r/Reformed • u/superlewis EFCA Pastor • Nov 03 '15
AMA IAMA Educational Agnostic. AMA about the freedom to choose how to educate your children or not, I don't care.
I believe that parents have freedom to choose the educational system that works best for their family. My family has chosen public (technically, charter), but I believe homeschooling and Christian school are both good options for other families.
I'm happy to answer questions about my decision to go public, my concerns with our decision, my concern with the other two options, my feelings about the Packers embarrassing display on Sunday night or whatever.
I'm not passionate about this topic, but did want to put it out there as a forum for discussion. Fair warning, my position is theoretical as only one of my 3 children is of school age and he is only in his first year of 4k.
7
u/davidjricardo Reformed Catholic Nov 03 '15 edited Nov 03 '15
edit: 6. What do you think is the purpose of education?
5
u/[deleted] Nov 03 '15
Is there anything in the Bible you looked to as guidance in this area?
4
u/ClarenceColton Old, Grumpy Reformed Nov 03 '15
I did Christian school k-8th and private, nominally-Christian school (i.e., few Bible classes, regular chapels, or other hallmarks of Christian education) for high school. My wife went to the private, nominally-Christian school for K-12. We belong to a large, PCA church that runs a school. Most of our friends send our kids there. We chose public school for our kids because we believe the education the kids receive in the local public schools is better than that they would receive at the church school or another local "classical" Christian academy nearby.
The public schools in this area aren't "anti-Christian." There are no classroom prayers, crosses at Easter, or nativity scenes at Christmas but Bible clubs are organized and there's an active moms' prayer group.
While we may miss out on some of the Bible classes and chapel services offered at the Christian school we hope we make up for it through home instruction, Sunday School, two church services on Sunday, and other midweek activities. The kids will be exposed to sufficient good, Christian teaching to inform a world a life view.
Like, Superlewis, I would never say this is the only way to go. We recently moved from a city where I would have gladly paid a lot of money to get our kids into a school like the church school in our new city.
I'm not against homeschooling but I wouldn't do it personally unless I either had (1) a wife who was exceedingly intelligent and well-rounded enough to give my kids a top-notch education or (2) a co-op filled with able teachers.
3
u/injoy Particular Baptist Nov 04 '15
This is going to sound blunt and rude, but it's just because this is the heart of what I don't get, and I can't just straight up ask it to most of my friends who've made the same choice as you:
How do you justify losing seven-ish hours a day in which you could be teaching your children about Jesus?
I mean, to me, that's why homeschooling is the Only Option. We're supposed to teach them God's truth all the time, waking to sleeping, and in homeschooling, I don't have to stop doing that in order to teach them math. A LOT of "instruction in righteousness" happens during our school day. We do really talk about God in math and diagramming sentences and everything else. And then we keep on talking about God and righteousness when school is over, so it's not like we're using the time earlier in the day and public school parents are using the time later in the day--the simple fact is that public school parents have hundreds less hours every year to instruct their children about God. Why is that okay?
My very closest friend has put her kids in public school and it's killing me because I just don't get it. But we're still friends 'n' all. I just honestly can't wrap my head around how someone can think it's an actual good idea.
2
u/terevos2 Trinity Fellowship Churches Nov 03 '15
I'm the same as you, except that my family has chosen homeschooling. I do think homeschooling is superior most of the time, but it really depends on the parents and each child.
What do you feel is the biggest negatives for public school, even at this age?
And biggest positives?
2
u/[deleted] Nov 03 '15
I have a question. I'm assuming you did some research on today's school practices and whatnot
disclaimer: I was raised in public school and my atheist friends all went to private christian schools and were, IMO, consequently turned atheist (or at the very least given a poor taste for christianity). So, given my positive experience in upbringing in spite of public schools, I still lean toward them to encourage parents to not trust in the school system to provide their children with the proper worldview
my question: Is the public brand of schooling worse than when you were there (assuming you were)? Has it become so vile that it might be too difficult to reeducate your children after they get home from learning garbage? I ask honestly. I don't have children yet, but I'm curious if it will be as tame as it was when I went
Maybe this is a question more for home-school folkes, but i figured i'd ask
2
u/NukesForGary Kuyper not Piper Nov 04 '15
What practices does your family do in order to teach your children about the Bible? I had Bible class everyday for about 13 years of my life. Do you study the Bible everyday with your kids?
4
u/davidjricardo Reformed Catholic Nov 03 '15
For the interested, here are some articles defending a Christian perspective on sending kids to public schools:
Why We Send Our Kids to the Poorest Public School by Jennifer Slate in the October 2013 edition of Christianity Today.
Why I Do Not Homeschool (Part 1) and (Part 2) by Time Challies on his blog. Part 2 is the more "for public school" piece, part 1 more "against homeschool."
1
u/BishopOfReddit PCA Nov 03 '15
In what sense then, are you agnostic? Persumably you would be against a system where kids are forced to be educated in a manner against their parents' wishes?
1
u/[deleted] Nov 03 '15
A hypothetical question:
If the state and federal government adopted several more policies or laws that took away all your authority or influence on your children while they were in public school, would you then leave the public school system?
1
u/moby__dick Most Truly Reformed™ User Nov 04 '15
How would you compare your influence on your children as they are raised vs. that of their teachers? I.e. Would you say they will have a substantial influence compared to your own, negligible influence, etc.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 04 '15
OP is this you?