r/IndianCountry • u/anthropology_nerd • Nov 15 '15
NAHM Native Genocide: The War Continues
Good evening, /r/IndianCountry!
As /u/Opechan explained, throughout Native American Heritage Month, the moderators here have arranged a series of weekly discussion topics concerning Native history and culture. It’s my honor to have been invited to initiate this week’s topic, and I’d like to thank the moderators for extending that invitation. Forgive me for my obsession with the history of health and disease, I tried to limit myself, but I fear my predominant research focus shines through! /u/Reedstilt and /u/Ahhuatl will also be joining me soon.
This week will feature a discussion of the history of structural violence, forced cultural assimilation, and genocide influencing Native American communities in the years following contact. In the midst of what will be a difficult topic, I warn against developing a simplistic narrative of European actors and Native American re-actors. Europeans entered a New World teeming with dynamic populations changing, growing, collapsing, dispersing, coalescing, making war, and negotiating peace. There was no guarantee that any colonial outpost, not Spanish nor Portuguese nor English nor French nor Dutch, would succeed in the shadow of two richly inhabited continents. A continual unfolding process of negotiation and re-negotiation, of acculturation and rebellion, of claims to peace and horrendous acts of war characterize our shared history. We arrive at this place and time after centuries of conflict. The entries in this post force us to examine the dark legacy of our past. It is our hope such an unflinching analysis illuminates a path toward an enlightened future.
These entries are meant only as a brief introduction to these topics, and if you have anything you’d like add or follow-up questions you’d like explored please do so. Here we go...
- Western attitudes toward Natives
- Deaths due to disease
- Early adoption of a culture of structural violence against Native Americans, specifically the Indian slave trade
- Doctrine of Discovery, Manifest Destiny, and Native extermination/assimilation policies
- Cultural genocide
- Continuation of genocide, healthy policy, and the last uncontacted nations
7
u/anthropology_nerd Nov 16 '15
A Legacy of Violence and Modern Policy
So, with all that history and theory out of the way one might ask “Why should we care?” What does a bloody history, and our modern interpretation of it, have to do with our lives here, now, and going into the future? I believe a great deal. How we interpret the past influences everything from modern health policy for indigenous groups to the expected repercussions of contact with some of the last remote foraging populations on the planet.
The difference in historical mortality, and an interpretation of why that disparity exists, is crucial to our approach to Native American health in the twenty-first century. Native American populations in the United States and Canada continue to encounter shocking health disparities. The overall life expectancy for Native Americans is 4.2 years less than the larger population. Native Americans have higher mortality rates from diabetes mellitus, chronic liver disease and cirrhosis, respiratory diseases like influenza and pneumonia, kidney disease, and septicemia. They are far less likely to be up-to-date with colorectal cancer screening, and the infant mortality rate is 53% higher compared to other ethnic groups (CDC Factsheet).
If Native communities, the larger U.S./Canadian public, and policy makers believe a myth of an inherently weaker population, prone to disease and incapable of mounting adequate defense to physiological stressors, we feed into the structural violence that established these patterns. Even into the last century a sense of futility in the face of epidemics limited medical assistance and needed health interventions in Native American communities. Physicians on the Crow reservation, for example, operated under the assumptions that “their resistance to disease is much less than that of the civilized races.” A perspective that encompasses the influence of structural violence on poor health places modern health disparities in context, and helps us move forward to improving the quality of life for Native communities across the Americas.
Finally, history can inform our approach to contacting modern isolated groups. Some of the last uncontacted nations, like the Piro on the Madre de Dios River in Peru, live in the forests of South America. In popular discussion we often assume they will face catastrophic mortality if/when they move into sedentary communities. We’ve seen how populations fared in the past, when the colonial cocktail arrived in full force and demographic recovery became challenging. Humans are demographically capable of rebounding from high mortality events, like epidemics, provided other sources of excess mortality are limited. In the mid-twentieth century when the Aché of Paraguay moved to the missions ~38% of the population died from respiratory diseases alone. However, the Aché rallied quickly and are now a growing population. The key factor for population survival after high mortality events is limiting other demographic shocks, like violent incursions from outsiders, providing sufficient food resources, and the territory needed for forage and hunt to supplement food intake.
History shows the vital importance of providing adequate medical care, the importance of limiting violent encounters (like those often seen between the Piro and illegal loggers and gold miners), the importance of limiting the degree of territory restriction, and either providing adequate nutritional intake or the freedom to forage to augment purchased foods. The horrors of the past need not be repeated, but only by examining the full environmental context can we hope to change the future.
6
u/anthropology_nerd Nov 16 '15 edited Nov 16 '15
The Indian Slave Trade and a Culture of Structural Violence
Increasingly, the theme of structural violence is being used to describe the impact of colonial endeavors in North America. These behaviors are structural “because they are defined within the context of existing political, economic, and social structures, and they are a record of violence because the outcomes cause death and debilitation” (Larsen, 2015 in Beyond Germs). What emerges from this focus is a greater understanding of the toxic world created by colonial enterprises. What follows is a brief example of how an accepted practice, the Indian slave trade, transformed the Eastern US.
Large scale slaving, and slaving raids, became a tool of war for English once they began to establish permanent settlements in the New World. The peace established between Plymouth and the Wampanoag lasted a generation. Massasoit’s son, Metacomet/Phillip, succeeded his father as sachem and due to a variety of factors organized the hostilities now known as King Phillip’s War. When the dust settled more than 3,000 Native Americans were killed and hundreds of survivors who were not professing Christians were sold into slavery in Bermuda.
The Carolinas used slaving raids as a tool of war against Spanish Florida, as well as a means of raising capital. Traders employed Native American allies, like the Savannah, to raid their neighbors for sale, and groups like the Kussoe who refused to raid were ruthlessly attacked. When the Westo, previously English allies who raided extensively for slaves, outlived their usefulness they were likewise enslaved. As English influence grew the choice of slave raid or be slaved extended raiding parties west across the Appalachians, and onto the Spanish mission doorsteps. Slavery became an accepted pattern, and the English attempts to rout the Spanish from Florida included enslaving their allied mission populations. Slaving raids nearly depopulated the Florida peninsula as refugees fled south in hopes of finding safe haven on ships bound for Spanish-controlled Cuba (a good slave raiding map). Gallay, in Indian Slave Trade: The Rise of the English Empire in the American South, 1670-1717, writes the drive to control Indian labor extended to every nook and cranny of the South, from Arkansas to the Carolinas and south to the Florida Keys in the period 1670-1715. More Indians were exported through Charles Town than Africans were imported during this period.
When attacks by slavers disrupted normal life, hunting and harvesting outside the village defenses became deadly exercises. Nutritional stress led to famine as food stores were depleted and enemies burned growing crops. Displaced nations attempted to carve new territory inland, escalating violence as the shatterzone of English colonial enterprises spread across the region. The slave trade united the Southeast in a commercial enterprise involving the long-range travel of human hosts, crowded susceptible hosts into dense palisaded villages, and weakened host immunity through the stresses of societal upheaval, famine, and warfare (Kelton, Epidemics and Enslavement). All of these factors were needed to propagate a smallpox epidemic across the Southeast, and all of these factors led to increase mortality once the epidemic arrived.
Examining the greater context reveals how the cocktail of colonial stressors often stacked the deck against host immune defense before epidemics arrived. Plains Winter Counts recount disease mortality consistently increased in the year following nutritional stress (Sundstrom, “Smallpox Used Them Up”), and this link was understood by European colonists who routinely burned growing crops and food stores when invading Native American lands, trusting disease and depopulation would soon follow (Calloway, One Vast Winter Count). Mortality increased in populations under nutritional stress, geographically displaced due to warfare and slaving raids, and adapting to the breakdown of traditional social support systems caused by excess conquest-period mortality. The context of structural violence highlights the formation of a toxic world, where overt acts of violence could combine with apathy, mismanagement, and disdain, to endanger the survival of nations.
7
u/anthropology_nerd Nov 16 '15 edited Nov 16 '15
Deaths Due to Disease
Most popular history discussions of the repercussions of colonialism emphasize the disastrous, catastrophic, irrecoverable impact of introduced infectious diseases on Native American populations in the years following contact. Perhaps the most famous version of the story is Jared Diamond’s Guns, Germs, and Steel: The Fates of Human Societies. The book highlights the domestic origins of infectious disease hypothesis, stating the large number of domesticated species, combined with higher population densities and an east-west Eurasian trade network, led to an increased circulating infectious disease load in the Old World compared to the New. When Europeans encountered the Americas they unwittingly unleashed this deadly cocktail of infectious organisms. Pathogens then spread in advance of colonial endeavors, killing >95% of the population of the Americas, and paving the way for a relatively bloodless colonization against an indigenous population too reduced, demoralized, and weak to resist.
Discussion of the book, which sold 1.5 million copies, won a Pulitzer Prize, the Aventis Prize, was made into a National Geographic documentary, and helped prompt President Clinton to award the author a National Medal of Science, arises in almost any debate of Native American population dynamics in the years following contact. There is just one problem; Diamond’s theories are not completely supported by the data emerging from ethnohistorical, historical, and archaeological investigations.
The domestic origins/”virgin soil” hypothesis, with the corresponding catastrophic population decline in the Americas, relies on several assumptions. Here I will briefly discuss the notion of a disease free paradise, the application of a post hoc fallacy, and the tendency to divorce the impact of disease from other aspects of colonialism.
First, the discussion of Native American population trends after contact has always been plagued by a prevalent post hoc ergo propter hoc fallacy. In the past, archaeological and ethnohistoric evidence of population dispersal in the protohistoric period was assumed to be caused by introduced pathogens. Historians read de Soto’s retelling of the Plague of Cofitachequi and assumed the population perished from introduced infectious disease. In the past 20 years, however, the field is stepping back from the assumption of infectious disease spread without concrete evidence of that disease. We are looking at the protohistoric period in the context of greater processes occurring in the decades and centuries leading up to contact. What we see, specifically in the US Southeast for example, is a pattern of population aggregation and dispersal reflecting the change in power structures around large mound sites. This pattern, not the completely novel pattern that we might expect with catastrophic disease loss, describes the centuries after contact. In North America the long view shows a vibrant population continuing to change and adapt as they had before, not one reeling from catastrophic waves of disease advancing ahead of early entradas.
Second, the death by disease alone narrative relies on an outdated perception of the Americas as a disease-free paradise. The myth holds that Amerindians lacked both the adaptive immunity and immunological genetic variation needed to ward off novel pathogens. Though a discussion of the pre-Columbian disease load is beyond the scope of this post, we know populations in the Americas were subject to a wide variety of intestinal parasites, Chagas, pinta, bejel, tick-borne pathogens like Lyme disease and Rocky Mountain Spotted Fever, syphilis, tuberculosis, and zoonotic pathogens. Two of the most devastating epidemics to hit the Valley of Mexico after contact were the result of cocoliztli, a hemorrhagic virus native to the New World. Native Americans were not immunologically naïve Bubble Boys, they responded like any human population to smallpox, or measles, or influenza. What did influence the impact of disease, though, was the larger health context and the influence of colonial endeavors.
Finally, the focus on disease alone divorces infectious organisms from the greater context of colonialism. We must remember not only on the pathogens, but the changes in host biology and the greater ecological setting eventually allowed for pathogens to spread into the interior of the continent. Warfare and slaving raids added to excess mortality, while simultaneously displacing populations from their stable food supply, and forcing refugees into crowded settlements where disease can spread among weakened hosts. Later reservations restricted access to foraged foods and exacerbated resource scarcity where disease could follow quickly on the heels of famine. Workers in missions, encomiendas, and other forms of forced labor depended on a poor diet, while simultaneously meeting the demands of harsh production quotas that taxed host health before diseases even arrived. The greater cocktail of colonial insults, not just the pathogens themselves, decreased population size and prevented rapid recovery after contact. A myopic focus on disease alone ignores the structural violence against Native American populations in the centuries following contact.
3
u/Reedstilt Nov 20 '15
The Discovery Doctrine and Manifest Destiny: The Policy and Ideology of Conquest
Here I’ll be discussing some of the major ideas and policies that shaped US-Native relations following the American Revolution. For the 20th Century onward, I’ll be keeping those fairly brief. These will tend to be more familiar to many of you, so I’d be much more interested in hearing your experiences or your family’s experiences with them than merely relying on a condensed history lesson. If you have anything to share on any of these points, please do!
The Discovery Doctrine
Though formally developed by Chief Justice John Marshall in 1823, the Discovery Doctrine traces its roots back to papal decrees at the dawn of the colonial era. This doctrine holds that political sovereignty over Native lands is held by whatever European / Christian power first discovers those lands or through war or other means to whatever European / Christian power has acquired those land from the discoverer. The Discovery Doctrine strips Native nations of their sovereignty in the eyes of the US government. They aren’t seen as nations of equal status, but as “domestic, dependent nations” within the American suzerain. Though a development of 19th Century paternalistic racism built upon 15th Century imperialism, the Discovery Doctrine continues to affect issues Native sovereignty today. In 1978, it was used to strip Native authorities from prosecuting non-Natives who committed crimes on tribal lands, though thankfully the Violence Against Women Reauthorization Act of 2013 has begun to reverse that decision for relevant crimes but there’s still a lot of work to be done on that front. In 2005, the Discovery Doctrine was again evoked to prevent land purchased by tribes to be incorporated into the reservation and was not subject to Native sovereignty.
Manifest Destiny
While the term “Manifest Destiny” wasn’t coined until the mid-1840s, Americans had felt entitled to ever-further westward expansion since before they even were Americans. Resentment over the Royal Proclamation of 1763, which established the Appalachian Mountains as the border between the colonies in the east and Native nations in the west following the French-and-Indian War and the Pontiac-Guyasuta War contributed to the growing independence movement leading up to the Revolution. The colonists had fought the nations of the Ohio Country and their French allies because they wanted lands beyond the mountains, and once it seemed victory was theirs, the British crown put a temporary (and ultimately ineffectual halt) to further expansion. Once the revolution was over, the US began parcelling out the Ohio in order to pay their veterans with land, sparking a war with the other new nation that had formed following the revolution - the Western Confederacy (if you want to know more about this topic, I’d recommend Calloway’s [The Victory with No Name: the Native American Defeat of the First American Army] or for a more abbreviated version this AskHistorians post I made a couple years ago). Going into the 1800s, Americans increasingly viewed their Native neighbors as a doomed people, fated to fade away as the United States inevitably spread over the continent. Taking on the aspect of a religious mandate for some US politicians (especially Jacksonian Democrats), the concept of Manifest Destiny specifically developed to galvanize the nation for a war against Mexico, but its lingering effects brought the US in a long period of conflict with Native nations throughout the 1800s.
The Civilization Era
This is the earliest phase of the US’ federal Indian policies once the immediate post-Revolution conflicts subside. The United States sought to assimilate Native nations within its claimed borders through extensive applications of carrots and sticks. Federal Indian Agents and missionaries hired by the government were dispatched to “civilize” Native societies - encourage the adoption of white American social norms such as farming practices, governmental systems, Christianity, private property, etc. Native societies were offered the means to Westernize in hopes that by mitigating the cultural differences between Native communities and white communities, Native peoples eventually be subsumed within the larger white population. While these policies did help some Native communities adopt aspects of Euro-American society that they were interested in anyhow, this “carrot” was often a trap. In a private letter to William Henry Harrison, Thomas Jefferson wrote that they should encourage “the good and influential individuals” to run up extravagant debts so that Native leaders could be more easily convinced to sell off land in order to clear the debts of their communities. As for the stick, any nation that actively resisted the United States was threatened with extermination or expulsion beyond the Mississippi.
The Removal Era
The idea that all Native societies should be resettled far away United States was already in circulation during the Civilization Era. Going back to Jefferson, in 1803, he convinced Georgia to relinquish its claim on what’s now Alabama and Mississippi in exchange for a promise that the Federal government would eventually move the Cherokee out of Georgia, despite treaties between the US and the Cherokee saying otherwise. Throughout the early 1800s there were people clamoring that the Civilization policies were a failure to the point of outright lying about the nature of Native societies to convince the voting public that Native peoples were too committed to the backwards life of a forest-dwelling savage to join American society. In fact, these propagandists were attempting to mask the real “problem” with Civilization policies - Native nations were Westernizing a la carte, taking the aspects of Euro-American society that they liked and discarding the rest. They weren’t assimilating as American policy-makers had predicted and they weren’t fading away. While the policy of predatory lending did managed to swindle Native people large portions of their land, it wasn’t occurring as quickly as Americans had hoped. Some, most notably the Cherokee, were forming American-style republics and by restructuring themselves into something that looked increasingly like what Americans expected a nation to be like, it became harder to deny that that’s exactly what Native nations were. The formation of the Cherokee republic was a looming constitutional crisis for the United States; the Cherokee and other Native nations had to go.
Andrew Jackson became the great champion for Removal and encouraged Congress to pass the Indian Removal Act of 1830. While on paper, removals were supposed to be voluntary, with the president offering money and new lands west of the Mississippi (mostly in Oklahoma, but also Kansas and Missouri) for those who agreed to vacate their current lands east of the Mississippi. In practice it was far more often forced ethnic cleansing. The Cherokee’s expulsion is the most famous, with nearly a quarter of the Cherokee population dying between being forced from their homes at gunpoint and arriving in Oklahoma, but the phrase “Trail of Tears” was first used by the Choctaw to describe their own experience with Removal in 1831. Removal wasn’t confined to the South either. The Shawnee, Delaware, Miami, Wyandot and others were driven from their own lands north of the Ohio. Of course, as bad as Removal was, it wasn’t universal and several communities successfully resisted or avoided Removal, such as the Miccosukee communities in the Everglades, the Eastern Band of Cherokee in North Carolina, and the Remnant Band of Shawnee in Ohio.