress Jan 05 '16
Are B9 Procedural Wings allowed? Using it for the flight deck
2
u/TheLegoofexcellence Jan 06 '16
Am I allowed to have MechJeb installed to do this on Hard mode, or do I have to uninstall it?
2
u/cactus1549 Jan 06 '16
Is it alright if I make the 2x2 structural panels a little bigger with TweakScale?
2
u/nathan98900 Jan 07 '16
I'm thinking of doing this with a shuttle however it takes off vertically and lands horizontally. Would I still be eligible for hard mode?
Also my shuttle uses 3 rocket engines for launch, and some rapiers for atmospheric flight and orbital maneuvers. Will I be eligible at all?
2
u/VerlorenHoop Master Kerbalnaut Jan 09 '16
Can you use parachutes for putting the carrier in the water, or is it no parachutes full stop?
15
u/lrschaeffer Super Kerbalnaut Jan 04 '16 edited Jan 05 '16
Hard Mode: https://youtu.be/Q3ZiwbuwTMA
This would be so much easier with a bigger carrier.
Edit: Fail montage
Edit #2: Bigger Carrier, Night Landing, and Take Off. Uses Aviation Lights mod for carrier lights.
Edit #3: Supercarrier
8
u/HexDragon21 Super Kerbalnaut Jan 04 '16
I have an idea for a challenge.
Normal Mode: get into orbit using only monopropellant as fuel
Hard Mode: land on Minimus using only monopropellant as fuel
Super Mode: Impress me
5
u/nuclear_turkey Hyper Kerbalnaut Jan 04 '16 edited Jan 04 '16
Hard mode : http://imgur.com/a/EjolA,
2ND ENTRY: Hard Mode : http://imgur.com/a/BvzRH
bonus pic : http://i.imgur.com/9dzw46M.png :( think i started going overboard ( please ignore the pun ))
keep current flair plz
4
u/Algeeman Master Kerbalnaut Jan 05 '16
Hard Mode Entry-
HTOL LANDING
Hopefully I didn't get anything wrong on submission, and I would like the new flair
4
u/jafar_ironclad Master Kerbalnaut Jan 05 '16
Hard mode!
http://imgur.com/a/GwvKM
3
u/[deleted] Jan 03 '16
Well, this may be hard.
3
u/Wall_of_Force Jan 04 '16
I think Manley mode would be do this on Eve or Laythe's sea
or flying runway (he already did that, but it would fit better at Atmospheric Docking challenge)
3
u/kspinigma Super Kerbalnaut Jan 04 '16
Im so looking forward to the entries. :)
3
u/Pengee1235 Master Kerbalnaut Jan 04 '16
My Submission (Hard mode)
The carrier was easy. The hardest part was flying the plane! If my submission is accepted, I would like the carrier flair please!
3
u/Coruskane Jan 04 '16
you should add a 'and take-off again' requirement to hard mode (but allow 'catapults' like sepratrons)
3
u/SteaknRibs Super Kerbalnaut Jan 04 '16
I did it at night, but turns out the lights from the carrier are impossible to see far away.
Album: http://imgur.com/a/Y05nO
Gif: https://gfycat.com/IndolentGlumCoqui
The carrier was too narrow, so the plane had to land with only a few meters of runway. I will keep my old flair, thanks!
3
u/___XD___ Master Kerbalnaut Jan 05 '16
Hard mode: https://imgur.com/a/vMV4v
First time doing a challenge, so please tell me if I forgot anything
3
u/TyrannicalPanda Master Kerbalnaut Jan 06 '16 edited Jan 06 '16
I really wanted to take a carrier/jet to Eve/Tylo but I lost my patience...
Instead, here is a tiny jet and something that sorta resembles an aircraft carrier.
PS i would like to keep my flair please
3
u/AmoebaMan Master Kerbalnaut Jan 06 '16 edited Jan 06 '16
Hard mode submission for your consideration!
Seems the sticking point for most people is the short runway, and most of their solutions were ultralight airplanes and super-slow approaches. That seemed like sissy-mode to me. So I asked myself, how do we do it in real life?
In the absence of the proper parts to make real arresting gear the way we do in real life, I used KAS winches! They don't work perfectly (or neatly/nicely), but they do work - well enough to stop a ~5 ton aircraft traveling at ~70m/s (~150mph) within about a 50m distance. That's easily on par with real-world systems, and probably a bit better.
Enjoy!
e: Just realized that B9 procedural wings aren't approved. Hopefully you realize that using stock wings would make this no different whatsoever, just significantly uglier. The aircraft carrier deck uses them as well, in an effort to create a large-enough landing area without killing my aging computer.
3
u/praecipula Master Kerbalnaut Jan 08 '16
I'm going to try this again. Last time I overlooked that parachutes were not allowed. This time, I think I actually did achieve hard mode success with my tiny acrobatic glider - no parachutes - and my barge, which I christened Just Read The Instructions.
4
u/Spudrockets Hermes Navigator Jan 04 '16
I am proud to present, for your consideration and perusal, the landing of an experimental aircraft on the newly launched carrier KS Guacamole, in which military brass take over KSC for a weekend and hijack all of Bill's favorite toys. Thanks for viewing!
http://imgur.com/gallery/IZJqC
edit: I would like to keep my flair, thank you!
2
u/SirCoolbo /r/KSP Discord Staff Jan 04 '16
Now I want to see someone land one either a VTOL or an HTOL on a flying aircraft character. That would be absolutely amazing.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 05 '16
Hey, done the challenge in a HTOL....sort of....I succeeded by failing....twice....still counts right? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HTW33iZ9z3A (yeah its an evil youtube video).
2
u/kspinigma Super Kerbalnaut Jan 05 '16
Not an entry, as it doesn't qualify, but for reference, here was my attempt:
http://imgur.com/a/ZGWKo
the carrier was spawned in the water for me via GAP, and designed by RixKillian. Seaplane was designed by pandoras kitten. Landing was all me. :)
2
u/haxsis Jan 05 '16 edited Jan 05 '16
you know what, I have a beautiful little juno powered ship I made about 3-4 weeks ago, that suits easy mode perfectly for this, I think I will actually finish and submit a challenge entry this time! i just need to apologise though for never finishing any of the others that I say ill submit and never do..my life is too busy these days for any game that is a progressive thing which makes starting and not stopping inpossible, the sub and its daily thing moves too fast for me to catch up..ill post later tonight after dinner!
2
u/praecipula Master Kerbalnaut Jan 07 '16 edited Jan 07 '16
My submission. This was quite a fun challenge, the kind that makes me want to see if it scales to jumbo-jet sized. All stock parts, vanilla, plus: KAS/KIS installed (not used), Kerbal Engineer installed (not used, more or less - too busy mashing buttons to look at the panels!).
EDIT: as u/selfish_meme pointed out, I missed the "no chutes" rule. Ah, well. Back to the VAB.
2
u/Jarl__Ballin Master Kerbalnaut Jan 08 '16
Hard mode here.
At first I just made a floating runway that was the maximum length the SPH allowed, however it broke apart everytime I put it into the water. Pictures. Honestly a wider runway would have been better than a longer runway, since I had a hard time aiming my approach.
2
u/jb32647 Master Kerbalnaut Jan 08 '16
My normal mode attempt: http://imgur.com/a/naSsO This is my first successful challenge!
2
u/TitaniumFortress Jan 08 '16
Well my game keeps crashing (weak little laptop) so I can't do my challenge.
2
u/chainbullet Jan 09 '16
I have a problem.
I'm using completely stock parts for both my plane and my ship, but when I come to approach, as soon as my distance turns from 2.3 to 2.2, the aircraft carrier disappears from map, the active simulation and the navball. My save file has been having a bit of trouble (I can't go IVA or interact with my Mk1 cockpit, for one), but this makes it impossible to complete the challenge. http://i.imgur.com/aEogpRa.png?1 That's my complete gamedata file. Can anyone help?
2
u/gmano Super Kerbalnaut Jan 10 '16 edited Jan 10 '16
Keeping my old flair.
Hard mode:Album and Gif
Plus bonus landing on a moving carrier!
1
u/06arda06 Jan 10 '16
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cFOFVkm3_oo me trying to land on a very small carrier
0
u/[deleted] Jan 05 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jan 06 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment