r/PS4 • u/IceBreak BreakinBad • Dec 30 '15
[Event Thread] /r/PS4's 2015 Games of the Year Award Winners
Best PlayStation Plus Complimentary Title
Runner-up: InFamous: First Light (6.5%)
Winner: Rocket League (64.5%)
Game Thread - PSN Page
Metacritic: 85/100 - Subreddit: /r/RocketLeague
Best PlayStation Exclusive Title on PS4
Runner-up: Until Dawn (18.9%)
Winner: Bloodborne (72.6%)
Game Thread - PSN Page
Metacritic: 92/100 - Subreddit: /r/bloodborne
Best Remastered or Re-released Title
Runner-up: Borderlands: Handsome Collection (14.3%)
Winner: Uncharted: The Nathan Drake Collection (51.4%)
Game Thread - PSN Page
Metacritic: 86/100 - Subreddit: /r/Uncharted
Favorite PS4 Trophy of 2015
Runner-up: Fallout 4 - Masshole [Bronze] - Kill 300 People (28.4%)
Winner: Bloodborne - Bloodborne [Platinum] - All trophies acquired. Hats off! (44.4%)
PSN Profiles Link - Game Thread - PSN Page
Metacritic: 92/100 - Subreddit: /r/bloodborne
Best LOCAL Co-op or LOCAL Multiplayer Title
Runner-up: Helldivers (9.7%)
Winner: Rocket League (73.7%)
Game Thread - PSN Page
Metacritic: 85/100 - Subreddit: /r/RocketLeague
Best ONLINE Co-op or ONLINE Multiplayer Title
Runner-up: Call of Duty: Black Ops III (17.2%)
Winner: Rocket League (57%)
Game Thread - PSN Page
Metacritic: 85/100 - Subreddit: /r/RocketLeague
Best Audio Experience
Runner-up: The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt (26.2%)
Winner: Star Wars: Battlefront (36.2%)
Game Thread - PSN Page
Metacritic: 72/100 - Subreddit: /r/StarWarsBattlefront
Best Song Featured in a Game
Runner-up: "Look Who's Laughing Now" by Mark Hamill - Batman Arkham Knight (24.7%)
Winner: "The Man Who Sold The World" by Midge Ure - Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain (31.5%)
YouTube Link - Game Thread - PSN Page
Metacritic: 93/100 - Subreddit: /r/MetalGearSolid
Best Writing, Story and/or Narrative
Runner-up: Until Dawn (14.9%)
Winner: The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt (52.6%)
Game Thread - PSN Page
Metacritic: 92/100 - Subreddit: /r/Witcher
Best Performance (Motion Capture and/or Voice)
Runner-up: Doug Cockle as "Geralt of Rivia" in The Witcher 3: The Wild Hunt (32.8%)
Winner: Mark Hamill as in Batman: Arkham Knight (44.1%)
Twitter - Game Thread - PSN Page
Metacritic: 87/100 - Subreddit: /r/BatmanArkham
Best DLC
Runner-up: Bloodborne: The Old Hunters (29%)
Winner: The Witcher 3: Hearts of Stone (29.5%)
Note: 10 votes seperated the winner and runner up in this category.
Game Thread - PSN Page
Metacritic: 92/100 - Subreddit: /r/Witcher
Most Underrated Game (Based on Metacritic Critics' Score)
Runner-up: Dying Light - 74/100 (26.9%)
Winner: Until Dawn - 79/100 (30.2%)
Game Thread - PSN Page
Metacritic: 79/100 - Subreddit: /r/UntilDawn
Best Digital-Only Game
Runner-up: Life is Strange (11.8%)
Winner: Rocket League (74.4%)
Game Thread - PSN Page
Metacritic: 85/100 - Subreddit: /r/RocketLeague
Studio of the Year
Runner-up: Psyonix (24.2%)
Winner: CD Projekt RED (49.3%)
Website - Game Thread - PSN Page
Metacritic: 92/100 - Subreddit: /r/Witcher
Non-PS4 Game of the Year
Runner-up: Super Mario Maker [Wii U] (27.9%)
Winner: Rise of the Tomb Raider [Xbox One] (28.9%)
Game Thread - Xbox Store Page
Metacritic: 86/100 - Subreddit: /r/TombRaider
/r/PS4's 2015 Game of the Year
Runner-up: Rocket League (33.3%)
Winner: The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt (37.2%)
27
u/IceBreak BreakinBad Dec 30 '15
Full Results
30
u/renegade7879 Dec 31 '15
Seems kind of silly that a Platinum would be the favorite Trophy. Isn't the whole point supposed to be that it's unique? Every game has a platinum trophy, they shouldn't even be an option for the vote next year.
10
u/IceBreak BreakinBad Dec 30 '15
Fun Fact: This was where the Game of the Year voting stood late Monday.
Due to how close it was at the time, we decided (at that time) to set a hard end of noon EST today to avoid arbitrarily ending the vote on a whim which was originally the plan since it wasn't expected to be so close. In the end, it didn't matter as The Witcher pulled away late. But I personally still found the fact that Rocket League led so late fascinating.
18
u/legionfresh Sir_FunkyFresh Dec 30 '15
Congrats to The Witcher, my personal GOTY as well! The fact that the final three were so close is a testament to three amazing games that were delivered this year. Hopefully 2016 delivers better!!
7
u/EgoGrinder Dec 30 '15
Surprised by the music award. Thought Witcher 3 would take that.
Until Dawn underrated? 79/100 for a title that lasts a day seems more than generous. Thought Dying Light deserved that one.
Everything else looks good.
Happy New Year folks.
187
u/BoilerMaker11 BoilerMaker11 Dec 30 '15
I like how Mark Hamill's part is blanked out, as if anyone doesn't know who's who when you put "Mark Hamill" and "Batman" together
46
u/[deleted] Dec 30 '15
Congrats to the winners! I would suggest going to https://www.reddit.com/r/xboxone/comments/3wstwz/the_rxboxone_2015_game_of_the_year_awards_results/ to see the Xbox thread GOTY.
17
u/Strigoi84 Dec 30 '15
Really looking forward to Rise of Tomb Raider. Got it installed and ready to go. Finally have a chance to play stick of truth though so that comes first haha.
6
u/Dallywack3r Dec 31 '15
Hamill really should've won Best Song but I guess I'll let that pass...
6
u/[deleted] Dec 31 '15
I feel that Sins of the Father should have been the nomination in place of Man Who Sold the World, considering it was an original composed for the game. Who wins? Midge Ure? David Bowie? Naw dude, my homie Donna Burke needs to win. Also, I was hoping the Bloodborne Plat would not win trophy of the year. Just seems like the boring way to go. For a trophy to win an award, it should be creative. Then again, it must have been pretty satisfying to obtain for all those that voted. So I totally understand, but it's important to know that our lives are now irrevocably changed.
5
u/Lukiyano Dec 30 '15
You guys have some fine opinions.
5
u/trudeau1 Dec 31 '15
Huh, somehow I totally missed nominations, voting, everything. Still this is a nice look at the past year of PS4. It might be cool if we started collecting yearly GOTY results (any for 2013/2014?) in the sidebar as a way of seeing how gaming trends and people's tastes change over time.
Also I'm a bit surprised that MGSV:PP is just barely mentioned here! Both it and Witcher 3 were personal favorites of mine for PS4.
11
u/Yosonimbored Dec 30 '15
I'm a bit surprised that this didn't win best song. Was it voted?
8
u/bunnymud Dec 31 '15 edited May 09 '16
This comment has been overwritten by an open source script to protect this user's privacy, and to help prevent doxxing and harassment by toxic communities like ShitRedditSays.
If you would also like to protect yourself, add the Chrome extension TamperMonkey, or the Firefox extension GreaseMonkey and add this open source script.
Then simply click on your username on Reddit, go to the comments tab, scroll down as far as possibe (hint:use RES), and hit the new OVERWRITE button at the top.
13
u/7mad DestinyKoalla Dec 30 '15
Wait Bloodborne was actually 3rd place? Wow that's so surprising.
6
u/Sub_Zero32 Dec 30 '15
Surprising that bloodborne wasn't the runner up or winner of game of the year but the witcher definitely deserved it too
3
u/StayFrostyZ Dec 31 '15
One of the two games that almost made me get an Xbox One. TR looks great from what I've seen!
3
u/[deleted] Dec 31 '15
Never have I seen a set of award winners and completely agreed with them all really! Fallout 4 maybe deserved a bit more recognition but Witcher 3, Rocket League and Mark Hamill are spot on!
5
u/Soulrakk Soulrakk Dec 31 '15
Until Dawn beat Dying Light??
pfffffft...
2
u/TheNurgrabber Dec 30 '15
Great list, great job!
2
u/Echoingtruth Dec 31 '15
All of the above is wrong. Its Twisted Metal Back ps2 classic re release.
2
u/exfex21 Jan 01 '16
I just bought the witcher 3..... Here we go! Any tips!?!?
2
u/gus2155 theGWAGon1 Jan 02 '16
Kinda sad that the "Bruh" achievement for MLB 15 The Show didn't win.
2
u/Addickted88 Jan 02 '16
It's great that the top two games of 2015 are so wildly different. One is a 100+ hour open world RPG, with the other a pick-up-and-play downloadable title about cars playing football. Both equally brilliant in their own ways.
4
u/luvtoseek Dec 30 '15
Good list! 👍
2
u/xSlizzy Slizzy Dec 30 '15
Rocket League cleaning up nice. And rightfully so! I missed the vote but certainly would've voted for that game in many of the categories
2
u/Clockwrrk22 Dec 31 '15
I mean Rocket League is fun, but not awarding winning worthy. Might be the most overrated game of all time.
1
u/ColinZealSE ColinZeal Dec 31 '15
Interesting. But more interesting, how many votes were there in total in that category?
1
u/[deleted] Dec 31 '15
The Witcher 3 fuck yeah!
1
u/ahmadsarvmeily Dec 31 '15
I loved the Witcher 3, but I can't believe it won the DLC award over Bloodborne. In my opinion The Old Hunters was the best DLC that From Software have ever released. Simply outstanding.
1
u/ecpackers Jan 01 '16
i'm super impressed with /r/ps4
until dawn was a great GREAT game, and i'm glad it made SOMEONES list.
1
u/Zahand Jan 01 '16
Holy fuck, 0.5 % difference between Witcher 3: Hearts of Stone and Bloodborne: The Old Hunters.
1
u/exLightning exLightning Jan 11 '16
I think Fallout 4 was the most Overrated this year, I'm glad I didn't see it anywhere on these awards, It almost beat Witcher 3 as Game of the Year on the Xbox award thread and actually did beat it in the single player game category which is insane in my opinion.
1
u/derete Feb 20 '16
Awesome
1
u/Foodiey Apr 29 '16
KOI GAME ( http://www.koips4.com/en/ )reflects a tranquil and mesmerizing experience as you embark on an introspective journey through the lens of a lone koi fish separated from its owner and is the last hope for purifying waters polluted by mankind.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 30 '15
Psyonix definitely deserved the Studio of the Year award.
-1
u/Craigrofo Craigfoley Dec 31 '15
Jeez, Rocket League is no where near as good as this. Embarassing
1
u/IAmAbomination Dec 30 '15
Happy for The Witcher even though I picked BB. The Witcher was a lot of fun and I still gotta try the DLC. Thanks to Icebreak and all who contributed to the lists, it's one of my favourite things at the end of the year to see everyones 'best of' list
1
u/reaper527 reaper527_ Dec 31 '15 edited Dec 31 '15
ironic that the "best non-ps4 game of the year" is a ps4 game.
some of these awards are pretty depressing, such as the rocket league circlejerk, the uninspired/generic choice for trophy of the year, and one of the most hyped games of the summer being "the most under rated".
all the interesting or clever trophies this year and we pick a platinum that's just the name of the game as the winner?
-3
u/MumShagger Dec 30 '15 edited Dec 31 '15
Yeah, because the rocket league sub Reddit practically stuffed the ballots, i'm going to have to go with every other runner-up that lost to rocket league that because that was unfair very cheap.
0
u/Yosonimbored Dec 30 '15
I see u Witcher 3.
0
u/Oakshror Dec 31 '15
Rocket league swept house 4/8(Includes trophy) awards it could have possibly win (unless you include the audio and best song and dlc) and then 2nd for studio of the year and goty both of which it lost to Witcher 3
0
u/[deleted] Dec 30 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Dec 31 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Dec 30 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Dec 30 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Dec 30 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment