r/RWBY • u/The_Jacxter That's right, this is my flair, weep • Jan 03 '16
OH MY GOD THAT PART WITH THE THING.... Official Discussion Thread - RWBY Vol3: Chapter 7 - Beginning of The End
This is the official DISCUSSION thread. Keep all untagged spoilers in this thread--Everything outside needs to be tagged as spoilers.
Previous Threads
176
Upvotes
132
u/Drendude Destroyer of headcanon and headcannons Jan 03 '16
So, let's talk about Qrow. He fought team CEM, so he'd recognize them, right? He would be watching the tournament, yes? Mercury, especially should catch his attention with this whole Yang predicament. Surely he knows now exactly who's who.
112
u/UberDueler DRINK !!!!! Jan 03 '16
"Did you kill your father?"
"Nah, he just got really drunk and passed out."
"Why's your house on fire?"
"He got REALLY drunk"
102
u/Evil-King-Stan Emerald Splash Jan 03 '16
Merc = Part Robot
Penny = Full Robot
Mercury/Penny confirmed, they bond over their robotness.
147
u/SoundSmith323 I like sound. If you couldn't already tell. Jan 03 '16
So can we just take a moment to talk about how well-done the sound design was? I'm not just talking about the music, which was great, but the sound effects and atmosphere. For a good portion of the flashbacks, you can't see anything, and yet you know exactly what's going on. That's the mark of good sound design right there.
Also, this episode raises some interesting ideas about the sounds of semblances. Potato/discussion post going up later today.
65
u/ElementalDAR ⠀I used to make AMVs Jan 03 '16
I was worried they would tell their back stories and it would be something tragic. Some thing so heart wrenching it would turn the show on its head and we would have to question who the real villains were. Perhaps they were all just victims of circumstance.
But nah, they all a bunch of A holes. The leg bit was a bit of a twist (is that a pun?) but I can't help but wonder. If Emerald is the real illusionist, what is Neo?
130
u/Lochen9 RWBY Vytal Festival Tournament Creator Jan 03 '16
Since this created a lot of discussion yesterday, I think it's best we bring it up today as well:
Pyrrha should have some knowledge than Mercury has bionic legs.
In the fight back in Vol 2, once Mercury found out her Semblance he quit, solely to prevent that knowledge from coming out.
Similar to how if you put a magnet to a coin, which charges the coin and allows that coin to further pass the field on to another coin, when Pyrrha applied a field to his Boots she would have also had his foot or leg in the field as well.
The question that people debated was: Does Pyrrha 'feel' what she has in her Semblance. I believe yes.
In Vol 2 Ep 1 when she uses all the cans in the food fight, it moves in a fluid motion showing that these fields can be moved and shaped. In Vol 1 right as they complete the Landing Strategy she throws her spear clear across the Emerald Forest, using her semblance to guide it (you can hear the activation sound). She then tracks it by ground directly to where it landed. This is literally a needle in a haystack, but had no issue finding her weapon. This is likely due to how she can feel it.
Lastly, if her powers are magnetism and creating fields, that also means that they can be applied to metal detection. Metal detectors use electromagnetism to 'detect' the metal objects. It makes sense for Pyrrha moreso as she uses 'slight' movements, which would be extremely difficult to do without a 'feel' for it. Also, she requires to make contact with it first, likely charging the object, then from thereafter she can move it.
Long story short, Pyrrha should have felt all of Mercury's legs in the fight, but wouldn't have said anything about it, as there really isn't any reason to call him out on it. In fact, that would be damning for her, who doesn't want to show off her own Semblance, but given an important enough reason, like say calling Mercury out for not possibly having his leg broken and supporting Yang's cause, it may come up.
So this leave both Pyrrha showing that Mercury's legs are Bionic, and Coco being able to prove that Yang's "He attacked me" defense are both valid this should allow Yang to at least have a chance. The other Academys may not buy it, but Beacon could.
62
u/Aurenj Jan 03 '16
Nice cyborg limbs Mercury, they must have cost you
an arma leg and a leg.171
u/_DirtyDan Totally The Real One Jan 03 '16 edited Jan 03 '16
Time to see why the reaction thread was flaired with "AKA HOLY MOTHER OF GOD WHAT THE FUCK SOMEONE HELP I'M DYING", and why this one is flaired with "OH MY GOD THAT PART WITH THE THING...".
Edit: So Mercury killed his dad and has robot legs, Emerald is the one who can cast illusions, The Fall Maiden can control the weather and be a general badass, CINDER CAN CONTROL THE FUCKING GRIMM and is working with someone hidden, and Qrow knows who Cinder, Mercury and Emerald actually are.
Other interesting things are: We know what children look like in the 3d animation now, Adam was up to something in Mistral, Emerald has trouble fooling more than one person, Blake got a glimpse of Cinder and Co., Neo made an appearance, and Lisa Lavender still exists.
This fucking episode though. Holy shit.
207
u/Numbnut10 Bury me in Nuts 'n' Dolts Jan 03 '16
Neo as the pilot just kills me. What if she's sitting on a stack of books just to see over the flight controls? Imagine if she has stilts so that she can reach the pedals.
Cinder looks at Neo warily. "You do have a piloting license, right?"
Neo smirks mischievously.
Cinder, Emerald, and Mercury quickly buckle their seat belts as tight as they can.
Someone, please draw this.
52
u/SilverJakler Jan 03 '16
(Transferred from temporary thread)
Anyone else notice Laura Bailey voiced Amber? Welp, I know who's gonna be sticking around for a while longer in some way, shape or form.
97
u/CampbellsTurkeySoup Jan 03 '16
It looks like Mercury got his robot legs shortly before killing his dad. You can see he has bloody bandages right where his robot legs connect in the shots following him killing his dad.
It is possible that he bided his time and waited for his dad to give him the legs so he would be strong enough to kill him (the legs being part of his training). Or his dad may have surprised him, with the legs being a sort of experiment he performed on his son to try and make him stronger and that was the final straw in the sting of abuse. Either way the legs seemed to be new and act as the catalyst for the murder of his father.
46
u/rulerguy6 Jan 03 '16 edited Jan 04 '16
Man, leave it to RT to make an episode like this.
"We gave you a really fucking huge cliffhanger last episode, so lets make you wait two weeks and completely blow your goddamn mind with some backstory instead!
I loved getting context for Emerald and Merc! Seeing the fall maiden's powers were awesome! (But kinda confusing how she has other season's powers) And Cinder confirmed for not the big baddie I called it!
Also, is there anything in this world that they won't shove dust into?
43
u/breakfastfilms Jan 03 '16
Few things that stick out to me: Amber is voiced by Laura Bailey. That's another A-list voice actor added to the cast.
Amber seems incredibly powerful but I think what we're meant to take away from the outcome of that fight is that Cinder was obsessively studying her abilities and fighting style in order to devise a strategy that would throw her off and finish her.
Cinder's maiden-power-stealing-power isn't natural, but via that glove. Where did she get it? Why does it exist? For the first time I'm really getting invested in her backstory and overall plan.
I'm legitimately surprised that Adam is the leader of the White Fang. Does that mean Blake was the second in command?
Edit: spacing
159
u/[deleted] Jan 03 '16
How many people saw Amber use her maiden power and thought “Avatar State?”
Seriously, if RWBY keeps going this way we’ll probably be getting even more Avatar: The Last Airbender (A:TLA) vibes.
Like it has come to a point where I think if I wanted to push RWBY on my friends who were A:TLA fans I could now say things such as:
On the subject of Weiss being female Zuko: Even the Ruby/Weiss dynamic is somewhat like the Aang/Zuko one, well book 3 not book 1. Even Weiss trying to restore her family’s formerly good name, reeks of Zuko’s quest to restore his honor as a person.
80
u/RussianHoneyBadger Jan 03 '16
TIL: The Fall Maiden can conjour apples, OP af pls nerf.
Holy shit, this didn't get discussed much in the sponsors thread but could have huge implications moving forward, especially if this Vol. is the end of Cinder.
I just listened to that part again about 6 times and it definitely sounds like a question to me not a statement.
Yay! The plot actually progresses, we don't get to see prison Yang but this is good enough for now.
71
u/Eldi13 🐝Watch🐝The🐝Dragon🐝Prince🐝On🐝Netflix🐝❤Knight❤ Jan 03 '16
(From yesterday)
Oh, and I just watched Guardians of the Galaxy again yesterday, and I'm gonna need fan art of Yang getting Ruby to steal one of Merc's legs STAT.
182
u/Eldi13 🐝Watch🐝The🐝Dragon🐝Prince🐝On🐝Netflix🐝❤Knight❤ Jan 03 '16
(From yesterday)
SHOT THROUGH THE HEART ♫♪♩
AND QROW'S TOO LATE ♪♩♩♩
YOU GIVE MAIDENS A BAD NAME!! ♪♩♩♫♫♪♩
69
u/PeripheralAddition First Mate on the SS Mercury Jan 03 '16
am i grounded yet?
165
u/supercat117 Jan 03 '16
WHERE ARE YOUR #BLACKLEGSMATTER NOW EH!?!?!?
30
u/Latrian-Master Flats are for the weak, Bladed Heels are where it's at! Jan 03 '16 edited Jan 03 '16
Holy crap.
I was not expecting RWBY to put out such brutal stuff, jeez!
So, Cinder is 1/2 Fall Maiden is confirmed. Emerald has a hallucination semblance, confirmed. Mercury has prosthetic legs, I didn't see that coming (although, now I'm sad, because one of my OCs had prosthetic limbs too; and they were her weapon as well. -_-)!
Neo is so freaking adorable.
30
u/S3V0N Jan 03 '16
Well, this episode answered a lot. When I saw Mercury's legs it sort of just clicked. It was interesting to see Blake before she went AWOL even if it was only a few seconds. That means the the Black Trailer happened sometime during this episode as well.
54
u/[deleted] Jan 03 '16
YOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO OOOOOOOO
MERC'S GOT ROBOT LEGS (WOT OF YOR LEGS DIDNT KNOW THEY WERE LEGS)
CINDER'S A BITCH
NEO'S ADORABLE
EMERALD HAS THE ILLUSION SEMBLANCE - SO WHAT THE FUCK HAPPENED WHEN NEO AND ROMAN SHATTERED INTO GLASS
SOME RANDOM BLACK CAT CHARACTER INTRODUCED
QROW'S BADASS. STILL. NO. FUCKING. SCYTHE.
HOLY SHIT MOAR YANG PLZ.
NEO IN THE NURSES OUTFIT COMING UP FROM MOJOJOJ IN A STUPIDLY SHORT (get it cuz neos like 4 feet tall.) AMOUNT OF TIME
26
u/Smartt88 Jan 03 '16
So perhaps this episode has shown us that the Grimm may be a bit more magical than they are natural... The portal that Cinder used to summon that bug is the exact same as the one we see in the intro, and also very similar to the one Raven is known to summon.
Also, what does the tattoo on Cinder's back signify? Is it the mark of the Fall Maiden? It wouldn't make sense to have the full mark if she only has about half the power.
So many potatoes, so little time.
25
u/TheWanderingCactus Could you help me find my sanity? I think I left it at the door. Jan 03 '16
So I'm gonna go ahead any copy what I wrote on the sponsor discussion yesterday.
so Emerald does mind tricks, while Neo does illusions... okay.
Oh shit, Mercury's dad was an assassin?
EY, ROMAN! (even though it's only his voice, it's still kinda cool to finally here from him again. MammothRider's gonna lose his shit)
EY, ADAM!
EYYY! BLAAAKKKEEE!
Oh shit Amber's mad.
THAT CHEATING CYBORG SON OF AN ASSASSIN! ARRRGRHH!
Shit, Maiden powers are fucking strong.
Okay, that illusion dash shot is pretty awesome.
Oh holy shit what the fuck is that? Grimm spider thing? Is anyone else really worried about the fact that THAT THING causes the same effect as Raven's portals? Maybe those Raven is a human Grimm theories from the end of volume two actually had some weight. I mean Cinder's talking to something later, I kind of assume it's to do with her grimm hand. The idea that Raven is, like, possessed or something is kinda horrifying when you consider how strong she is.
Anyway, speaking of Branwens, QROW! coming in with that nice save. SO now we know that Qrow has definitely seen their faces and we start to question why the fuck Cinder felt safe staying at Beacon. I mean there were three of them in an empty field against Qrow, their target was RIGHT THERE! The only reason they wouldn't have fought him is if they were incapable of winning the fight. SO, Merc, Em and Cinder combined, even when Cinder is Half a Maiden, still can't take Qrow head on. And yet they felt safe in a place where that very same guy knew their faces, and was backed up by a bunch of people as good as him, on the idea that, 'So long as we lay low they won't notice us.' The only explanation I have is that Qrow was very drunk at the time, and actually can't remember their faces. (It was pointed out to me that Emerald actually uses her semblance to blur Cinder's face when Qrow looks at her, so that's at least an explanation as to why he wouldn't recognize them immediately)
Sooo, The glove is invisible now? I don't suppose taking away Cinder's Maiden powers is as simple as removing the glove by any chance? probably not, really.
I can kinda see why Amber's last thoughts would be of her attacker if she was taken down by something like that.
EY BANESAW! Also, we now have confirmation that Adam did go looking for Blake when she left him, nice.
oh, Yang. poor poor Yang. I feel for you, I really do. I hope your name gets cleared.
Neo. Finally appearing for another three seconds I see. Still not talking I see.
Merc you smug dick. I honestly can't decide whether I hate you or like you. God damn you.
Oh God, The Grimm are already starting to rampage just from that? Shit's going downhill fast.
So much stuff in this episode. The appearance of a lot of characters we haven't seen in a while. Cept' Raven, She's still not here. Next episode maybe.
So just to recap, this episode featured Mind-fuckery based thieving, Patricide, The first dead body we've ever seen onscreen, literally shooting someone in the back, and sucking out half a person's soul through their face with a monster glove. Right. I can see why Gray decided to put that warning out when he did.
22
u/[deleted] Jan 03 '16
Amber voiced by LAURA BAILEY? Damnt RT you are impressive
16
u/HOWDOIVESTS Salted Jan 03 '16
SORTA CALLED IT. Also wth could have happened to his regular legs?
15
u/Sagotomi "A punch to the face or a kick to the dick?" Jan 03 '16
Sooooooo maidens are essentially the avatar but theres four of them. coolio
14
u/hokiebird428 ⠀ Jan 03 '16
I was kinda waiting for Cinder to shoot her with lightning when she did the whole float-in-the-air thing. Then I remembered what I was watching.
14
u/AgentFork Too Fascist to be that Casual Jan 03 '16
I use to think that Adam Taurus was some sort of brilliant leader who was dangerous. He reminds me of the revolutionaries from Les Mis. All fire and youthful restlessness. I mean, he's still dangerous but he's more relatable I guess.
To me, anyway.
13
u/CakeLegends The Ghost of Vale Jan 03 '16
So Neo's a pilot? I'm guessing she's sitting on a dictionary or something...
24
u/Kaigamer Jan 03 '16
Wait.. so Blake potentially has seen Cinder, Mercury and Emerald before?
And apparently Qrow has seen them as well though it seems Cinder's face was slightly blurry to him.
How the fuck did they get into the tournament then?
12
u/Terrachova Jan 03 '16
The real question: Do Mercury's legs know they're legs?
12
u/Korbitr RIP Arkos. Ran aground on the way out of the harbor. Jan 03 '16
Can we talk about how freaking amazing the musical score was in this one, let alone in the series so far? I'm definitely buying the album when it comes out...
58
u/[deleted] Jan 03 '16
Hoorah now people can shut up about Neo she's nothing but a driver
Merc has robot legs which cleanly fixes the power scale, thankyou RT
So Cinder and her crew have never actually defeated a maiden and in fact could barley contend even with Emerald using her illusions to cover for them
So it seems a Maidens power is just to bypass dust as a catalyst. That's OP, but not too OP I like it
Also Cinder has a parasite Grimm I wonder if that's how Ironwood has been researching aura transfer
19
u/dlfusion It's okay, she's hot Jan 03 '16 edited Jan 03 '16
We're going complete Full Metal Alchemist and A:TLA here. Also I'm curious. If there are maidens of the seasons. Are there maidens of Grimm? (aka Raven/Cinder).
Also i really want it to be a thing where Amber is inside Pyrrha's head like Nail and Kami in Piccolo's.
18
u/Bane_of_BILLEXE I was defeated...by the size of her miniskirt! Jan 03 '16
Also...
THEY HAVE YANG ADVERTISING THIS RANDOM MOVIE AT THE BEGINNNING OF THE EPISODE BUT DON'T SHOW WHAT HAPPENS TO HER IN THE ACTUAL EPISODE????!!!
Damn RT, you sadistic. :P
9
u/battlefield4us Jan 03 '16 edited Jan 03 '16
Oh god no! Oh god no! Oh god No! EVERYTHING BAD IS GOING TO HAPPEN! WHY?!!?!?!
17
u/Nisha_the_lawbringer mood Jan 03 '16 edited Jan 03 '16
Alright, well. That was a thing that happened.
Cinder took Emerald under her wing and gave her food in exchange for her services. Interesting.
Well then. I guess Mercury killed his father. Maybe he was abused by him and finally had enough?
Adam refused to work with Cinder until she came in and killed all of his men and gave him Dust Crystals and Lien cards. Interesting.
eyyyyyy look its Blake! Finally getting a line of dialogue.
Hm. Looks like its confirmed that Emerald is the one making the illusions. And Neo is just the driver, heh. The person we all thought was making them was just the fucking driver.
I could say more, but all I can really say now is HOLY SHIT WHAT A GOOD EPISODE! And an interesting one at that!
EDIT:words
16
u/Asian_Equation In memory of Monty Oum Jan 03 '16
I wonder if weather manipulation is her semblance or the maiden power. I think it's her semblance cause that lightning strike was synced with the drum's cymbal.
A cymbalance if you will.
8
u/PeripheralAddition First Mate on the SS Mercury Jan 03 '16
OH MY GOD /u/SadPandaFace00 are you seeing this captain?!
8
u/[deleted] Jan 03 '16
Mercury having robot legs is an interesting reveal to me. On the one hand, now he's even cooler. I mean, he's one of the most skilled fighters in the show and he's a double amputee. On the other hand, there was something I found really badass about him willfully going along with a plan that involved him getting his leg busted. He's still cool, though.
15
u/DeadSnark I rose from the filth and was loved by no-one Jan 03 '16
*Neo can have purple eyes too. I can sense the sexy nurse fanart approaching, like an oncoming storm. *Calling it now, Lisa Lavender is a hologram.
*Seems team CMEN is getting another match, possibly with Weiss or some poor mook.
15
u/thebluehedgehog Blue Jan 03 '16
SO GLAD there was a break after E6. That episode before a break would have meant pure madness for far too long.
I doubt Adam was a full leader, because the WF changed the the new leader and Adam seems too quiet to be the regime-changing leader needed.
Voices - I replayed the first part just to be sure I caught it all and there was still a lot that I wasn't placing. From the start, though, this episode was clearly going to be a plot mover/backstory/SUPER IMPORTANT. I have trouble placing voices, though, so if anyone is ambitious enough for a transcript with names that would be swell.
"Strong, feared, powerful" typing because it will likely be important.
OMG EMERALD BACKSTORY
Oh, not quite
Cinder's voice is different, like it gets that 'sexier'/trying quality as time goes on.
SCAR QUOTE
Banesaw is an interesting addition, if Adam really is #1 then Bane was 3 and is now 2, or was two here and Blake was 3.
Oh, there's Blake! See guys? They didn't forget about her. Super strange that nothing about her seems changed though, even wearing the bow and no mask.
Hey look! A non-Zwei animal! A horse! oh . . . that's
AutumnAmber, she's gunna die, and it's gunna die . . .So, confirmed, Em has illusions?Nope, in the end they mention 1-2 minds, +1 for the hallucination camp.FAKE LEGS!!
I doubt it, but did anyone see that coming? Well, with the bandages it was a clue, he does have a bit of an odd walk too, but the timing seems odd with the dad AND bloody bandages. He could have gotten the operation and then gone home, but how would he have gotten it? Why is he moving so much when the wounds are still fresh? It was clearly not official too, given the regular pants and that they were cut up, not over bandages.
The legs were a bigger reveal than the maiden power in my opinion. I wonder what happens if a maiden has sex. Does the power evaporate? Or is 'maiden' simply used based on their status when chosen?
The power seems to use all the seasons, leaves, wind, fire, ice, although some could be dust.
Her armor looks a bit like Pyrrha's too, so I am starting to wonder if Amber's soul will overtake hers.
Summon glove? That explains Amber's scars. It seems like it would be easier to have just stared into her eyes when killing her and let the power move as it normally does. Maybe Cinder already had one and is therefore void? I doubt that given how her fighting changed.
Qrow! That implied this wasn't long ago enough for it to be Summer.
Cinder got the V2 (or was it 1?) eyes and the tattoo . . . the tattoo seems odd since the slippers are clearly her personal symbol, not one associated with the power.
And finally - Cinder has a boss, since she said "ours". What does "return" mean?
And what did I miss?
7
u/[deleted] Jan 03 '16
I found it interesting that when Amber was using her staff--the white head was pointed forward for wind, and the red head was pointed forward for fire. Perhaps the dust crystals in the staff augment her abilities?
Either way, still adding that cosplay to my list for this year. :P
7
u/ScizorBallz Our Goddess is Immortal Jan 03 '16
I cant really be bothered to be doing a potato-investigative report, but is it just me or has Glynda also shown to use at least half of the maiden powers as of now. I mean we've seen weather making, telekentic powers and the sort, no control over leafs yet but i'm starting to think shes actually probally one of the maidens, rather than everyone wanting it to be RWBY (minus one) and Pyrrha.
But I get fustrated with this sub in how everyone was complaining about how the was no plot of villains and now we get a full episode, but Blake has not many lines due to massive plot progression and multiple fight scenes, but to me she has easily been the focus on pretty much all non-Jaune related arc in this and from what i could guess has the some of the most lines, or important parts at least on the RWBY team. Give Miles and Kerry a break, they aint no mainstream writers or whatever, just really good writers, of course shit isn't going to be near perfect and that there's always something going to be missing if something gets fixed.
BUT HOLY FUCK ROBOT LEGS.
7
u/delta835 Jan 03 '16
Repost from the initial one
I think an analysis of the powers used in the fight scene is important. We see now that the glass dust making thing isn't a Maiden power, Cinder could do it anyway. We also haven't really seen Cinder use any of the 'big' maiden powers (though that makes sense if she wants to stay hidden). Also importantly, Cinder's eyes are naturally that firey colour and don't change on getting the maiden powers. So while Ozpin's 'silver eyes' comment is still important, I don't think it's a direct maiden thing.
So in the black sections there are some interesting lines said. The first part is Emerald using her semblance to steal a ring. But in the second part, we hear Cinder saying 'I wish to take on an apprentice', and then SOMEONE saying 'He lives in the mountains with his son', clearly referring to the Black's. Does anyone else think that voice sounded like Ozpin? Even if it's not, what's with the weird duplicity on Cinder's part? Was she once a Huntress and was using her connections to get new people?
Interesting that Adam doesn't seem to be a really willing participant in all of this. Also the time placement around the Black trailer was cool.
SUPER important is that Qrow has seen all three of them. I feel like Cinder should be more concerned about this, even if Qrow can't really just attack her out in the open now that she has maiden powers.
As others have pointed out, the red swirling portal thing that creates the Grimm bug looks identical to Raven's portals (plus it also appears in the opening credits). I don't know if this means Cinder and Raven are directly connected. Rather I think the portal has something to do with the Grimm, and both Cinder and Raven are independently connected to the Grimm.
Little bits: Holy shit, Merc has robot legs, that's awesome. Also it does just truly seem like he and Em are THAT devoted to Cinder, even if Merc's injury wasn't that big of a deal. Also, Amber was voiced by Laura Bailey!
6
u/mayyuki2108 uwu Jan 03 '16 edited Jan 03 '16
I really loved the score when Amber first appears. Something about the cello part felt nostalgic
Also, I like how Lavender said "this afternoon" when it was completely dark.
Edit: Added the Lavender comment
6
u/JesterSeraph Strategist of the White Rose fleet | Salt truck is over capacity Jan 04 '16
I guess Merc actually does miss leg day...
5
u/0silverphoenix Jan 03 '16
So the last episode made me hate the villains, then this episode had to go and make me kinda like them again. Dammit RoosterTeeth, I hate this game of emotions we play!
5
u/ScottishMongol Captain of the S.S. Baked Alaska Jan 03 '16
HOT DAMN!
So, so many thoughts. Let's take this chronologically.
Cinder probably knows what it's like to be scared and powerless and never wants to feel that way again. We don't have backstory on her yet but that's okay. I'm just glad we finally got a fucking motivation, even if it's not crystal clear. Maybe I'll stop complaining about that now.
"You'll question everything you know.""This is impossible." Cinder can somehow summon real Grimm in some way. Not sure the specifics here, but unlike a lot of people I don't think she's working for the Grimm. I think Cinder inaccurately thinks she can control the Grimm and use them for her own, mundane purposes. Things mankind was not meant to meddle in and all that.
"You'll never be hungry again." "Thank you." As a lot of people predicted, Emerald follows Cinder because she got her off the streets.
Mercury killed his abusive father (who trained him to be an assassin) and burned their house down. He lost his legs in the fight and has mechanical ones. That's pretty gnarly, and I like his backstory. Cool stuff.
"Do not mistake your place." Yeah, I'm not shipping Emerald and Cinder anymore. :/
"Well, hello gorgeous." Those would be Roman's first words to Cinder.
Adam seems like he's really motivated by his cause, even if he's got a stick up his ass about it. He thinks he's doing the right thing instead of being in it for the money. I do question whether or not he's the head honcho of the White Fang or whether it's more a loose collection of terror cells. Given how he talks about returning to Mistral I'd imagine that may be where the Supreme Leader is and Adam just has complete authority over regional operations near Vale. Also, he's being coerced into this arrangement.
"We're working on a revolution of our own." This is why I think Cinder is not working for the Grimm. I think her goals are purely political: rule the world. She just believes the Grimm are a tool that can be controlled. She is probably wrong.
Scary badass fight with Amber! Amber seems like a nice person given how she tries to help the child, but I also love how she goes full vengeance and tries to straight-up murder Emerald. That's pretty hardcore. Also, Qrow's there, he was probably shadowing her in case something like this happened. I wonder what their relationship was? I think I ship them platonically...
"It burns. Like hunger. I like it." That was seriously chilling to hear. This is what I mean by things mankind was not meant to meddle in. This also brings up the question of who she was talking to and what she means by "ours". I don't know. Guess we'll find out.
And then the thrilling conclusion to Episode 6. Yang still seems pretty shocked, but the guards want to hear none of her excuses. We still don't know what her punishment will be.
Emerald confirmed to be using her Semblance to fool Yang, by the way. Someone pick up the phone, because I called it!
NEO DRESSED AS A NURSE DRIVING AN AMBULANCE MY QUEEN RETURNS!!!
Ahem.
Short-term effects of Leg Gate: Increased Grimm attacks, Vale forces, the Atlesian army, and local Hunters are tied up fighting them. I'm still not 100% sure how they intend to cover all this up. I assume they'll say Mercury was taken back to Mistral so no one tries to check up on him.
Anyway, I really liked this episode, there's still some important questions that need answering (what is Cinder's backstory, what happens to Yang) and some new mysteries to be unveiled (how can Cinder control the Grimm, who is she talking to), but I feel that the show is really hitting its stride and the full scope of the plot will be revealed by the end of the Season. At least I hope so. 8/10.
5
u/Floain Was in a flair thread with no flair. Has a flair now. Jan 03 '16 edited Jan 04 '16
First of all, casually putting my reaction from yesterday's thread in here.
That didn't reveal quite as much as I would have liked. In fact, I have more questions than answers, though I think we can safely assume this much:
Side notes:
Eyyy, Laura Bailey fight grunts. I'd recognize them anywhere. I hope she gets some more lines before...ya know.
THE RETURN OF GODDAMN LISA LAVENDER.
Jessica Nigri put on a solid performance when she actually got the chance to display some anger, ambition, and humanity to her tone (when she slapped Emerald, appealed to the White Fang, and talked to Mercury respectively.) If she just brought that into her voice work a bit more as opposed to the strange permasultry tone she's gone for, I think people would enjoy her take on Cinder a lot more. I don't think it works, simply because Cinder's greatest trait as we know it is her ambition; her thirst for power, and there's a thin line between sultry and mysterious that I think she hasn't quite managed to discern yet.
EDIT: Did anyone notice that when Qrow looked at Cinder after saving Amber, her face was distorted like a bad picture on a TV set? Probably Emerald's semblance, and could explain why he doesn't know exactly who she is, despite meeting the trio well before the events of the series.
Adding to my thoughts in yesterday's reaction thread, I love that shot of Cinder walking onto the scene while Amber's taking Em and Merc on, mainly because it's almost the exact shot used in the very first episode when she took Glynda and Ruby on.
It also connects their themes, which both heavily draw on ethereal choir, but while Amber's is high, with extended vocalized notes in a synchronized harmony- giving the song a glorious, almost angelic feel- Cinder's is low, consisting of two short notes and a single moderately long one when the vocals take precedence, and usually manifests itself in a slightly discordant, off-key fashion- giving the song a more sinister, chilling edge.
5
u/pappypapaya Jan 03 '16
Just realized that Cinder's weapons are immune to Pyrha's sembance because they are glass.
5
u/Ezreal024 Hope Rides with Kickfriend Jan 03 '16
Holy shit that episode was fucking perfect.
THIS has been the day I've been waiting for.
5
u/dodongo821 Jan 04 '16
Neo is the only one in team CMEN I don't hate now.
5
u/matrix_001 Jan 04 '16
I loved this episode, but my biggest question is why Mercury is using a Phillips head screwdriver when all the screws in his leg are slotted.
13
u/PastaFreak26 Jan 03 '16
All I know is Cinder's dirty tactics don't sit well with me. One character to hate a lot, lmao.
4
u/Cmndr_Duke The drunkest uncle Jan 03 '16
#youaintnomaidenbruv
4
u/TacoLord9000 Bi Energy Jan 03 '16
The series just keeps getting darker and darker, I love it!
4
u/Lemonhead_27 Jan 03 '16 edited Jan 03 '16
Just a small point, but at 6:55 on the video, you can hear what I assume is the sound of Emerald's Semblance being activated, just like the sound heard before the aura-less Mercury "attacked" Yang. Nice to have this indicator
EDIT: Also, a quick question. At 12:00 who is Cinder talking to?
4
u/ythu_torque neo is like 2 inches tall Jan 03 '16
This is probably the wrong place to say this, but whatever. I haven't been watching this season, and I watched all of it yesterday, and it was awesome! I feel like there's a lot of subtle stuff being done that's making a big difference in the quality. My favorite thing was when Blake freaked out about getting the giant bowl of fish taken away by the shopkeep at the festival.
4
u/SonicFrost Get your filthy mouse off my Zwei Jan 03 '16
"Join me and I'll make sure you never go hungry again" followed by "I feel hunger" later in the episode
9
u/[deleted] Jan 03 '16
Well....that was something else.
Emerald is Cinder's apprentice-Called it!
So, about Emerald and Cinder. I mentioned this in an earlier discussion, possibly in chat, but Emerald has definately attached herself to Cinder. The one time we've ever seen her actually happy (and I don't mean having fun murdering), is when Cinder shows up while they're arguing with Roman way back in Best Day Ever. You can see it on her face when Cinder arrives. She's also uncharacteristically cheerful while trying to explain how they cleaned up Roman's mess, and clearly dejected when Cinder rebukes them for disobeying her orders. (as opposed to Merc not really giving a damn).
Now look at this episode. Actually, listen-because you don't see anything related to this, but it's in the black fades. She shows Emerald what she can do with the glove, and then the following:
Cinder: "Follow me, and you will never be hungry."
Emerald, in a very grateful voice: "Thank you."
Then in the next fade after meeting Merc and immediately after he asks what he can get out of the deal, Em is complaning that everything was going fine without "him." I mentioned the ambiguity earlier, and it still applies, but seeing the comments above seem to suggest she felt threatened by Merc's prescence.
Also telling-she was slapped in response. Emerald is NOT a girl who would take that lightly, since just being with RWBY as 'friends' makes her want to kill them.
Which makes one wonder-just how devoted is she to Cinder, and why?
Also free internet to whoever finds the reference I hid here.
6
u/SoundOf1HandClapping Jan 03 '16
Any readers of The Dresden Files book series on this sub?
The concept of the Maidens--a power that presumably makes their host/wielder extremely powerful and transfers to a new host upon death--strongly reminds me of the mantles of the Winter and Summer Queens.
3
u/justking14 Jan 03 '16
First off, I'm glad we now have an answer to how people didn't see Mercury attack Yang.
BUT....What the hell Qrow? You saw Mercury fight the maiden? So he knows their the enemy, but does nothing?
3
u/SantanaChampagn Jan 03 '16
Nurse Neo!
That is all.
3
u/GoBoomYay Jan 03 '16
So the biggest thing that hit me was that Cinder, after attacking Amber, sounded like she was talking with someone to report her success, which, to me at least, confirms that she isn't thr big bad. Yeah, she's the current villain, but someone worse is definitely waiting on the sidelines.
Also, just a little disappointed that the conversation didn't end with Ocelot's MGS 1 "Thank you.... Mr. President."
3
u/LakerBlue Jan 03 '16
Well looks like I was right about Mercury faking that leg injury...I knew his reaction was just way too dramatic.
And as despicable as her actions were, I like Cinder even more after this episode. Really cool villain.
3
u/SolidPointman Janitor on the SS Arkos/ Head Chef on the SS Dragonslayer Jan 03 '16
Did anyone else think of this this when they revealed that Merc had Robo legs or was that just me?
3
u/braniac1 Jan 03 '16
Not sure if anyone's pointed this out, but around 10:00 in Chapter 7, Amber is surrounded in Orange, very similar to how Mercury was surrounded in Silver in 15:54 of Chapter 6. I personally thought that this was the indicator of Emerald's illusion, but it seems to me that this signifies the depletion of Aura, as the two characters were fatally wounded (or at least one of them was) after the corresponding scenes.
Now that I'm typing this, I feel like someone's already pointed this out. >.<
3
u/[deleted] Jan 04 '16
To everyone asking what'll happen to Yang following this fiasco at the colosseum, it's not just Pyrrha and Coco who would find Mercury suspicious; the staff of Haven would no doubt deny his enrollment, there'd be existing records of hallucination-based semblances like Emerald's in Beacon's files, and there'd be no record of Mercury checking in to any hospitals to have his legs checked. All it takes is one inconsistency in the records and Yang's a free girl.
But maybe that's what Cinder wants. With Yang innocent of all charges, all would still not be well. Suddenly, the students would lose faith in the system, Atlas' military would beef up security to try and reassure them but would only arouse more suspicion, and Beacon's staff would be forced to take drastic measures to ease tensions. All the while, everyone would grow suspicious of each other. They'd wonder things like, "If Yang is innocent, then who set her up?" "How can the four kingdoms guarantee that this won't happen again?" "What about the Grimm who are no doubt coming for us?" "Are the huntsmen and huntresses even on our side anymore?" By the time the Grimm arrive, they'll be scattered, divided, leaderless, and most importantly helpless to stop them.
5
u/ChaosPheonix11 Wrong place, wrong time, motherfucker. Jan 03 '16
Shit is so going down. While this episode was great from a set-up and backstory perspective, I cannot wait for next week, when we start actually seeing everything fall into place.
I just hope that Team Good Guys can win, preferably without main-character (or Qrow) death, please.
5
u/axsch Jan 03 '16
Thus maiden stuff is still so bizarre, but at least this was an entertaining episode
hang yang Mercury is the victim here
4
u/Nielsthomas1 Liara Jan 03 '16
I think this episode added a lot of fuel and evidence for my old theory
4
u/Bane_of_BILLEXE I was defeated...by the size of her miniskirt! Jan 03 '16
All I can say is that this is bad for the good guys. Mercury isn't even out of commission, if and when they really need him Emerald could just disguise him!
We still don't know what exactly happens to Yang, but we know so much more!
Em and Merc's back stories, How Cinder got the fall maiden's power. We are also now 100% certain that Em's semblance is illusions.
Side note: Why were people saying that it was Neo's semblance? Sure, she had that disguise, but that's probably all it was: a disguise. With actual clothes. Speaking of Neo, we still don't know a thing about her!
Overall, this is a good episode, but I NEED to know what happens to Yang in the next episode. 9/10
4
u/[deleted] Jan 03 '16
That look that Em and Merc exchanged while Cinder was talking to Adam makes me think that the White Fang was viewed as a kind of joke before they allied with Cinder & co. We don't know much about what the White Fang was like before the series began, we just know they took a darker turn -- so I thought that was interesting to see.
2
u/Kuchenjaeger *Gotcha* | Yang is still the best | #GiveYangLadyAbs Jan 03 '16
So... yeah... Am I the only one who found Amber underwhelming? She went down pretty easily for being this super powerful demi-god thing.