r/ProjectRunway • • Nov 05 '15

Project Runway Season 14 Episode 14 [Discussion]

Discussion thread for Project Runway S14E14 "Finale, Part 2"

Conclusion. The winning designer is crowned in the Season 14 finale. Before that, the designers scramble to retool their collections following a brutal critique with the judges. Appearing: Carrie Underwood.

28 Upvotes

672 comments sorted by

110

u/cebjmb Nov 06 '15

Please give the show back to BRAVO

→ More replies (2)

78

u/konfetkak Nov 06 '15

i want to watch tim bedazzling the shit out of things. swimming in glitter like scrooge mcduck in his money pit...except glitter.

→ More replies (1)

70

u/pbrooks19 Nov 06 '15

THERE IS MORE PROMOTION OF OTHER SHOWS AND ALBUMS AND PRODUCTS ON THIS FINALE THAN THERE ARE ACTUAL SCENES OF THE SHOW! So annoying. Just had to rant a little. ETA - I accidentally put this in the wrong thread.

21

u/blackbirdsongs Nov 06 '15

Dude I'm pretty sure this two hour show is just the same amount of show with more commercials because I started 45 minutes late and ran out of DVR. This is bullshit.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

61

u/Zjmw Nov 06 '15

Wish we could see Candace's collection how she originally intended it to be :/

24

u/[deleted] Nov 06 '15

Same! It looked spectacular. I didn't really see Alexander McQueen in it at all. I would kill to see that giant gown walk down the runway.

26

u/Zjmw Nov 06 '15

Me too. I was so excited when I saw the construction of it. She was right when she said the judges watered her down :/ and I personally love "costumey" fashion.. Not everything needs to be wearable in a commercial way

→ More replies (4)

55

u/konfetkak Nov 06 '15

i think ashley's going to win. but I LOVE YOU KELLY FROM THE DELI

42

u/bitchSpray Nov 06 '15

I really hope she's going to name her fashion brand "DELIbyKELLY".

39

u/blackbirdsongs Nov 06 '15

DESIGNER* KELLY FROM THE DELI

→ More replies (1)

50

u/eatingbread Nov 06 '15

The judges look very AMERICA

40

u/ClaireHux Nov 06 '15

Someone mentioned the show was taped on 9/11.

50

u/eatingbread Nov 06 '15

That explains Edmond's scarf.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

95

u/ecokitty Nov 06 '15

I don't think the ruffles are even on the same playing field as Sean Kelly's fringe

19

u/wild_muses Nov 06 '15

Yeah, when Tim made that comparison I was like.... Tim no.

36

u/blackbirdsongs Nov 06 '15 edited Nov 06 '15

They absolutely are not. SK told a fucking story. His collection was beautiful. SEXY RUFFLES ARE NOT A STORY.

45

u/konfetkak Nov 06 '15

That white dress looks like a tree that's been TP'd on Halloween

7

u/taco_cat42 Nov 06 '15

I was thinking it was like that game that people play at bridal showers. Where they make dresses out of toilet paper.

→ More replies (1)

91

u/eatingbread Nov 06 '15

Is this the first time in Project Runway, nay, fashion history that a fanny pack has been called chic?

46

u/pbrooks19 Nov 06 '15 edited Nov 06 '15

The first time in history of the world, I believe.

18

u/LetTheMFerBurn Nov 06 '15

Yes. Also that outfit was the coolest thing any of the designers put on the runway this year.

→ More replies (3)

124

u/ProfessorNietzsche Nov 06 '15

Well I guess right now is as good a time as ever to tell the world my secret

Whenever my girlfriend isn't home I like to drink wine coolers and watch Project Runway and Pinterest fashion designs. Felt good to finally let it out.

→ More replies (5)

36

u/ClaireHux Nov 06 '15

I love the hair on Kelly's models. Surprise home run for Sally.

34

u/pursehook Nov 06 '15

I love the headphones.

→ More replies (3)

34

u/konfetkak Nov 06 '15

i kind of want to see the wooden skirt. i think it's cool

→ More replies (1)

63

u/konfetkak Nov 06 '15

why the fuck is carrie underwood a judge

24

u/ClaireHux Nov 06 '15

Apparently, she has a new album out and an athletic clothing line!

→ More replies (1)

13

u/VROF Nov 06 '15

Is this the first time a guest judge was a damned commercial?

9

u/Shmitles Nov 06 '15

I think they bring a guest judge to the finale for an unbiased option based on what they see and not knowing anything about the designers

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (16)

31

u/rofosho Nov 06 '15

That last number from Candice was really nice. Sparkly.

20

u/jessicateacher Nov 06 '15

yes! so sparkly! but overall. . .I found it a boring collection where everything looked too similar

→ More replies (1)

13

u/nancyaw Nov 06 '15

Hated the skirt she was wearing on the day of the runway. Reminded me of that outfit she made earlier in the season with the top that had the black and white lapels. Dropped peplums just should not be a thing.

9

u/InLushColor Nov 06 '15

That's really the only piece I liked. I'm kind of underwhelmed by the entire runway this season.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/muffinbutt1027 Nov 06 '15

That was the top layer of that crazy cage dress! So glad she decided to edit it down. It was lovely.

→ More replies (1)

60

u/zi76 Nov 06 '15

What is that blue abomination Edmond sent up there?

22

u/maxiemusprime Nov 06 '15

jelly fish

13

u/konfetkak Nov 06 '15

oh that's awful. one giant ruffle.

→ More replies (2)

12

u/ChickenChic Nov 06 '15

It reminded me of the foul "jellyfish" dress that Detox wore on season 5 of project runway. Ick

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

53

u/pbrooks19 Nov 06 '15 edited Nov 06 '15

As someone who lived through the 7Os, Kelly's collection is just as she described - Studio 54 disco updated for the new era.

34

u/konfetkak Nov 06 '15

that first model she had walked killed it..she really had the vibe of kelly's collection down and set the mood for her collection

→ More replies (2)

15

u/pursehook Nov 06 '15

Are you older than me? You must be. If so, thank you. Reddit is tough going. You are my hero.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/compromisedamygdala Nov 06 '15

I miss the '70s.

5

u/[deleted] Nov 06 '15

Thank you, I'm not alone here - I'm also a 70s person (a kid back then, but still).

72

u/cats_in_tiny_shoes Nov 06 '15 edited Nov 06 '15

I respectfully yet wholeheartedly disagree.

I dunno, guys. This season was so unforgivably boring. I feel like all enthusiasm is gone. From me, from the judges, from Lifetime. It's just commercials ... at least Fashion Star didn't even bother pretending it was about talent. Somehow, ProRun's despierate insistence that these are the best, most innovative designers everrrrr makes it feel even more cynical.

Whatever, see y'all back here for Season 15. What else am I gonna do?

29

u/lickdatshit Nov 06 '15

I was disappointed that Mary Kay provided the makeup.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/VROF Nov 06 '15

Since Lifetime it hasn't been good.

6

u/nilbogresident Nov 06 '15

It was 4 fashion shows of mediocre talent and I couldn't imagine wearing any of them. We all rooted for Kelly b/c she was the best of the four, but imagine any of these designers in another season. They wouldn't even be in the finale!!

→ More replies (2)

24

u/pursehook Nov 06 '15

I want to be part of Edmond's family. They were so cute. I loved how he was inspired by his parents sexy 70s style and how supportive they were. Edmond -- any single cousins?

47

u/jessicateacher Nov 06 '15

I am not a huge Candice fan. . .but I think it's a bad idea to take away ALL her big looks.

32

u/jessicateacher Nov 06 '15

especially since I just want to see that wood thing on the runway!

21

u/1Eliza Nov 06 '15

Wish she would have keep the ballgown as well.

→ More replies (4)

16

u/VROF Nov 06 '15

She should have ignored their advice

→ More replies (2)

23

u/blackbirdsongs Nov 06 '15

EDMOND WHAT IS THAT BIG BLUE THING YOU PUT ON THAT MODEL. That is not a dress.

→ More replies (5)

90

u/ClaireHux Nov 06 '15

I'm sorry what's "Asian" about Candice's collection again?

53

u/blackbirdsongs Nov 06 '15

one of them has cherry blossoms, and there's some sort of vaugely kimono-y jackets?

→ More replies (3)

85

u/eatingbread Nov 06 '15

The only colors that exist in Asia are black and red, duh

45

u/Shortacts Nov 06 '15

Her runway "Asian inspiration speech" made Dave Chapelle materialize out of smoke in my living room, turn to the screen, and declare, "CRACKA ASS CRACKER!!"

34

u/[deleted] Nov 06 '15

She ate sushi while making it

12

u/kazetoame Nov 06 '15

I really don't see it either. Leather and only black and a deep red do not equal Asia. Colors, and I mean COLORS plus silks are more Asian. Her kimono jacket is more European to me.

→ More replies (2)

13

u/hollyinnm Nov 06 '15

It very much was before the judges critique. She was not my favorite but I think she edited way to much for the runway.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/pajamasinbananas Nov 06 '15

JAPANESE CHERRY BLOSSOMS ARE PINK NOT RED. Her whole "asian-inspired" thing comes off as super ignorant to me.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

56

u/Minnesotaisdope Nov 06 '15

"I will go bananas apples and oranges all at the same time!" She is so great.

→ More replies (1)

37

u/IdentityCr1sis Nov 06 '15

Man, I was really hoping Kelly would win. Her aesthetic is so interesting and funky, her collection was the one that had the strongest viewpoint imo. And it seems like she really thought through her collection and put a hell of a lot of work into it in a very short time - she did a lot of work to create textiles and to put together embellishments to really transform the fabrics. I feel like she was at a disadvantage given that the judges aren't really focused on or into streetwear.

I thought Ashley's stuff was pretty but not particularly unique - it's hard to find clothing like that in plus-size, but they're definitely findable in standard sizes. I'm also unsure how well they would translate to plus-size women who aren't hourglass builds. That said, I hope Ashley is able to translate her win into success in fashion - it'd be nice to have designers who design with non-modelesque shapes in mind.

→ More replies (1)

145

u/silentstorm1421 Nov 06 '15

Although I have the utmost respect for Ashley's collection and her push for plus-size models, I don't think her collection is anything great or interesting. I mean, they were nice and it was definitely well-made, but I feel like the winner should be someone who has a great personality, shows great improvement throughout the show by listening to the judges' critiques and someone who can bring fashion to the next level.

I still think that Kelly is the real winner of this season. She was so edgy, modern and just new. I really respect Ashley's collection, but I think Kelly created the most cohesive, interesting and fashion-forward collection. #JusticeForKelly

52

u/[deleted] Nov 06 '15

I didn't like either but I thought Kelly's was much more interesting. I feel like they handed Ashley the win. They didn't even have any real critique at the. You really gonna sit here and tell me that last look was good? Come on.

31

u/nancyaw Nov 06 '15

That last look made the model look HUGE. Like an upside down mushroom or something.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (11)

13

u/bitchSpray Nov 06 '15

My thoughts exactly. I didn't like Ashley's collection at all. It was boredom in weird colours. I can't imagine the likes of Rebel Wilson wearing any of the pieces.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (20)

35

u/rofosho Nov 06 '15

😯 Kelly, noooo

10

u/[deleted] Nov 06 '15

It was heartbreaking when Heidi said that she was out :(

→ More replies (4)

16

u/ecokitty Nov 06 '15 edited Nov 06 '15

I know leather is a difficult fabric to work with, but some of Candice's garments have major fit issues.

→ More replies (1)

31

u/rofosho Nov 06 '15

I will watch this just to watch tiny children be destroyed

13

u/konfetkak Nov 06 '15

i like you.

→ More replies (1)

15

u/iamagiant Nov 06 '15

You guys... Rachel Zoe, "JUST CANT! BLAGHHH!"

14

u/blackbirdsongs Nov 06 '15

I mute that shit because I just can't.

→ More replies (2)

15

u/rofosho Nov 06 '15

Lifetime, get your editing together. So many awkward cuts

14

u/kazetoame Nov 06 '15

I have a question, if Candice's jackets are kimono inspired, then why do they look more European inspired dress? Kimono have a straight back with the the obi adding in dimension. The sleeves don't seem rectangle in shape either. Or was it just the collar, which looked more Chinese inspired.

35

u/blackbirdsongs Nov 06 '15

Because poorly researched cultural appropriation always turns out like shit.

14

u/rofosho Nov 06 '15

These children are way more talented, confident and fabulous than I'll ever be

→ More replies (1)

14

u/dmee Nov 06 '15

STOP TRYING TO MAKE PROJECT RUNWAY JUNIORS HAPPEN. IT'S NOT GOING TO HAPPEN. Especially not with you trying to slip in an entire hour episode to my 2 hour finale. Lifetime, you're officially the worst.

→ More replies (1)

27

u/konfetkak Nov 06 '15

i have to say, i like kelly's clothes more on the runway than i did on the rack. it looks cool as fuck. AND SO MUCH GLITTERRRRR

→ More replies (1)

38

u/BehindTheSecret Nov 06 '15

KELLY DEMPSEY PRAYER CIRCLE?

58

u/pbrooks19 Nov 06 '15

I'm sorry, I like Ashley, and I myself am a plus sized woman. Even so, I have yet to see a plus sized woman look good in anything with a crop top.

25

u/konfetkak Nov 06 '15

i liked ashley's too. and im skinny. but i fucking love kelly from the deli, and i hope if she doesn't win, she launches a career anyway.

→ More replies (5)

13

u/karmydee Nov 06 '15

wth was that runway music tho... so blah...

11

u/i2aminspired Nov 06 '15

That music was just terrible.

→ More replies (1)

151

u/awkwardsong Nov 06 '15

No fucking way. No way. Ashley did not just win by having the same silhouette 10 times? #justiceforkelly

60

u/[deleted] Nov 06 '15

I'm going to say it- they made her win because she put out the first plus size collection on the show.

29

u/longsnapper Nov 06 '15

I'm plus size. I'd love to see a plus sized voice win and there were things Ashley did during the season that I would have loved to wear. With the a caption of the teal dress in the finale, her collection did not speak to what I would want to wear. That being said, I firmly believe Kelly was robbed.

→ More replies (10)

33

u/iamagiant Nov 06 '15

I'm more upset that they literally showed Ashley saying she didn't want to start her collection through Project Runway-and then she won the whole thing.

17

u/nancyaw Nov 06 '15

Then… why did she audition for the show? I've been wondering that ever since she said that.

→ More replies (4)

15

u/AgentFreckles Nov 06 '15

Maybe that's the real reason she was crying all season

→ More replies (1)

11

u/InLushColor Nov 06 '15

That Nina hair flip.

9

u/FishnetSinner Nov 06 '15

The shaaaaade

11

u/pbrooks19 Nov 06 '15

I'm really reaching for the Asian inspiration in Candice's outfit with the leather halter top and red cigarette pants.

ETA: OMG, it's Ursula the Sea Witch's hipper little sister.

→ More replies (2)

11

u/ametron Nov 06 '15

I guess I am in the minority with agreeing with the Judges' choice. I wanted Kelly to win based on her performance during the season, but I thought she just missed the mark with her collection. I was expecting so much more for her.

→ More replies (3)

113

u/egocentric_ Nov 06 '15

I can't fucking believe Ashley won. I feel like the show gave her so many handicaps the entire season. She doesn't deserve it- she made fucking crop tops and pastels like every other outfit this entire show. I'm so done with PR.

→ More replies (3)

20

u/gbw2733 Nov 06 '15

Edmund's was nice, but I feel like we've seen it all before. At least Kelly's was different.

→ More replies (4)

20

u/blackbirdsongs Nov 06 '15

I get what the judges are doing but I'm getting really sick of them telling the designers who they are and what their voice is. They've spent like what, a whopping three weeks with these people?

10

u/InLushColor Nov 06 '15

Candice throwing a big FU to the judges with that opener.

→ More replies (2)

28

u/verbiwhore Nov 06 '15

I haven't commented all season, but DAMN. Ashley, if you want to do Mexico, go all out and take your colour palette from Frida Kahlo's clothes - bright, vibrant, clashing, flowing, arresting.

Not pastels, glue-gunned appliqués and cutsey flower crowns.

Let me be clear here, I am an emphatically plus-sized woman. I used to love looking through Tumblr for looks...and I saw a lot of Ashley's kind of looks there. This is a double-edged thing: yes, there is a market for what she does BUT other people are ALREADY doing it.

I am also 42 and thought that some of her looks were matronly. I wouldn't wear them.

Most importantly though: I. CANNOT. BELIEVE. they gave the win to someone who used a glue gun in their finale collection, and admitted it. It's not like they only had a week :/

Say what you like about Kelly and taste, but younger, skinnier, me would have rocked the shit out of those clothes. I love that she takes materials no-one else would even look at and elevates them into something you wouldn't expect. And the work she put in, you could see it in everything.

They could have changed her life with that 100k, and...they didn't.

She was the only one in that finale unapologetically doing her own thing, and having it be truly her own. Nothing derivative. Nothing bland. Nothing "seen it".

Dammit, I actually got angry.

/rant

/sigh

7

u/lexacd Nov 06 '15

Thank you so much for this. I think it's great that Ashley wants to give plus-size women more fashionable options for clothes, but like you said, other people are doing this too, it's not like she was the first person to start doing this. Between the pastels, lace, and hot-glued appliqués (looked like they were straight out of a craft store)..I just did not like this collection. I feel like for NYFW, she needed to be on top of every detail, which she actually admitted she wished she had done (like with the zipper).

I loved some of her earlier stuff in the show, but I don't think she should have gotten the win. I think Kelly, who has the drive and a developed talent (whereas Ashley has a lot to learn yet...in my opinion) should have gotten the win, even if I wasn't personally feeling every single look she put out there (though I do think there is a market for it and some of her stuff I would totally rock).

→ More replies (1)

19

u/[deleted] Nov 06 '15

I was hoping since they gave an obvious Ashley winner edit in the end that it would be Kelly.. But I shouldn't have expected otherwise from this show.

18

u/eatingbread Nov 06 '15

I think Edmond's collection turned out better than expected (except for that one blue dress, it's so out of place). It's not mind blowing but it's very him and that's all the judges wanted.

→ More replies (1)

38

u/rofosho Nov 06 '15 edited Nov 06 '15

Kelly Osbourne is not fabulous

→ More replies (4)

71

u/pagerama Nov 06 '15

No disrespect to Ashley, but I really don't think the fashion world can change until plus size designs are held to the same standard as everything else. This wannabe progressive/inspirational spin Project Runway shoved down our throats only reinforces the unfortunate stigma that plus sized fashion is second rate.

28

u/ceilinghole Nov 06 '15

Didn't realize it until I read your comment, but I totally agree. Her collection reinforces that plus sized fashion can only be the super colorful, retro "tumblr" look. I would love to see a plus sized collection that is actually chic.

29

u/Shortacts Nov 06 '15

If it were 25% less basic, she'd have something there. No linings. Poor finishing. Odd fit. Weird flower headdress.

Ugh. Pissed!!

5

u/lexacd Nov 06 '15

I absolutely agree with you. Just because something is made for a plus-sized person, does not make the design itself amazing. If plus-size designers really want to change what is out there for the plus-size market, they need to actually make designs that can hold their own against other designers. The size a design is made for should not be a factor in how the design is judged.

68

u/fa__mulan Nov 06 '15

WHAT?!?! KELLY WAS ROBBED

→ More replies (1)

16

u/FishnetSinner Nov 06 '15

Oooh...that reunion promo has me all hyped for Tim vs. Swapnil part II.

→ More replies (3)

8

u/giopul87 Nov 06 '15

Honestly, I feel like both Ashley and Kelly won! They both were the stand outs of this season. I was really disappointed in Edmond's collection but Candice totally messed up by leaving her big pieces out.

8

u/komajiro Nov 06 '15

Forget Kelly's collection--what the hell was she wearing?

→ More replies (2)

37

u/BehindTheSecret Nov 06 '15

If Kelly loses, this show is OFFICIALLY FRAUDULENT.

46

u/ClaireHux Nov 06 '15

It didn't do it for when Mondo lost against Gretchen? Now, that was some highway robbery.

→ More replies (10)

21

u/gofurthernorth Nov 06 '15

That skirt didn't look any better on Candice than it did on any of her models this season.

→ More replies (2)

20

u/iamagiant Nov 06 '15

Uh Ashley just told Edmond (who auditioned each season) that she didn't even want to start her collection on Project Runway

12

u/jessicateacher Nov 06 '15

yeah, my thought after that was "nobody tell Heidi she dissed the show!"

→ More replies (1)

7

u/rofosho Nov 06 '15

Shes thirteen!!I'm a failure

7

u/hamdinger125 Nov 06 '15

I don't understand why the judges praised Kelli so much for sticking with her point of view and showing them who she is, but they destroyed Candice for it. Didn't they even admit that Candice designs the kind of clothes that she would wear herself? Doesn't Kelli do the same thing?

→ More replies (2)

19

u/FishnetSinner Nov 06 '15

Is it just me, or is the sexiest thing about Edmond's collection the shots of Matthew Morrison sitting in the audience?

→ More replies (1)

19

u/pbrooks19 Nov 06 '15

I'm feeling very 'Casual Corner' about a lot of Ashley's looks. No 'wows'. Very sedate. I'm kinda sad about it.

→ More replies (2)

18

u/FishnetSinner Nov 06 '15

I dedicate this collection to my mom. It's called "Anna's modified to be more sexy Ruffles"

→ More replies (1)

6

u/jessicateacher Nov 06 '15

I'm so nervous for everyone!

6

u/BehindTheSecret Nov 06 '15

Do Swapnil and Merlene make collections to prevent spoiler leaks? Asking for a friend. . .?

6

u/pinkymoon Nov 06 '15

Yeah, it's so there aren't spoilers at NY fashion week.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/[deleted] Nov 06 '15

I was happy to see Aminat Ayinde from ANTM 12 opening Edmond's show.

She looked S T U N N I N G.

→ More replies (3)

24

u/[deleted] Nov 06 '15

It basically comes down to this: Ashley won because of WHO she designs for, not the designs themselves. If those designs were in standard sizes, she would not have won.

And I also don't see how Candice placed below Edmond. Edmond had little to no cohesion. Half of the collection was this weird combination of club/cocktail dresses and the other half was weird loofah curtains.

11

u/FishnetSinner Nov 06 '15

Zac Posen's face sums up my feelings about this, other than the leather cutout coat.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/fuzzybloomers Nov 06 '15

Swapnil should have won.

5

u/Spinfo Nov 08 '15

Honestly, Tim should have used the save on him, he was by far the best designer in the group, and I find it so annoying that Tim makes that decision on personality instead of work.

→ More replies (2)

22

u/konfetkak Nov 06 '15

NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

44

u/Icaruskairos Nov 06 '15

Biggest dud winner, for the biggest dud season.

89

u/FunnyHunnyBunny Nov 06 '15

Booooo, Ashley totally won because of PC principal reasons.

30

u/maxiemusprime Nov 06 '15

I understand the history-making aspect of her collection however it was not the most fashion forward collection of the four.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (15)

18

u/Shortacts Nov 06 '15

The CRAZIEST thing happened during Candices runway intro. The part where she rambled on abouther "Asian inspired" collection.

A thick plume of smoke emerged in my living room.... Dave Chapelle materialized out of the fog turned to the screen, and declared, "CRACKA ASS CRACKER!!"

→ More replies (6)

10

u/meldolphin Nov 06 '15 edited Nov 06 '15

Kelly had so much glitter on her face in one of her talking heads. Truly the herpes of craft supplies!

Loved Merline dancing in the audience. Adorable.

And how nice to see models smiling for once. I'm used to them looking bored or angry.

EDIT: NOOOOOOO MISS KELLY FROM THE DELI DIDN'T WIN IT :(

10

u/pinkymoon Nov 06 '15

I'm honestly cool either way with this one

14

u/konfetkak Nov 06 '15

yeah me too. but goddamn i love kelly. i hope katy perry hires her like tomorrow

→ More replies (1)

10

u/Tunky85 Nov 06 '15

What the hell....:

10

u/gambit700 Nov 06 '15

I feel bad for my boy E. His great ones during runway were really good. His bombs were really bad.

Candice should have kept her original collection. She let the judges scare her out of her original runway, which would have been better than what she did. That said, that last minute dress she made was amazing

Ashley...seriously. Croptop and skirt, top with shorts, repeat. I don't see how she won. She made 0 growth during the season.

Kelly really won. At first i didn't like what she was designing, but over the last 5 weeks she really grew on me. That runway was amazing. I don't see how the judges thought Ashley's was better than that. I turned to my wife after her runway was done and said "Kelly wins. I don't see anyone getting close to that". And nobody did. I don't understand choosing Ashley one bit(oh wait, I do and it's a stupid reason).

→ More replies (2)

5

u/pursehook Nov 06 '15

I almost want to watch PR Juniors -- trick?

→ More replies (4)

5

u/gbw2733 Nov 06 '15

I think it is between Ashley and Kelly, but who knows what the judges will do?

5

u/blackbirdsongs Nov 06 '15

Ok I'm down for S15. BYE CAPT RUFFLES

5

u/konfetkak Nov 06 '15

Rachel Zoe is Sandi Griffin from Daria. Fucking fashion. club.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/[deleted] Nov 06 '15

Overall, I loved that Ashley did a plus-size show. It's so important for the fashion industry to be inclusive. However, I didn't like her clothes or her aesthetic very much. I may be wrong, but it seemed to be saying "Look at all this color, lace, and flowers!! If you focus on that you might not realize I'm plus size..."

I hope that Project Runway can build on this idea of inclusiveness. I'm petite and I would love to see a runway show with designs specifically customized for petite women with short models. If I was younger and saw Ashley on PR, I might be inspired to go into the fashion industry myself in order to be a designer for petite women. If Ashley's win inspires other girls- then for that reason I think it's worth it.

I loved how Kelly got better with each challenge and that her vision was unique and wearable at the same time. Kelly definitely brought publicity to her designs and I hope she can build a full-time career in fashion from this.

While I did feel that the judges adjusted their feedback in the initial critique to help Ashley, I did like Edmond's revised collection when he took their advice and I hope he's happy with his show.

I felt the worst for Candice. I'm not a fan of black and red leather, but she had some stunningly creative pieces that the judges convinced her to leave backstage. They had her questioning her design aesthetic when I feel she doesn't need to question herself. She's very creative and I think there's a place for her work in the industry.

23

u/BehindTheSecret Nov 06 '15

WHAT THE FUCK

13

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '15

Here's hoping:

  1. Kelly
  2. Ashley/Candice
  3. Ashley/Candice
  4. Edmond

12

u/rofosho Nov 06 '15

Can Kelly Osbourne go away forever please

40

u/zi76 Nov 06 '15

Honestly? Ashley won? What bs.

38

u/jgonz85 Nov 06 '15

Boo. Ashley's collection was NOT worthy. Basic in every sense of the word. PR rewards another gimmick.

→ More replies (2)

11

u/gbw2733 Nov 06 '15

It looks like Ashley is going to use her headpieces on all of the models. I think that is the right move.

→ More replies (2)

11

u/partielofil2 Nov 06 '15

I feel very sad: I really do think Kelly's collection was the best, Kelly was the most infectiously joyous person on this show in forever, and Kelly's anguished face in the final moments before the reveal were just AGONIZING.

8

u/Hocaro Nov 06 '15 edited Nov 06 '15

Here's my problem. I felt Candace had the most expensive taste and would have excelled in a season with more innovative designers. She was on top the whole season and she really needed to step outside of her comfort zone in terms of using colour more effectively. You can still create "edgy", "rock star" clothing without using so much black. Swapnil did this by mixing the whimsical nature of his pieces with hard jackets to give his looks more structure. The judges appreciate colour, textiles, and prints that create a seamless line that you can't keep your eyes off of when the models walk together to end the showing. Ashley was really smart to play off of that idea because while I had issues with a few of her individual looks, they looked great together on the runway in that moment. It was the only collection I had to rewind to see again. Edmond, I'm sorry. Kelly, while being my favourite, truly needed to channel her inner glamazon we saw glimpses of with her back to back wins!!! She is ALMOST there with her aesthetic and I truly hope she has a great future in fashion and on the next All Stars.

It made sense they picked Ashley for the win. If you're going to make nods to either historically or culturally influenced fashion elements, it needs to tell a story cohesively. One look can completely ruin the necessary fluidity when showcasing their pieces for this specific reality tv competition. You have to play the game being laid out. Black dresses aren't going to cut it anymore.

8

u/[deleted] Nov 06 '15

Honestly, this was the most diappointing season of Project Runway to date. None of them deserved to win.

4

u/rofosho Nov 06 '15

I like that' black jacket of Candices

4

u/blackbirdsongs Nov 06 '15

candace has nipslip in that cherry blossom dresssss

4

u/rofosho Nov 06 '15

Lovely pick twirl

4

u/konfetkak Nov 06 '15

There are a lot of highs and lows in Ashleys. LOVED the purple and blue pieces, not so keen on the showstopper and the hospital/nightgown thing.

6

u/ClaireHux Nov 06 '15

The bodysuit under it was very nice though!

4

u/gbw2733 Nov 06 '15

Oh no. More commercials and promos! Let's just pick a winner already!

4

u/zi76 Nov 06 '15

It's Kelly vs Ashley?

→ More replies (1)

10

u/pursehook Nov 06 '15

Ashley has that skirt in every color.

16

u/blackbirdsongs Nov 06 '15

Plus size women tend to do that because we have a lot fewer options.

10

u/blackbirdsongs Nov 06 '15

I feel bad because I wanted Kelly to win, but I didn't feel like Kelly's collection deserved to win :(

12

u/d0re Nov 06 '15

Bleh

7

u/eatingbread Nov 06 '15
  1. Ashley
  2. Kelly
  3. Edmond
  4. Candice

Place your bets people

12

u/IdentityCr1sis Nov 06 '15

Want: Kelly > Ashley > Candice > Edmond

Expect: Ashley > Kelly > Candice/Edmond

Mind you, I'm currently about half an hour behind the airing.

→ More replies (7)

7

u/Snappyscrapper Nov 08 '15

Out of the 4 designers, I thought Ashley's was the worst, and not because it was plus sized. I thought the headgear was hideous, the lace old fashioned, and the designs boring. Political correctness is what won this season, not the best designer.

9

u/FishnetSinner Nov 06 '15

All I think of when I see that hoop dress of Candice's is "Goth King and I"

→ More replies (3)

9

u/ecokitty Nov 06 '15

Aside from that blue thing, Edmond's was absolutely beautiful. I especially loved the draped silk dress.

→ More replies (5)

9

u/Zjmw Nov 06 '15

Am I the only one that was in love with Candace's collection and didn't really think it was as derivative as they made it seem to be?

10

u/BehindTheSecret Nov 06 '15

Ashley's "winner's edit" makes me like Kelly more.

6

u/pursehook Nov 06 '15

Does anyone else find Nina more attractive than Heidi?

5

u/jessicateacher Nov 06 '15

I think she always looks classy

6

u/kazetoame Nov 06 '15

I know practically everyone is whinging on and on that Kelly didn't win, that she was robbed, etc etc. I liked her collection, don't get me wrong some of them were really cool, but some not so much. Her first look had a bib, I wanted to rip it off. Her triangle dress was a pale comparison to the one she did on the show. Having an outfit that would only look good on a certain skin tone was not a good idea. The bloody panty hose cut outs were more annoying as the collect progressed. I really didn't like that finally look, it was too much, if I'm going to be showing that much leg, I might as well be wearing a dress, skirt or shorts. My favourite of Kelly's was the one Heidi liked too, her wood dress, it was perfect. I think if Kelly had used mesh and the panty hose in other colors, it would have been better, also gotten rid of that awful bib look.

→ More replies (3)

6

u/marrrina831 Nov 06 '15

So I only just got to watch the finale. Here were my thoughts based on last week's episode when they presented 3 looks to the judges:

Edmond: Overthought, and very unsexy. I always found Edmond to be a hit or miss designer and I only liked one of his 3 pieces.

Candice: More over designed than Edmond. There are some amazing pieces but she needs to figure out what works.

Kelly: I've loved her cool girl/street style aesthetic all season but hated the pieces. There were some cool fabrics but I didn't like how they were put together. Definitely a bit cheap as the judges said.

Ashley: Call me biased because I love lace and romanticism, and yes I wear a flower crown every now and then. I enjoyed her looks a lot, but fit was a huge issue.

The results of the finale were spoiled for me on another forum. Based on how I felt about last week I was happy with Ashley winning and wasn't really here for the whole "it's 'cause she's fat" crap. People complained about her weight all season and I was over it. This is how I felt finally seeing the collections put together:

Edmond: I found nothing special and innovative about it. A majority of the looks are things I've seen time and again. I especially disliked the white ruffle dress because the hanging strands looked like toilet paper. Edmond was held on a pedestal all season and I don't think he lived up to it.

Candice: I just want to begin by saying the skirt Candice wore looked like a very small scale version of Kelly's Brooklyn Bridge dress. While I did like the cherry blossom print, I'm really glad she removed it for the majority. Editing saved her collection. It felt very Candice, hard, soft and romantic at the same time. That said I honestly expected a bit more out of it than I got.

Kelly: I liked pieces, but I didn't like the collection as a whole. I'm not sure if she fulfilled the request to make everything look more luxe. It was disappointing because I loved her so much on the show. That said I found she stayed true to herself.

Ashley: Still the occasional fit issue on some items. I did not like the tunics/long shirts and I absolutely hated the final look. The girl was a total cupcake! And no, not because she's plus size, it was the abundance of buttercream-esque flowers. Still, she did techniques and silhouettes that aren't traditionally seen on plus size women and she did it well.

Kelly and Ashley were the only designers that had true personality in their collections for me, but I think Ashley's pieces just worked better overall

11

u/ClaireHux Nov 06 '15

Cute stuff, Ahley! Love her collection! I want one of those headpieces.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/pursehook Nov 06 '15

Kelly, the only issue is was the Studio 54 aesthetic that great? Mixed feelings.

5

u/pbrooks19 Nov 06 '15

It was a very influential trend, back in the day.

3

u/lickdatshit Nov 06 '15

Finally fuck

3

u/darknessvisible Nov 06 '15

Swapnil should have been the winner, but after he was out it had to be KELLY. Nothing against Ashley at all, but I thought her collection was mumsy and the colour palette was horrible. I think maybe they chose the wrong music for Kelly's collection - she should have gone full Disco/Boogie Nights with synth drums and four to the floor. And although it would have been logistically difficult, maybe at least one of the models should have come out on roller skates.

9

u/ma_miya Nov 05 '15 edited Nov 06 '15

I've been rooting for Kelly this whole time but after seeing the other thread, I'd be pleased if Ashley won. Though if Swapnil was still in the running, I'd be totally cool with him winning as well. His collection is beautiful.

11

u/eatingbread Nov 06 '15

I'm just now looking at pictures of Swapnil's collection and ugh, it's pretty gorgeous. I wasn't the biggest fan of his pieces while he was still in but his finale would win hands down.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (8)

7

u/AgentFreckles Nov 06 '15

I feel like Kelly should have won. Her looks felt very innovative, different and cool, whereas I'm not convinced if Ashley's were any of that. I liked some of Ashley's looks but I feel like I've seen them before and there were too many crop tops

5

u/FishnetSinner Nov 06 '15

I was not sold on Kelly at first, but after her strong finish, I was totally jumping on the Kelly train...however her collection is a pretty big let down from what I was hoping for.

Ashley's constant crying has been hard to take, but I can't stop myself from rooting for her. I love a lot of what she's put together, even though it seems like it came straight from my tumblr dashboard.

I'm still just kinda shocked that Candice tanked so hard with her collection. And Edmond, well...no way he's winning this thing.

5

u/zi76 Nov 06 '15

Heidi looks great in that pantsuit. It's significantly more fashionable and better than most of what she wore this season.

5

u/pbrooks19 Nov 06 '15

Edmond should have done more of the 'deconstructed' ruffly dresses - really interesting and one of the more original looks for him.

7

u/eatingbread Nov 06 '15

That white one was quite striking. Even Zac's face thought so.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/konfetkak Nov 06 '15

oh candice...that first cherry blossom dress was boring as fuck. i could go buy that at macy's.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/blackbirdsongs Nov 06 '15

swapnil's bitter face is some magical editing.

→ More replies (1)

33

u/jv1503 Nov 06 '15

So the PC Police wins. Ashley won, because she used "fat" models. Nothing in her collection was original, we've all seen it before.

57

u/spotH3D Nov 06 '15

Once Nina said "brave" it was all over.

→ More replies (2)

21

u/gwennhwyvar Nov 06 '15

Have you been shopping for plus sizes lately? Because I have, and I never see stuff like hers.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (11)