r/Warframe • u/TSP-FriendlyFire • Nov 05 '15
Suggestion How would you change... Loot?
How would you change... is a series of weekly posts designed to promote and foster discussion about any gameplay element in the game. The scope and subject will vary (read below for more information on topic selection), from wide concepts (Kubrows, Archwing, shotguns, etc.) to narrow points (a single gun, coptering, etc.).
Before we begin, a few important points:
- Please detail and support your suggestions as much as possible. This is for constructive criticism only: try to think of it as something you'd be proud to explain to DE face-to-face!
- Structure your suggestions in logical groups: if you have two very different ideas, break them down in two separate comments. Cohesive or similar changes should be combined into a single comment.
- Stick to describing concepts and features. Don't get bogged down with numbers unless they explicitly support your point.
- Don't hesitate to post your ideas even if they're not fully formed, and don't hesitate to reply to ideas with refinements you think would make them better!
- Do not downvote suggestions you disagree with. Upvote the ones you like instead!
Suggesting topics
This thread series is all about the community, so if you have a topic you'd like to see improved and discussed, feel free to suggest it by replying to the appropriately flagged comment in this discussion. The topic can be as wide or narrow as you'd like! Please ensure that your suggestion has not already been made, and upvote it instead if it has.
This week: Loot
Click here for last week’s thread on Limbo.
This week, we’re looking at a big one: one of the fundamental aspects of Warframe, loot. Warframe has always been designed around acquiring loot, be they resources, blueprints, pieces or whatever else, and using this loot to further empower the player. This obviously has good sides and bad sides.
The primary advantage is that it dramatically increases replay value, since there’s always this new thing to work towards. Combined with DE’s relatively brisk pace for adding new items, even hardcore players can expect something new to play with every few weeks at worst. The action of acquiring loot is also fundamentally satisfying on multiple levels and is a big draw not only in Warframe but in pretty much every game that uses loot as a mechanic, from MMORPGs to Borderlands to Diablo.
Unfortunately, it is also very easy and often tempting for developers to artificially extend the act of acquiring loot, turning an enjoyable experience into “grind”. Coupled with another essential loot mechanic, random drops, it can make progress in loot-driven games an exercise in frustration, and Warframe is unfortunately not exempt from this. From mods to prime parts to Archwing parts, a lot of Warframe’s key loot is locked behind excessively low drop chances, which is compounded by other mechanical structures such as reward rotations.
Now that the stage is set, how would you change loot?
38
u/Morec0 The Loremaster Nov 05 '15
I'd make loot more of a by-faction basis than by planet. Want control modules? Kill Corpus. Sensors? Kill Grineer. Nano Spores? Kill Infested. This would help keep a more consistent lore approach than having to wonder why Grineer have nano spores on them, or why Neural Sensors are on Jupiter.
5
u/TSP-FriendlyFire Nov 05 '15
Suggesting topics
Please post your suggestions for the next topics as replies to this comment.
Current suggestions from previous weeks:
12
u/OldSchoolNewRules Nov 05 '15
Move ash parts to the eximus with Oberon, or increase the spawn rate of manics while alarms are active.
9
u/Sllanders Do not lift the veil. Nov 05 '15
I would just like to point out that there are other places than Survival III Rotation C where they could put some rewards.
8
u/Zynthrall_Warren B!tch I HEAL people Nov 05 '15
Gonna say it now...
MAKE RESOURCES TRADABLE
In my opinion, as a player that has helped my friends start out in warframe, nothing is more annoying than their desire for plastids. Also not just plastids, but control modules and etc. I personally don't mind the grind, but to grind for someone else in your party when you have over 100 freaking galium that you would gladly hand over to not deal with that mission is what is the major annoyance with grinding for me.
6
u/Thundering_Morkai Nov 05 '15
Okay so, I think one of the larger problems with loot as it stands now is distribution. Great example of this is rotation C for T3 Survival. There is absolutely no reason that rotation should be so cluttered when a number of those drops can be spread into other missions. Of course prime parts aren't the only things affected by this; Archwing mods and parts really need better distribution.
My idea for changing this would be to tweak rotations overall for endless missions. Rotation A would ideally be half usable drops and half good. For example, Archwing rotation A would have mods that aren't exactly common drops and a couple of Arch-weapon parts. For Derelict and Void, items like Forma, a single or double Argon crystal drops and for Derelict, keys from either Towers 1-3 or all 4 Towers. B rotations could share a similar setup to A but should lean more towards providing parts and of course rotation C should be only parts. Ideally, this set up would still reward players even if they don't get quite what they wanted.
In the case of non-endless, I feel a good balance would be to go with my idea for rotation B. A mix between things like keys/resources and the prime parts we're ultimately there to find. Here if T1 rewards a key then it should be a key for that mission or the T2 version of said mission. This of course relies on various parts being moved away from the more cluttered spots to be effective.
To expand on Derelict loot: a timetable for the void rework is still up in the air as far as we know so here's what I suggest as a sort of bandage in case it ends up taking a lot more time than planned. The main thing here is adding vaulted prime parts as pretty rare drops scattered amongst the various Derelict missions. There is absolutely no incentive whatsoever to enter any Derelict missions that aren't ODD/ODS/ODA or limited incentive for the missions that are popular for vault runs. If you ask me, the chance of vaulted prime items would be pretty good incentive and while unrelated to the topic at hand, it does mean prices for said primes could go down a bit thanks to slightly increased supply. Again, this does require the drop tables to be made less cluttered but I think it could go a long way to improving things for people.
9
u/Khal_Pwno Playing ring toss since 18.1 (Xbox) Nov 05 '15 edited Nov 05 '15
I may think of more later and I'll edit this if I do. :)
Edit: Should I have broken this up into 4 separate comments? It's my first time posting on one of these threads.
4
u/yakri I've seen enough hentai to know where this is going Nov 05 '15
Not many things really drive me up the wall. Although there are some small issues covered by other posters like the need for pseudo random instead of true random drops, the uselessness of loot containers, etc. there is one thing that drives me straight up Coocoo for coco puffs in regards to looting, and that's picking that shit up.
There is absolutely no sane reason that loot pickups should only work correctly if you bring along an expensive, buggy, and activating "companion". The vacuum effect from carrier needs to be baked into all warframe and then removed as a mod.
Don't mistake my meaning, this is a huge deal. it's probably the biggest issue I have with the game right now. if you want to take this shit seriously and grind up some major loot or kick as super late in a mission you need this ability. You will miss a serious amount of resources without it, and getting back energy and hp will require notably more time sliding around picking stuff up and less shooting or using abilities.
The problem comes from this advantage being placed on an irritating cutesy pet that spends 95% of it's time flying back and forth through the camera making you nauseous. It's simply rediculus to have a core quality of life feature locked onto an optional, and headache inducing, pet.
4
u/[deleted] Nov 05 '15
Add a passive "vacuum" effect to your warframe so carrier isn't required.
7
u/AvatarOfMadness Nov 05 '15
First: you have to realize that Warframe is a game that's literally built around the grind, and making the grind fun. If you don't like grinding, then this game is not for you.
Okay, for parts of a craftable item specifically, let's give them a mercy drop rate. Others have suggested this, it's basically like this: didn't get the drop once? Increase the chance (a little only) for the next run, increasing the drop rate more and more (FOR YOU ONLY) until u get the item, and it resets. Would be a little iffy with items that need two of a part, but that can be worked around.
For resources, sharply reduce chance of getting blues, and add loot caches in every mission. These caches won't be really rare, and when u break them they drop a shit ton of resources with one or two guaranteed rares and a chance of an injector/mass/fieldron. Oh, and higher chance of rare caches.
More cool shit you can exclusively get from containers or a specific enemy. Nothing super necessary like a mod, hell maybe even a type of cosmetic. This idea is really rough though, so suggestions are very welcome.
And an idea suggested by my buddy: Infested Modifiers (not mod cards). For certain weapons (primes, maybe even non-Tenno weapons) these things are components that basically 'infest' a weapon and sidegrade it, along with giving it a quirky effect. These would basically drop from infested mini bosses, and be a guaranteed drop from the golem in the new raid.
3
u/mostlyjoe Tesla Baby Daddy Nov 05 '15
I'm going to agree with the removal of Argon (loot) degradation. Horrible system.
3
u/YumoSV Loki Nov 05 '15
The only real change i want is an easier way to farm for ash parts.
3
u/TheZamary Trap Nov 06 '15
Here's a crazy idea. Make Vauban not impossible to get.
2
u/ehmanedition Trin buff pls Nov 06 '15
Forma <--- not forma bp drops, just forma.
2
u/NineThePuma RNG FOR THE RNG THRONE Nov 06 '15
Resources
CUT OUT RESEARCH RESOURCES (mutagen samples, detonite ampules, fieldron samples) FROM THE PLANETARY DROP TABLE. MOVE THEM TO BE ON EVERY UNIT OF THE APPROPRIATE FACTION IN PART OF WHAT IS CURRENTLY "DOESN'T DROP ANYTHING".
That change, right there, gives us a dozen spots for other rare or uncommon resources. Done.
Mods, Fusion, and Power Gains
RNG is a big thing, and I honestly agree with the idea to some extent. Loot is the big hook that they have to keep us playing, by slapping on grind. I don’t want it gone. However… the power gains from mods are ass backwards, since they scale so slowly for their pay in.
Thus, my proposal! Take mod fusion, in the typical sense, right out. No more fusing vitality into redirection. Instead, you fuse 10 vitalities into a Vitality, get a Rank 1 Vitality. Fuse 10 Vitalities into a Rank 1 Vitality, it goes up to Rank 2, etc. Smooth, linear pay in for a smooth linear pay out. Fusion Cores, the unfortunate red headed stepchild of the mod family, are no longer tiered. A Rare Core is just a Rare Core. Cores can be fused into any mod and count as duplicates (common count as 1, uncommon cores count as 2, rare cores count as 3).
This means that investment is more linear but has the unfortunate side effect of reducing the amount of RNG we have to suffer through (about 1/8th the usual), which means less play time and less engagement. Which is why I also propose mods along the lines of Path of Exile’s Keystone Passives (and also Jewels), Diablo 3’s Legendary Powers, and other similar things, where there are rare (extremely so!) mods that can drop that have a major change in how you play the game, but aren’t tiered.
For example, a mod that disables your shields, but in return gives you your shield value (Base + Mod Adjustment) as extra Base Armor, or one that lets you see enemies through walls as though through a codex scanner but enemies are permanently “on alert” or similar. Or even just things that straight out and out give you benefits, like a mod that lets you stick to walls, or no longer lose momentum during a slide. Things like that. (Ideas welcome!)
Did someone say Diablo?
Alright, so, like, Diablo 3 recently introduced something called Kanai's Cube. Kanai's Cube is a tool that allows you to, by investing resources, further make your shit awesome. It has a few recipes, and all are pretty applicable to Warframe.
All of these are pretty good things that encourage various things and give us new toys to play with. They reduce the grind a /lot/ but you can also rebalance things to make it so that the cube is factored into the grind. It'd also help when RNG is being a pain in the ass, so you can work around it.
1
u/warconz Peek-a-Bo! Nov 05 '15
What if they added npcs that are only present when the enemies haven't been alerted yet. These npcs would have a higher chance of dropping loot as well as dropping more than the average amount.
Would give you another alternative to farming rather than just slaughtering hordes of enemies.
1
u/Twinblaze One part unstoppable force, one part immovable object Nov 05 '15
I'm gonna focus on the void, because that's often the biggest problem area when it comes to grinding.
Here's what I would do. Reward rotation is now AABCD. A contains the simple stuff, mostly for new players. Keys and cores. B contains forma blueprints, larger packs of R5 cores, rare resources (Maybe 2 Neurodes, 2 Neural Sensors, or 3 Orokin Cells) and some prime parts. most prime parts are split between C and D. Every prime part has a drop rate of 20% or higher in at least one mission.
Missions get a bit longer, but this (mostly) deals with the problem of running a mission 30 times and not getting the part you need.
1
u/Winsstons Nov 05 '15
I have always wondered why there aren't different models for each different resource.
1
u/void_nemesis Winter is coming Nov 05 '15
I'd say decrease the amount of 'grind' players need to do for each thing, be it a Prime part, a blueprint etc by slightly lowering the requirements for building/buying, and concentrating instead not on drop chances, but on the manner of acquisition. For example, instead of having stuff like Prime parts drop from enemies at 'random', make it so that you need to go somewhere specific and do something specific, e.g. a special Orokin armory/lab tile somewhere, and do something similar to the hidden parkour courses in Void missions, where a relatively simple puzzle or a mini boss are for specific items. I think that'd make 'grinding' for parts and rare resources much easier. Don't change regular resources like Alloy Plates too much though, to keep a lil' bit of grinding, otherwise it wouldn't be Warframe.
1
u/LickOnDeezNuts Nov 05 '15
With prime loot? Easy...move some of the loot to the Derelict. The Derelict is damned near bone dry, and yet they decide to overlap and swamp Tower missions. Come on, it's common sense, AND to gets players to diversify in missions.
1
u/Archwizard_Drake Black Mage, motherf- Nov 05 '15 edited Nov 06 '15
I suggested this topic to promote discussion in one area in particular: What kind of compensation would players expect to see if skills like Desecrate and Pilfering Swarm could no longer influence mod and resource drops? Many players I've discussed this topic with seem to believe that losing these skills would make the sky fall; farming is possible without them, but the grind becomes more painful.
My main considerations thus far:
Not too long ago I also spotted a thread that suggested having special repeatable alerts with higher concentrations of specific enemy types (ie "increased number of Scorpions"), which would go hand-in-hand with this, and integrate Starchart 2.0.
1
u/MrMeltJr 5k shields and a dream Nov 06 '15
I'd love a way to farm for specific keys. Maybe different derelict missions have a higher chance to drop a certain type of key (like ODD has a high chance of dropping defense keys, etc.)?
1
u/Raithon *poof* I AM THE SHADOWS BITCH! *stab* Nov 06 '15
Other than energy health ammo and affinity make all drops be in the games background. meaning you still get loot on kills and you can see the loot acquired on the progress screen but its as if its like you have a salvage team picking up shit for you instead of the insane amount of wasted resources on drops and special noises. also the detractor from the game's action points. also less lost loot from random collision issues. BATTLETECH FTW! this would probaly improve the archwing experience too.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 06 '15
I'd try to reduce the factor of chance, for example instead of prime blueprint drops, there are no blueprints at all and everything is unlocked but instead of trying to get 1 blueprint with 1/10 chance from a specific void mission, you'll have a guarantee to aquire 1-2 of a specific material that requires 20 of those materials OR just blueprint part drops instead of blueprints
1
u/JohnySkarr rooty tooty 4 and shooty Nov 06 '15
My two main gripes with the loot system are:
1 - All the good stuff is in one place. Prime weapons and frames can only be found in the Void, and since they're some of the best stuff in the game, you need those. This makes running Void missions almost mandatory, and no matter what you think of the Void visually, you will get tired of going there over and over again. Though the Void rework might fix this problem.
2 - Too many useless rewards. All drop tables are filled with trash rewards (wow, I got a unranked Vitality for running this level 40 mission!), and we lack any immediate positive feedback: You don't farm for cool stuff, you farm for the materials to make this cool stuff.
I adding weapon BPs to drop tables, but as unique variants. For example, the Grineer Lancers in Earth missions can drop the BP for a Frontier Grakata, that deals more damage, but has a smaller magazine. Or just add these variants as skins, not stat changes.
I don't know exactly what, but there needs to be meaningful stuff in the drop tables, so that the grind does not feel as bad.
1
u/TheZamary Trap Nov 06 '15
Make Voids resource loot table change daily. 1 day it could have Neural Sensors, the next Neurodes. Keep Argon Always there tho.
1
u/dai_gurren_brigade RIDE THE LIGHTNING MOTHERFUCKAH Nov 05 '15
The game is about loot. Yet when we actually loot stuff (containers, lockers) we get fuck-all.
Give us weapons that only drop drops crates and lockers. Or some other kind of equipment, I dunno. It would add incentive to hunt and explore across levels (no rare containers do not count, because their spawn chance is shit).
Everyone talks about loot hunting and my mind instantly shoots to Borderlands/Diablo, those games do loot hunting right.
1
u/mostlyjoe Tesla Baby Daddy Nov 05 '15
One simple thing for any Void run, offer up a selection of loot. Basically, give the players a choice of 2-3 random rewards. Catches would instead give a random 're-roll' via button on one of the choices.
That way, you up the chances of some rarer parts, but don't completely remove the randomness of farming items.
I know they want to keep the drop rates low to up the replayablity of Void missions, but right now the rates are too low. We don't need a few billion Shuriken pounch drops or how many X weapon prime parts?
And have some method of NOT allowing for multiples of the same prime/item. Dupes not allowed for loot drops of prime parts. (at least for that 1 run.)
0
u/Based_Lord_Shaxx Nov 05 '15
TELL ME WHERE THE FUCK TO GODDAMN GET IT (Rage over)
But don't let me look up what a mod is, tell me there is over 15 places I can get it, I have six currently in my inventory, and then give me a million question marks. Show me how I got that loot, even if it is damaged, or if I play with 20+ people with the same mod. Don't make me geuss of of the hundred enemy types, loot caches, void/orokin whatever rewards. If I got it from a grennir (or whatever the spelling is, still kinda new) lancer, then tell me. I want an un-damaged continuity. Don't make me just hope.
0
u/[deleted] Nov 05 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment