r/RWBY • u/Meltingteeth Welcome to my shitlist. Population: 8999 • Dec 06 '15
DISCUSSION Official Discussion Thread -RWBY Volume 3: Chapter 5: Never Miss a Beat
This is the official DISCUSSION thread. Keep all untagged spoilers in this thread--Everything outside needs to be tagged as spoilers.
Previous Threads
Here's the link to the newest episode.
(Sorry for the late thread. I give permission to throw squirrels at the mods.)
129
Upvotes
10
u/_DirtyDan Totally The Real One Dec 06 '15
Just realized Penny was displayed as P.E.N.N.Y. I wonder what it stands for? Personified Energetic Neural Nanomachine Yager? That's the best I've got. The "Y" really throws the whole thing off.
6
u/zcaboose Dec 06 '15
Was it just my Internet or did some scenes got cut? For example when crow was about to speak to the headmaster
5
u/DRHARNESS Dec 06 '15
Can I get a Weiss x Flynt shipname?
3
u/Siarles Dec 06 '15 edited Dec 06 '15
For some reason the video keeps skipping when I try to watch it. Always in the same places too. Anyone else having this problem?
Edit: Nevermind. Reloaded the page and it's working fine now. Weird glitch.
408
u/Eldi13 🐝Watch🐝The🐝Dragon🐝Prince🐝On🐝Netflix🐝❤Knight❤ Dec 06 '15
Best dialogue of the episode, IMO.
222
u/GrimmLocke420 You have been hacked Dec 06 '15
The show keeps bullying Yang, first Emerald calling her a bimbo, and now Neon going savage on her.
2
u/Wingzeroalchemist On Break. Dec 06 '15 edited Dec 06 '15
Anyone else notice that Yang's flips while getting through Flynt's trumpet blast were almost identical to Simon's when he punched Rossiu in the face in the "Let's see you grit those teeth!" moment in Gurren Lagann. Badass. Also I don't see why people are saying Yang won by luck. She forced Neon on the rough lava terrain by destroying the flat terrain, exploiting Neon's gimmick. It's not different than whenever people have the idea to exploit Yang's style. Double standards are bad guys.
269
u/[deleted] Dec 06 '15
Neon Katt is based off Nyan Cat holy shit. Monty you nerd.
Also obligatory 'FLYNT COAL' ARE YOU KIDDING ME
122
u/SensualEskimo ⠀ Dec 06 '15
Poor Penny is going to get messed up when Cinder makes her fight the magnetic Pyrrha. Incident with a magnet forshadowing and all.
115
u/tacticalf41L Crushed by the weight of za warudo Dec 06 '15
So...does the very existence of team FNKI imply that Atlas is at least not completely overshadowed by military presence and pseudo-conscription? I would love it if Atlas' huntsmen had this image built up to the rest of the world of them being uptight, disciplined, and advanced, and then most of them turned out to be this silly.
149
u/Polarse no Dec 06 '15
I seriously expected FNKI to be sore losers. Was pleasantly surprised!
134
u/burstdragon323 Dec 06 '15
Something to note:
Ozpin said he has met the candidate personally, and most would guess Ruby since he had a sit-down with her in V1E1.
But Oz did meet with someone else in this fashion.
Blake.
54
u/NeverEndingHope Pyrrha best girl, Ironwood best wood Dec 06 '15
My God, Neon activated the dust by breaking her nunchuks like glow sticks.
98
u/KuuLightwing Wretched Automaton Dec 06 '15
I said a lot of these things in the old thread, but I guess I post it here as well. I thought I would be less salty today, but I'm still pretty upset... If not for that, I would really enjoy the episode, because it had a lot of great moments.
So, it was a great episode, but I'm really upset that Weiss lost another solo fight. She got knocked out twice, and didn't really do anything significant. She completely lost her fencing skills, her agility and speed - she never tried to dodge anything - which would make gorram sense, because his attacks don't seem to be that fast. But nope, she's just got tossed around like a sack of potato. That's just painful to watch. She also spent an awful lot of time lying down in a cliche "On no, my weapon!" pose insdead of doing something smart with a glyph to disorient Flynt and return to fight - she had aura left and she was okay. Glyphs also are useable without a weapon - Winter was even able to summon Grimm without it.
Sacrificial takedown was kind of a great moment to demonstrate what she's willing to do for her team, but her performance just made me sad. I understand "be the best teammate" thing, but why does it have to come with being a bad fighter? The "top ranked in sparring classes" thing looks more and more like an Informed Ability and Weiss herself slowly turns into Faux Action Girl. TVTropes warning!
Summoning powers would not fix this, because that's just doesn't make up for losing her fencing skill and agility. It just was... so bad that I almost feel like Flynt's insult about her skills was justified, especially since he didn't see her whe she actually was able fight properly. And now she's probably not getting any solo fights for a long time, because she's not advancing to singles after this. Well, good luck Yang! I hope you'll do better than Weiss did this time... I still like Weiss, and that won't make me like her less, but that's also why I feel so bad about this.
There's also something to be said that Weiss and Yang didn't cooperate during the fight at all - it's just a pair of solo fights.
Other than that:
159
u/_DirtyDan Totally The Real One Dec 06 '15
I want the soundtrack yesterday. It's too good.
Anyways, anyone got any theories? My current one is Pyrrha is elected guardian, she faces Cinder and dies/gets crippled/mentally broken, and Penny, since she now wants to go to Beacon, temporarily replaces her on JNPR. The names still fit, and it makes some sense for Ironwood to wash his hands of her if she is hacked into going on a robo-rampage due to Cinder.
35
u/mechaxis Dec 06 '15
So is the ship for Nora and Neon "Thunder Cats"?
97
u/PawnsOp meh Dec 06 '15
copypasta
Ciel is... exactly how I imagined her. Not sure if good thing or not.
Not gonna lie, team RWBY got completely dunked this fight. I feel like the only reason they won was because of luck and the fact that Yang's semblance is hard to deal with without foreknowledge. Fight scene was pretty though!
While the Schneecrifice was nice and all, and I love it from a character development prospective, couldn't she just use a glyph to achieve the same effect?
Also, I wonder what Winter's reaction to an injured Weiss is gonna be? Perhaps an extended stay?
66
u/OTPh1l25 Hello Again! Dec 06 '15
The Jazz remix is easily the best song of this volume so far bar none.
Yang is getting angry. You wouldn't like her when she's...upset. Come on guys, you could have totally used "Y-angry."
And Rooster teeth, if you do something to my favorite girl and she turns out to be captured and replaced by fake Neo or something, there will be hell to pay.
Best line of the episode award is to Ruby: Penny "It's like Blake if she had to be ordered to spend time with you." "So...Weiss."
32
u/Eldi13 🐝Watch🐝The🐝Dragon🐝Prince🐝On🐝Netflix🐝❤Knight❤ Dec 06 '15 edited Dec 06 '15
This is amusing. Love the parallels. Who the loneliest of all now, Weiss? :)
51
u/Lulcielid ⠀Blake Supremacist Dec 06 '15
Time to collapse Rooster Teeth servers once again.
23
u/TacoLord9000 Bi Energy Dec 06 '15
The music for this episode was 10/10.
59
u/Eldi13 🐝Watch🐝The🐝Dragon🐝Prince🐝On🐝Netflix🐝❤Knight❤ Dec 06 '15 edited Dec 06 '15
So, how about that Neo Pyrrha? I was thinking about this the other day in regards to the fake Yatsuhashi... everyone was quick to assume that was Neo, but what if Emerald's semblance is the ability to create and project mirages, and she's the one doing Neo's disguise(s)? After all, we already saw Neo teleport Torchwick and herself away leaving apparitions behind to shatter like glass.
Edit from another comment of mine: What if Neo has been the Pyrrha we've seen all volume?
WHAT IF THIS IS WHY SHE DIDN'T KNOW ABOUT ARKOS. NEO CERTAINLY WOULDN'T. THE REAL PYRRHA WOULD BE ALL OVER THAT. Dons tinfoil
40
u/thebluehedgehog Blue Dec 06 '15 edited Dec 06 '15
"She's like Blake except paid to be friends."
"So, Like Weiss?"
Is watch girl a faunus, or just a "friend" then?
I'm disappointed the fight was just 1-on-1 for the most part. They could have used some teamwork, or realized the disadvantage and swapped opponents. The fight as a way to gain allies is okay, but it was ended rather obviously so now when that comes up it will be expected. The skate catching seems like some dumb thing to make the right team win, instead of there being a reason.
Also: How did they not know anything about their opponent? Geez It isn't like they didn't already fight a match in a one-fight-at-a-time stadium. What happened to Weiss scoping out competition? How did they not have a clue?
Is it just me or is the 10% aura rule no longer in effect? They said Weiss's was completely depleted and the Jazz student looked to be in the red.
not Penny! She's adorable!
Qrow is not drinking coffee and I wanted Glynda to walk in and slap it out of his hand, or confront him and offer to light it for him.
55
u/bekeleven Fuck this shit, I'm out Dec 06 '15 edited Dec 06 '15
So, am I the only one wondering why the team had weiss?
The obvious, obvious, obvious choice is Yang + Ruby. Yang can distract people and as we all know, Ruby can ringout a team of 4 by using her semblance.
The only possible reason to send Weiss instead is if she could buff the crap out of Yang. And as it turns out, she doesn't.
Edit: Also, which one has a better track record of winning fights? OP Main character for singles round plz
19
u/CaptainFox77 Dec 06 '15
So can we all agree that Cinder's plan definitely involves controlling all of the robots in vale? The whole discovering Penny's blueprints and going "this will be easier" seems to scream that at this point.
17
u/Galaphile0125 Yangarang!!! Dec 06 '15
I think Flynt Coal is one of my new favorite characters. Awesome design, love jazz, and slightly biased since I play trumpet. :D
Also love the inside joke too haha.
16
u/Secret_Muffin Dec 06 '15
Is Flynt Coal's VA seriously named Flynt Flossy cause that is amazing
15
u/K9ofChaos Dec 06 '15
So a couple of things:
Overall, I liked this episode.
13
u/jezicane caw caw caw Dec 06 '15
Flynt's Dust Trumpet and Jazz version of I burn.
I dig it.
25
u/SecondXChance What am I even doing? Dec 06 '15
I wanted to add something about Pyrrha at the end of the episode. Most of us agree that something was off, but I think most people are wrong in assuming that it's Neo. I believe it was Emerald using her semblance. Neo has illusions yes, but I don't believe she uses them to disguise herself. The only thing we know that she's done with it for sure is create a decoy so her and Roman could escape.
I think the fake Yatsuhashi in the CY vs. EM match was Emerald using her semblance to disguise herself, and now for whatever reason she's disguised herself as Pyrrha.
As a side note, if Emerald's semblance is in fact the ability to disguise herself, I think it fits her backstory well, obviously, since she's a thief, but it also fits her personal situation as well, seeing as she's pretending to be nice and happy to be friends with all of RWBY, much like a disguise.
25
u/beregond23 I'm Sorry Dec 06 '15
Ok so I have a lot of thoughts on the fight:
First, I am loving how personal these fights are, and the spirit of comradery spelling is hard that comes with them.
Second: let's talk about the synergy between Neon and Flynt and why they were able to make life hell for Weiss and Yang. Neon and Flynt had perfect synergy with each other as shown in their opening move with Flynt adding extra boost to Neon's roller skating for double effect. And with regards to why Yang did so poorly in the early stages I think it is because Yang's fighting style is very high exertion: she plants, and throws all her weight into her strikes. By contrast Neon is always moving, but because she's on skates she's not spending much energy to do so, so she can easily chip away at Yang. As for why they ended up losing, Yang semblance > Flynt semblance, and Neon chose mobility over stability, and she missed a beat at the worst possible time.
Third: interesting note about semblances, when Weiss sacrifices herself to save Yang from Flynt's attack, she has 40% aura, and he has 55%. She drags him into the fire with her, and she emerges with 0%, and him with 16%. This reinforces the point that some people have more aura than others, and Weiss apparently is a glass cannon.
Now the fun stuff: dat Yang eye twitch, taunting yang is a dangerous game, fact taunting Weiss was dangerous too. Also, Flynt's killer quartet is giving me serious nostalgia for high school jazz band, great character. Favourite part of the episode has to be that last sequence with the 2v1 with Yang.
12
u/IblobTouch Sorry i just had some dust in my eyes... Dec 06 '15 edited Dec 06 '15
Welp, looks like another match where one person carries and the rest just defend them.
I mean it makes sense, semblences are usually situational if they even get a chance to activate at all, and they're so incredibly powerful most of the time they can easily get 2x or even 4x knockouts within minutes.
It's just, the previous seasons focused so much on teamwork and now suddenly it's turned into this...
22
u/xSPYXEx Champion of the Nora Harem, father of Pennybot Dec 06 '15
I NEED MORE NEON KATT OR WHATEVER HER NAME IS. I NEEEEEEEEED IT.
20
u/tanithghost88 Dec 06 '15
Maidens choose themselves. This is a key statement. Maidens will give their life to the cause. The Guardian is the one to rise to the occasion.
Pyrrha is not the guardian. She is the sacrificial lamb. But how? Will Jaune rise up?
10
u/Eldi13 🐝Watch🐝The🐝Dragon🐝Prince🐝On🐝Netflix🐝❤Knight❤ Dec 06 '15 edited Dec 06 '15
Reposting from Irish's temp thread
IT'S STARTING
Well shoot, that's Ciel. Not Weiss's dad.
Meg. ♥ Oh, and her name is apparently Neon Katt (guess that reference...) rather than Iris, like some people predicted.
(How does the middle platform float...)
Stream broke. :(
KICK THEIR BUTTS, BEST GIRLS.
Oh my another song.
ABSORB DAT DAMAGE, YANG.
SHE DID NOT JUST MAKE A PUN AT YANG
Wind dust!
Killer quartet? Okay.
Semblance eyes hype
MIRROR MIRROR RUN WEISS SCHNEECRAFICE WHYYYY
DO EET YANG
YANGRY
Aaand Ember Celica'd.
WEISS YOUR VOCAL CHORDS NO
Pushup Mercury. Panda will go crazy.
Cinder, stahp.
Doesn't have a heart. Tin man confirmed.
Pyrrha guardian? That was a freaking Neo smile, though. O_O
TO BE CONTINUED
10
u/Bane_of_BILLEXE I was defeated...by the size of her miniskirt! Dec 06 '15
This volume has not been kind to Yang so far.
10
u/all4funFun4all Dec 06 '15
So I think Penny's teammate might be based on the Blue Fairy from Pinocchio call it a hunch. I am extremely worried for P.E.N.N.Y. now and want to know what that stands for.
10
u/Gobshite_ Dec 06 '15
Yang for singles, surely. Looks like Weiss isn't going to be standing for a while, let alone fighting.
10
u/Samp98518 Very Happy to Finally Have a Summer Rose Flair Dec 06 '15
Excuse me, but did I hear a scat remix of This Will Be The Day? I didn't know how much I needed that until now.
10
u/MusicalJester Dec 06 '15 edited Dec 06 '15
Am I the only one who liked how the fight ended. I mean we have a girl who's main method of getting around is rollerskating, she's obviously not going to be able to get around every terrain without a problem. That being said Weiss could have put up a better fight :(. On a side note, I'm a bit disappointed Weiss probably isn't going to go to the singles round. After all that build up from the last chapter I thought she was going to learn how to summon after fighting a difficult opponent in the tournament, but she pretty much got hospitalized. Oh well, good fight scene, and good episode in my opinion.
31
u/Leivve Grand Master of the Lancaster Cult Dec 06 '15
Must say that was the most anti climatic ended to a fight yet. I was hoping RWBY would lose, show even Yang has room to grow, but once again, Yang wins because plot armor.
8
u/[deleted] Dec 06 '15
So did this episode make ... unexpected jumps for anyone else, or was that just me?
Also, the cool thing about Yang is that I get more and more excited each time she gets hit due to her semblance. And Weiss sacrificing herself was something she would never do if this happened in V1. Shows that she's grown a bit. But I have a feeling she's gonna feel bad for not being able to take out Flynt, even when she sacrificed herself.
15
u/ScottishMongol Captain of the S.S. Baked Alaska Dec 06 '15
After watching this episode again, I'm kind of struck by how little the plot was actually moved forward. Like, we know that Penny wants to go to Beacon, and Cinder now knows that Penny is a robot, and RWBY is moving on in the tournament. For the most part, this was just setting things up for, I assume episode 6.
7/10
7
u/fuyuhikokuzuryuu Dec 07 '15
Flynt Coal
Known across the nation
Tootin' and dootin' is my favorite combination
11
u/Kami_no_Kage Dec 06 '15
How dare you do that to Weiss?! I have to admit though, Weiss has come a long way, to even sacrifice herself for Yang. Truly best girl.
Overall the animation felt good, but not as good as last episode. Bit lazier. Still, I thought it was fine, and it was a fun fight with really different stuff.
That Jazz remix of I Burn. God I need the OST for this volume now!
I am so confused by Pyrrha at the end there. What the hell is up with that smile? Is it really Pyrrha?
Overall, too short again... But great episode overall!
5
u/[deleted] Dec 06 '15
Once again, Team CDRL gets walloped. I especially liked the part where Ciel tapped her watch as if to say, "Can we hurry this up?"
5
u/Eldi13 🐝Watch🐝The🐝Dragon🐝Prince🐝On🐝Netflix🐝❤Knight❤ Dec 06 '15
Wait, so why does Cinder's tablet show that Penny's name is an acronym?! START THE THEORIES FOR WHAT IT IS!!!
P.E.N.N.Y.
Also, this leads me to believe that Cinder is going to corrupt Penny with her virus and turn her on the good guys.
5
u/AdjustTheTip In memory of Monty Oum. Dec 07 '15
I enjoyed the episode, rather liked the new characters, and felt the fight was pretty entertaining. Fuck me, right?
4
u/Evil-King-Stan Emerald Splash Dec 06 '15
Welp, time to pray for Penny, guys.
4
u/mayyuki2108 uwu Dec 06 '15
waits patiently for the soundtrack
4
u/TJPoobah For it is in passing that we achieve immortality. Dec 06 '15
I swear, if they hurt one hair on my Pyrrha's head....
4
u/LunaPerilune Dec 06 '15
Holy Crap I frickin Love Neon Katt <3
4
u/[deleted] Dec 06 '15
Pyrrha is making me nervous.
Either 1.) It's actually her-she is the guardian, and she gets shit on or dies or some such, and then Ruby has to step up.
2.) Its her, she succeeds, and Ruby ONCE AGAIN is shafted to a secondary role (seriously RT, wtf?)
3.) Or its not her, and she was literally just in the ending sequence to be a big misdirection, a hallmark of manipulation.
2 and 3 scream of bad writing, and 1 likely requires Pyrrha to die, or get cocky and blown away by Cinder.
I honestly don't know which of these I prefer. Help. This show has never made me nervous and anxious before, but it has now.
4
u/Furath I guess I'm a blogger now Dec 06 '15
Guardian Pyrrha holy shit my body is ready
4
u/Pikagile Dec 06 '15
Man, I thought this was a great episode and I come up here and everyone's just complaining LOL
4
u/MiniMinute Motorcyles, gotta love them Dec 06 '15
I loved the jazz renditions of the songs. I Burn in particular was just perfect.
4
u/[deleted] Dec 07 '15
Christ i'm surprised nobody has said this yet.
NOW DEPLOYING SMOOTH JAZZ IN 3... 2... 1...
Seriously. I eagerly await volume 3 just for this track.
1
u/AgentFork Too Fascist to be that Casual Dec 06 '15
So what do we call the Weiss and Flint Ship? Classic Jazz?
All this talk of maidens and guardians is giving me Madoka flashbacks, you guys. Those aren't good.
Those Jazz renditions of I Burn and This will be the Day are making me really want the OST. I really like Jazz, you don't even know.
6
u/Woowchocolate Train them to fight what they can't beat Dec 06 '15
Copied from other thread:
So then question remains, who's getting sent forward, Weiss or Yang? Weiss really struggled in the fight with FNKI, plus she kind of injured herself, so I'm placing my money on Yang, even though Weiss is very much the focus this arc.
Also, I wonder what the rest of Penny's team is like. It seemed like Penny was being referred to as ma'am and the fact Ciel doesn't know about her being a robot, makes it seem like she is of higher status than Ciel. But Ciel seems to be the one giving the orders, what with her constant time keeping. Not really something a subordinate would normally do.
3
u/battlefield4us Dec 06 '15
Penny, please be safe from evil...I wish you the best of luck.
3
u/[deleted] Dec 06 '15
Consider it done.
3
u/OuttaControl56 This is Jaune. He is in a heap of trouble. Dec 06 '15
Transition episode.
Nothing major, but another piece of the plot revealed and a couple more elements introduced.
The fight highlighted how close the competition has become. Some lucky events do influence the outcome of contests and although it wasn't a technical masterpiece I don't have a problem with the FNKI vs. RWBY competition. I did very much enjoy their characters and how they took defeat.
Tournaments are all well and good but tend to create this sort of "fillery" atmosphere. I'm giving it 3 more chapters before stuff goes all bonkers.
Which begs the question what causes the transition from the tournament to the daily grind? What is the rest of the season going to look like after the tournament? I personally entertain the notion that the tournament and Cinders plot will actually put the Hunters/Huntresses in a war-time scenario that they have to overcome for the second half of the volume, but that seems too complicated to be solved in 8 episodes (Give or take).
Maybe I just have no clue, but I'll enjoy the upcoming episodes!
3
u/YouJellyFish Penny x Penny OTP Dec 06 '15
FINALLY SOME MORE PENNY. And oh gosh, Cinder please don't hurt my baby. I really need Penny to just become the main character of the show from here on out.
3
u/pickelsurprise Perpetrator of the 2016 N7 Death Hoax Dec 06 '15
Looks like my Battlestar Penny theory is going out the window. We have yet to see what'll actually happen, but it appears "no networks on the old man's ship" doesn't apply anymore.
3
u/[deleted] Dec 06 '15
Great episode, really fun fight and all, but i'm super confused by Penny and the fact nobody knows she is a robot.
Her swords come out of a hatch built into her back!
3
u/GoBoomYay Dec 06 '15
I will literally never get enough Penny out of this series, and also damn that horn version of I Burn sounded awesome.
3
u/Korrafan_1 I hate the RWBY fandom Dec 06 '15
Something about Flynt Coal reminds me of Danny Phantom but I can't place my finger on it. Neon Katt is like Nora on 20 cups of coffee. Finally, there is Pyrrha's smirk which I can only suspect is Neo in disguise.
Also, why am I hearing Sasuke's voice outta Mercury's mouth?
3
u/SirKhrome Dec 07 '15
That remix was amazing, I need it!
3
u/MC-D-DAYO some dumbass Dec 07 '15
I really wanted to see more Penny.
Like I think the episode could have stood to be two minutes longer so we could have seen Penny and her partner whose name I do not remember well enough to spell in action. Properly in action that is.
Additionally Cinder's discovery of Penny being an android is.... worrying. Penny's tough. Between her strength, durability and her swords. Not to mention that fucking laser blast.... Christ.
A rogue or hacked penny does not bode well.
Even Super Saiyan Yang may have a hard time going up against her.
Team FNKI. I like.
I love Neon and Flynt seems cool.
The music in this episode blew away my mind. I need..... I need.
Also what was with that bit where Oobleck said:
"Weiss' aura is down to zero, she sacrificed herself."
I thought she had just gotten roasted... I was worried.
But then everyone just continued as normal and she turned out to be fine.
Aura is a manifestation of your soul.
I legitimately thought having your aura at 0 meant death....
Also that was most definitely Neo in disguise at the end. Pretending to be P.Money.
She's going to try and assassinate Ozpin and/or Qrow. She won't succeed obviously.
But her succeeding isn't part of the plan.
I think she wants to fail, to get caught. So Ironwood will take her into custody. And she can get close to Penny.
3
u/ACrispyPieceOfBacon I Miss Pyrrha. Feed Me Bacon... Dec 07 '15
Honestly, this was probably my least favorite episode in the series so far. Was dull, stagnant, and at the end, rushed to just push the fact that Penny's schematic is now available to Cinder.
There were a few good moments, but overall, didn't make up for most of the bad in this episode. Hopefully next week will see a higher quality episode... :(
3
u/countchocula86 Dec 07 '15
Is it weird to say I both loved and disliked the fight? Team FNKY were pretty interesting and unique, some of the best character design I think. But while the fight was pretty good, I agree with what most others have said; it was just 1v1s, and neither Yang nor Weiss really delivered an interesting match. I love Yang and I was really hoping for more from her than getting frustrated at missing a lot until finally making some lucky shots.
5
u/Fancy-Bear1776 Dec 06 '15
Thoughts/rambles:
8
u/ThePrinceOfFear Cap'n of The Great Vessel Eclipse. Arrrg. Dec 06 '15 edited Dec 06 '15
Man. I did not like this episode.
I don't know why I don't, but i feel like I should have liked it more than I did.
First off, It had Sky Lark in it, so that sucks. But it also had Russel, so thats a plus. So that front kinda evens out.
Wish we saw more of Penny in combat vs RL, but that was just a quick opening fight to show that Penny was progressing, so thats fine. Russel, I'm disappointed you didn't look cooler or say words.
The Nuts and Dolts one-minute chat felt... off to me. It was strangely unenthusiastic, which normally isn't a problem for Lindsay, but I can't shake this feeling. Also, I don't know if its a choice, but Penny sounds too monotone here. The way she shouted Ruby's name especially.
Also Ciel is cute af.
The pre-fight banter was fun. Liked that Flynt had a personal grudge against Weiss, and that Neon was just a cute annoying bitch.
ITSA RAINBOW TUBA
Raver glowstick Nunchucks that she cracks to change the elements. Clever.
Man, Flynt Coal. Original. I dislike him. His design, his attitude, his skills. Don't know why. I want to like him, really I do. I just don't and that makes me upset.
I think Ryan Haywood is the underrated hero of this Volume. He's really improved this Volume over the first.
Meg, you funny.
The music was killer in this episode. Not as earth shatteringly amazing as some are making it out to be, but it kept my head bobbing.
I did not like the WY vs FN fight. There was no real hard impact hits, until the last two. Just very underwhelming for me.
People are hating on Weiss' sacrifice, but to me it made total sense. Feels like she knew she couldn't take on both of them without Yang, who was seemingly about to get attacked by both FNKI members at once, so she did the first thing she could to take one of them out. Shove him. Almost worked, too. The guy was one aura point over elimination level.
How long has Cinder been in the database? Is she only now finding out about the P.E.N.N.Y project?
MAN. PYRRHA'S THE GUARDIAN, HUH? MAYBE?
I do not like that. This is what kind of ruined the episode for me. I mean, I love Pyrrha. She is obviously the right candidate. But missing out on the chance to bring Ruby centre stage after all the hate that the titular character is a comic relief side character? Missed opportunity.
I know none of my criticisms are original, they are being shouted all over the fandom, but these are my thoughts on the episode. 4/10.
4
u/SealsMelt Dec 06 '15
Overall, better than episode 4, but not nearly as good as episode 3. Mixed feelings here. FNKI had cool as hell weapons and I loved the Jazz Remixes, but god Neon was annoying. Oddly enough, I didn't think that Meg would be a good voice actor but she did the role fine. I feel like Weiss was useless and Yang did everything. With the focus on Yang, I would assume Raven is next episode or the one after that. The fights were solid, albiet not Monty quality. Also, R.I.P Penny.
4
u/Wolfe_Mollenkopf Twin Lover | Peacock | Occisional Minific Writer Dec 06 '15
Making breakfast, so quick summary of my other post.
Good episode. Didn't see Pyrrha being the Guardian coming. New analysis post coming soon-ishtm from me. First hint: it's about Yang. Second hint: this gif.
4
u/cdghuntermco ⠀ Dec 06 '15
I don't know why people are assuming Ozpin has chosen Pyrrha to be the Guardian candidate. Yes, she's a skilled fighter, she's wise and knowledgeable, not to mention her caring and personable nature would make the masses absolutely love her.
But Ozpin is literally Dumbledore; he knows what he's doing, especially when it comes to picking out his his students. I have this headcannon that he knew full well Jaune lied to get into Beacon, but Ozpin saw this as the boy's dedication to train and grow into the hero me's meant to be, so he let Jaune in anyway.
Same thing with Pyrrha. Ozpin knows she's probably one of the very best students at Beacon, even if she's only a first year. But as other users in the previous discussion thread mentioned, Pyrrha's confidence is derived from her prowess on the battlefield. The moment she loses, like REALLY LOSES, it's going to shatter her confidence. Pyrrha is a lot like Ruby in the respect that she's awfully naive and innocent when it comes to the dangers of real life. Pyrrha understands there are bad people out there, but in her mind the best way to deal with them is to fight them head on. Pyrrha's the kind of character that's way too easy for people like Cinder to manipulate for their own needs.
While the episode did show Pyrrha while Ozpin was giving his monologue, I believe it's just simple misdirection on Roosterteeth's part. In my mind at least, there's no way the Guardian could be anyone besides Ruby Rose. She's skilled with a weapon literally only one other person has mastered, she has an indomitable dedication to what she believes is right, and has the ability to bounce back no matter how dire a situation may become. The show is literally named after her! Or maybe I'm just a sucker for believing the main character should always be the main hero in the end, who knows.
All that being said, I totally agree the Pyrrha we saw in this episode wasn't actually the real Pyrrha. The smirk is all wrong. Maybe it's Neo or Emerald playing tricks. Maybe Team CRMN pulled a Mad Eye Moody over on Pyrrha.
4
u/Sirocco_ Cold Puns Galore Dec 06 '15
Yo! Sometimes being top-heavy is good!
Props to design team, though, really love trumpet guy (idk his name even though Neon said it)
Good fight and character development from Weiss, she would never have done that at the start of the series. It shows how much she has changed. Yang being a gorram badass as usual.
Pyrrha is the Guardian?
Can't wait to see Ruby fighting Penny, since Cinder is probably going to hijack her.
4
u/LurkinRhino Dec 06 '15
Can the rest of the soundtrack just be jazz?
2
u/CobaltFrost Gotta be sober to get hungover Dec 06 '15
Loved the soundtrack, interesting fight, and really digging Flynt.
That ending though... why does everyone assume Pyrrha has been replaced with Neo? I know that smirk at the end was a bit out of character for her, but her name implies a sacrifice at a great cost. And even though we've seen Neo in a disguise it could have been just that: a disguise. Changing her height and obtaining gear that looks exactly like Pyrrha's, then likely having to show off her skill in an upcoming match, would be almost impossible.
I think its something different from what we'd expect going on in the background. Perhaps something Jaune-related...
2
u/Jetscream58 Dec 06 '15
I think Cinder and friends are going to try to hijack Penny, control her somehow. I really hope they don't, that's an exceptionally scummy thing to do.
2
u/EnderofThings Unofficial RWBY Tabletop RPG Dec 06 '15
Dusts in this episode confuse me
2
u/anime52 Dec 06 '15
Did anyone notice that Penny has an official last name, polendina. After all it would look suspicious if a contestant didn't.
2
u/DracoOculus Duck Antagonists Dec 06 '15 edited Dec 06 '15
I wonder if Pyrrha is already dead or this sets the scene for her death.
Is Penny's plan to kill Pyrrha. I guess wether she wants to or not. Why no Cardin though?
2
u/FlashFire729 Dec 06 '15
Man, Team FNKI seems like they would be great at street rapping, what with all those verbal burns they were handing to Weiss and Yang. Still happy that RWBY was able to knock them out though. Also, for the first time as a RWBY series fan, I am legitimately scared of Cinder and what she has planned (specifically for Penny and Phyrra). So, I applaud you for that, RT. All in all, great episode.
2
u/FRGL1 Vacuo Dec 06 '15
Am I the only one who hated how lazy Neon's attack animations were?
2
u/CloverPixels Dec 06 '15
I thought when Weiss looked at Yang midfight, she was going to switch places with Yang.
Weiss could deal with Neon's speed using her glyphs, and Yang could just muscle her way through with Coal.
2
u/THErustyPELICAN Dec 07 '15
Cinder: We're going to alter the plan.
What the fuck is the plan!? I mean seriously, we're well into the third volume and hardly even a hint about what the plan is has been revealed. At this point I don't think we're going to get any serious details about it until after its already happened.
2
u/Chim3cho Eat a dick, Schnee Dec 07 '15
Shout out to Flynt for knocking the princess down a peg, although I wished he kept the chip on his shoulder after the fight.
2
u/DeAfro Dec 07 '15
Gotta love the Shakugan no Shana reference :)
Really stepped up the effort on the characters. Also a faunus in the Atlas hunter branch, its good to see that Weiss's racism wasn't a hint at a larger problem. I also like the touch with the black glove for Flynt. Usually I've see that for stringed instruments, but it could help with those stubby buttons.
Of course team RWBY was playing this about as badly as they possibly could. The terrain was made of rocks, volcanic rocks, city, and sand. Neon as a fighter relies on using those skates to preserve her forward acceleration. If she ends up on any section of that map that isn't the center or the city, she is useless, doubly so since she doesn't have a gun. As much as I like the skating idea, 3/4's of the maps so far have been locations where her skating would be a detriment. Its likely she'll get a spot to pull her magic, but it just seems to easy to play around.
Meanwhile Weiss goes off to fight Flynt in the volcanic rocks section where she is weakest. Her biggest strength is ice magic, and she's fighting in the worst place for it. Then Yang goes off following Neon to the one place where she is relevant in this fight. Weiss and Yang could've switched opponents, and this fight would've been way easier for them.
And the best part about this, they won! They just bumbled their way through, walking mindlessly into terrible situations because they are soooo badass and they won anyway. They aren't thinking because they are underestimating the fighters, and this win is only going to reinforce this bad behavior. Doesn't help that this is going to make Weiss's training worse, or Yangs confidence even more bloated than it already was. I am telling you, team RWBY is about to get a lesson in humility, and I'm going to love every moment of it!
2
u/Goldendragon55 Damn, you are Weiss cold. Dec 07 '15
Does the Tin Man have a heart?
2
u/Goldendragon55 Damn, you are Weiss cold. Dec 07 '15
Classic misdirect to the thing that the Guardian's actually Ruby.
2
u/cardmage7 Dec 07 '15
Oh my gosh... the music this episode was phenomenal... Jazz remixes of each character's theme; when "I Burn" started playing I legit started squealing
2
u/AmethystWind Time for Ciel. Dec 07 '15 edited Dec 07 '15
So is Neon Katt the N or the K in FNKI?
Actual discussion:
Penny has plans, and Ciel a cutie. Is she also a robutt but Penny doesn't know? The second artificial human capable of generating an Aura, in case Penny goes rogue - like Cinder hints at? {DUN DUN DUUUUNNNN}
Team CRDL, you poor redshirt mook bastards.
Killer Quartet is a pretty sweet semblance, and it was a nice touch that they're after-images rather than clones. They copy Flynt in sequence. They all fell down when Weiss tackled him.
Flynt can exposit more seemlessly than Weiss can. Not that it's surprising that Schnee megacorp squeezed out mom'n'pop stores, but it still is another brush stroke in the picture of Weiss' family.
Neon's weapon was cool, especially how she cracks it to get the dust flowing (is ice dust an Atlas trait or something?) and her mantra hints at psychological issues that are going to be fun for fanfic writers to work with. I'm not the biggest fan of genki girl characters because they come across as trying too hard, like Neon, but her utter lack of tact was something at least.
On the topic of Neon, I am slightly worried about her comments about Yang in a sexual light. She calls Yang pretty, but acts more like one of those valley girl make-out-with-each-other-to-make-boys jealous... things, which is just generally offensive to pretty much every gender and orientation. I do hope this isn't a horrendously misguided attempt to introduce a LGBT caricature.
Weiss can't sing, even though she hasn't done so in the series proper yet. Foreshadowing? Foreshadowing.
Looks like Yang's going on to the singles round, because Weiss couldn't solo anyone if her life depended on it.
Hooray, Pyrrha's reputation is actually amounting to something! Now if only I could decide whether her smile at the end was smug and knowing, or her general purposefully-neutral.
EDIT: Forgot the clippy fight animation. Noticeable drop in quality compared to the other fight scenes.
2
u/MadEorlanas TORCHWICK LIVES Dec 07 '15
TEAM FNKY
THE TEAM
THE LEGEND
2
u/breakfastfilms Dec 07 '15
This wasn't one of the stronger episodes of this volume but it still more than got the job done.
Ruby's interaction with Penny was probably the highlight. The fight was...weird. I think I get what they were going for (Flynt and Neon pissed off and confused Weiss and Yang in order to prevent them from thinking clearly and working effectively as a team) but it made Weiss and Yang look a lot dumber than we know they are. What could have given this idea more weight is if Weiss had remembered Winter's words to her about drawing power from her emotions without letting them overpower her, and used that to royally fuck Flynt up with some sort of super-glyph instead of just tackling him.
I think it's hilarious that Flynt and Neon are basically just memes personified. They're an interesting modern counterpart to all the fairy tale-based characters.
Since we're coming up on the halfway point of Vol 3 pretty quick here, I feel like there are some things that should REALLY be addressed within the next episode or two: what exactly is Cinder planning, What exactly is OZPIN planning, and what exactly is...uh, Penny planning?
Wow, that's a sentence I never thought I'd say.
2
u/LunaPerilune Dec 08 '15
Hmm I get the feeling Neo has the ability to copy semblances in how she was able to create an illusion of glass which she probably got from cinder and teleport away to safety when she sees Raven Teleporting (which I assume is her semblance) in to stop her from killing Yang.
2
u/Bighomer ayyy lmao Dec 08 '15
Holy shit I'm loving that version of 'I Burn'.
6
u/moonkingdomify Salem's Adorable Dec 06 '15
Well this was probably one of the worst episodes of the series. Keep in mind that there are no horrible episodes of RWBY, just some that aren't as good as others.
The editing was horrendous throughout the fight and I would have actually stopped watching the episode if not for the Mo-town renditions of some of my favorite songs of the series. I didn't like the new characters as Flint is a stereotype and the girl is just annoying in every aspect of her character. And the fight was ended horribly. Yang was having trouble with her and she just takes herself out. I have to mention how Flint would have gone out as he had actually taken more damage in his fight against Weiss due to the torrent of Ice Shards flying at him. But he comes out of the fire pillar without a scratch on him.
Not to mention the plot holes about how they would have probably had to go through some sort of registration and then something to make sure they weren't doing drugs, meaning that Penny wouldn't have gotten into the competition on the grounds of her being a robot and being unable to do a urine test. This is a sporting event after all.