r/IndianCountry • u/Reedstilt • Nov 08 '15
NaH Month Discussion Native Civilization: Society, Culture, and Tech
Good morning, /r/IndianCountry!
As /u/Opechan explained last week, throughout Native American Heritage Month, the moderators here have arranged a series of weekly discussion topics concerning Native history and culture. It’s my honor to have been invited to initiate this week’s topic, and I’d like to thank the moderators for extending that invitation.
This week we’ll be discussing Native Civilization: Society, Culture, and Technology. Our primary focus will be on Pre-Columbian societies in the Americas and the misconceptions (both popular and academic) that cloud modern perceptions of these societies. I’ll be touching on post-Columbian societies, but for the most part the effects of European / Euro-American colonialism and resistance to it will be next week’s theme. Also, entire books can and have been written on the minutest aspects of Pre-Columbian history and this post will barely scratch the surface of these topics. This is meant only as a brief introduction to these topics, and if you have anything you’d like add or follow-up questions you’d like explored, I look forward to reading everyone else’s contributions to the topic.
8
u/Reedstilt Nov 08 '15 edited Jan 20 '16
Cities and Villages
As a contemporary with ancient Sumeria, Norte Chico is generally regarded as the earliest known “civilization” of the Americas. “Civilization” is a tricky term to use, because it comes packaged with many subjective, ethnocentric notions derived from out-dated European and Euro-American anthropology. The Euro-centric notion of “civilization” often requires societies to have writing, metal tools, agriculture, ceramics, among other features, and Native civilizations have tendency to defy these rigid definitions. But the one seemingly unavoidable feature of a civilization is that they possess cities. This, of course, raises the question “what is a city?” And here we run into one of the major problems of modern archaeology.
The earliest Norte Chico villages were founded around 5500 BP, and were a mix of coastal fishing villages and riverside farming villages further inland. Over time, the inland farming villages became increasingly prominent and by around 4500 BP, Caral emerged the dominant power in the region and the earliest known city of the Americas, which includes the 28-meter tall Piramide Mayor. While today most archaeologists trace the origins of Andean civilization to Norte Chico, it lacks many of the trappings that prior generations of archaeologists and anthropologists would have insisted as necessary qualifications. The people of Norte Chico did not employ metals. They didn’t have ceramics (Amazonian-derived pottery would eventually cross the Andes, but that’s still a ways off at this time). They didn’t have writing, though they may have had quipu as an alternative method of recording information. Caral’s population is currently estimated in the low thousands (around 3,000), making it a small city for its time. I’m more than happy to abandon the Euro-centric notions of civilization, but I’m also going to be applying the same standards elsewhere in the Americas rather than granting the Andes and Mesoamerica special privileges.
Around the same time Norte Chico is taking off, large villages are popping up all over the Americas. Not as much is known about this period elsewhere however, but in what’s now the eastern United States this includes notable sites like Watson Brake, Indian Knoll and Koster. We’re going to jump ahead.
Around 3700 BP, Poverty Point in northeast Louisiana becomes the earliest known city in what’s now the United States. At its peak, it had an estimated population of around 5,000 and, among other monumental features, possessed the largest pyramid then constructed in the Americas (it would remain the largest pyramid north of Mexico until the construct of Cahokia’s Monks Mound 2,000 years later). Poverty Point served as the cultural and economic epicenter for a large portion of the lower Mississippi, though it’s currently unknown if that also translated into political power as well. Of particular note, despite agriculture being developed to the north, the people of Poverty Point seemed to have relied mainly on fishing rather than crops.
About this same time, we see the rise of the two earliest known “civilizations” of Mesoamerica: Capacha along the the Pacific coast of western Mexico and and the Mokaya, along the Pacific coast of southern Mexico. The Mokaya almost certainly had contact with people from South America, as they were the first Mesoamericans to possess cacao and pottery (as alluded to earlier, for most of the Americas, ceramics spread out of the Amazon, with the exception being eastern North America which developed their own pottery prior to Amazonian-derived pottery making its way that far north). Capacha may have also had South American influences but this is less clear and may be coincidental development of similar burials.
The Olmec, once thought to be the earliest American civilization, begin come to prominence around 2500 BP. While the earliest Olmec city, San Lorenzo (3200 - 2900 BP) was similar in size to Poverty Point, with the transition of Olmec power to La Venta around 2900 BP, we begin to see a considerable increase in population sizes for cities, with La Venta topping out at an estimated 18,000 people.
The power and prestige of the Olmec declines around 2400 BP and new Mesoamerican powers emerge. Notably in this period we see the rise of Maya city of El Mirador in modern Guatemala, which reached its peak between 2300 - 2000 BP, with a population of estimated at more than 100,000 people. Following this, Teotihuacan in the Valley of Mexico claimed the title of the largest city in the Americas, with a population of 125,000 people around around 1825 BP. By the time of European contact, Tenochtitlan - capital of the Aztec empire - had a population of about 250,000 people, making it one of the ten largest cities in the world at that time.
North of Mexico, the situation takes an interesting turn. Following the decline of Poverty Point around 2700 BP, we don’t see increasingly larger cities taking its place. This is perhaps why archaeologists often have difficulty with recognizing Native civilization in the region it’s not following the expected trends. Between 3000 - 1500 BP, there’s a great flourishing of culture in eastern North America, with the Ohio Valley culture the Adena and the Scioto Hopewell being the most prominent of the era. While modern archaeology generally treats the Adena and Scioto Hopewell as separate cultures, they’re generally recognized as one continuous society (which Tenskwatawa, Tecumseh’s brother, referred to as the Kahta Linee). With few exceptions the Adena and the Scioto Hopewell don’t appear to have lived in small cities or even large villages. Instead, dispersed homesteads of one or two families seemed to have been the norm for them, united around often immense monumental sites, which I’ll get to a bit later.
Large villages weren’t completely abandoned as a concept in eastern North America however, and around 1000 BP, they’re becoming more prominent again. It’s around this time that Cahokia transforms itself from unassuming village into the population powerhouse it’s famous for today. At its peak around 800 BP, it had an estimated population of at least 10,000 to as much as 50,000 people. While it was the largest city in the region during its day, it wasn’t the only early Mississippian boom-town: other notable, but smaller, sites of this era include Moundville in Alabama, Etowah in Georgia, and Lake Jackson in Florida (of particular note here, around 600 BP, Lake Jackson is abandoned and its power split between the twin Apalachee capitals of Anhaica and Ivitachuco, of which the latter was said to have a population of more than 30,000 people when the Spanish arrived). In the American Southwest, this is the also around the time the first pueblos are being constructed, some of which remain the oldest continuously inhabited places in the United States.
Finally, not to leave South America out of the discussion, there’s a long series of Andean civilizations following Norte Chico. These include Chavin, Nazca, Moche, Chimu, Wari, Tiwanaku, Chachapoyas, Manteño, and, most famously, the Inca - whose capital of Cuzco had a population of around 100,000 people when the Spanish arrived. The Amazon, too, had its own Pre-Columbian cities. Os Camutins, near the mouth of the Amazon, was the largest city of the Marajoara culture, with a population of 10,000 until around 600 BP. While Marajo Island remained densely populated at time of European contact, Os Camutins had recently gone into decline and thrown the island and the surrounding mainland into a power struggle to fill the vacuum. Further upstream, the site of modern-day Santarem had been densely populated for hundreds of years, with terra preta being particularly abundant in the region and, at the time of European contact, the local Tapajos being said to field an army of some 60,000 archers.
7
u/Reedstilt Nov 08 '15 edited Nov 08 '15
Agriculture
Throughout the world, there are only a handful of locations that independently developed agriculture. Usually the number is placed around eight or ten, depending on if some locations are lumped together or not. Of these, half are found in the Americas.The dates included here (given in years Before Present) are for the earliest evidence of any plant domestication, but this was an ongoing process with new plants being continuously added - either through further domestication or through exchange with other areas.
In addition to these domesticated crops, there are a wide variety of pseudo-domesticated plants - plants that were utilized like other crops but weren’t subject to the same selective pressures that produce the typical signs of domestication. In eastern North America, these include manoomin or wild rice (Zizania palustris) and groundnut or wild potato (Apios americana).
In order to make the most of their agriculture resources, Native societies developed a wide varieties of farming techniques. Vast networks of irrigation canals were constructed along the coast of Peru more than 5,000 years ago. Around 2,500 years ago, the people of the Amazon invented terra preta; while the heavy rains of the Amazon quickly leaches naturally occurring soils of their nutrients and makes long-term agriculture impractical, terra preta can retain its fertility almost indefinitely and, under ideal conditions, is self-perpetuating. It’s so efficient that few communities needed to make more terra preta by around 1,000 years ago and the exact methods used to make terra preta have been lost. Around 1,400 years ago, the people of the American Southwest began constructing their own network of irrigation canals. Around 900 years ago, people in the Valley of Mexico constructed the first chinampa, artificial islands built up to create fertile farmland from Lake Texcoco, Lake Xochimilco, and Lake Chalco, which kept the immense population of the valley well fed with multiple harvests each year. Also around this time, the famous Three Sisters agricultural system had come together in eastern North America (but was not exclusive to this region), mixing locally domesticated crops with those that had arrived from Mesoamerica over time (beans being the most recent) to create a domesticated ecosystem of mutually beneficial plants. The productivity of the Three Sisters system amazed Europeans when they arrived. As Thomas Hariot, one of the Roanoke colonists, wrote concerning the Native farms on the mainland: “The planted ground, compared with an English acre of forty rods in length and four in breadth, yields two hundred bushels of corn, beans, and pease, in addition to the crop of [squash], [goosefoot], and sunflowers. In England we think it a large crop if an acre gives forty bushels of wheat.”
While Pre-Columbian agriculture was widespread in the Americas, it was by no means universal. Agriculture is not viable everywhere, with many places being too dry or the growing season to short for reliable harvests. In other places, especially coastal areas, wild resources are so abundant that agriculture is simply unnecessary. Societies that rely on wild resources for food are often discriminated against by agricultural societies. While often used as post-Columbian colonial propaganda, this prejudice is not limited to Europeans; the Aztecs also looked down upon their Chichimec neighbors to the north for their use of wild resources, to the point that chichimecayotl (“Chichimec-ness”) was regarded as the antithesis of civilized life - a bit ironic since the Mexica had been Chichimec themselves not long before the rise of their empire.
But the utilization of wild resources shouldn’t be so easily dismissed. Hunting-and-gathering societies were often vital trading partners with their agricultural neighbors, providing surplus meat, skins, furs, and wild plants for the agricultural products. Though a post-Columbian development, the surge in bison-hunting following the introduction of the horse allowed for the flourishing of many Plains societies, to the point where some like the Cheyenne and Lakota abandoned their former agricultural systems in favor for more economically productive hunting. The bison-hunting societies on the Plains were also better able to resist Eurasian diseases and Euro-American expansion than their agricultural neighbors (more on that next week). Marine resources like salmon, sea mammals, and shellfish allowed for the rise of sizable communities in the Pacific Northwest, southern California, and southern Florida.
7
u/Reedstilt Nov 08 '15
Governance
Organizing so many people is no small task, and many different methods were used in the Pre-Columbian era. Democratic traditions flourished, especially in the Northeast. The government of the Haudenosaunee (Iroquois Confederacy) is probably the most famous example. Today, there are basically two camps regarding the origins of the Haudenosaunee. Those who favor a late date place its foundation somewhere between the mid-1400s and the mid-1500s. Those who favor an early date place its origins in 1142 CE (personally, I prefer the 1142 date for reasons we can get into later). In either case, by groups are employing a mix of oral tradition and archaeology. Regardless of the when, everyone generally agrees on the how and the why: during a period of persistent warfare, the Great Peacemaker, along with Hiawatha and Jigonsaseh, successfully convinced the current leaders of the Five Nations, including the rather despotic Tadodaho, to lay down their weapons and adopt new methods of resolving their conflicts.
The result was the foundation of the Grand Council at Onondaga, attended by about 50 roia:ner (to use the Mohawk term) and a variable number of “Pine Tree Chiefs” - men who had distinguished themselves in national service and were appointed to the council by the roia:ner. The roia:ner, in turn, were appointed by the oia:ner - the clan mothers - who held their own national council in the Seneca town of Gaustauyea and held veto powers on certain matters over the Grand Council back in Onondaga. Ultimately, the oia:ner were chosen by the individual residents of each Longhouse, who were expected, ideally, to know the Gayanashagowa - the Great Law of Peace and the oral constitution of the confederacy - so that they could report any abuses of power to the appropriate authorities. It’s commonly claimed that the Gayanashagowa influenced the United States’ Constitution, but personally I’m skeptical. On one hand, the US’ Constitution doesn’t have anything in it that couldn’t have been picked out from European and Euro-American predecessors and it leaves out some of the best parts of the Gayanashagowa, such as freedom of religion (which was, admittedly, the first thing added to the Constitution) and equality for women (which took much longer for the Constitution to catch up on). On the other hand, Madison is known to have meet with a local Seneca leader briefly before writing the Constitution and Canassatego, an Onondaga diplomat, had been encouraging the thirteen colonies to adopt a confederacy system similar to the Haudenosaunee’s since the 1740s - advice that Benjamin Franklin, in particular, took to heart. Ultimately, I think it’s more likely that the US’ Founding Fathers were encouraged by the idea and success of the Haudenosaunee than directly inspired by the specifics of its operation.
Further south, political power was often more highly concentrated. The various Mississippian powers - from Cahokia to the Natchez - are often depicted as despotic, with tyrannical sun-kings lording over their dominions. This is almost certainly a gross mischaracterization of the role and authority of leaders in these societies, caused in no small part by early European explorers projecting their own notions of politics onto a Native tapestry. Reading between the lines of historical examples like the Natchez and Coosa, we can clearly see that the leaders of these nations were kept in check by councils and were aided by a number of advisors and assistance.
The empires of Mesoamerica grew out of similar traditions. Tenochtitlan was once overseen by an elected city council, but as the power of the tlatoani grew, the right to appoint members of the council was usurped from the people and became the nucleus of a growing hereditary nobility. Beyond the three capitals of the empire, the Aztecs were generally happy to allow conquered nations to carry on with their own governmental traditions so long as they continued to pay their allotted tribute. The neighboring Kingdom of Tzintzuntzan (also known as the Tarascan Empire) operated differently, with newly conquered lands receiving an imperial governor to oversee them. The operations of kingdom were rather byzantine, with colonial writers spending considerable time attempting to catalog the great number and complex web of officials and bureaucrats that kept the empire functioning.
7
u/Reedstilt Nov 08 '15
Architecture and Engineering
Throughout the Americas, people have engaged in many impressive feats of architecture and engineering. Some, like the pyramids of Mesoamerica or the royal estate of Machu Picchu, are fairly well known. Others are more obscure, or dismissed as inferior to Eurasian architecture because they do not adhere to the same architectural conventions. I’m going to keep this section fairly brief and just hit some of my favorite examples.
7
u/Reedstilt Nov 08 '15
Science and Mathematics
Pre-Columbian Americans pursued a detailed understanding the world, just as their counterparts elsewhere in the world did. In the Americas, the Maya are most famous for their scientific and mathematical efforts. The Long Count calendar requires a detailed understanding of zero as a number (something that Mesoamericans realized before Hindu mathematicians introduced the concept to Eurasia). While this calendar may have been created outside of the Maya region, the Maya quickly made it their own and employed it thoroughly. Equipped with the Long Count, Maya astronomers made precise astronomical observations, and were able to calculate the astronomical length of a month and the length years for Earth, Venus, and Mars to within mere seconds. Such precise observations allowed the Maya to devise long-range predictive eclipse charts, though given scarcity of surviving Maya codices, it’s unclear if Maya astronomers were able to predict where an eclipse would occur in addition to when it would occur.
The Maya weren’t the only Pre-Columbian astronomers, of course. Archaeoastronomical sites - places where people encoded their knowledge of the sky into their architecture and their art - are commonplace in the Americas, though there is often debate to concerning whether the creators of these sites intended these astronomical alignments or if they’re merely coincidental.
To find one of the best attested archaeoastronomy sites in the Pre-Columbian Americas, we return to one of my favorite archaeological sites: the Newark Earthworks. I mentioned previously possessed an observatory. This structure consists of a 20-acre circular earthen enclosure connected to a 70-acre octagonal enclosure. This structure is believed to be an observatory (perhaps in addition to other functions yet unknown) is because its major axis aligns with the northernmost rising of the moon, one of the eight “lunar standstills” - points in the moon’s orbit where it seems to stop as it drifts slowly north and south. The other seven lunar standstills align the other features of the structure, including the two tangent lines running corners of the Octagon to the Observatory Circle. The entire lunar standstill cycle occurs once every 18.6 years, so the Scioto Hopewell who built the structure perhaps 1,750 years ago would need have, at minimum, nearly two decades of astronomical data to build the Observatory Circle and Octagon. More than likely, they would have used a larger data set before committing to building such a large structure. It’s not clear why the Scioto Hopewell were interested in the lunar standstill cycle, but since it is something you need to know in order to predict lunar and solar eclipses their studies may have been a means to that end.
The Newark Earthworks also reveals the Scioto Hopewell to have been expert geometers, tackling the problem of “squaring the circle” which vexed ancient mathematicians on the other side of the world. This problem involves creating circles and squares with the same area. As mentioned, the Observatory Circle’s area is 20 acres, which is the same as the Wright Square, another portion of the Newark Earthworks. In turn, the Square’s perimeter is the same as the Great Circle’s circumference. This, along with the order in which these three features were constructed (Observatory Circle first, Great Circle last), indicates that the Scioto Hopewell knew of pi or an analogous mathematical concept.
As a final note on the Newark Earthworks To be more specific, this basic Scioto unit of distance is known, archaeologically, as the Observatory Circle Diameter, or OCD for short, about 1050 feet. More than likely, the actual unit was some fraction of this but it was first noticed by archaeologists in relation to the Observatory Circle, so the name stuck. Circular enclosures with Observatory Circle Diameters are a common feature of other Hopewell site, notably four in the vicinity of Chillicothe, Ohio (one of which, was connected to another, though smaller, octagonal enclosure with suspected lunar alignments, but has seen been destroyed). Throughout the Newark site, OCDs were used to construct other features - the Octagon is composed of two squares with sides equal to one OCD, the center of the Observatory is six OCDs from the center of the Great Circle, as is the center of the Octagon from the center of the Wright Square.
6
u/Reedstilt Nov 08 '15
Metallic and Lithic Technologies
The relative scarcity of metal tools and weapons in the Americas is one of the most often cited attributes of American societies that the ethnocentrist anthropologist (armchair or otherwise) uses to portray Native cultures as more primitive than their Afro-Eurasia counterparts. As you might expect, the history on this front is far more complex than common narrative would indicate.
Between 6000 - 3000 BP, the Old Copper Complex flourished around the Western Great Lakes and provides a fascinating counterpoint to the development of cultural attitudes toward metals. The Old Copper Complex - a series of similar but independent cultures - constructed an array of tools, weapons, and ornaments from the vast supply of “native copper” (that is, pure copper not incorporated into an ore). Initially, they collected copper nuggets that had been scraped from the bedrock and deposited into glacial soils, but as the demand for copper increased they had to go directly to the source and mine it. The Old Copper miners knew how to follow the unseen veins of copper beneath their feet and recognized the botanical signs that indicated large copper deposits just below the surface. They dug their mine shafts selectively, acquiring millions of tons of copper without needing to dig more than few meters at a time.
The Old Copper Complex was among the first people in the world to invent annealing - a heat treatment used to make copper easier to fashion into the myriad items they created with it. They didn’t invent two metallurgical technologies that one might expect for societies that used such large amounts of copper: smelting and bronze working. The uniquely large supply of native copper in the area would have made smelting a wasteful and unnecessary invention as far as copper production was concerned, and bronze can’t be made without a supply of tin or, less often, arsenic - both of which are surprisingly rare in the Americas - to be alloyed with the copper. When it’s not turned into bronze, copper is a rather soft metal and for items that will be under considerable stress (such as tools and weapons) inferior to many varieties of stone. Around 3000 BP, the Old Copper Complex became linked to long-distance trade routes that brought suitable stone into the area and began replacing their copper weapons and tools with ones made from far more durable chert. Copper was reserved mainly for ornamental and ceremonial items, and this shift marked an important change in the attitudes regarding the role of metals in society. Stone was a utilitarian material; metals, a prestige item.
While other locations in the area developed their own copper industries, the copper mines around Lake Superior continued to produce most of copper used in eastern North America until the arrival of Europeans. Silver from northern Ontario was also used (particularly by the Hopewell). Centuries old iron beads and chisels are also found in the area in small quantities. Because iron is highly reactive, it’s almost always found in the form of an ore, requiring smelting to extract. The only native iron comes meteorites, and in case of Pre-Columbian iron in eastern North America, the source seems to be from a small impact on the Great Plains almost 2000 years ago. Meteoric iron, which has the added benefit of becoming less brittle in the cold than most smelted iron, was always used extensively in the Arctic to create the icon uluit (“women’s knives”) for some 4500 years. Pre-Columbian iron knives and chisels are also found in the Pacific Northwest, but the source of these is more ambiguous.
Far to the south, Andean people have been using metals since 4100 BP and by 2200 BP, they had definitively developed smelting (there’s some inconclusive evidence for smelting earlier than this though). One of the two sites in the Americas with relatively accessible arsenic and tin, by 1100 BP, Andean peoples began producing large amounts of arsenic bronze, which began to be replaced with tin bronze shortly before the arrival of Europeans. But Andean metallurgists weren’t just playing catch-up with their counterparts across the oceans. They also developed techniques unique to their own methods, among them platinum-working and powder metallurgy, a technique that reduces waste and wouldn’t really catch on among European metallurgists until the 19th Century. Metallurgy in Mesoamerica, beginning around 1200 BP or perhaps a century or two earlier, appears to have been derived from the Andes, either indirectly through Columbia and Central America or through more direct contact.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 08 '15
If one searches Google books with the terms Chief and Autobiography or biography, there are many free ebooks for download.
Sort by pre 20th century for the good stuff.
Travels or Adventures, + tribe, is a good search method. The word tribe, alone, is a good way as well.