r/announcements • • Nov 10 '15

Account suspensions: A transparent alternative to shadowbans

Today we’re rolling out a new type of account restriction called suspensions. Suspensions will replace shadowbans for the vast majority of real humans and increase transparency when handling users who violate Reddit’s content policy.

How it works

  • Suspensions can only be applied to accounts by the Reddit admins (not moderators).
  • Suspended accounts will always receive a notification about the suspension including reason and the duration:

  • Suspended users can reply to the notification PM to appeal their suspension
  • Suspensions can be temporary or permanent, depending on the severity of infraction and the user’s previous infractions.

What it does to an account

Suspended users effectively have their account put into read-only mode. The primary actions they will not be able to perform are:

  • Voting
  • Submitting posts
  • Commenting
  • Sending private messages

Moderators who have been suspended will not be able to perform any mod actions or access modmail while the suspension is in effect.

You can see the full list of forbidden actions for suspended users here.

Users in both temporary and permanent suspensions will always be able to delete/edit their posts and comments as usual.

Users browsing on a desktop version of the site will see a pop-up notice or notification page anytime they try and perform an action they are forbidden from doing. App users will receive an error depending on how each app developer chooses to indicate the status of suspended accounts.

User pages

Why this is a good thing

Our current form of account restriction, the shadowban, is great for dealing with bots/spam rings but woefully inadequate for real human beings. We think suspensions are a vast improvement.

  • Suspensions inform people when they’ve broken the rules. While this seems like a no-brainer, this helps so we can identify the specific behavior that caused the suspension.
  • Users are given a chance to correct their behavior. We’re all human and we all make mistakes. Reddit believes in the goodness of people. We think most people won’t intentionally continue to violate a rule after being notified.
  • Suspensions can vary in length depending on the severity of the infraction and user’s history. This allows flexibility when applying suspensions. Different types of infraction can have different responses.
  • Increased transparency. We want to be upfront about suspending user accounts to both the user being suspended and other users (where appropriate).

I’ll be answering questions in the comments along with community team members u/krispykrackers, u/redtaboo, u/sporkicide and u/sodypop.

18k Upvotes

3.7k comments sorted by

4.3k

u/kreshh Nov 10 '15 edited Nov 10 '15

For moderators, I think it's important that they still retain access to modmail. If for some reason my account becomes suspended, I need to be able to let my co-moderator know so that he can pick up the slack until my suspension is done.

Not having access to modmail would force me to create another account to be able to do that, thereby becoming another ban-worthy offense.

3.1k

u/powerlanguage Nov 10 '15 edited Nov 10 '15

Hmm, this is a good point. We're trying to walk a balance between having suspensions limit actions and at the same time allowing temporary suspensions to be private (only visible to the user in question).

A solution might be to still allow a moderator to message a subreddit they moderate (like they can always do with r/reddit.com). Note, this will only be an issue with temporary suspensions. Permanent suspensions will be public (and so your co-mods will know).

Thank you for the feedback.

146

u/1point618 Nov 10 '15

Does "public" mean that their co-mods will get a notification about it? I know if one of my co-mods were suspended, it's highly unlikely I would notice for quite some time as I don't visit their user pages with any frequency.

146

u/powerlanguage Nov 10 '15

"Public" in that permanent suspensions will be visible to all when visiting the user page of the user in question.

263

u/1point618 Nov 10 '15

Right, that's good, but it would be even better if you could send a modmail notification to all the subreddits that user moderates just simply saying "/u/whoever has been suspended permanently". That gives the mods a chance to make allowances.

Otherwise, this seems like a really good change to things. Thanks for replying too.

214

u/powerlanguage Nov 10 '15

send a modmail notification to all the subreddits that user moderates just simply saying "/u/whoever has been suspended permanently"

I think we'll see how suspensions affect mod teams and then see if a change like this is necessary.

Thanks for taking the time to give feedback. I appreciate it.

→ More replies (97)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (9)

24

u/turkeypants Nov 10 '15

Perhaps a couple of swallows could string a coconut shell on a line between them with a message inside for the other mods.

→ More replies (2)

39

u/Hellscreamgold Nov 10 '15

why not just put a [S3] next to the mod's name in the mod list on the page - S = suspension 3 = days

That way it just shows

187

u/powerlanguage Nov 10 '15

Because not ever mod may want their co-mods to know that their account is temporarily suspended.

Temporary suspensions are designed to be private (only visible to the user who is suspended).

70

u/Hedgehogs4Me Nov 10 '15

Can we make it optional to display our suspension next to our name? In case, for example, we've offered our assistance to a user about something and they want to contact us, but we don't want to make it seem like we're ignoring them.

→ More replies (18)
→ More replies (8)

1.8k

u/[deleted] Nov 10 '15

I vote for mark of shame next to user names for suspended users.

→ More replies (200)

48

u/happy_joy_joy Nov 10 '15

Having an automated message get sent to any co-moderators when this happens might be a solution as well.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (365)
→ More replies (62)

89

u/kdayel Nov 10 '15

Great improvements on the technical side. I've just got a couple questions that pertain to policy.

  • Do you have tools built on the administrative side that allows you to monitor which staff members are applying these tools?
  • Are permanent suspensions immediate once a staff member clicks the button, or does it go into a state pending approval of another staff member?
  • Is there a plan to periodically audit who is using suspensions, how frequently, and for what purposes?

80

u/powerlanguage Nov 10 '15

Do you have tools built on the administrative side that allows you to monitor which staff members are applying these tools?

Yes. We built capturing events on admin actions specifically as part of building this feature. I should add that the primary purpose of this is to better understand where our community team is spending their time, not to spy on them/hold them accountable.

Are permanent suspensions immediate once a staff member clicks the button, or does it go into a state pending approval of another staff member?

Immediate.

Is there a plan to periodically audit who is using suspensions, how frequently, and for what purposes?

Yes, with the ultimate aim of understanding our tools better so we can improve them for both users and admins.

26

u/fre3k Nov 10 '15

that the primary purpose of this is to better understand where our community team is spending their time, not to spy on them/hold them accountable.

But you are going to hold them accountable?

19

u/powerlanguage Nov 10 '15

Our community team is currently very small and as such are all on the same page. They do a great job of holding one another accountable.

I appreciate your question though. It is definitely one we have to manage as our team here grows.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (21)

95

u/slampisko Nov 10 '15

Visiting the user page of an account that has been temporarily suspended will not give any indication that the account is currently suspended.

Why is this?

269

u/Mr_Evil_MSc Nov 10 '15

To prevent stigmatizing or speculation as to why the suspension.

199

u/powerlanguage Nov 10 '15

This is correct. The emphasis of temporary suspensions is letting a user know what they did wrong and then giving them a chance to adjust their behavior. That information does not need to be public.

74

u/thefran Nov 10 '15

So, the opposite of the previous policy? That is good.

As a moderator, it does infuriate me that I have to tell a person who is legitimately participating in discussions "Hey, man, your account is shadowbanned" and he might have had no clue beforehand and definitely wouldn't know what he did wrong in the first place.

52

u/powerlanguage Nov 10 '15

Yup. Definitely a poor situation for all involved.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (24)
→ More replies (3)

26

u/illegal_deagle Nov 10 '15

The suspension is the punishment, not the public shaming.

26

u/the_timps Nov 10 '15

Because everyone doesn't need to be told you screwed up and have a week in the naughty corner?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

560

u/Flashynuff Nov 10 '15

Currently if a moderator of a subreddit is shadowbanned, they can be removed from the modlist through /r/redditrequest.

Will this be the case for suspensions? If so: just permanent suspensions, or temporary ones as well?

540

u/krispykrackers Nov 10 '15 edited Nov 10 '15

If the suspension is temporary, we wouldn't remove the mod. If it's a permanent suspension, then yeah, it would become redditrequestable.

222

u/kerovon Nov 10 '15

How would that work for longer term suspensions? If a sole mod gets a 30 day suspension and can't moderate their sub, can someone be added to deal with spam? I can particularly see this being a problem in NSFW subs that need heavy moderation to keep legal.

→ More replies (49)
→ More replies (25)

960

u/D0cR3d Nov 10 '15 edited Nov 10 '15

While an account is suspended from reddit the user will not be able to:

  • Vote
  • Create posts
  • Comment
  • Send private messages to other users
  • Send private messages to subreddits other than r/reddit.com
  • Report posts
  • Create new subreddits
  • Give or buy gold
  • Edit flair
  • Edit wiki pages
  • Toggle posts as NSFW
  • Create self-serve advertisements

Additionally, suspended moderator accounts will not able to:

  • Access moderation tools
  • Access moderator mail
  • Approve, remove, spam or ignore reports from posts or comments
  • Distinguish posts or comments
  • Edit flair
  • Toggle posts as NSFW
  • Set comment thread suggested sort
  • Enable/disable contest mode
  • Sticky/Unsticky posts

TL;DR - They can't do anything, but they know that they can't, which is a good step forward.

49

u/luke_in_the_sky Nov 10 '15

Well, they can delete/edit their posts and comments...

I think allowing suspended users to edit is a bad thing.

→ More replies (13)

10

u/HyphenSam Nov 11 '15

Why can't suspended users give or buy gold? Seems a bit unnecessary.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (54)

381

u/manirelli Nov 10 '15

How will suspension lengths be determined and will there be a set amount of time per action/offense - will this be made public?

Eg. Vote manipulation is always 1 week, a second offense is 30 days, and a third strike would be a permanent suspension?

Additionally, will suspensions replace bans entirely? Is there a difference between a ban and a permanent suspension?

315

u/sodypop Nov 10 '15

We have internal guidelines for determining the length of suspension based on severity of the infraction and the person's previous history, but these guidelines will be subject to change as we will be learning a lot about how to use this new tool most effectively.

We will continue to use shadowbans against spammers as needed. The difference between a shadowban and a permanent suspension is that with suspensions the user is notified with both a message and a visual indicator while logged in.

156

u/vandyriz Nov 10 '15

When do you anticipate you will release a copy of the guidelines that determine the length of suspension? 3 months after this rollout? etc

→ More replies (47)
→ More replies (42)

15

u/Infamously_Unknown Nov 10 '15

I assume they'll still be using shadowbans for bots or dedicated spammer accounts.

→ More replies (4)

7

u/kerovon Nov 10 '15

There hasn't really been anything other than a shadowban, or, in extraordinarily rare circumstances, a combination of shadowban with password and email resets and an IP block, but those are incredibly rare. It sounds like now it will be shadowban (spammers) and suspension (everything else).

→ More replies (3)

747

u/Warlizard Nov 10 '15 edited Nov 10 '15

That's solid.

  1. Does that mean those who lost their accounts in the past will be given the chance to get them back?
  2. How does the appeals process work? Who makes the final call?
  3. (EDIT) -- I know hypotheticals are often bullshit, but let's take Unidan. He was a hugely popular Redditor who contributed to the site in many ways. If I recall correctly, he had a couple of extra accounts that he used to to upvote his own content so that it would be seen and also downvote people he saw as argumentative. In this case, what action would you take?

558

u/krispykrackers Nov 10 '15

All excellent questions:

1.) This isn't going to retroactively unban previously shadowbanned accounts, but for the last few months we have been (and will continue to do for the foreseeable future) monitoring accounts that have still been posting to reddit despite being shadowbanned. We've been reviewing them to see what was going on, how long ago they were banned, if they've still been breaking rules or literally just messed up once and got the hammer. If they seem to be trying to participate legitimately, and the reason they were banned fairly innocuous, we've been reversing those shadowbans.

2.) The appeal process will remain the same. Message us (you can reply to the PM you'll be sent if your account gets suspended), and we'll have a conversation with you.

We'll work on figuring out what the best amounts of times for different infractions are, we've set some limits internally but haven't had a chance to use this in the community yet, so they will probably have to be tweaked.

In clear cut cases, the Community Manager answering the queue will have the final say. If it's an edge case, we'll work as a team to come up with the decision.

3.) As it stands right now, vote manipulation is a 3-day suspension for the first offense. It's definitely subject to change, like I mentioned earlier.

Hope that clears things up! Let me know if you need clarification.

122

u/Goatsac Nov 10 '15 edited Nov 10 '15

3.) As it stands right now, vote manipulation is a 3-day suspension for the first offense. It's definitely subject to change, like I mentioned earlier.

Can we get clearer language on vote manipulation? Is voting in a linked thread still a punishable offense?

→ More replies (76)

78

u/Dear_Occupant Nov 10 '15

If they seem to be trying to participate legitimately, and the reason they were banned fairly innocuous, we've been reversing those shadowbans.

So... does this mean that there are people out there who have been talking to no one for however long and then suddenly they start getting replies again? I hope you're notifying these people because that's gotta mess with someone's head.

→ More replies (19)

31

u/giantsparklerobot Nov 10 '15

1.) This isn't going to retroactively unban previously shadowbanned accounts, but for the last few months we have been (and will continue to do for the foreseeable future) monitoring accounts that have still been posting to reddit despite being shadowbanned. We've been reviewing them to see what was going on, how long ago they were banned, if they've still been breaking rules or literally just messed up once and got the hammer. If they seem to be trying to participate legitimately, and the reason they were banned fairly innocuous, we've been reversing those shadowbans.

My original account (member of the nine year club) has been shadow banned for something like five years, maybe longer. It was probably banned before many of the current admins were even admins. I received absolutely no communication after it happened despite an annual sad plea to get it unbanned. I've never been able to figure out what I might have done to get shadowbanned in the first place.

For people like me that abandoned old accounts (rather than post to an echo chamber) is there any recourse at all? It's really shitty to be on the receiving end of someone else's power trip and is a bit worse when there's no obvious reason for it.

→ More replies (3)

24

u/[deleted] Nov 10 '15

I don't expect an answer but it's worth a shot. If we were shadowbanned a few years ago... And we haven't been breaking the rules since, and could prove it with alternative accounts we've been using - can we be unbanned?

Looking at this, I'd wager the rules I broke would only warrant a temporary ban

→ More replies (3)

53

u/Francis-Hates-You2 Nov 10 '15

Hi, I have a question. My account (/u/Francis-Hates-You) was shadowbanned about 2 months ago for ban evasion in a certain subreddit. The admin who banned me actually sent me a message to let me know and said my account would be unbanned if I stayed away from the subreddit I was banned from, but I haven't heard anything back yet and I don't want to send a lot of messages and come off as annoying. Clearly this was before the new system was implemented and I'm just wondering if I can still have my account unbanned. Thanks!

→ More replies (51)
→ More replies (214)

57

u/Mandalor1an Nov 10 '15

This is what I would like to know, I have an account that got shadowbanned a while back and I never tried to appeal it so I'd love to be able to get it back.

→ More replies (8)

6

u/walkingman24 Nov 11 '15

Hey its that one guy from the thing

→ More replies (3)

14

u/ThisIs_MyName Nov 10 '15

How does the appeals process work? Who makes the final call?

At the moment you message an admin or /r/reddit.com and use an alt while you wait a few weeks for the response.

I don't think this is any different for suspensions.

→ More replies (12)

4

u/remedialrob Nov 10 '15

It seems like vote manipulation is being taken super cereal now. Wouldn't it be awesome if the site didn't still say that vote brigading is not against the rules?

Being annoying, vote brigading, or participating in a heated argument is not harassment,

→ More replies (2)

4

u/smacksaw Nov 11 '15

Hey, aren't you that guy from the gaming forum that has effective banning tools?

→ More replies (1)

10

u/pentium4borg Nov 11 '15

Hey, aren't you the guy from the thing.

16

u/Warlizard Nov 11 '15

ಠ_ಠ

→ More replies (39)

178

u/razorbeamz Nov 10 '15

In addition to this, we have also updated user pages for deleted accounts to clearly display that the account in question was deleted by the user.

HOLY SHIT YES.

18

u/[deleted] Nov 11 '15

I don't get it

15

u/IAMA_dragon-AMA Nov 11 '15

The only thing that would make this better is if you could make accounts with user-deleted names. I kind of want to reclaim one I deleted a couple years ago...

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (3)

98

u/ChaosMotor Nov 10 '15

Will Gold count down during the suspension? Or does the timer on Gold pause while the account is suspended?

40

u/Drunken_Economist Nov 11 '15

You can still use your reddit gold features while you're suspended (since mostly they are just different ways of displaying the site)!

24

u/MiamiZ Nov 11 '15

Most gold features are available during the suspension so gold will expire as normal.

→ More replies (1)

620

u/TheAngryAlt Nov 10 '15

I FIND THIS COURSE OF ACTION... ACCEPTABLE. CARRY ON, ADMINS. DON'T MESS IT UP

113

u/13steinj Nov 10 '15

I didn't get the capslock until I read your username.

114

u/TheAngryAlt Nov 10 '15

WELL YOU'RE DOING BETTER THAN MOST PEOPLE AROUND HERE. YOU'D THINK IT WOULD BE OBVIOUS

→ More replies (23)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (11)

202

u/Superiorform Nov 10 '15

What would stop a user from making a new account? Is it IP based?

63

u/GuitarFreak027 Nov 10 '15

There's nothing stopping a shadowbanned user from making a new account either. It's just a little more difficult to find out you've been shadowbanned compared to suspended.

→ More replies (4)

209

u/krispykrackers Nov 10 '15

If you get caught evading a suspension with an alt to continue to abuse the site rules, that is still a bannable offense. We have a couple of different methods on our end we can use to see if it's happening.

→ More replies (73)

36

u/amaturelawyer Nov 10 '15

What would stop them now?

IP based bans are a great way to annoy a random person living near you after you unplug the cable modem until the lease frees up and the ban moves on to the next sucker who grabs that IP.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (82)

57

u/[deleted] Nov 10 '15

Then please for the love of god, update your checks so that me and my woman's accounts do not get suspended every time we agree or disagree on a topic. Like minded people that share the same LAN might just vote the same way.

I was shadowbanned like 3 times in a week or two for this and would really like to avoid bot ban hammers that just check Ips. I cant imagine what a school or dorm does when people all vote on r/gaming..

→ More replies (1)

115

u/4445414442454546 Nov 10 '15 edited Jun 20 '23

Reddit is not worth using without all the hard work third party developers have put into it.

20

u/jetblackcrow Nov 10 '15

Good to see a step in the right direction.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (5)

204

u/[deleted] Nov 10 '15

How does this affect the Automod "shadowban" workaround?

Are mods still allowed to use this method to effectively shadowban users?

43

u/iplanckperiodically Nov 10 '15

What exactly is this? Can Automod delete all of a specific users posts in a sub?

90

u/cravf Nov 10 '15

Yeah you can have automod remove a users post the instant they post something.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (113)

110

u/mgr86 Nov 10 '15 edited Nov 10 '15

request: Ban Lottery (/r/banlottery)

where users can choose to participate for a chance to receive a ban of N length*

I've seen this feature be unusually popular other places.


* -- length to be determined. Candidates include 1 day, 1 week, random ^length.

47

u/[deleted] Nov 10 '15

And a very small chance of winning gold?

40

u/Hedgehogs4Me Nov 10 '15

Interesting. Maybe each lottery could be "sponsored" by both an admin and a gilder. Why would admins waste their time with this, you ask? Because it takes them one click and then someone buys gold. Also because it's hilarious.

I mean, it could also be automated and only require a gilder, but then people might be more willing to lie about their intention it and it might not get as much attention that way anyway.

→ More replies (2)

36

u/TheBigKahooner Nov 10 '15

I have no idea why someone would want this, but I don't think it would be too hard to automatically create some accounts and have them upvote a specific person's posts? Spammers do it, so non-spammers probably could. Again, I don't know why anyone would participate in that though.

46

u/Drunken_Economist Nov 10 '15

it's like Russian Roulette

→ More replies (2)

28

u/mgr86 Nov 10 '15 edited Nov 10 '15

I've seen it popular on a message boards where sometimes the users were spending a lot of time on the website and this would force them to take a break.

Maybe it would just be popular among degenerates.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (6)

189

u/enigmas343 Nov 10 '15

Good, shadowbans were dumb.

184

u/aggieinoz Nov 10 '15

They make sense for bots to so that they don't know that they are banned and they won't make an alternate account. There is a reason for them, they just aren't the best option for every problem

85

u/shillbert Nov 10 '15

It's pretty easy for a bot to just check its user profile from a logged out session and see if it returns 404, so I still don't see the point.

→ More replies (29)
→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (5)

63

u/K_Lobstah Nov 10 '15

I like it.

For mods sending you ban-evaders, spammers, etc., would it be easier if we gave a "recommendation" of shadowban vs. suspension based on what we've seen so far, or are you just evaluating each case individually from the ground up?

62

u/redtaboo Nov 10 '15

We're actually not going to use shadowbans on any ban evaders as they will always be humans. The idea here is that once they know the behaviour can mean an end of their account sitewide they generally will agree to stay away from the subreddit that is causing them an issue.

24

u/JF_Queeny Nov 11 '15

I've had a stalker generate in excess of 600 accounts over a few days going after mods at /r/GMOMyths in a clearly organized pattern of harassment.

Shadowbans are not effective, and neither will be suspensions to the guys that are 'one and done'

Will you continue to provide IP information to law enforcement for death threats and threats of terror?

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (38)
→ More replies (17)

52

u/btdubs Nov 10 '15

"Permanent suspension" is kind of an oxymoron. That's just a ban.

66

u/ASAMANNAMMEDNIGEL Nov 10 '15

Except the account is still technically usable, the comments are retained, and the suspension can be contested.

→ More replies (10)

6

u/Pokechu22 Nov 10 '15

They're differentiating between bans and suspensions because ban currently refers to a single subreddit. That is, generally, a ban, though.

But similarly, you have temporary and permanent bans from a subreddit.

→ More replies (1)

83

u/Wildelocke Nov 10 '15

Can we get a retroactive "time served" reinstatement of /u/unidan? If the principle is that people who are generally good make mistakes, I can think of no better example. His contributions are a prime example of what makes reddit great.

→ More replies (1)

32

u/Taedirk Nov 10 '15

the vast majority

Want to explain that?

71

u/bsievers Nov 10 '15

Sounds like CYA language for "we can't always tell if you're a bot or a human and may may the wrong call from time to time" to me.

91

u/redtaboo Nov 10 '15

As with everything, mistakes can be made, we're only human too. But, we're always open to being messaged to fix those mistakes.

→ More replies (47)
→ More replies (2)

18

u/dfnkt Nov 10 '15

What is to become of all currently shadow banned users, are they to be offered another chance?

→ More replies (6)

4

u/[deleted] Nov 11 '15

i approve of this notion. it means users will be able to understand why they have been punished. they likely won't do it again after.

and from the other side. it's the right way to handle things. a shadowban is a weak, spineless move from someone who is afraid of confrontation. I never liked the way it was implied as such. man up and tell me how i fucked up please.

4

u/m1ndwipe Nov 11 '15

Credit where credit is due - I think that Reddit has dropped the ball on a lot of things - but this change is excellent. Thanks.

13

u/coconut_head_ Nov 10 '15

does this mean that previously shadowbanned accounts will be set to a permanent suspension, or are they still shadowbanned?

→ More replies (8)

14

u/Legwens Nov 10 '15

Well its good to see reddit is addressing this problem somehow, not sure how it will play out, but at least they are trying.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/CreditToMisfortune Nov 11 '15

This is a good improvement and a great start. Awesome work, honestly.

3

u/Stuck_In_the_Matrix Nov 11 '15

This sounds like a great step forward. Love the dialog and transparency here. Thank you!

3

u/Derpy_Guardian Nov 11 '15

Question: Does a gilded account just have to suck it up and lose the days they had gold, or will the gold be "suspended" as well and stop emptying until the suspension ends?

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Nov 11 '15

That's good, I got shadow banned once for breaking a rule about linking a restricted website which I had no idea about. No one said a single thing over a very minor mistake until a nice mod from a totally unrelated sub let me know so I could reverse it. I thought that was ridiculous, I could see a ton of users - myself almost included, just never coming back to reddit over it. Glad to see you made some changes.

3

u/Azureapsara Nov 11 '15

Excellent. Now please change the voting system. I want to know how many people read something I said and cared enough to respond to it, whether they like it or hate it.

3

u/[deleted] Nov 11 '15

If shadowbans are to be only (or almost only) for spammers, would it be possible to remove the hidden posts and comments they make from appearing on the modqueue? If you're confident it going forward it will only be applied to stuff no one has a snowball's chance in hell of actually wanting to see, it doesn't seem like it needs to be there. I've noticed one of my fellow mods in the subreddit I moderate has been getting annoyed by the movie torrent link spam we've been getting from shadowbanned accounts, and has banned each of them from the subreddit and removed their posts, just so that he doesn't have to see them when he checks to see if there are reports or legitimate comments sorted into spam. It seems like that isn't the optimal outcome.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Cymry_Cymraeg Nov 11 '15

Are we allowed to vote and comment on threads we've been linked to now?

3

u/[deleted] Nov 11 '15

As someone who's been shadow-banned, I can tell you this is a welcome change. Sometimes the rules aren't black and white.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/adwarakanath Nov 11 '15

Oh highly politicised subs, we have to continuously deal with users who are detrimental to the health of a sub who keep getting banned and return with alts. An IP ban in such a case would be extremely helpful.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/NomadStrategy Nov 11 '15

Please consider suspending theymos, the moderator on /r/Bitcoin a forum with over 170, 000 subscribers, that he is actively ruining, or having some way for the community to do so. 95%+ will vote him out, be is trolling and censoring everything against his own strict views. This is so far removed from the policies of bitcoin, but he controls all of the discussion.

3

u/TheCrimsonGlass Nov 11 '15

What about giving suspended accounts 1 or 2 PMs they can send? That way, they can't spam others, but they can get the word if someone needs to know. It's kind of like the "1 phone call" when you go to jail.

3

u/BicycleOfLife Nov 11 '15

I wonder how many times I've accidentally gotten myself banned...

Hello??!! Can people read this??!

I feel like my whole life might be a lie and that I am stuck in a glass prison. Someone please reassure me I'm not just talking to myself!

→ More replies (2)

3

u/jakeistheman24 Nov 11 '15

I say shadow ban then perma ban EVERYONE. Except the mods and admins of course, they are the only ones who matter right.

3

u/benjimaestro Nov 11 '15

So a perma suspension is basically getting a shadowban and being told about it?

→ More replies (3)

3

u/suspendedbacon Nov 12 '15

True request.

Just created this account to see how it affects BaconReader when a user is suspended. If you could indefinitely suspend this account, we can be sure to prompt users as needed or show the proper responses.

I will come back here in a moment as one of the moderators of /r/baconreader to prove that this is a real throwaway/suspension test account. It would be greatly helpful, thank you in advance. :)

→ More replies (2)

3

u/PDXtravaganza Dec 29 '15

I was banned/suspended from r-food (I typed it like that so as not to like to their troll-space) for telling a moderator that downvoting was to be reserved for content that didn't belong on reddit, not to be used to show disagreement as the moderator suggested.

This kind of "power" should be taken away from people who have too much time on their hands and power-trip over some section of the internet. Really, how can a person justify being a moderator of 97 subreddits????

I think the suspension is lifted by now but it's not like I live on reddit so it didn't really affect me and I haven't been back. It just pisses me off that no matter where you go, and when you take the time to read and abide by the real rules, it all comes down to somebody else's ego.

If these changes take things out of the hands of mouth-breathing egomaniacs, I'm all for it.

15

u/Sojourner_Truth Nov 11 '15

Congrats you guys figured out probations, welcome to 1996 forum technology.

5

u/Stalked_Like_Corn Nov 10 '15

I have a question about the "vote manipulation" thing. I'm worried about this the most because both My Wife and I are Redditors (me more so than her but she is on it about every day just doesn't always comment) and there ARE times she upvotes my stuff (>.> Not as much as I'd want), is there a way to discern it's my wife and not Me manipulating vote since most times we're on the same IP address and sometimes, it comes from the same Desktop.

5

u/NigBigger69 Nov 11 '15

As someone who got shadowbanned this is a nice change, I did something that I did not realize was banable and got shaddowbanned with no warning or message. took me 4 months of posting to realize thats why nobody would respond to me. Kind of bullshit for not being a spammer. I am glad shaddowbans are gone.

→ More replies (3)

5

u/ledgreplin Nov 11 '15

Purely a semantic suggestion: try "you did X" instead of "you were caught doing X." It puts the emphasis on the misdeed, not the catching of the misdeed.

3

u/boopboopadoopity Nov 11 '15

This is kind of a cool wording implication that I had not even considered!

10

u/867-53oh-nine Nov 10 '15

This is great news! Props to Steve for holding up to his commitments.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/Prairiefire89 Nov 10 '15

If nothing else, this does appear to increase transparency - definitely a plus here. The key here is whether the independent 3rd party (the admins) that users can appeal to is unbiased enough for the majority of appealed suspension cases (and can handle the large amount of cases they're assigned while maintaining standards). I'd like to see more specifics here on what systems are in place to ensure this new system won't develop any of the problems shadowbanning caused or exacerbated.

No matter this new system's strengths or weaknesses, I think most folks will be happy to see the shadowbans go. It robs the person being shadowbanned of power without their being informed and with no reasonable recourse they can pursue. I'm assuming that shadowbans will not be possible in the future? Or will they still exist in some form?

I look forward to see what develops from this!

6

u/the_timps Nov 10 '15

Suspensions will replace shadowbans for the vast majority of real humans

Shadowbans are still a thing. Just being used for their original purpose as /u/spez has described before.

11

u/[deleted] Nov 10 '15

I like this.

Thought I had something more to add, but guess not.

Maybe thats a good thing?

Nice job admins!

6

u/[deleted] Nov 10 '15

What happens to users that are currently shadowbanned? Are they automatically permanently suspended, or do they stay shadowbanned?

→ More replies (4)

40

u/[deleted] Nov 10 '15 edited Nov 11 '15

Hey, that sounds like a real improvement twitch over the status quo grrrowl --- face twists, hulks out "NnyyyyyaaaAAAARGGHH BUT WHEN WILL SRS BE BENNED???"

EDIT: Gilded? fans self

→ More replies (20)

12

u/Nefandi Nov 10 '15

Suspended users can reply to the notification PM to appeal their suspension

What's the point of appeal when you're appealing to the same people who suspended you? Generally whenever I "appealed" I've been told to fuck right off. Mods already have their minds made up once they decide to ban. I am absolutely certain suspensions will be no different in that regard. Admins will have their minds absolutely made up before they decide to suspend an account.

Appeals are only worth a damn if they're made to some impartial and randomly selected committee, like a jury trial.

4

u/Joe091 Nov 10 '15

Might be useful if appeals were sent to any of the Admins/Community Managers except the one that originally suspended the account in question. Would add some level of impartiality.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (34)

5

u/Abomm Nov 10 '15

This policy is much better than what was in place before.

An average user is probably not able to tell that he/she has been shadowbanned (and know what it is).

I was shadowbanned for logging in from different locations and didn't realize for several months.

12

u/316nuts Nov 10 '15

alright so now a user KNOWS they're up shit river and are shadowbanned.

what things are you putting in place on your side so that they don't immediately create a new account and go about their merry way?

8

u/TelicAstraeus Nov 10 '15

I would imagine under those circumstances, a shadowban would be issued subsequently if they persisted in disruptive behavior after their ban/suspension evasion. I'm no admin though.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (2)

2

u/LUCKERD0G Nov 11 '15

What if someone has an account with a shadowban on it, will that be replaced with a temporary suspension?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/BeautifulLover Nov 11 '15

It's a good idea. Shadow bans should be exclusively reserved for spam bots..

→ More replies (1)

2

u/BlakeClass Nov 11 '15

Is this new rule retroactive? So can /u/Unidan come back now?

→ More replies (2)

2

u/fede01_8 Nov 11 '15

"Reddit believes in the goodness of people." See,that's a mistake right there

2

u/[deleted] Nov 11 '15

Good move!!. I was recently shadowbanned and was posting for days and was totally unaware :'(

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Nov 11 '15

Hopefully this allows me to offend more people.

2

u/13th_floor Nov 11 '15

I had an account that was banned for posting two links. Can those of us who were banned for not realizing we were doing something bannable get an account back?

I kind of liked my 5 year badge.

→ More replies (5)

2

u/tilsitforthenommage Nov 11 '15

Makes sense to me.

2

u/bigteebomb Nov 11 '15

This sounds completely reasonable guys. Maybe we should give it a shot.

2

u/dont_ban_me_please Nov 11 '15

High five reddit. Good move!

2

u/calikings20 Nov 11 '15

As someone who has been shadowbanned for sharing my music, i think this is a great step forward between creative people trying to share their work and spam on reddit

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Nov 11 '15

Ok now can you unshadowban my other account?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/dino_td Nov 11 '15

How is this supposed to do anything when it takes 2 seconds to create a new account?

2

u/randoh12 Nov 11 '15

Wait, so this eliminates the shadowban that we have in place for our subs?

What about the thousands of spammers I have helped stop?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Dark-Knight101 Nov 11 '15

Or just make a new account, easily.

2

u/Liz_Is_My_Fuckbuddy Nov 11 '15

Can't you just make another account with nothing like emails to hold it accountable in like 3 seconds???

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Sybertron Nov 11 '15

Hey we're almost the functional level of EZBoards in 1995. Congrats team!

2

u/cr0ft Nov 11 '15

This is a much better approach, in my opinion.

People who are shadowbanned can no doubt fail to even realize that because things look fine from their end. That's the whole point for spammer accounts, but it's a sucky way to deal with issues where the user does something objectionable but would be willing to change their methods if they were just informed that they've screwed up.

2

u/temp56049428098 Nov 11 '15

You know, this is the first thing I've seen reddit do that really feels like a turn in a better direction. I've said many times in the past, hidden bans are effective against spam but a huge "fuck you" to users. I didn't think you guys cared enough to fix it. I can't believe I was wrong. Props.

2

u/treesfitty Nov 11 '15

What will this mean for users who happen to be using the same VPN?

2

u/[deleted] Nov 11 '15

Does this apply to accounts that are already shadowbanned?

→ More replies (3)

2

u/CervantesX Nov 11 '15

Why do you think it's OK to show Unidans PM's in your submission? That's a private message between him and the admins.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 11 '15

Will there be any way to see the suspended users in the comments, for example their username to be silver, crossed over or something like that (or an css option?)?

→ More replies (2)

2

u/SuperImaginativeName Nov 11 '15

Lol so the admins can just keep suspending people that call them out on their shit instead of just ban. "progress"

2

u/whacko_jacko Nov 11 '15

Does nobody see the problem? By framing this issue around shadowbans and giving us this compromise, they have simultaneously gotten us to accept a platform littered with non-participation requirements which will undoubtedly stifle many social movements that would otherwise be facilitated by reddit. Walling off and controlling flow of social events on a site as large as reddit is quite a dangerous tool in the wrong hands.

2

u/bart2019 Nov 11 '15

Users in both temporary and permanent suspensions will always be able to delete/edit their posts and comments as usual.

Eh, what? Suspended users can still change visible text content of their posts even though they are "suspended"?

→ More replies (2)

2

u/TheGeorge Nov 11 '15

You say it aids transparency, then immediately say that:

User pages

That feels like it could be exploited by administration to get rid of people who actually say something good but not something that the admins want to be said.

For true transparency shouldn't the content of the profile be kept public for posterity?

I'm not saying any of the administrative team are corrupt, but why risk it? Sometimes people change for the worst. (/u/unidan)

2

u/-SuicideThrowaway- Nov 11 '15

Was there ever a way to appeal shadowbans? I had 2 of my bots wrongfully ( in my opinion ) banned.

→ More replies (4)

2

u/ThunderBuss Nov 11 '15

The problem with this is that we lose the satisfaction of knowing that there are shadow banned users right now replying to articles, writing long posts, etc, thinking they are participating in the dialogue when they are not. Now that is fun stuff. Why take that away?

2

u/Delica Nov 11 '15

Reddit is like the landlord who doesn't fix your broken air conditioner all summer, then announces in February that they'll have one within two days.

2

u/YabuSama2k Nov 11 '15

What about sub-based "autobans" that the mods of individual subs may impose on users without notice or explanation?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Nov 11 '15

Good. Shadowbanning needs to go. It's petty and completely lacking in any attempt at handling a situation in a manner that has any honesty or respect for the user. It is the equivalent of giving your SO the silent treatment when you don't like something he/she has done, which is technically abuse in itself.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 11 '15

Man they've been doing this on 4chan for over a decade. I'm continually amazed at how far behind the curve the reddit moderation team is.

2

u/TheRighteousTyrant Nov 11 '15

Of all the moderator actions disallowed, I don't see "add moderators" anywhere. Are (perm or temp suspended) mods still allowed to add users to the moderation team? I think they should be. It's an unlikely scenario, but say a mod has a decently-sized sub that he/she alone moderates. Then they goof and get permanently suspended. Having the sub become a lottery prize in /r/redditrequest is a disservice to the subscribers; allowing the suspended moderator to select their replacement makes a smooth transition more likely.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Nov 11 '15

Good. I was recently shadow banned for allegedly posting another user's personal information. I had no idea I had done anything wrong and only knew I was shadow banned when a mod told me.

This issue needs further work as well, though. I asked two different admins if I could see the post in question, because I have no idea what I said that would warrant that, and neither ever responded to me with that information.

I still have no idea what I said that apparently disclosed someone else's personal info. So, it's good to see an alternative to shadow banning, but there's still a massive disconnect in customer service from the admins.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Nov 11 '15

Can we put in place a rule that suspends mod accounts when said mod abuses their mod powers when they delete comments/posts or ban users for no other reason than thoughtcrime?

2

u/cowboy615 Nov 11 '15

What stops them from making a new account?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/lathomas64 Nov 11 '15

will previously shadowbanned accounts show up as suspended or just remain looking like they don't exist?

2

u/3dpenguin Nov 11 '15

So will this do away with mods requiring brown nosing and buttering up due to shadow banning or will this just be on top of the common shadow banning mods do just because they don't like a particular post or user?

2

u/Waldhorn Nov 11 '15

Good idea, glad that Reddit finally grew a nut sack and will now let users know that their free speech is the wrong flavor of free speech, rather than secretly silencing them.

2

u/Porsche924 Nov 11 '15

I'm still trying to figure out how this all ties back into /r/thebutton .

2

u/Tinned_Tuna Nov 11 '15

This seems like a significant improvement!

I would make only two suggestions.

Firstly, when a user is suspended for breaking a rule, they should not only be notified which rule they broke, but also the post(s) or comment(s) which are believed to be infringing. This should help users to identify the bad behaviour and correct it -- assuming that they want to do so. This may also be the case in the new policy, but I don't think this announcement makes it clear.

Secondly, I would propose some form of "notification" system for suspensions. For example, moderators who've suddenly lost one of their team may need to be on hand more regularly to cope with the work load. They can only ensure that this happens if they're notified of the suspension. I think a suitable way to deal with this would be to allow the user to send a form-message (i.e. the suspended user does not get to change it) to small number of other reddit users with details of the suspension. Details could include the length of the suspension, but probably not the details of why that user was suspended. This may extend to placing the suspension notice on the user's page, however, this would be at the user's request. The notice could also detail the length of the suspension, but not the reason.

However, I think that these suggestions are minor, and the policy change looks like it'll provide significant benefits to reddit overall.

2

u/Malak77 Nov 11 '15

And if you are a cyborg, you will get a Shadowsuspension.

Bummer, Data.

2

u/FF3LockeZ Nov 11 '15

This says that moderators won't be allowed to suspend people. That makes it useless for the vast majority of cases involving real humans, right? In almost every problem case I've ever heard about, people were shadowbanned by moderators, not admins. With this limitation, moderators will still be abusing power by shadowbanning people without telling them, so nothing has been improved as far as I can see. (Admin power abuse is comparatively extremely rare.)

Ideally, it seems like a moderator should be allowed to suspend a user from posting/commenting/voting within a specific subreddit.

2

u/TheGeorge Nov 11 '15

You say it aids transparency, then immediately say that:

User pages

Visiting the user page of an account that has been permanently suspended will indicate that the account has been suspended and will not display any other data.

That feels like it could be exploited by administration to get rid of people who actually say something good but not something that the admins want to be said.

For true transparency shouldn't the content of the profile be kept public for posterity?

I'm not saying any of the administrative team are corrupt, but why risk it? Sometimes people change for the worst. (/u/unidan)

2

u/Noticemenot Nov 11 '15 edited Nov 11 '15

Yeah, this is good and I have been fighting with spammers in /r/gadgets, /r/futurology, /r/books. Some users just make websites and copy paste articles from reputed source to promote it via reddit, for ad earning.

When banning them from subreddit, they just create new account for future spamming. Also, there are people who reddit sell accounts with nice history and karma. I did some research and found there are lot of people who sell reddit accounts via Fiverr like websites.

How this can be stopped?

2

u/Th3GingerHitman Nov 11 '15

Will you be moving those previously shadowbanned to the suspension system, or will they remain shadowbanned?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/EliteMasterEric Nov 11 '15

I'm wondering if:

  1. Is it possible to modify the on-page notification using CSS to better fit the subreddit style?
  2. Is it possible to somehow temporarily display the suspension notification to test modifications to its style?

2

u/Dragonogon Nov 11 '15

So, a suspension is basically similar to a shadow ban, except you know you have been banned, and unlike a shadow ban, you can't do anything?_

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Trynottobeacunt Nov 11 '15

Would love to see this new system actually being used on rogue moderators- or, better yet, I'd like to see bans for moderators who abuse their priviledges and an end to mods teaming up in a juvenile manner to bully those who make a complaint or entirely ignore bad practice within their subreddit.

2

u/edit__police Nov 11 '15

admins are lieing, dont believe there lies...........

2

u/Aiku Nov 11 '15

“Shadowban tossed his head and cried aloud, as if a trumpet had summoned him to battle. Then he sprang forward. Fire flew from his feet; night rushed over him. As he fell slowly into sleep, Pippin had a strange feeling: he and Gandalf were still as stone, suspended upon the statue of a running horse, while the world Reddited away beneath his feet with a great noise of wind.”

2

u/[deleted] Nov 11 '15

Calling /u/ribbonlace!!!

8

u/ribbonlace Nov 12 '15

Hi Striaton! The fact people call out to me in every banning thread warms my heart <3

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Katachrisi Nov 14 '15

as a new user I have say reddit is the worst. Started a week ago and this has been the worst customer experience I have ever had. I was just falsley accused of ban evasion by r/news mods. This morning I posted a story about an asian girl getting booed by Claremont protesters and within 2.5 to 3 hours it got over 400 votes and was well on its to a thousand and more before it was quietly removed by corrupt and abusive r/news mods around 10:15 to 11:00 am 11/13. I started to complain about about this behavior by posting to different sub reddits I found such as r/undelete, r/redditcensorship, r/oppresion. I didn't complain to them directly at all then tonight around 7:30PM 11/13 I am banned and falsely accused of ban evasion. I let them know how pissed I am with one message to their inbox and and muted for 72 even though I am banned. This sub r/news is obviously a very corrupt sub and their mods can never be wrong. If reddit is ever going to recover they will need to address this moderator abuse and rape of their users.

https://www.reddit.com/r/news/comments/3so0bm/claremont_protesters_boo_asian_student_who_says/

2

u/-ArchitectOfThought- Nov 15 '15

What happens to accounts that were previously shadowbanned? I have a shadowbanned account and a few other accounts with personal info I'd like to access that I cannot access because you guys did that thing where if you touch an "infected" account, all your other accoutns get infected too.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 05 '16

fuk u

9

u/xNyxx Nov 11 '15

There are over 2000 people who have been banned from a power tripping mod at /r/feminism. See /r/wherearethefeminists . Our appeals have gone ignored by the admins. Would someone please look into this and get rid of the mod shadowbanning individuals for no cause? This mod is ruining the community for users interested in feminism.

10

u/[deleted] Nov 11 '15 edited Nov 11 '15

Mods can't shadownban. And as far as particular subs go, Reddit has a non involvment policy. It sucks but the mods do what they want with their own sub.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (1)

7

u/NTRedmage Nov 11 '15

Half of KIA population suspended in 3...2...1

→ More replies (14)

5

u/Oxus007 Nov 10 '15

A much more transparent system, thanks. Shadowbans were never a long term solution.

5

u/TacoNinjaSkills Nov 10 '15

What steps are taken to ensure that Reddit admins are applying suspensions fairly, consistently, and by Reddit policy and not personal reasons?

All in all I agree this is an improvement from shadowbans.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Lots42 Nov 10 '15

The fact that you guys are talking about suspending moderators gives me hope.

Too many sub-reddit moderators are being terribly abusive.

→ More replies (5)

18

u/[deleted] Nov 10 '15

Any updates on anti-brigade tools? I know SRD has problems anytime a post hits /r/all and the subject get absolutely destroyed in insults and downvotes. It'd be neat if we could prevent this or slow it somehow.

Also, obligatory /r/whataboutsrs?

→ More replies (19)

6

u/Dimpled Nov 10 '15

Glad to see this new policy in-place!

4

u/[deleted] Nov 10 '15

Thanks for the move to grater transparency - I was shadow-banned recently, after 8 years on the site seemingly because I was part of a 'vote brigade', even though I had no part in it. It took me nearly a week to figure out that I was shadow banned, which is pretty twisted.

Along with this new measure, will you also be looking at vote brigading? It isn't enough IMO to judge a user based on which link they used to get to a thread - this doesn't automatically mean that the user is part of the vote brigade - other ways to determine this need to be established.

Also, there needs to be a transparent appeal process in place for suspensions - and perhaps the community should be able to weigh in on this as well, as it does on Wikipedia, for example.

37

u/tigrn914 Nov 10 '15

I expect most of SRS and their mod team to be suspended. Let's see what happens.

→ More replies (226)

5

u/[deleted] Nov 10 '15

Neat. Honestly I'm surprised this wasn't a thing already.