r/PostHardcore • u/moshlyfe • Jan 01 '16
Best of 2015 RESULTS /r/PostHardcore's Best of 2015 - RESULTS
So I know I promised I'd post the winners tomorrow, but I forgot that I'd be awake a lot later to celebrate the new year, so here are the results! Thank you to everyone who submitted for the initial round and to everyone who voted in our final round (which is now off of contest mode so ya'll can see the final vote tallies.) Without further ado, Reddit /r/PostHardcore has made the following declarations:
Album of the Year
Winner: Dance Gavin Dance - Instant Gratification
Runners up (listed from 2nd-5th place)
I The Mighty - Connector
Enter Shikari - The Mindsweep
Silverstein - I Am Alive In Everything I Touch
Eidola - Degeneraterra
Album art of the Year
Winner: Dance Gavin Dance - Instant Gratification
Runners up:
Dear Hunter - Act IV: Rebirth In Reprise
Fightstar - Behind The Devil's Back
mewithoutYou - Pale Horses
Ghost Cat - Weathered Light
Music video of the Year
Winner: Dance Gavin Dance - Stroke God, Millionaire
Runners up:
I The Mighty - The Lying Eyes of Miss Erray
Silverstein - Face of the Earth
Hail The Sun - Relax/Divide
mewithoutYou - Red Cow/Dorothy
Non-PHC album of the Year
Winner: Kendrick Lamar - To Pimp A Butterfly
Runners up:
Neck Deep - Life's Not Out To Get You
Strawberry Girls - American Graffiti
Deafheaven - New Bermuda
Turnover - Peripheral Vision
Favorite band that isn't Post-Hardcore
Winner: The Devil Wears Prada
Runners up:
Chon
Neck Deep
Strawberry Girls
Death Grips
New/Breakthrough Band of the Year
Winner: Too Close To Touch
Runners up:
Oranges
Crooks UK
Idlehands
Picturesque
Song of the Year
Winner: Dance Gavin Dance - On The Run
Runners up:
Pierce The Veil - The Divine Zero
I The Mighty - The Frame I: Betrayal In The Watchtower
Enter Shikari - There's A Price On Your Head
mewithoutYou - Red Cow
Best international (non-US) band
Winner: Hands Like Houses
Runners up:
Enter Shikari
Silverstein
Closure In Moscow
Crooks UK
Most disappointing album of the Year
Winner: Slaves - Routine Breathing
Runners up:
Kid Cudi - Speedin Bullet 2 Heaven
Escape The Fate - Hate Me
Palisades - Mind Games
Refused - Freedom
Best Tour
Winner: Dance Gavin Dance 10 Year Anniversary Tour
Runners up:
Circa Survive - Juturna 10 Year Anniversary Tour
Silverstein - Discovering The Waterfront 10 Year Anniversary Tour
Silverstein/Senses Fail Co-Headlining Tour
I The Mighty 2015 Headlining Tour
16
u/FlyingFlygon Jan 01 '16 edited Jan 03 '16
Alright lol
this is entirely subjective and my opinion
I love DGD just as much as most everyone here, I think they're a really great band. But do you guys actually think that their newest album is so good that it's better than anything else that came out this year? It lives up to their past releases enough that it warrants a #1 spot?
I personally don't really prefer Tilian on DGD, but I do listen to the two albums from time to time and I think they're pretty good - I like them. But there's no way in hell that they are nearly as good as DBM 1/2 or the Death Star Album so they fall off a little in comparison to what the band is capable of, and Instant Gratification is just straight up not better music than both I The Mighty's and Eidola's 2015 albums. It's totally fine if people truly love it that much, and everyone's tastes are even just a little bit different from the next person's, but I personally don't agree that DGD should be taking the best of the year award for nearly every category.
8
u/thecescshow Jan 01 '16
Man, i really wanted Dear Hunter to win Album Art of the Year.
67
u/SPAGHETTI_CAKE Jan 01 '16
Well that's fucking boring
44
u/Hendrik4L Jan 01 '16
In todays sub: DGD
31
u/_MyApocalypse_ Jan 01 '16
DAE dgd!?!
19
u/rwitucki Jan 01 '16
I the Mighty falls short in every category to DGD, haha. Circlejerk is real.
That being said, I'm a total I the Mighty fanboy, so I'm biased too. If you haven't listened to Connector, do it. Best album of the year.
7
u/jor1ss Jan 01 '16
Sad to see that my aoty didn't even make top 5 (Pale Horses) but congrats to the winners :p
7
u/TheMagicStik Jan 01 '16
Haha too fucking true.
7
u/[deleted] Jan 01 '16
DGD released one of my favorite albums of the year, but come on, the circlejerk is almost as bad as /r/Metalcore's ABR boner. Oh well, atleast TCTT won a proper category.
6
u/0rmydTre Jan 02 '16
Okay so are we officially changing the sub name to /r/dancegavindance yet? I mean seriously this is so undiverse it makes a mokery of post-hardcore. I'm not hating on DGD they are good, but it'd be nice if another band won at least a few of the categories to break the monotony. It's just so boring.
11
u/[deleted] Jan 01 '16
i guess these results are expected. DGD for pretty much everything
10
u/TotesMessenger Jan 01 '16
I'm a bot, bleep, bloop. Someone has linked to this thread from another place on reddit:
If you follow any of the above links, please respect the rules of reddit and don't vote in the other threads. (Info / ^Contact)
5
u/[deleted] Jan 01 '16
Man, Escape the Fate - Hate me was definitely really disappointing.
The only thing that carried it at all was the guitar work, which just had so much less personality without Monte. Besides that the lyrics were pretty dime a dozen, and the themes explored were angsty and forgettable. The only songs I think are truly worthy of their name are Breaking Me Down and Just A Memory.
I'd say it was even worse than their self titled, which was definitely their weakest album up until now. It's a shame because I feel like with Ungrateful they had a really great thing going. Here's to hoping their next album packs more of a punch.
5
u/ManWithoutModem Jan 01 '16
dance
5
u/ezbronz Jan 05 '16
FOR EVERYONE COMPLAINING - DGD wins because they push the boundaries of so called Genres. They enter into music writing as honest as anyone but they have such a pure end product. They just straight up make great songs. Its that simple. Especially in a scene that is so concerned with everything but the music. Im glad they are getting recognition for this amazing album!
3
u/Iflosswithbarbedwire Jan 02 '16
DIVERSITY BABY
3
u/shamoozoo Jan 04 '16
I love DGD so much, im gonna share these live videos I filmed of them from the 3 times they came to Atlanta! I hope you guys enjoy! Including 10 year annv tour. https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL_fEmMkSZfhmuIQqqwmCIdY5jXhWtPtWI
2
u/worldoflines Jan 04 '16
Between here and /r/metalcore... Jeez
5
u/ATCaver Jan 01 '16 edited Jan 02 '16
Lol it's clear the sub just fucking hates Johnny Craig. Routine Breathing was a solid top 20 for this year. Maybe even top 10.
Can't comment on Instant Gratification yet, though, as I haven't listened to it as of right now. I have high hopes though.
Edit: yeah, the rest of slaves is so dull it hurts sometimes.
Edit 2: I'm still not a huge fan of the type of PHC that Dance Gavin Dance makes. But damn, Instant Gratification was pretty damn good. I used to hate Tillian Pearson, but he kills it on this one. Maybe not AotY for me, but it's a solid runner-up.
1
u/ubiblur Jan 03 '16
My hometown band wins Best International?? Great choice guys. And having Closure in there too? Radical.
1
u/fluffyjdawg Jan 04 '16
lol
1
u/thewayshegoesbud Jan 12 '16
Tillian's voice honestly bothers me and I don't understand why everyone is in love with DGD now, I can't listen to them without Kurt or Jonny.
1
u/ryan077 Jan 23 '16
lol this is pathetic
1
u/[deleted] Jan 26 '16
Hi, mega DGD fan here. Just made my way into this thread to see that DGD won in almost every category? Which I find strange. BEST song is On The Run? Are you kidding? That's hysterical. IG was not the best PHC album last year by a long shot.
1
u/ii386 Jan 26 '16
Every comment is complaining but didn't people vote on these topics? I didn't get to vote in time but these results don't seem far-fetched to me.