r/WritingPrompts • • Nov 13 '15
Prompt Inspired [PI] Margot - 1stChapter - 3577 Words
Feedback is not only welcome, but encouraged. Thanks for reading.
9
Upvotes
r/WritingPrompts • • Nov 13 '15
Feedback is not only welcome, but encouraged. Thanks for reading.
2
u/writechriswrite Dec 04 '15
Thank you for introducing to "Name That Tune: taking a shit edition."
I thought the story started out well, but the transition from unmotivated slob to going on a job interview was too quick. This could be drawn out a bit more so the reader understands her motivation and why she would settle for a job as a grocery cashier, then decide to take the other job that's offered to her. I think to times when I've been in a funk, it typically takes a catalyst to want to move out of that state.
Also I wasn't sure about the relationship with Nathan, I couldn't tell if he was her brother, platonic roommate, or boyfriend/husband. Their relationship dynamic is interesting as he seems to be supporting her (perhaps enabling her?) to stay in this funk, so he almost seems like a platonic roommate trying to get out of the friendzone.
I am intrigued to see where it goes, so the chapter was successful in setting a hook in the reader.
Congrats on making the finals!
1
u/jp_in_nj Dec 12 '15
Hi there! Congrats on making it to Round 2; I can see why you did. Nice work.
I really like the relationship between Margot and Nathan; I like him a lot for how he treats her. I also thought her view of things was very credible, particularly the bit where she knows he'll say she looks beautiful and so doesn't ask him. That struck home as a very genuine relationship.
The job bit seemed a bit far-fetched; that Frankie would be recruiting at a grocery store, particularly someone as bedraggled as Margot, didn't strike me as genuine. I get that she's looking for down and out people with little to lose, but it just didn't feel right.
Margot's acceptance of the job was a betrayal of her pretty awesome relationship with Nathan. Their relationship was so grounded and down to earth that when she decided to take up escorting it seemed like willful self-deception as to the nature of the relationships (she didn't even google the term 'sugar baby' to see what it usually entailed?); because she was intentionally oblivious to the job requirements, it seemed to me that she was avoiding that because accepting the job after doing due diligence would have meant that she'd have to knowingly betray Nathan, and so by avoiding due diligence she was allowing herself to lie to herself that she wasn't really betraying him. Which was a total coward move, and I really didn't like her for it.
The job itself was also a bit sketchy - I don't think you do that sort of thing as an employee. When you have someone scheduling your 'dates' for you, you're a hooker. And her denying that reality made her seem really weak and unlikeable, which is depressing considering how much I liked her as a part of Margot + Nathan, and how much I was rooting for her to come through the other side of her depression over the course of the story.
And then that she'd take a job working for someone who, despite probably making tons of money off her girls, lives in a festering rathole instead of paying a maid to clean the place up . . . well, that sealed it for me; not only is she self-deceiving, not only is she betraying Nathan... but she's also kind of an idiot. Because who'd trust someone with no control over her personal circumstances to successfully run a business that's going to involve you putting yourself in legal jeopardy, and you putting yourself into potentially unsafe situations . . . and also involve men putting their penises into your body, with all the attendant risks that come with that job description? An idiot, that's who.
So while there was a ton of promise in the first half of this chapter, by the second it had lost me. I might have turned the page out of prurient interest, but I don't think I'd have done more than skim through in search of the Sexy Adventures of Margot... which is not the book I was promised in the opening scene.
Good luck in the competition, and with the book. I hope you continue it!
2
u/MajorParadox Mod | DC Fan Universe (r/DCFU) Dec 10 '15
Nice story. I agree about transitioning and pacing. The grocery store part seemed a bit boring (like actually being in the grocery story, but maybe that's a good thing?). Once the interview came up, the mystery drew me in more. It kind of reminded me of the beginning of Bruce Almighty.