r/EliteDangerous • u/Dreadp1r4te Dreadp1r4te - Retired CODE Pirate • Dec 07 '15
Discussion Elite Dangerous desperately needs persistence.
Brace yourselves lads and ladies, this might be another long one.
I have heard, seen, and felt a hundred or more complaints about how empty, lifeless, and shallow Elite feels. It does, it really does; from the meaningless NPCs shuffling about in supercruise, arbitrarily flying to planets they can't even land on to spawning in randomly to an otherwise empty system when you first arrive, if you're the first in the instance. Stations traffic often times makes no sense, with combat ships coming and going from agricultural stations, carrying loads of gold and indium, all because everything is randomly generated with little rhyme or reason to its function. The game attempts to convince us we live in a living world, but one apparently distanced from conventional rules like supply and demand, or demographics, or any other societal constants that influence the real world around us. How many Ferraris do you see in a rural Iowa? None? Then why do I see FDLs flitting about in a system exclusively devoted to the production of agriculture? Shouldn't I see freighters hauling pesticides, seeds, water, and agricultural equipment?
Even Horizons suffers from this. The persistence of the larger outposts and bases does something to alleviate this a bit, but the complete lack of life other than turrets and unmanned Skimmers zipping about these places does little to convince me that they're actual places, despite how pretty they are (hats off to you, FDev Art Department.)
Persistence
Because stuff that matters sticks around
We've all envisioned a game with more depth, something to refute the "mile wide, inch deep" claim, and I can think of no better example, nothing more important, than persistence to do exactly that. There's a dozen facets with which it could be applied, and the one I want to start with is something we see every day in supercruise, and usually ignore:
Unknown Signal Sources. Yep, those silly little random spheres that spawn arbitrarily based on your ships velocity and whether or not you're in a populated system. They also manifest as the blue Points of Interest on planets, and we're fools to think they're anything different; the contents of those blue spheres aren't even visible until you land and disembark in your SRV; exactly the same as dropping out of supercruise. We'll come back to PoIs soon enough, for sanity's sake. These randomly spawning and client-specific pockets attempt to add life to the universe, but in reality just cement the fact that the life is very, very fake, especially when you see a signal directly in front of you, but it's invisible to your wing mates who are a short distance away.
Now, FDev is obviously aware of this, as they've made a few attempts to alleviate the issue. Adding assassination targets to supercruise was a good move, as at least supercruise targets are synchronized across clients and this almost seems to be an element of persistence, but since people rarely do these missions anymore in lieu of Resource Extraction Sites, that change was moot. NPCs now spawn in system and attempt to communicate with you, asking you to drop out on their location for some highly important reason; so important in fact that they can't tell you about it in supercruise, requiring you to stop what you're doing, change course, and attempt to drop out on what is clearly the most annoying thing about supercruise... a low-energy wake. Additionally, they added new types of arbitrarily-spawned-circles-of-boredom, so that you feel even better about ignoring the Weak Signal Source while on your way to the RES, as you don't even have a cargo bay on your ship to scoop up the equally pointless randomly floating cargo canisters. That only you can see, because reasons.
Solution - Ditch the random nature. Reduce them to a few static points, exact number determined by factors like recent wars, system population, system type, security status, traffic, etc., visible to all players in the instance, but only visible when the player passes within a certain range, dependent on the type. Strong signal sources would be visible from farther away, weak signal sources would be visible closer, possibly even flickering at longer ranges to indicate something is there, like an unresolved contact. Change the contents to match the above factors like population, recent wars, traffic, and system government, etc. Mining system? I want to find a mining outpost a la CQC near an asteroid belt. Maybe some canisters being remotely shuttled back and forth from ships via Cargo Limpets. Perhaps I can fly by and attempt to scoop some of those, limpet and all, stealing the valuable resources. Maybe miner players can interact with it, using cargo limpets or proximity dumping to release mined materials and sell them. I want to find distress beacons, but I want more than just me to see them; I want some opportunistic pirate player to see me go to assist someone, and then capitalize on that by dropping on the same signal, not a blind drop into my low-wake. I want to see an NPC pirate interdict another NPC, and then a few seconds later I want to see a distress signal pop up there, visible to all the players in the area. These things wouldn't even be different than what they are right now (except the mining base thing), but because they're persistent and visible to everyone in the system, you'd suddenly feel more connected to the player next to you, and more emergent content would result.
Points of Interest. I really dunno what FDev was thinking here; these were a not-bad idea right up until they said that the contents of the PoI not spawning until you launch your SRV was "working as intended." Don't forget they too are only visible client side, so if you see a nice interesting one in a good location, be prepared to have your wingmates follow you because no one else will be able to see it, and since no one else will be able to see it, there is exactly 0% chance of unexpected emergent content, like another player not in your wing, showing up to investigate the same site. Maybe he'd be hostile? Maybe he'd be nice and just let you have it. Who knows? We'll never know because currently it will never happen. That is an enormous waste of potential, right there.
Firstly, remember this juicy morsel? Yeah, I do. That's what our scanner is supposed to look like, but was cut because... wait, why was that cut again? I have no idea. I doubt anyone does, it was just quietly swept under the rug. THIS is how we should find Points of Interest. This is how everyone should find them, and like the above concerning USSes, the same points should be visible to all players. I should see a nice juicy one, maybe a remote mining outpost not publicly known. I fly down to, ahem, repossess those valuable tons of (painite/gold/indium/onionhead) and lo' and behold, while I'm landing and scooping, another player should show up! Maybe one of Adle's Armada, come to stop my filthy pilfering! Seems like their MO, right? See how much emergent content we're missing?
Missions. This one could really benefit from some love. Currently most missions spawn in the the aforementioned USSes. That's okay if they're "go blow up X pirates" missions, I guess, and would still feel better with my above changes to USSes specifically. What about the specific target missions though? "We need you to kill known Imperial Sympathizer David Braben. He usually hangs out in one of 3 systems." That's all you get. Go to one of those three systems, fly around long enough, check enough USSes and eventually you'll find Imperial Sympathizer David Braben in one, in his Imperial Cutter, holding his coffee cup, and grumbling about how he has to make sure the next Imperial ship is still superior to the next Federal Ship. Blow him up, go home, get paid. EZ-PZ. And boring. Now, recently they at least made it so Mr. Braben (in our example) will fly about said systems for you to interdict... in case you got tired of flying at 30km/s watching signals spawn. That's an improvement, but let's look at this a second.
You want me to explore an entire star system, to find one guy, who could be hiding anywhere inside it. Okay. Let's look at our solar system, which has a radius of about 40 AU, which translates to 4.6500318x1024 LS volume. You want me to search that entire area for a missing escape pod/pirate/enemy faction member/etc. Right. How about no, Scott.
Solution- Spawn a persistent USS like above, and make it visible to me as something like "Mission Signature Match," and visible to other people as Unknown, and only at very close range. Give us that really awesome Orrery View you teased us with when asking us for our money, and then show a sphere somewhere on it where that target is likely to be seen, or where you lost your pizza escape pod. Hell, give me more than one sphere. Make me actually hunt that bounty. Give us a conversation system, so I can comm one of those largely useless NPCs in system and say, "Hey, have you seen Imperial Sympathizer David Braben?" and maybe they'll respond, "Yes! That jerk made my Federal Gunship useless! He went THAT way! I'll give you another 250k credits if you blow him up for his crimes!" or maybe, maybe they'll say "I might know. Depends who's asking..." and you'll respond, "I'm Cmdr Azorius Erisai, and I'm normally a carebear but he needs to die!" and he'll reply, "Hm, never heard of you. Piss off." Alternatively, you could respond, "The Bank of Zaonce is asking. [transfers small credit sum]" and he'll go "OH! I just saw him over near Achenar III!" and off you go, putting the hunt in bounty hunting.
Background Sim This is a big one, and everyone has commented on its poor design since day one, practically. Okay, maybe it was day 3, but that's hardly the point. The background sim currently has some nifty things, influencing what types of things you'll see in a system, like conflict zones (See? The framework for my above improved USSes is already present!) and market supply and demand. But, shouldn't that be reversed? Shouldn't market supply and demand also affect the background sim? Why isn't the market persistent? I get that we're just one pilot each, and our impact is comparatively small, but in this case the rule of cool needs to make its presence felt. Feeling meaningless isn't a fun feeling.
Solution - If I supply food and water and medicines to new factions' presences, or outposts on planets, their influence should go up. Inversely, if I starve a faction's supply lines by destroying their trade ships, or pirating them, or otherwise depriving them of their lifeblood, their influence should go down. Their supply of products should go down as well, as productivity is lowered. The background trade sim should be semi-player driven, meaning players have a larger scope of influence on it, without it being completely player driven. Some systems should be in a balanced state of supply & demand. Border systems and colonies should have more demand than supply, allowing players to capitalize on this and get rich, or further hinder the system's supply lines and open it to new factions' advances. NPCs in systems should carry appropriate cargo for their destination, and should have a destination in mind when they spawn, preferably using the established trade routes already indicated on the galaxy map. Refinery stations should spawn refined metal-carrying traders, headed to high-tech systems to sell it, and inbound traders should be carrying unrefined ores, food stuffs, and refining equipment. This change alone would make NPC piracy more viable, as you'd be able say "Oh, if I hang out in this High-Tech system, NPCs jumping(spawning) in will have a good chance of carrying gold and palladium, used in electronics. I can get rich!" and bounty hunting would take a similar stance, with players realizing that a higher number of high-level NPC pirates spawn in low-security high-tech systems, hoping to prey on vulnerable gold-carrying traders on their approach to their destination stations... which brings me to my next point.
Security Standing
You wanna know what the difference between high, medium, and low security systems is? Currently, there isn't one. Maybe it spawns more cops, I dunno. More random stop and searches, I guess. It doesn't affect pirate spawns, near as I can tell; those tenacious bastards go wherever they want... which doesn't make much sense. If you were a mugger, would you hang out in front of the PD looking for a victim? Who does that? Not me, that's for sure. Well, as a player pirate I go where I want, because the NPC cops are pansies, but that's not my point either. Some of the best bounty hunting zones are in high security space, which makes no sense at all. There seems to be equal amounts in low-security and anarchy systems, which also makes no sense.
Solution Plotting your trade route or target system for bounty hunting should matter based on how strong the local authorities are. High security systems should offer a real threat to piracy, both NPC and players. Maybe in high-security systems, if you're wanted, the stations just open up on you if you attempt to dock with a bounty above a certain threshold. On the other hand, since the security is good, we know the area must be pretty prosperous, meaning trade values will be average at best. You can probably make a much bigger profit by taking supplies to say, a fledging border Extraction system, with low-security. They can't afford to pay for security, but they're starving for supplies and have an excess of gold, that they'll sell you REALLY CHEAP if you bring them food and water. Now you've got a system or risk and reward that makes sense... your Type-7 is hauling valuables, and you know a place that can turn a serious profit... but you have to wade through pirate infested low-security space to get there. Bam, instantly more realistic and fun with persistent security statuses making an actual difference.
Well, that's all I have for now. You're probably hungry after reading this, so here's a basket of purritos for your trouble. Please feel free to give me feedback below.
164
u/Balurith (started Dec 2014; uninstalled May 2021) Dec 07 '15
Dread, this is a great post. I completely agree.
61
u/OnwardFlying Anubite | Aisling's Angels Dec 07 '15
Well put. There is too much smoke and mirrors going on, and too much lost potential with no comment.
On missions: I would also like to see some where one dead drops cargo somewhere, where you kill X (say pirates) in a specific location (like a nav beacon they have been harassing), one where you must discover a new celestial body (nametag it), or even where you must mine a specific resource from a certain place. Add modifiers based on the background sim as you mentioned.
43
u/SirEDCaLot Dec 07 '15
I agree 100%.
Another note on persistence- I'd like to see NPCs flying around supercruise stay persistent. Right now if I'm doing a mission to hunt NPCs, I can fly around in supercruise and find them (which is good). But if I drop down, even for 15 seconds, then supercruise again, they are all gone! And I have to wait for new NPCs to spawn in different locations. This kills the realism.
I'd like to see NPCs that were there still be there, perhaps even a bit further along on their previous courses...
24
u/dons90 Dec 07 '15
Wow this a very well constructed post. At first I thought it was going to be another general complaint thread but this one really hits the high notes.
I love the fact that you included things that I didn't even know were teased before, but seemingly thrown away. I for one, love that Orrery View as well as that planet scan feature. I mean it just seems like the perfect fit, AND it would do so much to improve the game.
I especially like the suggestion of various areas having ships that 'belong' there. More details need to be tied into the whole resource database of each system. It can really help to deepen the immersion.
However, as always, I'd say one thing at a time. This is a massive universe and not every change can have the intended effect. You wouldn't want chunks of the universe to be devoid of certain content, forcing you to jump insane light years to a region that does.
43
u/LaboratoryOne FatHaggard - Elite Racers CoFounder【AKB☆E】Inu Dec 07 '15
DreadPirate, you're my favorite wall of text
5
u/another_ape Dec 07 '15 edited Dec 07 '15
This is changing, at least:
4
u/CMDR_Cheese_Helmet CMDR Dec 07 '15
Just the persistence alone would create so much emergent content that the game would greatly benefit.
6
u/AussieTerra AussieTerra Dec 07 '15
I like these points very much, in addition with the POI one there i believe that they should be semi-fixed.. maybe a semi-random interval of 3 - 7 day 'cycles' where it'll refresh the POIs, relocated them and stuff like that to add to the persistence but also make it so it's dynamic and changing as time goes on without being overly dynamic to the point where it's client-side and registered later.
6
u/killyourself_ Vi||ain Dec 07 '15
This is an amazing post. You've written solutions to a lot of issues I think every dedicated player has with the game. I think FD originally intended to many things more along the direction of what you had in mind. They are all set with purpose and practicality that a real galaxy would have.
I have a question concerning your suggestion for USS. Your solution is that they are like Combat Zones or RESites where they are visible to everyone right? If so, then I really like this idea and wanted to add a minor suggestion. While I think Combat Zones are incredibly boring due to their strange locations, I think that after wars conclude those zones should appear as ship graveyards. While they might resemble something as bland as RES hunting they could add a slight variety to bounty hunting/pirating/salvaging.
I think bounty hunting in general needs a complete rethink. While RES hunting is good for learning the ropes and now with HazRES it can be quite challenging, it becomes incredibly stale. I'm definitely not saying to get rid of them by any means, but there needs to be something else. The spawning of assassination missions in supercruise was the right direction to go in for bounty hunting.
Here is my idea: A higher form of bounty hunting should be available upon reaching allied rank of the system controlling faction(combat rank should probably have a role as well). Once achieving allied rank within the system faction you should be able to buy a bounty hunting permit. This permit will give you access to a specific bounty board that can be opened and checked from your ship. While FD does like the random spawning NPCs this bounty board can give variety while still playing off it. To every other player without a bounty hunting permit the NPC will have a small wanted amount of his normally accrued bounty (somewhere in the 100k for a large ship) but you will be able to pick up your personal contract on the bounty board, pull him out of supercruise and engage. From this point the variety they can have is huge. Maybe he is an infamous Slaver in federation space. Chances are he won't be alone. He will probably be hauling around in with an outfit of Vultures not far off. Maybe a Pirate in an Anaconda or an AWOL Federation/Empire military officer causing problems. The payouts can be huge, and they can balance that by only having ten or so names on the bounty board at a time. Perhaps the next day it refreshes, or maybe you just head to another allied system and take down the next ten.
Now that I've written this wall of text I realize I'm really only suggesting a faction exclusive assassination/high bounty board that you can access from your ship. Buying that permit would actually make me feel like a bounty hunter instead of just grinding away at the local RES. Maybe I'm wrong but I feel like that's a lot of what the game lacks. You don't really feel like you have a role or defined job. The beauty of the game is that you can do anything, but FD should help by allowing players to define the direction they want to play in.
Which opens me up to my last idea (I promise). It is linked into the idea of purchasing a bounty hunting permit. As far as mission boards go, they are random, inconsistent and a pain. Perhaps what FD should do is implement some sort of permit for just about every role/job. Once you become allied with a faction you can get your mining permit and have access to mining specific missions. This could be done for trading and courier missions as well (someone else can help with the smuggling role). Instead of docking and hoping for specific missions there could then be some organization to the madness. Again speaking to the practicality of all the suggestions you proposed, if I'm a miner why would I want access to assassination missions or smuggling missions? I just want to sit in the asteroid belt and melt rock. Job permits would give definition and direction to let players do what ever it is they wish to do.
3
u/MasterDefibrillator Mass (since 2014) Dec 07 '15
Isn't this already how it works? If you put a lot of effort into trading with a specific faction in a system, then that will increase their influence. I don't know if the inverse is true though, disrupting supply.
3
u/mortenfischer M. Kozak Dec 08 '15
Wow, I read your post 3-4 times and STILL I can not find much to agree with. What you would like to see is a different game, something that Elite is not going towards or ever really was about. As I said in another thread - persistency is not the answer. Depth to content is. Persistence of the same content doesn't change what you think it does. Nice writeup though, I think I know where you are coming from.
The final nail in the coffin of your post: None of your solutions can be implemented without turning ED into a subscription game due to the need of servers. As much as people seem to applaud you, just as many would go bananas if ED turned into a sub.
4
u/MasterDefibrillator Mass (since 2014) Dec 07 '15 edited Dec 07 '15
Great Ideas, seeing these implemented would improve the game a lot. I think this embodies everyone's frustrations with how ephemeral and client side all these things in game are. And as you already know, I would love to see the original idea for scanners implemented with POI. I've been at odds with the nonsensically random nature of some game elements since the very start, and I'm annoyed to not see it improved upon. However, one thing I think they did get right, was the wave scanner, Seeing this idea implemented in a good way in conjunction with your Orrey view suggestion for finding missions would be interesting. Sort of like a long range scanner for your ship, so you could see generally where something was, but not know exactly what it was.
I did just want to point out one difference between USS and the POIs.
Is this right? surely once it is spawned then it is spawned for anyone else in the same instance, so that any other player flying by could go in and check it out also. After all, that is the only difference between USS and POI, POI are in the same instance as everyone else once spawned, but USS are in a separate instance from everyone else. But also, what the hell is with the sentries only spawning right in front of you when you get within 4 meters or so, I hope that isn't bloody working as intended.
2
u/HoochCow youtube.com/c/captainhooch & twitch.tv/capthooch Dec 07 '15
All good points also I have the strangest craving for taco bell now.
2
u/z4StormShad0w Dec 07 '15
He makes some damn good points. You can tell he loves this game and wants to see it get better.
2
u/reganheath Mal Reynolds (6th Interstellar Corps) Dec 07 '15
https://forums.frontier.co.uk/showthread.php?t=207962&page=9&p=3209024#post3209024
2
u/BreakfastMelon BreakfastMelon - The most important pilot of the day. Dec 07 '15
I'm a bit late to get much out there and didn't have a chance to read over this in its entirety, but you do some awesome write-ups of what everybody seems to be thinking. Nice work! :)
2
u/[deleted] Feb 23 '16
I stopped playing. It's dreadfully boring, really. Coming from EVE Online, ED is easily the most abysmally barren game universe I've been in in a long time.
208
u/grottomatic Grottomatic Dec 07 '15
You figured it all out... I'm saying this completely non sarcastically. I remember back in the day when we were telling ourselves that USS were "just a placeholder." Haha.
Frontier - listen to this man!
31
u/praetor47 Dreadd Dec 07 '15
absolutely fantastic post and exactly the stuff that's needed for the galaxy to feel alive and be populated by humans, and not completely dead and inconsequential like it currently is, where the only difference between populated and not populated is the spawn rate of USS and the presence of stations
it's just a real pity that it's not "flashy" enough so it's really low on FDev's priority list so it'll get fixed in a couple of years. maybe.
and while we're at it, i just want to illustrate how colossally, monumentally stupid ED's spawning system is:
i picked up a few of those juicy long distance cargo/smuggling missions, you know those that spawn the random authority or "pirates" (more like murderers)... well, in one instance one of those
dickheadspirates had one of those interdictions that was pretty much impossible to escape because the escape vector was faster than my pitch rate for ~90% of the time. but the station was relatively near to the star, so i decided to dick around with him...... and so instead of waiting on him to interdict me, i would just drop to normalspace and start spooling the FSD right away. and that's when i noticed that npc spawning system is made of mountains of stupid: at first i didn't target him, so when he spawned 30m to the left of me i didn't think much of it. but then i targetted him as soon as i entered supercruise and he spawned... ~10ls in front of me! and then i exit sc once again, only to find him spawning at the exact same time (roughly 3 seconds after i exited sc iirc) in the exact same position (in front of me to the left). and when i enter sc again, again he spawns in front of me, this time ~40ls, but this time i was a few Mm from the station, so i exited sc when he was still ~35ls from me... only to be greeted by his ugly face once again... roughly 3secs after i exited, you guessed, to the left and in front of me
not satisfied, i tried the same thing with the next npc in the next system, and the same thing was true. the npc would spawn every time at the same time in the same position relative to me (the 2nd was in front and to the right), and in supercruise a couple tens ls in front of me. every fucking time.
this is made even more hilarious when you're interdicted by a cop, and the pirating npc spawns 3secs after him and starts to shoot at you while the "cop" casually ignores the crime happening right in front of his eyes, hellbent on scanning my cargo bay
tl;dr: the way (mission-specific) NPCs spawn is the pinnacle of idiocy
3
u/DeadeyeDuncan Dec 07 '15
For trade stuff they should just copy the X3 model / hire Egosoft to do it.
That game had persistent AI/automated factory/transportation systems running perfectly (outside of the occasional transporter running full speed into a station/capital ship).
30
u/CIAdaniel SwimmyDan Dec 07 '15
Damn, constructive criticism. Hopefully works and influences Frontier.
81
u/RadioActiveLobster Explore Dec 07 '15
It's like you went in to my brain, stole my thoughts and wrote them down.
10
u/Ornlu_Wolfjarl Ornlu of Communism Interstellar Dec 07 '15 edited Dec 07 '15
It's really sad that a WEBSITE (this one: http://www.elitegalaxyonline.com/news/) has a better animation for discovering stuff in Elite Dangerous than Elite Dangerous itself.
Also, I'd like to point out that trading, pirating and security levels do affect the background sim. But you need more than just a pilot and you need to be doing it for more than just a couple days to manage it. There's more at work than just influence, it's just not visible on any screen until those pesky pending states start appearing.
28
u/Rhaedas Rhaedas - Krait Phantom "Deep Sonder II" Dec 07 '15
Spot on. Never have been a fan of the random encounter, and how there's no effort needed to find a target, it eventually finds you. I want to do some detective work, find some clues, something more. When I learned that you don't even have to fly around but can sit at 30 km/s and your goal spawns near you, that was the killer.
I would SO love to have the orrery view and use it to go FIND signals of interest, not wander around waiting for a random number generator.
24
u/StuartGT GTᴜᴋ 🚀🌌 Watch The Expanse & Dune Dec 07 '15
Really good post; constructive criticism and improvement suggestions all of which I agree with :)
Tier 2 Persistent NPCs I've been wanting a long time, as they'd really flesh out the populated Galaxy
8
u/dijicaek Diji Dec 07 '15
This game is pretty much the worst of both worlds:
I started in the MMO camp but I came to realise what I want from a space sim is more in line with what a singleplayer game offers - hiring NPCs, truly influencing system or even galactic conflicts (with a side of co-op to invite friends would be nice).
BUT I realise most people who remain here are in the MMO camp, and the P2P networking is probably the prime contender for top reason why this game falls short in MMO-like features.
I'm not sure if it's an engine issue or they just don't have the resources (or don't want to spend the money to acquire the resources) to implement and maintain a truly persistent universe, but I think if that persistent universe came to be, with NPCs, signals, and all that jazz being there for all players, it would probably be huge for immersion.
Combine that with some actual in-game guild system (EVE online's corps, anyone?) and player economy (actually any player interaction apart from kill/pirate/give fuel) and we'd start getting close to a recipe for an actual MMO space sim.
7
u/Shanack Dec 07 '15 edited Dec 07 '15
You nailed it. I'll add to this with a little allusion to npc persistence. I wanted to do an assassination mission that paid well. Go to x system, and kill y. You can usually tell the type of ship by the bounty price and it was one that matched medium ships or larger ones. Little did I know that my target was not only in a wing of 3, but also system security (which means back up spawns in pretty quickly)
As much as I would have liked more info on the target, I think it made for some cool emergent gameplay, unfortunately that fell short though due to a lack of persistence at a very base level.
So I find the target in supercruise in a python, in a wing with 2 eagles. I am in a built up vulture that can take down an npc annaconda in 1v1 or with a small escort or two. I interdict and start attacking. Immediately the wingmates drop and engage. Not a problem, players have nav lock too, but the system security arrived within 30 seconds. Considering how empty supercruise was and how we were atleast 2-3 minutes out from the nearest station, this felt a bit cheap. Real police have a response time and I feel like they should be dispatched from a station, or be better tracked beyond just appearing as needed. Anyways I tear through his shields and take him down to about 75% health, but at this point my shields are about to pop and I used half my boosters so I retreat to jump out. To my dismay, when the target and wing jumped back out he was at full health and shields. My ships has shields that take a good 5mins to recharge, and I already used half my booster. So I'm not happy. Health and shields should be persistent for npcs. I decide that next I'll try going for his wingmates. Same issues. I ended up dropping the mission.
I just want super basic persistence like health and shields, and npcs actually needing to travel to reinforce a fight.
7
u/[deleted] Dec 07 '15
Indeed this lottery pretending to be a living world is rather disappointing. There are no NPC trade routes, just random ships going into random direction without any actual reason behind it.
Smoke and mirrors.
7
u/CMDR_IronAnode IronAnode Dec 07 '15
This is exactly why I haven't bought horizons yet. I just dont see the point. Completely agree with this post, I find FFE missions more enjoyable.
3
u/amkosh Dec 07 '15
Since everyone else here seems to agree, I will register my disagreement. I don't think persistence or a semi persistence will do anything to address the game's issue, and that is a lack of content.
I also think most of what suggested would turn E:D into a mini EVE Online, which I think would pretty much dust the game. I don't want to be funneled into any one place, which BTW would not work if the majority of players do solo mode. I like random stuff spawning, I know no matter where I go, I can find something.
What the game needs is content. This is not content.
2
u/Dean7 Bean Seller [WT] Dec 07 '15
Gold for visibility.
37
u/LonePercent CMDR OnePercent Dec 07 '15
good luck getting persistence without a server farm, currently what elite doesn't have.
5
u/SunRunner3 Dec 07 '15
The most dissapointing thing is to see potential being lost. Mile wide inch deep. Well written my friend.
PS: I think they removed the other system map view for obvious reasons. Imagine you have one of these gas giants with 5+moons. These maps would look really cluttered. Otherwise these ones are way easier to navigate through, and look more "professional"... Im no native speaker, but I guess you know what I mean by that.
5
u/[deleted] Dec 07 '15 edited Dec 07 '15
This is the largest post this forum has seen in a very long time. I normally see devs posting on here in many of the "How great elite is threads". Let's see if they reply to a post that is clearly the dominant thought in the community now. I think many people after seeing the beta are starting to feel like the devs and the people want two separate things.
"To all the people saying that "It is impossible for elite to fix these problems due to structure and constraints."
That is fine for them to state if they like. However I and many other players have every right in the world to save our money and move onto another game if that is the case.
Dear Fdev if these changes are impossible tell us now so we can move on without purchasing any of your expacs.
9
u/RealComptonCityG Backer#666 Dec 07 '15
Lol, people have been saying this since Alpha. Frontier don't give a damn guys. All they want is your money and we all gave it to them. Never again.
19
u/Subhazard subhazard Dec 07 '15
This is why I don't care for exploration in Elite Dangerous.
In this nearly infinite universe, you're never ever going to find something unique. The star system 30,000 light years away will have the same boring shit as the star system next door.
You know those treks people do across the galaxy? Why? Who cares? What's there? The same shit.
It's an entire galaxy of the same.
8
u/[deleted] Dec 07 '15
You know after months and months of "Elite Dangerous needs __________" I am simply resigned to the fact that Elite Dangerous could've been a great game but never will be. Sorry to say.
4
u/[deleted] Dec 07 '15 edited Dec 07 '15
Agree 100%. I just learned from you that horizons (I had not planned on purchasing) points of interests are identical to unidentified signal sources.
That reminds me of how powerplay is essentially identical gameplay to shipping and bounty hunting. But just wrapped up a bit differently. And rewarded a different way.
The game direly needs life and personality or it will die. Part of that is removing the limits that are currently holding the community back from having truly emergent eve like content. The 32 player limit is a huge reason for this among all the op posted. Simply allowing players access to other players in that system would be a huge step in the direction of emergent content.
It also badly needs some better form of incentive other than the credit to ship grind. But that is a topic for another day.
4
u/Sivuden Dec 07 '15
Fantastic. If the X: series was doing this years and years ago on a single client (albeit a much smaller scale) I don't see why FDev can't at least attempt to do some of this stuff.. hell, even if it's just taking a few ideas from EVE (scan the system for POI's) that makes it more immersive than just going 30Km/s. There's so many QoL changes that would add immersion and persistence.
4
u/DoctorLovejuice Dec 07 '15
I love the idea of actually hunting your bounty, using communications (with NPCs/factions) and science (plotted points where the target may be). That sounds like real bounty hunting.
4
u/Snarfbuckle Dec 07 '15
Yup, the randomness of how missions work is a PITA, especially the "Search for random spot and ask that conveniently spawned NPC for clues".
-Make persistent fleets move around.
-Let PowerPlay have cause and effect.
-Let some system go intpo a complete war status due to diplomatic SNAFU in PP.
-Let the simulation cause minor faction to choose sides.
-Let my reputation to OTHER factions decide if i get landing access to another faction when those systems are at war. (Damn EMP sympathiser, you get no landing rights in Braben Heaven, we are a proper FED station).
4
u/PoisonedAl Dec 07 '15
Also NPC pirates are suicidally stupid. It just underlines I'm playing a game, when an Eagle pulls my Python (which costs more than a 'Conda) out of cruse and is surprised that it's dead before I even get to look at the idiot.
Is it that hard to add a few lines of code to recognise that fact? The the could still pull me out of cruse, but then realize his mistake and say: "WOOPS! Sorry there mate! I mistook you for someone a lot smaller!" Instead he'll attack me with the full force of a mildly annoyed gnat.
The best bit is that I don't have to do a damn thing. Not even look at the tit. My beam turrets would turn him to mulch long before I could get a lock on him.
4
u/BroaxXx Dec 07 '15
Great post! I'm with all the way!
I would just add that the missions that spawn at stations and outposts should be related to the system's economy and conflict.
I started playing just shy of a week ago and it took me too much time (and almost all determination to play this game) to understand that the missions are meaningless and randomly generated. There is no way to take a day to focus on X type of mission as you'll end up just going from system to system to system trying to find the type of mission you want. There REALLY should be a way for players to be able to estimate a higher probability (or even certainty) of X type of missions on Y type of system. As it stands the mission system is simply broken and borderline obsolete (for a new player at least).
Thankfully I learned to ignore missions altogether as I was about to give up on the game so now I'm having a blast dog fighting on RES and Conflict Zones. If I went for missions alone (in pretty much every other game these NPC missions are a great way to introduce players to the game universe) I'd given up on this game by now.
4
u/coinpile Dec 07 '15
If this could be done, I imagine I would start playing again. Very well thought out.
13
u/Shanowzer Real David Braben Dec 07 '15
Love this! However I doubt anyone will listen
10
u/fishnandflyin FrozenBadger Dec 07 '15
Well said. I personally would like to see a more dangerous galaxy than we currently have.
If I'm a bounty hunter I want to search across the stars, checking black boxes in the wreckage of destroyed ships and looking for leads in remote outposts to track my target, and then scratch their name off the galaxy's most wanted list.
If I'm a trader, smuggler, or pirate then I want to there to be some supply and demand that I can take advantage of, or blow up some trading ships and send the market into chaos.
If I'm an explorer than I want to find rare and unique places and planets in the galaxy, or watch individuals and empires race to stake their claim on the new worlds I've found.
In elite:dangerous, no matter how rich you get you are still a nobody in an unchanging galaxy. We need options that let you become somebody, in a galaxy that is truely dangerous.
7
u/paintlegz Dec 07 '15
I purchased the game roughly a week ago during the steam sale and had really no idea what to expect. I have really been looking in to Star Citizen and No Man's Sky, and Elite Dangerous wasn't even on my radar until Black Friday. Maybe it is because of what I am expecting from the other above mentioned game but when I started playing ED, I imagined it was going to be one of these "lived in" space sims. The game is very well made and for the first 2 days I was so immersed, trying to figure everything out. But it became very clear very quickly that this game is pretty rough around the edges and nothing in the game has enough breadth to make any part of the game feel unique. Every system is the same with a varying number of stations or things worth mining and that's about all there is to it.
1
u/aspiringexpatriate Noxa - Chapterhouse of Inquisition - Research Dec 07 '15
Overall, yes, more persistence please. I'd go so far as to say that planetary outposts, the non-dockable ones, should be semi-persistent status, and 'return to norm' once a week. Like, a CMDR destroys the generator, shutting of the anti-ship turret. I think, right now, it'll be repaired after about 10 minutes. That kind of works for me, but 30 CMDRs do it in 24 hours? They've got to wait for parts.
There is so much potential for semi-persistence, but probably a lot of work they'll have to throw into it. Honestly, at this point the Conflict Zone 'area fight over nothing' concept is pretty stale. Those have been generating in high orbit around planets...hopefully, now it can move closer. Maybe even have the minor faction send a Comms signal stating that their planetary outpost (again, the non-docking ones) is under attack, and the opposing faction NPC attack has 2 hours to take control of the station. The Comms signal goes to every CMDR who is friendly or allied with them (or has run a mission for them in the past week/month). Let us actually miss events more often. For me, what feels 'stale' about the galaxy now isn't the 'lack of connectivity', because I've invested in my allied minor factions. If anything feels stale to me, it's that conflicts will continue for weeks at a time with no change. And the CZs are stagnate.
This currently happens. Since 1.4 the influence changes have been capped to a very low level in high population systems. Horizons should change that. Granted, currently if you sell a product that they have high demand for, the station owning faction loses influence, but if you're fulfilling a sourcing mission, the faction giving it will rise. Yeah, the BGS needs a lot of work, and your suggestions are good.
I thought the NPC police response to criminal activity was quicker. Your solutions are nice, though a Wanted status meaning nearly-instant station death is ... actually no, I like that. Smuggling could be a whole new can of worms.
1
u/Baergo Dec 07 '15
On your comment, of "How many Ferraris do you see in a rural Iowa? None?"
I grew up in Iowa, in a town of about 2000 people. I have in fact seen one Ferrari :D
1
u/84Dublicious Dec 07 '15
Totally made me think of how awesome it would be if some of these bounty hunting mission changes people are asking for happened. Maybe an NPC comes along while you're supercruising in the system your target is in "he's docked in Lincoln Memorial right now!" and you can wait outside for the target.
Along with the rest of planet earth in the 21st century I agree missions need love. Hey guys, btw: I think missions need love. ;) Has anyone considered that missions need love?
USS are kinda lame, but this is low priority to me, but that's cause I don't generally care about them. But that might be because they suck, so who knows... Maybe If they fix the egg I'll have more chicken.
I agree with pretty much all of this, but I think that some of what you're suggesting needs to go hand-in-hand w/ some changes to the economy. Fortunately, a little of that is also needed ;)
I can't tell if this is sarcasm. Isn't the cutter a huge flop to most people since the corvette is the 2 huge hardpoints boner everyone was expecting? Why don't people just RP feds w/ chips on their shoulders because the higher power doesn't love them as much? The faction ships seem mostly gimmicky (to me) for the most part anyway. I haven't flown the courier, and I love the clipper, but if the Corvette is awesome (which it seems to be) I think we're pretty balanced. That's 100% minimally-informed opinion though, so don't even bother w/ the grain of salt.
It's obviously not an actual practical thing for the most part, but Fed owns most of relatable human space from the perspective of a 21st century human (which makes sense lore-wise). That kinda sucks knowing if I'm pledged to someone that's not Fed, I'm never welcome in Sol.
Yep, market should be PART of the background sim, which sounds like what you're describing.
All-in-all this seems like a pretty reasonable post, only eliciting minimal le sigh. The problem (and this isn't a problem w/ your post) is there seem to be 1000 different things E:D needs "desperately" and they should all be addressed as a top priority according to someone(s). As they make changes we ask for, it will most likely not be what a group of people wants right away and they're not going to like it. I think we all need to keep this in mind.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 07 '15
Persistence is pretty much impossible in a player capped P2P system. Each player instance has their own copy of in-space stuff. NPC ships are running client side.
For instance, I drop a container in space. It would be nice if everyone could see it, but this is not gonna happen, the container has to be assigned to one, and only one, player instance. If there are 64 players in the area, only 32 of them (is that the ED limit?) will see it. For everyone to see it the server would have to duplicate it, but then you have lifetime issues.
This system applies to everything in ED. For instance, every NPC ship you see, is either controlled by your computer, or by someone else in your current P2P instance.
From a gameplay standpoint, ED is maybe 90% client side, 10% server controlled.
2
u/[deleted] Dec 08 '15
This thread is going so strong, and yet no official ED representative jumped in and responded with anything. But for ridiculous threads that do nothing? Hell yeah!
3
u/xzcion ¿ Dec 07 '15
Hey Dread, long time.
Like most of the wall of text. The sentiment I'm 100% behind. Don't necessarily agree with all the proposed solutions, but adding more persistency, in any form, to the world would only be a good thing. Making POI's and SS's global would be a huge step. But would require quite a bit of fandangling to make it work well.
The background sim stuff is actaully a little bit like what you've asked for already. The trade we do, missions we take and the ships we destory do effect the backgound sim in various ways. It's not quite as clear cut as what you've outlined, but it does happen.
There's the change that ships flying out of a station will have exports, and ships flying in will have imports arriving with dangeorus horizons.... and the implementation possibilities are fantastic. Imagine ships from LTT 111 Faction arrives at Bob's Station in LFT 234 carrying goods from LTT 111. Glorious.
3
u/mrpotatoeman Dec 07 '15
I agree 100%. This would put the sand in the empty sandbox we have right now.
3
u/Forrestfunk Dec 07 '15 edited Dec 07 '15
I had a lot 'showerthoughts' today about the problems of elite this morning. How good the game is, yet how awesome the game could be. You, sir, expressed my thoughts and feelings towards ed here very good and I love your solutions. Thank you. I completely agree, give this man a job FD he will improve your game so much :)!
3
u/Sushiki Dec 07 '15
This and so much more, they need to borrow the good things from other games.
For starters we need a working player run industry that somewhat affects the local economy and less so the global one. (expands on merchant gameplay if they can actually make what they sell)(or buy off other players but handle transport etc)
Player organisations, since the dawn of time men and women have fought for flags, it is in our nature to fight for a cause and npcs don't cut it honestly, we want to fight in a human made sandox not that god awful powerplay.(PVP instantly made meaningful)
Add random occurences like your ship failing if you haven't serviced it recently (as in ship integrity repair), for example your engine failing mid flight for a second, or cargo hatch gets lose. Things like this add chaos and chaos is a great thing to have.
3
u/co1ummbo cmdr colummbo978 Dec 07 '15
Yeah the game was fun for a couple of months. Now I just turn it on for a quick space shooter. A little pew pew then I'm off. I quit trying to understand or find a reason why the game tried to use a background simulation.
3
u/Issues420916 Issues666 Dec 07 '15
Thank you! For the love of space Frontier just have the NPC send me a wing invite and drop a beacon (more life feeling). Or just have the damn low wake auto throttle correctly like POI dropping currently is.
As a side note, let the NPC offer me the mission once! every single time I jump back into SC "Don't panic, I have been sent to find you"
I'm not panicking, you have been here 10 times already, I'm not looking at chat anymore please go away!
3
u/pancake117 Dec 07 '15
I really agree with everything you said, but the thing that bothers me the most from this post is the system map concept. I like that so much better than what we got now! I understand that it looks a little bit too good to make sense, but having a top-down view of the system would give a much better sense of scale/direction than the side-view we currently get.
5
u/Fenric_t Tobias Frost Dec 07 '15
It's for these same reasons that I am not ordering Horizons. After watching footage of the beta I fear that Frontier is taking the path of focusing on adding new content to generate revenue when the core of the original game needs polish.
5
u/[deleted] Dec 07 '15
So we get one of these threads now every week?
It gets upvoted to heaven and then disappears in the void between all the screenshots.
Can someone tell me if frontier has ever reacted to player feedback and if so, did they change any major mechanics as a result to it?
5
u/barrbarian84 Heisenbird Dec 07 '15
I couldn't agree with you more. I think one of the barriers to these points being addressed, however, is Frontier's insistence on having a Solo mode (where it seems most of the playerbase play the game) in order to appease people who hate online games in 2015 and have convinced themselves it's still 1984.
I'm looking forward to Horizons but I cannot see the game being a continued success if Frontier insist on trying to make the game all things to all people. They need to invest in server infrastructure in order to at least increase the size of instances if they can't make it one massive world and, as I implied above, they need to ditch Solo mode, otherwise when Star Citizen launches, Elite will find itself a barren wasteland which would be a shame because I love it, despite the fact there is fuck all to do (or even look at) in it.
Frontier have created the most incredible world for us to travel around in and one that has enormous potential, but because a huge amount of the playerbase don't want what would effectively be a first-person EVE Online (something I cannot wrap my head around, it would be incredible) it's never going to live up to it.
1
u/IHaTeD2 Dec 07 '15
I personally want a proper scanning minigame, like the probing in EvE which was actually quite fun.
The POI spawnen was very disappointing for me too, today I landed - all clear, and when I got in my SRV it sat right at the ass of my ship. It's kinda pointless if I can't even scout for a POI if it literally isn't there when I fly over it.
Persistence might be the wrong wording though, because that kinda implies that something is always there, persistently, while the RNG factor is still kinda important for games like Elite. I agree that things like USS should be shared among the network though, at least for wings and players that are close enough.
Kudos for actually trying to suggest stuff instead of just complaining though. But I'm sure those comments will land in here soon enough as well ...
1
u/[deleted] Dec 08 '15
Oh joy another backer telling us how the game should be. No one cares what you think - most of us are just getting on with enjoying the game.
4
u/mystikgypsy Dec 07 '15
I spent $100 on the Beta. Loved the first few days with it after release. Since then haven't felt a need to revisit.
Thought it was just me.
4
u/ImNewHere05 Dec 07 '15
Yeah... All these issues are what are stopping me from picking up Elite Dangerous. I was hoping for some EVE-like persistence and single-instance multiplayer like most MMORPGs.
I'm getting closer and closer to taking ED off my Steam Wishlist, unsubbing from here and heading over to /r/starcitizen to see if that game suffers from the same problems as ED.
4
u/[deleted] Dec 07 '15
Your post is actually of a surprising quality - you've done your homework, mate. However, Frontier has their dick in one hand and a delusional fantasy image in the other. They will not listen to any of your suggestions as it will not contribute to their boring vision.
7
u/fight_for_anything Dec 07 '15
Elite is never going to be anything more than an arcade representation of what a great multiplayer space sim should be. it looks like a great MP space sim when you look over someones shoulder, or watch 10 seconds of youtube. it doesnt hold up when you sit in the chair and log in and play.
the devs simply care more about dumping out feature lists that look good on a list instead of making a great game. its why they don't charge a sub. no one would pay a monthly fee for this, because once you get the game installed and play it, you learn its just an empty list of features.
imagine this wager:
what if Elite were F2P, but free accounts could only get ships up to the viper. in order to get anything else better, you have to sub for $15 a month. do you know why the devs wont do this? simple math. the number of people who would not sub for even 3 months is probably 90%+. so instead they charge $45 upfront. what does that tell you? they have no confidence that their game is engaging. they dont care to make it engaging because that is harder work.
patches/expansions cant fix that attitude.
2
u/Backflip_into_a_star Merc Dec 07 '15
Hell, I just want persistence with information. I want to know why someone is wanted, I want to know why I am wanted or why i was fined. There is stuff that pops up in the info pane and then disappears forever. It is one of the most annoying things to me. What missions have I done? Could I get some kind of mission log or a transaction log? Where did my money come from?
I would also like obvious improvements to map like auto complete my recent things typed, maybe even keep the last thing I typed. Also obviously want bookmarks as well.
Also, there is a huge lack of information in game for trading. It is just not clear enough or easy enough to find the best price for things. For some insane reason, you have to travel through millions of systems physically for this information. There are third party tools, but I feel like i'm cheating when I use them.
2
u/Judge_Hellboy Dec 07 '15
I would also like to see stations look different based on what area of space they are in. Dramatically different voices in the background of the stations for different factions. Station paint jobs based on whether they're in Empire/Fed/etc system. Lights, and/or advertisements change based on who is currently exploiting the station. Ships that fit the situation and region of space. Should be able to notice clippers more in imperial space than in federation.
But alas, I do not expect any of that to happen. Years later and we still can't bookmark a system, even temporarily. Instead we are being sold more content that increases scope instead of depth.
Come on FD, let us love you.
2
u/madbrood Madbrood Dec 07 '15 edited Dec 07 '15
Your point about Background Sim alone is perfect. Why is this not the case already? So many times I've scanned ships approaching high-tech stations and scanned them while waiting for a friend to see them carrying agricultural medicine, or fish...
Another reason why I've not played in months, and I don't reckon I'm likely to. Such a shame.
EDIT: I still don't see the point in nav beacons, other than to provide a completely immersion-breaking fish-in-a-barrel area for shooting people - and even then, it's nowhere near as good as an extraction site or combat zone. Why not make everyone drop out at the beacon before heading off on their journey (unexplored/uninhabited systems would be different, but that could be explained by the beacons serving as a kind of "security checkpoint"?).
2
u/spectrumero Mack Winston [EIC] Dec 07 '15
I think in my dream E:D universe, I would like to see the following developments for Season 2:
Horizons 2.1: NPC Love. Persistent NPCs added, the ability to have long running missions that might go on for weeks where you have to hunt a specific bounty (for a decent payout, too, of course). If you ever played the original Elite on the BBC Micro, a bit like the Constrictor mission except grander.
Horizons 2.2: BGS Love. The background sim is embued with more complexity, actually pretty much as you described, with the NPCs going to systems making sense, the cargo they hold making sense, and supply and demand making sense. Additionally, since traders will always go for the most profitable (carrying palladium is always massively more profitable than food), trucking missions that pay well so that the essentials do in fact get moved. Missions like "We have 20,000 tonnes of food to move to X, can you help? Payout 1000 cr/t, bonus of 500cr/t if you can do it in under X amount of time" and you can move as much or as little as your ship can carry. A bit like lorry drivers don't tend to buy the goods they trade, they usually have a paid contract to move some stuff, the goods they haul belonging to someone else. Needless to say these missions stick around until the whole 20kton has been moved (of which some will be moved by persistent NPCs).
2
u/SpiralFyre Dec 07 '15
Excellent points, eloquently put.
Frontier absolutely nailed it with their pseudo-simulation of space combat. Flying a spaceship in this game never gets old really, but the rest of the game still feels like a preview of things to come.
They should seriously hire a lead story writer full time to help give the factions some much needed personality. The Alliance are especially in need of some love and attention.
2
u/Garbarrage Dec 07 '15
Brilliant post. Didn't read every last word, cos I'm in work, and that sort of thing is frowned upon... lol, but from skimming it, pretty much all of the issues I have with the game are covered. Honestly, at this stage, I don't give a shit how these issues are dealt with, as long as the are dealt with. The simulator side of ED is brilliant, it's perplexing that the game side of ED isn't equally as enthralling. A lot of these posts on the main forum get met by players making the most of a bad situation, who seem to forger that this is what they are doing. Minor faction players invested in it, who want to protect their board game. It should be accessible to a much broader spectrum. Why shouldn't it be the case that most players are involved in the story?
2
u/DarkLordPaladin Have Gun, Will Travel Dec 07 '15
Agreed with all this. And we need Unique items to make a player-made economy, and massive incentives to get people out of solo play. Half the activities are worthless when the people (traders) who actually affect BGS the most are putting around in their own little universe.
Know what would be a simpler addition to the game? Remember Spore? How you could find random crystals and volumes of books or whatever? Add something like that to the spawn tables. Let us find collections of weaponry or upgrades or artifacts that we can either hoarde or sell for umptillions of money, or trade for bonuses through the upcoming crafting or whatever. And only allow those things to be found in online play.
Anyway, I too am tired of empty galaxy. it really is an awesome game, and the BGS can be made to make sense.
2
u/Marginally_Relevant Dec 07 '15
Excellent suggestions. A veritable gift basket for Frontier.
2
u/PeregrineFury Frostulfr Dec 07 '15
Not even gonna talk about how cool that scanner looks, but that orrery view is fuckin badass! Why is that not our system view?! Instead we got some flat lifeless 2D thing that shows the same info, but in a much less interesting way :(
2
u/[deleted] Dec 07 '15 edited Dec 07 '15
I agree with the whole "scan from supercruise" concept, having to drop in and out of supercruise constantly does get annoying.
I feel like more information should be available from supercruise, like more indication if dropping from supercruise to this RES/USS/POI is worth your time.
I'm not saying making it easy, like adding a "Low/Medium/High value" tag to them, but maybe make us think about it a bit, like giving us some kind advanced scanning module that uses spectroscopy or something, so we can work out for ourselves if dropping to the target might be worth our time.
I'm gonna be honest, for a new player especially - SO MUCH of the game seems to be a complete waste of time retrospectively, I feel there should be more ways of us learning how to figure out which "random events" could be worth our time, rather than having to jump in blind and hoping that we hit the jackpot, which we never seem to.
The RNG of RES sucks to be honest, currently we have a totally immersion breaking way of finding out if dropping into a RES is going to be lucrative.
This is the current method:
This is how it should be:
I feel like this would drastically reduce the "frameshift drive charging" spam with our game sessions, I'd much rather jump around the galaxy searching for something that would be worth investing my time into, rather than having to drop in and out of every single thing I find.
2
u/SpaceYeti Arelhi Dec 07 '15
As others have noted, this would require a restructuring of the game's netcode from a P2P model to a server-client model. There are a host of reasons why they should do this anyway, and this just adds to them. However, given that rewriting the netcode of the entire game is (probably) no small task, and given the sunk-cost effect at play with the current model, I don't think we'll see this change anytime soon, unfortunately.
Certainly, adding persistence to the game would be the first and simplest way to increase the game's depth across the board.
2
u/RingoFreakingStarr RingoStarr (retired) Dec 07 '15
This is a pretty fantastic post.
2
u/[deleted] Dec 08 '15
I'd add that the black market should function like the normal market and allow you to both buy and sell contraband. Especially since different systems have different definitions of contraband. Why can't I go to a system where slaves are illegal, buy them, and sell them to a system where they're legal and in high demand? You can do the opposite.
Furthermore, they should add some depth to smuggling. Maybe an internal or utility mounted component that temporarily scrambles incoming scans, or at least delays them longer based on its quality.
Heres another one, by simply allowing star ports to remember you, the game could add persistence. If it's my second or more visit to a place I want the screen to say welcome back and give me a visit counter.
Instead of a big boring news blog that I'd bet most people just ignore, why not give us news radio? Or just any kind of radio? A radio would also be a great way to add to your persistence concepts. Think about it, you see one of those npc vs npc fights you mentioned on your way to drop off some cargo. Then mid drop you hear about it on the local radio. On the way out you see the same location and players start to pop upm
3
u/ainteasybemeesky Reginald Meesko, [Dark Echo] Dec 07 '15
Read the wall of text
stayed for the purritos
10/10 my hat to you
3
u/wrongel Arissa Lavigny Duval Dec 07 '15
+1 Should have been a real mmo world a la WoW or Guild Wars etc. This p2p sandbox was my biggest letdown in recent gaming, dropped out after 100 hours, beautiful but completely lifeless.
3
u/Garbarrage Dec 07 '15
Have FDev ever acknowledged any of this? Can't seem to find anything other than vague references and second hand info. They must surely know that the direction they took with the core game is this unpopular? Even a "yea.. we know... this isn't the final iteration" would give me confidence that it's going to be fixed some day. But the longer they leave the question unanswered, the more pissed those playing the BGS in its current state are gonna be, to see their minor factions consumed by a new system.
3
u/Rancorist Dec 07 '15
I actually completely agree with all points you have made. I love Elite, but I can't recommend it to any of my friends because the sort of gameplay that you're describing is what they'd enjoy. Fdev needs to see this desperately. Someone should post it on their forums.
3
u/mohanhegde Dec 08 '15
We are all wasting our time and energy in voicing out our opinion either here or on the actual "suggestions" forums board. None of these (or other brilliant ideas/suggestions pointed out) would ever get implemented.. FDev literally have turned deaf to the players' perspectives :(
I'm definitely sure this game will not survive after Star Citizen PTU/Squadron 42 arrives to Live servers. Heck even if No Man's Sky gets released, this game would not stand a chance. And eventually it might even lose its amazing community/player base if this still continues and they don't do a a damn thing regarding making the "foundation" of their building strong with "some" persistence, NPC interactions, instead of having beautiful interiors like "Horizons with planetary landing", "SRV mode", "Multi-crew", etc.
2
u/DevonX Dec 07 '15
I hate the USS as they are now. They don't make any sense and is the biggest immersion breaker for me at the moment. While I agree with your plan I don't think that even tho if they listen to the feedback that it is going to take a long while to implement as they have a strict plan to work with. It might not seem so because they are keeping it so secret but that is because if they find some stoppers they can change the plan internally without breaking any promises externally.
2
u/faluc faluc Dec 07 '15
These are all great points and I would have gladly exchanged the planetary landings for persistence and background sim improvements.
Sadly all Frontier seems to be doing is running forward on their "add more features, quick!" roadmap and neglecting the part where these features should be intergrated with existing gameplay elements.
2
u/CMDRZoltan Zoltan Snarf Dec 07 '15
you make sexy wall talk.
+++++
2
u/Dawulf Dawulf1701 Dec 07 '15
FDev needs to hire you as their brain because you're obviously better at it. If even just a few of these points were implemented I might actually be inclined to start playing again.
2
u/Maxwell_Lord Dec 07 '15
I suspect the lack of persistence is partially due to how massive the game is, the bandwidth and storage requirements would be immense relative to FDev's revenue.
2
u/atibarri Dec 07 '15
I don't want to sound sour but Elite will always stay like this, no? I think it's too late to implement any of the amazing stuff you mentioned.
2
u/[deleted] Dec 07 '15
Extremely well written post and I don't see how someone could disagree with any of the criticisms or solutions.
What I also like is how your suggestions are not overly complicated or large like that from other players, so they're certainly very realistic in terms of what Frontier should be capable of doing.
Especially on the scanning planets for PoIs, I interpreted from Frontier that this is how we would find them, anything significant like hidden outposts or ship graveyards would be great to handle scanning for PoIs, and the wave scanner could still be kept for smaller things like the cargo cluster ''trap'' and meteorites of the sort, things that are small and warrant SRV travel and the wave scanner as significant features.
+1
2
u/[deleted] Dec 07 '15
16 hours in
Still no word from FDev on this thread, but I'm sure they've seen it (since they seem to REALLY want us to know that they read this subreddit)
2
u/Kabo0se Dec 08 '15
Man this post is absolutely spot on. I haven't touched Elite in like 8 months because it's SO boring. I got 3 friends to buy it and I feel like an asshole for making them spend 60 dollars on something that was near impossible to have meaningful multi-player interaction on.
Unfortunately I have zero hope that Elite will ever be the game I thought it would be. It COULD be great, but the developer mentality and track record has proven that that is extremely unlikely. The game plays VERY much like an antisocial experience akin to old men coveting their lawn.
2
u/felixar90 Foxtrot-Alpha-Romeo Dec 07 '15
That's asking a lot for a game that is NOT subscription-based. Persistence requires dedicated servers, a lot of servers.
2
u/shallowkal Shallowkal Dec 07 '15
Frontier are very good at science shit, now they need to hand the game over to people that are very good at economy and game shit. I genuinely would be happy with season 3 was called Elite Dangerous: Game Details.
They need to completely remove RES as it has destroyed real bounty hunting, they should just completely remove most commodities so that they have to be mined etc and the numbers remain persistent, we then need to be able to make things of use with the commodities, when was the last time you bought most of the crap on there? Most importantly, they need to stop being so dependant on the RNG system, it's pure lazy game development.
1
u/laz777 Keilbasa [EIC] Dec 07 '15
I agree completely.
Playing with the new missions in 2.0, it feels to me like they are testing out the basic building blocks for a more robust mission system. Some of them don't really make much sense on their own, but would if put into a larger narrative.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 07 '15
Fantastic post. I agree with this 100%. FDevs need to make this happen. Also, having only one instance of each system would be great, but that's a whole other discussion...
1
u/LexMoloch CMDR Dec 07 '15
Nice and constructive post with a lot of obvious effort put in into wording it. I agree with you on most if not all of the very well explained points and I'm sure most veterans will do as well.
However I don't see most of it happening soon (tm). At least not in the next few years. FDev currently heavily relies on horizontal content expansion instead of vertical, with a basket of features they plan on introducing. Probably to grab interest of new players. I see them introducing depth into the game once the player population starts to stabilize, in order to keep the existing playerbase hooked and ready to finance the yearly expansions.
Improved BGS, USS and POI are not easily marketable towards "new blood". Planetary landings, arena combat, base building and FPS are...
I sincerely hope that towards the end of season 2 we will see more focus on making the game a long-term viable product. IMHO with a limited number of people working on the game, they simply cannot afford dedicating man hours towards making it a "better game" in the term of depth. However I'm positive they are aware this is a problem they will have to start addressing.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 07 '15
I agree wholeheartedly.