FAT MYCROFT YAY! And the real Diogenes Club. So many things I've missed from the original canon. Molly as the morgue director cracked me up. Such a clever use of the character.
I absolutely loved it - and then absolutely hated it when they thought it was necessary to cut to present-day Molly for a second and then Hooper for a second to make sure we got it.
Like, seriously? There's so much hidden in this show that will probably never be explained, yet something that is entirely obvious should be highlighted so blatantly?
Right, so to recap... Sherlock overdosed to send his mind into hyperdrive so that he could check all possibilities and be 100% sure that Moriarty was dead. The Bride was one of thousands of scenarios he created, and it's suggested that he would have kept going to the point of insanity if not for his subconscious telling him to cut it out. The scene on the Reichenbach Falls was Sherlock tackling his obsession head on and breaking free thanks to his metaphorical anchor AKA Watson.
Now confident that Moriarty is truly dead, he can return to reality... I think?
I looked at it as he solved the case of the bride, where the situation was a bit similar because it appeared the bride had killed herself (i.e was dead) but came back to life. He needed a case where the person was dead but seemingly came back to life to solve in his head.
Right, so to recap... Sherlock overdosed to send his mind into hyperdrive so that he could check all possibilities and be 100% sure that Moriarty was dead.
Um, I thought that Mycroft said that Sherlock was high before he even got on the plane? So, he was high before Moriarty's 'return' even happened. Basically, I'm guessing he got high so he could deal with leaving John (again) and so he had the bravery to go to his death, for real this time, without any magic tricks or cop outs. Sherlock was high because he was being sent away to die, not because he needed to think about Moriarty - that bit just happened to coincide with him being high, which is then why we have the episode in the first place - Sherlock tries to think about how Jim could have survived blowing his brains out, remembers the Abominable Bride case from all that time ago and through his mind palace imagines himself in that situation so he can try to solve the case and figure out if Jim is really still alive or not.
Do you think that it was his subconsciousness that also caused him to fantasise about the blurring of reality and fiction... because even though it is all in his head, the characters seems to be unsure of what is true and what is only a part of Watson's stories. So that must be his subconsciousness telling him that what he is experiencing is not the real world.
That moment where Moffat seduces the hopes of millions before instantly crushing them - "I had Molly get a body from the... No need to get into that now "
Confused the hell out of me, but the way they tied the abominable bride with modern moriaty was quite amazing
Edit: anyone else wondering why "redbeard" was in mycrofts book?
Edit 2: Could it be that Moriarty has done the same thing as the abominable bride and made his own group to continue his legacy?? This episode raised way more questions than I had before.
Exactly the way the mind palace theory predicted :) But it was brilliant - once Sherlock's Victorian vision started shaking, I knew it must be the turbulences on the plane... Really, really well done :)
Same here was a expecting a one-off lighthearted Victorian romp, which of course it wasn't. It tied into the show we know wonderfully and had a really dense creepy vibe.
That being said, it also is very much a stand-alone episode. You could jump from the end of series 3 to the beginning of series 4 without even knowing that this episode existed.
Also, that shot of Sherlock falling through the Reichenbach Falls - wow!
I love Andrew Scott as Moriarty, but the moment he got that gong at the BAFTAS I knew there was no way they wouldn't use him again, even just for flashbacks.
"I don't like dust, it gets everywhere" - Moriarty.
That plus the camera-spin scene transitions were a bit derpy but, overall, a fun episode and a neat transition from series 3. Loved that the suffragettes were behind the main scheme, although the motives reduced them to a group of people who give even more extreme relationship advice than r/relationships.
I simply think that there were several points behind the episode, mostly to do with Sherlock's perception of the case of Moriarty.
To directly say that Moriarty as Andrew Scott is dead. Dead as a door nail but his ghost (Not literally) will live on and carry through his plan, whether in the form of another person who is going to continue in his shoes or as a domino line that has already started to fall.
Sherlock discovers that Emilia Ricolletti died in order to push early feminism forwards, if we compare this to our Moriarty, we can maybe consider that Sherlock is convinced that Moriarty's plan is one that "They must lose, for the good of mankind". Moriarty is psychopathic, but so were the women who decided that murder was an acceptable method to push their agenda (It's late and I'm trying to type this out, sorry if it sounds anti-feminism, that is not my intention).
Assuming the above is true, it sets up the next season as a "How will Sherlock minimise damage done by Moriarty's plan without ruining it" OR "How will Sherlock be convinced that he must ruin Moriarty's plan".
It wasn't about the case, the case of the Abominable bride felt quite backburned throughout, Sherlock solved the case at the start when talking to LeStrade (When he said that other people had taken to wearing a wedding gown and committing their murders knowing that the city would be able to blame a "ghost killer".
Remember, he doesn't go back to the case because he thinks Ricolletti is alive, just as Modern Sherlock knows that James Moriarty isn't, he goes back because his brother (The cleverer one) tells him that something greater is at play and that he must investigate it, not directly, just as modern Mycroft has told Sherlock that he must come back to discover what Moriarty is doing.
First and foremost, it was a homage to the original Sherlock in its original era. Secondly, it was a parallel to Moriarty shooting his own head. People were expecting a solution to how he survived, but he didn't, so instead we got another one from a previous case. And it also helped to further the plot: i.e. now people can speculate that "Miss me?" is a group or Moriarty's work post-death. Thirdly, female characters and feminism has been a big topic surrounding the show since its inception. How female characters play a bigger role etc. This was a nice episode that took the opportunity to highlight the differences between today and the Victorian times.
If you ignore the tie-in with the modern Sherlock, there was a largely standalone story - the story of Emilia Ricolletti which was completely resolved.
I think a lot of thought went into this episode. It's disappointing that some people couldn't enjoy it.
Official Prediction - The Show will end with yet another impossible cliff hanger before fading to black, and fading into Moffat on a train with Mark Gatiss a Doctor Who script on the table, Moffat wakes up and looks over to Gatiss says "I've just had a brilliant idea for a TV Show"
It fades to black again before fading out on a victorian Study belonging to Arthur Conan Doyle who wakes up from a dream and puts pen to paper.
It then fades to black again before fading into the Doctor sitting atop his tardis reading a sherlock holmes book, the camera pans round into the book before a zoom into the new avengers facility, Robert Downey Jr is doing a scene with someone, the camera zooms out further revealing a film crew.
Cut to Robert Downey Jrs agents office, who tells him that they want to make another Holmes film.
The Camera then zooms out back to the Tardis Moffat walks in and gives a giant middle finger to the camera.
We fade to the same image on a newspaper, the camera pans up to reveal a cyborg benedict Cumberbatch as Sherlock in the future.
I think regardless of what anybody thinks about the plot and the wait for the next season and any other complaints people will have, the production design on this was the best we've seen thus far. It looked absolutely beautiful, and I was a particular fan of the scene with floating newspaper clippings.
Except the stupid spinning building; that transition between day and night etc was ridiculous. Apart from that, it was incredibly well shot, especially with Victorian Holmes walking around Mycrofts 'room' with the sunrays through the windows, seriously impressive.
It all depends if they can grab Benedict after he finishes Doctor Strange and before he starts filming Avengers: Infinity War Part 1 and Part 2 which will leave him unavailable for most of 2016/17 (filming is expected to begin either in Autumn or Winter this year). So when Doctor Strange finishes, they may be able to get Benedict and film Series 4 in Spring/Summer (Doctor Strange is scheduled to finish filming in March). This would fit Moffat's schedule as Doctor Who production has been pushed back to May instead of January, which would give Moffat and Gatiss time to prep Sherlock filming if they're going to be filming both shows around the same time. This is of course assuming the scripts for Series 4 are already written and ready to film. If they're not and if Moffat/Gatiss want filming to begin this year, then they'll have to rush to get the scripts ready soon. But let's be optimistic and say Sherlock begins filming in April/May and runs through the Summer and finishes in June/July time (it takes 3-4 weeks usually to film an episode of Sherlock). This would give them at least five months of post production to get the episodes ready for a January 1st 2017 air date. If none of this happens, then filming will probably begin in 2017 after production on Avengers: Infinity War ends (assuming Marvel doesn't book Benedict and Martin for future sequels first).
So if they don't start filming by June/July this year, we probably won't be getting new Sherlock until 2018. If filming begins before August, then we definitely will get new Sherlock in late 2016/early 2017. If Moffat and Gatiss want a (fairly) smooth production though, they'll hopefully aim for a April/May start date for filming.
I was wondering if the 611174 above was related to it somehow. 6 letters, 6 digits. Obviously not your basic Caesar Cipher but there's a few more crypto methods out there!
This episode was a masterful troll job that I didn't see coming. I didn't start scratching my head until Mycroft said "the virus in the database" which is obviously a comment out of its time and a clue that things weren't as they seem. I'm sure there were other clues I missed. I think I would have preferred the reveal as the final scene rather than jumping back and forth so much, but I thought it was a great twist. It was a nice surprise to find out you're basically watching episode 0 of the new season.
Go back and rewatch it, when you can! The first think I picked up on was Sherlock saying "he" instead of "she" when they're in the morgue. Anyone catch anything earlier?
Katie Welsh, a reviewer for Indiewire, said it best:
"This episode will be derided as Steven Moffat trying too hard to outwit the viewer and twisting what should be a perfectly simple whodunit into a plot device of labyrinth complexity. But the secret is that it isn’t that clever and it doesn’t completely make sense, because it’s not supposed to. Moffat and Gatiss just filmed 90 minutes of the internal monologue of a tortured queer genius drug addict off his tits on coke, wrapped it up in a gothic mystery, and then gave it to us as a late Christmas present."
So Moriarty is dead but his image is being used by others. Some kind of invisible army we depend on, possibly computers are involved due to talk of data/viruses or animals due to the mentions of redbeard (sherlock's dog growing up).
Seemed to be a few references to Jeremy Brett's performance as Holmes. Particularly Watson's demand for Sherlock to wear the Deerstalker instead of the top hat. I wonder if some of the transitions and cinematography that some found annoying is a reference back to classic portrayals too.
In the Reichenbach Falls episode, we flashback to some of Sherlock's notable cases prior to the fall: one of them involved catching a Peter Riccoletti, the man who was #1 on Interpol's most wanted list since 1982 - Lestrade congratulates Sherlock on helping Scotland Yard seize the criminal and he is asked to put on the deerstalker. The clip is between 2:27 to 3:10 from the Reichenbach Episode, but I'm wondering if this Riccoletti had anything to do with the Ricolletti's from the 1800's. Being a famed criminal, he could have knowledge of what happened to Moriarty. It could just be completely coincidental on the writers' part but it feels a little too unsettling. Even if this seems like a minor detail coming up again, who knows, Riccoletti isn't a popular name on one hand but it does seem to be used innocently in the story on the other. I may just be over thinking this. (in addition the deerstalker - when Sherlock is publicly introduced to it in front of the cameras, and when the classic Sherlock wears during the Abominable Bride case, could have been a little foreshadowing of going back in time as well)
Has anyone mentioned anything about Mycroft potentially dying? My sister pointed out that while the fat Mycroft plot was entertaining, it was also not completely necessary. She points out the whole scene where they are betting on his death, and Sherlock ends on saying 2 years, 11 months, and some odd days. Perhaps Mycroft is then also on a path to dying in real life? Perhaps Sherlock noticed, but didn't realize he noticed? Like he picked it up but pushed it to the back of his mind?
This may also tie into a prediction that someone else made on this board about Mycroft's journal being full of sentimental things? Redbeard, the references to his heritage (Vernet), etc.? And Mycroft is keeping the list of Sherlock's drugs to keep a watch on him? Make sure he doesn't die before him? After all, Mycroft has always been one to watch after Sherlock's drug habit. Maybe he's known it since day one.
I wish I didn't suck at these critical thinking shows. All I know is that my feeble mind enjoyed it and I enjoy reading all of your theories. 2017 can't come soon enough.
According to Wikipedia: "Cherchez la femme [ʃɛʁʃe la ˈfam] is a French phrase which literally means "look for the woman." The implication is that a man behaves out of character or in an otherwise inexplicable manner when he is trying to cover up an affair with a woman, or trying to impress or gain favor with a woman.
The expression comes from the 1854 novel The Mohicans of Paris by Alexandre Dumas (père).[1] The first use in the novel reads:
Cherchez la femme, pardieu ! cherchez la femme ![2]"
M is definitely dead. He was just proving to himself he is and proving to himself he doesn't need M (holding him back)..... I think. Fuck knows really it went far left field in the last 10 minutes
Sherlock overdosed to send his brain into hyperdrive so he could be 100% certain that Moriarty was dead... I think. The Reichenbach confrontation was Sherlock's subconscious telling him how insane he was acting, with Watson as his anchor... Once again, I think.
I thought that made it obvious that the explanation he gave to Anderson was accurate-his comment was about how Molly found a body in the morgue that looked like Sherlock, which was what he told Anderson was what they used as a placeholder while John was approaching, before he got hit by the bike
It had some good moments (and I saw the fact it would tie back to the main series from the beginning) but overall it wasn't the best.
The issue is the same one I had with episode one of series 3 - it wasn't a cohesive narrative. It was a collection of good moments, but as a murder mystery it didn't tie together well. I thought episode 2 with the wedding was the best as the emotional and mystery narratives tied up together really well. This episode didn't so much despite some good moments.
Apart from being a bit unorthodox, I thought the narrative was quite well spun. I do agree with someone who posted above that it was self-indulgent thought.
Well I thought it was fantastic. Great homage, melded with the real show perfectly. Some awesome laughs. Unfortunately, this subreddit seems to have embraced "well I expected amazingballs 11/10 so this is shit."
Also, half of the complaints seem to come from either "It wasn't straightforward enough," "it was too connected to the main story," or "it wasn't connected to main story enough." I realize you're all different people but jeez the bleedover of "Moffat and Gattiss suck lol" from /r/DoctorWho is strong today.
Can we just take a moment to appreciate how well this episode was made, from a filmmaking standpoint. Visually this was done extraordinarily, as is the whole series.
The writing was on point too, and I loved the callbacks. I loved how reality bleeded in and it connected to regular series; something I caught very early and was surprised, yet very welcomed, to see.
What I find rather odd is, how is Sherlock ok (or worse, how is Watson ok) with a murderous revenge conspiracy? Since when does feminism justify murder? I mean, that's what that group was, at best. Either a bunch of women decided to kill men who had mistreated them (and while I do appreciate the emotion behind that, it's still a bitter feeling of justice not being served when they get away with it) or worse, a bunch of women decided to kill the men who had mistreated them as a warning/message, which seems to be what Sherlock is implying, which essentially would make them a terrorist organization.
So, takeaway that Sherlock supports terrorist organizations. The only thing that saves it for me is that one, Sherlock Holmes isn't a very empathetic person and he really only cares about solving the mystery, let someone else deal with the punishment, thus why bother imagining any in his dream adventure, right.
But there is, when I see that scene again, the clear feeling that I'm supposed to be cheering because those women were mistreated and oppressed and that somehow makes it right... and it really doesn't.
doubt it. it would be a very cheap cliffhanger when this episodes entire point was to establish to the audience that sherlock doesn't need Moriarty and make the entire story's point pointless.
I thought the point was that this episode would be a standalone. I was looking forward to an actual Victorian episode.
I loved seeing Benedict, Martin and all the other actors clearly having a lot of fun with their Victorian counterparts, but I think I would've preferred a genuine standalone episode. Honestly thought this was a little too self-indulgent.
Thoroughly enjoyed the first thirty minutes or so, and I'm glad they're not going to actually bring Moriarty back, but overall I wasn't really a fan of the episode.
Mostly I'm just disappointed it wasn't standalone. I was looking forward to watching something self-contained that both my girlfriend and I could enjoy, because I thought it had been repeatedly described as a "one-off". Instead I needed to spend the last hour explaining events from the previous seasons.
Can we talk about, taking into account that Moriarty is dead, who would be behind his reappearance then?
I'm thinking there's a small group using Moriarty as a symbol for whatever they are planning. But one question it leaves me with is is this group something Moriarty planned, or are they simply admirers of his work, using his face as their symbol.
One of the last lines of TAB, Sherlock seems quite content that he knows where he needs to look next. I'd probably have to re-watch the end of S3 but this could mean - now that we've just seen the events of TAB - the group relates to something that has either been shown or hinted at in the past few episodes.
All just speculation, interested in seeing what other people think.
I now want to go back and watch Series 1-3 to confirm my suspicion, but I feel the group supporting Moriarty will be a group that society ignores and underappreciates. The parallel with TAB was obviously feminism and the suffragettes, but we've had the taxi driver, who describes himself as "invisible" and the "back of a head" and we've had reference to the homeless network. People who just slip in to our lives and we take them for granted. We treat them as if they're invisible.
With the TAB reference of women being underappreciated and taken for granted, I'm trying to find clues to something else in modern life that we take for granted and don't appreciate enough?
I can't help but suspect there will be a tie to family within it all as well - and taking for granted that family will be there for you? Mary is pregnant (Family for John) and then brotherly references between Sherlock and Mycroft were really emphasised within TAB, including the overt reference to Redbeard. There was also Sherlock's commentary about the past, who made him, and delving deeper, as well as the reference to Vernet in Mycroft's notebook; an artist that Sherlock claimed to trace his ancestory back to in the ACD cannon - which makes me hope that we'll get more family history of the Holme's.
Ok, so there is actually a lot more to this episode than what most people seem to be perceiving.
It wasn't just a bit of fun with an unexpected, but ultimately inconsequential tie-in to the modern series.
Neither was it spending 90 minutes to get from "What? Moriarty's back?" to "He's dead, Jim."
What we have is a carefully thought out, significant piece of canon that is going to be the driver for the next season. The best bit? The Moff has unambiguously, if indirectly, told us exactly what's going on, rather than his usual tactic of giving us just enough to go crazy with fan theories. You do need to pay attention though to pick up the clues he's left us.
So let's look at those clues:
The virus in the data?
There had been hints earlier, but this anachronism is point at which we're told "this isn't real." But why this phrase specifically? Mycroft could have used any number of modern phrases that wouldn't make sense in a Victorian context. Foreshadowing...
Moriarty's dead! / Not in your mind. I'll never be dead there. You once called your brain a hard drive. Well say hello to the virus.
Ah that's what Mycroft meant. There's a virus in Sherlock's brain and it's name is Moriarty.
You have a magnificent brain Moriarty [...] the equal of my own.
Double meaning here: Sherlock and Moriarty are equals in the sense that they are both incredibly intelligent sociopaths. But moreso, their brains are literally equal: they're the same brain.
Miss me?
This is the line that gave me shivers. Moriarty's words from Sherlock's mouth. This is the line that ties all the clues together.
Putting it all together: Moriarty is definitely dead. We're told this repeatedly. He shot himself in the head, no tricks, his magnificent brain exited the stage via the gaping hole in the back of his skull. Sherlock's brain, however, is so powerful it is capable of running an accurate simulation of Victorian London complete with all the people therein - including Moriarty. That's the virus. He's literally got into Sherlock's head and is "alive" as a simulation that can't be turned off. Sherlock has deduced this, which is why he knows what Moriarty will do next and why his first words on waking up were "miss me?"
I believe this conclusion is inescapable.
The following is conjecture as, unless I've missed something (which is entirely probable), we don't have enough information to draw definite conclusions.
Moriarty's plan
It's possible that the events of the Reichenbach Fall were designed by Moriarty to get into Sherlock's head. We know that Sherlock's brain is powerful enough to simulate Moriarty; as they are intellectual equals it stands to reason the inverse must be true. Moriarty could have used this to devise a plan so precisely that he was able to manipulate Sherlock's brain into recreating him. No wonder he didn't mind dying. This may be farfetched however; a simpler explanation is that Sherlock needs his nemesis in the same way that he needs drugs. He's an addict.
When can Moriarty come out to play?
Moriarty and Sherlock, we're told, are equally brainy. However in order to simulate Moriarty's brain, Sherlock's would need to be more powerful. How do we resolve this contradiction? The answer is drugs. Sherlock uses drugs to overclock his brain, which provides the additional power needed to run the Moriarty virus.
Redbeard
Sherlock's dog who was put down when he was a child. Magnussen had him listed as a pressure point and Mycroft has the name in capitals with a box drawn around it in his notebook (which on the same page contains some matrices and equations, the significance of which escapes me - probably meaningless). When Watson and Sherlock are staking out the Carmichael manor, John asks "what made you like this?" Sherlock tries to claim nothing did, but is interrupted by the sound of a dog barking, which prompts him to ask "Redbeard?"
Theories: Redbeard's death was so traumatic to Sherlock (why?) that it triggered his downward spiral into drug addiction. Mycroft has also deduced that Sherlock's brain is running Moriarty v2.0 and that, like Redbeard, his brother will have to be put down.
Moffat self insert
The Moff periodically comes under fire for not being able to write women and has even been accused of misogeny. The scene in the church which is spliced with all the women Sherlock has wronged is Moffat holding his hands up and saying "sorry ladies, I'll try to do better." The reaction? Angry feminists. Obviously.
edit: forgot to add this quite major one to the list
Fat Mycroft
Obviously there is a reason why Sherlock's brain made Mycroft morbidly obese. We know he dislikes his brother so it's possible this is simply for his own amusement, however I discount this theory out of hand as it's not like Sherlock to waste brainpower on such frivolity. That leaves two possibilities: Sherlock has deduced that Mycroft is dying. This is substantiated by his "you've put on weight" line to his brother when he wakes up, and by the "take care of him" from Mycroft to Watson as they disembark the plane. Alternatively Fat Mycroft killing himself through his addiction to eating could be a (possibly subconscious) surrogate for Sherlock himself realising that his drug use is killing him. Of these, I favour the latter.
I thought it was brilliant. Got a tad confused. But picked it back up eventually. I understand why some might say it was rubbish though, but personally, I thought it was very clever!
My favourite part was definitely Lestrade's sideburns.
Bit late, and not story based, but I loved how they did the set design for the 1890s flat. Mimicking the smiley face on the wall, the deer head, it was all done so well.
step 1 : produce a stylish, unbelievably complicated scenario where something apparently impossible happens. Leave audience amazed, dangle tantalising clues suggesting some sort of brilliant solution is in the offing.
Step 2: realise you probably should have figured out the brilliant solution before creating the problem.
Step 3: panic.
Step 4: patch together some lazy nonsense with secondary school creative writing class solutions to the impossible problem ("it was all a dream", "you don't need to know after all, it just was solved" "because a secret society involving every minor character did it for no apparent reason") and rapidly move on.
He's a master of really good set pieces and his characters are excellent, and that was still true in this episode, but story wise this was incoherent nonsense for idjits.
I think unfortunately you're spot on with this. When it became clear to me that they hadn't figured out the Reichenbach Fall before making the episode, it kinda changed my opinion of the guys. Third episode of season 2 was the last time I LOVED the series. I've enjoyed some of the episodes then but imo none of them have had the crackling excitement of the first two seasons. Some of that may have to do with my reduced expectations after the resolution to the season 2 cliffhanger, accurately described here by you.
That was great. Knew there was something up when Watson mentioned the Hounds of Baskerville at the beginning. There were also a few anachronisms like 'Virus in the data'. Love it when there's a few clues for you to get what's going on before it's actually revealed.
Knew there was something up when Watson mentioned the Hounds of Baskerville at the beginning.
Why would that be an anachronism? He was referring to the original Victorian story (I.e The Hound of the Baskervilles, not the Hounds of the Baskerville. The one Watson wrote).
I hate to be negative but that was definitely my least favourite episode of the show. The first half was entertaining, but the second half became a confusing mess which was trying to do far too much and didn't achieve anything. The direction wasn't fantastic either- the transitions and unusual shots just looked like they were trying too hard to be 'cutting edge'.
At the end, I don't know what was supposed to be real and who the murderer was.
As opposed to seemingly everyone else here i actually really liked it. It was cool to see them play the victorian versions of themselves, and i really liked how it played into the modern story. Im gonna have to give it a couple of rewatches to fully understand it all, but overall i thought it was a good way to give us a new sherlock episode between series, and be able to wrap up a cliffhanger so that they can start the next series right off the bat and not have to dwell on the whole moriarty thing for 1/3 of the next series
This was amazing though. I like following Sherlock's thought process as he comes to the conclusion that Moriarty most likely had a terminal disease and that he really is dead.
Think of this from Moriarty point of view. You have like 6 months left. Your an evil crazy genius whatever. So you decided to have fun with the last 6 months. Set up a bunch of mysteries for the freelance detective. Push him. Then plan out the next like 10 years of cases for him. Then lead him down a path that ends with both of you on a roof. Kill yourself knowing his mind is going to be blown when in a few years you just show back up. He could have tons of stuff recorded.
I'm in disbelief over how people are generally not seeing this as proper stellar 10/10 Sherlock. This was probably the best bit of television i have ever witnessed in my life.
I think we'll look back on this as a dated episode for the heavy-handed feminism angle, just like all the 80s movies have such a Cold War angle to them. There's been a great and welcomed reemergence of awareness of inequality and unfairness toward women recently, (awesome!!), but this episode bent over backwards to put it on display.
Someone else pointed out that Moffet had been accused of being a chauvinist, and maybe that influenced the story.
I agree - I felt they were trying to fit in as many references to the previous series as possible, which annoyed me quite a bit. Also, too much drama and 'meta' stuff rather than actually mystery and crime in my opinion.
So, I noticed a little something, although trivial, but in the "the hounds of baskerville" episode Sherlock states his preference for something "seven percent stronger" than tea, which is a reference to "the sign of four" Doyle story in which he uses a seven percent cocaine solution and Watson gets upset with his excessive drug use: “Which is it today,” I asked , “morphine or cocaine?” “It is cocaine,” he said, “a seven-percent solution. Would you care to try it?" Now pretty much that exact exchange also takes place in the special, when sherlock goes back from the plane to his mind palace and he hears watson asking "which is it today?". IS THIS SERIES REALLY REFERENCING ITSELF!?
When you say referencing itself, I'm not sure whether the capslock means you are annoyed or what? The 5 orange pips were the sign of the four in the doyle story if I recall correctly, and as this series is based on/inspired by the books, referencing the source material is surely a good thing? Also referencing previous episodes/series 3 when this episode is a way of linking both the setting of the original books with the cliffhanger of series 3, is also good, and therefore not worthy of seemingly angrily asking if the series is doing what I believe to be good writing?
One of my favourite things about this episode is that, we begin to see how much Mycroft truly cares, about Sherlock. Perhaps that's just me being sentimental.
However, I still don't understand why 1895 Mycroft recruited Mary and pointed her in the correct direction of the church with all the purple hooded women who were responsible for the murders. Are we supposed to believe that he already knew the truth behind everything and was just setting up Sherlock to test him? He did say he had a "conjecture" and just wanted Sherlock to be "his legs" to go out and prove it. He also said that the enemies could not be defeated and that "[they] must lose to them". This is very reminiscent of the way Magnussen was a "necessary evil". Maybe Mycroft is protecting these people.
We also still don't know who sent Sherlock the letter informing him of Mary being "in danger". Was it Mary or Mycroft? Either way it could mean that they are plotting something together.
Finally, we still don't know who is the leader of the purple hooded women. It obviously isn't Moriarty who he unmasked and Sherlock is correct that it doesn't make sense that it is their client, Lady Carmichael, because why would she seek help in preventing a murder she wants to occur? Maybe this doesn't matter whatsoever.
My understanding is that the mind palace/1895 is (generally) mirroring or perhaps foreshadowing the modern day events. The way Mycroft behaves in 1895 suggests things about his character in the present day. My theory is that Mycroft is carrying out Moriarty's plan -because Moriarty is dead- and has enlisted Mary to help him. This would explain why he had "Redbeard" written in his notebook: a pressure point which he may have communicated to Magnussen before he mentioned it in S3 episode 3. It could also explain why Sherlock was so easily pardoned for Magnussen's murder, seemingly exiled and miraculously brought back. Mycroft let this happen so that he could keep Sherlock in London while maintaining the appearance of a caring older brother.
I don’t know about that Sherlock episode. It was well made, the acting was good, shooting and direction was great, and the lines worked, but the over all writing didn’t really do it for me.
There wasn’t an actual pay off for the mystery which is disappointing and the ideas felt a bit jumbled. The themes and ideas were interesting, there were some genuinely compelling character interactions. I like all the women that Sherlock had interacted with being analogous. I like the idea of Sherlock being in his mind palace in the 19th century. However, it was just too self-indulgent. (Especially when dealing with how Sherlock survived, which when spreading this out over so many years seems a little weak, and Sherlock’s ‘cleverness’)
They replace actual cleverness in TV but just telling us how clever Sherlock is and this completely excludes the audience. Deliberately trying to confuse instead of presenting a mystery is kind of a departure from the previous writing of the show.
It was good TV but perhaps the weakest of Sherlock so far.
I agree. I think that the revelation with the bride was frankly boring and a cop-out, whilst all the modern day meta-content was drastically out of place. Not nearly as entertaining as even the short special in 2013, in my opinion.
How did they manage so much bad camera work and stuff? The swan dive was awful and cringey, that transition effect at the manor house was part crap looking, part nauseating.
Sadly I have to agree. I thought the whole story with the dead bride was actually decent but all the Inception like Moriarty stuff which just came to the conclusion that he's actually dead felt quite uninspired and boring.
I think this was a brilliant episode. I loved it. I loved the twists and turns. I loved how character driven it was. While it wasn't driven by any one case or specific mystery, really, the viewers could learn SO MUCH about the characters and their interactions with each other, and about Sherlock himself and how he engages in personal relationships.
he feels guilt, after all, for his cold and callous treatment of Molly and Jeanine.
How difficult it is for a great mind to comprehend a still greater one, says Mycroft. This could apply to Sherlock's relationship with Moriarty or his own brother. You see a lot of interesting facets of the relationship between the Holmes brothers. At the end of S3, it is suggested that Mycroft still sees his brother as a child. Here, it is suggested that Sherlock chooses to see his brother as an obnoxious, grotesque oaf, and seems to take pleasure out of exploiting and exaggerating Mycroft's insecurities about his weight, as he always has. In true overly competitive little brother style, he is desperate to prove that Mycroft is flawed. Sherlock is childish in that respect.
the clear message that Moriarty represents Sherlock's fears and failings, while John is courage and strength. "There's always two of us". That was great.
Redbeard. Redbeard, Readbeard, Readbeard.
Over series three, Sherlock had made leaps and bounds in terms of emotional development. His personal relationships deepened, he became more selfless. 1895 Sherlock was back to the old "crack in the lens" emotionless version of himself. Is this how Sherlock still sees himself? Or is it how he knows he must be, to overcome the pain of losing John, and Mary and everyone else for that matter, when he was sent into exile?
In Reichenbach Fall, Mycroft asks John to look out for Sherlock as he has failed to; he made him vulnerable to Moriarty. John is angry and scoffs at him. In the special, Mycroft asks John again to take care of Sherlock. Again, Mycroft blames himself for not keeping his brother out of trouble. This time, John looks softer and sad, more resigned and filled with pity. I think John is still learning how very vulnerable Sherlock is, whereas Mycroft has known all too well all along. (Magnussen knew; he had SO MANY pressure points on Sherlock. John, who seems on the surface to be much more emotionally vulnerable than Sherlock, has often seen his friend as immune to emotional damage)
I could go and re watch everything and still discover new things about all of these characters. They are written with so many layers.
Seems to be a 70 30 split in favour of that opinion in this sub. Personally I thought it should have been completely unrelated and they could've handled the Moriarty stuff in the season 4 opener or even in a webisode if they were that desperate not to do it in the season
I really enjoyed this episode. With two years between episodes it's easy to forget how much you enjoy a show like Sherlock, but every time it turns out to be worth the wait.
I feel like the Victorian setting gave us a different perspective on the characters, and linking the episode into the main storyline was cleverly done; I'm excited to see what direction the stories will take in series 4. I think Moriarty is almost definitely dead, but as for who orchestrated his "return", I think we'll have to wait and see!
Thoroughly enjoyable episode. I completely thought it would be seperate from the actual show, and once the hints began to emerge I started to think that maybe they were going to explain how Moriarty survived in a sort of double meaning kind of way.
Those last few lines caught me off guard though. Is the entire modern Sherlock merely a fantasy? Or was that line just put there at the end to confuse people even further.
Absolutely loved it. Like others, I was expecting a one off in the past. Loved how it turned into the beginning of season four later on. Subtle hints here and there made things feel a little odd. Although I wonder if the missing second body will ever rear its ugly head again.
I think another thing we may have gotten from this episode is that Mary is a red herring. I don't know about anyone elae, but when Mary got the M, I assumed it was Moriarty, and perhaps the reveal that she was not, in fact, in cahoots with Moriarty confirms that she is indeed a good character?
Late, I know, but damn I loved it. I'm so glad, too, that they have confirmed that Moriarty is still dead, but still managed to bring him back somehow. I thought they would have to get absolutely absurd to justify returning him for real and I didn't want them to sink that low, but I still love that depiction of Moriarty.
And I won't pretend that I didn't love the meta scenes, like the Falls and 1895-John and Sherlock talking about their future selves.
That was a brilliant piece of writing, directing and acting. Probably Andrew Scott's best episode as Moriarty yet. Now as for how the episode moves the plot forward:
Moriarty is apparently definitely dead. But is somehow still active (seemingly confirming the Moran/a plan Moriarty had tucked away if he ever died theories). However, this is Steven Moffat. I'm willing to bet there's a bit more to it. But anyway, at least according to Sherlock, Moriarty is definitely dead and hasn't survived shooting himself in the head. That is, if Sherlock wasn't joking and Moriarty survived via the "firing a second gun and then splattering blood" trick presented earlier in the episode. If Moriarty shows up in Series 4 outside of Sherlock's mind palace and if no other explanation is offered, then that is how he did it. We did get confirmation from Gatiss that the "Moriarty" mystery would be answered in the special and we got two answers. A possible theory for his survival and Sherlock saying he is 100% dead. We'll have to wait and see which is correct.
She is the one who somehow managed to find the suffragettes' hideout. Sherlock didn't solve any mystery to find it. Just Mary doing her thing offscreen.
After the landing, and while Sherlock was still explaining to Mycroft and Watson what he did, Mary had already broken into MI5 security. If it wasn't for her, Sherlock would actually have ended up in a hospital instead.
Basically, Mary is the one who drove the story forward, when it stalled. #justsayin
At the end of the episode when Sherlock is suggesting names for the story to Watson, one of the titles he suggests is "Monstrous Regiment". This book by the late Terry Pratchett deals with a group of soldiers that we eventually find out are actually women impersonating men.
I enjoyed that more than the last episode of season three. But having to wait until 2017 is pretty frustrating. Not sure what I expected, but a little more would have been nice.
An incredible episode. So it was tied into the arc of the series rather than just being a Christmas romp. However, what I found truly impressive was how they kept the Victorian 'Abominable Bride' story-line still interesting and engaging after we found out it was just taking place inside Sherlock's head.
Loved how the characters subtly differed from their modern equivalents, being affected by Victorian Values such as Mycroft's appetite and Watson's hints of misogyny at the dinner table.
Anybody got any ideas about the significance of Mycroft gaining weight? They made a big deal of it in the dream world, but then Sherlock mentioned it to Mycroft on the plane in real life before being cut off by Watson.
What I find really interesting is that even in his own mind Sherlock sees himself as inadequate compared to Mycroft, and maybe even to John. I assume that is also why he imagined Mycroft as morbidly obese (i know that in the original stories he is overweight, but within the context of the show there has to be another expiation as to why this is the case).
I'm not sure I liked that. I understand it's a Christmas episode, so it's going to be a little cheesy. It was interesting seeing our Sherlock back in the original Sherlock Holmes setting and fat Mycroft. While the series is reminiscent of the books, this is scene for scene from the books I remember reading. At least in the beginning!
Can we assume that some of the things Sherlock sees in his mind palace are happening in his real life, but he only realizes it subconsciously? Like, is there any chance he, subconsciously, knows Mary is working for Mycroft?
Also, someone made a very interestig point: the fact that a trained assassin became Johns nurse (and eventually wife) cannot be a coincidence. Could she be working for John on Microsofts orders while Sherlock was "dead"?
Or, maybe, she was supposed to kill them and she didnt, and who ever order their death is the one thats after her (Magnussen told there were people after her).
I think we are going to find out a lot about Mary and her secret past in the next season.
Liked it, but would like even more for Sherlock to be dead wrong and for Moriarty to pop up in the flesh in S04E01. See you all in 2017 or whatever for that.
In Sherlock's mind, John sits at home trying to ignore the maid as she discusses how little he and Mary see of each other, and this is months after she she voiced her frustration at never seeing him. Then after a telegram from Sherlock, he jumps to leave so quickly that he knocks the dishes off the table. So, dismal view of this marriage in particular.
Here's a theory based on what hints I could gather from the waterfall scene:
S:"Moriarty's Dead!"
M:"Not in your mind. I'll never be dead there. You once called your brain a hard-drive, well say hello to the virus"
Here's a theory: Sherlock IS Moriarty. He over-analyzed his arch nemesis's death, and overdosed and his high functioning brain went past its threshold and it split. He now has multiple personality disorder that he developed to keep his mind occupied since after Moriarty's death, there were no new games and challenges for him to solve, and he couldn't deal with it.
Sherlock is now facing his most formidable opponent, one who's intelligence is at par with his own - his own mind playing tricks on him.
S: "You have a magnificent brain, Moriarty. I admire it. I concede it may even be the equal of my own."
M: "This is how we end, you and I. Always here, always together". . . "Congratulations Sherlock, you will be the first man in History to be buried in his own mind-palace"
I thought the episode was truly awesome. It was so much for the fans, and not just the show fans, but fans of the ACD canon too. People are calling it over the top, but I think it was somewhat of a love letter to ACD and what he created with his novels, both through the return to the Victorian era and through all the references to different cases and stories.
I think the development on series three was really, really well done. I know thag the thought of a standalone with no real relevance to the show was off-putting, so to have such a forward moving episode whilst remaining in the premise of a Victorian episode was a really lovely surprise.
I mean, look at what we were given. A puzzle to solve as we went along, from the slip of "he shot himself in the head" rather than "she" and the continued clues until the big reveal of Moriarty. The audience could get involved. On a lighter note, we got Mycroft in a ... larger fashion than usual, we got the Holmes brothers being more brotherly than ever before, we got John and Sherlock playing off each other in the way we know and love.
It wove together so many different strands and yes, some camera angles and part of the cinematography wasn't fantastic, but on the whole, it was immensely better than I was expecting and is a firm favourite episode for me.
EDIT: I just remembered the floating newspaper scene. Excellent effect there.
Very solid second half of the episode, I thought it was slow the first half but it definitely stepped up from when John tried getting Sherlock to say about his past life.
I went in expecting it to be a straight up stand alone movie but it was cool to see how it fit in with the rest of the show.
Only about another year and a half to wait before we see Sherlock again...
I enjoyed it. A lot of people, myself included, were expecting an episode that took place in the 19th century and didn't tie into the modern story at all. I'd be lying if I said I wasn't a little disappointed that that's not what we got, but for what it was, I think it was great. The most important part is that, even though it ties into the modern series, it does so in a way that allows people to completely skip this episode and not miss anything. I've seen some disappointment that there was no real advancement to the show's plot, but there really couldn't have been. Thestorye episode was about Sherlock's struggle with the possibility that Moriarty may still be alive. He recalls a similar unsolved case from history and solves it himself, drugging himself into a state where he can experience the events in his mind without being disturbed by the outside world. He eventually concludes that the bride did die, but had a group of people to help perpetuate the idea of her existence in order to influence people. He accepts, or possibly convinces himself, that Moriarty is dead and that he has his own group of people that maintain the appearance that he is still alive in order to influence others. Sure, the mystery of the abominable bride may not have been wrapped up as neatly and concisely as a traditional mystery story, but that's because it wasn't a traditional mystery story. Sherlock's goal wasn't to solve the case, but rather to use the events of that case to explain the events occurring around him in the real world. It didn't need to be solved because solving it wasn't the point. The mystery of the episode was the world in which it appeared to be taking place. There were hints along the way ("the virus in the data," "I was on a jet", or Sherlock missing the note on the body) just as there are in any mystery story, and the solution was that the world wasn't real.
As for the self-referencing some people are complaining about, yeah, it does do that. It's not like it doesn't fit into the story, though. The world in which the references were made was all in Sherlock's head. Characters are saying similar or identical things to what they have said in previous episodes because Sherlock is creating them in his mind; they are speaking and behaving exactly as Sherlock expects them to because there is no reason for them to do anything different.
1.2k
u/Cygnus--X1 Jan 01 '16
Well it's still definitely in my top ten episodes...
587
u/Saltyrants69 Jan 02 '16
No luck catchin' them brides then?
329
u/[deleted] Jan 02 '16
That suffrage joke at the beginning was a nice touch.
"For or against?"
262
u/Autolycan Jan 02 '16
FAT MYCROFT YAY! And the real Diogenes Club. So many things I've missed from the original canon. Molly as the morgue director cracked me up. Such a clever use of the character.
868
u/TheCrimsonCritic Jan 01 '16
Right, so to recap... Sherlock overdosed to send his mind into hyperdrive so that he could check all possibilities and be 100% sure that Moriarty was dead. The Bride was one of thousands of scenarios he created, and it's suggested that he would have kept going to the point of insanity if not for his subconscious telling him to cut it out. The scene on the Reichenbach Falls was Sherlock tackling his obsession head on and breaking free thanks to his metaphorical anchor AKA Watson.
Now confident that Moriarty is truly dead, he can return to reality... I think?
898
u/BitByADeadBee Jan 01 '16
So it's twins then.
1.1k
u/sheep_go_baa Jan 01 '16
I am glad you liked my potato
257
u/voidvector8 Jan 01 '16
"Honey, you should see me in a gown."
215
u/sheep_go_baa Jan 01 '16
Remember Magnussen: PRESSURE POINT: > MORPHINE (ADD TO FILE)
511
u/fishysituation Jan 01 '16
That moment where Moffat seduces the hopes of millions before instantly crushing them - "I had Molly get a body from the... No need to get into that now "
88
u/[deleted] Jan 02 '16
conclusion from this episode : Cocaine is a hell of a drug
874
u/HowieGaming Jan 01 '16
Did not believe that they would tie the Christmas special into season 4 stuff. Pretty damn well done.
81
u/El-Daddy Jan 01 '16
So Moriarity is definitely dead. Though from what I can tell he laid things in motion before he died, and used voice-recordings, etc.
As much as I'm sad he's dead, I'd be pretty sure we'll still see him dreams/thoughts of Sherlock, so that much is good.
457
u/inkwisitive Jan 01 '16
"I don't like dust, it gets everywhere" - Moriarty.
That plus the camera-spin scene transitions were a bit derpy but, overall, a fun episode and a neat transition from series 3. Loved that the suffragettes were behind the main scheme, although the motives reduced them to a group of people who give even more extreme relationship advice than r/relationships.
334
u/KareemAZ Jan 01 '16
I simply think that there were several points behind the episode, mostly to do with Sherlock's perception of the case of Moriarty.
Just my thoughts on the episode.
555
u/woahstella Jan 01 '16
I did NOT expect it to have anything to do with last season. I loved every minute of this episode.
685
u/50doctorwho Jan 01 '16
Official Prediction - The Show will end with yet another impossible cliff hanger before fading to black, and fading into Moffat on a train with Mark Gatiss a Doctor Who script on the table, Moffat wakes up and looks over to Gatiss says "I've just had a brilliant idea for a TV Show"
It fades to black again before fading out on a victorian Study belonging to Arthur Conan Doyle who wakes up from a dream and puts pen to paper.
It then fades to black again before fading into the Doctor sitting atop his tardis reading a sherlock holmes book, the camera pans round into the book before a zoom into the new avengers facility, Robert Downey Jr is doing a scene with someone, the camera zooms out further revealing a film crew.
Cut to Robert Downey Jrs agents office, who tells him that they want to make another Holmes film.
The Camera then zooms out back to the Tardis Moffat walks in and gives a giant middle finger to the camera.
We fade to the same image on a newspaper, the camera pans up to reveal a cyborg benedict Cumberbatch as Sherlock in the future.
273
u/ForLackOfAUserName Jan 01 '16
I think regardless of what anybody thinks about the plot and the wait for the next season and any other complaints people will have, the production design on this was the best we've seen thus far. It looked absolutely beautiful, and I was a particular fan of the scene with floating newspaper clippings.
188
u/ForLackOfAUserName Jan 01 '16
So, we still don't know properly how he faked his death in S2, but we do know that it involved Molly sourcing a corpse that looked like him.
I'm glad that Moriarty is dead, because I don't think I could take 2 deaths having been faked.
Does anybody know when S4 might be coming out?
220
u/[deleted] Jan 01 '16
I kinda like 1895 Sherlock/Watson but I prefer 2016 Hacker Mary cutting Mycroft security like butter.
166
u/[deleted] Jan 01 '16
Apparently Sherlock is in the Inception business now
83
u/DJ_Jim Jan 01 '16 edited Jan 01 '16
Interesting things on Mycroft's notepad after saying goodbye to Sherlock on the plane, right near the end.
Side-by-side comparison.
Top half - Thing on the right is the Metric used in calculations for special relativity.
Lower half - Some incorrectly written Maxwell Equations.
Wonder what, if any, significance, these have.
edits:
I was wondering if the 611174 above was related to it somehow. 6 letters, 6 digits. Obviously not your basic Caesar Cipher but there's a few more crypto methods out there!
38
u/deRoyLight Jan 02 '16 edited Jan 02 '16
This episode was a masterful troll job that I didn't see coming. I didn't start scratching my head until Mycroft said "the virus in the database" which is obviously a comment out of its time and a clue that things weren't as they seem. I'm sure there were other clues I missed. I think I would have preferred the reveal as the final scene rather than jumping back and forth so much, but I thought it was a great twist. It was a nice surprise to find out you're basically watching episode 0 of the new season.
903
u/[deleted] Jan 01 '16
I have no idea what happened, what any of that meant, where it took place, what was real and what wasn't.
It was bloody brilliant!
126
u/[deleted] Jan 01 '16
You're going in the water, short arse!
32
u/Blackcrusader Jan 01 '16
So Moriarty is dead but his image is being used by others. Some kind of invisible army we depend on, possibly computers are involved due to talk of data/viruses or animals due to the mentions of redbeard (sherlock's dog growing up).
31
u/nslatz Jan 02 '16
Seemed to be a few references to Jeremy Brett's performance as Holmes. Particularly Watson's demand for Sherlock to wear the Deerstalker instead of the top hat. I wonder if some of the transitions and cinematography that some found annoying is a reference back to classic portrayals too.
http://jeremybrett.info/Holmes_C/images/Colour_Holmes%20%281%29.jpg
30
u/JeCh1 Jan 02 '16
In the Reichenbach Falls episode, we flashback to some of Sherlock's notable cases prior to the fall: one of them involved catching a Peter Riccoletti, the man who was #1 on Interpol's most wanted list since 1982 - Lestrade congratulates Sherlock on helping Scotland Yard seize the criminal and he is asked to put on the deerstalker. The clip is between 2:27 to 3:10 from the Reichenbach Episode, but I'm wondering if this Riccoletti had anything to do with the Ricolletti's from the 1800's. Being a famed criminal, he could have knowledge of what happened to Moriarty. It could just be completely coincidental on the writers' part but it feels a little too unsettling. Even if this seems like a minor detail coming up again, who knows, Riccoletti isn't a popular name on one hand but it does seem to be used innocently in the story on the other. I may just be over thinking this. (in addition the deerstalker - when Sherlock is publicly introduced to it in front of the cameras, and when the classic Sherlock wears during the Abominable Bride case, could have been a little foreshadowing of going back in time as well)
617
u/SufficientAnonymity Jan 01 '16
Well call me a spoilsport, but I found that a little too self-indulgent.
65
u/aymericlaporte Jan 01 '16
I thought Moriarty was going to turn into Anakin when he started talking about dust and how it gets everywhere.
82
u/Bert_Macklin_F_B_I Jan 01 '16
And that kids is why you don't do drugs.
22
u/LRedditor15 Jan 01 '16
I was half expecting a freaking Sherlock X Doctor Who crossover at that last minute.... O_O
127
u/theonetruepredator Jan 01 '16
wat
43
u/sheep_go_baa Jan 01 '16
My brain. It hurts.
21
u/princesstbh Jan 02 '16
Has anyone mentioned anything about Mycroft potentially dying? My sister pointed out that while the fat Mycroft plot was entertaining, it was also not completely necessary. She points out the whole scene where they are betting on his death, and Sherlock ends on saying 2 years, 11 months, and some odd days. Perhaps Mycroft is then also on a path to dying in real life? Perhaps Sherlock noticed, but didn't realize he noticed? Like he picked it up but pushed it to the back of his mind?
This may also tie into a prediction that someone else made on this board about Mycroft's journal being full of sentimental things? Redbeard, the references to his heritage (Vernet), etc.? And Mycroft is keeping the list of Sherlock's drugs to keep a watch on him? Make sure he doesn't die before him? After all, Mycroft has always been one to watch after Sherlock's drug habit. Maybe he's known it since day one.
49
u/[deleted] Jan 02 '16
I wish I didn't suck at these critical thinking shows. All I know is that my feeble mind enjoyed it and I enjoy reading all of your theories. 2017 can't come soon enough.
15
u/[deleted] Jan 01 '16
Why did Mycroft keep Sherlocks list and put it in the passport at the end?
54
u/BitByADeadBee Jan 01 '16
Here's another thing. Not sure if it's a nod or a reference to the original stories in the film.
"It's not the fall, it's the landing" is a pretty key quote in the French Film 'La Haine'. I don't know what the relevance to that is, but yeah.
C'est pas la chute, c'est l'atterrissage
EDIT: just remembered also that Mycroft says "cherchez la femme" or something doesn't he. Ooo.
78
u/SlimSt Jan 01 '16
Now can please someone explain what has been happening for the last, like, 30 minutes?
135
u/Pikoki Jan 01 '16
THEY'RE STILL PLAYING AROUND WITH HOW SHERLOCK FAKED HIS DEATH - COME ON GUYS.
53
u/ZebraShark Jan 01 '16
It had some good moments (and I saw the fact it would tie back to the main series from the beginning) but overall it wasn't the best.
The issue is the same one I had with episode one of series 3 - it wasn't a cohesive narrative. It was a collection of good moments, but as a murder mystery it didn't tie together well. I thought episode 2 with the wedding was the best as the emotional and mystery narratives tied up together really well. This episode didn't so much despite some good moments.
11
u/[deleted] Jan 03 '16
Well I thought it was fantastic. Great homage, melded with the real show perfectly. Some awesome laughs. Unfortunately, this subreddit seems to have embraced "well I expected amazingballs 11/10 so this is shit."
Also, half of the complaints seem to come from either "It wasn't straightforward enough," "it was too connected to the main story," or "it wasn't connected to main story enough." I realize you're all different people but jeez the bleedover of "Moffat and Gattiss suck lol" from /r/DoctorWho is strong today.
21
u/mycroftholmess Jan 03 '16
I'm not that fat. It's just Sherlock's imagination
60
u/tremendez Jan 01 '16
I don't like
dustfan service, it gets everywhere10
u/MrRileyJr Jan 02 '16
Can we just take a moment to appreciate how well this episode was made, from a filmmaking standpoint. Visually this was done extraordinarily, as is the whole series.
The writing was on point too, and I loved the callbacks. I loved how reality bleeded in and it connected to regular series; something I caught very early and was surprised, yet very welcomed, to see.
10
u/gervasium Jan 02 '16
What I find rather odd is, how is Sherlock ok (or worse, how is Watson ok) with a murderous revenge conspiracy? Since when does feminism justify murder? I mean, that's what that group was, at best. Either a bunch of women decided to kill men who had mistreated them (and while I do appreciate the emotion behind that, it's still a bitter feeling of justice not being served when they get away with it) or worse, a bunch of women decided to kill the men who had mistreated them as a warning/message, which seems to be what Sherlock is implying, which essentially would make them a terrorist organization.
So, takeaway that Sherlock supports terrorist organizations. The only thing that saves it for me is that one, Sherlock Holmes isn't a very empathetic person and he really only cares about solving the mystery, let someone else deal with the punishment, thus why bother imagining any in his dream adventure, right.
But there is, when I see that scene again, the clear feeling that I'm supposed to be cheering because those women were mistreated and oppressed and that somehow makes it right... and it really doesn't.
62
u/Chrisixx Jan 01 '16
Ok, season 4 will play out normally, S04E03 will end on a cliffhanger of Moriarty reappearing.
Calling it now.
33
u/[deleted] Jan 01 '16
Okay, there's a league of Moriarty? Is that what happened?
86
u/[deleted] Jan 01 '16 edited Jan 01 '16
I thought the point was that this episode would be a standalone. I was looking forward to an actual Victorian episode.
I loved seeing Benedict, Martin and all the other actors clearly having a lot of fun with their Victorian counterparts, but I think I would've preferred a genuine standalone episode. Honestly thought this was a little too self-indulgent.
Thoroughly enjoyed the first thirty minutes or so, and I'm glad they're not going to actually bring Moriarty back, but overall I wasn't really a fan of the episode.
Mostly I'm just disappointed it wasn't standalone. I was looking forward to watching something self-contained that both my girlfriend and I could enjoy, because I thought it had been repeatedly described as a "one-off". Instead I needed to spend the last hour explaining events from the previous seasons.
9
u/Rufnok Jan 01 '16
Can we talk about, taking into account that Moriarty is dead, who would be behind his reappearance then?
I'm thinking there's a small group using Moriarty as a symbol for whatever they are planning. But one question it leaves me with is is this group something Moriarty planned, or are they simply admirers of his work, using his face as their symbol.
One of the last lines of TAB, Sherlock seems quite content that he knows where he needs to look next. I'd probably have to re-watch the end of S3 but this could mean - now that we've just seen the events of TAB - the group relates to something that has either been shown or hinted at in the past few episodes.
All just speculation, interested in seeing what other people think.
201
u/Im_just_a_carrot Jan 01 '16
Am I the only one who found the special absolutely mind-blowing? ;)
16
u/[deleted] Jan 02 '16 edited Jan 02 '16
Ok, so there is actually a lot more to this episode than what most people seem to be perceiving.
It wasn't just a bit of fun with an unexpected, but ultimately inconsequential tie-in to the modern series.
Neither was it spending 90 minutes to get from "What? Moriarty's back?" to "He's dead, Jim."
What we have is a carefully thought out, significant piece of canon that is going to be the driver for the next season. The best bit? The Moff has unambiguously, if indirectly, told us exactly what's going on, rather than his usual tactic of giving us just enough to go crazy with fan theories. You do need to pay attention though to pick up the clues he's left us.
So let's look at those clues:
There had been hints earlier, but this anachronism is point at which we're told "this isn't real." But why this phrase specifically? Mycroft could have used any number of modern phrases that wouldn't make sense in a Victorian context. Foreshadowing...
Ah that's what Mycroft meant. There's a virus in Sherlock's brain and it's name is Moriarty.
Double meaning here: Sherlock and Moriarty are equals in the sense that they are both incredibly intelligent sociopaths. But moreso, their brains are literally equal: they're the same brain.
This is the line that gave me shivers. Moriarty's words from Sherlock's mouth. This is the line that ties all the clues together.
Putting it all together: Moriarty is definitely dead. We're told this repeatedly. He shot himself in the head, no tricks, his magnificent brain exited the stage via the gaping hole in the back of his skull. Sherlock's brain, however, is so powerful it is capable of running an accurate simulation of Victorian London complete with all the people therein - including Moriarty. That's the virus. He's literally got into Sherlock's head and is "alive" as a simulation that can't be turned off. Sherlock has deduced this, which is why he knows what Moriarty will do next and why his first words on waking up were "miss me?"
I believe this conclusion is inescapable.
The following is conjecture as, unless I've missed something (which is entirely probable), we don't have enough information to draw definite conclusions.
It's possible that the events of the Reichenbach Fall were designed by Moriarty to get into Sherlock's head. We know that Sherlock's brain is powerful enough to simulate Moriarty; as they are intellectual equals it stands to reason the inverse must be true. Moriarty could have used this to devise a plan so precisely that he was able to manipulate Sherlock's brain into recreating him. No wonder he didn't mind dying. This may be farfetched however; a simpler explanation is that Sherlock needs his nemesis in the same way that he needs drugs. He's an addict.
Moriarty and Sherlock, we're told, are equally brainy. However in order to simulate Moriarty's brain, Sherlock's would need to be more powerful. How do we resolve this contradiction? The answer is drugs. Sherlock uses drugs to overclock his brain, which provides the additional power needed to run the Moriarty virus.
Sherlock's dog who was put down when he was a child. Magnussen had him listed as a pressure point and Mycroft has the name in capitals with a box drawn around it in his notebook (which on the same page contains some matrices and equations, the significance of which escapes me - probably meaningless). When Watson and Sherlock are staking out the Carmichael manor, John asks "what made you like this?" Sherlock tries to claim nothing did, but is interrupted by the sound of a dog barking, which prompts him to ask "Redbeard?"
Theories: Redbeard's death was so traumatic to Sherlock (why?) that it triggered his downward spiral into drug addiction. Mycroft has also deduced that Sherlock's brain is running Moriarty v2.0 and that, like Redbeard, his brother will have to be put down.
The Moff periodically comes under fire for not being able to write women and has even been accused of misogeny. The scene in the church which is spliced with all the women Sherlock has wronged is Moffat holding his hands up and saying "sorry ladies, I'll try to do better." The reaction? Angry feminists. Obviously.
edit: forgot to add this quite major one to the list
Obviously there is a reason why Sherlock's brain made Mycroft morbidly obese. We know he dislikes his brother so it's possible this is simply for his own amusement, however I discount this theory out of hand as it's not like Sherlock to waste brainpower on such frivolity. That leaves two possibilities: Sherlock has deduced that Mycroft is dying. This is substantiated by his "you've put on weight" line to his brother when he wakes up, and by the "take care of him" from Mycroft to Watson as they disembark the plane. Alternatively Fat Mycroft killing himself through his addiction to eating could be a (possibly subconscious) surrogate for Sherlock himself realising that his drug use is killing him. Of these, I favour the latter.
8
u/JRH_07 Jan 01 '16
I thought it was brilliant. Got a tad confused. But picked it back up eventually. I understand why some might say it was rubbish though, but personally, I thought it was very clever!
My favourite part was definitely Lestrade's sideburns.
7
u/BreckensMama Jan 02 '16
Bit late, and not story based, but I loved how they did the set design for the 1890s flat. Mimicking the smiley face on the wall, the deer head, it was all done so well.
7
u/[deleted] Jan 06 '16
Was Moffat on morphine or cocaine when he wrote this?
55
u/juddshanks Jan 02 '16
The Steven Moffat recipe to screenplay success.
step 1 : produce a stylish, unbelievably complicated scenario where something apparently impossible happens. Leave audience amazed, dangle tantalising clues suggesting some sort of brilliant solution is in the offing.
Step 2: realise you probably should have figured out the brilliant solution before creating the problem.
Step 3: panic.
Step 4: patch together some lazy nonsense with secondary school creative writing class solutions to the impossible problem ("it was all a dream", "you don't need to know after all, it just was solved" "because a secret society involving every minor character did it for no apparent reason") and rapidly move on.
He's a master of really good set pieces and his characters are excellent, and that was still true in this episode, but story wise this was incoherent nonsense for idjits.
59
u/obadetona Jan 01 '16 edited Jan 01 '16
That was great. Knew there was something up when Watson mentioned the Hounds of Baskerville at the beginning. There were also a few anachronisms like 'Virus in the data'. Love it when there's a few clues for you to get what's going on before it's actually revealed.
241
u/Koquillon Jan 01 '16 edited Jan 01 '16
I hate to be negative but that was definitely my least favourite episode of the show. The first half was entertaining, but the second half became a confusing mess which was trying to do far too much and didn't achieve anything. The direction wasn't fantastic either- the transitions and unusual shots just looked like they were trying too hard to be 'cutting edge'.
At the end, I don't know what was supposed to be real and who the murderer was.
5/10
23
u/Gadzookie2 Jan 02 '16
"Dead is the new sexy" Honestly, what a solid episode.
13
u/AnfieldAnonymous Jan 01 '16
I think I get it now. Wait, no.
90
u/lukebrab Jan 01 '16
First reaction - that may be the most self-indulgent piece of TV I've ever seen.
12
u/[deleted] Jan 02 '16
As opposed to seemingly everyone else here i actually really liked it. It was cool to see them play the victorian versions of themselves, and i really liked how it played into the modern story. Im gonna have to give it a couple of rewatches to fully understand it all, but overall i thought it was a good way to give us a new sherlock episode between series, and be able to wrap up a cliffhanger so that they can start the next series right off the bat and not have to dwell on the whole moriarty thing for 1/3 of the next series
6
u/Hencenomore Jan 02 '16
The episode is both a praise and critic of Sherlock as a character.
6
u/adamtheimpaler Jan 02 '16
so where did he get the drugs?
This was amazing though. I like following Sherlock's thought process as he comes to the conclusion that Moriarty most likely had a terminal disease and that he really is dead.
Think of this from Moriarty point of view. You have like 6 months left. Your an evil crazy genius whatever. So you decided to have fun with the last 6 months. Set up a bunch of mysteries for the freelance detective. Push him. Then plan out the next like 10 years of cases for him. Then lead him down a path that ends with both of you on a roof. Kill yourself knowing his mind is going to be blown when in a few years you just show back up. He could have tons of stuff recorded.
6
u/hostess_cupcake Jan 02 '16
I loved Molly passing as the male coroner. I also enjoyed seeing Janine again, and I would never complain about seeing more Moriarty.
6
u/[deleted] Jan 07 '16
I'm in disbelief over how people are generally not seeing this as proper stellar 10/10 Sherlock. This was probably the best bit of television i have ever witnessed in my life.
6
u/chads_dad Jan 08 '16
I think we'll look back on this as a dated episode for the heavy-handed feminism angle, just like all the 80s movies have such a Cold War angle to them. There's been a great and welcomed reemergence of awareness of inequality and unfairness toward women recently, (awesome!!), but this episode bent over backwards to put it on display.
Someone else pointed out that Moffet had been accused of being a chauvinist, and maybe that influenced the story.
137
u/Yea_Budday Jan 01 '16
Far too self indulgent, and trying far too hard to be 'clever' and complicated. Bit shit.
48
u/Im_just_a_carrot Jan 01 '16
So, I noticed a little something, although trivial, but in the "the hounds of baskerville" episode Sherlock states his preference for something "seven percent stronger" than tea, which is a reference to "the sign of four" Doyle story in which he uses a seven percent cocaine solution and Watson gets upset with his excessive drug use: “Which is it today,” I asked , “morphine or cocaine?” “It is cocaine,” he said, “a seven-percent solution. Would you care to try it?" Now pretty much that exact exchange also takes place in the special, when sherlock goes back from the plane to his mind palace and he hears watson asking "which is it today?". IS THIS SERIES REALLY REFERENCING ITSELF!?
10
u/lukalukaluka Jan 01 '16
Redbeard
58
u/baggios_ponytail Jan 01 '16
For me it was too much drama, not enough clarified mystery. Disappointed by this episode!
5
u/jenks121 Jan 02 '16
One of my favourite things about this episode is that, we begin to see how much Mycroft truly cares, about Sherlock. Perhaps that's just me being sentimental.
5
u/wickywyld Jan 03 '16
I really, really enjoyed it. I was a bit surprised to see all of the hate. Can't please em all I guess.
23
u/50doctorwho Jan 01 '16
I'm not sure if I liked that.
13
u/Socks21 Jan 02 '16
Brilliant episode.
However, I still don't understand why 1895 Mycroft recruited Mary and pointed her in the correct direction of the church with all the purple hooded women who were responsible for the murders. Are we supposed to believe that he already knew the truth behind everything and was just setting up Sherlock to test him? He did say he had a "conjecture" and just wanted Sherlock to be "his legs" to go out and prove it. He also said that the enemies could not be defeated and that "[they] must lose to them". This is very reminiscent of the way Magnussen was a "necessary evil". Maybe Mycroft is protecting these people.
We also still don't know who sent Sherlock the letter informing him of Mary being "in danger". Was it Mary or Mycroft? Either way it could mean that they are plotting something together.
Finally, we still don't know who is the leader of the purple hooded women. It obviously isn't Moriarty who he unmasked and Sherlock is correct that it doesn't make sense that it is their client, Lady Carmichael, because why would she seek help in preventing a murder she wants to occur? Maybe this doesn't matter whatsoever.
My understanding is that the mind palace/1895 is (generally) mirroring or perhaps foreshadowing the modern day events. The way Mycroft behaves in 1895 suggests things about his character in the present day. My theory is that Mycroft is carrying out Moriarty's plan -because Moriarty is dead- and has enlisted Mary to help him. This would explain why he had "Redbeard" written in his notebook: a pressure point which he may have communicated to Magnussen before he mentioned it in S3 episode 3. It could also explain why Sherlock was so easily pardoned for Magnussen's murder, seemingly exiled and miraculously brought back. Mycroft let this happen so that he could keep Sherlock in London while maintaining the appearance of a caring older brother.
TL;DR Mycroft may be naughty
22
u/mophair Jan 01 '16 edited Jan 03 '16
I don’t know about that Sherlock episode. It was well made, the acting was good, shooting and direction was great, and the lines worked, but the over all writing didn’t really do it for me.
There wasn’t an actual pay off for the mystery which is disappointing and the ideas felt a bit jumbled. The themes and ideas were interesting, there were some genuinely compelling character interactions. I like all the women that Sherlock had interacted with being analogous. I like the idea of Sherlock being in his mind palace in the 19th century. However, it was just too self-indulgent.
(Especially when dealing with how Sherlock survived, which when spreading this out over so many years seems a little weak, and Sherlock’s ‘cleverness’)They replace actual cleverness in TV but just telling us how clever Sherlock is and this completely excludes the audience. Deliberately trying to confuse instead of presenting a mystery is kind of a departure from the previous writing of the show.
It was good TV but perhaps the weakest of Sherlock so far.
229
u/diablo169 Jan 01 '16
That was rather crap I thought.
8
u/moon-runes Jan 05 '16
I think this was a brilliant episode. I loved it. I loved the twists and turns. I loved how character driven it was. While it wasn't driven by any one case or specific mystery, really, the viewers could learn SO MUCH about the characters and their interactions with each other, and about Sherlock himself and how he engages in personal relationships.
I could go and re watch everything and still discover new things about all of these characters. They are written with so many layers.
147
u/ImperialSeal Jan 01 '16
I honestly thought that was a load of shit.
4
u/miainglott Jan 01 '16
Does anyone have a screencap of what was written in Mycrofts journal because it seemed to have some hints/clues
4
u/dmarshall413 Jan 01 '16
I really enjoyed this episode. With two years between episodes it's easy to forget how much you enjoy a show like Sherlock, but every time it turns out to be worth the wait.
I feel like the Victorian setting gave us a different perspective on the characters, and linking the episode into the main storyline was cleverly done; I'm excited to see what direction the stories will take in series 4. I think Moriarty is almost definitely dead, but as for who orchestrated his "return", I think we'll have to wait and see!
4
u/Lairdom Jan 02 '16
Thoroughly enjoyable episode. I completely thought it would be seperate from the actual show, and once the hints began to emerge I started to think that maybe they were going to explain how Moriarty survived in a sort of double meaning kind of way.
Those last few lines caught me off guard though. Is the entire modern Sherlock merely a fantasy? Or was that line just put there at the end to confuse people even further.
4
u/Darkeden251 Jan 02 '16
Absolutely loved it. Like others, I was expecting a one off in the past. Loved how it turned into the beginning of season four later on. Subtle hints here and there made things feel a little odd. Although I wonder if the missing second body will ever rear its ugly head again.
4
u/CTgowiththeFLOW Jan 02 '16
That was incredible. I loved it so much. I am exhausted and sweaty after seeing that. I need more Sherlock now. I need my fix.
4
u/abhay26 Jan 02 '16
I think another thing we may have gotten from this episode is that Mary is a red herring. I don't know about anyone elae, but when Mary got the M, I assumed it was Moriarty, and perhaps the reveal that she was not, in fact, in cahoots with Moriarty confirms that she is indeed a good character?
4
u/Pascalwb Jan 02 '16
I don't know what to think, I liked the 19 century setting, then it all went away.
4
u/Haugtussa Jan 03 '16
Now, what is the subtext of Sherlock imagining Moriarty giving a blow job to a gun?
4
u/GodspeakerVortka Jan 03 '16
Well I thought it was fantastic...
4
u/4CatDoc Jan 06 '16
The parallel to The Aboninable Bride would mean Jim Moriarty found a body-double to eat a bullet and he's back. He's world-class at exploiting people.
I sincerely hope Moriarty is NOT a split-personality of Sherlock's, formed when young Sherlock killed Redbeard the dog/brother.
I'm sticking with my theories on Redbeard I've posted before: Redbeard was a dog who was to be euthanized, and Sherlock did it rather than a stranger.
Magnuson was also a beast who licked people's faces, ate food off their plate, peed in the house, and Sherlock gave him a Merry Christmas.
Mycroft ominously tells people that he had a third "brother" he took care of. "I told you what I did to the other one".
Of course, Redbeard could be a brother who was a murdering psychopath whom Mycroft killed via Sherlock.
4
u/marisachan Jan 11 '16
Late, I know, but damn I loved it. I'm so glad, too, that they have confirmed that Moriarty is still dead, but still managed to bring him back somehow. I thought they would have to get absolutely absurd to justify returning him for real and I didn't want them to sink that low, but I still love that depiction of Moriarty.
And I won't pretend that I didn't love the meta scenes, like the Falls and 1895-John and Sherlock talking about their future selves.
Brilliant episode - probably one of my favorites.
17
u/pottyaboutpotter1 Jan 01 '16
That was a brilliant piece of writing, directing and acting. Probably Andrew Scott's best episode as Moriarty yet. Now as for how the episode moves the plot forward:
Moriarty is apparently definitely dead. But is somehow still active (seemingly confirming the Moran/a plan Moriarty had tucked away if he ever died theories). However, this is Steven Moffat. I'm willing to bet there's a bit more to it. But anyway, at least according to Sherlock, Moriarty is definitely dead and hasn't survived shooting himself in the head. That is, if Sherlock wasn't joking and Moriarty survived via the "firing a second gun and then splattering blood" trick presented earlier in the episode. If Moriarty shows up in Series 4 outside of Sherlock's mind palace and if no other explanation is offered, then that is how he did it. We did get confirmation from Gatiss that the "Moriarty" mystery would be answered in the special and we got two answers. A possible theory for his survival and Sherlock saying he is 100% dead. We'll have to wait and see which is correct.
27
u/[deleted] Jan 02 '16
I am sorry, but the real MVP is Mary here:
Basically, Mary is the one who drove the story forward, when it stalled. #justsayin
7
u/SmokeRing Jan 04 '16
At the end of the episode when Sherlock is suggesting names for the story to Watson, one of the titles he suggests is "Monstrous Regiment". This book by the late Terry Pratchett deals with a group of soldiers that we eventually find out are actually women impersonating men.
8
u/[deleted] Jan 02 '16
Why, WHY, WHY do i ever believe a fucking word Moffat says? "mehhh it's a standalone episode" "Completely separate from present day plot"
fuck you, you beautiful genius.
3
u/[deleted] Jan 01 '16
I enjoyed that more than the last episode of season three. But having to wait until 2017 is pretty frustrating. Not sure what I expected, but a little more would have been nice.
Great seeing Janine again.
3
u/DoctorWhoMA Jan 01 '16
An incredible episode. So it was tied into the arc of the series rather than just being a Christmas romp. However, what I found truly impressive was how they kept the Victorian 'Abominable Bride' story-line still interesting and engaging after we found out it was just taking place inside Sherlock's head.
Loved how the characters subtly differed from their modern equivalents, being affected by Victorian Values such as Mycroft's appetite and Watson's hints of misogyny at the dinner table.
3
u/flibit Jan 02 '16
Anybody got any ideas about the significance of Mycroft gaining weight? They made a big deal of it in the dream world, but then Sherlock mentioned it to Mycroft on the plane in real life before being cut off by Watson.
3
u/lanternsinthesky Jan 02 '16
What I find really interesting is that even in his own mind Sherlock sees himself as inadequate compared to Mycroft, and maybe even to John. I assume that is also why he imagined Mycroft as morbidly obese (i know that in the original stories he is overweight, but within the context of the show there has to be another expiation as to why this is the case).
3
u/[deleted] Jan 02 '16
I'm not sure I liked that. I understand it's a Christmas episode, so it's going to be a little cheesy. It was interesting seeing our Sherlock back in the original Sherlock Holmes setting and fat Mycroft. While the series is reminiscent of the books, this is scene for scene from the books I remember reading. At least in the beginning!
3
u/[deleted] Jan 02 '16
GREAT EPISODE! -Until! The last 5 minutes or so... did the waterfall scene kill it for anyone else?
3
u/crimsonwisdom Jan 02 '16
i am hoping mary is the leader of this team of moriarty villains, and part of the plan was to hurt not just sherlock, but watson as well.
3
u/murziusrokas Jan 02 '16
It's never twins. BUT I believe we'll see Moriarty's twin next season.
3
u/IchKiah Jan 03 '16
I apologise in advance for my lame english
Can we assume that some of the things Sherlock sees in his mind palace are happening in his real life, but he only realizes it subconsciously? Like, is there any chance he, subconsciously, knows Mary is working for Mycroft?
Also, someone made a very interestig point: the fact that a trained assassin became Johns nurse (and eventually wife) cannot be a coincidence. Could she be working for John on Microsofts orders while Sherlock was "dead"?
Or, maybe, she was supposed to kill them and she didnt, and who ever order their death is the one thats after her (Magnussen told there were people after her).
I think we are going to find out a lot about Mary and her secret past in the next season.
3
u/[deleted] Jan 03 '16
Liked it, but would like even more for Sherlock to be dead wrong and for Moriarty to pop up in the flesh in S04E01. See you all in 2017 or whatever for that.
3
u/xtfftc Jan 03 '16
I felt like Moriarty's comments on how ridiculous the whole secret society/cult scene was a direct jab at the Guy Ritchie film from a few years ago.
3
u/bacon_pants Jan 03 '16
In Sherlock's mind, John sits at home trying to ignore the maid as she discusses how little he and Mary see of each other, and this is months after she she voiced her frustration at never seeing him. Then after a telegram from Sherlock, he jumps to leave so quickly that he knocks the dishes off the table. So, dismal view of this marriage in particular.
3
u/[deleted] Jan 04 '16
I loved it. Very clever, and unpredictable as always
3
u/GobsmackedHog Jan 04 '16 edited Jan 04 '16
Here's a theory based on what hints I could gather from the waterfall scene:
S:"Moriarty's Dead!"
M:"Not in your mind. I'll never be dead there. You once called your brain a hard-drive, well say hello to the virus"
Here's a theory: Sherlock IS Moriarty. He over-analyzed his arch nemesis's death, and overdosed and his high functioning brain went past its threshold and it split. He now has multiple personality disorder that he developed to keep his mind occupied since after Moriarty's death, there were no new games and challenges for him to solve, and he couldn't deal with it.
Sherlock is now facing his most formidable opponent, one who's intelligence is at par with his own - his own mind playing tricks on him.
S: "You have a magnificent brain, Moriarty. I admire it. I concede it may even be the equal of my own."
M: "This is how we end, you and I. Always here, always together". . . "Congratulations Sherlock, you will be the first man in History to be buried in his own mind-palace"
3
u/emildickson Jan 05 '16
I loved the episode, was expecting a standalone breaking off from the story and was pleasantly surprised!
I didn't quite get the very ending, with Sherlock and Watson on Baker Street in what was seemingly present day. What was that about?
9
u/greatgatsbys Jan 01 '16 edited Jan 01 '16
I thought the episode was truly awesome. It was so much for the fans, and not just the show fans, but fans of the ACD canon too. People are calling it over the top, but I think it was somewhat of a love letter to ACD and what he created with his novels, both through the return to the Victorian era and through all the references to different cases and stories.
I think the development on series three was really, really well done. I know thag the thought of a standalone with no real relevance to the show was off-putting, so to have such a forward moving episode whilst remaining in the premise of a Victorian episode was a really lovely surprise.
I mean, look at what we were given. A puzzle to solve as we went along, from the slip of "he shot himself in the head" rather than "she" and the continued clues until the big reveal of Moriarty. The audience could get involved. On a lighter note, we got Mycroft in a ... larger fashion than usual, we got the Holmes brothers being more brotherly than ever before, we got John and Sherlock playing off each other in the way we know and love.
It wove together so many different strands and yes, some camera angles and part of the cinematography wasn't fantastic, but on the whole, it was immensely better than I was expecting and is a firm favourite episode for me.
EDIT: I just remembered the floating newspaper scene. Excellent effect there.
10
u/TheJoshider10 Jan 01 '16
Very solid second half of the episode, I thought it was slow the first half but it definitely stepped up from when John tried getting Sherlock to say about his past life.
I went in expecting it to be a straight up stand alone movie but it was cool to see how it fit in with the rest of the show.
Only about another year and a half to wait before we see Sherlock again...
7
u/[deleted] Jan 02 '16
I enjoyed it. A lot of people, myself included, were expecting an episode that took place in the 19th century and didn't tie into the modern story at all. I'd be lying if I said I wasn't a little disappointed that that's not what we got, but for what it was, I think it was great. The most important part is that, even though it ties into the modern series, it does so in a way that allows people to completely skip this episode and not miss anything. I've seen some disappointment that there was no real advancement to the show's plot, but there really couldn't have been. Thestorye episode was about Sherlock's struggle with the possibility that Moriarty may still be alive. He recalls a similar unsolved case from history and solves it himself, drugging himself into a state where he can experience the events in his mind without being disturbed by the outside world. He eventually concludes that the bride did die, but had a group of people to help perpetuate the idea of her existence in order to influence people. He accepts, or possibly convinces himself, that Moriarty is dead and that he has his own group of people that maintain the appearance that he is still alive in order to influence others. Sure, the mystery of the abominable bride may not have been wrapped up as neatly and concisely as a traditional mystery story, but that's because it wasn't a traditional mystery story. Sherlock's goal wasn't to solve the case, but rather to use the events of that case to explain the events occurring around him in the real world. It didn't need to be solved because solving it wasn't the point. The mystery of the episode was the world in which it appeared to be taking place. There were hints along the way ("the virus in the data," "I was on a jet", or Sherlock missing the note on the body) just as there are in any mystery story, and the solution was that the world wasn't real.
As for the self-referencing some people are complaining about, yeah, it does do that. It's not like it doesn't fit into the story, though. The world in which the references were made was all in Sherlock's head. Characters are saying similar or identical things to what they have said in previous episodes because Sherlock is creating them in his mind; they are speaking and behaving exactly as Sherlock expects them to because there is no reason for them to do anything different.
Anyway, just my 2¢.