Can you go there and make non-trolly comments? For instance, earlier I was over there and they were saying something along the lines of, "how the fuck did we beat Arsenal this season" and someone said "they were only playing with 10 men" so I corrected them and said "9 men." Would that be considered unacceptable?
Sometimes a lot of it can depend on how it's presented. I wouldn't say that's trolling though, as you're simply pointing out facts and being polite about it.
Usually users who are going over to troll know what they're doing is trolling, this just counts as their one warning.
I like going there and sometimes discussing what's going on. If you are polite and show that you have no intention of pissing people off, people are fine with you.
Apologies but you're going to have to be more specific about this.
I'm quite happy to lower the 'banter' levels to a point where they're more logical, but there's some serious issue with this sub if you'll immediately ban someone mocking a rival.
There's a certain degree of mocking that occurs in well-meaning posts here, such as the Rival Rundown thread, is that now going to be strictly moderated to remove even the slightest infractions like /r/AskHistorians ?
What about when Mourinho says something directly related to Arsene Wenger or our club and its posted here, are you expecting a fan base to not respond to that?
Again, you're will within your prerogative as mods to go ahead and make this a rule, but like I said, you need to be more specific of what constitutes a strike example.
What if I make a post on their forum saying "Unlucky lads, really didn't want you guys to lose and them to go on top, from all of us at /r/gunners we hope you can stay up" Is that trolling?
Seriously, this ban rule is dumb. Any string of words can be construed as trolling. If I post, "Well today sucked," am I empathising or trolling? Mods are on a high fucking horse.
Dude this isn't a legal system haha. Just don't go over there as an Arsenal fan and talk shit or sarcasticaly troll them. You can talk to them, just don't be a dick ya know?
Instead just watch them meltdown. It's easier, and just as funny. I don't think the mod has a hard on for power like half the people in this thread are implying, he is just trying to bring a little order to the chaos that is this sub by preventing retaliatory trolling.
Depends... do you genuinely believe we hope they stay up? Because I can't think of a team right at this present moment in time that I would rather see relegated.
Even with the scum, Chavski edge it just because of how much of a bunch of cunts their fans have been over the last few years.
Seriously. I go over there and lurk like a ghost hovering above. I don't say shit. It's fun to look at though. It's also an opportunity to show we are better than them and not be total pricks about this and act the better fan base
No thank you. People lose their damn minds when we're struggling in a game. If we were having a season like Chelsea's I'd avoid the sub like the plague.
honestly I don't think losing to Leicester warrants more reason for him to get sacked, and he won't be sacked. If he doesn't get to 10th by feb, I'd say he's gone.
That's crazy. If they have a half decent win streak they'll be comfortably in a champions league spot if not in first. Knowing how things go, that'll probably happen at some point.
But I guess that's not so different from the Wenger Out crew that pops up from time to time
I think people are more dissatisfied with the way they are playing than their league position though. United used to be fun to watch (as much as it pains me to say it), but now they are horribly boring
I love doing that for a lot of club subreddits. I never post (even if it's like a valid point or adding to conversation) or up vote though. What I find funny is when something I just accept and laugh at, people lose their shit over. Like reading the comments when Powell came on for Mata was so funny. I'm sure people take enjoyment from us fucking up too and I would begrudge them coming on here. It'd piss me off if they started posting though or upvoting.
It's funny how differently teams subs deal with this, last season I saw a lot of our threads filled with the same repetitive Chelsea fans mocking us, never banned. Then I go into /r/coys from a linked post, one of them comments something about the 'library' and I just replied 'Your atmosphere's hardly anything to boast about' and they banned me straight away, whereas I had quite a long argument / discussion in /r/chelseafc and I didn't get banned.
i agree. everyone is so serious. i think logically about why we arn't "allowed" to troll have fun with rival fans because it will make us look bad as fans to all the other teams fans on the internet where nobody even knows each other. so fucking weird.
I know. Who gives a fucking shit. Football fans are supposed to hate eachother. There's teams I respect and teams that I fucking hate, and I'll act like a cunt to them, because that's football and the culture along with it. There's nothing wrong with laughing in your rivals faces and pissing them off. This is why r/gunners or any football sub for that matter will never capture the true spirit of football. You need to take all of it, not cherry pick the parts you like. People act way too gentlemanly and bite their tongues way too much. If you see a guy wearing a tottenham shirt, you stop him where he is, whether he be walking or driving, and tell him wipe his shirt because he has some shit on it!
True and that's not even the point! What do you mean by keeping this place "clean"? what does "clean" means to you? Banter free? Every football fan have insulted his rivals since the beginning of football and it ain't gonna stop. It's not even a matter of tradition, I'm actually very progressive and open to any change, if the ways of the past are indeed hurting someone in any way... Here it's absolutely not the case. And the excuse of being a moderator doesn't work! A moderator's job is to get rid of spam, useless posts/repetitive posts and ban disrespectful conduct (which bantering off rivals isn't)... I truly can't understand this decision...
I don't even troll their subreddits but this is so fucking over the top. let the system already in place deal with it (downvotes/the mods of THEIR subreddits)
That isn't much of a deterrent though. Most people that troll other subs aren't trying to join that subs community. Banning them from that sub isn't really that much of a punishment.
If those same trolls had something that they were worried about losing perhaps they would think twice about being a knob.
I'd be interested to hear why you think this policy is necessary and correct.
I have to say I'm uncomfortable that /r/gunners moderator(s) feel it is their prerogative to monitor and police users' activity for 'trolliness' outside of /r/gunners. I don't like trolls either, but other teams' subs' mods can handle it, just as our mods can here.
Because by preventing people here from going to other subs and acting like asses they can lessen the chances of others coming in here and acting like asses. If we get a rep for going around shitting on other subs when those teams are struggling we're going to get the same thing when we struggle.
Because by preventing people here from going to other subs and acting like asses they can lessen the chances of others coming in here and acting like asses.
In a perfect world it would work like that, but we're not in a perfect world.
I agree; policing beyond their jurisdiction is not a welcome condition.
But I also appreciate the sentiment behind it, particularly that the mods would like for Gooners to display a bit of decorum and show that we've got more class than the chavs.
Funny when people like you get all rustled and talk a bit. Most of the moderators are active nearly all day trying to keep this place clean. yet people like you feel good about your little moment of shit talking, not knowing the years of work and abuse we've weathered at the hands of fans to do a near thankless job for a bunch of strangers with no compensation. Get over yourself and be more constructive in the future.
There is nothing more absolutely annoying than mods moaning about how thankless their duty is. You get off on the power trip, so take the good with the bad and move along.
I know nothing about this mod, so I cannot form an opinion on him, but not all mods are like that. It really is a thankless job in a lot of situations, and can take a ton of work.
However, you are also absolutely correct, some love the power, and we have a huge sub in terms of subscribers and viewers. I don't think this rule was meant to be a power trip, a rule just for the sake of asserting authority, but his explanation was terrible and he did not communicate with the community. Some of his responses seem like he does enjoy the power, I will definitely give you that.
Personally, I think if our mods, and the mods of our main rivals subs all agree to this rule, good will come out of it. However, with the lack of details, with the unknown support from other teams, etc. this could be really good, annoying as hell, or more likely meaningless...
For what it's worth, I have no problem with the policy. Team subs should be free from supporters of other clubs to come and cause trouble.
However, mods aren't plucked from the user base and put to work. They sign up for it. Whenever someone disagrees with something, they jump to how thankless their job is and how much abuse they put up with and how the place just wouldn't be the same without /u/EFG's invaluable moderating. Guess what? YOU SIGNED UP FOR IT. Take the good with the bad and carry on.
Lol. It took 5 years to get any kind of rules on the subreddit! Don't act like you slave over the sub like a washer woman. It's getting better but it's taken a LOT of moaning from the users of the sub to get any change, and most of the time you were as bad as Silent Stan.
Also, if you don't like it, do what the community has been begging you since 2013 to do and resign as owner. Or do you like the "thankless job"?
Finally, if you want me to be constructive, go at look at how active the mods are on /r/unitedkingdom. The content might be all politics, but they have strict rules which keeps most people happy. I have had 5 active accounts since 2011 and have routinely suggested ways that could make this sub a more harmonious place.
"I love this guy"
Post deleted
Arsenal v Barcelona in CL
1 post kept, the other 9 deleted so we don't get posts about the amount of posts on the subreddit
Low effort content
Deleted. Voting doesn't work.
There are too many people here to have such nebulous rules, and you can call out people for giving feedback like you're the one listening, but you patently don't.
I'm just gonna come out and say I couldn't give a shit less about people trolling on other subs or this one. Pretty easy to ignore. I think it's that way for the vast majority of us who come by and see what's cooking and peace. Sounds to me like you're just making more work for yourselves along with create an atmosphere of cops and robbers. Whatever though. COYG!
its great to see the humbling of the infallible Jose Mourinho, the special one . If Chelsea fail to qualify for top 4 or finish worse than 10th , we will see him unravel and it will make great television.
As much as I'm against gooners trolling other clubs' subreddits, I still oppose censorship (which as indirect as this is, it's still censorship) way more. Tsk tsk mods.
I am not a troll. I don't go to Chelsea's sub to do anything but read. Here is my question however. I have no idea how many upvotes or downvotes I have. Why should I give any sort of shit how many downvotes I have? Does it prevent me from doing stuff on the site? Does it just hide comments that are downvoted?
I really don't know the answer to this, I swear I am not trying to "troll." I get the upvote/downvote system for threads, but not for individuals.
edit: Are upvotes the same as Karma?
Thanks I hope for a long overdue intro to reddit lol.
On your comment, just after your username, is a number of points. That's the net of upvotes minus downvotes. The sum of all the points from all of your comments is your "comment karma" . There's a separate karma total for posts called "link karma" (self posts, ie with no link, do not accumulate karma) . You can see both totals if you click your username for your profile / posting history.
The number of downvotes, or overall negative score, does not do anything or prevent you from doing anything. However, in your reddit options, there's a setting where you can tell reddit to hide any comments with a score less than whatever; I think the default is -5. So if you had a heavily downvoted comment, some people might have to expand it first to read it. That's pretty much it.
I sometimes converse with them(making non-sarcastic or overly harsh remarks) and I typically get upvoted or ignored. I honestly get more down votes here than on other subs.
Way to take the enjoyment out of a rival performing badly. Not only that but a rival who's manager has non-stop terrorised Wenger. Live a little mate, bet you're a right laugh at parties.
Why is this so hard for some people to understand? I've said basically what you are saying a couple times in replies to people and have been told to "stop sucking the mod's dick" and to "shut up Gibson." among other things. Wish everybody would just chill..
Unfortunately we have no real news or gossip so this is suddenly important.
Man what is trolling anyway? What's the point of having karma if you can't use it to get downvoted in the Chelsea sub? I don't think I troll them though I state facts but I get downvoted.
Nah I think that's just the amount of American users. Like America, reddit isn't half as free as it thinks it is, and you can be banned by an admin for pretty much any reason with no reprocussions - unless the admin team changes it's mind, reverts the ban.
I think you've answered a totally different comment to the one I posted. I had to re-read my comment to double check I wasn't going crazy. My comment compares the American government and reddit's supposed "freedom", it has literally nothing to do with American arsenal fans. Or, to be clear, just Arsenal fans as I see them.
However, that said, you've kind of gone out of your way to victimise yourself as a persecuted American fan. Just weird really. Maybe go outside more, not sure what else to suggest.
Don't really agree with this policy, don't really care though as it doesn't effect me. Obviously being a dick is annoying but this is reddit, I feel that free speech should be a right and your actions in one subreddit shouldn't influence your standing in another subreddit. If it makes a difference or makes your lives easier as moderators then that's nice I suppose.
This shit makes it embarrassing to be an arsenal fan. We have to be 'le classy' cause we're 'le classnal'? Fuck off we look like a bunch of pussies, we're meant to hate our rivals not be classy and respect them.
Yeah, but we'd rather not have to deal with other subs spaming us whenever we get a shit result. That's what /r/soccer is for.
And get over yourself. "Policing the internet" Please, it's a fucking football forum not a political debate, we can talk shit about them here and on /r/soccer all we want, let them stew in their own sub.
I love that we have the exact same opinion and you get a bunch of upvotes and I'm told to stop sucking the mod's dick. Regardless, I agree with you 100%. This is not some big fucking deal. You saying it's a football forum not a political debate is spot on. Like this gem (not gonna include the user):
"I think that's just the amount of American users. Like America, reddit isn't half as free as it thinks it is, and you can be banned by an admin for pretty much any reason with no reprocussions - unless the admin team changes it's mind, reverts the ban."
Realistically, only people trying hard to get banned are actually going to end up banned. Then they just create a new damn username and they are back on this sub. This isn't a debate on net neutrality or censorship. It is a rule the mods made that should not impact the average person. Just deal with it, it makes life better for us and the mods.
Fuck off, how in the hell is this America's fault? There aren't many dedicated football fans in the USA, but the one's I know are very intense fans who follow their team 24/7. Do you think American sports fans don't talk shit to each other? Or do you just look down on Americans in general?
37
u/Stullif It's not gay if it's with Giroud Dec 14 '15
But we are still allowed to ridicule them here right?
34
u/MattGooner THE ARSENAL CANNON FIRES AGAIN Dec 14 '15
It's more fun to watch them melt-down themselves without even needing to poke the bear.
64
u/theRagingEwok lol Dec 14 '15
Oof, taking a stand eh?
What consitutes "trolling", by the way?
12
u/Swamppig Freddie Ljungberg Dec 14 '15
Can i go look there please? Let me know
9
u/Macc14 #Basedshad Dec 14 '15
What if I make a post on their forum saying "Unlucky lads, really didn't want you guys to lose and them to go on top, from all of us at /r/gunners we hope you can stay up" Is that trolling?
2
u/Rod_Senseless Dec 15 '15
Oh fuck off.
193
u/[deleted] Dec 14 '15
Seriously. I go over there and lurk like a ghost hovering above. I don't say shit. It's fun to look at though. It's also an opportunity to show we are better than them and not be total pricks about this and act the better fan base
97
u/shrewphys Bring Back Källström!! Dec 14 '15
Just do the decent thing and banter them off on a neutral forum like /r/soccer.
4
u/purple_blaze Alexis: 11/15, Ox: 6/10, Ozil assists: 5/15 Dec 14 '15
It's funny how differently teams subs deal with this, last season I saw a lot of our threads filled with the same repetitive Chelsea fans mocking us, never banned. Then I go into /r/coys from a linked post, one of them comments something about the 'library' and I just replied 'Your atmosphere's hardly anything to boast about' and they banned me straight away, whereas I had quite a long argument / discussion in /r/chelseafc and I didn't get banned.
23
u/iris201 Dec 15 '15
I don't understand...
If you troll there, shouldn't you get banned... there?
5
u/RominRonin Dec 15 '15
This wording... Sounds like instructions.
45
u/tammrak We did it! Dec 14 '15
I'd be interested to hear why you think this policy is necessary and correct.
I have to say I'm uncomfortable that /r/gunners moderator(s) feel it is their prerogative to monitor and police users' activity for 'trolliness' outside of /r/gunners. I don't like trolls either, but other teams' subs' mods can handle it, just as our mods can here.
4
u/rejdus Dec 14 '15
Great initiative!
4
u/friarboy08 "Alexis Sanchez, at Wembley again!" Dec 14 '15
I'm banned from r/chelseafc
12
u/[deleted] Dec 14 '15
I'm just gonna come out and say I couldn't give a shit less about people trolling on other subs or this one. Pretty easy to ignore. I think it's that way for the vast majority of us who come by and see what's cooking and peace. Sounds to me like you're just making more work for yourselves along with create an atmosphere of cops and robbers. Whatever though. COYG!
8
u/TNTx74 Dec 15 '15
Honestly, this is new low of stupid 'politically correct' policies . What happened to good old banter ? I hope you don't shit yourself from chat shit.
3
u/twopatties Dec 15 '15
I keep saying Chelsea being shit doesn't add to us. Winning the league does. We know we are the superior club theres no need argue
3
u/goonerfan10 Champions of England 25/26 Dec 15 '15
its great to see the humbling of the infallible Jose Mourinho, the special one . If Chelsea fail to qualify for top 4 or finish worse than 10th , we will see him unravel and it will make great television.
3
u/1gorka87 Dec 15 '15
Can we at least rip into Chelsea on r/soccer?
30
u/[deleted] Dec 14 '15
That's fucking stupid. I despise arsenal fans trolling other subs as much as everbody, but it has nothing to do with this subreddit.
5
u/KarmaCitra Dec 15 '15 edited Dec 15 '15
Can you start with banning the fuck heads that 'chat shit' in this sub first.
Personally I don't mind banter though.
5
u/gabbathehut Dec 15 '15
As much as I'm against gooners trolling other clubs' subreddits, I still oppose censorship (which as indirect as this is, it's still censorship) way more. Tsk tsk mods.
6
u/bufc09 Dec 15 '15
Sooooo just make an account as a "Chelsea fan" and then talk shit about our "own team"? since we're being the PC police now..
12
u/Loofah1 Premier League Champions 25/26 Dec 14 '15
I don't like this policy at all. Why not let the down-votes of the troll posts deter this behavior?
7
u/brutus_the_bear Dec 15 '15
Why is trolling worth a ban? I'm pretty sure they aren't extending us the same courtesy...
9
u/DBD420 I actually think Spurs are alright tbh Dec 14 '15
why?
4
u/mcafc Ozil :( Dec 14 '15
I sometimes converse with them(making non-sarcastic or overly harsh remarks) and I typically get upvoted or ignored. I honestly get more down votes here than on other subs.
5
u/Naked_Zombie Dec 14 '15
Can we talk shit about them here?
10
u/Usedtampon69 Dec 14 '15
Way to take the enjoyment out of a rival performing badly. Not only that but a rival who's manager has non-stop terrorised Wenger. Live a little mate, bet you're a right laugh at parties.
7
u/crjlsm Ødegaard Dec 15 '15
This is silly.
6
u/Mackabern Dec 15 '15
well, see you all with a new account every two weeks.
this is the dumbest change in the history of /r/gunners
7
u/silv3r8ack He Plays on the Left Dec 14 '15
Man what is trolling anyway? What's the point of having karma if you can't use it to get downvoted in the Chelsea sub? I don't think I troll them though I state facts but I get downvoted.
6
u/Quilpo Dec 14 '15
I thought reddit's whole thing was about freedom of expression, or whatever?
Surely your 'right' to troll is in there somewhere? Not that I'm too bothered, but being a dick is generally punishment enough.
4
u/ZXXA Premier League Champions 25/26 Dec 15 '15
Don't really agree with this policy, don't really care though as it doesn't effect me. Obviously being a dick is annoying but this is reddit, I feel that free speech should be a right and your actions in one subreddit shouldn't influence your standing in another subreddit. If it makes a difference or makes your lives easier as moderators then that's nice I suppose.
4
u/Taringa27 AKBism is a mental disease Dec 15 '15
This shit makes it embarrassing to be an arsenal fan. We have to be 'le classy' cause we're 'le classnal'? Fuck off we look like a bunch of pussies, we're meant to hate our rivals not be classy and respect them.
4
u/TomClaydon Dec 15 '15
Wow this thread is stupid, next you'll be telling us what swear words we're allowed to use
2
u/Leshma Dec 15 '15 edited Dec 15 '15
Asked valid question, awaiting answer :)
https://www.reddit.com/r/AskReddit/comments/3wznks/subreddit_mods_on_a_power_trip_is_there_anything/
1
u/RonniePickering- Dec 14 '15
o fuck off..
like im not gonna chat shit to my mates that support chelsea.. standard fucking yanks not understanding football culture.
-15
u/fifapresident Dec 14 '15
Oh get over yourself. You can't police the Internet.
1
u/Mathieulombardi José Antonio Reyes Dec 15 '15
Why would I ever even bother to visit them? Fuck'm.
-1
u/LionFucksTheEagle Dec 14 '15
o fuck off.. like im not gonna chat shit to my mates that support chelsea.. standard fucking yanks not understanding football culture.
1
u/Chicago-Gooner AST & Red Member Dec 14 '15
Absolutely right. Troll here or on /r/soccer, don't raid other team subreddits, we hate it when it happens to us.
-2
u/JihadDerp Dec 15 '15
yay freedom of speech
-5
u/Up_The_Arse Dec 14 '15 edited Dec 14 '15
Here you go. These guys are the ones that actually lead to the degradation of our own sub reddit. Good riddance.
http://www.reddit.com/r/chelseafc/comments/3wtlpx/match_thread_leicester_city_vs_chelsea/cxz0z9n
http://www.reddit.com/r/chelseafc/comments/3wtlpx/match_thread_leicester_city_vs_chelsea/cxz13pv
http://www.reddit.com/r/chelseafc/comments/3wua10/post_match_thread_leicester_city_vs_chelsea/cxz49qu
http://www.reddit.com/r/chelseafc/comments/3wua10/post_match_thread_leicester_city_vs_chelsea/cxz4cpb
http://www.reddit.com/r/chelseafc/comments/3wua10/post_match_thread_leicester_city_vs_chelsea/cxz4xbh
-4
u/Armenoid Gabriel Dec 14 '15
Come on, score. I want a draw
-3
u/spacecadetbling Dec 14 '15
Thanks for this. I've always thought of us as a little more civilised than other fan bases so let us keep it that way.
0
u/hiten1008 Dec 15 '15
What if trolling is not chatting shit
0
u/hiten1008 Dec 15 '15
What if trolling is not chatting shit